C-FIX Test Version

1.43.1.0
Database version
2016.12.21.10.48
Date
22.12.2016

Product
performance
comparison

High performance anchor FH II #Spatec_Plus

versus

High performance anchor FH II-S #Sleeve_anchor_Spatec Plus Spatec

Plus

ETA-07/0025 24/05/2013 - 24/05/2018 Approval-No.:

Approval Document type

Expansion anchor Functioning principle Expansion anchor

Mechanical Anchor Type of construction Mechanical Anchor

Sleeve anchor Regulated fixing elements Sleeve anchor

Internal threaded sleeve anchor

Option 1 Use category Option 1

Pre-positioned installation Regulated installation modes Push-through installation

Push-through installation

None Regulated steel types galv.

galv.
A4
A4-70

no data available Design under fire exposure acc. TR020 no data available

no data available Design under seismic actions acc. TR045, no data available
performance category C1

no data available Design under seismic actions acc. TR045, no data available
performance category C2

no data available Dynamic action no data available

Temperature ranges

none Mortar- resp. resin type none

rFPc lOIC dSM5 ZyWj WL0hnw Page 1

10
 C-FIX Test Version
1.43.1.0
Database version
2016.12.21.10.48
Date
22.12.2016

Product
performance
comparison

High performance anchor FH II #Spatec_Plus

versus

High performance anchor FH II-S #Sleeve_anchor_Spatec Plus Spatec

Plus

Permissible tensile loads for uncracked concrete C20/25

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK) Decisive failure mode
Type hef Nperm Deviation Deviation Nperm hef Type FH II-S (gvz) Spatec Plus (S
[mm] [kN] [kN] [mm] +SK)

FH II 10 S 40 6.08 -20.2% +25.2% 7.62 50 Spatec Plus M6 Concrete cone Steel failure
failure
FH II 12 S 60 11.18 +17.4% -14.8% 9.52 60 Spatec Plus M8 Concrete cone Pullout failure
failure
FH II 15 S 70 14.08 +0.0% +0.0% 14.08 70 Spatec Plus M10 Concrete cone Concrete cone
failure failure
FH II 18 S 80 17.21 +0.0% +0.0% 17.21 80 Spatec Plus M12 Concrete cone Concrete cone
failure failure
FH II 24 S 100 24.05 +0.0% +0.0% 24.05 100 Spatec Plus M16 Concrete cone Concrete cone
failure failure
FH II 28 S 125 33.61 +0.0% +0.0% 33.61 125 Spatec Plus M20 Concrete cone Concrete cone
failure failure
FH II 32 S 150 44.18 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Concrete cone
failure

Hammer drilling Hammer drilling

dry hole dry hole
Standard anchorage depths Standard anchorage depths

Permissible tensile loads for cracked concrete C20/25

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK) Decisive failure mode
Type hef Nperm Deviation Deviation Nperm hef Type FH II-S (gvz) Spatec Plus (S
[mm] [kN] [kN] [mm] +SK)

FH II 10 S 40 3.57 +50.0% -33.3% 2.38 50 Spatec Plus M6 Pullout failure Pullout failure

FH II 12 S 60 5.71 +0.0% +0.0% 5.71 60 Spatec Plus M8 Pullout failure Pullout failure

FH II 15 S 70 7.62 +0.0% +0.0% 7.62 70 Spatec Plus M10 Pullout failure Pullout failure

FH II 18 S 80 11.90 -2.9% +3.0% 12.27 80 Spatec Plus M12 Pullout failure Concrete cone
failure
FH II 24 S 100 17.14 +0.0% +0.0% 17.14 100 Spatec Plus M16 Concrete cone Concrete cone
failure failure
FH II 28 S 125 23.96 +0.0% +0.0% 23.96 125 Spatec Plus M20 Concrete cone Concrete cone
failure failure
FH II 32 S 150 31.49 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Concrete cone
failure

Hammer drilling Hammer drilling

dry hole dry hole
Standard anchorage depths Standard anchorage depths

rFPc lOIC dSM5 ZyWj WL0hnw Page 2

10
 C-FIX Test Version
1.43.1.0
Database version
2016.12.21.10.48
Date
22.12.2016

Permissible shear loads for uncracked concrete C20/25

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK) Decisive failure mode
Type hef Vperm Deviation Deviation Vperm hef Type FH II-S (gvz) Spatec Plus (S
[mm] [kN] [kN] [mm] +SK)

FH II 10 S 40 6.08 -28.4% +39.8% 8.50 50 Spatec Plus M6 Pryout Pryout

FH II 12 S 60 18.86 +1.2% -1.2% 18.63 60 Spatec Plus M8 Steel failure Steel failure

FH II 15 S 70 28.17 +0.4% -0.4% 28.06 70 Spatec Plus M10 Pryout Steel failure

FH II 18 S 80 34.41 +0.0% +0.0% 34.41 80 Spatec Plus M12 Pryout Pryout

FH II 24 S 100 48.10 +0.0% +0.0% 48.10 100 Spatec Plus M16 Pryout Pryout

FH II 28 S 125 67.22 +0.0% +0.0% 67.22 125 Spatec Plus M20 Pryout Pryout

FH II 32 S 150 88.36 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Pryout

Hammer drilling Hammer drilling

dry hole dry hole
Standard anchorage depths Standard anchorage depths

Permissible shear loads for cracked concrete C20/25

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK) Decisive failure mode
Type hef Vperm Deviation Deviation Vperm hef Type FH II-S (gvz) Spatec Plus (S
[mm] [kN] [kN] [mm] +SK)

FH II 10 S 40 4.34 -28.4% +39.8% 6.06 50 Spatec Plus M6 Pryout Pryout

FH II 12 S 60 15.93 +0.0% +0.0% 15.93 60 Spatec Plus M8 Pryout Pryout

FH II 15 S 70 20.08 +0.0% +0.0% 20.08 70 Spatec Plus M10 Pryout Pryout

FH II 18 S 80 24.53 +0.0% +0.0% 24.53 80 Spatec Plus M12 Pryout Pryout

FH II 24 S 100 34.29 +0.0% +0.0% 34.29 100 Spatec Plus M16 Pryout Pryout

FH II 28 S 125 47.92 +0.0% +0.0% 47.92 125 Spatec Plus M20 Pryout Pryout

FH II 32 S 150 62.99 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Pryout

Hammer drilling Hammer drilling

dry hole dry hole
Standard anchorage depths Standard anchorage depths

Standard member thickness

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK)
Type hef hmin,1 Deviation Deviation hmin,1 hef Type
[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

FH II 10 S 40 80 -20.0% +25.0% 100 50 Spatec Plus M6

FH II 12 S 60 120 +0.0% +0.0% 120 60 Spatec Plus M8

FH II 15 S 70 140 +0.0% +0.0% 140 70 Spatec Plus M10

FH II 18 S 80 160 +0.0% +0.0% 160 80 Spatec Plus M12

FH II 24 S 100 200 +0.0% +0.0% 200 100 Spatec Plus M16

FH II 28 S 125 250 +0.0% +0.0% 250 125 Spatec Plus M20

FH II 32 S 150 300 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Spacings in uncracked concrete

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK)
Type hef smin Deviation Deviation smin hef Type
[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

FH II 10 S 40 40 -20.0% +25.0% 50 50 Spatec Plus M6

FH II 12 S 60 60 +0.0% +0.0% 60 60 Spatec Plus M8

FH II 15 S 70 70 +0.0% +0.0% 70 70 Spatec Plus M10

FH II 18 S 80 80 +0.0% +0.0% 80 80 Spatec Plus M12

FH II 24 S 100 100 +0.0% +0.0% 100 100 Spatec Plus M16

FH II 28 S 125 120 -4.0% +4.2% 125 125 Spatec Plus M20

FH II 32 S 150 160 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Increased edge distances are required

rFPc lOIC dSM5 ZyWj WL0hnw Page 3

10
 C-FIX Test Version
1.43.1.0
Database version
2016.12.21.10.48
Date
22.12.2016

Spacings in cracked concrete

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK)
Type hef smin Deviation Deviation smin hef Type
[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

FH II 10 S 40 40 -20.0% +25.0% 50 50 Spatec Plus M6

FH II 12 S 60 50 -16.7% +20.0% 60 60 Spatec Plus M8

FH II 15 S 70 60 -14.3% +16.7% 70 70 Spatec Plus M10

FH II 18 S 80 70 -12.5% +14.3% 80 80 Spatec Plus M12

FH II 24 S 100 80 -20.0% +25.0% 100 100 Spatec Plus M16

FH II 28 S 125 100 -20.0% +25.0% 125 125 Spatec Plus M20

FH II 32 S 150 120 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Increased edge distances are required

Edge distances for uncracked concrete

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK)
Type hef cmin Deviation Deviation cmin hef Type
[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

FH II 10 S 40 40 -50.0% +100.0% 80 50 Spatec Plus M6

FH II 12 S 60 60 -40.0% +66.7% 100 60 Spatec Plus M8

FH II 15 S 70 70 -30.0% +42.9% 100 70 Spatec Plus M10

FH II 18 S 80 80 -50.0% +100.0% 160 80 Spatec Plus M12

FH II 24 S 100 100 -44.4% +80.0% 180 100 Spatec Plus M16

FH II 28 S 125 120 -60.0% +150.0% 300 125 Spatec Plus M20

FH II 32 S 150 180 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Increased spacings are required

Edge distances for cracked concrete

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK)
Type hef cmin Deviation Deviation cmin hef Type
[mm] [mm] [mm] [mm]

FH II 10 S 40 40 -50.0% +100.0% 80 50 Spatec Plus M6

FH II 12 S 60 50 -50.0% +100.0% 100 60 Spatec Plus M8

FH II 15 S 70 60 -40.0% +66.7% 100 70 Spatec Plus M10

FH II 18 S 80 70 -56.3% +128.6% 160 80 Spatec Plus M12

FH II 24 S 100 80 -55.6% +125.0% 180 100 Spatec Plus M16

FH II 28 S 125 100 -66.7% +200.0% 300 125 Spatec Plus M20

FH II 32 S 150 120 - XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Increased spacings are required

Increasing factors for pullout

FH II-S (gvz) Advantage fischer Advantage Ramset Spatec Plus (S+SK)
Concrete strength ψcp Deviation Deviation ψcp Concrete strength
class class

C20/25 1.00 +0.0% +0.0% 1.00 C20/25

C25/30 1.10 +10.0% -9.1% 1.00 C25/30

C30/37 1.22 +0.0% +0.0% 1.22 C30/37

C35/45 1.34 +9.8% -9.0% 1.22 C35/45

C40/50 1.41 +0.0% +0.0% 1.41 C40/50

C45/55 1.48 +5.0% -4.7% 1.41 C45/55

C50/60 1.55 +0.0% +0.0% 1.55 C50/60

Valid for the smallest anchor size Valid for the smallest anchor size

rFPc lOIC dSM5 ZyWj WL0hnw Page 4

10
 C-FIX Test Version
1.43.1.0
Database version
2016.12.21.10.48
Date
22.12.2016

Remarks

Data basis FH II-S

Approval ETA-07/0025, Option 1, Validity: 24.05.2013 - 24.05.2018
Design method ETAG 001, Annex C, Method A
"http://content.fischer.de/cbfiles/fischer/zulassungen/eta/ZD_ETA_F_07-0025_%23SEN_%23AIP_
%23V7.pdf"

Spatec Plus
-
Design method ETAG 001, Annex C, Method A

Anchor loading The given permissible or recommended loads in this document do not consider any reduced
measures e.g. spacings or edge distances. It is assumed that the member thickness is much
enough that spalling will not occure.
For chemical anchors the cleaning of the drill hole must be done by means of the best possible
cleaning method which is given in the assessment.

Advantage fischer

Advantage Ramset

Identical values

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Anchor size only available at fischer.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Anchor size only available at Ramset.

rFPc lOIC dSM5 ZyWj WL0hnw Page 5

10