Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Natural Honey and Black Radish Juice As Tin Corrosion Inhibitors
Natural Honey and Black Radish Juice As Tin Corrosion Inhibitors
Natural Honey and Black Radish Juice As Tin Corrosion Inhibitors
com
Abstract
The influence of natural honey (chestnut and acacia) and natural honey with black radish juice, on corrosion of tin in aqueous and
sodium chloride solutions was studied using weight loss and polarization techniques. The inhibition efficiency of acacia honey was lower
than that of chestnut honey, while the addition of black radish juice increased the inhibition efficiency of both honey varieties. The pro-
cess of inhibition was attributed to the formation of multilayer adsorbed film on the tin surface. The adsorption of natural honey and
honey with black radish on tin was found to follow the Langmuir adsorption isotherm.
Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0010-938X/$ - see front matter Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.corsci.2008.01.013
I. Radojčić et al. / Corrosion Science 50 (2008) 1498–1504 1499
character, some vitamins and a few minor compounds. It is tin, and methylthiobutenyl glucosinolate as the predomi-
considered as part of traditional medicine being effective in nant one [16]. The honey solutions were prepared in
gastrointestinal disorders, in healing of wounds and burns, concentrations 200, 400, 600, 800, and 1000 ppm by dissolv-
and as an antimicrobial agent [11]. Black radish (Raphanus ing 20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 mg of honey in 100 g of water or
sativus L. var. niger) is a root plant belonging to Cruciferae 3% NaCl solution, respectively. The black radish juice,
family. It contains a mixture of various inorganic and obtained by squeezing black radish root, was mixed with
organic compounds (minerals, lipids, proteins, carbohy- honey in equal quantities (1:1; w/w). After 24 h 20, 40, 60,
drates, dietary fibres and vitamins) as well as polyphenols 80 and 100 mg of this mixture was dissolved in 100 g of
and sulphur containing organic compounds such as gluco- water or 3% NaCl solution, respectively, to prepare solu-
sinolates, having different biological properties (anticancer, tions in concentrations 200, 400, 600, 800, and 1000 ppm.
antimicrobial and antiviral) [12].
3. Results and discussion
2. Experimental method
The mean values of pH and ion conductivity of all solu-
Before the weight loss measurements, the tin samples tions under examination (aqueous and sodium chloride
were polished using emery paper with different grits, fol- honey solutions without and with the addition of black
lowed by washing in ethanol and double distilled water. radish juice) are given in Table 1.
Potentiostatic polarization studies were carried out The pH values of both honey varieties (acacia and chest-
using EG&G model 173 Potentiostat/Galvanostat. Electro- nut) aqueous solutions are lower than that obtained for the
chemical measurements were conducted in a conventional same solutions with black radish juice added. The same
three-electrode electrolytic cell, capacity 150 mL, with relations are evident for honey sodium chloride solutions
99.95% tin rod working electrode, a platinum counter elec- with pH values being higher. Also, the higher pH values
trode, and a saturated calomel electrode as the reference were obtained for acacia honey in aqueous as well as
one. The tin electrode was isolated with polyethylene, hav- sodium chloride solutions in comparison with those
ing a free surface area of 0.56 cm2. For electrochemical obtained for chestnut honey.
measurements the exposed surface was ground with abra- The ion conductivity of both honey varieties in aqueous
sive paper up to 600 grit, degreased with ethyl alcohol, solutions is lower than in those with black radish juice
and rinsed by redistilled water. To avoid the influence of added, while the ion conductivity in sodium chloride solu-
oxygen, during electrochemical measurements, the electro- tions in all combinations (acacia honey without and with
lyte was thoroughly deaerated with nitrogen at 25 ± 0.1 °C addition of black radish juice, as well as chestnut honey
for 30 min. without and with addition of black radish juice) is higher,
The pH and conductivity values were determined with being in the range of the values obtained for 3% NaCl solu-
EA 940 ‘‘ORION” Expandable Analyser, electrode model tion alone.
91-02 and LF 320/SET, respectively. The values of tin corrosion rate (w), surface coverage
Two monofloral honey types used in experiments and (H), and inhibition efficiency (IE) obtained by weight loss
obtained from the local market were: dark-coloured chest- measurements for 3% NaCl solutions with acacia and
nut and light-coloured acacia honey, collected during chestnut honey in the absence and presence of black radish
2003 in Slavonia (the eastern part of Croatia). The analysis juice are given in Table 2.
of polyphenols in these two honey samples was carried out The corrosion rate of tin was determined by using the
by RP-HPLC. Total content of flavonoids in acacia honey relation:
was 286.0 lg/100 g, and in chestnut honey 231.0 lg/100 g,
respectively [13]. Both honey samples have similar flavonoid w ¼ Dm=St
profile (quercetin, luteolin, kaempferol, apigenin, chrysin where Dm is the mass loss, S is the area and t is the immer-
and galangin) with one difference. Namely, flavonoid sion period.
myricetin was found in chestnut honey in significant quan- The inspection of Table 2 reveals that tin corrosion rates
tities, while in acacia honey samples myricetin was not pres- decrease following an increase of the acacia and chestnut
ent at all [14]. Black radish (Raphanus sativus L. var. niger), honey concentrations. The same correlation is evident in
a cruciferous plant rich in polyphenols and glucosinolates solutions with black radish juice added.
(sulphur-containing compounds) was of Croatian domestic The degree of surface coverage (H), which represents the
production. The total polyphenol content of the juice from fraction of the metal surface covered by inhibitor mole-
squeezed black radish root was determined by the Folin– cules, was calculated using the following equation:
Ciocalteu method described in AOAC [15]. In 100 g of
H ¼ 1 w=w0
black radish juice the total polyphenol content was
37.5 mg, with quercetin as the predominant compound. where w and w0 are the corrosion rates of tin in solutions
The total glucosinolate content was determined by HPLC with and without inhibitor, respectively, while the percent-
method being 22.5 mg, with minor quantities of progoitrin, age inhibition efficiency (IE) was obtained by multiplying
4-hydroxyglucobrassicin, glucobrassicin, and gluconastur- H with 100.
1500 I. Radojčić et al. / Corrosion Science 50 (2008) 1498–1504
Table 1
The pH and ion conductivity values of aqueous and sodium chloride solutions of chestnut and acacia honey alone and with addition of black radish juice
(Raphanus sativus L. var. niger) measured at (20.5 ± 0.4) °C
Solution choney pH Ion Solution choney pH Ion
(ppm) conductivity (ppm) conductivity
(j/mS cm1) (j/mS cm1)
Aqueous solutions of chestnut honey 200 4.19 21.60 103 3% NaCl – 5.25 41.10
(CHaq) 200 4.95 41.70
400 4.25 32.75 103 3% NaCl solutions of chestnut honey 400 5.05 40.70
600 5.08 27.00 103 (CHNaCl) 600 5.33 40.15
800 5.13 11.50 103 800 5.30 40.95
1000 5.30 11.40 103 1000 5.38 41.00
Aqueous solutions of chestnut honey 200 4.23 22.30 103 3% NaCl solutions of chestnut honey 200 5.01 40.08
with addition of black radish juice 400 4.28 32.65 103 with addition of black radish juice 400 5.02 41.02
(CHBRaq) 600 4.92 27.51 103 (CHBRNaCl) 600 5.31 40.08
800 4.90 13.60 103 800 5.29 41.12
1000 5.25 12.85 103 1000 5.40 41.05
Aqueous solutions of acacia honey 200 5.60 29.70 103 200 5.68 40.60
(AHaq) 400 5.20 25.50 103 3% NaCl solutions of acacia honey 400 5.90 41.20
600 5.19 21.7 103 (AHNaCl) 600 5.70 41.10
800 5.52 28.30 103 800 6.15 40.70
1000 5.45 24.40 103 1000 6.20 40.90
Aqueous solutions of acacia honey 200 5.62 30.01 103 3% NaCl solutions of acacia honey with 200 5.63 41.02
with addition of black radish juice 400 5.23 26.70 103 addition of black radish juice (AHBRNaCl) 400 42.05 42.05
(AHBRaq) 600 5.21 22.90 103 600 5.75 42.30
800 5.60 29.10 103 800 6.12 41.80
1000 5.48 25.80 103 1000 6.08 41.05
0.0025 0.0025
AHaq
CHaq 200 ppm
AHBRaq
CHaq 1000 ppm 0.002 AHNaCl
w /g cm-2 h-1
0.002 AHaq 200 ppm AHBRNaCl
3% NaCl
AHaq 1000 ppm 0.0015
w/g cm-2 h-1
0.0015
0.001
0.001 0.0005
0
0.0005 0 200 400 600 800 1000
c / ppm
0.0015
0.001
0.0005
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000
c / ppm
Table 3
Corrosion parameters obtained by the Tafel-extrapolation for tin in 3% NaCl without and with the addition of inhibitors at different concentrations at
(20.5 ± 0.4) °C
Potentiostatic polarization method
Solution choney ba bc Ecorr icorr H IE
(ppm) (mV/d) (mV/d) (mV) (mA cm2) (%)
3% NaCl – 49 108 320 1.75 103 –
3
3% NaCl solutions of chestnut honey (CHNaCl) 200 48 102 380 1.09 10 0.38 38
400 69 211 381 0.89 103 0.49 49
600 68 307 378 0.77 103 0.56 56
800 69 199 345 0.58 103 0.67 67
1000 48 114 383 0.26 103 0.85 85
3% NaCl solutions of chestnut honey with addition of black radish juice (CHBRNaCl) 200 68 191 371 1.05 103 0.40 40
400 71 164 368 0.86 103 0.51 51
600 66 168 372 0.54 103 0.69 69
800 32 33 383 0.47 103 0.73 73
1000 31 250 397 0.18 103 0.90 90
3% NaCl solutions of acacia honey (AHNaCl) 200 67 201 283 1.03 103 0.41 41
400 43 95 280 0.84 103 0.52 52
600 41 54 281 0.75 103 0.57 57
800 44 58 265 0.46 103 0.74 74
1000 31 32 273 0.39 103 0.78 78
3% NaCl solutions of acacia honey with addition of black radish juice (AHBRNaCl) 200 42 43 282 0.98 103 0.44 44
400 46 45 283 0.74 103 0.58 58
600 67 240 267 0.70 103 0.60 60
800 31 131 268 0.37 103 0.79 79
1000 37 104 273 0.23 103 0.87 87
600
added. This is the consequence of the fact that honey and
black radish juice are multicomponent systems, consisting 400 CHNaCl
CHBRNaCl
of various compounds able to form protective layer on 200
tin surface, interact mutually or with protective layer. 0
The H values obtained by corrosion rate and corrosion 0 200 400 600 800 1000
current data fit into the Langmuir isotherm, and are related c / ppm
to the equilibrium constant K and c via equation Fig. 5. The relationship between c/H and concentrations of chestnut
honey alone (CHNaCl) and with addition of black radish juice (CHBRNaCl)
K c ¼ H=ð1 HÞ in 3% NaCl solutions.
600
K ¼ 1=55:5 expðDG0ads =RT Þ 400
AHNaCl
AHBRNaCl
200
where R is universal gas constant, and the value 55.5 is the 0
concentration of water in the solution, expressed in moles 0 200 400 600 800 1000
per dm3. c / ppm
The values of adsorption constants (K), and Gibbs free Fig. 6. The relationship between c/H and concentrations of acacia honey
energy (DG0ads ), calculated on the basis of H values (Table alone (AHNaCl) and with addition of black radish juice (AHBRNaCl) in 3%
2 and 3) for 3% NaCl solutions of acacia and chestnut NaCl solutions.
I. Radojčić et al. / Corrosion Science 50 (2008) 1498–1504 1503
Table 4
The values of adsorption constant (K) and the adsorption Gibbs free energy changes (DG0ads ) for 3% NaCl solutions of chestnut and acacia honey alone and
with addition of black radish juice (Raphanus sativus L. var. niger) at 25 °C
Inhibitors c (ppm) Obtained from corrosion rate Obtained from corrosion current
K 103 (dm3) DG0ads (kJ mol1) K 103 (dm3) DG0ads (kJ mol1)
Chestnut honey (CHNaCl) 200
400
600 2.51 19.13 ± 0.01 3.18 19.70 ± 0.02
800
1000
Chestnut honey with black radish juice (CHBR NaCl) 200
400
600 9.52 22.38 ± 0.01 4.37 21.18 ± 0.11
800
1000
Acacia honey (AHNaCl) 200
400
600 4.55 19.10 ± 0.02 5.21 20.01 ± 0.12
800
1000
Acacia honey with radish juice (AHBRNaCl) 200
400
600 6.67 21.50 ± 0.01 5.18 20.28 ± 0.01
800
1000
honey without and with black radish juice added are listed The corrosion inhibition of tin in 3% NaCl solutions of
in Table 4. both honey varieties in the absence and presence of
Table 4 shows the thermodynamic data obtained from black radish juice takes place via adsorption on the tin
the Langmuir adsorption isotherm for both honey varieties surface following Langmuir adsorption isotherm.
without and with addition of black radish juice. The stan-
dard free energy of adsorption calculated from the surface Acknowledgement
coverage values, obtained on the basis of corrosion rate,
vary in the range of 19.10 ± 0.02 to 21.50 ± 0.02 kJ/ The financial support of the Ministry of Science, Tech-
mol for acacia honey and acacia honey with black radish nology and Sport of Republic of Croatia (Grant No.
juice added, and from 19.13 ± 0.01 to 22.38 ± 0.01 058-0582261-2256) is gratefully acknowledged.
kJ/mol for chestnut honey without and with black radish
juice added, respectively. References
The data for DG0ads support a physisorption based mech-
anism for corrosion inhibition by compounds present in [1] I.L. Rozenfeld, Corrosion Inhibitors, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1981.
honey and honey with black radish juice. [2] E. Kunze, Korrosion und Korrosionschutz, vol. 6, Wiley-VCH,
Weinheim, 2001.
[3] I. Esih, Z. Dugi, Technology of Corrosion Protection, Školska knjiga,
4. Conclusions Zagreb, 1990.
[4] E. Stupnišek-Lisac, K. Berković-Salajster, J. Vorkapić-Furač, An
investigation of the efficiency of several organic descaling inhibitors,
The following conclusions can be made on the basis of Corros. Sci. 28 (1988) 1189–1202.
the results obtained: [5] A.Y. El-Etre, Natural honey as corrosion inhibitor for metals and
alloys. I. copper in neutral aqueous solution, Corros. Sci. 40 (1998)
Natural honey (chestnut and acacia) in 3% NaCl solu- 1845–1850.
tion as well as their solutions with black radish juice [6] A.Y. El-Etre, M. Abdallah, Natural honey as corrosion inhibitor for
metals and alloys. II. C-steel in high saline water, Corros. Sci. 42
added act as corrosion inhibitors of tin. (2000) 731–738.
The inhibition efficiency (IE) of all the inhibitors exam- [7] Y.J. Yee, Green Inhibitors for Corrosion Control: A Study on the
ined obtained by both methods used decrease in the Inhibitive Effects of Extracts of Honey and Rosmarinus Officinalis L.
order: chestnut honey with black radish juice > acacia (Rosemary), Thesis, University of Manchester Institute of Science
honey with black radish juice > chestnut honey > acacia and Technology, 2004.
[8] I. Radojčić, K. Berković, K. Kovačević, K. Delonga, J. Vork-
honey. apić-Furač, Inhibition efficiency of cabbage glucosinolates extracts
The inhibition efficiency of honey and honey with black on tin corrosion, in: Proceedings of Euro Food Chem XII
radish juice increase with the increase of their (Strategies of safe food) Brugge, vol. 1, Belgium, FECS Event
concentrations. 279, 2003, pp. 300–304.
1504 I. Radojčić et al. / Corrosion Science 50 (2008) 1498–1504
[9] K. Berković, I. Radojčić, K. Delonga, J. Vorkapić-Furač, Polyphe- [13] D. Kenjerić, Determination of Botanical Origin of Selected Types of
nols – Environmentally Friendly Corrosion Inhibitors of Tin, Current Unifloral Honey on the Basis of Their Flavonoid Profile Obtained
Studies of Biotechnology, vol. III, Food, Zagreb, Croatia, 2003, pp. Using RP-HPLC Method, Thesis, Faculty of Food Technology and
365–372. Biotechnology, University of Zagreb, 2004.
[10] K. Berković, S. Kovač, K. Delonga, J. Vorkapić-Furač, Effect of [14] D. Kenjerić, M.L. Mandić, Lj. Primorac, D. Bubalo, A. Perl,
quercetin on the aluminium corrosion process, Acta Alliment. 33 Flavonoid profile of Robinia honeys produced in Croatia, Food
(2004) 237–247. Chem. 102 (2007) 683–690.
[11] S. Bogdanov, Nature and origin of the antibacterial substances in [15] AOAC, Official Methods of Analysis, 15th ed., Arlington, USA,
honey, Lebensm. Wiss. Technol. 30 (1997) 748–753. 952.03/A-C, 1990, p. 703.
[12] A. Lugasi, E. Dworschák, A. Blázovics, Á. Kéry, Antioxidant and [16] K. Delonga, Thioglucosides Glucosinolates in Cruciferae Family
free radical scavenging properties of squeezed juice from black radish Vegetables, Natural Source Of Biologically Active Compounds,
(Raphanus sativus L. var. niger) root, Phytother. Res. 12 (1998) 502– Thesis, Faculty of Food Technology and Biotechnology, University
506. of Zagreb, 2001.