Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Politics of Planning: - Topic
Politics of Planning: - Topic
-Topic-
Politics of Planning
By :
Desy Rosnita Sari
P28017016
NCKU
Urban Planning Department
1st Presentation
Seminar 4th course
March 28th 2014
2/19
ARTICLES :
Looking back; Making city planning work
-- Allan B. Jacobs --
Published in : Making city planning work (1980)
– Classic Reading In Urban Planning 1995. p;426
Keywords : Politic of planning, Planning profession, Planning process, and San Francisco
“Planning is political”
Planning profession certainly operate within the web of political relationship
4/19
Looking back;
Making city planning work
Making city planning work (1980)
Classic Reading In Urban Planning 1995. p;426
Keywords: Politic of planning, Planning profession, Planning
process, San Francisco
BOOKS
The Boulevard Book (2003), Great Streets (1995), Looking at Cities (1985), Making City Planning Work (1980), The
Urban Design Element of the San Francisco General Plan, Toward an Urban Design Manifesto (well-known paper
describes how cities should be laid out)
5/19
Looking Back.
Jacobs’ reflection on his experiences as a planner
----- mostly during his duty as San Francisco’s planning director (1967 - 1974).
• Pictured the flavor of doing planning under governmental setting (win/fail the
battle)
• Revealing some strategies and tactics used by Jacobs and his agency in trying to
influence various policy decisions in San Francisco.
• Both explicitly and implicitly informed that planning can indeed work if
skilled, dedicated and committed people are willing to devote sufficient energy
into it.
6/19
San Francisco
X Comprehensive plan
√ Master plan
Based on large-measure on an assessment of the social
and economic needs
Accompanied by a set of recommendation for programs
and actions, which is all separate plan elements related
**Program that could be achieved via legislative action and directly under
planning department of SF Government , is more likely to be successful
7/19
Long-range
development goal
Policy documents, statistic picture of
future, Dictated plan, inefficient planning
process (too vague, too biased, too
subjective, etc)
decentralization Semi-autonomy
Forester’s argument
• Information is an important source of
planner’s power in the planning process
• requests planners to be progressive
practitioners
Managing Misinformation:
• Comprehension (distorted by problem framing)
• Sincerity or trust (distorted by false assurance)
• Legitimacy (distorted by lack of consent)
• Knowledge (distorted by misrepresentation)
To be professionally effective,
be politically articulate John Forester
Published in : Making Equity Planning Work (1978)
Keywords : politic planning, planning practice, planning
profession, Cleveland
Norman Khrumholz
Norman Khrumholz
M.C.R.P., Planning, Cornell University, 1965
Professor in Levin College of Urban Affairs
President of the American Planning Association (1986-1987)
President of the American Institute of Certified Planners (1999)
Planning Director of the City of Cleveland from 1969-1979 (10 years)
Planning practitioner in Ithaca, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland
BOOKS
Making Equity Planning Work (1978)
Revitalizing Urban Neighborhoods (1999)
Reinventing Cities: Equity Planners Tell Their Stories (1994)
To be professionally effective, be politically articulate
• A review of Cleveland political experience in the practice of equity
planning during his duty (Planning Director; 1969-1979)
• In the time of equality and racial justice issues emerged in the nation