1

2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14

15
16
E-0006 QC comments

NC4 is pure component ? As per markup is pseduocomponent in HMB

Pipe segement 6-P-110-5809-1 and 6-P-110-5809-2 flash calculation fails. Please check
Please check the pressure profile across the Heat exchangers should be as per HMB
Heat exchanger and pipe should have heat loss
Min. flow scale factor -0.001 for heat exchangers
Design flow rate for case -1 SOR and case-2 EOR + 21% overdesign as per heat exchanger datasheets
Please check the Signal processing for the indicators
shell and tube side MOC specification such as thermal cond., wall Cp and wall density source not mention.
Vapor flow shell side should be match as per HMB.
110-PSV-5802-A/B valve type, Kd and back pressure co-effiecent are defualt.
Strip chart needs to be configure for the heat exchangers and PSV
With step size 0.1 and model speed is near ~1
In model notes not mention about assumption or data reference for the equipemnts like HE, PSV and pipe
Flow indicators for the strip chart are missing for the shell and tube side flow
Tube rupture orfice area is 692.37 mm sq as per model, but one tube area is 346.36 mm sq.
what is source of two tube area considered for the tube rupture orifice.
All applicable comments use for the other heat exchangers models.