Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dreamwork in The Light of Emotional and Spiritual Intelligence Daniel Deslauriers, PH.D
Dreamwork in The Light of Emotional and Spiritual Intelligence Daniel Deslauriers, PH.D
The idea that we can develop “dream skills” is based on my work as teacher in a
graduate psychology program (East-West Psychology) with a strong emphasis on
consciousness studies. In the many classes and groups I facilitated, I have observed
1 The word 'dreamwork' is used here in the sense of conscious engagement with dream contents
before, during or after recalling a dream. This is in contrast to the psychoanalytic use of the same
word to refer to the mechanisms at play during dream formation (displacement, condensation,
reversal, etc.) as proposed by Freud (1953).
1
noticeable differences in how people contribute to dream group, an activity that implies
sharing personal feelings and deciphering the meaning of dream images. Often, people
with dreamwork experience approach dreams in ways that inexperienced persons do
not. I link the improvement of dream-related skills to life-long learning and the
development of certain capacities.
2
As conscious beings, humans are purposive and seek to actualize and realize
themselves in relationships with their fellow beings. We often refer to this purposive
being as self2. Within the understanding of self as a process finding expression in an
"autopoietic" or self -generating manner (Arden, 1996), dreams are intimately related to
the unfolding of the self. Dreams are a natural, adaptive and possibly transformative
process. At the core of an hermeneutic of discovery (an approach to interpretation, that,
in contrast to an hermeneutic of suspicion, takes dreams at face value and plays down
the idea that they are the result of a defensive censoring mechanism), dreams are
viewed as directly expressing emotionally laden situations, current concerns and even
as introducing elements of creative problem solving. In dream groups, a dreamer's
natural ability to work non-defensively with dream images is affirmed and a supportive
context is provided. Knowledge derives from dreamwork because of the dreams' poetic
(in the root sense of creative) capacity to reveal something about self, about the
relationship between self and world, or about the relationship between self and its
transcendent core.
Very few authors however discuss developmental changes taking place between
childhood/adolescence and adulthood or discuss changes occurring during adulthood.
Watkins (1986) argues that more attention needs to be given to study the link between
early and later phases in the development of dream skills and other imaginal capacities.
Many questions are still unanswered about adult development of dream skills. How do
people develop their imaginal capacities as adults? How do certain individuals choose
dreams as their main way of accessing and unfolding spiritual intelligence?
2 With its emphasis on nouns, the English language innocently leads us to think of self as an
entity, i.e. ʻthe selfʼ, whereas it is more appropriate to view self as a complex dynamic interplay of
several nested capacities such as consciousness, proprioception (our bodily felt sense) and
knowing; self-awareness and will; and the capacity for interority and empathy. In this view self is
like more an event than an object.
3 Infants proportionally display longer periods of REM sleep than do adults, leading researchers
to postulate that REM may be related to implicit (or unconscious) consolidation of learning. There
is a debate as to whether very young infants really 'dream' since they may lack the cognitive
apparatus to do so (and, like non-human animals, do not have the linguistic means to convey
their inner life).
3
Education about dreams is more likely than not a matter of chance: a sympathetic
parent or teacher might encourage and teach about the value of paying attention to
dreams. For many, skills related to dreams may become arrested because knowledge
about dreams is generally not taken as seriously in Western cultures as it is in non-
Western cultures (Tedlock, 1992). As a result, despite the fact that dreams have been
used in therapeutic settings for more than a hundred years (Piotrowsky and Biele, 1986,
1985), relatively little is known about the way ordinary people both find and maintain
interest in dreams once they reach adulthood, or how dreams affect their lives
spiritually.
A way to address this lack is to link the notion of imaginal skills to the concept of
multiple intelligences (Gardner 1993) and that of spiritual intelligence (Noble 2000).
Gardner has identified a spectrum of specific abilities (verbal, logical-mathematical,
musical, spatial, emotional, kinesthetic, naturalistic) beyond the standard definition of
intelligence. Recently, emotional intelligence (the ability to recognize the feelings and
emotions of others, and the ability to analyze one's own feelings to guide one's actions)
has gained wide recognition through the work of Goleman (1995). It has provided the
framework for numerous interventions in educational and corporate settings, in
particular ones, which foster greater self-monitoring (intrasubjective skills), emotional
literacy (the naming and verbalizing emotions) and intersubjective skills and empathy.
Compared to the concepts of multiple and emotional intelligence, the notion of spiritual
intelligence is more recent. Since the Age of Enlightenment, the development of
spiritual abilities has been relegated and understood almost exclusively within the
bounds of contemplative or religious practices. Within psychology, the notion of a
spiritual intelligence is just coming into view. Gardner (1998) has recently hinted at a
ninth form of intelligence4, calling it “existential intelligence”, and referring to the ability to
understand and reflect on the fundamental questions of life. Coles (1997) speaks of a
"moral intelligence" developing throughout childhood. Maslow (1968) has hinted at
spiritual intelligence when he coined the term "Being cognition" as a particular
orientation in the thinking pattern of a person, which includes ultimate values.
Spiritual intelligence is also related to the ability to absorb information, to learn and to
cope, to understand and deal with new situations and to the ability to apply knowledge
in making choice or in thinking abstractly (essential to the development of dream skills).
It is however concerned with distinctive dimensions of thinking, being, affect and action,
such as those that lead to greater authenticity, openness, compassion, truthfulness, and
the exploration of ultimate values. One could argue that spiritual intelligence may serve
to integrate other forms of intelligence or, at least, to situate the use of intelligence in a
wider context. The development of such capacities takes place over the entire life
4For Gardner (1998), the status of 'intelligence' has not been completely established since,
according to his own criteria, we will need to identify specific neuronal centers associated with it
have been identified.
4
span5, and as Jung (1961) and Washburn (1988) have both pointed out, it takes on a
special significance at or around middle age. At this time proposes Jung (1974); one is
confronted not only with the personal concerns, but also a deeper level, connected to a
“collective unconscious”:
“The ʻbigʼ or ʻmeaningfulʼ dreams come from this deeper level… [W]e are dealing
with a collective emotion, a typical situation full of affect, which is not primarily a
personal experience…it is a universally human problem which, because it has
been overlooked subjectively, forces itself objectively upon the dreamerʼs
consciousness” (p.77-78).
Spiritual intelligence thus includes formal rationality as described by Piaget (1962) but
also transcends the merely rational (Wilber, 1995). One does not work through a
psychological crisis in mid-life the same tool, as one would resolve a logical problem.
The form of self-inquiry that takes place at that time cannot be exclusively confined
within a rational linguistic framework. Such inquiry often relates to experiences
individuals undergo either spontaneously (such as a ʻbigʼ or ʻmeaningfulʼ dream) or as a
result of meditation and contemplation (Rothberg, 1996). This in turn underscores the
importance of what is known as “other ways of knowing”, and the attainment of a level of
meaning often metaphorically referred to as a “knowledge of the heart.” Dreams, as
largely non-linguistic, non-rational phenomena, provide a medium particularly well suited
not only for psychological exploration but spiritual actualization as well.
Over time, the sustained practice of dreamwork leads to the development the following
skills (of course predicated on that essential skill, or discipline, of dream recall):
1- improved metaphoric and imagistic thinking;
2- increased appreciation of the nuances of dream life and variety of dreams;
3- increased openness to the creative potential of the mind and development of
an understanding of intentional work with dreams;
4- better understanding of the fluid boundaries between body and mind;
5- increased ability to apply guidance from dream;
5 Jung points out that ʻbigʼ or archetypal dreams occur “during the critical phases of life, in early
youth, puberty, at the onset of middle age, and within sight of death.” These dreams provide
opportunity to
5
6- increased empathy towards others.
a) At the beginning of dreamwork, the dreamer is often faced with the problem of
identifying relevant metaphorical referents. Each dream image may be
connected to many metaphorical referents, some of which are "transparent" and
some of which are only known to the dreamer. Refinement in metaphorical skills
allows a dreamer to develop the ability to unfold metaphorical nuances from
dream images and to verbalize complex connections between dreaming and
waking life. I previously referred to this skill as “dream metaphorical mapping”
(Baylor and Deslauriers 1987).
6
Dreamwork is not only a cognitive process, but closely relates to our emotional
landscape. It connects to emotional intelligence in four major ways.
1- Emotions serve as bridges between the dream and the waking life context.
Dreamwork often follows the emotional cues given by the dream encapsulated in
the following question: "Where in waking life is the dream emotion played out"?
Dreams help to identify the emotional tenor associated with a particular situation.
4- Related to the previous point, sharing dreams can facilitate the development of
empathy. One comes to recognize similarities between one's core life issues and
those of others. Dreamwork can extend the range and depth of connection we
can establish with others, in a relatively short time frame. I will address this
dimension below as a specific dream-related skill.
7
When incubating the Divine, dreamers found themselves confronted with important
existential questions in their dreams. In a second incubation study (Bogzaran and
Deslauriers, 1995), non-lucid dreamers were asked to report their spiritual experience.
The following dream is from a participant for whom the experience of formulating
incubation was at first "confusing": "First I had to define 'Divine' and this was difficult
since I do not believe in God or an organizing principle of the universe. It made me
question whether I could actually experience something I didn't believe in or at least was
unsure of. I felt some tension about participating in a project that I presumed was about
something I didn't think existed."
She adds: "I know this doesn't deal directly with the Divine as I learned
about it but one of my problems with this task has been a personal definition of
' Divine.' I don't think of it as an entity or energy outside myself... nor as a presence
with intention or guidance. I would define 'Divine ' as I have experienced it in this
dream: utter tranquility no dichotomies, complete calm and serenity."
This dream is especially poignant because the dreamer previously had serious doubts
about the goal of the research. The incubation task sent her on a quest only to portray
an exquisite creative response in her dream. In the word of the dreamer, there is no
explicit reference to or vision of "Christian, Buddhist, Hindu or any other deities."
Nevertheless, the dream had the effect of clarifying her understanding of the Divine. A
paradoxical thought lingers to her after the dream: "Perhaps the Divine is experiencing
nothing and everything."
For Browning (1987) "when it comes to speaking about the most ultimate (in the sense
of the most determinative aspect of our experience), we do it in a metaphorical
language...The metaphors we use to represent the ultimate context of experience
function to orient us toward that context, form our expectations, teach us to see the
world in a certain way, and give us the basic vision by which we live" (p. 58).
Furthermore, as Goleman argues, the emotional mind is associative; " [t]his is why
similes, metaphors, and images speak directly to the emotional mind... Religious symbol
8
and ritual make little sense from the rational point of view: it is couched in the vernacular
of the heart" (p.294). When we apply the context of ultimate concerns to dreamwork,
we are invoking the metaphoric and evocative potential towards understanding the
spiritual dimension (Bulkeley, 1995).
The second set of skills people develop in tending their dreams over time is a sensitivity
to the nuances of their dream life and appreciation of the multiplicity of dreams.
Dreamers come to know that dreams, like waking thoughts, are infinitely varied. Just as
each person has a unique sleep signature, fluctuating night after night, dreams too
cannot be described in a unitary way as if they were of the same kind (Hunt, 1989).
Over time, people learn to recognize of the various kinds of dreams they have and many
even develop original ways to categorize them. Experienced dreamers develop a sense
of the kind of dreams they typically have and of those that are possible to achieve.
Both vernacular and scholarly dream typologies abound in the literature (see Van de
Castle, 1994 for an historical review). Here is a list of the most common dimensions
upon which dream typologies are formed: a continuum of mundane to archetypal
dreams; a continuum of pleasant to unpleasant dreams (e.g., good dreams vs.
nightmares); a continuum of "past" "present" "future" dreams (respectively dreams about
unfinished business or past traumas, dreams about emotional integration, and
prospective/ precognitive dreams); a continuum of "body" "psyche" and "spirit" (dreams
respectively concerned with body function, psychological well-being, and experience of
transpersonal or spiritual nature e.g., dreams of visitation by the deceased or by a
spiritual teacher); and finally a continuum of lucidity (awareness that one is currently
dreaming and can exercise control over one's dreams). There exist also a series of
extraordinary dream experiences such as dream within dream and false awakening and
so-called mutual dreams.
In their research on impactful dream, Kuiken and Sikora, (1991) point out to a particular
type of dreams that seems to foster a connection with spiritual concerns. Such
experiences make one aware of one's assumptions about the nature of reality and may
lead dreamers to question what they know and how they know it. These dreams may
expand the boundaries of self-understanding. Shortly after the birth of his first son, a
colleague received a letter from a friend asking him when his child was born and how
the delivery went. It also contained a detailed dream. With uncanny precision, this
dream metaphorically portrayed a difficult delivery (which was indeed the case) and was
dated the day of the birth. This event propelled him to make a career change and to
make dreams the focus of his psychological research. Dreams such as these also alter
the common understanding of dreams as being almost exclusively self-referential.
9
3- Increased openness to the Creative Potential of the Mind and Development of
an Understanding of Intentional Dreaming
Dreamwork is fueled by conscious intent and focuses a dreamer's attention to the
unfolding meanings of his or her dreams. To reflect on a dream can be construed as a
prototypical act of self-reflectiveness. "The phenomenon of dreaming is 'located' in the
interval which extends between 'I' and 'me', between the subject and the object of self-
reflexivity" (Kugler, 1988, p. 1). In my opinion an integral approach to dreamwork takes
into consideration that this can take place at before, during or after the dream. Most
likely self-reflection occurs after the dream, such as during dream interpretation or in a
dream group. It can however occur before the dream such as in dream incubation
(Meier, 1966) or even during the dream itself as in lucid dreaming. Lucid dreams are
dreams within which the dreamer is aware that he or she is dreaming. As a result of
dream lucidity, a dreamer might display similar self-reflective capacities as in waking
(Laberge, 1985). The cultivation of awareness within dreams can be a very powerful
means of understanding the creative dynamics of the self and their creative role in the
perception of the world. It also can open up the active exploration of imaginal and
spiritual worlds in the dream states (Bogzaran, 1990; 1994).
10
presents an enabling manifestation of this thought. The image was, so to speak, a
direct reflection of this desire to fly.
This passage points out to the fact that development of dream skills is not confined to
dream interpretation but also can include the cultivation of awareness in the dream state
itself. Dreaming becomes an evolutionary activity suggesting that self-cultivation can be
undertaken for the benefit of the self or for that of the species as a whole.
The relationship between dream and proprioception also finds expression as the
dreamer, with or without conscious awareness, uses bodily felt-sense during dreamwork
(Gendlin, 1986). As is well known in the fields of somatics and biofeedback, the body is
one of primary means of accessing psychological material as exemplified by the
11
intimate link between breathing or heart rhythm and particular emotional states. This
skill thus is constellated within a somatic orientation to dreamwork and it integrates
dreamwork with kinesthetic and somatic intelligence. As a mode of working with
dreams, I use a method called the dream body map in which dreamers are asked to
make the connection between their bodily experiences and the images from their
dreams, through imagery and drawing. The exercise serves to enhance body
consciousness and the connection between the "imaginal self" and the "bodily self".
Breakthrough in understanding occurs when dreamers realize that areas of
psychological constriction are closely related to areas of physiological tension or
somatic symptoms. Vice versa, the psychological understanding of bodily symptoms
through dream work often give the chance to the dreamer to ascribe meaning to what
was previously experienced as senseless symptoms.
While the work of imagination necessitates the ability to be open and receptive (a
characteristic of dreams is their spontaneous occurrence), it also requires the
ability to ponder and to use proper discernment. The link between dreams and
action has been viewed with ambivalence by most secular modern thinkers and
by organized religions alike. Rationality and reasonableness are favored as
means to express motives and to justify actions even though they rarely
completely account for the felt meaning that accompanies many of our most
important choices. However, when the right context of intimacy is created, such
12
as that found in psychotherapy, it is not rare to hear people claim that they have
taken important life-changing steps based on dreams. This finds echo in many
traditional cultures where important actions are not undertaken unless some
confirmation has been given through a dream.
Furthermore, many people report that dreams provide them with intimations of
future events. These can be experienced either as precognition6 or as active
anticipation; as a result questions often arise as to whether one should act on
one's dream to change a future outcome, as if dreams are giving warnings, or
else, make the dream a reality as in the case of positive anticipatory dreams.
Ethical considerations
Integration of the various dimensions of the self is a central task for maturing adults and
we have seen that dreams can present valuable information addressing the state of
6We do not have totally satisfactory psychological model to account for such occurrence. The
most plausible models borrow from principles of non-locality put forward by quantum mechanic.
13
psychological balance between different aspects of the self. Important questions
however are raised by linking dreams to spiritual development; for instance, does
learning to work with dreams makes one a better person? What demarcates excessive
self-centeredness from the healthy pursuit of self-integration? Since dreamwork puts a
strong emphasis on self-reflectiveness, how do the skills mentioned above provide
safeguards against narcissistic tendencies? Moreover, given that particular course of
action can be taken from dreams, similar ethical consideration needs to be give to these
action even if they "come from our dreams". What principles are there to balance self-
interest with the common good? Such concerns point out the ethical dimensions of
dreamwork in general. My personal experience led me to believe that the group or the
therapist can serve an important role in the case where ethical questions stemming from
dream work are raised. Moreover, future studies might shed light on how dream related
work could foster ethical behavior and life affirming actions.
Conclusion
Dreams can play an important role in self-actualization because they present privileged
material that may spark insights about spiritual dimensions. They have often been
understood as a way of knowing because they present an enactive context where a
world is not just "represented" but rather they are an occasion for experience. In this
article I emphasized the development of dream-related skills that result from engaging in
dream work for extended period of time. These skills help dreamers integrate complex
emotional material and derive insights and self-knowledge. Also a sense of openness
may develop regarding the possibility that dreams might present, in imagistic form,
information that complements waking thought. Jung (1974) termed the “transcendent
function" the spontaneous ability of the psyche to produce symbols signifying the
emergence of figurative resolutions, which transcend the ability of conscious thinking to
achieve. This can give one's current waking existence a sense of depth.
14
Baylor, G.W. & Deslauriers, D. (1987). Understanding dreams, Method, maps
and metaphor. Dreamworks, 5 (1), 46-57.
Bulkeley, K. (1994). The Wilderness of Dreams. Albany, NY: State University of New York
Press.
15