Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Association Between Diabetic Complications and
The Association Between Diabetic Complications and
The Association Between Diabetic Complications and
net/publication/51331941
CITATIONS READS
107 225
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Barrett Jeffers on 23 July 2014.
N
IDDM accounts for 90% of diabetic cations that are associated with significant hypothesis that certain microvascular com-
cases in the U.S. (1) and is responsible morbidity and mortality. Complications plications of NIDDM are associated with
for greater than $90 billion of health specific to diabetes include retinopathy, impairment in exercise capacity. The study
care costs today (2). It is a disease accom- nephropathy and neuropathy There is also was conducted with 265 male and 154
panied by characteristic long-term compli- an increased prevalence of cardiac and female NIDDM patients who underwent a
screening exercise test for the Appropriate
From the Divisions of General Internal Medicine (R.O.E., J.G.R) and Cardiology (E.E.W), the Internal Med- Blood Pressure Control in Diabetes (ABCD)
icine Residency Program (M.D.), and the Division of Renal Diseases and Hypertension (B.J., R.WS.), Depart- Trial (13) to determine if complications
ment of Medicine, Denver Health and University of Colorado Health Sciences Center, Denver, Colorado. specific to diabetes are related to impaired
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Robert W Schrier, MD, Division of Renal Diseases and exercise capacity. The population study had
Hypertension, Department of Medicine, 4200 East Ninth Ave., B178, Denver, CO 80262.
Received for publication 31 January 1997 and accepted in revised form 16 October 1997. no previous diagnosis of cardiovascular dis-
Abbreviations: ABCD Trial, Appropriate Blood Pressure Control in Diabetes Trial; PE, parameter estimate; ease. Peak oxygen consumption (Vc"h) was
RER, respiratory exchange ratio; UAE, urinary albumin excretion. analyzed with respect to neuropathy
nephropathy, and retinopathy while con- (16). The electrocardiogram was monitored min during recovery from exercise, 4) sys-
trolling for the known risk factors for continuously (Q5000 Exercise Monitor; tolic hypotension with exercise (systolic
diminished exercise performance in these Quinton, Seattle, WA) and blood pressure blood pressure falling during exercise to lev-
NIDDM patients. was measured at the end of each stage by an els lower than rest), or 5) ventricular tachy-
automated blood pressure cuff (model 412 cardia (>5 consecutive beats) with exercise.
RESEARCH DESIGN AND automated blood pressure cuff; Quinton). Neuropathy staging. Neuropathy was
METHODS Patients exercised until symptoms forced assessed and staged according to the rec-
them to stop. Measurements of oxygen con- ommendations made by the American Dia-
Study population sumption and CO2 production with calcula- betes Association and American Academy of
The ABCD Trial is a large, prospective, ran- tions of the respiratory exchange ratios were Neurology at the San Antonio Conference
domized, blinded clinical trial designed to continuously performed using an automated on Diabetic Neuropathy (19). Staging of
determine the effects of moderate versus gas exchange measuring system (Q-Plex neuropathy was based on the following: 1)
intensive antihypertensive control on the Metabolic Cart; Quinton). Values were neurological symptom score (includes sub-
outcome of NIDDM complications. This recorded at 15-s intervals. The respiratory categories of sensory, motor, and autonomic
trial has been described in detail previously exchange ratio (RER; the ratio of carbon symptoms), 2) neurological disability score
(12). Participants in the ABCD Trial, ages dioxide production to oxygen consump- (scored neurological examination with sub-
40-74 years, were identified based on diag- tion) was used as a measure of exercise categories of cranial nerve, sensory, motor,
nosis-related groups and pharmacy and intensity Peak Vo2 was defined as oxygen and reflex function), 3) autonomic function
billing lists from participating hospitals consumption (ml kg"1 • min"1) at peak testing (heart rate responses to deep breath-
during the period March 1991 to January exercise and was calculated as the mean of ing), and 4) quantitative sensory examina-
1993. Individuals found to be eligible after values during the last minute of exercise. To tion (computerized examination involving
an initial phone screen and eligibility visit ensure an adequate effort, only patients who thermal and vibratory sensation). The stages
were enrolled. reached an RER >1.0 were used for analy- were defined as follows: stage 0, no neu-
NIDDM diagnosis for all patients sis; 35 of the 456 patients who did not have ropathy (fewer than two abnormalities
enrolled in the ABCD Trial was made a previous diagnosis of coronary artery dis- among the above tests); stage 1, asympto-
according to criteria based on the World ease did not reach a peak RER of 1.0 and matic neuropathy (more than two abnor-
Health Organization report of 1985 (14), were excluded. Also, because we felt that malities among neurological disability score,
which followed the National Diabetes disabling neuropathy could affect exercise autonomic function testing, or quantitative
Group criteria of 1979. Institutional Review tolerance, we excluded these patients (n = 2) sensory examination, but no abnormality
Board approval was obtained for the con- from the analyses. Thus the following analy- on the neurological symptom score); stage
duct of all aspects of the ABCD Trial, and all ses were performed on the remaining 419 2, symptomatic neuropathy (more than two
eligible patients gave informed consent to NIDDM patients. abnormalities among neurological disability
be studied. During the exercise test, patients were score, autonomic function testing, quanti-
During the prerandomization period asked to report their degree of exertion tative sensory examination, or neurological
of the trial, participants were tapered off according to the Borg Scale (18). Exercise symptom score but no disabling neuro-
preexisting antihypertensive agents, and treadmill results were categorized as 1) non- pathic symptoms as assessed by the neuro-
placebo was prescribed for a minimum of 7 ischemic, 2) positive or strongly positive for logical symptom score); and stage 3,
and a maximum of 11 weeks. During this ischemia, or 3) nondiagnostic. A nondiag- disabling neuropathy (more than two
time, all baseline examinations were per- nostic treadmill test was defined by 1) an abnormalities among neurological disability
formed. A structured interview with inadequate heart rate response that was score, autonomic function testing, quanti-
detailed questions regarding medications <85% of the predicted maximum heart rate, tative sensory examination, or neurological
and history of cardiovascular disease was or 2) the presence of a left bundle branch symptom score accompanied by disabling
also done. Patients on beta-blockers or block on resting electrocardiogram (ECG). neuropathic symptoms as assessed by the
digoxin were excluded (17). During this The predicted maximum heart rate was neurological symptom score).
prerandomization period, 524 consecutive determined by 220 — age of subject. A pos- Urinary albumin excretion. Urinary albu-
patients completed a graded exercise tread- itive treadmill test was defined by J) ^1.0 min excretion (UAE) was measured from a
mill test with respiratory gas analysis along mm ST-segment depression (horizontal or 24-h collection using radioimmunoassay
with the neuropathy testing, retinal pho- down sloping >0.08 s from the J-point) techniques (Double Antibody Albumin
tographs, and urine collections. Patients with progressive exercise with or without #KHD2; Diagnostic Products, Los Angeles,
with a history of coronary artery disease or angina, and 2) normal blood pressure CA). During thefirst8 months of the study,
congestive heart failure (68 of the 524 response and signs and symptoms of angina UAE was initially measured by the neph-
patients) as determined by self-history, a occurring in the second stage of exercise or elometric method (20). The correlation 2
positive Rose questionnaire (15), or Q- beyond and then resolving within 7 min coefficient for the two methods was r =
wave criteria on the baseline electrocardio- into the recovery period. A strongly positive 0.99. UAE was classified into one of the fol-
gram were excluded in the analyses. treadmill test was defined by 1) >1.0 mm lowing categories: 1) normal albuminuria
ST-segment depression with or without (<20 ug/min), 2) microalbuminuria
Procedures angina in thefirststage of the protocol in one (20-200 ug/min), or 3) overt albuminuria
Exercise testing. An exercise treadmill test or more leads, 2) >2.0 mm ST-segment (>200 ug/min) (21).
was administered during the prerandom- depression in more than five ECG leads, 3) Retinopathy staging. Stereoscopic fundus
ization period using a Half Bruce protocol persistent ST-segment depression for >7 photographs with pupillary dilation were
obtained at the study site by a trained retinal Exercise treadmill results Multiple regression analyses
technician. Blind to the treatment regimen, Patients with a nondiagnostic test result The results of the multiple regression
technicians at the Wisconsin Retinal Reading had a significantly lower peak Vo2 (18.0 ± analyses are given in Table 3. Increasing
Center interpreted and graded the retinal 0.7 ml • kg" 1 • mirr 1 ; n = 42) than the retinopathy stage (PE = —0.59 ± 0.3 ml •
films using the modified Airlie House classi- patients with a diagnostic result: nonis- kg"1 • min""1; P = 0.026) and increasing
fication (22). For the analyses, fundus pho- chemic, 22.2 ± 0.3 ml • kg" 1 • min"1, n = UAE stage (PE = -0.62 ± 0.3 ml • k g 1 •
tographs were categorized according to the 305, P = 0.0001; strong positive, 22.8 ± min"1; P = 0.044) were both associated
presence or absence of retinopathy. 1.3 ml • kg" 1 • min"1, n = 14, P = 0.002; with a decrease in peak Vo2.
and positive, 21.9 ± 0.7 ml • kg"1 • min"1,
Statistical analysis n = 58, P = 0.0001. The average maxi- CONCLUSIONS— Previous studies
Univariate analyses were performed relat- mum heart rate was 156 ± 14 bpm. The have demonstrated that N1DDM subjects
ing peak oxygen consumption with various average maximum systolic blood pressure and possibly their relatives (23) have a
clinical factors and diabetic complications. was 210 ± 25 mmHg. The average maxi- lower peak Vo2 than nondiabetic subjects.
The complications were categorized as 1) mum perceived effort (Borg scale) was In the present study, an assessment of dia-
no neuropathy versus asymptomatic neu- 16.4 ± 1.8, and the averaged peak respi- betic complications with regard to exercise
ropathy, 2) UAE stages, and 3) no retinopa- ratory exchange ratio was 1.13 ± 0.08. In capacity was undertaken in an NIDDM
thy versus presence of retinopathy. Linear all, 330 patients stopped secondary to population. We found that increasing dia-
regressions were performed in the case of overall or leg fatigue and 86 stopped sec- betic retinopathy and UAE were both asso-
continuous independent variables, and x2 ondary to dyspnea. ciated with a decrease in exercise capacity as
tests were used with discrete variables. measured by peak Vo2. These micro vascu-
Multiple regression analyses were then per- Diabetic complications lar diabetic complications were associated
formed controlling for age, sex, duration of The presence of retinopathy and neuropa- with exercise performance independent of
diabetes, hypertension, race, and BMI. All thy were univariately associated with a age, sex, race, length of diagnosed diabetes,
results were reported as means ± SE. decrease in exercise capacity (Table 2). Sub- duration of hypertension, BMI, and GHb
jects with normal albuminuria had a signifi- level. No independent association was
RESULTS — Data from a total of 419 cantly higher peak Vo2 than patients with found between exercise capacity and dia-
patients (265 men and 154 women) were microalbuminuria or overt albuminuria. betic neuropathy.
used for the final analyses. Patient charac-
teristics and their univariate association with
peak Vo2 are reported in Table 1. Of all sub-
jects participating in the study, 65% had Table 2—Univariate correlations between diabetic complications and peak Vo2
hypertension (defined as a systolic blood
pressure >140 mmHg or diastolic blood Complication Present (n) Absent (n) P value
pressure >90 mmHg at the time of ran-
domization). Male subjects had a signifi- Retinopathy 21.3 ±0.3 (217) 22.4 ± 0.4 (204) 0.03
cantly higher peak Vo2 than female subjects. Neuropathy 20.7 ±0.7 (161) 22.5±0.3(253) 0.002
The presence of electrocardiographic left UAE
ventricular hypertrophy, increasing age, Normal (n = 270) vs. 22.3 ±0.3 21.1 ± 0 . 5 0.04
duration of hypertension, BMI, and increas- microalbuminuria (n = 95)
ing systolic blood pressure was associated Normal vs. overt albuminuria (n = 54) 22.3 ±0.3 20.9 ± 0 . 7 0.06
with a decrease in peak Vo2. Data are means ± SE.
Table 3—Multiple logistic regression analy- that was manifested as an impairment in sensitivity and glucose utilization and
sis exercise capacity. This association of peak improving blood pressure control (37).
Vo2 with increased UAE is intriguing and Another possible explanation for this
may suggest a clinical link or possible com- association between retinopathy and exer-
Parameter estimate
mon pathogenic mechanism for microvas- cise capacity may be related to left ventric-
Variable (ml • kg"1 • min"1) P value
cular derangements in the kidney and heart. ular function. Although Pauwels et al. (38)
Intercept 45.8 ± 2 . 0 0.0001 Kimball et al. (34) demonstrated an increase demonstrated no association between
Retinopathy -0.59 ±0.3 0.026 in left ventricular mass with increasing uri- severe proliferative retinopathy and left
stage nary albumin in young IDDM subjects. This ventricular function in young IDDM male
UAH -0.62 ±0.3 0.044 observation may further support the possi- patients, work from Takahashi et al. (39) in
Daia are means ± SE. Unit for each variable equals bility that changes in the heart and kidney a middle-aged population of NIDDM
1 for calculation of parameter estimate. may be related, and thus support the Japanese subjects suggested that retinopa-
hypothesis that abnormalities in these two thy is associated with impaired left ventric-
organ systems may develop in parallel with ular function.
In the present study, we chose to NIDDM, especially with exposure to addi- In conclusion, the present study of
include patients with a test positive for tional factors such as hypertension. In the NIDDM subjects demonstrated a signifi-
ischemia in the analyses, since the predic- present study, electrocardiographic left ven- cant independent association of diabetic
tive value for screening asymptomatic indi- tricular hypertrophy was univariately but nephropathy and retinopathy with exercise
viduals with an exercise treadmill test is not multivariately associated with a decrease capacity. Because the results obtained from
poor (24). Thus we may have included in peak Vo2. this study were from cross-sectional data, it
some patients with coronary artery disease Another important complication of is beyond the scope of this study to deter-
in the analysis. diabetes is retinopathy. As with dia- mine if these associations were causally
Previous studies involving IDDM betic nephropathy, this complication is related. The results suggest that a common
patients have demonstrated impaired car- also considered to result from micro- pathogenic link may be present to explain
diovascular responses in patients with dia- vascular disease. It is well known that these associations. Because the subjects
betic autonomic neuropathy (25-27). poor glycemic control, hypertension, and included in the study had no history of
However, this association has not been length of diagnosed diabetes contribute to macro vascular disease, it is plausible that
demonstrated in NIDDM patients. In the the development and progression of dia- the findings may be attributed to microvas-
present study with NIDDM subjects, uni- betic retinopathy (35). In the present study cular disease. We have demonstrated in
variate analyses revealed a strong associa- of NIDDM subjects, we found that increas- previous studies that several risk factors
tion between neuropathy and exercise ing severity of retinopathy was associated (i.e., smoking, hypertension, increasing
capacity (Table 2). But when neuropathy with decreasing peak Vo2. A possible expla- BMI, diabetes duration, and GHb), some
was placed in a multivariate model that also nation for this association is that NIDDM of which are reversible, were associated
included retinopathy and nephropathy, no patients with diabetic retinopathy are with these microvascular complications
independent association between neuropa- involved in less physical activity than their (12,40). Thus the presence of diabetic
thy and exercise capacity was demon- counterparts without retinopathy, which nephropathy and retinopathy in NIDDM
strated. This suggests that there was a then results in a decrease in exercise capac- subjects in conjunction with other cardio-
strong correlation or interaction between ity. Unfortunately, physical activity ques- vascular risk factors may decrease exercise
neuropathy and the other two NIDDM tionnaires were not obtained from an capacity The diminished exercise perfor-
complications, a correlation that Savage et adequate number of subjects to ascertain mance in association with diabetic
al. (28) previously demonstrated. the amount of physical activity involved in retinopathy and nephropathy has possible
Microalbuminuria in European NIDDM their daily routine. In this regard, it is not implications for NIDDM patients' ability to
patients has been associated with future car- uncommon for caretakers of patients with perform normal daily activities and may be
diovascular events (29,30). Schneider et al. diabetic retinopathy, especially proliferative associated with an increased cardiac mor-
(31) previously demonstrated a univariate retinopathy, to recommend abstinence bidity and mortality.
association between resting overt albumin- from vigorous exercise to avoid vitreoreti-
uria and impaired exercise capacity in IDDM nal hemorrhage. Albert et al. (36) has
and NIDDM subjects. Similar to Schneiders demonstrated that patients with prolif- Acknowledgments — This work was funded
findings, we found in the univariate and erative retinopathy have an impaired in part by Bayer Pharmaceutical Company and
multivariate analyses that the presence of autoregulatory response to blood pres- the National Institutes of Health.
micro- or overt albuminuria was associated sure increases during exercise. The resul-
with a decrease in exercise capacity. Further- tant increase in cerebral and ophthalmic
more, studies in IDDM subjects without blood flow may contribute to the devel- References
coronary artery disease have demonstrated opment of vitreoretinal hemorrhage. 1. National Diabetes Data Group: Classifica-
that increasing UAE is associated with left Ironically, exercise is considered an inte- tion and diagnosis of diabetes mellitus and
gral component of NIDDM management, other categories of glucose intolerance. Dia-
ventricular dysfunction (32,33). Thus it can betes 28:1039-1057, 1979
be postulated, but not proven, that the and exercise improves some of the factors
2. American Diabetes Association: Costs of
NIDDM subjects in the present study with that contribute to the development and diabetes. In Diabetes 1996: Vital Statistics.
micro- or overt albuminuria may also have progression of diabetic retinopathy (e.g., Alexandria, VA, American Diabetes Associ-
an impairment in left ventricular function poor glucose control) by increasing insulin ation, 1996, p. 67-69