Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Novel
Novel
Abstract
In modern structural constructions, concrete-filled steel tubular (CFT) columns have gradually become a central element in structural
systems like tall buildings, bridges and so forth. The effective parameters on load carrying capacity of CFT columns are the bond
between the steel and internal concrete, local buckling strength of steel tube, creep of concrete and loading conditions of column at
connections. Considering these effective parameters, a novel section is suggested which can be used for columns of tall buildings and
bridges with large spans. The main characteristic of the suggested steel section is internal longitudinal symmetric stiffeners. In the present
study, a comparative investigation into the behavior of this novel section (with circular and octagonal shapes) and the most common
used sections of CFT columns has been carried out under axial and cyclic loading. Having verified the finite element modeling, several
different analyses have been undertaken. The results of the analyses clearly exhibit the increase in strength and ductility of the suggested
novel section under axial and cyclic loading and therefore, its application is recommended in construction practice.
r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Concrete-filled steel tubular (CFT) columns; Internal longitudinal symmetric stiffeners; Nonlinear finite element modeling; Strength and
ductility
1. Introduction tested to investigate the effect of the steel shape and wall
thickness on the ultimate strength of the composite
In the building construction industry, concrete-filled column. Experimental results suggest that circular tubes
tube (CFT) columns are gaining popularity all over the offer substantial post-yield strength and stiffness, not
world. Compared to conventional steel or reinforced available in most square or rectangular cross sections.
concrete columns, CFT columns possess many advantages Susantha et al. [3] have presented a method to predict the
such as the steel tube providing confinement and formwork complete stress–strain curve of concrete subjected to
for the concrete core, stability and stiffness of the steel tube triaxial compressive stresses caused by axial load plus
is improved because of the concrete filled into the column, lateral pressure due to the confinement action in circular,
and lower construction cost. CFT columns have become so square and octagonal shaped concrete-filled steel tubes.
widespread owing to their axially compressed nature The highest confinement was found in circular-shaped
making them superior to conventional reinforced concrete columns, while the lowest was in square columns. Inai et al.
and steel structural systems in terms of stiffness, strength, [4] have conducted experimental study into the behavior of
ductility, and energy absorption capacity. The appropriate concrete-filled circular and square steel tubular (CFT)
behavior of these columns is due to the confinement of beam columns with a variety of material strengths under
concrete core by steel wall [1]. Schneider [2] has undertaken axial compression, cyclic horizontal load and biaxial
an experimental and analytical study on the behavior of bending. The test results show that the ductility of circular
short, concrete-filled steel tube columns concentrically CFT beam columns is superior to that of square CFT beam
loaded in compression to failure. Fourteen specimens were columns and the ductility of square CFT beam columns
decreases as the width to thickness ratio increases.
Corresponding author. Fujimoto et al. [5] have investigated experimentally the
E-mail address: k_abedi@sut.ac.ir (K. Abedi). effects of section shape and higher material strengths on
0263-8231/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.tws.2007.07.019
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K. Abedi et al. / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 310–319 311
the flexural behavior of eccentrically loaded concrete-filled to undertake nonlinear analyses for comparative in-
steel tubular columns. They have found that the use of high vestigation into the behavior of this novel section (with
strength filling concrete generally caused a reduction in the circular and octagonal shapes) and the most common
ductility of a circular CFT column. Also, an increase in used sections of CFT under axial and cyclic loading;
bending strength due to the confinement effect cannot be to put forward some recommendations for appropriate
expected in square CFT columns. Han and Lin [6] provided design of the CFT columns.
new test data pertaining to the seismic behavior of
concrete-filled hollow structural steel columns after ex-
2. Suggested section for CFT columns
posure to fire. They have found that concrete-filled tubular
columns after exposure to fire exhibit very high levels of
In spite of the appropriate behavior of CFT columns
energy dissipation and ductility. Also, it has been found
under different loading conditions, especially cyclic load-
that generally the energy dissipation ability of the columns
ing, the most common used sections of CFT columns have
with circular sections was much higher than those of the
some weak points such as:
specimens with square sections.
Despite the good performance of CFT columns with most
common used sections, some stiffening schemes have been high sensitivity of beam-to-column connections to the
proposed to improve the load carrying capacity and ductility manner of load distribution [9];
of these columns under different loading conditions. Huang local buckling of steel wall under lower loads due to the
et al. [7] have investigated the axial load behavior of pressure of concrete to the inside surface of steel wall [10];
concrete-filled steel tubular (CFT) columns and proposed an considerable reduction of strength due to the shrinkage
effective stiffening scheme to improve the mechanical and creep of concrete [9];
properties of square cross-sectional CFT columns in terms separation of steel and concrete at the end of columns at
of ultimate strength and ductility. The proposed stiffening lower loads due to the lack of enough contact surfaces
scheme involves welding a set of four steel bars at regular between them [11].
spacing along the tube axis. Results in this study demon-
strate that the proposed stiffening scheme can significantly In order to eliminate the above weak points, a special
enhance the ultimate strength and ductility of square CFT steel section is suggested for CFT columns as shown in
columns. Also, the failure modes of the specimens indicate Fig. 1. Ferdousi [12] has explained the process of
that the stiffening scheme effectively delays local buckling. suggesting these shapes.
Hu et al. [8] have used four reinforcing ties at regular spacing The main characteristics of this novel section are as
along the axis of square section. The results of study show follows:
that the use of reinforcing ties prevents the local buckling of
steel tube and enhances the lateral confining pressure of the internal longitudinal symmetric stiffeners are welded to
square tubes, especially when the tie spacing is small and tie the inside surface of steel wall throughout the length of
number (or tie diameter) is large. column;
In the present study, a novel section is suggested which these sections can be produced by welding at the
can be used for columns of tall buildings and bridges with workshops of construction sites with special arrange-
large spans. The main characteristic of the suggested steel ments and careful preparations (Fig. 2);
section is internal longitudinal symmetric stiffeners. For the shape of this section can be either circular or octagonal.
selecting this novel section, the effective parameters on the Also, special advantages of this novel section are as
behavior of CFT columns should be considered. These follows:
parameters are as follows: using this section, there is no need to use any type of
shear connections at the beam-to-column connection
slenderness and compactness of steel section; zone for transferring loads to the concrete core;
concrete confinement effect on the strength and ductility in this section, load transferring can be carried out very
of CFT columns; appropriately due to the increase in the contact surface
type of steel and concrete filling used in CFT columns; between steel and concrete;
residual stresses and corner effects;
creep and shrinkage effects of filling concrete;
loading conditions and connection type;
bond between steel and filling concrete.
3. Finite element modeling of CFT columns Fig. 3. Failure surface in principal stress space szp close to zero.
Table 1
The specifications of the experimental CFT columns
Sample name Type of Cross section Dimensions L/D FY (MPa) fc0 (MPa)
loading (mm)
Fig. 8. Loading condition the loading conditions for ST85-I and CIIS3 specimens (R ¼ D/L, N0 ¼ As Fy+Ac sc, sc ¼ 1.2fc0 : confinment effect).
O2.pr (octagonal section with filled concrete and stiffen- The total cross-section area of the columns in each
ers). The assumptions made in the selection of these group, including the cross-section areas of steel wall,
sections are as follows: concrete core, stiffeners and reinforcement bars, as well
as the material properties are the same. In the groups of
The selected CFT columns have been considered as 1 and 2, the total cross-section area of steel is 23,047 and
columns with common used dimensions and with high 30,219 mm2, respectively. In each group, the cross-
load carrying capacity (L=3000 mm). section area of concrete is 23,823 mm2.
For steel: Fy=280 MPa, Es=200,000 MPa and for In suggested novel sections, area of the stiffeners is 30%
concrete: fc0 =27.0 MPa, Ec=23,823 MPa. of the cross-section area of steel section.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
K. Abedi et al. / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 310–319 315
Fig. 12. Three types of load application. Load applied to: (a) the concrete core section, (b) the steel section, and (c) the entire section.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
316 K. Abedi et al. / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 310–319
Fig. 13. The axial load–axial displacement responses of the CFT columns Fig. 15. The axial load–axial displacement responses of C1.cr and C2.pr
of group 1 (load application type of (a)). samples (load application type of (c)).
Fig. 16. The axial load–axial displacement responses of the CFT columns
of group 2 (load application type of (c)).
Fig. 14. The axial load–axial displacement responses of the CFT columns
of group 1 (load application type of (b)).
4.2. Numerical results of the CFT samples under lateral group 1 under lateral cyclic loading. This figure clearly
cyclic loading indicates the less degradation of load at the subsequent
cycles for suggested CFT sections, especially O1.pr CFT
The process of lateral cyclic loading and the number of sample. Fig. 18 shows the deformed shapes and Von-Mises
cycles–lateral displacement history applied to the CFT stress contours for CFT columns of group 1 at the end of
column samples have been illustrated in Fig. 12. It is worth lateral cyclic loading. This figure shows buckling occur-
noting that in this cyclic loading, after applying 30% of rence of S1.cr, C1.cr and C1.cr–re CFT samples. However,
nominal load carrying capacity of the column as an axial in C1.pr and O1.pr suggested novel sections, before
load (3600 kN for CFT columns of group 1 and 4200 kN yielding, the steel wall has not buckled. Therefore, the
for CFT columns of group 1), lateral cyclic displacement concrete confinement effect has been increased. Fig. 19
has been applied to the top of column. Fig. 17 shows the illustrates the hysteretic curves for CFT columns of group 2
envelope curves of hysteretic loops for CFT columns of under lateral cyclic loading. This figure clearly indicates the
Fig. 17. The envelope curves of hysteretic loops for CFT columns of Fig. 19. The hysteretic loops for CFT columns of group 2 under lateral
group 1. cyclic loading.
Fig. 18. Deformed shapes and Von-Mises stress contours for CFT columns of group 1 at the end of cyclic loading.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
318 K. Abedi et al. / Thin-Walled Structures 46 (2008) 310–319
Dipartimento di Ing. Struct. Universita di Palermo, 1999; I-90128, [14] Yousef M A, Schneider S. Analytical behaviour of connections
Italy. to concrete-filled steel tube. J Construction Steel Res 1998;45(3):
[11] Shakir-Khalil H. Pushout strength of concrete-filled steel hollow 321–52.
sections. Struct Eng 1993;71(13):230–8. [15] Sakino K, Ishibashi H. Experimental studies on concrete filled square
[12] Ferdousi A. Investigation into the behaviour of a novel steel section steel tubular short columns subjected to cyclic shearing force and
used for concrete filled tubular columns. Ms. thesis, Sahand constant axial force. Trans Architect Inst Jpn 1985;353:81–9.
University of Technology, 2002. [16] Sakino K, Tomii M. Hysteretic behaviour of concrete filled square
[13] ANSYS (Vers. 5.62). Reference manuals (Theory, elements, analysis steel tubular beam-columns failed in flexure. Trans Jpn Concrete Inst
guide, and comments). SAS IP Inc. 1981;3:439–46.