Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pathogenesis of Dental Caries in South African Children A Molecular Approach
Pathogenesis of Dental Caries in South African Children A Molecular Approach
Pathogenesis of Dental Caries in South African Children A Molecular Approach
C S Toi
To cite this article: C S Toi (2005) Pathogenesis of dental caries in South African children: a
molecular approach, Southern African Journal of Epidemiology and Infection, 20:4, 121-126
Article views: 35
REVIEW ARTICLE
Pathogenesis of dental caries in South African
children: a molecular approach
CS Toi
Bacterial communities are characteristic for distinctive ecological niches. Yet, some
indigenous bacteria have the potential to express virulence characteristics when a change in
the environment disturbs natural stability, producing a condition of disease. An example of
such a system is the human mouth where dental caries can result from the complex
interaction of diet, the normal bacterial flora and the host. The mutans streptococci species
are most implicated in the cause of this disease. They constitute part of the natural oral flora
but express virulence when exposed to increased dietary carbohydrate, especially sucrose.
Yet, dental caries is also a transmissible disease, with mutans streptococci acquired and
spread through contact from various sources. Modern molecular biology methods have been
used to trace the spread of infection and now provide the strongest evidence of the source of
transmission of infection in dental caries. These methods also provide insight into change in
virulence gene expression and that different levels of virulence are associated with genetic
differences between mutans streptococci strains. Surveillance of this complex pathogen in
South Africa is reviewed herein.
The mutans streptococci are aciduric and are able to survive According to Berkowitz,26 the primary oral colonisation by S.
at low pH levels in plaque; they produce large quantities of mutans coupled to caries-promoting feeding behaviours
acid as a by-product of carbohydrate fermentation cause levels of these bacteria to exceed 30% of the total
(acidogenic) and synthesise extracellular polysaccharides cultivable plaque flora. This in turn proceeds in the rapid
(ECP) from sucrose, which promotes attachment to the tooth demineralisation of tooth structure. However, the isolation
pellicle.12, 13 An increase in mutans streptococci numbers is frequency of these bacteria in relation to dental caries differs
usually accompanied by expression of these virulent between countries and populations, but the general indication
cariogenic properties. is that in preschool children, high counts of mutans
streptococci have high levels of dental caries.27-29
The production of water insoluble polysaccharide is
synonymous with dental plaque. ECP is formed from sucrose A study on mutans streptococci levels in 5-year-old black
and other carbohydrates, catalysed by the enzyme African and coloured children living in the greater
glucosyltransferase (EC 2.4.1.5). The related gtfB, gtfC and Johannesburg area, showed that counts from children with
gtfD genes in S. mutans, and the gtfI gene in S. sobrinus dental caries were higher (77%) than caries-free children
encode this enzyme.14-18 The gtfB gene produces a water- (23%).30 In the same investigation, results indicated that S.
insoluble glucan (a-1,3-linked glucose);16 the gtfD gene mutans and S. sobrinus accounted for 46% and 39%,
makes primarily water-soluble glucan (a-1,6-linked respectively, of the predominant cultivable flora in children
glucose); the gtfC gene makes both water-soluble and with caries. In Germiston, mutans streptococci species
-insoluble glucans and the GTF-I enzyme encoded by the gtfI comprised 4.3% of total viable count in caries-free children, 31
gene, catalyse the formation of water-insoluble glucans.19 whereas children with dental caries had mutans streptococci
levels comprising 8.2% and 14.4% in caries-free teeth and in
Dental caries in Africa and South Africa carious lesions, respectively. Differentiation between species
showed that 58% of the isolates were S. mutans, and 30%
In many industrialised countries 80% of the caries is present were S. sobrinus. Collectively, these investigations
in approximately 20% of the population.20 Studies on caries confirmed an overall increase in mutans streptococci in
prevalence in sub-Saharan Africa have shown a downward dental caries with S. mutans predominating, but the presence
trend in nursery school children and teenagers, while in the of mutans streptococci in caries-free children confirms other
Middle East and North Africa caries prevalence has remained reports that colonisation does not necessarily accompany
constant over a 30-year review period.21, 22 In South Africa, dental caries.32,33 Overall, the general decrease in dental caries
repeated cross-sectional epidemiological surveys of dental prevalence in South Africa with a relatively high count of
caries between 1981 and 1997 in Germiston, the largest mutans streptococci (105 cfu/ml saliva) in children with and
industrial city in Africa, have also shown a downward trend without caries suggests a reduction in the virulence of this
of this disease in 2-5-year-old nursery school children.23 species.
However, the most recent cross-sectional study (2002) on
pre-school children in the same nursery schools in Germiston The relatively higher numbers of mutans streptococci
has indicated that in primary teeth, caries rates are on the observed on healthy teeth in children with dental caries in the
increase in this low fluoride area.24 same individual compared to children with no dental caries,
implies that a transition in the microenvironment is typically
Although dental caries severity in South Africa is classified accompanied by a shift in microbial composition between
as low by World Health Organization standards, the high health and disease.
level of untreated caries in all age groups is cause for
concern25 and South African children of 5 years and younger Genetic diversity of mutans streptococci
show a prevalence of 46.6% of untreated dental caries. This
owes to lack of access to dental services through non- According to Napimoga et al,1 the S. mutans species are
availability, or non-utilisation of available services. genetically diverse, with increased virulence in caries-active
subjects, where higher numbers of genotypes are present. A
study on ECC has also shown that more than one clonal type
of S. mutans is implicated in the presence of high sucrose
Although some studies have found that diet has limited Bacterial mRNA was measured using the reverse
influence on the development of dental caries,20,33 some transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)
fermentable carbohydrates promote virulence such as acid technique. Analysis showed that 80% to 100% of S. mutans
and extracellular polymer production more than others that expressed the gtfB gene in maize plus milk and sugar, samp
can have an effect on streptococcal strain selection and and beans, bread plus margarine and peanut butter and brain
survival in the mouth. Chemostat studies have since shown heart infusion broth containing 3% sucrose (BHI plus 3%
that the low pH generated from the metabolism of dietary sucrose). However, gtfB gene expression by S. mutans
carbohydrates, especially sugar, leads to a breakdown in clinical strains was mainly inhibited in maize, samp and
microbial homeostasis in dental plaque, rather than sugar brown bread. In comparison, the gtfI gene was transcribed by
availability.60 all S. sobrinus reference and clinical isolates grown in 3%
sucrose and BHI containing 3% sucrose. Yet, samp and maize
Mattos-Graner and co-workers2 hypothesised that biofilm plus milk and sugar were foods that were most inhibitory to
formation in S. mutans was independent of the GtfB and GtfC gtfI gene expression. Hence, expression of the gtfI gene
genotype and there was more of a need to identify factors that appears to be enhanced by the sucrose component of foods,
control and modulate gtf gene expression. In the South whereas expression of the gtfB gene in clinical strains is
African context, S. mutans and S. sobrinus genotypes induced by other nutrients besides sucrose, compared with
identified by gtf polymorphisms may have arisen through laboratory reference strains. These findings suggest that S.
adaptation to the traditional African diet. This implies that the sobrinus are more cariogenic when sucrose is available in the
response of a bacterium to sugars is dependent on the diet, but S. mutans are more adaptive to a variety of foods.
expression of the encoding gene.
The relationship between gtf gene expression and the
Investigations on dietary patterns and caries have based quantity of ECP produced differed between S. mutans and S.
studies on the typical westernised diet. Undoubtedly, high sobrinus reference strains and clinical isolates, emphasising
sucrose consumption is accompanied by higher mutans the need to study clinical isolates and not just laboratory-
streptococcus counts in individuals, but some populations adapted strains. In addition, polymorphisms produced by
that have a minimum intake of refined sugars are still carriers HaeIII enzyme digest of the transcribed gtfB and gtfI genes
of large numbers of these microorganisms. Urban black 5- were evident in three of the 11 test strains investigated. The
year-old South African children also eat a mainly westernised differences shown were between transcripts of the same
diet,61 but cultural influences do play an important role in strain exposed to different test foods, suggesting that
food preferences,62 and some traditional African food staples adaptive genetic changes had occurred.
such as maize63 and its combinations64 have shown little
potential to produce caries in rats. Dietary surveys Regulation of gtf expression
undertaken in South Africa between 1983 and 2000 in urban
areas have indicated that foods commonly eaten by children According to Marsh,60 disease is prevented not only by
between the ages of 1-9 were: maize porridge, sugar, brown inhibiting the putative pathogens, but also by interfering with
bread, margarine, peanut butter and cooked samp.65 the environmental factors driving the selection and
enrichment of these bacteria. The differences in gtf gene
A study on S. mutans reference strains exposed to a transcription between the test microorganisms after exposure
chemically defined culture medium with sucrose and glucose to traditional African food challenges appear to be an
as carbohydrate sources has suggested that the type and adaptive response to different dietary carbohydrates. This is
amount of these sugars in the environmental pH have a major important in the context of mutans streptococci pathogenesis
influence on transcription of the gtfBC genes when the and dental caries. It must be kept in mind that the mutans
organisms were grown in biofilms.67 In batch culture, the streptococci species are normal oral floras that become
synthesis of glucosyltransferase by S. mutans was regulated pathogenic when the opportunity arises.
by the addition of sucrose. Hudson and Curtiss59 recorded a
twofold increase in enzyme synthesis, whereas Wexler et al67 Current research has found that many species of streptococci
found a threefold increase in activity from the gtfBC have evolved peptide pheromone quorum-sensing systems
promoter when sucrose was added to slowly growing that probably help them adapt to and survive host-imposed
glucose-limited S. mutans cells in continuous culture. fluctuations in the immediate environment and coincidently
regulate the expression of virulence factors that promote their
Gtf gene expression and the traditional African diet pathogenicity.69 In S. mutans, a peptide pheromone quorum-
sensing system controls genetic competence and the system
A preliminary investigation to determine the effect of functions optimally when the cells are living in actively
traditional African staple foods (maize, samp, brown bread) growing biofilm.71 These quorum-sensing systems are
primarily made of small soluble signal peptides that are