Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BG109 Industrial+Cooperation+between+Korea+and+Ethiopia (Dong-Joo,+Joo)
BG109 Industrial+Cooperation+between+Korea+and+Ethiopia (Dong-Joo,+Joo)
109
November 2019
Dong-joo Joo
Senior Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade
Jooyoung Yang
Associate Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade
Eunsong Lee
Research Associate, Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade
Amare Matebu
Lead Researcher, Policy Study Institute, Ethiopia
Netsanet Jote
Senior Researcher, Policy Study Institute, Ethiopia
Dereje Rahmet
Researcher, Policy Study Institute, Ethiopia
Sisay Sintayehu
Researcher, Policy Study Institute, Ethiopia
Sirack Kassahun
Researcher, Policy Study Institute, Ethiopia
References ···································································208
ANNEX-1. Korean SMEs Data ········································214
ANNEX-2. Ethiopian SMEs Data ······································219
List of Tables
Figure 6.1 Trade Balance between Ethiopia and the Republic of Korea
2014-2018 ······························································174
Abstract
historical perspective.
Chapter 5 analyzes the status of industrial cooperation between
the two countries.
Chapter 6 provides an Ethiopian perspective on the bilateral co-
operation.
Chapter 7 proposes ideas for measures to promote SME coopera-
tion between the two countries.
Chapter 1. Introduction 13
Chapter 1. Introduction
1 PSI was renamed to the current name in 2018 from its former name of PSRC (Policy
Research and Study Center)
Chapter 1. Introduction 15
This section will further explain why this study is paying atten-
tion to industrial cooperation with Ethiopia. First of all, as noted
previously, Ethiopia is emerging as a promising future market, hav-
Chapter 1. Introduction 17
ing realized rapid economic growth over the last decade. Ethiopia
is a huge country in Eastern Africa with enormous development
potential. It has a vast land area of 1.104 million km², which is
some five times larger than the entire Korean Peninsula, together
with a population of about 105 million (2018) and abundant re-
sources. As a country with a long history stretching back to antiqui-
ty, it maintained independence even during the colonial era, in
which all the other countries in the African continent suffered from
colonial rule.2 During the Korean War of 1950-53, it stood with Re-
public of Korea by joining the UN Peace Corps.
Despite this potential and great history, Ethiopia in modern times
has suffered severely as one of the Least Developed Countries
(LDCs) due to long-stagnant economic development and socio-
political confusion. This hardship has been mainly caused by the
ineptitude and corruption of the last monarchy, and the subsequent
dictatorship and socialist policies of Communist rule (1975-1991),
which eventually led to a civil war and separation of Eritrea in
1993.3
However, in the 2000s, the Ethiopian economy has been chang-
ing rapidly with one of the world's highest growth rates for more
than 10 years. During 2006/07~16/17, the Ethiopian economy grew
at an annual average rate of 10.3%, nearly double the average of
5.4% in East Africa (World Bank, 2019).4 In recent years, growth
2 In the year 1936, just before World War II, Italy under Mussolini invaded Ethiopia and
occupied the country for five years. Except this, it has never fallen into the colonial rule.
3 The rule of the last emperor Haile Selessie (1892-1975) collapsed in September 1974
has slowed down a bit due to social instability, but in 2017/18, the
growth rate was 7.7%, which is still very high on a global basis
(see <Table 2-3>).
Ethiopia's high growth rate is largely accounted for by the suc-
cessful implementation of the first and second "Growth and Trans-
formation Plan" (GTP) and subsequent performance of active in-
dustrialization policies. As a result, its manufacturing industry has
shown remarkable growth, with rapid increases of textiles exports.
Increased foreign investment targeting abundant low-wage labor
has aided this performance. The preferential tariffs from the US
and Europe to support the development of the LDCs in Africa also
helped the increase of exports. Some comment that Ethiopia will
grow as a manufacturing hub in Africa, and is showing a potential
to grow as a future global factory like China.5
This study pays attention to this dynamic change of the Ethiopi-
an economy, and intends to provide information on such trends to
promote bilateral industrial cooperation. For KIET, this study can
be said to be a follow-up study of previous research on “Strategy
for Industrial and Development Cooperation with East African
Countries”, carried out in 2017 by the same project manager of this
study(Joo, et al. 2017). At the time two years ago, the study target-
ed four countries in East Africa. In this current project, the study
narrowed down the subjects and target countries, then carried out
an in-depth study of Ethiopia.
Looking at the Korean situation, the ongoing trade conflicts be-
5 BBC News, August 24, 2017, “Can Ethiopia be Africa's leading manufacturing hub?”
Chapter 1. Introduction 19
tween USA and China, the World’s No.1 and No.2 economies and
also Korea’s second and first trade partners respectively, are lead-
ing to serious uncertainties in the external trade environment. In
addition, Korea is experiencing new trade conflicts with Japan, af-
ter Japan's sudden regulations on semiconductor exports in July of
this year. In this situation, the Korean government is struggling to
explore new markets through its New South and New North poli-
cies. The private sector is also struggling to keep the existing mar-
kets and to find new markets.
The African Growth and Opportunity Act, or AGOA (Title I, Trade and De-
velopment Act of 2000; P.L. 106–200) is a piece of legislation that was approved
by the U.S. Congress in May 2000. The purpose of this legislation is to assist the
economies of sub-Saharan Africa and to improve economic relations between the
United States and the region. After completing its initial 15-year period of validi-
ty, the AGOA legislation was extended on 29 June 2015 by a further 10 years, to
2025.[ AGOA provides trade preferences for quota and duty-free entry into the
United States for certain goods, expanding the benefits under the Generalized Sys-
tem of Preferences (GSP) program. Notably, AGOA expanded market access for
textile and apparel goods into the United States for eligible countries, though
many other goods are also included.
Everything but Arms (EBA) is an initiative of the European Union under
which all imports to the EU from the Least Developed Countries are duty-free and
quota-free, with the exception of armaments. EBA entered into force on 5 March
2001. There were transitional arrangements for bananas, sugar and rice until Janu-
ary 2006, July 2009 and September 2009 respectively. The EBA is part of the EU
Generalized System of Preferences (GSP).
Apart from the GSP, the EU provides its separate customs benefits to the former
colonies of Africa, the Pacific, and the Caribbean (ACP). In 2000, EU signed a
new agreement with 78 ACP countries in Cotonou of Benin in Africa.
6 http://biz.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2017/09/15/2017091502335.html
https://www.hankyung.com/economy/article/2019060471081
Chapter 1. Introduction 23
ics and KIET has contributed to these projects greatly through the
research and implementation of the consulting projects.7
Despite these opportunities for Korean SMEs, however, there
still exist lots of risks as well. First, Ethiopia is a landlocked coun-
try without harbors. To use the ports, they have to go to the Red
Sea through the bordering countries Djibouti and Eritrea. This
leads to an unstable logistics environment and high logistical costs,
especially in times of socio-political instability. In fact, Korean
companies operating in Ethiopia indicated this point as the most
serious impediment to their businesses.
Secondly, Ethiopia is a multi-ethnic country with over 80 tribes,
which in good times can be a source of blessed cultural diversity
but in bad times leads to complicated socio-political issues. Not
only by this, but the complex socio-political situation combined
with tribal conflicts occasionally leads to violent incidents. This
instability inevitably hampers economic development and negative-
ly affects the business environment.
Third, there is abundant low-cost labor, but it is not easy to ob-
tain skilled labor. On-the-job-training is not easy due to the lack of
relevant facilities and costs. Finally, infrastructure conditions such
as electricity and transportation are poor yet in general. <Table 1-
2> summarizes these factors as a whole, illustrating the opportunity
and threat factors of Ethiopian business environment that should be
taken into consideration for SME cooperation.
7 The project manager of this research has led many consulting projects on industrial poli-
cies of developing countries, including Algeria and Indonesia. He also led the research
for the Korean ODA Model in 2012 (Joo, et.al, 2012).
24 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Opportunity Threats
terms of form, this study has been carried out through the joint
research and co-authorship by major research institutes in Korea
and Ethiopia.
26 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Source: Compiled from the Annual Report of National Bank of Ethiopia (20162017)
<Figure 2.1> shows economic growth trends for the last nineteen
years (1999/00 to 2017/18) in terms of real GDP. During this peri-
od the highest growth (12.7%) was posted in fiscal year 2004/05
while the lowest growth (1.6%) was recorded in fiscal year
2001/02. Economic growth greatly intensified since 2003/04 at a
Chapter 2. Recent Economic Status and Challenges in Ethiopia 29
rate of slightly above 10% per annum, pushing average per capita
GDP growth to nearly 8% annually. Real GDP was growing on av-
erage by 10.9% per year. This strong economic record has been
mainly driven by investment, much of which undertaken by the
government and state-owned enterprises. Economic growth has
been relatively broad-based (across sectors), although the economy
remains dependent on agriculture (ECA, 2018).
In fiscal year 2014/15 which is the last fiscal year of the first
growth and transformation plan (GTP I), Ethiopia registered GDP
growth of 10.4%, somewhat lower than the targeted 11.2% for this
fiscal year. Growth has been extraordinary compared to the 4.4%
growth rate estimated for sub-Saharan Africa in 2015. Moreover,
growth was broad-based as industry recorded 21.6%, services
10.2% and agriculture 6.4% growth rates. Overall, in the five year
GTP I period (2010/11 to 2014/15), Ethiopia achieved a very high
growth rate of 10.1% per year, on average. Economic growth in
2015/16 due a recent drought. Real GDP grew by 8% in 2015/16
compared to 10.4% growth in 2014/15.
In GTP II, the government has planned for broad-based growth
of the economy by accelerated growth of the manufacturing indus-
try, realizing a desirable economic structural transformation. From
2013/14 - 2017/18 fiscal years the Ethiopian economy has shown
9.3% average annual growth, recording 7.7% growth in 2017/18
fiscal year, slower than the growth rate registered in the previous
year owing to growth deceleration in agriculture and industry sec-
tors. The growth in real GDP was mainly attributed to 8.8% growth
30 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
2.1.2 Inflation
One of the major economic problems in the Ethiopian economy
is the rising general prices of both food and non-food items. Figure
2.3 shows inflation trends in Ethiopia for the past fifteen years. An
inflation rate of 36.4% was posted in the 2008/09 fiscal year, the
highest on record, but inflation dropped to 2.5% in the following
fiscal year — the lowest over the period in question. The govern-
ment has taken fiscal and monetary policy measures to quell the
highest inflation rate which is mostly driven by high prices of im-
ports.
The annual average headline inflation rose to 13.1% in 2017/18
from 7.2% a year earlier due to the rise in both food and non-food
inflation. Similarly, annual headline inflation went up to 14.7%
from 8.8%, owing to a 6.7 percentage point increase in food infla-
Chapter 2. Recent Economic Status and Challenges in Ethiopia 33
2014)8
The highest proportion (73%) of the employed population work-
ing in the Agricultural sector at the national level. Agriculture plays
a predominant role in absorbing the rural labor force, while the ser-
vice sector performs that function in urban areas. The service sec-
tors, which include Public Administration, Defense, Compulsory
Social Security, Education, Health, other Social activities, Hotel
and Restaurant and Household activities account for 15% of em-
ployment, followed by Manufacturing, Mining, Quarrying and
Construction (6.9%) in the industry sector. Wholesale and Retail
Trades constituted 5.4% of employment as of June 2013 (CSA, 2014).
The definition of unemployment varies among developed and
developing countries. In the developed countries where the labour
market is largely organized and labour absorption is adequate, un-
employment is measured based on the standard definition of work-
seeking criteria that is having taken active steps to search for work
during a specified reference period. On the other hand, in develop-
ing countries like Ethiopia, where there is no strong labor market
information, labor absorption is inadequate and where the labor
force is predominantly self-employed, the standard definition, with
its emphasis on work-seeking, is somewhat restrictive and might
not fully capture the prevailing employment situation.
reached 289 billion Birr since import values surpassed export val-
ues. However, there was an improvement in the trade deficit in
2016/17 of 1.2% compared to the previous. A reduced trade deficit
and strong growth in remittances helped to improve the current ac-
count deficit from 8.1% of GDP in 2016/17 to 6.0% in 2017/18.
Gross official reserves remained low, at 2.5 months of imports in
2016/17 and 2.1 months in 2017/18 (African Development Bank,
2019).
The merchandise trade deficit in 2017/18 amounted to USD 12.4
billion, depicting 3.7% improvement over the preceding fiscal year.
This was mainly attributed to reductions of import bills. As a result,
the merchandise trade deficit-to-GDP ratio declined by 2.4 percent-
age points and stood at 13.6%.
External debt accounts for about 56% of total public and public-
ly guaranteed (PPG) debt. At the end of June 2018, total PPG debt
amounted to 61.8% of GDP, an increase of 4 percentage points
compared to June 2017, largely due to an increase in the domestic
currency value of external debt outstanding. This mainly reflected
the devaluation of the birr in October 2017. Domestic debt made up
44% of total debt, with domestic debt of the central government
accounting for 21.4% of this, and the remainder corresponding to
SOEs. The bulk of the domestic debt of the central government is
owed to banks, primarily the NBE, largely reflecting advances to
finance the budget. The remainder mainly comprises Treasury bills
held by commercial banks. Domestic borrowing by the SOEs,
whether through loans or bond issuance, was entirely from domes-
tic banks (IMF, 2019).
lenges. Real GDP growth rate has decelerated as the result of poor
performances in the agricultural, manufacturing and construction
sectors. In the second growth and transformation plan (2015/16 to
2019/20), the growth rate declined to 8.8% in 2016 and 7.5 % in
2018, which are far lower than the growth rates that the economy
experienced in the past 13 years.
(FDI) and Public enterprises. All are expected to play a major role
in Ethiopian industrial development, especially in the manufactur-
ing industry. As stated earlier, the private sector is considered to be
the engine of the industrial development in Ethiopia, and domestic
private investors are expected to play a major role. But currently
the role and contribution of domestic private investors in manufac-
turing industries is very low. Most DPI prefer to engage in service
sector activities like trade or real estate than manufacturing sector
due to the following reasons. First, manufacturing requires high
initial investments and working capital. Second, it faces high levels
of global competition compared to services. Third, the import and
distribution of foreign manufactured goods offers fast returns and
high profits in Ethiopia compared to local production, for which
investment returns take more time. Fourth, entry and exit barriers
are much lower in the service sector than in the manufacturing sec-
tor. Fifth, service businesses are comparably easier to manage than
manufacturing businesses. Sixth, service businesses carry less risk
than manufacturing businesses. Seventh, getting a bank loan to be-
ing a manufacturing business is a lengthy and tedious procedure.
Finally, the government has failed to properly encourage develop-
ment of the sector.
50 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
agencies at both the federal and regional level. In this section, insti-
tutions which are responsible for the implementation of the strategy
at the federal and regional levels are indicated by classifying into
two, key institutions and supporting institutions.
ㅇ Regional Organizations
· In regional states, key institutions responsible for the imple-
mentation of the strategy are the Bureaus of Trade and Industry,
Technical and Vocational Education and Training Agencies, Small
and Medium Enterprise Development Agencies, TVET colleges,
MFIs and regional lease finance offices. These organizations per-
form duties designated by respective federal authorities. However,
their structure and responsibilities differ from region to region. In
addition to the above, there are One Stop Service (OSS) centers in
each city to deliver different front line services for entrepreneurs.
· Microfinance Institutions (MFIs) are responsible for develop-
ing appropriate financial products to SMEs based on their respec-
tive growth stages. They are also mandated to promote a savings
culture among SMEs and ensure that SMEs draw up financial re-
ports in order to facilitate access to credit.
· TVET colleges are responsible for the provision of SME
training in the areas of job creation, innovation, KAIZEN man-
agement methods, quality control, design and maintenance. Some
Chapter 3. Status of SME in Ethiopia 67
that are engaged in the manufacturing sector and that produce items
for export or to substitute imports. Particular attention is given to
subsectors, activities and enterprises to be established in the manu-
facturing, construction, trade, services and agricultural sectors that
have potential to generate large scale employment.
According to the GTP II projection, the share of the manufactur-
ing sector of GDP is expected to show a fourfold increase from 4.8%
in 2014/15 to 18% by 2025. From this projection the share of Micro
and Small Enterprises of GDP under the baseline scenario is 1.1 per-
cent in 2014/15 to 1.8 percent by 2019/20 with an average contribu-
tion of 1.4 percent in 2015/16 to 2019/20. The projection for Medi-
um and Large scale enterprises as 3.7 percent from 2014/15 to 5.9
percent in 2019/20 with an average share of 4.9 percent from
2015/16 to 2019/20 (GTP II plan, 2016). Though the plan has tried
to project the contribution of Micro and Small enterprises and Medi-
um and Large enterprises to GDP, the entire projection is made only
for manufacturing, overlooking the service sector.
Small and medium manufacturing industries were recognized as
major contributors to the envisioned structural change of the econ-
omy. The second growth and transformation plan (GTP II) also ac-
corded due attention to the promotion of small and medium scale
industries. Accordingly GTP II stipulates that a wide range of SME
promotional measures and support services should be designed to
facilitate the growth and development of the sector. The plan’s stra-
tegic pillars are sustainable and rapid economic growth through
industrialization, social development, increased investment in agri-
74 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Construction input
manufacturing,
5 >> 1576 19 912 561 461 3529
chemical & mining
products
Table 3.3 Have there been any linkages created to supply your prod-
ucts to foreign markets?
Textile & Metal & Leather Shoe Food
Response Construction
Garment Wood works products making processing
yes 7% 14%
no 100% 100% 93% 100% 100% 64%
missing 22%
total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Source: Tigist Derese Gebre, 2016
any loan. MFIs and public officials are responsible for collecting
loan payments for ensuring the proper use of financing.
A study undertaken on 519 SMEs drawn from six major cities
and towns in Ethiopia in 2016 indicated that access to finance is
significantly influenced by the age of a firm, its previous engage-
ment with banks and the experience of its managers or other firms
managed by the owner. The same study also identified that finan-
cial institutions, especially banks, exhibit low levels of engagement
with SMEs is low. Both banks and MFIs emphasized that SME-
specific factors such as poor financial records, a lack of adequate
collateral, poor management of risks and largely informal nature
are major obstacles to their engagement with SMEs (HESPI, 2016).
In short, young firms without adequate managerial or operational
experience and those with inadequate collateral are face a tight
credit market in Ethiopia. Despite the importance of SMEs to the
national economy and increasing government support, many of
them remain unable to fulfill their full potential due to limited ac-
cess to finance. A similar report released by the World Bank in
2015 reached similar conclusions. Small firms face greater chal-
lenges in obtaining formal financing than large firms; they are
much more likely to be rejected for loans and are less likely to have
external financing due to a lack of collateral and credit history
(World Bank, 2015)14.
The NBE directive no. SBB/53/2012 restricts commercial banks
to 25% of their capital for single borrower and 15% of their total
14 World Bank (2015) SME Finance in Ethiopia: Addressing the Missing Middle Chal-
lenge. Washington, DC : World Bank Group.
Chapter 3. Status of SME in Ethiopia 85
ㅇ Number of SMEs
Knowing the actual number of SMEs is very challenging in
Ethiopia. Different organizations have different data with a large
variations. However, for this analysis the FeSMMIDA report is
taken as a reference. With this in mind, there are 9,823 (73%) small
manufacturing industries and 2,788 (21%) medium-sized business-
es, for a total of 12,611 small and medium manufacturing enter-
prises throughout the country (FeSMMIDA, 2018). In addition to
this, total capital assets were not listed for 878 firms. Including
those firms, the number of SMEs in Ethiopia comes to 13,489.
ㅇ Regional Distribution
With regard to SME distribution in the country, two regions, Tig-
ray 5111 (38%) and SNNPR 2902 (21.5%), dominate. The data is
shown in the table below.
15 During 2017/18 alone, a total of 144,107 new micro and small scale enterprises (MSEs) were
established which employed about 187.9 thousand people (NBE 2017/18 annual report)
Chapter 3. Status of SME in Ethiopia 89
ㅇ Paid-up Capital
As depicted below in Table 3.1, the total paid-up capital by small
and medium enterprises came to 16,995,887,000 (7,456,294,000 by
small enterprises and 9,539,593,000 by medium enterprises). More
ever, the table shows that in terms of total paid up capital by indus-
trial group, food products and beverage ranked first (around 7 bil-
lion). Among the small and medium manufacturing industries, pri-
vate paid-up capital was 82% followed by public industries (9%)
and foreigners (9%) (see Table 8 in the Appendix A).
ㅇ Employment
As shown in table below, the total number of employees of small
and Medium Manufacturing industries came to 113,872, of which
Small industries employed 54,908 (48%) and Medium industries,
58,964 (52%). This indicates the medium manufacturing industry
contributed greatly to total employment created at manufacturing
SMEs. From a total of 115,286 persons engaged in manufacturing,
114,614 (99%) were Ethiopians and the remaining 672 (1%) were
foreign-born. This shows that the majority of employees were
Ethiopian. Of those employees, 72,964 (64%) were male and
41,650 (36%) were female. This shows females employees were
fewer in number than males. In other words, male employees are
employed more frequently in the small and medium manufacturing
firms than female employees.
Chapter 3. Status of SME in Ethiopia 91
ㅇ Capacity Utilization
Capacity utilization plays an important role in evaluating current
economic activity and forecasting future activity. It has been used,
along with other factors, to explain investment, inflation, produc-
tivity, profit, and output behaviors. The figure below shows the ca-
pacity of small and medium manufacturing industries. SMEs only
utilize 60 percent of their production capacity (FeSMEDA, 2018).
92 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
ㅇ Investment
The total investment of fixed assets by small and medium indus-
tries was around 3.4 billion Birr. About 81% of manufactures indi-
Chapter 3. Status of SME in Ethiopia 93
cated that their source of investment was their own funds followed
by domestic banks (11%) while foreign sources played insignifi-
cant roles as shown in Figure 3.3 below.
The result indicates that the support system failed to reach the right
group of small and medium manufacturing industries with potential
for export marketing and import substitution.
small firms, and 18.5 percent of medium sized firms reported that
limited access to finance in Ethiopia was a major constraint to daily
operations. In Ethiopia, female-owned enterprises are challenged
by bad prices for their products and services, compared to other
similar enterprises. In addition a shortage of raw materials and a
lack of experience in owning a business were challenging factors
for women entrepreneurs” (Tadesse Demeke, 2016). In a study
conducted by Singh and Belwal (2008), Ethiopian women-owned
MSEs faced challenges a lack of capital, limited access to markets,
networks and facilities, a lack of training and cultural oppression.
Hagos Yared (2012) revealed that new MSEs face high levels com-
petition given low barriers to entry. In addition, the country’s de-
velopment strategy and policy focus on agriculture, which in turn
discourages MSEs from operating in other sectors.
Regionally, various studies describe a multitude of challenges.
According to Yonas Abera (2016), unfair practices, an unattractive
market a lack of marketing and limited market linkages were iden-
tified as challenges faced by MSEs in the Diredawa city admin-
istration. In a survey conducted by the FDRE Minstry of Urban
Development and Construction (2013) SMEs in Addis Ababa were
challenged by a lack access to finance, facilities and training. In
Hawassa city, the major challenges facing SMEs were a shortage of
electricity and unscheduled power cuts, a lack of market access,
limited access to facilities, insufficient credit and bureaucratic red
tape (Bereket Teklehimanot, 2017). According to Berhanu et. al
(2015) MSEs in the Gedeo Zone were challenged by high taxes,
Chapter 3. Status of SME in Ethiopia 97
17 The Framework Act on Small and Medium Enterprises (중소기업기본법) was enacted as
Law No. 1840 in 1966. The most recent revision was made in July 26, 2017 as Law No.
14839. The full text in English is available at the National Law Information Center web-
site; http://www.law.go.kr/LSW/eng/engMain.do
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 103
Employee SME 14,027,636 87.9% 15,127,047 90.2% 15,392,246 90.3% 15,527,605 89.8%
4.3> shows that the Yeongnam area, which is a traditional name for
the regions in the southeast including Busan, Daegu, Ulsan,
Gyeongbuk and Gyeongnam, is a major center for SMEs.
18 Kyu Soon Choi (1991), History of Korean Small and Medium Industry Policy, Global
Information Service Systems (in Korean)
108 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
20 In 1997, The Act on Special Measures for Small Enterprises (소기업지원을 위한 특별조치법)
was enacted, but this Act was replaced in December 2000 by The Special Act on the Support
of Small Enterprises and Micro Enterprises (소기업 및 소상공인지원을 위한 특별조치법) (Law
No. 6314).
110 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
For Large Enterprises that do not belong to the groups above, the
criteria set forth in the ‘Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act’
(독점규제 및 공정거래에 관한 법률, 1990) is applied. According to this,
Large Enterprises are those companies with over 10 trillion won in
total assets as of 2018 and under the restriction of mutual capitali-
zation. The number of these companies was counted 1,332 under
32 conglomerate groups.21
21 The Act divides Large Enterprises into two subgroups. The companies with the total
asset over 5 trillion won as “disclosure companies group” and the companies with more
than 10 trillion won as “restricted mutual capitalization group”. As of May 1, 2018, 60
company groups (2,083 companies) were designated as the disclosure group.
https://www.kefplaza.com/labor/manage/econo_view.jsp?nodeid=289&idx=14825
https://www.mk.co.kr/news/economy/view/2018/12/762542/
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 111
24 http://theme.archives.go.kr/next/organ/organBasicInfo.do?code=OG0018055
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 113
25 Its name was the Small & Medium Business Corporation (SBC) at the time of estab-
lishment, but was renamed as of April 2019 in line with the name of the government
new Ministry.
26 Agency for SMEs (2013), 2012 Modularization of Korea's Development Experience:
Business, but in August 2006 it was renamed as Korea Federation of SMEs (K-biz).
https://www.kbiz.or.kr/user/nd46557.do
114 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
28 Many parts of the old policies until the early 1970s described here depend on the sources
compiled by Kyu-Soon Choi, 1991.
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 115
In the 1990s, the continued growth of the economy raised the in-
ternational status of Korea but brought widened and deepened
global competition along with the liberalization. In 1996, Korea
joined the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Develop-
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 117
29 UNKRA was established as a result of the 5th UN General Assembly in December 1950.
Its mission was to provide emergency relief for the Korean people suffering from the war
and to help the reconstruction of Korean economy. The aid amounted to $ 122 million, and
its mission was completed by the end of June 1958 (Kyu-Soon Choi, 1991, p.27).
30 Low-cost loans were provided to SMEs by using the funds, which consist of Special
118 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Accounts reserves of Enemy Asset sales and Aid material sales (Kyu-Soon Choi, 1991,
p.38).
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 119
33 As the UNKRA's mission ended in 1958, the grant aid to Korea began to decline signifi-
cantly. US aid to Korea continued to decline since its peak at $383 million in 1957, stay-
ing at $113 million in 1965.
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 123
34 A pyeong (abbreviation py) is a traditional Korean unit of area and floor space, equal to
3.3058 m2 .
35 National Archives of Korea, Korea’s Export Industry Complexes in the 1960s
124 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
36 http://theme.archives.go.kr/next/industry/delegate1960B.do
37 http://theme.archives.go.kr/next/economicDevelopment/increaseInExport.do
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 125
38 http://news.khan.co.kr/kh_news/khan_art_view.html?art_id=201312192058505
126 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
41 http://www.archives.go.kr/next/search/listSubjectDescription.do?id=007255
42 Article 10 (Encouragement of Fair Competition and Mutual Growth). The Government
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 131
shall take measures necessary to ensure that small and medium enterprises can cooperate,
fairly compete with businesses other than the small and medium enterprises, and pursue
mutual growth. [This Article Wholly Amended by Act No. 10952, Jul. 25, 2011]
43 The unbalanced growth theory is the economic development theory on developing coun-
duced for local SMEs to take advantage of the rural labor force and
to promote local industrialization. To this end, eight specialty prod-
ucts, such as sweaters, wigs, and artificial pearls were selected and
supported as joint projects through cooperatives in the relevant in-
dustries (Kyu-Soon Choi, 1991, p. 62).
In 1969, the Saemaul Undong (New Village Movement) was
promulgated with the modernization of rural areas as the slogan. In
the 1970s, the campaign was carried out nationwide based on the
government's extensive public relations and organizations. In con-
nection with this movement, the construction of Saemaul factories
began in 1973. This was to expand the local specialty industry de-
velopment strategy further. It attempted to establish small factories
in the cities and villages nationwide and generate income by pro-
ducing goods suitable for local characteristics. According to this
policy, 1,357 companies were designated as Saemaul factories by
the end of January 1984. However, the actual outcomes were dubi-
ous as the policy was excessively pushed to show off the govern-
ment's achievements, ignoring local market conditions. At the end
of 1987, the number of Saemaul factories decreased to 556, of
which only 452 companies were operating normally (Kyu Soon
Choi, 1991, pp.162-166).
At the end of 1983, the government enacted the ‘ Act on the
Promotion of Rural Income Source Development’(농어촌소득원
개발촉진법) and promoted the creation of new Rural Industrial De-
velopment Promotion District (agro-industrial complex). Under
this law, it was planned to build at least one agro-industrial com-
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 133
plex in 135 counties across the nation and to house 2,300 factories.
As of 1987, 77 agro-industrial complexes were established or un-
derway, and 1,158 companies applied to locate there (Kyu Soon
Choi, 1991, pp.162-166). In 2015, a media reported that 167 of the
460 agricultural complexes in operation at that time were built in
the 1980s, and most of them were losing competitiveness due to the
old and outdated infrastructure and neglect from government
policies.44
The Korean economy has grown rapidly over the past 70 years,
and the government has guided this process by setting appropriate
policy directions when called for. This process, however, could not
be accomplished by government policy alone, but by the efforts of
numerous companies and individuals. The growth process of the
Korean economy was the combined process of hard efforts of indi-
viduals who dreamed of breaking out of poverty, creating compa-
nies and working hard to grow them. In response to the govern-
ment's export-led industrialization policies, the companies that
have taken advantage of the given opportunities well have grown
into large global corporations.
The list of the world's 500 largest companies, published by For-
tune magazine in the US in 2019, included 17 companies in Korea.
The number of companies by country shows that Korea is the 7th
44 No Cut News, December 7, 2015, “Why treat them like extramarital children? 30 years
of agro-industrial complexes”
134 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
45 https://fortune.com/global500/2019/
Chapter 4. Korea’s SME Policy Development and Issues 135
This section examines the current status of bilateral trade and di-
rect investment, together with the status development cooperation.
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 139
5.1.1 Trade
Korea and Ethiopia's bilateral trade amounted to $151 million as
of the end of 2018, which showed a 9.7% decrease compared to
2017. As shown in Figure 5.1, in the 2000s, the trend of bilateral
trade has shown relatively fast growth, quickly rebounding after
temporary declines. However, in the more recent years, perfor-
mance has been sluggish. This is interpreted as a general reflection
of the trends of the world economy and Ethiopia. In other words,
the sharp decline in 2010 reflected the impact of the global reces-
sion after the financial crisis that occurred in USA at the end of
2008. The recent years of sluggishness seem to reflect a situation in
which the high growth of Ethiopian economy began to slow down
mainly due to political instability.
Source: http://stat.kita.net
Optical, Photographic,
Cinematographic, Medical
Articles Of Leather, Trav-
7 90 Instruments and Appa- 3,676 42 256
el Goods, Handbags
ratus, Parts And Accesso-
ries
Articles Of Apparel and
Rubber and Articles
8 40 2,816 61 Clothing Accessories, 238
thereof
Knitted Or Crocheted
Source: https://oec.world/en/profile/country/eth/
Source: https://oec.world/en/profile/country/eth/
Numbers 2 1 1 4 3 2 3 0 16
Amount
0 0 0 2 7 12 6 9 36
($million)
Source: EximBank of Korea
46 KOTRA homepage, May 2, 2019, “Ethiopia 2019 Economic Outlook and Business
Environment Analysis,” report by the Addis Ababa Office
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 145
Source: http://www.odakorea.go.kr
Korea's ODA for Ethiopia closely tracks bilateral trade and in-
vestment trends. It increased rapidly in the 2000s, peaking 2016 but
then decreasing. It also seems to be related to the political instabil-
ity after 2016. By sector, $22.57 million, or 48.5% of the total in
2017, was allocated to social infrastructure including education and
health, followed by $14.84 million (31.9%) for economic infra-
47 http://www.odakorea.go.kr/ODAPage_2018/cate02/nation_stats2_Ethiopia.jsp
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 147
structure and $5.37 million for the production sector (11.5%). The
remaining portions went to multi-sectors $2.69 million (5.8%) and
humanitarian assistance $1.05 million (2.3%).
Looking at Korea's major ODA projects as of 2019, KOICA,
which is in charge of grants, is carrying out nine projects. Major
projects include rural development projects in Dodota, Oromia, and
family planning support projects as part of the the Small Happy
and Prosperous family in Ethiopia (SHaPE) program. An integrated
water hygiene support project and the construction of a vocational
training center in Tigria are also under way. Projects funded by the
EDCF, the agency in charge of concessionary loans, include Mojo-
Hawasa Highway Project Phase 1, the Gore-Tepi Road Project and
the Suluta-Gebre Guracha Power Transmission project.
In addition, several ODA projects are also underway by public
agencies of Korea with sponsorships of each Ministry. Among
them, Ministry of Strategy and Finance is sponsoring a Knowledge
Sharing Program focusing on policy dialogues with officials and
experts for economic policies development. The Ministry of Trade,
Industry and Energy is sponsoring the construction of a Techno
Park, and Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs is spon-
soring an irrigation project in Harari Province.48
As for other major cooperation issues, there were 40 MOUs
signed during former Korean President Park Geun-hye's visit to
Ethiopia and summit meeting in May 2016, including the construc-
tion of an industrial park for Korean textile corporations. The two
49 http://english.hankyung.com/news/2016/05/27/0920411/korean-textile-firms-to-build-
industrial-zone-in-ethiopia?setct=print&popup=1
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 149
52 =∑
∑
152 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Halogenated deriv-
Oil-cake & other
290369 atives of aromatic 122,469 230610 1,940
solid residues
hydrocarbons
Brass-wind musi-
Sheet piling of cal instruments.
730110 83,856 920510 926
iron/steel (e.g., trumpets,
trombones)
1-(1,3-
Nickel oxides &
293292 Benzodioxol-5- 83,496 282540 371
hydroxides
yl)propan-2-one
53 Since international trade database (UN Comtrade) provides trade data for Ethiopia up to
2016, we use 2016 data.
154 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
East Africa 7,253 6,615 6,873 7,694 8,665 8,966 46,066 7,202 37,855 91,537
Ethiopia 1,344 1,855 2,627 3,989 4,017 3,310 17,142 941 4,206 22,253
Tanzania 2,087 1,416 1,561 864 938 1,105 7,971 2,781 9,712 20,712
Kenya 1,119 821 620 681 1,275 1,626 6,142 932 5,449 14,421
Uganda 1,096 1,059 738 626 803 1,337 5,659 807 5,575 13,333
Madagascar 551 314 436 451 389 349 2,490 141 4,383 6,360
Mauritius 293 456 216 379 443 372 2,159 683 4,658 5,313
Somalia 258 261 303 334 384 409 1,949 4 566 2,725
Djibouti 286 153 124 160 165 265 1,153 40 878 2,219
Seychelles 170 230 195 155 192 124 1,066 515 1,701 3,023
The six-year trend confirms that Ethiopia has been very active
and successful in attracting inflows of foreign investment. Looking
back, in 2013, inflows to Ethiopia came to just 64% of what neigh-
boring Tanzania had attracted, and did not show much difference
with Kenya or Uganda, but by 2017 it had increased rapidly every
year and was 3-4 times higher than that of Tanzania, Kenya and
Uganda. In terms of total FDI in East Africa from 2013-2018, Ethi-
opia ranked first with $17.142 billion accounting for 37.2% of the
region, followed by Tanzania, Kenya, and Uganda.
This growth has led Ethiopia to become the regional leader in
FDI stock as well in 2018, which refers to the balance of inflows
and outflows up to the time. Also looking at the <Table 5.1>, Ethi-
opia's FDI stock was $4.206 billion in 2010, less than half of Tan-
zania and only the sixth in the region, but in 2018 it reached
$22.253 billion and was in the first place, surpassing Tanzania.
This fact supports the motivation of this research which was ini-
tiated by the recognition that Ethiopia is emerging as a promising
market in Africa and is drawing attention as a production base in
East Africa, as foreign investment in the manufacturing sector is
rapidly increasing, especially in labor-intensive industries such as
textiles, clothing, and leather goods. It surely affirms that the Ethi-
opian government was very successful in attracting foreign invest-
ment in spite of unfavorable geography, being a landlocked country
without ports.
According to the Ethiopian Investment Commission (EIC), a to-
tal of 5,318 investment declarations were made during 1992 and
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 159
This study is going to introduce two cases among these in the fol-
lowing subsection, whose situations were identified through the
local interviews and various press releases.
54 http://news.kotra.or.kr/user/globalAllBbs/kotranews/album/2/globalBbsDataAll Vie
w.do?dataIdx=174594&searchNationCd=101124
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 161
55 https://addisfortune.net/articles/korean-textile-company-starts-operation/
162 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
56 http://www.shints.com/main-factory/
Chapter 5. Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia: Current Status and Opportunities 163
tax incentives, as did all the other investors.57 Finally, the chairman
expressed an optimistic opinion about business prospects and
commented that more Korean investment in the apparel industry
would be desirable. He expected that Ethiopia would rise as a main
destination of production bases in the industry in the near future
owing to the advantage of low cost labor and duty-free exports to
USA and Europe.
According to a local media report in October 2018, the company
was considered as a success story, operating the facility on a
51,350m2 plot and employing 3,690 staff. However, it was known
that the low productivity and logistics issues were persistent. The
promising sign was the opening of the 4 billion USD, 756km Ethi-
opia-Djibouti electrified passenger rail in line with a parallel cargo
rail. Also, the recent improvement of the relationship with Ethio-
pia’s bitter enemy, neighboring Eritrea, raised hopes for new busi-
ness opportunities, as it would enable the company to use the port
of Assab in Eritrea, which is in the same distance as the port in
Djibouti.58
57 Ethiopia's corporate income tax is 30%, while personal income tax is 35% and sales tax
is 15%. Foreign investment is given corporate tax exemption for the initial seven years
after the investment. https://tradingeconomics.com/ethiopia/personal-income-tax-rate
58 https://www.just-style.com/analysis/africa-continues-to-face-challenges-to-reach-ful l-
potential_id134720.aspx
164 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Health
The goal of this program is for the improvement of the status of
maternal and child health in Ethiopia by supporting the health of
women and children through efforts to reduce both the fertility and
mortality rate of mothers and infants. Nowadays the program is
implemented both in urban and rural parts of Ethiopia.
Economic Infrastructure
Building an economic infrastructure is a game-changing activity
from a developing country’s perspective, because development and
investment require a well-developed economic infrastructure. In
Ethiopia, building this infrastructure is a challenging task since it
requires significant investments. To tackle such problems, estab-
lishing bilateral cooperation with developed nations like the Re-
public of Korea is a sound strategy.
Technical Assistance
Training programs include: The dispatch of experts and volun-
teers, development research and policy advisory services and cross-
cutting issues (gender equality and the environment).
The lifespan of the above two projects was only one year, and
both have already been completed. The KSP has continued its con-
tributions, with a special focus on the agricultural and service sec-
tors.
Construction
contracting 2 1 1 14,363 4 0
water well
Others 1 1 200 50 50
Grand total 33 6 8 19 573,657 1,667 6,690
Source: FDRE investment commission (EIC)
Exports
Ethiopia is the 129th largest export economy in the world and
the 116th most complex economy according to the Economic
Complexity Index (ECI). In 2017, Ethiopia exported $2.2 billion
and imported $8 billion worth of goods, resulting in a negative
172 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
Import
As seen in <Table 6.3>, imports were highest in 2015 and lowest
in 2018. This may be due to the country’s foreign exchange short-
age. According to the data from Ministry of Trade and Industry,
Chapter 6. Ethiopian Perspective on Bilateral Cooperation 173
most of imported items from the Republic of Korea are mainly cap-
ital goods such as machinery, vehicles and other industrial goods.
This shows that Ethiopia is in a low level of industrial development
and highly independent on foreign imported industrial products.
Trade balance
The trade balance between the two nations shows a negative trade
balance on the Ethiopian side and is in favor of the Republic of Korea.
As mentioned above, most of the export items from Ethiopia are agri-
cultural products or semi-processed items and their prices on the in-
ternational market are very low.
250,000,000
200,000,000
150,000,000
100,000,000 Export In Usd
Based on the above figure, one can understand that the negative
trade balance (or deficit) begins to decline after recording a high in
2015. This is due to falling imports from Korea and a slight uptick
in exports beginning from 2014.
6.4.1 Strengths
The bilateral relationship between Ethiopia and Republic of Ko-
rea has been growing in economic, social, political and cultural ar-
eas. According to FDRE Ministry of Finance, the Republic of Ko-
176 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
opment of the SME sectors. Many countries have shown great con-
cern for SME bilateral cooperation and have reaped many benefits.
According to the data from the Federal Small and Medium Manu-
facturing Industry Development Agency (FeSMMIDA), the follow-
ing institutions (Table 6.5) are engaged in different capacity building
activities.
World BANK and EIB through Provide financial (lease finance ) and
1
SMEs finance project Non-financial (BDS) support to SMEs
6.6.1 Conclusions
In the recent development agenda, international economic coop-
eration and assistance are very important enablers for a broad range
of development goals in the world. Investment and trade are inte-
gral parts of the international economic system and major compo-
nents of local development. International cooperation will also aid
the development of developing nations like Ethiopia (UNCTAD,
2014). The bilateral cooperation between Ethiopia and the Republic
of Korea is considered a fine example. The Ethiopian government
has tried to create a better investment environment for Korean in-
180 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
61 Korea Fashion Industry Association, "Ethiopia is rising as a new global production ba-
sis", January 2, 2018,
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 187
Korean SMEs, Africa is still far not only in the geographical dis-
tance but also in psychological and cultural distance as well, and
this distance seem to work as a barrier to their investment deci-
sions. In this regard, more active cooperation by the governments
of both countries are necessary to shorten such distance and pro-
mote investment and trade. A variety of cooperative activities can
be pursued to raise the mutual understanding of business environ-
ments as well as cultural inheritance. Also, as a means of overcom-
ing these obstacles, it is expected to bring a positive effect if an
industrial complex in Ethiopia specifically for Korean companies,
for which the MOU was signed by the two governments in 2016,
can be realized soon.
Increased local investment also brings the effect of significantly
increasing bilateral trade through the imports of raw materials and
exports of finished products by invested companies, as seen in
China and Southeast Asia. In the process of the growth of China
and Southeast Asian countries as major trading partners for Korea,
overtaking the previously dominant positions of the US and Japan,
the role of Korean companies that have invested heavily in the re-
gion has been very significant. It might be assumed that increased
investment in Ethiopia would certainly bring similar effects to bi-
lateral trade as well.
One thing to remember is that while global investors are looking
for low wages, low wages often lead to labor issues and social ten-
sions in many developing countries. A recent study by some US
scholars that viewed the low wages of the Ethiopian textile and
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 189
63 Aisha Salaudeen (2019), “Ethiopia ’s garment workers make clothes for some of the
world ’s largest clothing brands but get paid the lowest”, CNN, May 13, 2019
190 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
with its vast land area and warm highland climate, but until now,
production has been sluggish: around 50,000 metric tons per year,
which is not enough to be self-sufficient. The textile industries are
also vulnerable in most subsectors such as spinning and weaving,
and considerable portions of local demand in the garment industry
are being met by imports. Even though foreign investment in vari-
ous sectors of the textiles industry is endorsed, Ethiopia is more
focused on the garments industry, which aims to export to the US
and Europe, taking advantage of duty-free benefits.
Indeed, in recent years, Ethiopia has made remarkable achieve-
ments in these areas with the surge in foreign investment and ex-
ports. According to an Ethiopian media report in April 2018, Ethio-
pia's textile and clothing industry has grown by 51% annually over
the last five to six years, with 61 foreign investment permis-
sions. 64 Data from the Ethiopian Investment Commission (EIC)
reveals that a total of 386 FDI projects in the textile and apparel
industry were implemented during 1992-2017 valued at $386 mil-
lion, creating 57,768 full-time and 7,133 contract jobs. In terms of
the origins of the investors, China accounted for more than one-
third with 56 cases, while Turkey had 14 cases, India 13 and China-
Ethiopia 12.
64 The Ethiopian Herald, “Ethiopia: Textile on the Rise – Ministry”, April 5, 2018.
192 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
The one remaining park outside of the textile and clothing industry
is the Kilinto Industrial Park, which is under construction in the
metropolitan area and aims to attract pharmaceutical companies.
The full list of Industrial Parks provided by the Ethiopian Invest-
ment Commission (EIC) is attached to the annex of this research.
The Ethiopian government provides separate tax exemptions for
developers and resident companies in order to continuously devel-
op industrial parks and attract foreign investors. In addition, the
EIC has established a One-Stop-Shop (OSS) for foreign invest-
ment, providing services to simplify the process of issuing investment
permissions, moving in and beginning operation. <Table 7.3> summa-
rizes the income tax exemption benefits. In addition, tariff exemp-
tions are provided for imports of parts and equipment, and more
information is available through the EIC.
So far, some Korean companies have entered the Bole-lemi 1 in-
dustrial park and the Kombolcha industrial park as introduced in
the previous chapter. These companies aimed at the low costs for
labor as well as land lease, and duty-free exports to the US and Eu-
rope utilizing the AGOA and EBA. The United States and Europe
provide no tariff exports benefits for the UN-selected Least Devel-
oped Countries (LDCs) to help developing countries to end pov-
erty. Germany, in particular, is actively pursuing the Africa Initia-
tive for that purpose and is the largest importer of Ethiopian appar-
el products.
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 195
65 https://allafrica.com/stories/201802140625.html
196 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
66UNIDO(2017), Ethiopian Leather Sector – Current Status and Future Prospects, Semi-
nar Presentation
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 197
Source: UNIDO (2017), Ethiopian Leather Sector – Current Status and Future Prospects, Sem-
inar Presentation
period, Korean companies can also benefit from AGOA for locally
produced products in Ethiopia. Comprehensive and detailed infor-
mation on AGOA is available here: https://agoa.info/
The AGOA system is implemented in conjunction with the Gen-
eralized System of Preferences (GSP) provided by developed coun-
tries to developing countries under the 1971 GATT Agreement.
While limiting the targeted countries, the AGOA system expanded
the target items further from the GSP. The GSP is a benefit system
that all developed countries provide to all developing countries on
the same terms, whereas the AGOA differs in that the United States
only provides benefits for LDCs in Africa. In addition to the 4,600
items covered by the GSP, 1,800 items including textiles, clothing
and leather goods are added, providing duty-free or low-duty
benefits.
The effect of AGOA on the trade growth of African LDCs is
considered to be significant. Exports under the AGOA regime in-
creased by 6.6 times from $8.15 billion in 2001 to $53.8 billion in
2011. Ethiopia's exports under the AGOA also increased by more
than 80% annually from $215 thousand in 2001 to $18,294 thou-
sand in 2012 (Ethiopia Ministry of Trade, 2013). One of the im-
portant factors contributing to the high growth of the Ethiopian in
the 2000s was the significant increase in exports of the textile,
clothing and leather industries, using the AGOA and the European
Union's EBA.
However, compared to other countries in Sub-Saharan Africa
(SSA), Ethiopia is considered to have not fully utilized the AGOA
200 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
67https://www.one.org/africa/blog/the-10th-agoa-forum-in-lusaka-zambia/
68The full text of AGOA Response Strategy can be downloaded here: https://agoa.
info/downloads/national-strategies.html
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 201
69 http://www.seoul.co.kr/news/newsView.php?id=20160527001010
70 Korea Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2019), Ethiopia in 2019
202 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
who took office in April 2018 was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize
in October 2019 for his contribution to improving the hostile rela-
tions with neighboring Eritrea. As such, one important barrier to
bilateral cooperation is fading away, and another round of active
cooperation is expected. It would be desirable for the two govern-
ments to prepare specific implementation plans for the underper-
forming agreements and endeavor to implement them sincerely.
The agreements between the two governments are diplomatic is-
sues concerned with the states' prestige, so they should be carefully
reviewed and concluded. It is important to avoid such signing cer-
emonies that are made prematurely to show off their achievements
when high-level officials including the president or ministers visit
each country. Repeated events like these will reduce the trust in the
promises between nations and exhaust the practitioners in the
fields.
In addition, our Ethiopian authors pointed out that there are no
bilateral cooperation agreement focused on SMEs and that there is
no investment guarantee agreement. This seems to be owing to the
fact that the cooperation between companies in Ethiopia and Korea
has not reached full scale yet to take into the SME issues seriously.
It will be desirable to review such agreements in advance to pro-
mote full-scale cooperation in the future.
71 https://www.hankyung.com/politics/article/2016052651211
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 205
72 https://www.asiae.co.kr/article/2018031909494913377
73 https://www.mk.co.kr/news/business/view/2008/11/683358/
74 https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20170924001700077
206 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
75 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0016718517303056
76 http://www.e-eiz.com/about.php?lg=en
Chapter 7. How to Promote Bilateral SME Cooperation? 207
References
Assefa, Berihu et.al (2014), Identifying Key Success Factors and Con-
straints of Ethiopia’s MSE Development: An Exploratory Research,
EDRI Research Report 18. Addis Ababa.
Kong, Byung-Ho (2011), History of the Rise and Fall of Korean En-
terprises (in Korean), Seoul: Haenaem Publisher,
Louise Fox1 and Upaasna Kaul (2018), The Evidence Is In: How
Should Youth Employment Programs in Low-Income Countries Be
Designed?Background Paper to the 2018 World Development Re-
port, World Bank Development Economics Development Research
Group.
Nega, Fredu and Edris Hussein (2016), Small and Medium Enterprise
Access to Finance in Ethiopia: Synthesis of Demand and Supply,
the Horn Economic and Social Policy Institute (HESPI), Working
Paper 01/16, Addis Ababa.
212 Industrial Cooperation between Korea and Ethiopia
<Data>
UN Comtrade, https://comtrade.un.org/
Date of Type of
No Name of Investor Investment Activity Region
Permit Investor
Wholly Provision Of Hospital Service By
21 07-Apr-14 Jaeko Medical PLC Oromia
Foreign Constraction Own Building
Wholly Deformed Bar And Steel Angle
22 10-Jun-14 Ekos Steel Mill PLC Oromia
Foreign Manufacturing
Manufacturing Of Other Plastic
Joint with
23 01-Jul-14 M.S.Technology PLC Product Excluding Plastic Shop- Oromia
Domestic
ping Bag
Wooam corporation Wholly Consultancy in electrical engi-
24 07-Aug-14 Addis Ababa
Ethiopian branch Foreign neering service
Susan food and bever- Wholly Farming of bees/Production of
25 23-Apr-15 Oromia
age PLC Foreign honey
WB Manufacturing Wholly Manufacture of plastic water tank,
26 12-Jun-15 Oromia
PLC Foreign pipes and fittings
Hanure Manufacturing Wholly
27 16-Jul-15 Mnufacturing of Leather Prducts Oromia
PLC Foreign
Pax Industrial Machin- Wholly Manufacture of general purpose
28 16-Sep-15 Addis Ababa
ery PLC Foreign machinery(Expansion)
Evertop Sportswear Wholly Manufacturing of wearing apparel
29 05-Aug-16 Addis Ababa
PLC Foreign (Including sport wears)
Provision of Technical and Voca-
Joint with
30 10-Feb-17 S and E Service PLC tional (including Sports Training Oromia
Domestic
Service)
Shints ETP Garment Wholly
31 17-Jul-17 General contractor (GC-1) Addis Ababa
PLC Foreign
Shints ETP Garment Wholly Manufacture of made-up textile
32 06-Dec-17 Addis Ababa
PLC Foreign article, except apparel
Machinery (factory) and medical
Wholly
33 11-Dec-17 Kora Pharma Plc equipment maintenance and Addis Ababa
Foreign
servicing business
Source: EIC data provided through PSI
ANNEX 219
Addis
1 211 2,151,800,613 90 974,618,623 12 110,339,217
Ababa
Manufacturing of food
760,371 5,461,086 475,851 198,651 6,895,958 3,962,404 2,933,554
products and Beverages
Manufacturing of Wearing
- 101,168 65,809 135,358 302,335 108,803 193,532
Apparel, except fur Apparel
Manufacturing of footwear,
2,125 256,680 92,185 153,131 504,119 184,558 319,561
luggage and handbags
Manufacturing of Cork
23,855 8,401 504 - 32,761 13,340 19,421
except furniture
Manufacturing of paper ,
8,645 736,015 153,262 48,267 946,189 286,258 659,931
paper products and printing
Manufacturing of chemicals
- 483,604 132,126 34,081 649,811 269,807 380,004
chemicals products
Manufacturing of machinery
195,747 1,005,710 37,454 7,028 1,245,939 298,286 947,653
and equipment
Manufacturing of machinery
- 143,016 18,731 - 161,746 19,684 142,062
and equipment n.e.c.
Manufacturing of furinture ,
14,275 464,604 180,025 11,833 670,737 311,357 359,380
n.e.c.
Manufacturing of food
18,074 9,109 141 27,324 27,020 12,616 14,404
products and Beverages
Manufacturing of Wearing
1,819 7,564 93 9,476 9,451 3,278 6173
Apparel, except fur Apparel
Manufacturing of footwear,
2,959 1,859 50 4,868 4,833 1,737 3,096
luggage and handbages
Manufacturing of Cork
2,719 315 7 3,041 3,022 389 2,633
except furinture
Manufacturing of paper,
3,249 2,373 54 5,676 5,634 2,116 3,518
paper products and printing
Manufacturing of chemicals
2,423 1,119 8 3,550 3,522 1,848 1,674
chemicals products
Manufacturing of rubber
4,789 3,669 47 8,505 8,436 3,419 5,017
and plastic products
Manufacturing of other
non-mettalic meniral prod- 19,587 4,301 126 24,014 23,528 16,535 6,993
ucts
Manufacturing of machin-
4,665 1,235 13 5,913 5,786 3,694 2,092
ery and equipment
Manufacturing of machin-
652 459 5 1,116 1,103 807 296
ery and equipment n.e.c.
Manufacturing of furinture ,
4,796 2,456 61 7,313 7,197 3,696 3,501
n.e.c.
3
Hawassa special
Textile & opera- Fully
Phase- I, Hawassa 37 12 22 sheds
Garment tional occupied
Cycle -I (39,68
0 m2)
Hawassa
Textile & opera- Fully
Phase- I, Hawassa 15 5 10 -
Garment tional occupied
Cycle -II
Garment,
opera- Fully
Adama Adama Textile 19 6 9 4
tional occupied
&Machinery,
Ready
Garment,
Dire- Dire- for 13 sheds
Apparel and 15 5 6 4
Dawa Dawa inaugu- available
Textile
ration
Apparel opera- 3 sheds
Mekelle Mekelle 15 5 6 4
&Textile tional available
Kombol- Kombol- Apparel opera- Fully
9 2 7 -
cha cha &Textile tional occupied
Apparel Inaugu- Fully
Jimma Jimma 9 - 4 5
&Textile rated occupied
Under
Garment 8 Sheds
Bahir-Dar Bahir-Dar 8 - 8 - con-
&Apparel available
struction
Debre- Debre- Garment Inaugu- 4 Sheds
8 8
Birhan Berhan &Apparel rated available
Source: INDUSTRIAL PARKS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION (IPDC)
http://www.ipdc.gov.et/index.php/en/industrial-parks
ANNEX 223