Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Bstra: On The Assessment of Harmonic Pollution
A Bstra: On The Assessment of Harmonic Pollution
A BSTRA CT
This paper analyzes the interactions between the incre- is the bus impedence matrix. For a network with N buses (1)
mental changes of current harmonic phasors injected by a is detailed in the expanded form (41:
N L (nonlinear load) and the resulting variations of har-
monic voltages and powers. It proves that it is not always V1 I1
possible following simple measurements of individual har- v 2 12
monic powers to decide i j a certain harmonic current is
harmful or useful. It is suggested to evaluate the N L “dis-
V n In
tortion” with the help of a quantity called Non-6OHz (Non-
fundamental) Apparent Power.
Keywords: Harmonics, Definitions of Powers V N IN
h h
INTRODUCTION
The harmonic voltage V l l h at bus n. is
There is wide acceptance of the thought that quantification
and measurement of consumer produced voltage and current Vnh = Vnuh + ZnnhInh
There is a need to recover a fee from the consumer, that “will Vnuh = ZnihIih
t=n
pay for alleviation of problems, or to encourage the consumer”
and indirectly equipment manufacturers, “to take appropriate Equation (1)shows that a harmonic voltage at a certain bus
steps to reduce distortion charges”[3]. The engineering liter- has two components; the first term is “Background Harmonic
ature is rich in papers that allude to the need for monitor- Voltage” or the Thevenin voltage caused by the contributions
ing the harmonic power generated by NLs and apply a billing of all other sources of harmonics. The second component is due
method based on tariff adjustment. The application of con- to the harmonic current injected at the observed bus.
cepts similar to low power factor penalties, VA demand, are The effect of injecting the harmonic current Inh at bus n on
frequently discussed at recent IEEE working group meetings. the harmonic voltage V , h at bus m is quantified by
As “Retail Wheeling”(Deregulati0n) becomes imminent, and as
projections for current and voltage distortions predict a steady v m h =Vmnh f ZmnhInh (3)
increase, it becomes critical for the engineering community to
focus on finding a viable, expedient method of monitoring con- where
sumer produced harmonic pollution. N
The goal of this paper is to stimulate discussions and much Vmnh = ZmihIih
i=n
needed research on this topic.
Equation (3) is similar to (2) and lends itself to the same
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND kind of conclusions. To evaluate the incremental effect of har-
monic current injection at a bus n one has to calculate the
A power network with nonlinear loads (NLs) can be ana- sensitivities of the harmonic voltage Vmnh to the incremental
lyzed by modeling every NL with the help of an array of equiva- variations of the phasor
lent harmonic current sources, and solving the linear equations.
Inh = InhLenh
- -
ph=o I \
v
w
0 1 0
00 4 L
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 V
ANGLE @EC)
Fig. 3 Normalized Current vs. Angle p = 8 a. The + . Ri /(RI + Ri)= LI/(LI + b)s 0.9
Geometric Loci x/vM= 1 and Ph = 0. -
02
0-9
marked points). o o - " " ' ' " " " " " " ~ ' " "
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360
This means that the voltage harmonic can be reduced even PHASE ANGLE B(DEG\
60
when harmonic power is generated. To illustrate this fact in
more detail it is necessary to compare the geometric loci ,-. 48
11. Harmonic Active Power "Generated By Fig. 4 Power System with Two NLs
Two Different NLs"
(a) Equivalent Circuit
This example is meant to shed light on the case when two
major NLs are connected at different buses. Figure 4a shows (b) Harmonic Voltages
the h-order harmonic equivalent circuit of a feeder supplying
(c) Harmonic Powers
two NLs. The phase angle of the phasor harmonic current I l l @
is varied. The phasor IzLO' is kept constant and the magnitude readily understood with the help of the phasor diagrams pro-
of the harmonic voltages, VI,5,as well as the power generated posed by M. Depenbrock [lo]. Figure 5a gives the basic case,
by the current sources 11 and I2 are monitored. The purpose when I2 = 0 (no NL is connected at bus 2) and PI > 0, i.e.
of this test is to check if measurements of harmonic voltage harmonic power is generated. The two cases described in Figs.
and current phasors are sufficient for the purpose of revealing 5b,c backup the observation collected from Figs. 4b,c. The
the nature of the NL. Typical curves are shown in Fig. 4b most fascinating case is described in Fig. 5d; where 8 has the
and 4c. Increasing the phase angle 8 from 0 to 360" is causing critical value that yields P2 = 0, while I2 remains a contributor
the harmonic voltages to decrease and increase back, while the to the magnitudes of I , V2 and V,. It becomes clear from here
Harmonic Active Power ph enters the node 2 for 20" < 8 < 175" that the simple reading of the harmonic phasors Vz and I at
and for the rest of the range is generated. A most interesting the PCC (point of common coupling) will not reveal enough
observation follows: information on the nature of the NLs connected at PCC.
If the angle 8 is shifted from 8 = 8, to 8 = -eo, the voltage Even the separate measurements of V 2 , I z and V I I1 , are
magnitudes remain practically unchanged while the sign of the not conclusive unless analyzed together. Comparing Fig. 5b
active harmonic powers is reversed. Using the notations shown and Fig. 5c one sees that the source I1 sinks harmonic power
in Fig. 4a, P2 is changing from sinking power to generating pow- in one case and generates in the next. For both cases, however,
er if 20" < 8" < 172". The reverse holds true for the power PI. the overall effect of I1 on the network is the same.
An identical observation is made if 8 is shifted from 8 = 180"- E
to 180" + e . This result proves that in spite of the fact that the 111. Network With Series Resonance
phasor I2 remains unchanged the harmonic voltage V2 is varied
by harmonic currents injected at other buses. A special case A hypothetical circuit, Fig. 6a, was chosen to describe an-
occurs when the harmonic power P2 = 0, (for this particular other important situation when the harmonic cancellation at
situation 0 = 20" or 172", Fig. 4b). We should not conclude one bus may cause the impairment of equipment at a remote
that Pz = 0 means that the NL at bus 2 does not polute the bus. The harmonic current source I1 is kept constant, assumed
network. Even in this case the current 1 2 adds phasorically to 11 1 pu, and taken as reference. The magnitude of harmonic cur-
augmenting the line current, and causes more electromagnetic rent source I 2 = 12L170" is varied from 0 to 1.4 pu, Fig. 6b.
interference and voltage distortion. These observations can be As I2 increased from 0 to 0.98 pu, the harmonic voltage
1696
I,:
Fig. 5 Phasor Diagrams for Fig. 4
(c)
(d) I2
> 0; 0 > 0";
> 0; e < 00;
P2 < 0; PI > 0
P~> 0; P~< o
> 0; 0 > ;'0 Pz = 0; PI > O
I
9
260
240
220
200
... ..... . . .... . . . ... . . . ..... . . ..... . . ... .
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .
...........................
. .. .:.. .
.. .:. ??.
. .V .? .N F
.;p
~ ...... .:.
U
. . .. . . . ... . . ... . . ... . . ... . . . .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . .. . . . .. . . . ..
v
2 180 ...........
..........
2 160
6140 .. .. .
z120 .....
. .. . . _..:
. . .
............
f 100 . .
0 ..... ~.
.
80 .._ . .
2 60 .,.. ....
I, = l0OLO0pu I 40
. . .
.
.
.
.... i
.
...I...
.
.
.j_.
.
.!...I
.
.
.
.
. . . .;. . . j . .
. .
.
.
. .
.;. . i . . . j . . .I_
. .
.:,.
m'
:.... j
.
20 t .
. I
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O t ' " " " ' ~ : ~ ~ ' : I
140
I30
120
1 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
PHASEANGLE 0 (DEG)
70 80 90
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100110120130140
HARMONIC CURRENT1i:PU)
The four examples presented above provide some insight on
Fig. 6 Network with Series Resonance the peculiarities of harmonic flow. The main conclusions that
should be considered for the purpose of "distortion measure-
(a) h-Harmonic Equivalent Circuit ment" are:
(b) Harmonic voltages vs. Harmonic Current I2 0 The injected harmonic current phasor at a given bus can-
not be labeled good or bad based on its phase angle with
Vz drops linearly from 1 pu to 0 while the voltage VIincrease respect to the bus harmonic voltage, hence the measure-
at the same rate. The explanation for this behavior is tied to ment of the Active and Reactive Harmonic Power for each
the series resonance between L,,C,.Such situations cannot be harmonic order separately is not always a reliable method
excluded among actual applications. of judging how offending is one NL or a cluster of NLs.
1697
h R 2: + &/@c
\/~SM/QC (16)
or where
sN/sI= J ( I T H D ) ~+ ( V T H D ) +~ ( I T H D . V T H D ) ~(13) SM = Total kVA of the rotating equipment
QC = Total kVar of capacitances
This equation shows that S N is a function of the current and ST = Input transformer rated kVA
voltage distortion. The importance of this expression becomes K. = Input transformer p.u. short circuit impedance
evident when the approximation A family of graphs that allow the evaluation of harmonic
1698
frequency are shown in Fig. 8c. The transformer short (91 A.E. Emanuel, “Powers in Nonsinusoidal Situations a Re-
circuit impedance is the key parameter that can be used view of Definitions and Physical Meaning”, IEEE Trans.
to shift the resonance point. A typical frequency response on Power Delivery, Vol. 5, No. 3, July 1990, pp. 1377-89.
of the circuit is presented in Fig. 8b. These preliminary [lo] M. Depenbrock, “Private Communication”, Second In-
results demonstrate that if ITHD, 5 10% to 20% linear ternational Workshop on Power Distortion and Mea-
loads may be exempted of distortion penality figured by surements Under Nonsinusoidal Conditions, Stressa, Italy,
means of SN. Sept. 8-10, 1993.
[ll]A. Zahedi, J.A. Orr, A.E. Emanuel, D.J. Pileggi, T.J.
CONCLUSIONS Gentile, “Comparative Harmonic Flow Studies Using Cur-
The examples presented prove that simple measurements of rent Harmonic Injection Method”, ICHPS VI, Bologna,
the harmonic power or harmonic voltage and current phasors a t Italy, Sept. 1994, pp. 311-17.
the bus of a NL or at the PCC, cannot always reveal the overall
effect of the NL on the Power Quality of the network. It is pos-
sible to determine if the harmonics generated by the particular
consumer are useful or not, by means of synchronized multiple
pL ; cose = 1.0
measurements taken at strategically located nodes. Such mea-
surements would be processed at automatic monitoring centers
where, based on agreed economical criteria, it will be decid- (a) Equivalent Circuit
ed when and by how much to penalize or discount. Such so-
phisticated systems are not yet actual. Instead it is suggest-
ed that harmonic distortion be measured using the Non-6OHz
Power as the quantity that reflects the degree of distortion as
10.
REFERENCES
J.D. vanWyk, “Power Quality, Power Electronics and Pow-
er Control”, 5th European Conference on Power Electron-
ics and Applications (EPE’93), Sept. 1993, Brighton, UK.
A.J. Berrisford, “Should a Utility Meter Harmonics?”,
Proc. of IEE, 7th International Conference on Metering
26
Aparatus and Tariffs for Electricity Supply, Nov. 1992,
24
Glmkow, UK, IEE Cod. Publ. NO. 367, pp. 86-89. 22
P.H. Swart, M.J. Case, J.D. vanWyk, “On the Techniques 70
for Localization of Sources Producing Distortion in Elec- 618
tric Power Networks”, Second International Workshop on
3 4
Power Definitions and Measurements Under Nonsinu- 512
soidal Conditions, Stressa, Italy, Sept. 8, 1993, pp. 510
187-90. 9 8
J. Arrillaga, D.A. Bradley, P.S. Bodger, Power Systems 6
I
Harmonics, J . Wiley, 1985, p. 269.
D.P. Hartmann, “Harmonic Measurement Techniques”,
01 02 03 0 4 05 06 07 08
Power System Harmonics, IEEE Tutorial Course No. 84 NORMALIZED CAPACITANCE vsr Q&u
EH 0221-2-PWP, pp. 12830.
IEEE Recommended Practices and Requirements for Har-
monic Control in Electrical Power Systems. IEEE Std.
519-1992, p. 28. Fig. 8 Linear Loads Supplied with Nonsinusoidal
E.W. Gunther, “Novel Instrumentation for Monitoring Volt age
Power Flow in Non-Sinusoidal Situations”, IEEE Tuto-
rial Course No. 90 EH 0327-7-PWP, Nonsinusoidal Alexander E. Emanuel (SM’71) received the BSc., MSc. and DSc.
Situations Effects on the Performance of Meters and Def- degrees in Electrical Engineering from Technion-Israel Institute of Technol-
ogy, Haifa, Israel in 1963, ’65 and ’69. Ftom 1963 to 1969 he was on the
initions of Power, pp. 51-55. s t d of the Electrical Engineering Department at Technion-Israel Institute
T.H. Ortmeyer, N. Kakimoto, T. Hiyama, A. Hammam, of Technology, first as a Teaching Assistant and later as a Lecturer. Ftom
“Harmonic Performance of Individual and Grouped 1969 to 1974 he worked for the High Voltage Power Corporation as Senior
Loads”, Proceedings of Third International Conference on Research and Development Engineer. In 1974 he joined Worcester Polytech-
nic Institute, Worcester, MA. Presently he holds the rank of Professor and
Harmonics in Power Systems, Sept. 1988, Nashville, In- acts BS a consultant to local industry.
diana, pp. 277-83.