Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Telenor in Bangladesh 1: Tousif Khan Majlis Ashland University
Telenor in Bangladesh 1: Tousif Khan Majlis Ashland University
Telenor in Bangladesh 1: Tousif Khan Majlis Ashland University
Telenor in Bangladesh
Ashland University
Dr. Venkataramany
Date 04/22/2013
Telenor in Bangladesh 2
Table of Contents
i. Introduction
iii. Environment
a) Social
b) Religious
c) Political
d) Economic
e) Legal
f) Ethical
v. Summary
a) Other Factors to be considered
b) Communication Process
c) Expatriate Managers
vi. Conclusion
vii. References
Telenor in Bangladesh 3
i) Introduction:
As part of my individual final integrative research project which requires analyzing the
Bangladesh” as the topic of my final project. Telenor Group is one of the leading mobile
operators in the world, with close to 150 million mobile subscriptions. Launched in March 26,
1997, Grameenphone was the first Telenor venture in the Asian telecom market which is the
leading and largest telecommunications service provider in Bangladesh with more than 40.33
million subscribers as of January, 2013 and has about 5,100 full and temporary employees.
The reason behind choosing Telenor as the company and Bangladesh as the country is
due to the inspiration that 300,000 people are directly dependent on Grameenphone for their
livelihood, working for the Grameenphone as dealers, retailers, scratch card outlets, suppliers,
vendors, contractors and others. With the study of the international business venture of Telenor
in an emerging and developing country like Bangladesh, I would like to use this knowledge to
understand how a business firm functions in a global setting and identify the company’s strategic
environment is analyzed.
Telenor was founded in 1855 and builds on more than 155 years of telecom experience. It
operating in 18 markets. Approximately half of Telenor's employees work outside Norway. With
31,000 employees worldwide, Telenor Group is able to offer a wide range of telecom-related
services to consumers and enterprises. Telenor Group provides telecommunication, data and
Telenor in Bangladesh 4
media services in the Nordics, Central and Eastern Europe and Asia. Their main revenues come
from mobile operations, making them one of the world’s major mobile operators. Grameenphone
is the largest mobile phone operator in Bangladesh which is a joint venture enterprise between
Telenor and Grameen Telecom Corporation, a non-profit sister concern of the internationally
In a publication in the Global Telecom Business article titled “The Death of Distance in
Bangladesh” (2007) it was mentioned that “The biggest shareholder in GrameenPhone is a world
away, in climate and wealth. Telenor, the incumbent operator in Norway, owns 62% and has
nurtured the operation since it started. It's one of many investments Telenor has in international
businesses: there are others in Denmark, Sweden, Ukraine, Hungary, Montenegro, Thailand,
Malaysia and Pakistan. Telenor also holds minority interests in mobile operations in Russia and
Starting its operations on March 26, 1997, the Independence Day of Bangladesh,
Grameenphone has come a long way by being the pioneer of the then breakthrough initiative of
mobile to mobile telephony and became the first and only operator to cover 98% of the
iii) Environment
a) Social:
urbanized few. The cell phone was a luxury: a flouting accessory for the select elite. The
mass could not contemplate mobile telephony as being part of their lives. Grameenphone
started its journey with the Village Phone program: a pioneering initiative to empower
Grameenphone has always been a pioneer in introducing new products and services in the
local telecom market and was the first company to introduce GSM technology in
Bangladesh when it launched its services in March 1997. Socially the launching of
cellular telephone service by Grameenphone has been widely accepted by people from
different social background because it provided them a way of mobility to stay in touch
with their near and dear ones round the clock. In the Journal of Marketing Management
Ahmed T. Rashid and Mizan Rahman (2009) mentioned that “For villagers in general,
phones offer additional non-economic benefits such as improved law enforcement, more
rapid and effective communications during disasters, stronger kinship bonding, etc. In
sum, available evidence indicates that VPP had a positive impact on the people in rural
b) Religious:
Corporation, it enables rural people who normally cannot afford to own a telephone to
avail the service while providing the VP operators an opportunity to earn a living.
Although Bangladesh is a moderate Muslim country, yet there are comparatively more
conservative people in the rural areas of the country who do not encourage the free
mixing of women in the society outside their household. So during the launching of the
Village Phone Program, which also started in 1997, there was concern from religious
point of view whether it will lead to the empowerment of women which will no longer be
able to hold them back in their household only. According to the article “Grameen
Revisited: Investors Reach Out to the Poor” (2004) published in the DAC Journal, the
Telenor in Bangladesh 6
200,000 women living in rural areas who were considered as Village Phone operators.
c) Political:
Telenor was able to gain significantly from the early-mover advantage in the nascent
Ahmed T. Rashid and Mizan Rahman (2009) mentioned that the strategy of Telenor AS
needs more elaboration as it represents the case of a large MNC entering into the market
political and regulatory instability of Bangladesh made the venture highly risky. (p. 1055)
d) Economic:
markets could bite sooner rather than later” (p. 38). He also mentioned that the Nordic
unaffordable because of the spiral cost of foods. Telenor CEO John Fredrik Baksaas even
shared with Financial Times that “Inflationary pressures on daily necessities are hitting
ARPU (Average revenue per user) fell 24% year-on-year in Bangladesh and 14% in
was mentioned that the ARPUs in various markets continue to decrease owing to
increasing penetration of new services to offset the effect of low ARPU. Lower ARPU
e) Legal:
regulatory authority for this sector, overseeing licensing, policy etc. Organizations often
do have the privilege for not revealing the internal information by the excuse of corporate
secrets. A company like Grameenphone is also not likely to express the incidents of
hustles and tussles with its competitors or its bargaining with parties. The out of record
facts from the grapevines and some cover stories give us the idea that management has
strategic and operational fields. In case of external dealing, the company approaches
with the protocol used by the firms. As Grameenphone is a private Ltd corporation,
legislative affairs are treated according to the company Act. Some of the disputes have
been solved through the “Arbitration Act” as well. However, for keeping confidential the
organization never uncover its strategies or plan of actions in the public. The internal
matters of an organization are always a hard nut to crack where Grameenphone restricts
Month” (2011) “Telenor disputes a $400m tax bill from the government arising from a
dispute covering subsidiary Grameenphone's revenue share on the sale of SIM cards. ” (p.
10). In another article “Nobel Winner At War With Norway Partner” (2006) published in
the Fortune International, it was mentioned that when Dr. Md. Yunus traveled to Oslo to
receive the Nobel Peace Prize, he came prepared to fight for management control over
Grameenphone with Telenor as he believes that Telenor is sucking profits from the poor
Telenor in Bangladesh 8
of Bangladesh. Joanne Taffe (2008) in her article “Chain Reactions” published in the
Total telecom Magazine mentioned that Telenor argues that if any intentions about
transferring ownership were expressed at the time, they are now legally non-binding.
f) Ethical:
television program made by free-lance journalist Tom Heinemann which was shown on
Danish and Norwegian television. The documentary pointed to several areas of poor
towers for Telenor and Ericsson. Three major problems were reported: child labor, unsafe
working conditions, and pollution problems. (p. 363). Joanne Taffe (2008) in her article
“Chain Reactions” published in the Total telecom Magazine mentioned that Telenor says
Telenor's subsidiary Grameenphone was also fined multiple times and later sued
because they participated in illegal VOIP (Voice Over Internet Protocols) operations.
Commission) rules and as a result Grameenphone's offices were also raided in the
process. BTRC claimed that the regulator and government were deprived from large
Grameenphone's profits fell 32% when BTRC forced Grameenphone to cease VOIP
24.5 million for illegally depriving the government of revenue by ignoring laws requiring
private operators to use the state-owned BTTB land phone network for international calls
Telenor in Bangladesh 9
by its subscribers, when they used Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) to receive such
a case against GP's two former CEO's and other officials for involvement in illegal VoIP
business.
Any kind of regulation of the Home or Host country Government may cause a
huge problem for any company. Regulations changes because of government changes. So
the rapid change of government becomes a great threat for Telenor and GrameenPhone.
that Telenor’s operations in various countries are highly regulated both by national
authorities and European Union (EU) authorities. Through, regulations benefit the society
at large, the regulation on termination rates and international voice roaming directly
impact telecom companies' revenues and profitability. For instance, the call termination
prices and roaming rates have been decreased in a number of countries in EU.
from Europe will continue to affect the company's operating performance in future.
call rate for all of mobile operator with the range of minimum 25 paisa to maximum 2
taka as well as specified subscription form of the customers which will seriously affect
b) Business Analysis
i) Industry Analysis:
Telenor in Bangladesh 10
economy. The industry basically took off with Citycell being the first to introduce
mobile phone services using the CDMA technology, then GrameenPhone was the next to
join using GSM technology. The following table shows the overall telecommunication
introduce the pre-paid service in September 1999. It established the first 24-hour Call
Telenor in Bangladesh 11
Center, introduced value-added services such as VMS, SMS, fax and data transmission
personal ring back tone and many other products and services.
In the last decade Banglalink, Aktel, and Teletalk (government owned) have all
joined in. Recently the coming of Airtel with interest in mobile phones as one of its
intended targets shows the potential for the Mobile Phone Industry in Bangladesh.
The telecom sector in Bangladesh is rapidly emerging. There are six mobile
Citycell 6. Teletalk. The number of mobile phone users has reached at 97.180 million at
in Bangladesh having the largest mobile phone customer base and the widest network
coverage by subscribers with 41.18 percent market share. Total subscribers are 40.021
Telenor in Bangladesh 12
million at the end of the December in 2012. GP has changed their tagline recently. New
("Banglalink") is fully owned by Orascom Telecom Holding s.a.e, Egypt, ("OTH"); the
ultimate parent company of the group is Vimpelcom, the 6th largest mobile phone
operator in the world. Banglalink was acquired by OTH in 2004, and after a complete
overhaul and the deployment of a new gsm network, its telecommunication services were
re-launched under the brand name Banglalink. When Banglalink began operations in
Bangladesh in February 2005, its impact was felt immediately: overnight mobile
telephony became an affordable option for customers across a wide range of market
segments. Market share of Banglalink is 26.63% and total subscribers are 25.883 million
and NTT DOCOMO INC, Japan. Robi Axiata, formerly known as Telekom Malaysia
name AKTEL. On 28th March 2010, the service name was rebranded as ‘Robi’ and the
company came to be known as Robi Axiata Limited. The third largest operator Robi
Axiata Limited (Robi) is based on subscribers as well as market share. This took different
kind of new initiatives recently to increase its brand image. Total numbers of subscriber
are 21.039 million as a result Robi captures 21.65% market share in telecommunication
industry in Bangladesh.
the sixth mobile phone carrier to enter the Bangladesh market, and originally launched
Telenor in Bangladesh 13
commercial operations under the brand name "Warid Telecom" on May 10, 2007. Airtel,
also rolling as fourth number player in the mobile market of Bangladesh with 7.26%
market share and total subscribers are 7.051 million at the end of the December in 2012.
Registrar of the Joint stock companies of Bangladesh. Total shares owned by the
for the first time in Bangladesh on 14 Oct'2012 for commercial testing purpose. Teletalk
1989. As the only CDMA mobile operator in the country, we provide innovative, reliable
subscribers is 1.536 million with 1.58% market share at the end of the December in 2012.
The SWOT analysis makes an attempt to analyze the internal strength and
Such an analysis enables a company to identify and enhance its strengths further, to
Low start-up cost: A low start-up cost required to reach out to the public.
Telenor in Bangladesh 14
Experience in telecom market: Most of the Point of Sale (POS) i.e. the GP
Well located Point of Sales (POS): All the POS’s are situated in good
location, which ensures easy access for all the consumers of the product.
accessible to the mass market, GP has set up its POS in the most
Lack of working capital for Outlet and Individual agents: This is a major
Hand set and Kit lifting from the same point. GP sells all cellular related
Availability of concern contact point of GP. No matter what the time is,
lower tariffs and better quality. This might pose a threat to GP.
Split sale. Day by day consumers are spread out to many other competitors
in the market.
the future, then many subscribers can make decision in buying GP before
c) Country Analysis
Two rankings of the competitiveness of nations are from the World Economic
Forum (Global Competitiveness Report) and the prestigious Swiss business school
Yearbook). Data from the World Economic Forum (September 2011) shows
Bangladesh in 108th position in GCI 2011-2012 Rank with a score of 3.73 and
Norway in 16th position in GCI 2011-2012 Rank with a score of 5.18 and its rank in
the previous year was 14th. Data from the International Institute for Management
Development (May 2012) shows Norway in 8th position with a score of 89.67 and its
rank in the previous year was 13th. The World Competitiveness Scoreboard presents
Telenor in Bangladesh 17
the 2012 overall rankings for the 59 economies covered by the WCY where
Bangladesh is far away from inclusion. The economies are ranked from the most to
mentioned that Telenor is facing stiff competition in all the markets in which it
operates. The competition in the mobile industry is based on factors such as price,
with several other operators that provide fixed line and other types of telecom
times.
industry of Bangladesh is now operating its business all over the country with a
subscriber base of about 40.33 million. Grameenphone is the market leader in the
But in this edge of competition, it is very difficult to keep the leading edge intact.
Companies need to come up with new ideas to remain competitive. They need to keep
others mobile companies are also doing well. Five other competitors of
Grameenphone are City Cell, Robi, Bangla Link, Airtel and Tele Talk.
it has large number of base station (Tower). Still the network coverage of
Telenor in Bangladesh 18
Grameenphone is the widest one which has covered almost every districts and
upazillas of Bangladesh. The nearest competitor Bangla Link has also wide network
coverage. Here one thing should be mentioned that is, Bangla Link covers this area
within very short span of time. City Cell and Robi have better services in
metropolitan area. But their service level in rural area is not so appreciable. Tele Talk
has the best connectivity with the land phone operator and Tele Talk to Tele Talk. But
strategy. For promotion, they focus on mainly press and media publications. On the
other hand, Grameenphone focuses on sponsorships beside the press and media
publication.
Now a days, Airtel has the best call rate among all the other operators and Bangla
Link also providing competitive call rates as well as offering frequent discounts to
their customers. Airtel provides instant cash back which is a unique idea for attracting
customers. But among all these Grameenphone may be charge little higher rate than
advantage is its customer service that the other telecommunication organizations still
Desks all over Bangladesh are working as branch office to bring the service to the
Telenor and its partners has so far invested more than BDT 21,343 crore to build
the network infrastructure to boost network capacity and extend coverage to new and
often remote areas, connecting millions of previously unconnected people. Since its
inception Grameenphone has built the largest cellular network in the country with
over 8000 base stations. Presently, nearly 99 percent of the country's population is
within the coverage area of the Grameenphone network. Grameenphone is one of the
largest taxpayers in the country, having contributed more than BDT 30,876 crore in
direct and indirect taxes to the Government Exchequer over the years. Besides,
Grameenphone also started trading its shares on the stock exchanges in Dhaka and
followed by a public offer to the retail investors of Bangladesh. But the current
political, economic and social condition of Bangladesh is not investment friendly due
According to recent study, even the existing cost of doing cellular telecom
high import duty on handsets, and high cost of interconnection. For example, the
infrastructure leasing cost from BTCL per E-1 PCM in Bangladesh is about 10 times
higher compared to that in other countries of the South Asian Region. Besides, the
and usages of bonus talk time for the mobile industry. The tariff rate has set to
Telenor in Bangladesh 20
minimum 25 paisa to maximum 2 taka and the bonus talk time is applicable to any
operator. Although, price is one of the most important marketing tool for the mobile
service providers, but now tariff rate becomes limited weapon to play with the rivals.
d) People in Bangladesh:
country-wide network. As a result of this strategy, the subscribers are from different
segments or from different income levels. From the very beginning, Grameenphone
recent years, the focus has been to provide after-sales within a short distance from where
Grameenphone nearly doubled its subscriber base during the initial years while
the growth was much faster during the later years. It ended the inaugural year with
18,000 customers, 30,000 by the end of 1998, 60,000 in 1999, 193,000 in 2000, 471,000
in 2001, 775,000 in 2002, 1.16 million in 2003, 2.4 million in 2004, 5.5 million in 2005,
11.3 million in 2006, 16.5 million in 2007, and it ended 2012 with 35 million customers.
GP has generated direct and indirect employment for a large number of people
over the years. The company presently has more than 5,000 full and temporary
employees. Another 100,000 people are directly dependent on Grameenphone for their
livelihood, working for the Grameenphone dealers, retailers, scratch card outlets,
one of its most important assets. GP has an extensive employee benefit scheme in place
Education Support for employees, in-house medical support and other initiatives.
With the slogan Go Beyond, Grameenphone promises its customers to bring the
v) Summary
a) Other Factors to be considered
b) Communication Process
c) Expatriate Managers
vi) Conclusion
Telenor in Bangladesh 22
References
Falkenberg, A., & Falkenberg, J. (2009). Ethics in International Value Chain Networks: The
doi:10.1007/s10551-010-0429-x
GrameenPhone Revisited: Investors Reach Out to the Poor. (2004). DAC Journal, 5(3), 15-56.
Rashid, A. T., & Rahman, M. (2009). Making profit to solve development problems: the case of
Management, 25(9/10), 1049-1060.
Review, 86(5), 26.