Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stockholders' Equity: Overview of Exercises, Problems, and Cases
Stockholders' Equity: Overview of Exercises, Problems, and Cases
Stockholders’ Equity
OVERVIEW OF EXERCISES, PROBLEMS, AND CASES
Estimated
Time in
Learning Outcomes Exercises Minutes Level
1. Identify the components of the Stockholders’ Equity category 1 10 Easy
of the balance sheet and the accounts found in each 2 10 Mod
component.
11-1
11-2 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
Problems Estimated
and Time in
Learning Outcomes Alternates Minutes Level
1. Identify the components of the Stockholders’ Equity category 1 20 Mod
of the balance sheet and the accounts found in each 12* 15 Mod
component. 14* 15 Diff
Estimated
Time in
Learning Outcomes Cases Minutes Level
1. Identify the components of the Stockholders’ Equity category 1* 15 Mod
of the balance sheet and the accounts found in each 3* 10 Mod
component.
QUESTIONS
1. The two major components of stockholders’ equity are contributed capital and
retained earnings. Accounts in contributed capital include the Common Stock and
Preferred Stock accounts and the Additional Paid-in Capital accounts. The primary
account in the retained earnings component is the Retained Earnings account.
2. The number of shares authorized is the total number that the corporation can issue,
as indicated in the corporate charter. Shares issued are shares that have been
distributed to stockholders. Shares outstanding is the number of shares in the
stockholders’ hands as of the balance sheet date. The difference between shares
issued and shares outstanding is normally the result of treasury stock.
3. Firms designate the par value of the stock for legal reasons. Par value is not an
indication of the selling price or market value of the stock.
4. The balance of the Retained Earnings account is not equal to the firm’s net income.
The account indicates the amount of income for all previous years that has been
earned but has not been paid out as dividends to the stockholders.
5. Preferred stock normally must be paid a dividend before a dividend may be paid to
common stock. However, even if the preferred stock is cumulative, preferred
stockholders do not have a right to dividends in arrears until the time the dividend is
declared.
6. Preferred stock is generally a lower risk stock that provides a stable return but does
not provide for the potentially high return of a common stock. The advantages of
preferred stock are the safety and stability it provides.
7. Common shareholders are considered residual shareholders because the amount of
book value of preferred shareholders is subtracted from total stockholders’ equity
before the common book value is determined. Common shareholders also have a
right to the earnings after preferred dividends are distributed.
8. The asset should be recorded at the fair market value of the consideration given (the
stock) or the fair market value of the consideration received (the asset), whichever is
more readily determinable. Fair market value may be determined by reference to
sales of the stock on the stock exchange or, in some cases, by an appraisal of the
asset.
9. Treasury stock is stock that has been issued and then repurchased by a corporation.
There are a variety of uses of treasury stock, including use in employee benefit
plans, prevention of an unwanted takeover, and reduction in the number of shares of
stock to improve financial ratios. Treasury Stock is a contra equity account and is
shown as a reduction of stockholders’ equity.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-5
10. Gains or losses on treasury stock are not recorded on the income statement. Rather,
the amounts are shown as additions or deductions of stockholders’ equity. Additions
appear in the Paid-in Capital—Treasury Stock account. Deductions reduce that
account or the Retained Earnings account if the Paid-in Capital account is not
present. No income statement amounts are recorded to prevent manipulation of
income by firms who would buy and sell their own stock in order to show a “profit.”
11. Firms do not pay out all of their income as dividends because there are other
alternative uses of the income. Management’s objective should be to maximize the
wealth of the stockholders. Sometimes that can be achieved by paying dividends;
other times it can be achieved by retaining the income and reinvesting it in
alternatives that will produce a satisfactory return.
12. A stock dividend occurs when a company issues shares of stock to its existing
stockholders instead of paying cash as a dividend. Stock dividends should be
recorded as a reduction of Retained Earnings and an increase in Stock Dividend
Distributable. Therefore, stock dividends do not affect total stockholders’ equity.
Normally, retained earnings is reduced by the market value of the stock distributed.
13. It is better to receive a stock dividend when the company is using earnings to
expand and reinvest in the business. A cash dividend is preferred by investors who
need the cash to meet current needs, like senior citizens.
14. Stock dividends do not reduce the par value per share of the stock. Stock splits do
reduce the par value per share. Splits do not require any journal entry but should be
noted in the notes that accompany the balance sheet.
15. Book value per share is calculated as the total net assets of the corporation divided
by the number of shares of common stock. It is a measure of the rights of the
common stockholders to the assets of the firm in the event of liquidation. It does not
mean that the common stockholders will receive a dividend equal to the book value
per share.
16. The market value per share of the stock is related to the income of the corporation,
but many other factors also influence the market value. General economic factors
such as inflation, factors related to the particular industry, tax consequences, and
the mood of current and potential investors all have an impact on the market value of
the stock.
17. The statement of stockholders’ equity explains all reasons for the difference between
the beginning and ending balances of each of the accounts in the stockholders’
equity category. The retained earnings statement details the changes in only one
component of stockholders’ equity—retained earnings.
18. The advantages of organizing as a corporation include limited liability and the
increased ability to raise funds from a wider group of unrelated investors.
Companies choose not to incorporate because it costs to file papers with the state
and to issue stock, and corporations must file annual reports, open to public
inspection.
11-6 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
EXERCISES
1. a. The effect on the accounting equation of the issuance of common stock for cash
is as follows:
b. The effect on the accounting equation of issuing common stock for a building is
as follows:
c. The effect on the accounting equation of the March 18, 2007, issuance of
preferred stock is as follows:
d. The effect on the accounting equation of the April 12, 2007, issuance of
common stock is as follows:
3. The balance sheet does not indicate the market value of the stock. Market value is a
function of the demand for the stock at various economic indicators such as interest
rates and inflation.
11-10 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
b. The effect on the accounting equation of the March 1 purchase of treasury stock
is as follows:
2. The company sold treasury stock at amounts less than those it had paid to reacquire
the stock. In a sense, the company had a loss of $8 per share on the stock
purchased February 1 and $1 per share on the stock purchased March 1, but the
“loss” is not shown on the income statement. Instead, the “loss” reduces
stockholders’ equity.
Dividends Retained
Payable 100,000 Earnings (100,000)
Stock
Dividend
Distribut-
able 40,000*
Additional
Paid-in
Capital—
Common
Stock 80,000
Retained
Earnings (120,000)**
b. The effect on the accounting equation of the January 30 issuance of the stock
dividend is as follows:
Common
Stock 40,000
Stock Divi-
dend Dis-
tributable (40,000)
2. WORTHY COMPANY
PARTIAL BALANCE SHEET
JANUARY 31, 2007
Stockholders’ Equity
Common Stock, $10 par, 44,000 shares issued and outstanding $440,000*
Additional paid-in capital—common stock 180,000**
Retained earnings 280,000***
Total stockholders’ equity $900,000
*40,000 shares × 110% × $10 par = $440,000.
**$100,000 + $80,000 = $180,000.
***$400,000 – $120,000 = $280,000.
Overall, these transactions did not change total stockholders’ equity. They
reclassified some equity from the retained earnings category to contributed capital.
3. Stockholders’ equity:
Common stock, $5 par value, 138,000 shares
issued and outstanding $ 690,000
Additional paid-in capital* 570,000
Retained earnings [$1,240,000 – (9,000 × $20)] 1,060,000
Total stockholders’ equity $2,320,000
*9,000 shares × ($20 – $10) = $90,000 from May 1.
$90,000 + $480,000 = $570,000
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-15
RYDE INC.
STATEMENT OF STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY
FOR THE YEAR ENDED APRIL 30, 2007
Additional Total
Common Paid-in Retained Stockholders’
Stock Capital Earnings Equity
Balance, May 1, 2006 $345,000 $1,298,000 $3,013,000 $4,656,000
Net income 556,000 556,000
Dividends (78,000) (78,000)
Balance, April 30, 2007 $345,000 $1,298,000 $3,491,000 $5,134,000
Note: Even though they are financing transactions, no cash changed hands in the
transactions marked “N.” As a result, they would not be listed under the financing
category of the statement of cash flows. However, they would be reported in a
supplementary schedule relating to the statement of cash flows.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-17
Note: Even though they are financing transactions, no cash changed hands in the
transactions marked “N.” As a result, they would not be listed under the financing
category of the statement of cash flows. However, they would be reported in a
supplementary schedule relating to the statement of cash flows.
2. Clifford would report the cash dividend payments of $380,000 as a cash outflow in
the financing activities category of its 2007 statement of cash flows.
11-18 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
1. The owner’s equity section of Par Golf’s balance sheet consists of the owner’s
capital account as follows:
Woods, Capital ($50,000 – $10,000 – $20,000) $20,000
PROBLEMS
PEELER COMPANY
PARTIAL BALANCE SHEET
DECEMBER 31, 2007
Stockholders’ Equity
Preferred stock, $100 par, 7%, 1,000 shares authorized, 500
shares issued and outstanding $ 50,000
Common stock, $5 par, 10,000 shares authorized, 5,000 shares
issued, 4,600 shares outstanding 25,000
Additional paid-in capital—preferred stock 10,000
Additional paid-in capital—common stock 365,000
Additional paid-in capital—treasury stock 500
Total contributed capital $450,500
Retained earnings 13,500
Less: treasury stock, 400 shares, common (24,000)
Total stockholders’ equity $440,000
1/10 Preferred stock: 500 × $100 par = $50,000 credit
Additional paid-in capital: 500 × ($120 – $100) = $10,000 credit
1/10 Common stock: 4,000 × $5 par = $20,000 credit
Additional paid-in capital: 4,000 × ($80 – $5) = $300,000 credit
1/20 Common stock: 1,000 × $5 par = $5,000 credit
Additional paid-in capital: 1,000 × ($70 – $5) = $65,000 credit
Acquisition of treasury stock:
Treasury stock: 500 × $60 = $30,000 debit
Resale of treasury stock:
Treasury stock: 100 × $60 = $6,000 credit
Additional paid-in capital: 100 × ($65 – $60) = $500 credit
12/31 Net income: Retained earnings $40,000 credit
12/31 Preferred dividend:
(500 × $100 par × 7%) = $3,500 debit to retained earnings
Common stock dividend:
4,600 outstanding × $5 per share = $23,000 debit to retained earnings
11-20 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
1. Common stock has ownership privileges. The residual of the company belongs to
the common shareholders.
Preferred stock has preference over common stockholders in dividend payouts.
Bonds earn interest that is a legal obligation of the company.
2. The return on the preferred stock depends upon its issue price. If it is assumed that
the stock is issued at par value, the return is 8%. Since all three instruments yield
the same rate of return, 8%, Ellen should choose to invest in the bonds because
they carry the lowest risk. As risk increases, the expected rate of return on an
investment should increase.
1. The memo to the board of directors should include the following points:
a. A stock dividend does not change the total stockholders’ equity amount.
b. A stock dividend does reduce the balance of Retained Earnings and transfers the
amount of the stock dividend to the contributed capital component of
stockholders’ equity.
c. A stock dividend results in additional shares of stock outstanding. Therefore, it
affects the financial ratios of the firm. For example, book value per share and
earnings per share decline as a result of the stock dividend.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-21
Explanations:
1/10 Preferred Stock: 500 × $100 par = $50,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 500 × ($120 – $100) = $10,000 increase
1/10 Common Stock: 4,000 × $5 = $20,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 4,000 × ($80 – $5) = $300,000 increase
1/20 Common Stock: 1,000 × $5 par = $5,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 1,000 × ($70 – $5) = $65,000 increase
Acquisition of treasury stock:
Treasury Stock: 500 × $60 = $30,000 decrease
Resale of treasury stock:
Treasury Stock: 100 × $60 = $6,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 100 × ($65 – $60) = $500 increase
12/31 Net income:
Retained Earnings: $40,000 increase
12/31 Cash dividends:
Preferred Stock:
(500 × $100 × 7%) = $3,500 decrease in Retained Earnings
Common Stock:
4,600 outstanding × $5 per share = $23,000 decrease in Retained
Earnings
11-24 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
1. Comprehensive Income for the year ended January 31, 2005 (in millions):
Net income $10,267
Foreign currency translation adjustment 2,130
Hedge accounting adjustment (194)
Minimum pension liability adjustment (93)
Comprehensive income $12,110
The effect of including these items on the income statement would have been to
increase net income. While this would show all sources of income for the period,
these numbers could lead readers to believe this is an ordinary result of operations.
2. Some items, such as the market value adjustments on investments and the foreign
currency translation adjustment, are considered to be “paper” gains or losses; these
adjustments are not presented on the income statement because they are also
unrealized. These adjustments are often volatile and may be quite sizable. Further,
no cash inflows or outflows directly result from these adjustments. Accordingly some
of the stockholders of Wal-Mart’s may prefer that these items be reported on the
statement of stockholders’ equity. Including these items on the income statement
might make it difficult for investors to predict future income. On the other hand,
because this information may be useful in evaluating the effectiveness of the
company’s management, others might prefer to see these items reported on the
income statement.
The dividend declared on December 31, 2007, will not be paid until 2008. As a
result, the payment of this dividend will appear as a cash outflow in the financing
section of the 2008 statement of cash flows.
1.
Sales (108,000)
Expenses 84,000
Income
Summary 24,000
To close revenues and expenses.
Chong Yu,
Capital 24,000 (24,000)
To close income summary.
Chong Yu,
Capital (12,000)
Chong Yu,
Drawing 12,000
To close the drawings account.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-27
Beginning balance $ 0
Investment by owner 120,000
$120,000
Add: Net income 24,000
Less: Withdrawals (12,000)
Ending balance $132,000
2. The capital account indicates the amount of the owner’s investment that has not
been withdrawn. It is based on accrual accounting and does not indicate the amount
of cash in the business.
11-28 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
Nerise O’Brien
Beginning balance $ 0 $ 0
Add: Investments 25,000 100,000
Allocation of net income 11,200 10,000
$36,200 $110,000
Less: Withdrawals *13,200 4,000
Ending balance $23,000 $106,000
MULTI-CONCEPT PROBLEMS
2. HORTON INC.
PARTIAL BALANCE SHEET
DECEMBER 31, 20XX
Stockholders’ Equity
Common stock, 2,000,000 authorized, 220,000 issued,
218,000 outstanding, $0.50 par value $110,000
Additional paid-in capital ($400,000 + $90,000) 490,000
Retained earnings (–$10,900 + $180,000) 169,100
Less: Treasury stock (16,000)
Total Stockholders’ Equity $753,100
1. IVES INC.
BALANCE SHEET
AS OF XXX
Assets
Cash $ 3,500
Account receivable 5,000
Plant, property, and equipment 108,000
Total assets $116,500
Liabilities
Accounts payable $ 5,500
Dividends payable 1,500
Stockholders’ Equity
Common stock, $1 par, 100,000 shares outstanding 100,000
Additional paid-in capital 11,000
Retained earnings (1,000)
Treasury stock (500)
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity $116,500
Treasury stock is not an asset; it is a contra owners’ equity account. Retained
earnings is not an asset; it is the accumulated, undistributed profit of the company.
2. The Retained Earnings account has a debit balance because the accumulated
earnings of the company represent a net loss and/or dividends paid out have
exceeded the cumulative earnings.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-31
ALTERNATE PROBLEMS
KEBLER COMPANY
PARTIAL BALANCE SHEET
DECEMBER 31, 2007
Stockholders’ Equity
Preferred stock, $100 par, 7%, 2,000 shares authorized,
1,000 shares issued $100,000
Common stock, $5 par, 20,000 shares authorized, 10,000
shares issued, 9,100 shares outstanding 50,000
Additional paid-in capital—preferred stock 20,000
Additional paid-in capital—common stock 730,000
Additional paid-in capital—treasury stock 500
Total contributed capital $900,500
Retained earnings 27,500
Less: Treasury stock, 900 shares, common (54,000)
Total stockholders’ equity $874,000
1/10 Preferred Stock: 1,000 × $100 par = $100,000 credit
Additional Paid-in Capital: 1,000 × ($120 – $100) = $20,000 credit
1/10 Common Stock: 8,000 × $5 = $40,000 credit
Additional Paid-in Capital: 8,000 × ($80 – $5) = $600,000 credit
1/20 Common Stock: 2,000 × $5 par = $10,000 credit
Additional Paid-in Capital: 2,000 × ($70 – $5) = $130,000 credit
Treasury stock acquired:
Treasury Stock: 1,000 × $60 = $60,000 debit
Treasury stock resold:
Treasury Stock: 100 × $60 = $6,000 credit
Additional Paid-in Capital: 100 × ($65 – $60) = $500 credit
12/31 Net income:
Retained Earnings: $80,000 credit
12/31 Dividend:
Preferred: 1,000 × $100 par × 7% = $7,000 debit
Common: 9,100 shares × $5 = $45,500 debit
11-32 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
2. Rob should invest in the common stock because the return is greatest. Rob must be
aware, however, that the risk is also the greatest. If the company fails to perform as
it has in the past and is expected to perform in the future, Rob not only would lose
dividends but might lose the investment in stock.
1. March 1 Cash dividends increase (or Retained Earnings decrease) and total
stockholders’ equity decreases.
April 1 Total stockholders’ equity remains unchanged.
June 1 Common Stock Distributable increases by $8,000 (10,000 × 8% ×
$10). Additional Paid-in Capital—Common Stock increases by $12,800
(10,000 × 8% × $16). Retained Earnings decrease by $20,800. Total
stockholders’ equity does not change.
July 1 Common Stock Distributable decreases and Common Stock increases
by $8,000.
Sept. 1 Retained Earnings and total stockholders’ equity decrease by $7,560
[(10,000 + 800) × $0.70].
Oct. 1 Total stockholders’ equity does not change.
Dec. 1 The par value of common stock changes from $10 to $3.33 as the
number of shares issued and outstanding triples from 10,800 to
32,400, but the total par value does not change. The total stockholders’
equity also does not change.
11-34 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
2. SVENBERG INC.
PARTIAL BALANCE SHEET
DECEMBER 31, 2007
Stockholders’ Equity
Preferred stock, $80 par, 8%, 1,000 shares issued
and outstanding $ 80,000
Common stock, $3.33 par, 32,400* shares issued
and outstanding 108,000**
Additional paid-in capital—preferred 60,000
Additional paid-in capital—common 237,800***
Total contributed capital $ 485,800
Retained earnings 2,665,240****
Total stockholders’ equity $3,151,040
*(10,000 + 800 stock dividend) × 3 (stock split) = 32,400
**Difference due to rounding of par value
***$225,000 + $12,800 stock dividend = $237,800
****$1,980,000 – $6,400 cash dividend – $20,800 stock dividend – $7,560 cash
dividend + $720,000 net income = $2,665,240
Explanations:
1/10 Preferred Stock: 1,000 × $100 par = $100,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 1,000 × ($120 – $100) = $20,000 increase
1/10 Common Stock: 8,000 × $5 = $40,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 8,000 × ($80 – $5) = $600,000 increase
1/20 Common Stock: 2,000 × $5 par = $10,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 2,000 × ($70 – $5) = $130,000 increase
Acquisition of treasury stock:
Treasury Stock: 1,000 × $60 = $60,000 decrease
Resale of treasury stock:
Treasury Stock: 100 × $60 = $6,000 increase
Additional Paid-in Capital: 100 × ($65 – $60) = $500 increase
12/31 Net income:
Retained Earnings: $80,000 increase
12/31 Cash dividends:
Preferred Stock:
(1,000 × $100 × 7%) = $7,000 decrease in Retained Earnings
Common Stock:
9,100 outstanding × $5 per share = $45,500 decrease in
Retained Earnings
11-36 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
1. Other comprehensive income includes items that are not in the traditional net
income amount but are included in the broader measure of comprehensive income.
These items include: foreign currency translation adjustments, adjustments in the
market values of certain investments, and occasionally an adjustment for the
minimum pension liability amount.
2. Other transactions that affect stockholders’ equity include: issuing stock or
repurchasing stock as treasury stock, cash dividends, and stock dividends.
3. Cash dividends reduce stockholders’ equity. A stock dividend changes the balance
of accounts within the stockholders’ equity category, but the total amount of
stockholders’ equity is not affected.
The following transactions would not appear in the financing activities section of the
statement of cash flows:
Kebler obtained the building site by issuing 2,000 shares of common stock; no cash
changed hands. As a result, this transaction would be reported as a noncash
investing and financing transaction on the statement of cash flows.
Assuming the indirect method is used, the company’s 2007 net income would
appear as the first item under the cash flows from operating activities section of the
statement of cash flows.
The dividend declared, on December 31, 2007, will not be paid until 2008. As a
result, the payment of this dividend will appear as a cash outflow in the financing
section of the 2008 statement of cash flows.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-37
1. Katz Kan
Salary to Katz $ 40,000
Interest to Kan: 10% × $600,000 $ 60,000
Remainder in 2:1 ratio:
($30,000 – $100,000) × 2/3 = (46,667)
($30,000 – $100,000) × 1/3 = (23,333)
Total distributed $ (6,667) $ 36,667
Note: Generally, salary and interest are allocated first to the partners’ accounts and
then, if there is a deficit, the deficit is allocated in the agreed ratio. The result, in this
case, is a negative amount distributed to Katz.
1.
Sales (135,000)
Expenses 105,000
Income
Summary 30,000
To close revenues and expenses.
Beginning balance $ 0
Investments by owner 150,000
$150,000
Add: Net income 30,000
Less: Withdrawals (15,000)
Ending balance $165,000
2. The capital account indicates the amount of the owner’s income that has not been
withdrawn. It is based on accrual accounting and does not indicate the amount of
cash in the business.
11-40 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
Locke Keyes
Beginning balance $ 0 $ 0
Add: Investments 35,000 140,000
Allocation of net income 11,000 8,600
$46,000 $148,600
Less: Withdrawals 8,400 5,600
Ending balance $37,600 $143,000
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-41
2. Contributed capital is the amount given in exchange for assets. In the first
transaction, the company gave stock for cash, an asset. In the second transaction,
the company gave stock for a patent, also an asset. Contributed capital may also be
given for payment of debt. Retained earnings is the second category of owners’
equity and it represents the amount of undistributed, accumulated earnings of the
company.
Hilton’s retained earnings balance is the income of $340,000 less dividends of
$9,500 = $330,500.
11-42 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
3. The book value of the common stock at the end of the year is computed as follows:
Stockholders’ Equity:
Common stock $ 20,000
Additional paid-in capital—common stock 180,000
Retained earnings ($340,000 – $9,500) 330,500
Less: Treasury stock (10,000)
Total $520,500
Number of shares of stock outstanding = 10,000 + 10,000 – 1,000 = 19,000
Book value per share = $520,500/19,000 = $27.39
1. GRAINFIELD INC.
PARTIAL BALANCE SHEET
Stockholders’ Equity
Preferred stock, 10,000 shares authorized, 5,000
shares issued and outstanding, $10 par, 5% $ 50,000
Common stock, 1,000,0000 shares authorized, 100,000 shares
issued and 97,000 shares outstanding, $1 par value 100,000
Additional paid-in capital 68,400
Retained earnings 54,900
Treasury stock, 3,000 shares of common (15,000)
Total Stockholders’ Equity $258,300
DECISION CASES
LO 1,8 DECISION CASE 11-1 COMPARING TWO COMPANIES IN THE SAME INDUSTRY:
FOOT LOCKER AND FINISH LINE
2. Foot Locker’s Retained Earnings account increased during the period from $1,386
million to $1,601 million.
Finish Line’s Retained Earnings account increased from $206 million to $263 million.
Retained earnings is increased by the net income for the period and reduced by
dividends that are declared to stockholders.
3. Foot Locker had a total stockholders’ equity of $2,027 million while Finish Line had
$428 million.
The dollar amount of stockholders’ equity, by itself, does not indicate the overall
position of the company because the two companies are not the same size. Both
companies are solid companies and have a large amount of value to the
stockholders as reflected by total stockholders’ equity.
1. The company had only one source of cash from financing activities during the year:
issuance of common stock.
3. When treasury stock is purchased, cash is reduced in the asset category and total
stockholders’ equity is reduced by the same amount.
11-44 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
1. The purpose of this problem is to allow students to see the similarities and
differences between a liability and an equity. In the problem, the loan of First
Company is very similar to the preferred stock of Second Company. Both securities
indicate annual payments of 8% (interest or dividend). Further, the stock carries a
mandatory redemption feature that indicates it must be repaid or redeemed at the
end of five years.
Note: There are specific FASB and SEC guidelines on the classification of preferred
stock with mandatory redemption features that you may wish to ask the students to
reference. Especially note the FASB difficulties with SFAS 150.
There may, however, be differences between the securities of First and Second
companies. Legally, the loan payable has a right to assets before stock. Also, the
preferred stock dividend is cumulative, but that is not the same as interest on a loan.
Stockholders do not have the right to dividends until they have been declared, even
when the stock is cumulative.
Preferred Stock—Preferred stock has no voting rights. The company is not obligated to
pay dividends until they are declared; however, the cumulative feature requires that the
company pay preferred shareholders all dividends in arrears before common
shareholders receive a dividend.
If one person purchased all 50,000 shares of common stock, the new investor would
own 11% (50/450) of the company. The original owners would own 18% (80/450) of the
company. If one or two of the original owners purchased the stock, the power could shift
to those shareholders. Dividends are never required on common stock. They become a
legal obligation of the company only after they are declared.
In order to develop a recommendation, the issues concerned must be evaluated
more thoroughly. If the primary concern is the ability to monitor cash flow, then common
stock is more attractive. However, common stock is not attractive if the current owners
are concerned that additional shares of stock may result in loss of voting control of the
company. One solution may be to issue common stock that allows the current
stockholders the right to maintain their ownership percentage. Another solution may be
to issue a second class of common stock that does not have equal voting rights.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-45
The ethical issue in this case is whether or not Jim Brock acted improperly when he
advised his father to buy shares of Hubbard Inc. stock. Surprisingly, in discussing this
case with students, many students do not see that Brock has a professional
responsibility to his employer. Further, most students are not aware of the term “insider
information.” Issues that should be discussed include the following:
1. Was anyone harmed by Brock’s actions, e.g., the parties that sold the stock at a low
price?
2. Does it matter if Brock himself profited or if some other party purchased stock based
on his knowledge?
3. Do brokers and analysts receive information about the firm that is not available to
the public? Doesn’t everyone engage in insider information?
4. If Brock decides he did act unethically, what action should he take to correct the
situation?
5. What company policies or procedures could be adopted to ensure that similar
situations do not arise in the future?
The company had preferred stock authorized but none was issued during the year. The
company had two classes of common stock: Class A common stock and Class B
common stock.
.
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-47
Part 3
2. Alternative A. If the equipment had been acquired under an operating lease instead
of a capital lease, the transaction would have been as follows:
BALANCE SHEET INCOME STATEMENT
Assets = Liabilities + Stockholders’ Equity + Revenues – Expenses
GRIFFIN INC.
INCOME STATEMENT
FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2007
(IN MILLIONS)
Revenues $ 50.00
Expenses:
Rent on leased asset $ 1.50
Depreciation—other assets 3.20
Other expenses 27.40
Income tax (30% rate) 5.40
Total expenses 37.50
Income before extraordinary loss $ 12.50
Extraordinary loss (net of $0.9 taxes) (2.10)
Net income $ 10.40
EPS before extraordinary loss $ 3.10
EPS extraordinary loss (0.53)
EPS—net income $ 2.57
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-49
Alternative B. If Griffin had issued bonds to purchase the asset, the transactions
would have been as follows:
BALANCE SHEET INCOME STATEMENT
Assets = Liabilities + Stockholders’ Equity + Revenues – Expenses
Equipment 8
Cash (8)
Griffin’s financial ratios if the asset is purchased with the proceeds from the issuance
of bonds are as follows:
Current ratio: $8.0/$4.0 = 2 to l
Debt-to-equity ratio: $16/$44 = 0.36
Net income = $10.4 million
EPS net income = ($10.4 million – $0.1 million)/4 = $2.57 (rounded).
The effect on the financial statements of purchasing an asset with the bond
proceeds is the same as if the asset were acquired with a capital lease (Part 1 of this
problem). Therefore, the financial ratios are the same as in Part 1.
Alternative C. If Griffin issued preferred stock and purchased the asset, the
transactions would be as follows:
BALANCE SHEET INCOME STATEMENT
Assets = Liabilities + Stockholders’ Equity + Revenues – Expenses
Equipment 8
Cash (8)
*The above entry records the dividend on the additional 200,000 shares of stock
issued. The total number of shares outstanding is 300,000.
11-52 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS MANUAL
*Because the dividend does not result in a tax deduction, the tax expense for the
year is increased. This transaction records the additional tax.
If Griffin issued stock to acquire the equipment, the financial statements would
appear as follows:
GRIFFIN INC.
BALANCE SHEET
DECEMBER 31, 2007
(IN MILLIONS)
Assets
Cash $ 2.8
Other current assets 6.4
Equipment (net of accumulated depreciation) 7.0
Other long-term assets 45.0
Total assets $61.2
Liabilities
Other current liabilities $ 3.0
Other long-term liabilities 6.0
Total liabilities $ 9.0
Stockholders’ Equity
Preferred stock $ 3.0
Additional paid-in capital on preferred stock 8.0
Common stock 4.0
Additional paid-in capital on common stock 16.0
Retained earnings 21.2
Total stockholders’ equity 52.2
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity $61.2
CHAPTER 11 • STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY 11-53
GRIFFIN, INC.
INCOME STATEMENT
FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2007
(IN MILLIONS)
Revenues $50.00
Expenses:
Depreciation of equipment $ 1.00
Depreciation—other assets 3.20
Other expenses 27.40
Income tax (30% rate) 5.50
Total expenses 37.10
Income before extraordinary loss $12.90
Extraordinary loss (net of $0.9 taxes) (2.10)
Net income $10.80
EPS before extraordinary loss $ 3.15
EPS extraordinary loss (0.53)
EPS—net income $ 2.62
The use of preferred stock to acquire the equipment causes a difference in the
financial statements because the preferred stock is part of stockholders’ equity,
rather than liabilities. Also, the dividend on preferred stock is not tax deductible,
whereas lease payments or interest payments are tax deductible. The resulting
impact is an increase in the current ratio, net income, and EPS but a decrease in the
debt-to-equity ratio.