2015 - Gaspard - Aerosol Sampling Using An Electrostatic Precipitator Integrated With A Microfluidic Interface - Paper

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/snb

Aerosol sampling using an electrostatic precipitator integrated with a


microfluidic interface
Gaspard Pardon 1 , Laila Ladhani 1 , Niklas Sandström, Maxime Ettori, Gleb Lobov,
Wouter van der Wijngaart ∗
Micro and Nanosystems, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Osquldas väg 10, 100 44 Stockholm, Sweden

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: In this work, the development of a point-of-care (PoC) system to capture aerosol from litres of air directly
Received 28 August 2014 onto a microfluidic lab-on-chip for subsequent analysis is addressed. The system involves an electrostatic
Received in revised form 26 January 2015 precipitator that uses corona charging and electrophoretic transport to capture aerosol droplets onto a
Accepted 3 February 2015
microfluidic air-to-liquid interface for downstream analysis. A theoretical study of the governing geo-
Available online 9 February 2015
metric and operational parameters for optimal electrostatic precipitation is presented. The fabrication
of an electrostatic precipitator prototype and its experimental validation using a laboratory-generated
Keywords:
aerosolized dye is described. Collection efficiencies were comparable to those of a state-of-the-art
Exhaled breath analysis
Electrostatic precipitator
Biosampler impinger, with the significant advantage of providing samples that are at least 10 times
Microfluidics more concentrated. Finally, we discuss the potential of such a system for breath-based diagnostics.
Lab-on-a-chip © 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Diagnostics
Aerosol sampling

1. Introduction chromatographic, or mass spectroscopic techniques, which are


reviewed by Buszewski et al. [14]. However, non-volatile sub-
The field of in vitro point-of-care (PoC) diagnostic tests has stances in breath are transported via aerosol droplets, such as
rapidly grown during the past decade. It promises robust systems the Torque Teno virus [15], or Influenza [16]. These aerosolized
capable of delivering precise and rapid results about the condi- droplets, are thought to be generated from the lung lining fluid via
tion of an individual, which can lead to an improved quality of film rupturing following contraction of the bronchioles [17–19].
healthcare at a reduced cost. Urine, blood, and oral or nasal swabs There has been a lot of emphasis on detection of VOCs using gas
have been extensively investigated as diagnostic samples in the analysis or condensates [20–22], however few studies have been
healthcare setting. Here we present a detection method aimed at aimed at the capture detection of microorganisms in exhaled
diagnosis using breath sampling. breath. Specifically, aerosols with droplet size >1 ␮m are formed
Much effort has been made in the past to link volatile organic through coughing [23–27] and are targeted in our work.
compounds (VOCs) in exhaled air, to a patient’s state of health Integrating a capture system for these aerosol droplets in a
[1], specifically with respect to identifying biomarkers for cancer PoC device could form a completely non-invasive alternative to
[2–6]. Exhaled breath contains both gases, and aerosol droplets, traditional lung sampling methods, such as the very invasive
however, the main focus of breath analysis thus far, has been and uncomfortable bronchoscopy procedure. Nonetheless, there
on gas detection, which can contain: inorganic gases, i.e. NO [7] are difficulties that are inherent to sampling breath including:
CO [8]; hydrocarbons, i.e. isoprene [9] ethane or pentane [10]; variances in aerosol droplet size, number concentration, compo-
and volatile and non-volatile substances, such as isoprostane, sition, and low concentration of analytes present in the sample
cytokines, leukotrienes [11], proteins, nucleic acids, or polypep- [24,25,28–31]. Such a complex and diverse aerosol is difficult to
tides [12,13], bacteria or viruses. VOCs appear in gaseous form simulate in the laboratory, thus a mock breath aerosol of specified
in breath, typically analyzed using ion mobility spectroscopy, composition, droplet size, and concentration is generated and used
for characterization. The challenge of the low amount of sample
present in breath means it is crucial for a point-of-care test to have
both: a high collection efficiency, and the ability to up-concentrate
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +46 8 7906613; mobile: +46 733 254021.
collected samples for very sensitive detection of analytes. There
E-mail address: wouter@kth.se (W. van der Wijngaart).
1
First authors. also exists a lack of standard methodology for breath sampling,

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2015.02.008
0925-4005/© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352 345

and appropriate and standardized breathing protocols remain to prototype are reported and compared with those of a commercial
be established. Biosampler impinger.
Traditionally, sampling of aerosol droplets is achieved using
inertial impaction, e.g. using impingers [32–34], which was used for 2. PoC concept for integrated aerosol sampling and analysis
comparison in this work, or via direct impaction [35,36]. In 1955,
the use of electrostatic precipitators (ESPs) was introduced as a The concept of the proposed PoC device arises from the unique
potential alternative, when Kraemer and Johnstone [37] explained, combination of two elements: an ESP to capture aerosol droplets,
theoretically, the charging and capture of aerosol droplets in the and a microfluidic lab-on-a-chip containing an air–liquid interface
presence of electrostatic fields. Since then, ESPs have been used and an on-chip biosensor. All of this can potentially be incorpo-
extensively by industry, e.g. in air purifiers, but only recently have rated into one portable instrument with a mouthpiece for sampling
they been considered as a potential method for the capture of patients’ breath (Fig. 1).
exhaled bioaerosols. Miller et al. [38] demonstrated a hand-held The aerosol droplets enter the ESP through a mouthpiece, are
ESP device for breath sampling relying on transmission electron electrically charged, transported, and captured onto the microflu-
microscopy (TEM) for sample analysis, which is not a suitable detec- idic air–liquid interface of the lab-on-a-chip cartridge. In the ESP,
tion method for PoC applications. Alternatively, Kettleson et al. a two-electrode multi-point-to-plane corona discharge cell is used
[39] demonstrated inactivation of aerosolized viruses using an ESP. to charge and capture aerosol droplets. Metal needles are used as
Christensen et al. [40] utilized a commercial, chip-based ESP to corona discharge electrodes, and the air–liquid interface consti-
analyze breath from cattle for detection of foot-and-mouth dis- tutes the planar capture electrode. The collected sample can then be
ease. The drawback with their method is the indirect collection, subsequently analyzed for biomarkers or other biological entities
i.e. not directly from the cattle’s mouth but from ambient air in using a relevant assay and on-chip transducer.
the farmhouse, leading to lower collected amounts of exhaled Contrary to the analysis of VOCs, which can be performed
aerosol when compared with direct breath. Similarly, Han and utilizing optical equipment, the analysis of complex biomolecules
Mainelis [41] introduced an ESP sampler for bioaerosols, mainly such as nucleic acids, proteins or even entire pathogens present
targeting airborne pathogens and microorganisms, by collecting in aerosol, requires collection of the dispersed aerosol droplets
rolling water droplets off the collection electrode. Tan et al. [42] into a continuous liquid phase suited for subsequent sample
proposed an airborne bacteria sampler using a semi-spherical preparation and analyte detection. Microfluidic devices are ideal
electrostatic precipitator, and reported varying relative collection for handling and analysis of such liquid samples [46] and have
efficiencies,  ESPon/ESPoff , from 50% to 100%, where the total cap- the advantage of allowing integration with an ESP. A previous
ture was compared with that when no voltages were applied to the
ESP electrodes. The collection was dependent on applied voltages,
flow rates, particle sizes and geometrical design parameters. All
the above ESP devices, although successful in capturing their tar-
get aerosol, are solely focused on capturing airborne droplets from
ambient air, and do not provide the possibility for uncomplicated
downstream integration of biosensors with the instrument.
For integration of breath aerosol sampling in a PoC diagnostic
device, one of the most challenging aspects is the direct interfacing
of breath with a lab-on-a-chip (LoC) cartridge [43]. In particular,
a robust air–liquid interface is required to allow capture of the
aerosol droplets and dispersion of the captured sample in a liq-
uid medium, in which direct initiation of specific ligand–receptor
biochemical reactions can occur. We have previously presented
microsystem-based components for air–liquid interfacing in com-
bination with downstream analysis, for quartz crystal microbalance
(QCM) sensing of airborne narcotics [44,45]. Two examples of such
surface tension-based air–liquid interfacing include: pillar forests
and perforated diaphragms. They allow for use of a liquid flow in
the chip while simultaneously offering a large and robust air–liquid
interface area. Moreover, a perforated diaphragm allows for place-
ment of a biosensor in close proximity to the air–liquid interface,
which potentially simplifies the overall LoC design and reduce the
risk for sample-to-channel surface interactions inherent to fluidic
transport in microfluidics.
This paper considers an integrated aerosol sampling and
analysis system, designed for future use in point-of-care breath
based diagnostics. We first introduce the combination of ESP with
lab-on-chip technologies, the former for aerosol collection and the
latter for integrated sample handling and biomarker detection. The
remainder of the paper details the design, governing parameters
and experimental investigation of an aerosol-to-chip ESP based
sampler. First we review the major physical phenomena involved
in electrostatic aerosol capture and investigate the governing Fig. 1. Conceptual design of the proposed PoC device using exhaled-breath aerosol
geometric and operational parameters using finite elements (FE) as diagnostic sample. A cross-section of the PoC ESP sampler shows needles as corona
discharge electrodes, while the lab-on-chip cartridge acts as the collection electrode.
simulations. Thereafter we describe the building and experimental
Exhaled breath aerosol enters in the centre, and a sheath flow is implemented to
testing of the prototype. We used laboratory generated aerosol to increase flow control. The lab-on-chip cartridge includes an air–liquid interface, and
derive the prototype characteristics. Sampling efficiencies of the a biosensor.
346 G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352

Fig. 2. (A) SEM image of a perforated Si diaphragm with, in inset, a biosensor lab-on-chip integrated below the diaphragm. The second inset shows a magnified view of a
diaphragm with 45 ␮m wide pores. (B) A smoke source and the corona needle of an ESP device (not visible in the photograph) are positioned at the bottom of a Y-shaped
breathing tube and the collector chip is positioned at the top-right outlet. In the left image, both the smoke and the ESP are off. In the centre image, the ESP is off and no
smoke is generated, exiting through both the left and right outlets. In the right image, the ESP is on and the generated smoke is successfully guided towards the collector
chip at the right outlet of the Y-shaped tube.

preliminary investigation, by Sandström et al. [47], demonstrated diaphragm. Next we describe the underlying physics, the parame-
a prototype microfluidic air–liquid interface for integration with ters, and the FE model of the ESP sampler.
ESP (Fig. 2A). This air–liquid interface, featuring a perforated Si
diaphragm for stabilizing the interface position, was combined 3.1. Physical mechanism of ESP
with a geometrically non-optimized ESP system, and was shown
to successfully capture airborne smoke particles to a microfluidic An ESP consists of a discharge and a collection electrode with
device. Hydrophobic smoke particles were shown to mostly collect a voltage difference that results in a strong electric field. This
on the surface of the air–liquid interface, while hydrophilic smoke field induces a corona discharge that leads to ionization of the
particles absorbed into the liquid on-chip. Further, previously air molecules near the electrode tip. Incoming aerosol droplets
unpublished experiments on a similar system demonstrate inte- collide with the ionized air molecules, thus becoming electrically
gration of the smoke capture system with components from a charged, and are transported by the electrostatic force towards
breathing apparatus, see Fig. 2B. The ESP system is shown to the collector electrode. Aerosol droplets acquire positive charges
successfully guide smoke particles through one of the branches of in a positive corona, and negative charges in a negative corona.
a symmetric Y-shaped junction to a collector chip. Initiation of a corona depends strongly on the electrode configura-
tion, i.e. point-to-plane, or wire-to-plane; and the electric potential
gradient around the discharge electrode, which is determined by
3. Design and modelling of ESP the electrode curvature. Exceedingly high field strength can cause
an electrical breakdown of the corona, leading to arcing, and to
We built an experimental device to investigate the capture effi- unwanted production of ozone molecules. Inhalation of ozone, has
ciency of aerosol droplets using an ESP integrated with an open been linked to reduced lung function [48] and increased suscepti-
air–liquid interface. We optimized the design of this ESP sam- bility to respiratory infections [49] therefore limitations to the field
pler for an efficient and localized aerosol capture. A two-electrode, strength must be enforced.
multi-point-to-plane configuration is used (Fig. 1), in which sev- Aerosol droplets acquire charges by either active field charging
eral needles constitute the corona discharge electrodes, and the or diffusion charging, with both effects often occurring simulta-
air–liquid interface, a 10 mm diameter open well, constitutes the neously but with varying intensity depending on the conditions.
collection electrode. To better assess the capture efficiency of the Field charging is the active collision of corona-generated ions with
ESP design, we forego the perforated Si diaphragm, to avoid the an aerosol droplet and is predominantly governed by ion concen-
risk of sample loss due to adsorption of aerosol droplets to the tration, electric field strength (Eq. (1)), and time. Diffusion charging
G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352 347

is the process by which aerosol droplets acquire charge from ran- Physical phenomena addressed in this model include the bi-
dom collisions with ions, due to Brownian motion, and is dependent directional couplings between: the electrostatic potential and the
on the number of ions available, as well as the duration of exposure transport of charged species, via the charge density and electric
(Eq. (2)). field; the transport of charged species and the fluidic flow, via
 3ε   Ed2   K eZ N t  the charge density and electric force; and unidirectional coupling
E i i between: the electrostatic potential and the fluidic flow, via the
nfield charging (t) = (1)
ε+2 4KE e 1 + KE eZi Ni t electric force.
  The electrostatic potential and field are described using the
dp kT KE dp c̄i e2 Ni t Poisson equation; the transport of charged species is described by
ndiffusion (t) = ln 1 + (2)
2KE e2 2kT the Nernst–Plank equations; the fluidic flow is described by the
Navier–Stokes equations; and particle tracing is achieved using
where n(t), number of charges acquired by an aerosol droplet; dp ,
Newton’s second law with drag and electric force using a specific
aerosol droplet diameter; k, Boltzmann’s constant; T, temperature;
module in the FE software. Part of the model is based on the work
KE , constant of proportionality; e, elementary charge; C̄i , mean ther-
of [50,51], using the Kaptzov’s hypothesis for the corona onset, i.e.
mal speed of ions; Ni , concentration of ions; E, electric field; ε,
with electric field density at the outer ionization zone of the nega-
relative permittivity; t, charging time; Zi , mobility of ions (Hinds,
tive corona discharge at a constant value of Epeek = 3.6 × 106 V m−1 .
1999).
The unipolar zone is defined as the region in space where mostly
After acquiring charges, electrohydrodynamic (EHD) transport
only co-ions, those of same sign as the electrode potential, subsist
of the droplet in the ESP occurs by a combination of diffusion,
and travel towards the collection electrode. The radius of the outer
migration, and convection. More detailed information about the
ionization zone can be estimated as
physics of electrostatic precipitators can be found in Hinds’ Aerosol
Technology (1999). Etip
Rionization = Rtip · (3)
Epeek
3.2. Geometric and electrical parameters   1/2
−2 1
Three types of parameters govern the ESP: electrical parameters, Etip = Epeek · 1 + 2.62 · 10 · . (4)
Rtip
geometrical design, and aerosol characteristics. Firstly, the number
of electrodes and their potentials dominate the electrical parame- As boundary conditions, the electric potential was set at given
ters. Secondly, physical geometrical parameters are governed by: values, Vdischarge and Vcollector , on the corona and collector elec-
trodes, respectively. In previous publications, the electric field at
a. the axial inter-electrode distance, D, i.e. distance between the the outer ionization zone was manually iteratively adjusted by
axial centric of the plane created by the tips of the needles and adapting the surface charge density,  ion , at the outer ionization
the plane of the collection vessel zone until the electric field EPeek was obtained, which corresponds
b. the number of the coronizing electrodes, three, and their radial to the Kaptzov’s hypothesis. Our model features an automatic
position, Rn , placed at an angular distribution of 120◦ adjustment of the ion density to respect the following function:
c. the flow rates, for the supplementary clean air sheath flow which Epeek − E = 0 V m−1 . The ion density at the collector electrode was set
surrounds the aerosol influx (Fig. 1). to zero, assuming no ion accumulation at the surface, i.e. no limiting
current density, which is justified by the very low current induced
Thirdly, the aerosol characteristics are governed by flow rate, by the corona discharge and the large electrode surface. The zero
droplet size distribution, and droplet concentration. ion density condition was also applied at the flow inlets and out-
let, which is equivalent to an outlet connected to an infinitely large
3.3. Finite elements modelling reservoir free of ions. The other surfaces were insulating. The flow
rates, Qsheath flow and Qaerosol flow , were fixed at the sheath flow and
The ESP parameters considered are: the axial electrode distance, aerosol inlets, while non-turbulent flow at atmospheric pressure
D, the corona current, I, and the device geometry, i.e. the diam- was imposed at the outlet.
eter of the ESP, inlet tube, collector vessel, as well as the radial For particle tracing, 50 water droplets of diameters 1 and 2.7 ␮m,
position of the needles, and their tip radius, Rtip . The coronizing corresponding to the size of droplets generated by the medical neb-
electrodes’ position and number are chosen to maximize ion gener- ulizer used in the experimental work, were released at the entrance
ation, whereas the amount of electrodes used was limited to keep of the aerosol inlet tube with a uniform distribution. The particle
the device complexity low. Aerosol characteristics are modelled charge, qparticle , was approximated to increase linearly with expo-
after the nebulizer used in the experiment. The ESP geometry and sure duration and was increased linearly after passing near the
operational parameters were first studied using finite element (FE) corona electrode until reaching a maximum value. The saturation
modelling. The interplay between the electric field, charge trans- charge value was computed by taking the limit as time approaches
port, and aerosol flow was studied by implementing a model in infinity, of the equations for field and diffusion charging (Eqs. (1)
COMSOL Multiphysics 4.2b. The ESP geometry, shown in Fig. 1, can and (2)).
be simplified for modelling using cylindrical and planar symmetry The flow profile, electric field lines, and particle flow trajectory
(Fig. 3E). A 60◦ slice of the cylindrical ESP is used during compu- were computed for different values of the needle voltage, flow rates,
tation. The geometry that is presented here corresponds to that of charges, and distances. Some results are presented in Fig. 3, where
the experimental prototype, the size ratio between the cylindrical the electric potential distribution, the anion volume density distri-
chamber and the aerosol inlet tube was chosen to approach isoki- bution, the anion flux stream lines, the gas flow and the particle
netic conditions for both the sheath and aerosol flows. The outer trajectories are shown for D = 3 cm and an electrode potential dif-
domain of the ESP was given a dimension of 0.4 m in height and ference of 6 kV. The total electric current was computed as 1.22 ␮A.
radius for two reasons: to account for the electric field extension For these conditions and for a particle size of 2.7 ␮m, 37 out of the
outside of the ESP; and for investigating the influence of electri- 50 particles released were collected; while the remaining parti-
cally grounded objects at close distance to the ESP, on the overall cles entered flow vortexes induced by the EHD flow, and did not
electrostatic field distribution. reach the collector within the computed time. For 1 ␮m particles,
348 G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352

Fig. 3. Simulation results. From left to right: (A) the electrical potential distribution in colour; (B) the anion volume density in colour and the anion flux stream line in white
lines; (C) the air flow velocity distribution in colour and with white arrows, and the particle trajectories tracing in white lines; and (D) the location of impact for the particles
onto the liquid collector; and above, (E) the geometry used for the simulations.

29 out of 50 were collected. The decrease in capture efficiency with one outlet placed at the bottom. The cylindrical geometry of the ESP
particle size is expected considering the decrease of accumulated was chosen for its axial symmetry, with the aim to allow for smooth
charge, electric force, and inertia for decreasing particle size. For and controlled air stream with minimum turbulence to avoid dis-
increasing values of D, the collection efficiency was considerably turbing the aerosol collection. Three, 5 ␮m tip Tungsten needles
decreasing, but limited computing power prevented quantification (American Probe Inc., USA) optimally positioned, according to the
of the collection efficiency. One must note that it is difficult to obtain FE simulations, radially at 2 cm from the centre line, and axially
exact quantitative data for the aerosol transport through modelling, aligned such that the needle tips are 1 cm below the aerosol inlet.
due to approximations made by setting: the Peek value, the coro- The collection electrode is a shallow well milled in polycarbonate
nizing volume at the needle electrode, and the particle charging. plastic.
However, the FE model allows us to determine a number of design The remaining setup includes the ESP aerosol inlet connected
features and to simulate relevant configurations, from which two to an Albatross 009H-40-A nebulizer (AIOLOS Medical, Sweden)
main points can be concluded. First, the corona discharge can pro- working at a nebulization rate of 0.8 ml/min and airflow rate of
duce strong EHD jet (wind), depending on the geometrical and 8 l/m, providing aerosol droplets with a mass median diameter
electrical configurations. This can cause flow vortexes that severely (MMD) of 2.7 ␮m at a pressure of 2 bar. To prevent contamination of
reduce the particle capture efficiency. The following design fea- the needles from incoming aerosol droplets, or from stray particles
tures reduce the occurrence of vortices and increase the trapping from the outside environment, two sheath flow inlets (connected
of aerosol droplets: to Inlet 2 in Fig. 4) are connected via a HEPA filter (HMEF 750, GE
Healthcare, Finland) to a humidifier, ensuring an input of clean,
i. several corona needle electrodes placed concentrically, instead controlled 85% RH air. The ESP outlet is connected to an impinger,
of one that is centrally positioned SKC BioSampler (SKC Inc., USA), which in turn, is connected to a
ii. the smallest radial distance of the needles, with respect to the vacuum pump.
aerosol inlet A power supply module, based on the negative C60 component
iii. an increased sheath flow rate and reduced aerosol flow rate (EMCO High Voltage Corporation, USA), supplied a high poten-
iv. a distance, D, tuned for optimal electrical charging of the parti- tial difference (1–5.5 kV) over the electrodes. Varying the needle
cles, and reduced EHD flow jetting through a lower electric field. potential between −3 and −5.5 kV provides a tuneable corona
current, I, which varies in the range 0–20 ␮A depending on D.
Currents were monitored with a 8Z True RMS multimeter (Fluke
4. Experimental setup Corporation, USA), and a 34401A multimeter (Hewlett Packard,
USA).
4.1. Aerosol sampler prototype The Biosampler impinger, a gold standard, operates at a fixed
flow rate of 12.5 l/min at a minimum working pressure drop of
The experimental ESP sampler, Fig. 4, consists of a 100 mm 0.5 bar as compared with atmospheric pressure. The flow and pres-
diameter polycarbonate cylindrical tube encasing three corona dis- sure over the impinger were monitored with a MPX5100D mass
charge needle electrodes and a collector electrode, with inlets flow sensor (Motorola, USA) and a differential pressure sensor,
placed on top of the tube for aerosol and sheath flow input and respectively.
G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352 349

Fig. 4. Schematics of the ESP and of the experimental setup. A compressor supplies air to a nebulizer. The aerosol droplets flow towards the ESP device, where the ions
generated by the corona discharge electrically charge the particles. The particles are transported and captured onto the open-air liquid surface. Particles that are not captured
on the collector continue to flow towards the reference Biosampler impinger. The air stream continues towards the exhaust via HEPA filters, regulated by flow and pressure
sensors. The light grey shaded area represents the breath sampler, whereas the dark grey shaded area simulates a patient breathing into the device.

4.2. Measurement protocol a stable current was achieved, the nebulizer was switched on for
30 s. Following this, the nebulizer was turned off, while the vac-
The ESP sampler efficiency and performance were evaluated by uum and electrode potential conditions were left on for one extra
measuring the transport of dye solution from the nebulizer to the minute to purge the system of any remaining aerosol. Subsequently
collector and to the impinger. The evaluation was performed for the liquids from the collector, and the impinger, were extracted by
D = 0, 3, 5, and 7 cm. pipetting the volume into an Eppendorf tube, and weighed, in order
Experiment preparation included: placing 4 ml of 300 mg/l dye to calculate their volumes. Optical absorption values of all sam-
solution Alphazurine A (Sigma–Aldrich, Sweden) dissolved in 0.5 M ples were measured using a Genesys 20 visible spectrophotometer
KCl (Sigma–Aldrich, Sweden), in the nebulizer, 2 ml of 0.5 M KCl (ThermoScientific, USA) at a path length of 10 mm, and Eppen-
in the impinger (SKC BioSampler), and 200 ␮l of the same 0.5 M dorf UV-specific cuvettes (VWR, Sweden). The absorption data and
KCL solution placed inside the collector. In this study a laboratory- corresponding sample volumes allow calculation of the respective
generated aerosolized dye is used to be able to characterize the ESP molar dye concentrations and the amount of dye particles collected
rather than real breath samples, since it provides a simple method using the Beer–Lambert law.
of quantification using absorption of light through the samples. This Additionally, experiments were conducted to quantify the out-
synthetic dye aerosol is a well-controlled sample, which is ideal for put flow of the nebulizer, as well as the flow split after the
characterizing the ESP since it eliminates all the unknowns that are T-junction in order to characterize the aerosol input entering the
present in a human breath sample. ESP. Nebulization rate of the AIOLOS was determined by measuring
The ESP cylinder was sealed to create a closed system and the the volume of liquid before and after 4 min of nebulization. The neb-
vacuum was turned on. Thereafter, the electrode potential was ulization rate was found to be 0.256 ml per 30 s. An AWM5102VN
switched on to induce a corona current, which was measured. Once flow sensor (Honeywell, USA) was used to measure the flow output
350 G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352

Fig. 5. (Left) Current–voltage relationship for the ESP, plotted for D = 3 (circle), 5 (square), and 7 (diamond) cm. (Right) Capture Efficiency of the ESP as a percentage of the
estimated input aerosol, ndye input for D = 0 (triangle, inset), 3 (circle), 5 (square), 7 (diamond) cm. The shaded ellipses allow for ease of visualization of the data points for each
inter-electrode distance. The error bars indicate measurements made in triplicates. The efficiency of the state-of-the-art reference impinger was measurement consistent
and is also indicated.

at the nebulizer to be 7.17 l/min, and the flow at the entrance of the When the ESP was turned off, meaning no voltage was applied
ESP to be 1.36 l/min, 20% of the output flow of the nebulizer. There- and no corona occurs, the collection efficiency of aerosol droplets
fore, assuming the air flow rate is directly related to the number of was consistently <1%, confirming the success of electrostatic pre-
particles, and at a nebulization rate of 0.256 ml/30 s using a dye con- cipitation as mechanism for aerosol capture.
centration of 300 mg/l, the total amount of aerosolized dye entering The absolute losses in the system can be estimated from
the ESP, ndye input , is calculated to be 21 nmol for the duration of the the consistent collection efficiency of the impinger to be
experiment. nlosses = 1 −  impinger = 1 − (ndye impinger /ndye input) = 81% of ndye input
and are attributed for the most part to the tube bends and junctions.
In comparison with the state-of-the-art Biosampler impinger,
the performance of our ESP sampler is on par, with maximum
5. Experimental results and discussion collection efficiencies 21% for our ESP sampler and a consistent
efficiency 19% for the impinger.
This section describes and discusses the electrical characteris- In addition to a comparable efficiency, our ESP sampler has spe-
tics and experimental collection efficiency of the ESP sampler for cific advantages over the impinger. The microfluidic interface at the
varying inter-electrode distances and corona currents. collection site enables integration with lab-on-a-chip technologies,
The current–voltage relationship of the ESP is plotted in Fig. 5 by allowing for robust sample handling and for the possible integra-
(left) for D = 3, 5 and 7 cm. Similar to findings from Vega (1999) and tion of a biosensor in very close proximity to the interface. The small
Gallo (1977), no corona is produced at an electrode potential dif- collection volume used in our ESP sampler, 300 ␮l, is in stark con-
ference of <3 kV. Gallo presents a voltage–current relationship for a trast with the large volume, 4 ml, used in the impinger, and provides
point-to-plane configuration for air around atmospheric pressure, collected sample solutions with higher concentrations, at least 10-
which displays a stable quasi-linear region (for 3–7 kV) where a fold in our experiments, than when sampled using the impinger.
self-sustained corona can be maintained. This is also observed in Furthermore, the collection volume in the proposed ESP sampler,
our ESP, confirming the presence of a corona. Values of corona cur- Fig. 1, has the potential to be further miniaturized, allowing sample
rent for our ESP are lower than the findings from Gallo, since their volumes as little as 3.5 ␮l, as previously shown (Frisk et al. [45]).
configuration involved needle-to-plane electrodes with a larger Hence, the concentrated solutions achieved using our ESP sampler
distance between needle and plane electrodes, while ours is a potentially allows for highly sensitive and rapid detection of ana-
multi-needle-to-plane system with a small inter-electrode dis- lytes when integrated with a biosensor. Additional advantages of
tance. the ESP sampler as a method of aerosol capture include: flow rates
Successful aerosol capture was achieved with the ESP sam- of the ESP sampler not being fixed, as with impingers, and can be
pler and the absolute collection efficiency is plotted in Fig. 5 dictated by the breath patterns of the patient.
(right). The efficiency can be calculated as the ratio of dye cap- In comparison with results from Tan et al. [42], the rela-
tured in the collector, to the amount of dye entering the ESP, tive collection efficiency of our ESP sampler was consistently
 absolute = ndye collector /ndye input . A maximum efficiency of >20% is  relative = (1 − nESPoff /nESPon ) ≈ 100%, without the large variations,
achieved for D = 3 cm, and I = 4 ␮A. For larger inter-electrode dis-  relative = 70–90%, seen from their sampler.
tances, decreased collection efficiency was observed, and confirms For translating the technology from our lab setting to clinical
results from the FE modelling. For shorter distances, i.e. D = 0 cm, breath aerosol sampling, the following challenges need addressing.
a decreased collection efficiency was also observed, which is There is a need to further investigate the effect on the sampling
attributed to shorter charging time and, hence, less-efficient elec- efficiency of both the large range of aerosol droplet sizes and
trophoretic capture.
G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352 351

number concentration occurring in patient breath samples, and in healthy volunteers, Analyst 138 (2013) 2134–2145, http://dx.doi.org/
10.1039/c3an36756h.
the patient breathing pattern. Also, further research is needed
[10] L. Seabra, J.M. Braganza, M.F. Jones, A system for the quantitative-determination
on the integration of downstream sensing of the biomarkers of of hydrocarbons in human breath, J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 9 (1991) 693–697.
interest, and the adaptation to the clinical end-user setting in [11] J. Li, Y. Peng, Y. Duan, Diagnosis of breast cancer based on breath anal-
terms of power supply and form factor. ysis: an emerging method, Crit. Rev. Oncol. Hematol. 87 (2013) 28–40,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.critrevonc.2012.11.007.
[12] S.F. Solga, A. Alkhuraishe, K. Cope, A. Tabesh, J.M. Clark, M. Torbenson, et al.,
Breath biomarkers and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease: preliminary observa-
6. Conclusion tions, Biomarkers 11 (2006) 174–183.
[13] M. Janicka, A. Kot-Wasik, J. Kot, J. Namiesnik, Isoprostanes-biomarkers of lipid
In conclusion, we present a concept device for ESP-based peroxidation: their utility in evaluating oxidative stress and analysis, Int. J. Mol.
Sci. 11 (2010) 4631–4659, http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ijms11114631.
aerosol sampling for the potential capture of human exhaled-
[14] B. Buszewski, D. Grzywinski, T. Ligor, T. Stacewicz, Z. Bielecki, J. Wojtas,
breath aerosols, in particular generated by coughing, for PoC Detection of volatile organic compounds as biomarkers in breath anal-
diagnostics. This device would directly interface aerosol droplets ysis by different analytical techniques, Bioanalysis 5 (2013) 2287–2306,
with a microfluidic lab-on-chip platform by using a microfluidic http://dx.doi.org/10.4155/bio.13.183.
[15] K. Chikasue, M. Kimura, K. Ikeda, T. Ohnishi, S. Kawanishi, T. Iio, et al., Detection
air–liquid interface. The capture of the aerosol droplets relies on of Torque Teno virus DNA in exhaled breath by polymerase chain reaction, Acta
an ESP, using a multi-point-to-plane corona discharge mechanism. Med. Okayama 66 (2012) 387–397.
To design this system, a finite elements model was implemented [16] P. Fabian, J.J. McDevitt, W.H. DeHaan, R.O.P. Fung, B.J. Cowling, K.H. Chan, et al.,
Influenza virus in human exhaled breath: an observational study, PLoS ONE 3
for qualitative prediction of the behaviour of aerosol droplets in (2008) e2691, http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0002691.t002.
the ESP sampler. This design was used to build an experimen- [17] K. Haslbeck, K. Schwarz, J.M. Hohlfeld, J.R. Seume, W. Koch, Submicron
tal prototype, which was characterized for its capture efficiency droplet formation in the human lung, J. Aerosol Sci. 41 (2010) 429–438,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jaerosci.2010.02.010.
using an aerosolized dye sample simulating breath aerosol. Vary- [18] H. Holmgren, B. Bake, A.-C. Olin, E. Ljungstrom, Relation between humidity and
ing inter-electrode distances and corona currents allowed finding size of exhaled particles, J. Aerosol Med. Pulm. Drug Deliv. 24 (2011) 253–260,
optimal operational parameters, and an open air–liquid microflu- http://dx.doi.org/10.1089/jamp.2011.0880.
[19] G.R. Johnson, L. Morawska, The mechanism of breath aerosol forma-
idic interface was used, which can be used advantageously towards tion, J. Aerosol Med. Pulm. Drug Deliv. 22 (2009) 229–237, http://dx.doi.
integration in a point-of-care test. The ESP sampler proved suc- org/10.1089/jamp.2008.0720.
cessful in capturing >20% of the total aerosol generated by [20] O.I. Emilsson, P. Gislason, A.-C. Olin, C. Janson, I. Olafsson, Biomarkers for gas-
troesophageal reflux in respiratory diseases, Gastroenterol. Res. Pract. (2013),
the nebulizer, and was as efficient as a gold standard aerosol
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/148086.
sampler, an impinger, with the additional benefit of providing [21] M. Gube, J. Ebel, P. Brand, T. Göen, K. Holzinger, U. Reisgen, et al., Biological effect
highly concentrated samples. These advantages make the proposed markers in exhaled breath condensate and biomonitoring in welders: impact of
electrostatic precipitator-based prototype potentially suitable smoking and protection equipment, Int. Arch. Occup. Environ. Health 83 (2010)
803–811, http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00420-010-0516-4.
for point-of-care diagnostics based on human exhaled-breath [22] P.P.R. Rosias, C.M. Robroeks, K.D. van de Kant, G.T. Rijkers, L.J. Zimmermann, C.P.
aerosol. van Schayck, et al., Feasibility of a new method to collect exhaled breath con-
densate in pre-school children, Pediatr. Allergy Immunol. 21 (2010) E235–E244,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1399-3038.2009.00909.x.
Acknowledgements [23] J.D. Noti, W.G. Lindsley, F.M. Blachere, G. Cao, M.L. Kashon, R.E. Thewlis,
et al., Detection of infectious influenza virus in cough aerosols generated in
a simulated patient examination room, Clin. Infect. Dis. 54 (2012) 1569–1577,
This work was partly supported by the Innovative Medicines Ini- http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cid/cis237.
tiative, a public–private partnership between the European Union, [24] S. Yang, G.W.M. Lee, C.-M. Chen, C.-C. Wu, K.-P. Yu, The size and concentration
and the European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and of droplets generated by coughing in human subjects, J. Aerosol Med. 20 (2007)
484–494, http://dx.doi.org/10.1089/jam.2007.0610.
Associations (RAPP-ID project, grant agreement, no. 115153).
[25] W.G. Lindsley, F.M. Blachere, R.E. Thewlis, A. Vishnu, K.A. Davis,
It was also partly supported by the Swedish Governmental G. Cao, et al., Measurements of airborne influenza virus in
Agency for Innovation Systems, the Swedish Foundation for Strate- aerosol particles from human coughs, PLoS ONE 5 (2010) e15100,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0015100.
gic Research, and the Swedish Research Council as part of the Rapid
[26] S. Stelzer-Braid, B.G. Oliver, A.J. Blazey, E. Argent, T.P. Newsome, W.D. Rawlin-
Pathogen Analyzer (RPA) project. son, et al., Exhalation of respiratory viruses by breathing, coughing, and talking,
J. Med. Virol. 81 (2009) 1674–1679, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jmv.21556.
[27] K.P. Fennelly, J.W. Martyny, K.E. Fulton, I.M. Orme, D.M. Cave, L.B. Heifets,
References Cough-generated aerosols of Mycobacterium tuberculosis – a new method
to study infectiousness, Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 169 (2004) 604–609,
˛
[1] B. Buszewski, M. Kesy, T. Ligor, A. Amann, Human exhaled air analytics: http://dx.doi.org/10.1164/rccm.200308-1101OC.
biomarkers of diseases, Biomed. Chromatogr. 21 (2007) 553–566. [28] L. Morawska, G.R. Johnson, Z. Ristovski, M. Hargreaves, K.L. Mengersen, C. Chao,
[2] P. Fuchs, C. Loeseken, J.K. Schubert, W. Miekisch, Breath gas aldehydes as et al., Droplets expelled during human expiratory activities and their origin, in:
biomarkers of lung cancer, Int. J. Cancer (2009), http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ Proceedings 11th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate
ijc.24970. Paper - 1023, Copenhagen, Denmark, 2008.
[3] M. Hakim, Y.Y. Broza, O. Barash, N. Peled, M. Phillips, A. Amann, et al., Volatile [29] C.E. Wainwright, M.W. France, P. O’Rourke, S. Anuj, T.J. Kidd, M.D. Nissen,
organic compounds of lung cancer and possible biochemical pathways, Chem. et al., Cough-generated aerosols of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and other Gram-
Rev. 112 (2012) 5949–5966, http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/cr300174a. negative bacteria from patients with cystic fibrosis, Thorax 64 (2009) 926–931,
[4] A. Amann, P. Mochalski, V. Ruzsanyi, Y.Y. Broza, H. Haick, Assessment http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/thx.2008.112466.
of the exhalation kinetics of volatile cancer biomarkers based on their [30] A.-C. Almstrand, E. Ljungstrom, J. Lausmaa, B. Bake, P. Sjövall, A.-C. Olin, Airway
physicochemical properties, J. Breath Res. 8 (2014), http://dx.doi.org/ monitoring by collection and mass spectrometric analysis of exhaled particles,
10.1088/1752-7155/8/1/016003. Anal. Chem. 81 (2008) 662–668.
[5] Y.Y. Broza, H. Haick, Nanomaterial-based sensors for detection of disease [31] H. Holmgren, E. Gerth, E. Ljungstrom, P. Larsson, A.-C. Almstrand, B.
by volatile organic compounds, Nanomedicine (Lond) 8 (2013) 785–806, Bake, et al., Effects of breath holding at low and high lung volumes on
http://dx.doi.org/10.2217/NNM.13.64. amount of exhaled particles, Respir. Physiol. Neurobiol. 185 (2013) 228–234,
[6] B. Buszewski, J. Rudnicka, T. Ligor, M. Walczak, T. Jezierski, A. Amann, Analytical http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.resp.2012.10.010.
and unconventional methods of cancer detection using odor, TrAC Trends Anal. [32] X. Lin, T. Reponen, K. Willeke, Z. Wang, S.A. Grinshpun, M. Trunov, Survival
Chem. 38 (2012) 1–12, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.trac.2012.03.019. of airborne microorganisms during swirling aerosol collection, Aerosol Sci.
[7] L.E. Gustafsson, A.M. Leone, M.G. Persson, N.P. Wiklund, S. Moncada, Endoge- Technol. 32 (2000) 184–196, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/027868200303722.
nous nitric oxide is present in the exhaled air of rabbits, guinea pigs and [33] T. Han, G. Mainelis, Investigation of inherent and latent internal losses
humans, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 181 (1991) 852–857. in liquid-based bioaerosol samplers, J. Aerosol Sci. 45 (2012) 58–68,
[8] K. Zayasu, K. Sekizawa, S. Okinaga, M. Yamaya, T. Ohrui, H. Sasaki, Increased http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jaerosci.2011.11.001.
carbon monoxide in exhaled air of asthmatic patients, Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care [34] J.J. McDevitt, P. Koutrakis, S.T. Ferguson, J.M. Wolfson, M.P. Fabian, M.
Med. 156 (1997) 1140–1143. Martins, et al., Development and performance evaluation of an exhaled-
[9] P. Mochalski, J. King, M. Klieber, K. Unterkofler, H. Hinterhuber, M. Bau- breath bioaerosol collector for influenza virus, Aerosol Sci. Technol. (2013),
mann, et al., Blood and breath levels of selected volatile organic compounds http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02786826.2012.762973.
352 G. Pardon et al. / Sensors and Actuators B 212 (2015) 344–352

[35] L.R. Crilley, G.A. Ayoko, L. Morawska, Analysis of organic aerosols collected on Biographies
filters by Aerosol Mass Spectrometry for source identification, Anal. Chim. Acta
803 (2013) 91–96, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aca.2013.07.013.
[36] E. Miaskiewicz-Peska, M. Lebkowska, Comparison of aerosol and Gaspard Pardon obtained his BSc and MSc degrees in Micromechanical Engineer-
bioaerosol collection on air filters, Aerobiologia 28 (2012) 185–193, ing at EPFL Swiss Institute of Technology in Lausanne, Switzerland in 2008. During
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10453-011-9223-1. his master, he specialized in Micro and Nanosystems engineering. He obtained his
[37] H.F. Kraemer, H.F. Johnstone, Collection of aerosol particles in presence of elec- PhD degree in Electrical Engineering at KTH Royal Institute of Technology in Stock-
trostatic fields – industrial & engineering chemistry, Ind. Eng. Chem. (1955) holm, Sweden, in 2014. He is a member of the Micro and Nanosystem department
(ACS Publications). as post-doctoral researcher and his research interest includes design and fabrica-
[38] A. Miller, G. Frey, G. King, C. Sunderman, A handheld electrostatic precipita- tion of micro and nanosystems for biomedical and energy applications, as well as
tor for sampling airborne particles and nanoparticles, Aerosol Sci. Technol. 44 theoretical studies of electrokinetic transport in fluidics systems.
(2010) 417–427, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02786821003692063.
[39] E.M. Kettleson, B. Ramaswami, C.J. Hogan Jr., M.-H. Lee, G.A. Statyukha, Laila Ladhani studied Astrophysics at Western University in London, Canada, and
P. Biswas, et al., Airborne virus capture and inactivation by an elec- graduated with a Bachelor’s in 2008. She then went on to study in the field of nano-
trostatic particle collector, Environ. Sci. Technol. 43 (2009) 5940–5946, technology receiving her Master’s in Nanobiophysics from TU Dresden in Dresden,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/es803289w. Germany. She currently works with Professor Wouter van der Wijngaart at the
[40] L.S. Christensen, K.E. Brehm, J. Skov, K.W. Harlow, J. Christensen, B. Haas, Detec- Micro and Nanosystems department at KTH. She is involved in the EU-based RAPP-
tion of foot-and-mouth disease virus in the breath of infected cattle using ID project focusing on the development of integrated, rapid, PoC breath sampling
a hand-held device to collect aerosols, J. Virol. Methods 177 (2011) 44–48, devices. Specifically, diagnosis platforms for infectious diseases, integration of flui-
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jviromet.2011.06.011. dic devices into compact, lab-on-chip devices, ESP-based breath sampling, as well
[41] T. Han, G. Mainelis, Design and development of an electrostatic sampler for as QCM-based biosensors
bioaerosols with high concentration rate, J. Aerosol Sci. 39 (2008) 1066–1078,
Niklas Sandström was born in Nynäshamn, Sweden. In 2007, he graduated with a
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jaerosci.2008.07.009.
master’s degree in Engineering Biology, an inter-disciplinary education with a spe-
[42] M. Tan, F. Shen, M. Yao, T. Zhu, Development of an automated electrostatic sam-
cial emphasis on Biosensors and Microsystems, at Linköping University, Sweden.
pler (AES) for bioaerosol detection, Aerosol Sci. Technol. 45 (9) (2011) (Taylor
He is now a PhD-student in the department of Micro and Nanosystems, School of
& Francis Online).
Electrical Engineering, KTH, Sweden, under the supervision of prof. W. van der Wijn-
[43] P.C.H. Li, Microfluidic Lab-on-a-Chip for Chemical and Biological Analysis and
gaart. Niklas’ main research focus is on technology for future medical applications,
Discovery, CRC Press, 2005.
in particular point-of-care and rapid diagnostics. His work includes development of
[44] T. Frisk, D. Rnnholm, W. van der Wijngaart, G.R. Stemme, A micromachined
novel manufacturing techniques, biosensor and instrument integration, bioassays,
interface for airborne sample-to-liquid transfer and its application in a biosen-
microfluidic designs and aerosol/liquid sample handling.
sor system, Lab Chip 6 (2006) 1504, http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/b612526n.
[45] T. Frisk, N. Sandström, L. Eng, W. van der Wijngaart, P. Månsson, G. Stemme, An Maxime Ettori received his Master’s from EPFL in Lausanne. He completed his thesis
integrated QCM-based narcotics sensing microsystem, Lab Chip 8 (2008) 1648, project at the Micro and Nanosystems department at KTH.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/b800487k.
[46] G. Konvalina, H. Haick, Sensors for breath testing: from nanomaterials Gleb Lobov received his MSc degree in Robotic engineering in 2008 at Bauman
to comprehensive disease detection, Acc. Chem. Res. 47 (2014) 66–76, Moscow State University, continued his education and received another MSc degree
http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/ar400070m. in Nanotechnology at Royal Institute of Technology in 2011. His current research,
[47] N. Sandström, T. Frisk, G. Stemme, W. van der Wijngaart, Electrohydrody- as a part of his PhD project, lies in the branch of the electro-optical polymers which
namic enhanced transport and trapping of airborne particles to a microfluidic takes place at the department of optics and nanophotonics at KTH.
air–liquid interface, in: IEEE 21st International Conference on MEMS, 2008, pp.
595–598. Wouter van der Wijngaart (www.kth.se/profile/wouter) was born in Belgium
[48] I.B. Tager, J. Balmes, F. Lurmann, L. Ngo, S. Alcorn, N. Künzli, Chronic exposure in 1973. Wouter received the MSc degree in Electrotechnical Engineering at the
to ambient ozone and lung function in young adults, Epidemiology 16 (2005) Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium, in 1996. Wouter received the PhD degree
751–759. in microsystem technology at the KTH Royal Institute of Technology in 2002, where
[49] A.J. Chauhan, M.T. Krishna, A.J. Frew, S.T. Holgate, Exposure to nitrogen dioxide in 2005 he promoted to Associate Professor and in 2010 to full Professor. Wouter
(NO2 ) and respiratory disease risk, Rev. Environ. Health 13 (1998) 73–90. is currently leading the research in micro- and nanofluidic systems at KTH, with a
[50] D.F. Colas, A. Ferret, D.Z. Pai, D.A. Lacoste, C.O. Laux, Ionic wind generation by research focus on both lab-on-chip diagnostic systems and microsystems for energy
a wire-cylinder-plate corona discharge in air at atmospheric pressure, J. Appl. and pneumatic applications. Wouter is co-founder of the companies Easypark, a
Phys. 108 (2010) 103306, http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3514131. mobile parking payment system provider, MyFuelCell, developing and selling micro
[51] N.E. Jewell-Larsen, S.V. Karpov, I.A. Krichtafovitch, V. Jayanty, C. Hsu, A.V. Mami- fuel cells for mobile applications, and Mercene Labs, developing and selling novel
shev, Modeling of corona-induced electrohydrodynamic flow with COMSOL polymer systems for labs-on-chip.
multiphysics, in: Proc. ESA Annual Meeting on Electrostatics, 1, 2008.

You might also like