Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 2 - Synthesis and Processing of PEEK For Su - 2012 - PEEK Biomaterials H
Chapter 2 - Synthesis and Processing of PEEK For Su - 2012 - PEEK Biomaterials H
Figure 2.1 PEEK production facility, Thornton-Cleveleys, United Kingdom. Source: Victrex.
polymers from being synthesized in common organic acid to form PEEK. This route has only remained of
solvents. Early attempts to synthesize PEEK in academic interest due to the extremely high cost and
methylene chloride or nitrobenzene produced only corrosive nature of the solvent used (Scheme 2.2).
low-molecular-weight variants. The electrophilic synthesis of PAEK polymers
Work by DuPont using a combination of anhy- produces materials with reactive end groups such as
drous hydrogen fluoride/boron trifluoride succeeded benzoic acids. Such polymers cannot be processed,
in protonating the carbonyl groups and meant that without endcapping, due to their high thermal
high-molecular-weight polyetherketone (PEK)
became a possibility (Scheme 2.1) [5].
Raychem also reported the synthesis of PAEK O
polymers using similar reaction conditions in the
presence of alkylthiochloroformates. O C Cl
Another electrophilic process exemplified by
Ueda and Oda uses methanesulfonic acid (MSA)/
phosphorus pentoxide (P2O5) at low temperatures
[6]. Although PEEK produced by this method has HF / BF3
O Scheme 2.2
n O O C OH
CF3SO3H
* O O C *
instability. When the reactive end group materials are quantities in the finished polymer. The choice of the
subjected to high-temperature processing, the poly- endcapping agent may therefore significantly alter
mer immediately cross-links, producing gels, which the leachable and biocompatibility profile of the
cannot be shaped into desired articles. Therefore, material.
PEEK production by electrophilic processes as
described earlier has historically had limited 2.2.2 Nucleophilic Routes to PAEK
commercial success.
More recently, a modification to the electrophilic Polymers
process for manufacturing PAEK polymers has been The nucleophilic route to PAEK polymers
described. This again involves the polycondensation provides a straightforward pathway to polymers such
of 4-(40 -phenoxyphenoxybenzoic acid). However, as PEEK. Initial attempts to form high-molecular-
methanesulfonic acid was used as the reaction weight PAEKs from the reaction of a dihalobenzo-
solvent in the absence of phosphorus pentoxide, and phenone and an equivalent bisphenate failed due to
1,40 -diphenoxybenzene was used as an endcapping the polymer product crystallizing from the sulfolane
agent [8]. This route permits the manufacture of solvent (Scheme 2.4).
thermally stable PAEK polymers and has been used Owing to the poor solubility of PEEK, the selec-
in industrial processes (Scheme 2.3). tion of the synthesis solvent is crucial. Suitable
It should be noted that to ensure thermal stability, solvents should be thermally stable and inert to
significant quantities of the endcapping agent are phenoxide species. It became apparent that solvents
used and as a result may be present in significant such as benzophenone or diphenylsulfone could be
O Scheme 2.3
n O O C OH
CH3SO3H
* O O C *
C6H6-O-C6H6
End Capping Agent
O C O
12 PEEK B IOMATERIALS H ANDBOOK
O O
F C F + KO C OK
Sulfolane
* O C *
Scheme 2.4
F C F + HO OH
Diphenylsulfone
K2CO3
* O O C *
Scheme 2.5
used in the synthesis of PAEK polymers [3]. The whereas the crystalline melt transition temperature
inherent instability of bisphenates to oxidation was (Tm) occurs around 343 C.
overcome by the use of hydroquinone and sodium or
potassium carbonate to form the bisphenate in situ.
Very high temperatures (>300 C) are required 2.3 Nomenclature
to reach high molecular masses, the molecular
weight being controlled by a slight excess of di- The literature on PAEK resin is a maze of trade
fluorobenzophenone, leading to fluorine-terminated names and producers, which have changed over the
chains (Scheme 2.5). years, complicating interpretation of reported data
This process was patented in 1977 by ICI and sold for today’s materials. For researchers interested in
under the brand “Victrex PEEK,” and this route deciphering the historical polymer science literature,
provided the majority of PEEK polymer used in we provide here a brief primer on the nomenclature
industrial applications. of PAEK resins used for industrial purposes as well
The establishment of the nucleophilic route to as for biomaterials (Table 2.1). Resin, when used in
PAEK polymers permitted the investigation of this context, refers to the neat, unfilled powder that is
polymer variants by the use of different bisphenols to created by polymerization, whereas grades are typi-
produce PAEK polymers with various properties, as cally characterized by flow characteristics (e.g., for
reported by Attwood et al. [1]. The family of PAEK injection molding or compression molding) or based
polymers grew to contain variants such as PEK, on their filler content (e.g., glass fiber or carbon
PEEK, PEKK, PEKEKK, and so on, with a range of fiber). Because PAEK polymers are converted using
glass transition temperatures (143e160 C) and high standard thermoplastic processing techniques, such
crystalline melt temperatures (335e441 C). As the as injection molding, they are generally available as
dominant member of the PAEK family of polymers, pellets, although powder resin is also available. Stock
PEEK is in its “glassy” state at room temperature, as shapes, such as rods, are also available from
its glass transition temperature occurs about 143 C, producers.
2: S YNTHESIS AND P ROCESSING OF PEEK FOR S URGICAL I MPLANTS 13
Historically, PAEK materials, including PEEK, device masterfiles and manufactured in compliance
have been produced primarily as niche polymers for with Good Manufacturing Practice. In 2001, Victrex
industrial use, because their cost even today is at least established Invibio Biomaterial Solutions to specifi-
two orders of magnitude more expensive than low- cally provide grades of PEEK suitable for long-term
temperature thermoplastics such as polyethylene. implantation. In reviewing the historical PEEK liter-
When ICI launched Victrex PEEK in 1987, the ature, whether for industrial or biomedical applica-
primary application targets were not medical. tions, the reader should keep in mind that polymers
However, Victrex PEEK was used, if not yet sup- from ICI, Victrex, and Invibio were all produced at
ported, for implant applications. The Victrex PEEK the same plant location, although the name of the
business was sold by ICI in 1993, and in 1998, Victrex company has changed since that time. Similarly, the
launched PEEK-OPTIMAÒ for long-term implant- nomenclature for the resin grades has changed over
able applications. The offering of PEEK-OPTIMA time, but the polymerization technology has remained
provided a higher specification product and was fundamentally similar (Table 2.2). Today, PEEK
aimed at addressing the previous failings of PAEK biomaterials are designated by the OPTIMA trade
polymers by offering long-term supply assurance name based on their molecular weight, which governs
agreements in addition to a policy of no change con- their flow properties in the melt (Table 2.2). The same
cerning the main characteristics of polymer proper- range of molecular weight of PEEK polymers was
ties. PEEK-OPTIMA was supported by drug and also previously available from Victrex.
14 PEEK B IOMATERIALS H ANDBOOK
Table 2.2 Contemporary and Historical Nomenclature for Medical Grades of PEEK
(A)
(B)
Figure 2.5 Representative injection molding system for PEEK. Picture supplied with kind permission of Krauss Maffei
Technologies.
2.5.2 Extrusion
Extrusion is a manufacturing process for
producing long stock shapes, such as rods, sheets,
Figure 2.7 Amorphous regions within an injection-
molded part as a result of low mold tool temperatures. and monofilament fibers (Fig. 2.9). PEEK pellets or
Photo courtesy of Invibio. granules are typically the starting, raw material for
extrusion. Similar to injection molding, the pellets
are poured into a hopper that feeds into a heated
mold temperature results in rapid cooling of the part,
screw assembly that melts and pressurizes the molten
with insufficient time for crystallization, as demon-
polymer. The molten, pressurized polymer is then
strated in Fig. 2.7. Additional detailed guidelines
forced through a heated die and slowly cools to room
for injection molding and mold design for PEEK
temperature along an extrusion line.
implants can be obtained from raw material
The extrusion of PEEK can be accomplished
suppliers [10].
using conventional extrusion equipment and dies at
It is possible to increase crystallinity by annealing
similar temperatures as those described for injection
amorphous or low-crystallinity PEEK moldings
molding. The drive motor typically requires a power
(Fig. 2.8). However, the process of crystallization
output of 0.25 HP/kg h. This power requirement
may lead to distortion and dimensional changes.
is similar to that required for polycarbonate,
poly(ethersulfone) (PES), or high-molecular-weight
polyolefins.
PEEK is a very stable polymer and as such is not
sensitive to prolonged exposure (up to 2 h) to
temperatures above its melting point. However, for
optimal results, residence times should be of the
order of 5e10 min. Dead spots, areas of material
hold within the barrel, should be avoided. Therefore,
careful design of the screw and barrel is necessary.
The extrusion of PEEK-OPTIMA stock shapes
followed by machining remains the predominant
method of manufacturing medical device compo-
nents. PEEK-OPTIMA can be purchased in rod or
plate form ranging from 6 to 150 mm in diameter for
rod and 40 mm in plate thickness (Fig. 2.10). In
addition to this, thin-walled implantable PEEK
Figure 2.8 Effect of annealing after processing on
tubing is also available from commercial suppliers.
injection-molded test specimens. The amorphous
sample was created by heating to 400 C and then The thermal processes involved in extrusion and
immersed in liquid nitrogen. Image courtesy of David annealing of stock shapes also result in slight
Jaekel, Drexel University. mechanical property variances when compared with
2: S YNTHESIS AND P ROCESSING OF PEEK FOR S URGICAL I MPLANTS 19
Figure 2.9 PEEK polymer extruder. Photo kindly supplied by Coperion GmbH, Stuttgart.
Figure 2.11 Graphical representation of the differences between injection-molded and machined PEEK components.
Source: Invibio.
2.6 Machining
Table 2.4 Properties of a 0.5-mm PEEK
Monofilament Often for prototype designs or short production
runs, it is not economically viable to manufacture an
Typical
injection molding tool. Under such circumstances, it
Material Property Value
is common to use compression molding or to
machine PEEK-OPTIMA polymer materials to form
Energy to break 1.24 J
components. PEEK-OPTIMA polymer may be
Tensile load at 2% elongation 1.18 kg machined and finished using the same techniques
Tensile load at 5% elongation 1.77 kg and equipment as for other engineering thermo-
plastics. However, because of the excellent physical
Tensile load at 10% elongation 2.66 kg properties and wear characteristics of these mate-
Tensile load at break 5.81 kg rials, it is advisable to use carbide or diamond tipped
tools and bits. Machining and finishing operations
Elongation at break 22.0%
on polymeric materials are prone to propagating
Knot strength 2.42 kg molded-in or residual stresses. Before machining, it
is recommended that components formed from
PEEK are annealed to relieve stress. During
of fully amorphous PEEK films becomes more machining or finishing, further stresses may be built
challenging. up within the material by localized heating at the
PEEK monofilament can be produced by extrusion cutting point. Therefore, if a large amount of
followed by drawing of the PEEK extrudate. machining and finishing is to be carried out on
Drawing the polymer provides orientation within the a component, a second annealing procedure may be
fiber prior to heat setting. The resultant monofilament required.
is tough, highly oriented, and has a controlled The thermal conductivity of all polymeric mate-
diameter, which will retain its set form above the rials is lower than that of metals; hence, heat build-up
glass transition temperature of the material. Typical during machining is rapid. It is advisable that
properties of a PEEK monofilament are shown in a cooling fluid is used to remove some of the heat
Table 2.4. PEEK monofilaments are distributed as generated by working the material. Water or air jet
multifilament yarns (Fig. 2.13) and can be woven into cooling is generally recommended for medical grade
more complex three-dimensional shapes. PEEK polymer-based materials. A summary of the
suggested machining conditions for PEEK-OPTIMA
has been provided by Invibio [10].
2.7 Summary
As detailed in this chapter, there are various
synthetic routes involved in the production of
polyketone-based materials. These routes have been
developed to overcome the initial challenges in
relation to polyketone manufacturing, resulting in the
consistent production of polymers for medical
applications. It should be noted that the synthetic
chemistry used in PAEK manufacture has a major
influence on the thermal stability of the polymer in
processing operations and on the leachable and
volatile content of these polymers. Therefore, the
manufacturing route has the potential to alter the
biocompatibility of PAEK materials. The progress in
Figure 2.13 Spool of technical grade, multifilament manufacturing has been extended to processing
PEEK yarn. where established methods have been developed to
22 PEEK B IOMATERIALS H ANDBOOK