Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Applied Surface Science: Full Length Article
Applied Surface Science: Full Length Article
A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T
Keywords: The continuous AlFeCrCoNi high entropy alloy coating was firstly fabricated on aluminium alloy by resistance
Resistance seam welding seam welding. During welding, the coating was formed rapidly under the effect of instantaneous joule heating
High entropy alloy coating and the pressure. The gradient temperature transformed the nanocrystalline AlFeCrCoNi powder into the
Joule heating effect AlFeCrCoNi HEA coating consisted of body-centered-cubic and face-centered cubic structures. According to the
Wear properties
calculation and experimental results, the welding process was not brought the negative affect to the substrate
and only a certain amount of aluminum element penetrated into the coating. The average thickness and hardness
of the coating were 420 µm and 715HV0.2, respectively. Compared to A6061, the coating exhibited excellent
wear-resistance in dry, deionized water and 3.5 wt% NaCl solution conditions. The environment played an
important role in the wear behaviour of the AlFeCrCoNi HEA coating. Meanwhile, the corrosive wear of the
AlFeCrCoNi HEA coating was proved to be beneficial to reduce the wear rate.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: zhao.dechao696@mail.kyutech.jp (D. Zhao), yamaguchi.tomiko374@mail.kyutech.jp (T. Yamaguchi).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2020.145980
Received 10 January 2020; Received in revised form 16 February 2020; Accepted 4 March 2020
Available online 05 March 2020
0169-4332/ © 2020 Published by Elsevier B.V.
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 1. (a) the XRD patterns of the HEA powder and HEA coating and (b) the SEM and TEM results of the HEA powder.
heating effect of the electrical resistivity was the only heat source.
Furthermore, the low electrical resistivity and high thermal con-
ductivity properties of aluminum alloy were also benefited to avoid the
low heat generation of joule heating. Moreover, the conductive powder
itself also generated a joule heating effect when the current was passed
through. If the pressure and current were applied to the powders at the
same time, the coating could be formed theoretically. Therefore, it is
promising to fabricate the high-performance wear resistance coating on
aluminum alloy thin plate by RESW method.
In this study, a typical lightweight HEA (AlFeCrCoNi HEA) with
high strength and good corrosion resistance, was selected as the coating
material. After that, the continuous high-entropy alloy coating was
rapidly fabricated on aluminum alloy by resistance seam welding
method. Moreover, the coating formation ability of the RESW method
was evaluated by the theoretical calculation of the instantaneous tem-
perature and the experimental results. Finally, the wear performance of
HEAc was systematically investigated in dry, deionized water and
3.5 wt% NaCl solution conditions. The wear mechanisms of the coating
Fig. 2. The DSC curve of the AlFeCrCoNi HEA powder and coating. in three conditions have also been revealed.
method for the joining of thin metal sheets such as aluminum alloys and
magnesium alloys. During welding, the electric current and electrode
pressure were applied on the substrate simultaneously, and the joule
Fig. 3. The EDS elemental mappings of the single AlFeCrCoNi HEA powder.
2
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 4. (a) the schematic of fabricating HEA coating by RESW process, (b) the macro-morphology of HEAc on A6061 thin plate, (c) the SEM image of the side surface
of the HEA coating, and (d) the SEM image of the top surface of the HEA coating.
Fig. 5. (a) the principal diagram of RESW, (b) the distribution of the instantaneous temperature between adjacent particles, (c)~(d) the side surface of HEAc.
Table 1 Co were mixed with equal atomic ratios and then added in the plane-
The parameters of the HEA powder for the calculation of the instantaneous tary ball mill (Pulverisette 5/4, Fritzsch) under the argon atmosphere.
temperature. The tungsten carbide grinding ball and tank were used for the milling
Cv (J/(kg·K) ρm (g/cm3) ρ (Ω·cm) Δt (s) r (µm) Is (kA) Ipx (A) process, and the AlFeCrCoNi HEA powder was obtained after 35 h of
the ball milling with a speed of 250 rpm. The specific heat capacity (Cv)
−3
490.84 7.1 3.45 × 10 0.004 10 3.0 0.003 of the AlFeCrCoNi HEA powder was tested by differential scanning
calorimeter (DSC-60Plus, SHIMADZU) and the average resistivity (ρ) of
HEA powder was measured by resistivity meters (Loresta-GX MCP-
2. Materials and methods
T700). The structures of AlFeCrCoNi HEA powder were characterized
by the transmission electron microscopy (TEM, JEM-3000F, JEOL,
2.1. The properties of the AlFeCrCoNi HEA powder
Japan) and X-ray diffraction (XRD, JDX3500, JEOL, Japan).
The high purity (> 95%) elemental powders of Al, Fe, Cr, Ni, and
3
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 6. (a) the IPF map of the HEA coating and (b) the phases map of the HEA coating.
4
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 8. The EPMA analysis of the interface between the HEA coating and substrate.
Fig. 9. The EDS elemental mappings of the top surface of the AlFeCrCoNi HEA coating.
Fig. 10. The friction coefficient curves of the HEA coating and A6061 in three conditions. (a) the dry condition, (b) the deionized water condition and (c) the 3.5 wt%
NaCl solution condition.
obviously exothermic peaks have appeared at 808.6 K and 916.5 K, the final coating will be formed under the effect of the instantaneous
which was also illustrated that the HEA powder belonged to the na- joule heating of powders. Thus, the shape and the distribution of ele-
nocrystalline structure. During welding, the pressure and current will ments in the powder were important for the formation of the HEA
be applied to the powder at the same time, as shown in Fig. 4(a), and coating. According to the EDS elemental mappings of a single HEA
5
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 11. (a) the friction coefficient rate of the HEA coating and A6061 and (b) the wear rate of the HEA coating and A6061 in three conditions.
Table 2 πr 2
Ipx = Is
The chemical compositions of the worn surface of HEA coating in three con- S (2)
ditions.
where S was the total area of the powder and r was the radius of the
Conditions Elemental compositions (at%)
particle. Therefore, the instantaneous temperature of adjacent particles
O Al Si Cr Fe Co Ni Na can be derived from Eq (3) [24]:
Dry condition 20.99 30.17 3.27 11.42 11.54 11.84 10.75 – 16 I2px ρΔt
Deionized water 25.19 14.42 4.9 13.97 13.66 14.11 13.75 –
ΔT=
π CV ρm [r 2-(r − x)2]2
2
(3)
3.5 wt%NaCl(aq) 31.41 13.74 7.71 11.34 11.73 11.99 11.73 1.35
The x was the distance from the contacting area. All of the para-
meters for calculation were shown in Table 1. The instantaneous dis-
powder in Fig. 3, the five elements were homogeneously distributed in
tribution of temperature between the adjacent particles was shown in
the spherical powder.
Fig. 5(b), in a tiny contact area (x ≤ 0.75 µm), the instantaneous
temperature was over 3000 K much higher than the melting point of
3.2. Characterization and calculation of the AlFeCrCoNi HEA coating by AlFeCrCoNi HEA alloy (~1645 K) [25]. If the distance x was larger than
RESW 0.75 µm, the temperature began to decrease sharply and the tempera-
ture at the center of the HEA powder was only about 63 K, which in-
After welding, the macro-morphology of HEAc was shown in dicated that the substrate was not affected directly by the instantaneous
Fig. 4(b), the continuous HEAc was fabricated at a welding speed of joule heating effect. Therefore, during the RESW process, the in-
0.5 m/min for one time and the flat back appearance of A6061 implied stantaneous joule heating effect first generated high temperature in the
that macroscopic morphology of the substrate was not affected by tiny contact area and then combined them, as shown in Fig. 5(c) and
welding. The top surface and side surface of HEAc were shown in (d). After that, the presence of the gradient temperature, which was
Fig. 4(c) and (d), respectively. The top surface of HEAc was relatively caused by the joule heating effect, was continuously transferred from
flat, and the average thickness was about 420 µm. According to the XRD the contact area to the center of the particle and other adjacent pow-
patterns in Fig. 1(a), HEAc contained the FCC and BCC structures, ders, eventually, the HEAc was fabricated under the action of the
which was the same as the vacuum arc-remelting and homogenization electrode pressure and the gradient temperature. However, due to the
[22,23]. short contact time of the welding process, a certain number of in-
Different from other methods, the heat input of the RESW process complete bonding areas such as gaps were also found in Fig. 5(c) and
was only the joule heating effect of the adjacent powders, once the (d). Compared with the DSC curve of HEA powder in Fig. 2, the DSC
powders and the matrix combined to form a conductor, the joule curve of HEAc was relatively stable in the temperature range of
heating effect between the powders disappeared. Therefore, the in- 700–1000 K and there was no obvious exothermic peak. An en-
stantaneous joule heating effect between the powders was an important dothermic peak appeared at the end of the curve, which indicated that
factor for the formation ability of the coating. In order to evaluate the the melting point of the HEAc was approximately 1600 K and was
effect of the transient joule heating effect on the bonding temperature closed to that prepared by the vacuum arc melting and casting method
of powders, the principle of the RESW process was simplified as shown (~1635 K) [26]. Therefore, the gradient temperature of the RESW
in Fig. 5(a). It is assumed that all of the heat generated by the joule process finally transformed the nanocrystalline HEA powders into the
heating effect of adjacent powders was converted to an increase in its HEA coating consisted of the BCC and FCC structures. Fig. 6(a) shown
temperature. Therefore, the relationship between joule heating effect the inverse pole figure (IPF) map of the HEA coating, the crystal-
and temperature of powders can be expressed as lographic orientation was distributed disorderly, and the black areas
with an average diameter of 0.12 µm were defects between crystals. In
Is 2Rpowder Δ t= C v mpowder ΔT (1) the phases map of Fig. 6(b), the five phases were homogenously dis-
tributed with an average size of 0.365 µm. According to the XRD and
where Is was the total current passing through the powders, Rpowder was HETEM results of the HEA powder, the average grain size of crystals in
the resistance of powder, and Δt was a quarter of the AC period. Cv, powder was 2.56–2.9 nm. Thus, the RESW process was not greatly in-
mpowder, and ΔT were the heat capacity, the mass and the instantaneous creased the grain size of the phases, and the disorderly small-size grains
temperature of powder, respectively. In the whole circuit, the powders may also be beneficial to improve the hardness of the coating.
and substrate belong to a series circuit. However, the two adjacent As shown in Fig. 7, the average hardness of HEAc was 715HV,
powders in the horizontal direction belong to the parallel circuit as which was much higher than the maximum hardness of the bulk
shown in Fig. 2(a), and the current was set as Ipx. Ipx can be calculated (527HV) [23]. According to the EPMA analysis of the interface between
by Eq. (2): the HEA coating and substrate in Fig. 8. After welding, as shown by the
6
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 12. The SEM image and EDS mappings of the worn surfaces in three conditions. (a), (e), (h) the dry condition, (b), (f), (i) the deionized water condition, and (d),
(g), (j) the 3.5 wt%NaCl solution condition.
7
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 14. The XPS high-resolution analysis of the oxidation films on the worn surface in dry condition. (a) Al2p, (b) Fe2p, (c) Cr2p, (d) Co2p and (e) Ni2p.
was proportional to the hardness, the HEAc had an average hardness of A6061(5.66 × 10−4 mm3 Nm−1). Therefore, compared with A6061,
715 HV, which was almost 10 times higher than A6061. The friction the HEAc possessed good wear-resistance in three conditions. More-
coefficient curves of the HEAc and A6061 in three conditions at a load over, the maximum wear rate of 0.44 × 10−4 mm3 Nm−1 in the cor-
of 8 N were taken as an example in Fig. 10. It was clearly identified that rosive environment was much lower than that in dry condition
the friction coefficient value of A6061 in dry condition was remarkably 1.75 × 10−4 mm3 Nm−1 and in deionized water condition
fluctuated and shown an upward trend with the increasing of time. 0.99 × 10−4 mm3 Nm−1. Consequently, the AlFeCrCoNi HEAc per-
Contrasted to A6061 in dry condition, the curve of HEAc was extremely forms best wear resistance in corrosive environment at 8 N. In sum-
smooth with evidently slight fluctuation, which demonstrated a good mary, the environment significantly influenced the wear performance
wear-resistance after the test for 3 h. Due to the lubricating effect of of AlFeCrCoNi HEAc, and the deionized water and corrosive environ-
water, the friction coefficient curves of A6061 in deionized water and ment reduced the wear rate.
NaCl solution conditions were rose rapidly at first and gradually in- The worn surfaces of HEAc in three conditions with a load of 8 N
creased to the steady-state, and the average friction coefficient values were shown in Fig. 11(a)–(g), large-scaled of cracks and peeling pit
were nearly 2.24 and 1.83 times higher than the HEAc, respectively. As areas (the red dotted areas) in all conditions suggesting the existence of
for the wear rate in Fig. 11(b), the wear rates of HEAc in different severe adhesive wear [27]. Furthermore, the tiny wear debris on the
conditions were much lower than A6061. For example, at a load of 8 N worn surface illustrated that the abrasive wear also occurred. Due to the
in the corrosive environment, the wear rate of HEAc BCC-phase in AlFeCrCoNi HEA was proved to possesses a higher
(0.29 × 10−4 mm3 Nm−1) was about 20 times lower than hardness and the FCC-phase has good plasticity [28,29]. The BCC
8
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
Fig. 15. The XPS high-resolution analysis of the oxidation films on the worn surface in deionized water. (a) Al2p, (b) Fe2p, (c) Cr2p, (d) Co2p.
phases were supposed to bear the main load in the coating during the surface in three conditions. As seen in Fig. 13, the XPS results show that
test, resulting in cracks, while the FCC phase was prone to wrinkle and the metal-oxygen bonds of all the metal elements were detected in dry
may promote the propagation of the crack. Once the hard particles were condition, which indicated that all metal elements were oxidized during
impacted into the coating beyond a critical depth, the cracks initiated the friction. The XPS high-resolution results of the worn surface in dry
and then propagated. Then, the crack-induced peeling area of the condition were shown in Fig. 14. It was clear that the oxidation film
coating was easily damaged and formed the debris particles as shown was composed of a large number of metal oxides such as Al2O3, Fe2O3,
by the black dotted circle area in Fig. 11(e), (f) and (g). The ploughing Cr2O3, Co3O4, etc. In deionized water condition, in addition to nickel,
grooves (the white dotted line) parallel to the sliding direction in other metal elements also oxidized with oxygen offered by the deio-
Fig. 11(f) also indicated a wear mechanism of abrasion. In contrast to nized water. The XPS high-resolution results in Fig. 15 also obviously
the deionized water, a relatively clean morphology and the lower wear demonstrated the peaks of Al2p, Fe2p3/2, Cr2p3/2, Cr2p1/2, and
rate in 3.5 wt% NaCl solution suggested that the friction behavior in the Co2p3/2. In 3.5 wt% NaCl solution condition, under the combined
corrosive environment was not only dependent on the water lubrication action of long-term friction and corrosive environment, the oxides on
but also depended on other factors. In the corrosive condition, Al, Cr, the surface were dissolved or completely disappeared, and no corre-
and Fe had the lower standard electrode potential and were vulnerable sponding peak was found in Fig. 13. In a word, the environment played
to corrosion. Moreover, in the high-entropy alloy, the elements in- an important role in the wear behavior of the AlFeCrCoNi HEAc. The
volved with high activity were favorable to generate passive film. formation of protective metallic passive film improved the wear re-
However, the Cl− in the corrosive environment could attack the passive sistance. The liquid condition had the function of lubrication and heat
films and gradually dissolute the films by the formation of oxide- dissipation. Compared with deionized water conditions, the corrosive
chloride compounds [30]. After three hours of continuous friction test, wear in 3.5 wt% NaCl solution also elevated the wear resistance of the
the oxide-chloride compounds were likely to be completely removed. coating.
The experimental results have shown that the wear rate in this condi-
tion was the lowest. Therefore, corrosive wear has occurred in 3.5 wt%
4. Conclusions
NaCl solution and beneficial to decrease the wear rate of the coating.
The higher oxygen fraction and distribution on the worn surface in
In summary, the continuous AlFeCrCoNi high entropy alloy coating
three conditions, which was confirmed by the EDS detection in Table.2
was rapidly fabricated on aluminum alloy by resistance seam welding
and the EDS elemental mappings in Fig. 12(h)–(j), indicated that the
method. The instantaneous temperature of the joule heating effect
oxidative wear was also one of the wear mechanisms. During the in-
bonded the HEA powders together and the gradient temperature
stability of Al, Cr elements, with a standard electrode potential of
transformed the nanocrystalline AlFeCrCoNi powder into the
−1.662, −0.744 [31], the Al2O3 and Cr2O3 films were suspected to be
AlFeCrCoNi HEA coating consisted of FCC and BCC structures. After
the main passive coatings. Since the high temperature and friction heat
welding, the aluminum elements in the matrix penetrated into the
occurred during the wear test, it was inevitable for the formation of
coating and the other elements were evenly distributed in HEAc.
oxidation films. Moreover, the oxidation films also have a great impact
The average hardness of the AlFeCrCoNi HEAc with a thickness of
on the tribological performance of the coating. Thus, the chemical
420 µm was 715 HV0.2, which was higher than that of the same alloy
bonds in the near-surface region of the worn surface were determined
prepared by other methods. Compared with A6061, the HEAc exhibited
by the XPS test. Fig. 13 were the wide spectra results of the worn
good wear-resistance in three conditions. The wear mechanisms in dry
9
D. Zhao, et al. Applied Surface Science 517 (2020) 145980
condition were mainly oxidation and severe adhesive wear. The abra- [11] J.C. Li, Y.X. Huang, X.C. Meng, Y.M. Xie, Adv. Eng. Mater. 21 (2019) 1–27.
sive and adhesive wear, as well as oxidative wear, have occurred in [12] Y. Feng, K. Feng, C. Yao, Z. Li, J. Sun, Mater. Des. 157 (2018) 258–272.
[13] X. Qiu, J. Alloys Compd. 735 (2018) 359–364.
deionized water. Different to the deionized water, the corrosive wear [14] Q. Ye, K. Feng, Z. Li, F. Lu, R. Li, J. Huang, Y. Wu, Appl. Surf. Sci. 396 (2017)
and adhesive wear in 3.5 wt% NaCl solution brought the lowest wear 1420–1426.
rate to the coating. It is feasible to fabricate the high-performance HEAc [15] Q. Fang, Y. Chen, J. Li, Y. Liu, Y. Liu, Physica B. 550 (2018) 112–116.
[16] S. Calderon Velasco, A. Cavaleiro, S. Carvalho, Prog. Mater. Sci. 84 (2016)
on aluminum alloy thin plate by resistance seam welding. 158–191.
[17] W. Zhang, R. Tang, Z.B. Yang, C.H. Liu, H. Chang, J.J. Yang, J.L. Liao, Y.Y. Yang,
Author contributions N. Liu, J. Nucl. Mater. 512 (2018) 15–24.
[18] F. Cao, P. Munroe, Z. Zhou, Z. Xie, Thin Solid Films 645 (2018) 222–230.
[19] A.D. Pogrebnjak, I.V. Yakushchenko, O.V. Bondar, V.M. Beresnev, K. Oyoshi,
Dechao Zhao: Design, Conduct experiments and Writing. Tomiko O.M. Ivasishin, H. Amekura, Y. Takeda, M. Opielak, C. Kozak, J. Alloys Compd. 679
Yamaguchi: Design, Review & Editing. Jinfeng Shu, and Tsubasa (2016) 155–163.
[20] Y.Q. Jiang, J. Li, Y.F. Juan, Z.J. Lu, W.L. Jia, J. Alloys Compd. 775 (2019) 1–14.
Danjo: Date analysis.
[21] J.B. Cheng, X.B. Liang, Z.H. Wang, B.S. Xu, Plasma. Chem. Plasma. Process. 33
(2013) 979–992.
References [22] Y.F. Kao, T.J. Chen, S.K. Chen, J.W. Yeh, J. Alloys Compd. 488 (2009) 57–64.
[23] W.R. Wang, W.L. Wang, S.C. Wang, Y.C. Tsai, C.H. Lai, J.W. Yeh, Intermetallics. 26
(2012) 44–51.
[1] J.R. Davis, Aluminium and Aluminium Alloys, ASM International, Ohio, 1993. [24] X.Y. Song, X.M. Liu, J.X. Zhang, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 89 (2006) 494–500.
[2] L.F. Mondolfo, Aluminum alloys: structure and properties, Butterworths, Boston, [25] S. Uporov, V. Bykov, S. Pryanichnikov, A. Shubin, N. Uporova, Intermetallics. 83
1976. (2017) 1–8.
[3] H. Mindivan, M. Baydogan, E.S. Kayali, H. Cimenoglu, Mater. Charact. 54 (2005) [26] W.R. Wang, W.L. Wang, J.W. Yeh, J. Alloys Compd. 589 (2014) 143–152.
263–269. [27] Y. Liu, S.G. Ma, M.C. Gao, C. Zhang, T. Zhang, H.J. Yang, Z.H. Wang, J.W. Qiao,
[4] E. Lugscheider, G. Krämer, C. Barimani, H. Zimmermann, Surf. Coat. Technol. 74 Metall. Mater. Tans. A 47 (2016) 3312–3321.
(1995) 497–502. [28] H. Shiratori, T. Fujieda, K. Yamanaka, Y. Koizumi, K. Kuwabara, T. Kato, A. Chiba,
[5] H. Korhonen, A.P. Koistinen, R.J. Lappalainen, Mach. Sci. Technol. 1 (2018) 1–33. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 656 (2016) 39–46.
[6] P.U. Arumugam, A.P. Malshe, S.A. Batzer, Surf. Coat. Technol. 200 (2006) [29] S. Guo, C. Ng, C.T. Liu, J. Alloys Compd. 557 (2013) 77–81.
3399–3403. [30] Y. Wang, S.L. Jiang, Y.G. Zheng, W. Ke, W.H. Sun, J.Q. Wang, Corros. Sci. 63 (2012)
[7] M. Pellizzari, Wear 271 (2011) 2089–2099. 159–173.
[8] M.H. Staia, M. Cruz, N.B. Dahotre, Thin Solid Films. 377 (2000) 665–674. [31] D.J. Yang, Z.S. Shen, Corrosion of Metals, Metallurgical Industry Press, Beijing,
[9] H.C. Man, S. Zhang, T.M. Yue, F.T. Cheng, Surf. Coat. Technol. 148 (2001) 1999.
136–142.
[10] J. Rams, A. Pardo, A. Ureña, et al., Surf. Coat. Technol. 202 (2007) 1199–1203.
10