Geometric Parameter Optimization of Mold Heating Channels For Rapid Heat Cycle Molding

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Thermal Energy and Power Engineering TEPE

Geometric parameter optimization of mold heating


channels for rapid heat cycle molding
Fatma Kria, Moez Hammami, Mounir Baccar
Computational Fluid Dynamic and Transfer Phenomena
Mechanical Engineering Department, National Engineering School of Sfax,
Soukra, B.P. 1173-3038 Sfax, TUNISIA
Phone: 216 74 274 418 / Fax: 216 74 275 595
Fatmakria1984@yahoo.fr ; HammamiMoez2003@yahoo.fr*; Mounir.Baccar@enis.rnu.tn

Abstract- In this work, mold for producing LCD panels with In spite of the development of thermal regulation system
Rapid Heat Cycle Molding (RHCM) process was studied. The of conventional injection molding, several problems are still
thermal control system of the mold allows the improvement of faced in the finished product mainly surface defects and
the process productivity and the product quality. Hence, our appearance. To significantly reduce or completely eliminate
objective was to minimize the heating time and to homogenize these problems, we have added a preheating phase to obtain
the temperature at the mold cavity surface. For this purpose,
a suitable mold temperature at the filling stage. With this
we propose in the present study, a geometric parameter
optimization of the conformal thermal control system such as new technique, called Rapid Heat Cycle Molding (RHCM),
heating/cooling channel diameters, heating/cooling channel the production efficiency and parts quality are significantly
spacing and heating/cooling channel distance to the cavity affected by the temperature distribution on the cavity
surface. Thus, a 3D numerical model was developed using the surface. Therefore, the temperature distribution must be as
finite volume method. The results show that the thermal homogeneous as possible. Together, the heating time must
regulation system which assures minimum heating time does be short enough to maintain efficient production.
not necessarily achieves the best temperature distribution
throughout the product. In fact, to ensure the homogeneous In a molding cycle, the RHCM process can be divided
temperature distribution in the surface of the mold cavity, it into four stages: heating, maintaining high temperature,
was found advantageous to reduce the diameter of the heating cooling and maintaining low temperature. In the heating
channels, removing them from the cavity surface and spacing step, the mold is heated to a temperature slightly greater
them. On the other hand, it was demonstrated that these than the glass transition temperature (Tg) of the injected
actions cause a loss in productivity. polymer. When the mold temperature reaches the desired
Keywords- RHCM; Heating/Cooling Channels; Conformal value, the heating step is completed and the melted polymer
Thermal Regulation System; Numerical Analysis is injected into the mold cavity. After filling, the
maintaining high temperature stage ends and the molding
I. INTRODUCTION process pass to the cooling step. In this step, the mold is
rapidly cooled in order to solidify the polymer. When the
Injection molding is one of the most important industrial polymer reaches the temperature of the ejection, the cooling
processes for thermoplastic parts production. It’s generally step is completed and maintaining low temperatures begin.
used for the high speed production and high volume for the During this phase, the mold is opened to eject the part
automobile sector, household appliances and cosmetics. In injected. After that, the mold is heated again for the next
addition, it is found in the production of small series in cycle.
aeronautics. Faced with the rapid development of the
plastics industry, improving the quality of thermoplastic Currently, several studies have focused on the RHCM
items and reducing the time of the injection cycle become process. Chen et al. [10] have carried out research on
the primary objectives for processors. To achieve these electromagnetic induction heating and confirmed through
effects, the thermal control system of the mold must be numerical simulation, the effectiveness of this method in the
carefully studied. In fact, the cooling phase in the cavity surface heating. Hwang and Chang [11] have
conventional injection molding (CIM) is the longest during suggested the infrared method to heat the cavity surface.
the injection cycle; it represents about 70% to 80% of the W.Guilong et al. [12] have proposed the heating by
total cycle time [1]. In addition to its effect on productivity, saturated steam. However, the maximum temperature of the
the cooling phase affects the quality of molded parts. Indeed, saturated steam limits the application of the RHCM process
an inadequate design of cooling system generates a non- for specific materials such as engineering plastics and fiber-
homogeneous and non-equilibrium solidification, which will reinforced polymers. For this reason, the electric heating
cause defects such as shrinkage [2], warpage [3] and the system was proposed and adopted.
creeks. Later, the researchers have proposed a system of On the other hand, W. Guilong et al. [12] have studied
channels that follows better the shape of the piece called the effect of thermal insulation. They have demonstrated
"conformal cooling". Thus, many previous researches [4, 5, that the presence of an insulating layer between the
6, 7, 8, 9] have showed the importance of conformal cooling cavity/core plate and retaining plate is necessary to increase
on the CIM productivity and the quality product. the heating limit and to reduce the energy consumption.

TEPE Volume 3, Issue 1 Feb. 2014, PP. 185-190 www.vkingpub.com/journal/tepe/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
185
Thermal Energy and Power Engineering TEPE

In addition W.Guilong et al. [13] have studied three on the cavity surface of the mold. The geometrical
types of heating medium namely hot water, saturated steam parameters studied in this work are: the diameter of the
and oil. They have verified that during the two phases of heating channels, the distance of these channels to the cavity
heating and cooling, hot water and saturated vapor promote surface and the spacing between channels.
a heating rate which is higher than that obtained with oil and
therefore energetic gain. II. PHYSICAL MODEL
Also, W.Guilong et al. [13] have investigated the effect Figure 1 shows the design and the dimensions of the
of the temperature of the heat source on the heating rate and studied LCD panel. In our study, considering the
the amount of energy consumed. They have founded that the effectiveness of the saturated steam for the RHCM process,
temperatures of the hot water and oil should be as high as we have adopted this medium to heat our mold. For the
possible to get firstly, an important heating efficiency and studied mold, we added insulator layer between the
secondly, low power consumption. For saturated steam, they cavity/core plates and retaining plates in order to minimize
have showed that the heating efficiency and energy heat loss, and therefore, to increase heating efficiency.
consumption were improved when the temperature of the Taking into consideration the symmetry of the problem, the
steam have increased. Thus, they [13] have evaluated a three-dimensional study was limited to a quarter of the mold.
reasonable temperature of saturated steam approximately Moreover, because of the presence of insulator layers, heat
between 180°C and 200°C. transfers are located between cavity/core plates which will
further reduce the computational domain.
Another operating parameter has been studied by W.
15
Guilong et al. [13]: it is the cavity/core plate material. To do
this, three metallic alloys were proposed: the aluminium
alloys, steel and copper. Based on their study, they have
improved the efficiency of the thermal response and thus to
reduce the cycle molding time, using materials with high
thermal conductivity and having a low specific heat. 150

W.Guilong et al. [13] have examined the effect of the


channels’ position on the heating rate and the temperature
2

distribution at the cavity surface. They have founded that


when the distance between the channels is great and the 150
distance between the channels and cavity surface is low,
heating is more efficient and therefore the molding cycle
time decreases. In addition, the distribution channels with a 25
low spacing and far from cavity surface promotes Fig. 1 LCD panel
temperature homogeneity at the cavity surface.
The studied domain is shown in Figure 2. In this figure,
However, L.Xi-Ping et al. [14] found that the increase of two sets of points A, B, C, D and E, F, G are given to
the distance between the heating channels, was done on the determine the temperature distribution. Each series of points
one hand, a gain of 54.5% on the homogeneity of the represents a plan, respectively P1and P2.
temperature distribution on the cavity surface and on the
other hand, a decrease in the heating rate. The positions of the heating channels and the thermal
characteristics of cavity/core plates of RHCM mold are
Lately, W. Guilong et al. [15] have carried out 2D
grouped in Tables 1 and 2.
numerical simulation for fatigue analysis and heat transfer
to investigate the effect of the conformal heating channels TABLE I POSITIONS OF HEATING CHANNELS
on thermal response, structural strength and fatigue life of
Position x (mm) z (mm)
the mold. They have demonstrated that the required heating
time was reduced by 61.70%, cavity surface temperature Channel 1 35 57
uniformity was improved by 80.97%, and the structural Channel 2 50 57
strength of the cavity block was also slightly improved. Channel 3 65 57
Previous work developed on RHCM processes were Channel 4 87 45
devoted to simple geometric configurations in 2D. In Channel 5 50 18
addition, the thermal control system is limited to a Channel 6 65 18
conventional system. In this current research, we propose to
Channel 7 90 18
study through 3D numerical simulation, the geometric
parameter optimization of thermal regulation system of
TABLE II THERMAL PROPERTIES OF CAVITY/CORE PLATES [12]
RHCM mold for producing LCD panels. This study can
reproduce the temperature distribution generated in the Density
Heat Thermal
cavity and the mold at any time throughout the process, and Material capacity conductivity
(kg/ m3)
(J/kg°C) (W/m°C)
thus shows the effect of each geometric parameter. Our
major concern is the improvement of the process Cavity/core AMPCO
8710 380 208
plates 940
productivity and the homogeneous temperature distribution

TEPE Volume 3, Issue 1 Feb. 2014, PP. 185-190 www.vkingpub.com/journal/tepe/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
186
Thermal Energy and Power Engineering TEPE

phase, the convective heat transfer coefficient is given by


the following expression [16]:
1/ 4
 K 3 (ρ w − ρ S ) g r 
h c = 0,555  
 µ D ∆T 
With:
K thermal conductivity of water at 100°C;
g acceleration of gravity;
r latent heat of liquefaction;
ρs density of saturated steam;
ρw density of water;
µ dynamic viscosity of water at 100°C;
D diameter of the heating channels;
∆T temperature difference between the saturated steam
and the heating channel wall.

B. Mesh study
We studied the problem in a Cartesian coordinate system
by adopting a non-uniform structured mesh. Before
searching the thermal responses in the RHCM mold, we
carried out tests of convergence to study the influence of the
mesh and time step on the accuracy of results. We found a
mesh consisting of (162 x 162 x 102) nodes and a time step
of 10-3s is sufficient to give a compromise between accuracy
and computation time.

IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

A. Effect of Channel Diameter


Figure 3 illustrates the channel diameter effect on the
rate of heating mold. For a definite channel position (X=12
mm), the heating rate increased using channel sections
which are increasingly important. In fact, by increasing the
diameter, the heat quantity contribution becomes important,
Fig. 2 Studied domain for the RHCM mold
which explains the increase in the heating rate. Indeed, the
temporal evolution at point A showed an increase in the
III. PHYSICAL MODEL speed at the beginning of the process of 50% from diameter
6 to 10 mm.
To build our model, we used the finite volume method. 160
For this, we write the heat transfer equation in a three-
dimensional Cartesian coordinate system in a form that is
Temperature(°C)

120
ready for the finite volume discretization. In general, the
mold can be considered as a solid part. Therefore, the heat 80 D=6mm
transfer in the mold is purely conductive. D=8mm
40 D=10mm
A. Initials and Boundary Conditions
0
For the heating phase, the initial mold temperature is
0 5 10 15 20
30°C and the temperature of the heating channels is Heating time(s)
considered a constant equal to 180°C. For boundary
conditions, we considered zero flux at symmetries plans. In Fig. 3 Influence of the diameter on the heating rate
addition, conditions of zero flux at the surfaces of the On the other hand, Figures 4 and 5 show respectively the
cavity/core plates in contact with insulators layers. temperature distribution at the planes P1 and P2 at the
In this study, the temperatures of heating channels are instant when the temperature reaches 110 °C (temperature
assumed to be constant. The heat transfer between these slightly greater than the glass transition temperature of the
channels and the mold can be taken into consideration by studied polymer). It was noted that the increase in diameter
the thermal transfer coefficient interface hc. In the heating amplify the thermal gradients in the plane P1 and especially

TEPE Volume 3, Issue 1 Feb. 2014, PP. 185-190 www.vkingpub.com/journal/tepe/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
187
Thermal Energy and Power Engineering TEPE

at point B (Figure 4). Indeed, the difference between points


B and D can reach 18 °C with 10mm channel diameter.

126 D = 10mm (t=8s)


Temperature (°C)

D = 8mm (t=9s)
122
D = 6mm (t=11.5s)

118

114

110
A B C D
Cavity surface
b) Distribution with D=6 mm (11.5 s)
Fig. 4 Effect of the diameter on the temperature distribution at the plane P1
Fig. 6 The temperature distribution in the plane P1
From Figure 5, and considering the plan P2, we realized
that by increasing channel diameter, the amplitude of the B. Effect of Channels’ Distance to the Cavity Surface
curves is almost the same. However, this finding masks the In order to study the effect of the position of the
reality because high temperatures appear for diameters 8
channels, we determined numerically, for a diameter
and 10 mm. This confirms again that this increase does not
contribute to the improvement of the surface quality of our d=6mm, the heating rates for different positions X. Figure 7
LCD panel. shows an increase in the rate of heating when the channels
are near the cavity surface and therefore gain in productivity
D=10mm (t=8s) D = 8mm (t=9s) will be important. However, using the curves in Figure 8,
140 D = 6mm (t=11.5s) we registered the best profile for the position farther from
the surface. In fact, the excessive rise of temperature at
135 point B is attenuated by 5% from X=9 to 15mm. In addition,
perfect temperature uniformity can be seen at the segment
Temperature (°C)

130 [CD].
160
125
Temperature (°C)

120
120

115 80 X = 15mm
E F G
Cavity surface X=12mm
40
X = 9mm
Fig. 5 Effect of diameter on the temperature distribution in the plane P2
0
Figure 6 shows a comparison between the temperature
0 4 8 12 16 20
distributions obtained with channels diameter 6 and 10 mm
Heating time (s)
in the planes P1 and P2 at the instant when the temperature
reaches 110 °C. It is clear that for D=10 mm heating is Fig. 7 Effect of the channels’ position on the heating rate
faster resulting in an increase in productivity of the mold.
However, the heating at the upper surface becomes very 124
excessive by comparisons with the rest of the outer surface, X=9mm (t = 11s)
122
which can cause degradation of the quality of the finished X = 12mm (t = 11,5s)
Temperature (°C)

product. 120 X = 15mm (t = 12s)


118

116

114

112

110
A B C D
Cavity surface

Fig. 8 Effect of the channels’ positions on the temperature distribution


in the plane P1

Considering the plane P2 (Figure 9), it is noted that with


approaching the channels to the cavity surface, the reached
a) Distribution with D=10 mm (8s) temperature at the cavity surface are higher than the glass

TEPE Volume 3, Issue 1 Feb. 2014, PP. 185-190 www.vkingpub.com/journal/tepe/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
188
Thermal Energy and Power Engineering TEPE

transition. Moreover, it is noted the appearance of a more cavity are the optimal parameters. For parameter E, two
pronounced thermal gradient at the corner of the cavity cases are considered 15 an 18 mm. The results in Figure 11
generating a difference in temperature at the surface cavity. show a slight decrease in the heating rate when switching to
E=18 mm. However, Figures 12 and 13 show an
X = 9mm (t=11s) X = 12mm (t=11.5s) improvement with E=18 mm promoting temperature
135 X = 15mm (t=12s)
uniformity at the planes P1 and P2. Indeed, with this
configuration the gap at the entire surface cavity does not
130
Temperature (°C)

exceed 10°C.
160
125

Temperature (°C)
120
120

80
115 E = 18mm
E F G
Cavity surface 40
E=15mm

Fig. 9 Effect of channels’ positions on the temperature distribution


in the plane P2 0
0 5 10 15 20
Figure 10 shows the temperature distribution at the time
Heating time(s)
when the surface cavity has reached 110°C for different
values of X. It proves the mediocre effect of near channels Fig. 11 Effect of the spacing between channels on the heating rate
to the cavity on the temperature uniformity. The overall look of temperature fields in the planes P1
and P2 is given in Figure 14. It can be deduced that the
increase of the spacing between channels helps to reduce the
effect of the central part of the mold on the one hand and the
heat supply at the corner part on the other hand, thus
resulting in a more uniform heating.

118 E = 18mm (t = 12,5s)

E = 15mm (t = 12s)
Temperature (°C)

116

114

112
a) X = 15mm

110
A B C D
Cavity surface

Fig. 12 Effect of the spacing between channels on the temperature


distribution at the plane P1

126 E = 18mm (t=12.5s) E = 15mm (t=12s)

124

122
Temperature (°C)

120
b) X = 9mm
Fig. 10 Temperature distribution for different positions of the channel
118
C. Effect of the Spacing Between the Heating Channels
116
In this section, we will test the effect of the parameter E
reflecting the spacing between the three channels 1, 2 and 3 114
E F G
in the heating rate and the temperature uniformity at the
Cavity surface
planes P1 and P2. For that, and benefiting from the results
found in the previous paragraphs, we deduced that channel Fig. 13 Effect of the spacing on the temperature distribution at the plane
diameter of 6mm and a distance X = 15mm from the surface P2

TEPE Volume 3, Issue 1 Feb. 2014, PP. 185-190 www.vkingpub.com/journal/tepe/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
189
Thermal Energy and Power Engineering TEPE

actions cause a loss in productivity of the mold due to the


increase in the cycle time.

REFERENCES

Z. Lin and M. Chou, “Design of the Cooling Channels in


Nonrectangular Plastic Flat Injection Mold”, Journal of
manufacturing systems, vol. 21, pp. 167-186, 2002.
J-F. Pichon, “Aide mémoire Injection des matières plastiques”,
Dunod, 2001.
W.H. Chow, “C-mold for Design of Injection Die”, Taipei, Taiwan,
Wen King Book Co., AC Technology, 1999.
E. Sachs, S. Allen, H. Guo, J. Banos, M. Cima, J. Serdy, and D.
Brancazio, “Progress on tooling by 3D printing ;
a) E = 15mm (11.5s) conformal cooling, dimensional control, surface finish
and hardness”, Solid Freeform Fabrication Proceedings,
1997.
W.R. Schmidt, R.D. White, C.E. Bird, and J.V. Bak, “Conformal
cooling versus conventional cooling : an injection
molding case study with P-20 and 3DPTM-processed
tooling”, Materials Research Symposia Proceedings, pp.
51–56, 2000.
D.I. Wimpenny, B. Bryden, and I.R. Pashby, “Rapid laminated
tooling”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology,
vol. 138(1-3), pp. 214–218, 2003.
A. Alban, S. Vincent, P. Laetitia, J. Yvon, D. Didier,
“Optimisation du refroidissement d’un moule d’injection
de thermoplastique”, SFT Proceedings, 2009.
Y. Wanga, K.-M. Yua, C.C.L. Wangb, Y. Zhangb, “Automatic
b) E = 18mm (12.5s)
design of conformal cooling circuits for rapid tooling”,
Computer-Aided Design, vol. 43, pp. 1001–1010, 2011.
Fig. 14 Temperature distribution for different E K.M. Au, K.M. Yu, W.K. Chiu, “Visibility-based conformal
cooling channel generation for rapid tooling”, Computer-
V. CONCLUSIONS Aided Design, vol. 43, pp. 356–373, 2011.
In this paper, a three-dimensional numerical modeling of S.C. Chen, W.R. Jong, J.A. Chang, “Dynamic mold surface
thermal regulation system of RHCM mold for LCD panels’ temperature control using induction heating and its
effects on the surface appearance of weld line”, J Appl
production is presented. The study focuses on the heating
Polym Sci, vol. 101, pp. 1174–1180, 2006.
phase of the mold. In fact, for this type of process, this step
P.C. Chang, S. Hwang, “Simulation of infrared rapid surface
is the most important in the cycle because it is decisive for
heating for injection molding”, Int Comm Heat Mass
the quality of the finished product. Thus, our goal is to Tran, vol. 49, pp. 3846–3854, 2006.
optimize the thermal control system to achieve uniform
G. Wang, G. Zhao, H. Li, Y. Guan, “Research of thermal response
heating of the cavity surface and therefore to improve the simulation and mold structure optimization for rapid heat
outside surface quality of the LCD panel. cycle molding processes, respectively, with steam
To do this, a specific code using the finite volumes heating and electric heating”, Materials and Design, vol.
31, pp. 382-395, 2010.
method has been developed to simulate the thermal behavior
of RHCM mold. The simulations were allowed to provide G. Wang, G. Zhao, H. Li, Y. Guan, “Analysis of thermal cycling
efficiency and optimal design of heating/cooling systems
the temperature distribution in the mold and hence to
for rapid heat cycle injection molding process”,
optimize the thermal control system. In this work, we chose Materials and Design, vol. 31, pp. 3426–3441, 2010.
a conformal thermal control system to regulate the RHCM
X.P. Li, G.Q. Zhao, Y.J. Guan, M.X. Ma, “Optimal design of
mold temperature. This configuration has a temperature heating channels for rapid heating cycle injection mold
difference at the outer cavity surface of 15°C. With a view based on response surface and genetic algorithm”,
to reduce further this gap, we have optimized the Materials and Design, vol. 30, pp. 4317–4323, 2009.
geometrical parameters of the system. We are interested in G. Wang, G. Zhao, H. Li, Y. Guan, “Multi-objective optimization
the effects of the channels diameter, their relative positions design of the heating/cooling channels of the steam-
to the surface of the cavity as well as their spacing. Analysis heating rapid thermal response mold using particle
has shown that to ensure more uniform temperature swarm optimization”, International Journal of Thermal
distribution at the outer cavity surface, it is advantageous to Sciences, vol. 50, pp. 790-802, 2011.
adopt the diameter D=6mm, a distance X=15mm and a M.W. Rohsenow, J.P. Hartnett, “Handbook of heat transfer”, New
spacing between channels E=18mm. The optimum York: McGraw-Hill, 1973.
configuration has increased the homogeneity at the cavity
surface of 67%. On the other hand, it turned out that these

TEPE Volume 3, Issue 1 Feb. 2014, PP. 185-190 www.vkingpub.com/journal/tepe/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
190

You might also like