Engineering Procurement Directorate

Summary of Foreign Contractors' Performance Evaluation

Reporting Period End of November 2019
Reporting Period 30-Nov-19

Total contract Time

Actual Aggregated Average No. of
period in 10/9 times Time Total Average elapsed is
Mobilization cumulative actual expected Contracts Additional
Contractor's Revised Commencement months Contract elapsed in Expected Expected beyond 10/9 Pass/ Non
I. No. Contract Name Period progress to performance Progress under expected
Name Contract Price (ETB) Date considered for period months Progress (%) Progress of the Performing
(in months) date (%) (%) (%) consideratio progress
this Evaluation (10/9*A) (C) (in %) Contract
n
(A) Period

Harar-Kombolcha-Ejersagoro-Fugnanbira-
1 1,771,548,687.63 6.0 13-Nov-18 36.0 40.0 12.6 1.9 12.4 No
Bombas and Ejersagoro-Ahimed Imam

Not qualified for

Menebegna-Shambu-Bako Road Upgrading CGCOC 30.20 40.6 3 2 42.61
2 993,280,400.04 4.0 7-Jul-16 40.3 44.8 40.8 91.2 81.5 No tendering
Project Contract 2: Shambu-Bako

3 Menebeghna-Fincha-Shambu 999,352,015.02 4.0 1-Jun-17 40.7 45.3 30.0 19.7 49.9 No

4 Mendir-Hana 1,668,794,447.63 3.0 5-Jan-15 51.0 56.6 58.8 96.8 100.0 Yes

Mombasa -Nairobi-Addis Ababa road corridor

5 phase III projects Hawassa-Ageremariam 1,138,684,112.87 4.0 27-Jan-17 31.1 34.6 34.1 95.3 91.5 No Not qualified for
Sinohydro 96.16 96.6 3.0 2.00 98.57
section Lot 1 Hawassa-Chuko tendering

Continuation of Contract 1: Gedo-Menebegna

6 942,471,547.72 4.0 11-Oct-19 24.0 26.7 1.6 0.5 (6.5) No
(80.5km) Road Upgrading Project

7 Mekelle Industry Park 913,224,109.15 2.00 20-Oct-17 25.1 27.9 25.3 72.8 81.09 No

China Tiesiju
8 Konso-Yabelo 1,380,977,684.75 4.0 15-Jan-15 61.7 68.6 58.5 84.5 74.1 No
Civil Eng'g 79.85 76.9 3.0 2.0 78.89 Pass
Group

Merewa – Somodo – Seka and Somodo – Limu

9 2,268,391,159.90 4.0
Junction Spur Design and Build Road Project

China MCC 17
10 Mizan-Dima 1,259,227,607.14 4.0 23-Sep-13 75.0 83.3 74.27 94.8 94.77 78.9 78.9 1.0 - 78.89 No Pass
Group

Hawassa-Hawassa Airport -Bishan

11 592,084,400.00 2.0 17-Nov-17 24.0 26.7 24.4 49.1 82.1 No
Guracha(Tikur Weha)

12 Jijiga-Gelesh Lot I 1,064,407,802.78 4.0 2-May-17 36.0 40.0 31.0 81.5 64.1 No

13 Cherereti-Hagermekor 1,058,056,622.75 4.0 26-Apr-17 36.0 40.0 31.2 76.8 64.7 No

14 Lot-II Hageremekor -Kundi 1,558,150,706.39 4.0 12-Nov-18 36.0 40.0 12.6 10.3 12.5 No

15 Lot 2 Hamero-Imi 1,544,036,614.16 4.0 8-Nov-18 36.0 40.0 12.7 10.4 12.9 No

16 Ali town-Agarfa-wabe Revier 2,153,060,671.98 4.0 1-Feb-19 36.0 40.0 9.9 4.0 8.1 No
Not qualified
Modjo -Hawassa Highway Phase I:Modjo - CCCC 19.21 25.7 11.0 51.26 76.98
17 4,857,360,800.00 4.0 7-Mar-18 42.1 46.8 20.8 9.58 26.0 No for tendering
Zeway Lot ll : Arsi Negele-Hawassa

18 Mekaneyesus/Este-Simada 1,925,451,264.45 4.0 21-Feb-19 36.0 40.0 9.3 4.36 7.2 No

19 Kombolcha -Indutrial park Access Road 478,975,000.00 1.0 27-Jun-19 12.0 13.3 5.1 - 19.7 No

20 Bilalo - Kersa - Arsi Negele 1,565,358,431.41 4.0 16-Aug-19 36.0 40.0 3.5

Abay River Bridge and Adjacent Concrete

21 1,437,000,000.00 4.0 5-Aug-19
Structures

Sodo - Tercha Road Upgrading Project

22 1,323,251,622.47 4.00 2-Jun-15 46.8 52.00 54.0 84.3 100.0 Yes
Contract 1: Sodo-Omo River Hunan-Hunda Not qualified
52.03 68.4 2.0 0.0 68.39
RBC for tendering
Tulu Bolo - Kela Design and Build Road
23 1,309,798,352.48 4.0 15-Oct-17 42.0 46.69 25.5 19.4 36.5 No
Project

1
 Engineering Procurement Directorate

Summary of Foreign Contractors' Performance Evaluation

Reporting Period End of November 2019
Reporting Period 30-Nov-19

Total contract Time

Actual Aggregated Average No. of
period in 10/9 times Time Total Average elapsed is
Mobilization cumulative actual expected Contracts Additional
Contractor's Revised Commencement months Contract elapsed in Expected Expected beyond 10/9 Pass/ Non
I. No. Contract Name Period progress to performance Progress under expected
Name Contract Price (ETB) Date considered for period months Progress (%) Progress of the Performing
(in months) date (%) (%) (%) consideratio progress
this Evaluation (10/9*A) (C) (in %) Contract
n
(A) Period

Bonga-Meyachida Road upgrading Project

24 912,916,840.51 4.0 1-Apr-13 71.2 79.1 80.0 77.4 100.0 Yes
Contract 2: Felegeselam--Ameya-Chida

Jiangxi
25 Ambo-Gedo Overlay Road Project Zhongmei 483,546,735.51 3.0 12-Jul-17 36.0 40.0 28.6 39.7 56.7 No Not qualified
45.16 55.8 4 3 58.76
Engineering for tendering
Ltd
26 Mota-Jaragedo 1,618,179,826.58 3.0 12-Jul-17 42.0 46.7 28.64 44.18 43.7 No

27 Mintamir-Metehbila - Metehara 1,096,639,115.40 4.0 18-Oct-17 42.0 46.7 25.4 22.15 36.3 No

Felegebirhan-Bahirdar Road Project

28 Contract 1: Zema River Bridge- 1,244,361,405.80 3.0 10-Jun-15 52.9 58.8 53.7 94.4 81.9 No
Felegebirhan

Sodo - Tercha Road Upgrading Project

29 1,674,383,031.77 4.00 2-Jun-15 52.80 58.7 54.0 66.5 82.7 No
Contract 2: Omo River-Tercha

Design and build of Modjo-Hawassa

30 Highway project Phase 1:Modjo-Zeway 3,675,286,150.00 4.00 28-Nov-15 50.00 55.6 48.1 80.40 75.7 No
Lot 1:Modjo-Meki China Railway
Not qualified
7th Group 69.76 68.75 7.0 10.13 78.87
31 Sodo -Dinke 1,054,003,610.30 4.00 14-May-18 48.00 53.3 18.6 14.5 16.0 No for tendering
(CRSG)
Abobo-Km 76 Design and Build Road
32 960,130,378.57 3.00 7-Feb-17 41.40 46.0 33.7 63.4 58.9 No
Project

Tercha–Weldehane–Omonada Junction
33 Road Project, Contract I: 2,450,000,000.00 4.00
Tercha–Weldehane–Werebo/

Tercha–Weldehane–Omonada Junction
34 Road Project, Contract-II: Werebo – Gona 1,450,000,000.00 4.00
– Omonada Junction

35 Gashena-Bilbila 1,442,916,047.83 3.0 12-Feb-14 75.4 83.8 69.6 78.5 71.2 No

Mombasa Nirobi-Addis Ababa Road

Corridor Phase III Projects-Hawassa
36 Ageremariam Section The Construction of 894,037,924.20 3.0 24-Apr-17 32.9 36.5 31.2 54.2 74.3 No
Balance of Works for Lot 2: Chuko- Not qualified
CRTG 42.52 61.5 5.0 4.50 65.95
Yirgachefe for tendering

37 Muketuri-Kokebmesk 768,622,711.45 3.0 23-May-17 36.0 40.0 30.3 32.6 61.8 No

38 Iteya-Robe 1,324,234,510.32 4.0 7-Nov-17 36.0 40.0 24.8 12.9 44.4 No

39 Pawi Junction - Km 69 887,759,651.45 3.0 1-Jul-17 36.0 40.0 29.0 25.2 57.8 No

Hawassa Ageremariyam LOT III, The Arab Not qualified

40 1,078,751,895.99 4.0 1-Apr-13 67.0 74.5 80.0 90.7 90.71 100.0 100.0 1.0 - 100.00 Yes
Yirgachefe-Ageremariyam Contractors for tendering

Hawk
International
Bedele metu road upgrading project Lot1,
41 Finance and 706,483,175.16 4.0 22-Apr-13 70.9 78.8 79.3 95.2 95.17 - - -
Km 0+000 KM 61+000
Construction
Co

2
 Engineering Procurement Directorate

Summary of Foreign Contractors' Performance Evaluation

Reporting Period End of November 2019
Reporting Period 30-Nov-19

Total contract Time

Actual Aggregated Average No. of
period in 10/9 times Time Total Average elapsed is
Mobilization cumulative actual expected Contracts Additional
Contractor's Revised Commencement months Contract elapsed in Expected Expected beyond 10/9 Pass/ Non
I. No. Contract Name Period progress to performance Progress under expected
Name Contract Price (ETB) Date considered for period months Progress (%) Progress of the Performing
(in months) date (%) (%) (%) consideratio progress
this Evaluation (10/9*A) (C) (in %) Contract
n
(A) Period

JMC Project Not qualified

42 Nekempt - Bure Lot 2 :Andhode-Agamsa 1,753,006,280.38 4.0 1-Nov-16 36.0 40.0 36.95 53.31 53.31 83.18 83.2 1.0 - 83.18 No
(India) ltd for tendering

China First
Not qualified
43 Bilbila-Sekota Highway 2,041,313,289.84 3.0 12-Jun-15 55.0 61.1 53.65 70.81 70.81 77.21 77.2 1.0 - 77.21 No
for tendering
Eng.Co.Ltd
Daewoo
Modjo-Hawassa Phase-I Modjo-
44 Enginering & 2,009,627,407.98 4.0 9-May-16 48.3 53.7 42.74 68.05 68.05 66.88 66.88 1.0 - 66.88 No Pass
Zeway,LotII:- Meki-ZewaySection
Construction

Albereketi-Gelemso-Mechara,Contract
45 1,018,376,811.96 4.0 25-May-15 59.3 65.9 54.25 67.58 70.29 No
1:Albereketi-Gelemso
Not qualified
Al Asab 62.38 67.6 2.0 - 67.64
for tendering
Albereketi-Gelemso-Mechara,Contract
46 982,246,411.15 4.0 16-Nov-15 55.9 62.1 48.5 57.0 64.9 No
2:Gelemso-Mechara-Micheta

Aykel-Zufan-Angereb , Lot II: Km 69+00 -

47 1,473,670,095.45 4.0 20-Jun-17 40.0 44.4 29.4 27.2 49.7 No
Angereb Not qualified
China Wu Yi 28.09 49.1 2.0 - 49.13
for tendering
48 Daye-Chiri-Nansebo 1,682,275,009.45 3.0 27-Sep-17 36.0 40.0 26.1 28.9 48.7 No

Abobo - Meti (contract 2: Kubito Mazoria- China

49 Gezhouba 1,298,029,530.00 4.0 13-Nov-17 42.0 46.7 24.6 30.0 34.4 No
Meti-km 76) Not qualified
Group 20.68 28.7 2 - 28.74
for tendering
50 Tepi-Mizan Road Project Company 1,246,200,728.65 4.0 26-Jan-18 48.0 53.3 22.1 11.0 22.9 No
Limited
China Railway
Gambela -Abobo - Gog -Dima (Contract 1: 21st Bureau
51 1,310,919,269.00 3.0 16-Oct-17 48.0 53.3 25.5 20.4 29.4 No
Gambela -Abobo-Pugnido) Group Co., Ltd
in Joint Not qualified
7.91 14.9 3 2.00 16.93
Jimma -Agaro Dedesa River Road venture with for tendering
52 1,306,509,305.58 4.0 1-Jan-19 42.0 46.7 10.9 2.0 7.6 No
Upgrading project Jiangxi Water
Construction Works of Shishinda –Tepi and
53 1,556,573,045.57 4.0 9-Oct-18 48.0 53.3 13.7 2.4 8.9 No
Road Project Hydropower

Fisiha Genet-Kele-Segen-Gebelbano Road Shandong

54 Project, Lot 1: Fisiha Genet-Kele-Nedele Highway 1,589,317,000.00 4.0 19-Oct-17 42.0 46.7 25.4 7.1 36.2 No
Design and Build Road Project (92.5Km) Not qualified
Construction 9.54 32.6 2 - 32.60
for tendering
Group Co.,
55 Atat Junction - Gunchire -Kose -Geja -Lera LTD 1,165,299,596.00 4.0 16-Oct-17 49.7 55.2 25.5 12.9 27.7 No

Gambela -Abobo - Gog -Dima (Contract 1:

56 1,310,919,269.00 3.0 16-Oct-17 48.0 53.3 25.5 20.4 29.4 No
Gambela -Abobo-Pugnido) Jiangxi Water
and
Not qualified
Design and Construction Works of Fiyel Hydropower 21.89 38.5 2 - 38.50
for tendering
Weha - Abi Adi Road Project, Contract-1: Construction
57 1,166,300,000.00 4.0 26-Sep-17 36.0 40.0 26.1 23.6 48.8 No
Fiyel Weha – Tekeze River (Km 0+000 to Co, .Ltd.
km 35+500)

SBI
Modjo-Hawassa Highway project Phase Not qualified
58 International 3,182,975,440.73 4.0 23-Feb-18 42.0 46.7 21.2 5.3 5.27 27.0 27.0 1 - 26.95 No
II:Zeway Lot 1:Modjo-rsi Negele(57.1km) for tendering
Holding AG
Investroy Not qualified
59 Tercha-Chida 1,171,155,172.55 3.0 8-Sep-17 30.0 33.4 26.7 11.45 11.45 67.50 67.50 1.0 - 67.50 No
Proekt LLC for tendering
Jigjiga - Tulu - Lowwanja - Dul'ad -
60 CCECC 1,551,507,344.53 4.0 27-Jun-19 36.0 40.0 5.1 1.64 1.64 1.55 1.55 1.0 - 1.55 No Pass
Samekab - Harmukale Junction
61 Dinke-Sawla 1,020,177,271.01 4.0 16-Jan-19 48.0 53.3 10.5 4.08 5.92 No
Bejing Urban
Not qualified
62 Morka-Gircha-Chencha Construction 1,967,496,759.60 4.0 13-Mar-19 42.0 46.7 8.6 0.79 2.43 5.08 5.81 3.0 2.00 7.81 No
for tendering
Group Ltd
63 Debark-Zarima 2,412,000,000.00 4.0 1-Jan-19 48.0 53.3 10.9 3.08 6.37 No

3
 Engineering Procurement Directorate

Summary of Foreign Contractors' Performance Evaluation

Reporting Period End of November 2019
Reporting Period 30-Nov-19

Total contract Time

Actual Aggregated Average No. of
period in 10/9 times Time Total Average elapsed is
Mobilization cumulative actual expected Contracts Additional
Contractor's Revised Commencement months Contract elapsed in Expected Expected beyond 10/9 Pass/ Non
I. No. Contract Name Period progress to performance Progress under expected
Name Contract Price (ETB) Date considered for period months Progress (%) Progress of the Performing
(in months) date (%) (%) (%) consideratio progress
this Evaluation (10/9*A) (C) (in %) Contract
n
(A) Period

Hyundai
Not qualified
64 Gore-Masha-Tepi Road Upgrading Project Development 4,468,211,740.75 4.0 1-Jan-19 54.0 60.0 10.9 5.44 5.44 5.46 5.46 1.0 - 5.46 No
for tendering
Company

Hebei
Tenta Junction-Wegeltena-Kurba(31+500-
65 Contruction 1,873,489,476.53 4.0 1-Apr-19 36.0 40.0 8.0 5.50 5.50 5.48 5.48 1.0 - 5.48 No Pass
110+740)
Group Co. Ltd.

Zhejiang
Bayong
Lare-New Jinkawo-Ninighang Road Not qualified
66 Highway 1,420,584,397.57 4.0 2-May-19 48.0 53.3 7.0 - - 2.72 2.72 1.0 - 2.72 No
project for tendering
Engineering
Co. Ltd.

Mesle/Musle-Kore/Kori-Ture Road Project;

67 1,536,235,536.54 4.0 11-Feb-19 36.0 40.0 9.6 0.06 7.70 No
Contract I: Mesle/Musle Km 84+200
China State
Construction
Mesle/Musle-Kore/Kori-Ture Road Project; Not qualified
68 Engineering 1,502,371,329.81 4.0 11-Feb-19 36.0 40.0 9.6 0.61 0.33 7.70 7.70 3.0 2.00 9.70 No
Contract II: Km 84+200-Teru(km 156+589) for tendering
Corp. Ltd.
(CSCEC)
Muketuri Alem Ketema Road Project, Lot 2:
69 1,695,796,682.10 3.0 19-Sep-19 36.0 40.0 2.4 - (0.77) No
Kokeb Mesk – Alem Ketema
Note
1 2
Formula to
Category of Contract Period
be used Contractors who failed to complete projects after one ninth of the contract
First (1/3)rd 11(t1) period elapsed beyond the Contract period will be disqualified
Second(1/3)rd 11+31(t2)
last (1/3)rd 42+38(t3)
Beyond Contract period 80+20(t4)

Prepared by: Approval recommended by: Approved by:

Project Engineer _________________ Engineering Procurement Team-3, Team Leader ___________________ Engineering Procurement Directorate, Director ___________________

4
20-Feb-12
27-Feb-13

5
20-Feb-12
27-Feb-13

6
20-Feb-12
27-Feb-13

7
 20-Feb-12
27-Feb-13

___________________