Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Research in Nursing & Health, 2008, 31, 576–585

Perceived Stress in Survivors


of Suicide: Psychometric
Properties of the Perceived
Stress Scale
Ann M. Mitchell,1* Patricia A. Crane,2** Yookyung Kim3{

1
Department of Health and Community Systems, University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing and
School of Medicine, 3500 Victoria Street, 415 Victoria Building, Pittsburgh, PA 15261
2
School of Nursing, University of Texas Medical Branch Galveston, Galveston, TX 77555
3
Center for Research and Evaluation, University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing and Graduate School of
Public Health, Pittsburgh, PA 15261
Accepted 17 March 2008

Abstract: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the psychometric


properties of three versions of the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS; ß American
Sociological Association) in adults who had survived the death of a family
member or significant other by suicide. Reliability and validity were
examined. Exploratory factor analysis was conducted to assess dimension-
ality of the underlying constructs. All three versions of the PSS demonstrated
acceptable reliability. Two shorter versions retained good psychometric
properties and demonstrated convergent and concurrent validity with
measures of posttraumatic stress symptoms and mental health quality of
life. Factor analysis provided further evidence of their usefulness as brief and
valid measures of perceived stress in acutely bereaved adult survivors of
suicide. In a sub-sample of closely related survivors, the psychometric
properties of the 4-item version of the PSS were retained. ß 2008 Wiley
Periodicals, Inc. Res Nurs Health 31:576–585, 2008

Keywords: Perceived Stress Scale; psychometric properties; stress; survivors of suicide

Suicide is a major public health problem, 15 and 24 years and the ninth leading cause of
occurring most often as a consequence of a serious death in the United States (U.S. Department of
mental disorder (National Institute of Mental Health and Human Services, 2000), accounting
Health, 2003). Suicide is the third leading cause for approximately 30,000 deaths annually. For
of death in young people between the ages of each person who dies by suicide, there may be as
This work was made possible by the generous support of the American Foundation
for Suicide Prevention, New York, NY, and the University of Pittsburgh Central
Research Development Fund, Pittsburgh, PA. The authors wish to acknowledge the
support of David Brent, MD, Department of Psychiatry, Pediatrics, and Epidemio-
logy at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and Graduate School of Public
Health, Karen Evanczuk, PhD, CRNP, Family Nurse Practitioner, Department of
Community Outreach, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, UPMC McKeesport,
and American Sociological Association (ASA).
Correspondence to Ann M. Mitchell.
*Assistant Professor of Nursing and Psychiatry.
**Assistant Professor.
{
Adjunct Associate Professor and Biostatistician.
Published online 30 April 2008 in Wiley InterScience
(www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/nur.20284

ß 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.


PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF PERCEIVED STRESS SCALE / MITCHELL ET AL. 577

many as six or more persons who must cope with being predictive of longer-term adaptation
the loss, resulting in about 4.64 million American (Cleiren et al.).
survivors of suicide (American Association of A global approach to measuring perceived
Suicidology, 2002). For this study, survivors of stress may help to determine if a person is
suicide were defined as persons who had survived experiencing stress during a particular period
a death by suicide of a family member or of time, regardless of the specific cause. Perceived
significant other. Bereaved survivors of suicide stress is defined as the degree to which situations
may be affected adversely by their global percep- in one’s life are appraised as unpredictable,
tions of stress, which may then alter daily uncontrollable, and overwhelming (Cohen et al.,
functioning and quality of life. Although survivors 1983). One’s perceived stress on a global level has
of suicide share many of the same reactions as been shown to have a negative impact on life
survivors of other types of unexpected deaths, events and to influence depression levels and other
Jordon (2001) highlighted important theoretical mental and physical health symptoms (Wang &
differences related to suicide bereavement. The Patten, 2001). Kuiper, Olinger, and Lyons (1986)
purpose of this study was to evaluate the psycho- found that for people with high levels of perceived
metric properties of three versions of the Per- stress, negative life changes led to increased
ceived Stress Scale (PSS; American Sociological depression symptom levels. For those with low
Association) (Cohen, Kamarck, & Mermelstein, perceived stress, negative life changes had only
1983), a global assessment of stress developed and a minimal impact on depression symptom levels.
used in other situations, in adults who had survived High levels of perceived stress, in certain circum-
the death of a family member or significant other stances, may overwhelm the individual’s ability to
by suicide. adapt and cope with an event. Thus, perceived
Bereavement following any sudden, unnatural stress could be expected to have an effect on how
death, including the suicide of a family member or one copes with a death by suicide.
significant other, is usually extremely stressful. Assessment of perceived stress and under-
Suicide bereavement is distinct from other types of standing the usefulness of perceived stress mea-
bereavement in three significant ways: the the- sures in survivors of suicide is important for health
matic content of the grief, the social processes care professionals because of the potential for
surrounding the survivor, and the impact suicide associated health risks (Mitchell & Kim, 2002) and
has on family systems. Unlike survivors of natural the negative effects of stress on functional status
deaths, survivors of suicide often deal with the and quality of life. The PSS was used in this study
difficult questions of meaning-making around to measure the level of global stress experienced
the death, that is, the whys surrounding the by survivors of suicide because perceived stress is
death; feelings of responsibility, guilt, shame, also associated with a number of health-related
and blame; heightened feelings of rejection, anger outcomes. If shown to be psychometrically sound,
associated with abandonment of the family; and the PSS (Cohen et al., 1983) could enable
social stigma and the often-negative reactions researchers to enhance their understanding of
of others. bereaved individuals at risk for developing com-
During the period of bereavement there may plicated patterns of grief or symptoms of mental
be an increased risk for health problems. and/or physical distress (Mitchell, Kim, Prigerson,
Although it is accepted that the loss of a family & Mortimer-Stephens, 2004).
member is stressful and may have severe Application and utilization of a global question-
consequences for the bereaved, little is known naire with a new population require confirmation
about the factors that determine the effects of of its reliability and validity for the target
the death on those who must cope with the loss. In population being studied (Walsh & Betz, 2001).
an effort to determine the significance of the loss The PSS has been used for more than 15 years in a
to the family, Cleiren, Diekstra, Kerkhof, and variety of health-related contexts and with various
Van der Wal (1994) examined the consequences populations. Despite its long history of application
of a loss after suicide, traffic fatality, or long-term and because of the lack of repeated analyses
illness for first-degree family members. They of its psychometric properties, re-evaluation of
found that the influence of the mode of death its psychometrics in the population of suicide
was not as significant as the kinship relationship survivors was considered essential before using it
to the deceased, which played a significant role in in further research or intervention development.
all aspects of functioning. Relationship charac- The PSS measures the degree to which situa-
teristics also played a role in the level of tions are perceived to be stressful. It taps into
problems after the death, with early adaptation how unpredictable, uncontrolled, and overloaded
Research in Nursing & Health
578 RESEARCH IN NURSING & HEALTH

respondents find their lives. The scale has After an extensive review of the literature, the
been found to predict a wide range of physical authors were unable to find any studies utilizing
symptoms, independent of psychological distress the PSS with survivors of suicide or other types of
levels (Cohen et al., 1983; Cohen & Williamson, traumatic death. Therefore, the purpose of this
1988; Marsland, Cohen, Rabin, & Manuck, 2001). study was to evaluate and confirm the psycho-
As a global assessment of stress, the PSS does metric properties of the two short versions of the
not measure the same concept as psychological PSS (the 10-item and 4-item scales) and compare
distress; it measures the degree to which situations them to the original 14-item version in a popula-
in an individual’s life are appraised as stressful tion of adult survivors of suicide during the acute
(Cohen et al., 1983). If, however, people have phase of bereavement (within 1 month of a death
perceived stress that is high, they may then be at by suicide). The specific aims were to: (a) estimate
risk for future psychological distress. Concurrent the reliability of the three versions of the PSS;
psychological distress could then be an additional (b) test the convergent and concurrent validity of
predictor of clinical outcomes like functional the three versions of the PSS by examining their
status and quality of life. relationships with other mental health and quality
The original PSS is based on Lazarus and of life measures; and (c) examine the dimension-
Folkman’s (1984) transaction model of stress. ality of the three versions of the PSS using factor
This model posits information on relationships analysis.
among variables, such as stressful events, percep-
tions of stress, health, and the interactions among METHODS
them. It was designed to assess the importance of
the subjective interpretation of life events. The
experience of stress is assessed in a global, rather Design and Setting
than event-specific manner. The items are scored
on a Likert-type scale ranging from never (0); Analyses were performed on cross-sectional,
almost never (1); sometimes (2); fairly often (3); baseline data from a study of a modified, family-
to very often (4). The sum of the item scores focused critical incident stress debriefing inter-
represents the total score, with a possible range vention for adult survivors (N ¼ 60) within
from 0 to 56, and higher scores reflecting greater 1 month of the death by suicide of a family
perceived stress. Cohen and colleagues (1983; member or significant other (Mitchell & Lucke,
1988) reported the following reliability coef- 2001). The purpose was to examine the efficacy of
ficients for the three versions of the PSS: the 14- a crisis intervention program during the acute
item version, alpha ¼ .75; the 10-item version, phase of bereavement. Participants were recruited
alpha ¼ .78; and a 4-item version, alpha ¼ .60. with the assistance of local coroner’s offices,
Test–retest reliability coefficients with the 14- funeral homes, community mental health centers,
item version were .84 to .86 over three adminis- and other social service agencies.
trations within a 2-week time period. All data reported here were collected from 1997
Construct validity and factorial validity of the to 2000 and before any intervention was adminis-
14-item version were supported by items loading tered. The study received university Institutional
on three factors, the first two of which accounted Review Board approval prior to being conducted,
for 41.6% of the variance (Cohen & Williamson, and informed consent was obtained from all
1988). Dropping the four lowest loading items, participants.
the 14-item version was refined and tested as a
10-item scale and then as a 4-item scale. Factor Sample
analysis of the 10-item scale resulted in all items
loading on one factor that explained 48.9% of the The sample for the present study included
variance. This led the authors of the scale to 60 survivors of suicide (100% White) who
recommend that the 10-item scale be used for completed baseline measures in the parent
future research. Further analysis of the 4-item study. The sample included 43 females (72%)
version revealed a single factor, accounting and 17 males (28%), with a mean age of 43.3 years
for 45.6% of the variance (see Cohen et al., (SD ¼ 13.7) ranging from 18 to 78 years (inter-
1983; Cohen & Williamson, 1988, for a detailed quartile range: 17.5). The majority of the partic-
description of their development of the short ipants (55%) was married or widowed (20%).
versions of the PSS). The 4-item scale was Nearly all (95%) lived with a spouse, partner,
suggested for research projects when there was a children, or another relative. They were predom-
concern with time constraints or subject burden. inantly Catholic (67%) or Protestant (23%). Most
Research in Nursing & Health
PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF PERCEIVED STRESS SCALE / MITCHELL ET AL. 579

participants had a high school education (40%), respondents’ status over time and relevant dif-
technical/vocational diploma (13%), bachelor’s ferences in the response to traumatic events
degree (32%), or master’s degree (12%) and (Horowitz et al.; Weiss & Marmar, 1997), sup-
worked full-time (65%) or part-time (33%). porting content and criterion validity.
Of the total sample, 27 (45%) were classified as Sundin and Horowitz (2003) evaluated the IES
closely related. These relationships included after over 20 years of use in a meta-analysis. A
spouses, parents, children, and siblings. The other review of 20 different studies supported the value
33 (55%) survivors were classified as distantly of the instrument. Psychological impact of life
related, and these relationships included in-laws, events and the associated stress experienced by
aunts/uncles, nieces/nephews, and friends or individuals decreased over time and differed
co-workers. The categorization of relationships by type of event. Overall, the meta-analysis
(closely versus distantly related) was based solely supported the reliability and validity of the IES
on kinship and social relationship and did not for assessing psychological stress reactions after
take into consideration the level of emotional negative life events, including loss and bereave-
attachment to the suicide victim. Of the 27 closely ment. Little variation was attributable to age,
related survivors, 9 (33%) were spouses, 6 (22%) gender, or cultural differences.
were parents, 5 (19%) were children, and 7 (26%) Posttraumatic Stress-Arousal Symptoms Scale
were siblings. Of the 33 distantly related sur- (PTS-AS; Ursano, Kao, & Fullerton, 1992) is a 12-
vivors, 18 (55%) were in-laws, 1 (3%) was a niece/ item scale that has been highly correlated (r ¼ .58
nephew, and 14 (42%) were friends or co-workers to .80) with other PTSD scales (Ursano, Fullerton,
(Mitchell et al., 2004). Kao, & Bhartiya, 1995). The 12-item PTS-AS
asks the subject to rate the level of distress
experienced in the past week due to hyperarousal
Measures Used for Validity Testing symptoms of PTSD, using a 5-point Likert-
type scale ranging from not at all (0) to extremely
Impact of Event Scale (IES; Horowitz, Wilner, & (5). These items allow for a more complete
Alvarez, 1979; Zilberg, Weiss, & Horowitz, 1982) assessment of all dimensions of PTSD than use
is a self-report measure developed to assess of only the intrusion and avoidance items in
the degree of subjective impact of a particular the IES.
stressful psychological event. The most frequently Medical Outcomes Study-Short Form36 (MOS-
used statements describing distress by people SF36; Ware, Johnston, & Davis-Avery, 1979;
seeking psychotherapy in the clinical setting were Ware & Sherbourne, 1992; Ware, Snow, Kosinski,
used to derive the 15 items of the IES. It has & Grandek, 1993) is a generic measure that
two subscales: intrusion (ideas, images, feelings, evaluates health concepts appropriate to an indi-
and dreams) and avoidance (avoiding ideas, vidual’s quality of life. The 36-item self-report
feelings, and situations). Total scores were used scale assesses eight health concepts, including:
as indicators of general psychological distress. physical functioning, role functioning (physical
Zilberg and colleagues validated the IES as and emotional), bodily pain, general health,
reflective of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), vitality, social functioning, and mental health. It
which was included in the third edition of the has shown good internal consistency (alpha ¼
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental .62–.96 with a median of .80) and a reasonable
Disorders III (American Psychiatric Association, test–retest reliability (r ¼ .43–.90 with a median
1980). The internal consistency reliability for of r ¼ .64) for 6 months (McHorney, Ware, Lu, &
the two subscales of the IES was acceptable Sherbourne, 1994). The items and scales are
(alpha ¼ .78 intrusion, and avoidance ¼ .82), and scored so that a higher score indicates a better
the split-half reliability of the total scale was health state. Two subscales of the MOS-SF36,
high (r ¼ .86). A correlation of .42 between the mental health and the physical health, were used
intrusion and avoidance subscale scores indicates for this study.
that they are associated, but do not measure
identical dimensions (Horowitz et al.). Test–retest
reliability from two time points was high (r ¼ .87 Data Analyses
total; .89 intrusion, and .79 avoidance; Horowitz
et al.; Zilberg et al.). The IES taps two of the Internal consistency reliability of the three versions
dimensions of PTSD, but not the dimension of of the PSS was examined using Cronbach’s alpha,
hyperarousal. The subscales had high respondent Spearman Brown split-half, and Standard Error of
endorsements of 80% and detected change in Measurement. Convergent and concurrent validity
Research in Nursing & Health
580 RESEARCH IN NURSING & HEALTH

were assessed using correlation analyses. Concur- .90, and .87, respectively). In addition, the
rent validity of the PSS was estimated by examining Standard Error of Measurement for each of the
its relationship with the present status of mental three versions of the PSS was small (3.20, 2.48,
and physical health-related quality of life (as the and 1.59, respectively), indicating that the true
criterion variable) as measured by the mental scores fall within the given intervals around the
health component score and the physical health test scores.
component score of the MOS-SF36.
Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was con-
Construct Validity: Convergent Validity
ducted to assess dimensionality of the three
versions of the PSS using principal component
All three of the versions of the PSS were
extraction with varimax rotation methods. The
moderately correlated (p < .01) with the IES
primary function of EFA is to explore and reduce indicating that they measure a similar concept,
information from many measured variables into
but not the same type of stress. Convergent validity
a smaller set of components in order to better
was further confirmed by the significant associa-
classify and explain the variables, and thus make tions (p < .01) of all three versions of the PSS with
the global perception of stress measurable. If the
the 12-item PTS-AS scale. The three versions
conceptualization of stress is uni-dimensional,
of the PSS had stronger relationships with the
then the internal consistency or homogeneity of
12-item PTS-AS scale than with the IES.
the PSS could be evidence of construct validity.
The original PSS was designed to measure one
global concept, and its items appear to be Criterion-Related Validity:
homogeneous. Each of the three versions of the Concurrent Validity
PSS was examined for uni-dimensionality.
The correlations among the three versions of the
PSS and the mental health component score of the
RESULTS
MOS-SF36 were significant (p < .05) providing
evidence of concurrent validity (r ¼ .65, .70,
Reliability and .70, respectively). The correlations among
the three versions of the PSS and the physical
In the present study sample, all three versions of health component score of the MOS-SF36
the PSS had Cronbach’s alpha reliability coef- were low and inconsistent across the 3 versions
ficients that met criteria for a mature scale (14-item, r ¼ .27, p < .05; 10-item, r ¼ .21, ns;
(Nunnally & Bernstein, 1994). The Cronbach’s 4-item, r ¼ .23, ns, respectively). Thus, during
alphas for the 14-item, 10-item, and 4-item the acute phase of bereavement in these par-
versions were .89, .91, and .82, respectively. ticipants, the PSS was more highly negatively
These results indicate that the items in the scales associated with mental health quality of life than
are highly homogeneous and that 82–91% of the with physical health quality of life (Table 1).
variance is true score variance, with the remainder
due to error variance. Construct Validity: Uni-Dimensionality
The Spearman Brown split-half reliability
coefficient was acceptable for all three versions EFA was used to assess for uni-dimensionality
(the 14-item, 10-item, and 4-item) of the PSS (.86, of each version of the PSS. The criteria used to

Table 1. Correlations Between the PSS and Validity Measures

PSS PSS PSS


Measurement Scales 14-Item 10-Item 4-Item

IES .51** .54** .58**


12-item PTS-arousal scale .68** .69** .70**
MOS-SF36, mental health component .65** .70** .70**
MOS-SF36, physical health component .27* .21 .23

PSS, Perceived Stress Scale (N ¼ 60); IES, Impact of Event Scale (N ¼ 60);
PTS-AS, Posttraumatic Stress-Arousal Scale (N ¼ 60); MOS-SF36, Medical
Outcomes Scale-Short Form 36 (N ¼ 55).
*p < .05; **p < .01.

Research in Nursing & Health


PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF PERCEIVED STRESS SCALE / MITCHELL ET AL. 581

examine dimensionality were: eigenvalues, scree variance (65.2%) than in the two longer versions
plots, and total explained variance over 50%. of the PSS and the factor loadings ranged from
Factor loading values greater than or equal to .60 to .75.
.40 were considered significantly related to that In summary, the results of this analysis were
factor or construct. The EFA for the PSS 14-item consistent with previous findings. The items
version retained the three factors with eigenvalue retained in the 10-item and 4-item versions of
criteria > 1. However, the primary factor (i.e., the PSS were the same items that were retained
global perception of stress) accounted for a in Cohen and Williamson’s (1988) original
sufficient amount (51%) of the total variance, 10-item and 4-item versions. The primary factor
and scree plots showed a clear break after the explained 56.6% of the total variance for the
primary factor in the plot of eigenvalues, support- 10-item version, which was higher than Cohen
ing the uni-dimensionality of the scale. The EFA and Williamson’s (48.9%), and the primary
for the PSS 10-item version retained one factor factor explained 65.2% of the total variance
with eigenvalue criteria > 1, with the primary for the 4-item version, which was also higher than
factor accounting for 56.6% of the total variance. Cohen and Williamson’s (45.6%). Although
With the PSS 4-item scale, all four items loaded on the current sample was small, the EFA supported
the primary factor, accounting for 65.2% of the the uni-dimensionality of each version of the PSS,
total variance. For the PSS 14-item version, items and all versions demonstrated adequate internal
1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 14 loaded on the reliability and validity. The associations among
primary factor, with loadings ranging from .45 to the 14-item, the 10-item, and the 4-item versions
.88 (see Table 2 for item content). The items in the of the PSS were significant (p < .01) and ranged
14-item version with factor loadings less than from r ¼ .92 to r ¼ .98 (see Table 3), indicating
.40 on the primary factor were items not included that they were measuring the same underlying
in the two short versions. The items with the construct.
lowest loadings, 4, 5, 12, and 13, were dropped for To examine whether only the closely related
the 10-item version. This resulted in values higher survivors carry the reliability and validity of the
than .40 for all the remaining 10 items loading scale, we performed post hoc analyses on the
on the primary factor. In the 10-item version, the closely related and distantly related survivor
primary factor explained slightly more variance groups. The aims of these analyses were to
(56.6%) than in the 14-item version, and the factor estimate the reliability and test the validity of the
loadings ranged from .66 to .85. In the PSS 4-item three versions of the PSS in the closely related and
version, the primary factor accounted for more distantly related groups of survivors.

Table 2. Perceived Stress Scale Items With Principal Component Factor Loadings on Primary Factor

PSS PSS PSS


Item Item Content 14-Item 10-Item 4-Item

7 You felt things were going your way .88 .77 .60
10 You felt that you were on top of things .85 .84 —
2 You were unable to control the important things in your life .82 .85 .75
1 You were upset because something happened unexpectedly .67 .67 —
8 You found you could not cope with all the things you had to do .67 .80 —
6 You felt confident about your ability to handle personal problems .61 .76 .65
3 You felt nervous and stressed .60 .77 —
11 You have been angered because of things that happened that were .59 .66 —
outside of your control
14 You felt difficulties were piling up so high you could not overcome them .52 .69 .61
9 You were able to control irritations in your life .48 .68 —
5 You felt you were effectively coping with important changes that were .45 — —
occurring in your life
13 You were able to control the way you spend your time .25 — —
12 You found yourself thinking about things you have to accomplish .01 — —
4 You dealt successfully with irritating life hassles .22 — —
Amount of explained total variance per scale 51.0% 56.6% 65.2%

PSS, Perceived Stress Scale. All items have been adapted from the PSS (Cohen et al., 1983).
Significant factor loadings are bolded.

Research in Nursing & Health


582 RESEARCH IN NURSING & HEALTH

Table 3. Correlations Among the Three Versions of of the PSS was small (3.16 and 3.42, respectively).
the Perceived Stress Scale However, the Standard Error of Measurement for
the 10-item version was 8.28, indicating that a
PSS PSS PSS
PSS Versions 14-Item 10-Item 4-Item
wider variability of scores could be expected from
this version of the PSS used for closely related
PSS 14-item 1.00 .98* .92* survivors.
PSS 10-item 1.00 .95*
PSS 4-item 1.00
Post Hoc Sub-Sample Criterion-Related
PSS, Perceived Stress Scale.
*p < .05.
Validity: Concurrent Validity

The correlations among the three versions of


Post Hoc Sub-Sample Analyses the PSS and the mental health component score
of the MOS-SF36 were significant for the PSS
Nearly half of the sample (45%) were closely 10-item version (r ¼ .77, p < .001) and the
related survivors (defined as spouses, parents, 4-item version (r ¼ .82, p < .001), but not for
children, and siblings), and thus were most at risk the 14-item version (r ¼ .19, ns), providing
of perceived stress and subsequent stress-related evidence of concurrent validity for the 4- and
health problems following the suicide of a 10-item versions for those survivors most at risk
significant other. We had combined the closely (i.e., the sub-sample of closely related survivors).
related and distantly related survivors of suicide The correlations among the three versions of the
to maximize the sample size and enhance the PSS and the physical health component score
statistical validity of the findings. To determine of the MOS-SF36 were non-significant across
whether there were important differences between all three versions, 14-item (r ¼ .09, ns); 10-item
these two groups of survivors, we examined (r ¼ .06, ns); and 4-item (r ¼ .10, ns).
the two group’s mean scores on the PSS. For the
sample of closely related survivors (N ¼ 27) the
mean score on the PSS was 32.63, SD ¼ 8.64; for Post Hoc Sub-Sample Construct
the distantly related survivors (N ¼ 33) the mean Validity: Uni-Dimensionality
score on the PSS was 22.82, SD ¼ 8.01,
F(1,58) ¼ 17.74, p < .003. Thus, closely related For confirmation of the validity of the PSS 4-item
survivors of suicide experienced significantly version with the sub-sample of closely related
higher levels of perceived stress than those survivors, the EFA was repeated. The four factors
survivors in the distantly related relationship loaded onto one component with a very narrow
group (defined as in-laws, aunts/uncles, nieces/ range of factor loadings, from .88 to .90, and
nephews, and friends or co-workers). accounted for 73.78% of the variance, supporting
the uni-dimensionality of the PSS 4-item version.

Post Hoc Sub-Sample Reliability


Post Hoc Sub-Sample of Distantly
Cronbach’s alpha, Spearman Brown split-half, Related Survivor Reliability
and Standard Error of Measurement were used to
confirm internal consistency reliability of the Confirmation of the reliability of the PSS with the
three versions of the PSS in the closely related distantly related survivor sub-sample was sought
subjects. The Cronbach’s alphas for the 14-item, to assure the usefulness of the PSS. In the distantly
10-item, and 4-item versions were .90, .92, and related survivors (N ¼ 33) the Cronbach’s alpha
.87, respectively. All three versions of the PSS had was comparable to the closely related survivors
Cronbach’s alpha reliability coefficients that met on the 14-item and 10-item versions of the PSS
criteria for a mature scale (Nunnally & Bernstein, (.80 and .72, respectively). The Spearman Brown
1994). split-half reliability coefficient was acceptable
The Spearman Brown split-half reliability for the 14-item and 10-item versions of the
coefficient was acceptable for all three versions PSS (.84 and .72, respectively). In addition, the
(the 14-item, 10-item, and 4-item) of the PSS in Standard Error of Measurement for the 14-item
the closely related survivors (.89, .92, and .90, and 10-item versions of the PSS was small
respectively). In addition, the Standard Error of (3.13 and 2.90, respectively). The reliability of
Measurement for the 14-item and 4-item versions the 4-item version of the PSS did not hold up in the
Research in Nursing & Health
PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF PERCEIVED STRESS SCALE / MITCHELL ET AL. 583

distantly related group of survivors, meaning the with traumatized individuals who have had a
items had little in common, were measuring recent stressful life event in order to reduce
different dimensions, or that this version was too participant burden without sacrificing efficiency,
short to be useful in this group of survivors as they can be included easily in a complete
(Nunnally & Bernstein, 1994). assessment battery. The shortened forms are well-
suited to administer in both clinical and research
DISCUSSION settings, as they remain comprehensive in their
assessment of perceived stress in this population.
There was a high correlation among the PSS, the For comparison purposes, the utilization of a
IES, and the 12-item PTS-AS scales. Cohen single question which asks participants to rate
and Williamson (1988) found PSS scores to be their perceived stress on a 10-point scale ranging
associated with physical health outcomes, inde- from no stress to high stress could be the focus for
pendent of levels of psychological distress. In future research with similar populations.
contrast, in the current sample, the PSS was more Relational health involves a process of forming
highly negatively correlated with the mental an intimate circle of persons who respond to the
health quality of life component than with the presence of unmet needs and who provide social
physical health quality of life component of the support (Cohen & Herbert, 1996). First-degree
MOS-SF36. Bereavement following the death of a relatives, because of primary socialization that
significant other from suicide may be a different stresses a value of being responsive to immediate
experience from that following other types of family members, are most likely to have been
losses. In this study, the survivors were assessed invested in a relationship with the suicide
within 1 month of the death, during the acute victim. The abrupt end to that relationship could
phase of bereavement, which is an extremely be expected to contribute to higher levels of
stressful time and a period during which physical perceived stress in this group of survivors. In the
symptoms may not yet have appeared. Bailley, future, it will also be important to take into
Kral, and Dunham (1999) found that survivors consideration and assess levels of psychological
of suicide, compared to other groups of bereaved, closeness or emotional attachment, as well as
experienced more unique reactions including kinship to the suicide victim.
frequent feelings of rejection, responsibility, With intervention development in mind, the
shame, and perceived stigmatization. These reac- higher stress levels in closely related survivors
tions are similar in nature to the content of the indicate a need to focus and direct initial
items that loaded on the 4-item scale and are interventions with this important group. On the
related to items on the mental health component basis of examining early adaptation and kinship
scale. Interestingly, a similar trend was seen with relationship Cleiren, Diekstra, Kerkhof, and Van
the IES. There was a significant negative relation- der Wal (1994) were able to identify those most at
ship between the IES and the MOS-SF36, mental risk for future problems coping with the loss.
health component score. However, the IES was not Further, multi-faceted measurement strategies are
correlated with the MOS-SF36 physical health important for eliciting unique responses that guide
component score, perhaps because it was so early the refinement and development of preventive
in the bereavement process. interventions for varied levels of stress and the
In this study, closely related survivors of suicide individuals experiences (Gottlieb, 2000). Specifi-
experienced significantly higher levels of per- cally, the concepts of control and confidence in
ceived stress than those survivors in the distantly one’s abilities could be utilized as a focus in the
related relationship group. When working with development of a preventive intervention. Further,
individuals, especially in a highly distressed higher perceptions of stress in these survivors also
population like survivors of a family member’s may indicate that physical symptoms could
or significant other’s suicide, one must be highly worsen (Dunne, 2004; Williams, 2005), which
cognizant of the issue of participant burden. There means they are worthy of close observation and
is often a problem with participant recruitment, assessment over time following the death of a
retention, and attrition rates. Because the mea- significant other.
surement qualities of the two shorter versions are
as reliable and valid as the longer 14-item version,
it seems that these shorter versions could be Limitations
used in a variety of settings, providing a good
alternative to the longer version. The shorter In this study, closely related and distantly related
versions are particularly relevant when working survivors were first combined for the purpose of
Research in Nursing & Health
584 RESEARCH IN NURSING & HEALTH

psychometric analyses. Even so, this was an understanding of the link between an individual’s
admittedly small sample for an exploratory factor ability to cope with a death by suicide and long-
analysis. Although this does not present a problem term health outcomes is an important next step.
with the 4-item version, it is a limitation of the Replication of this study with a larger sample size
study with the 10-item and 14-item versions. would be important to confirm that the scales can
This is more of a limitation for the analysis of the be used in further study of this topic.
sub-sample of closely related survivors, who are
the people most likely to be at risk for stress and
stress-related illnesses. It should be noted, how-
REFERENCES
ever, that we had a sound sampling plan and were
able to recruit a good number of very difficult to
American Association of Suicidology. (2002). Re-
access participants in a sensitive area of inquiry. trieved September, 3, 2005 from http://suicidology.
org/associations/1045/files/Suicide2002.pdf.
American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic
SUMMARY and statistical manual of mental disorders. 3rd
edition. Washington, DC: Author.
Results provide evidence for the reliability and Bailley, S.E., Kral, M.J., & Dunham, K. (1999).
validity of the PSS in the present sample of adult Survivors of suicide do grieve differently: Empirical
survivors of suicide. The three versions of the PSS support for a common sense proposition. Suicide and
were highly correlated and reflect one construct of Life-Threatening Behavior, 29, 256–271.
Cleiren, M., Diekstra, R., Kerkhof, A., & Van der Wal, J.
stress. The four instruments utilized for validity
(1994). Mode of death and kinship in bereavement:
evidence measure different types and qualities of Focusing on ‘‘who’’ rather than ‘‘how’’. Crisis, 15,
stress (i.e., IES and PTS-AS) and quality of life 22–36.
(i.e., mental health component scale and physical Cohen, S., & Herbert, T.B. (1996). Health psychology:
health component scale of the MOS-SF36) and Psychological factors and physical disease from the
confirm convergent and concurrent validity of perspective of human psychoneuroimmunology.
the PSS. The PSS measures a global, subjective, Annual Review of Psychology, 47, 113–142.
perceived stress construct; the IES and 12-item Cohen, S., Kamarck, T., & Mermelstein, R. (1983). A
PTS-AS measure the three PTSD symptom global measure of perceived stress. Journal of Health
clusters of avoidance and intrusion (on the IES) and Social Behavior, 24, 385–396.
Cohen, S., & Williamson, G.M. (1988). Perceived stress
and hyperarousal (on the PTS-AS); while the
in a probability sample of the United States. In
MOS-SF36 is a generic measure of quality of life, S. Spacapan & S. Oskamp (Eds.), The social
including both a mental health and a physical psychology of health (pp. 31–67). Newbury Park,
health component. CA: Sage.
Ongoing reliability and validity testing of the Dunne, K. (2004). Grief and its manifestations. Nursing
PSS is necessary for clinicians and researchers Standard, 18, 45–52.
to determine its usefulness in assessing global Gottlieb, B.H. (2000). Selecting and planning support
perceived stress in survivors of suicide. The results interventions. In S. Cohen, L.U. Gordon, & B.H.
of this study confirmed that the three versions (the Gottlieb (Eds.), Social support measurement and
14-item, 10-item, and 4-item) of the PSS were intervention: A guide for health and social scientists
(pp. 195–218). Oxford, UK: Oxford University
reliable and valid for use with survivors of suicide,
Press.
and that the two shorter versions retained Horowitz, M., Wilner, N., & Alvarez, W. (1979). Impact
good psychometric properties. In this study, the of event scale: A measure of subjective stress.
participants (i.e., spouses, parents, children, and Psychosomatic Medicine, 41, 209–218.
siblings) who were closest to the deceased, Jordon, J.R. (2001). Is suicide bereavement different? A
reported higher levels of perceived stress than reassessment of the literature. Suicide and Life-
the distantly related participants. When adminis- Threatening Behavior, 31, 91–102.
tered to the sub-sample of closely related survi- Kuiper, N.A., Olinger, L.J., & Lyons, L.M. (1986).
vors, the psychometric properties of the 4-item Global perceived stress level as a moderator of
version of the PSS were retained, although this the relationship between negative life events
and depression. Journal of Human Stress, 12, 149–
was not true in the distantly related survivors. For 153.
distantly related survivors, the 14-item or 10-item Lazarus, R.S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal,
version of the PSS was more useful. Levels of and coping. New York: Springer.
perceived stress will vary over time and circum- Marsland, A.L., Cohen, S., Rabin, B.S., & Manuck, S.B.
stance, and given the evidence for the association (2001). Associations between stress, trait negative
between stress and disease, gaining a greater affect, acute immune reactivity, and antibody
Research in Nursing & Health
PSYCHOMETRIC PROPERTIES OF PERCEIVED STRESS SCALE / MITCHELL ET AL. 585

response to hepatitis B injection in healthy young U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
adults. Health Psychology, 20, 4–11. (2000). Healthy People 2010 (2nd edition), Vol. I:
McHorney, C.A., Ware, J.E. Jr., Lu, J.F., & Sherbourne, Understanding and improving health and Vol. II:
C.D. (1994). The MOS 36-item short form Objectives for improving health. Washington, DC:
health survey (SF-36). III. Tests of data quality, U.S. Government Printing Office.
scaling, assumptions, and reliability across Walsh, W.B., & Betz, N.E. (2001). Tests and assess-
diverse patient groups. Medical Care, 32, 240– ment. 4th edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice
266. Hall.
Mitchell, A.M., & Kim, Y. (2002). Depression, Wang, J., & Patten, S.B. (2001). Perceived work stress
traumatic grief, stress, and quality of life in survivors and major depression in the Canadian employed
of suicide: Use of generalized linear modeling populations, 20–49 years old. Journal of Occupa-
(GLM). Quality of Life Research, 11, A669. tional Health Psychology Special Issue, 6, 283–289.
Mitchell, A.M., Kim, Y., Prigerson, H.G., & Mortimer- Ware, J.E., Johnston, S.A., & Davies-Avery, A. (1979).
Stephens, M. (2004). Complicated grief in survivors Conceptualization and measurement of health for
of suicide. Crisis, 25, 12–18. adults in the Health Insurance Study: Mental health
Mitchell, A.M., & Lucke, J.F. (2001). A Critical (vol. 3). Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation.
Incident Stress Debriefing (CISD) intervention for Ware, J.E., & Sherbourne, C.D. (1992). The MOS 36-
survivors of suicide. Proceedings of the American item short form health survey (SF-36): Conceptual
Association of Suicidology 34th Annual Conference, framework and item selection. Medical Care, 30,
Atlanta, GA, p. 64. 473–483.
National Institute of Mental Health. (2003). In Ware, J.E., Snow, K.K., Kosinski, M., & Grandek, B.
harms way: Suicide in America. Retrieved September (1993). The SF-36 Health Survey Manual and
3, 2005 from http://www.nimh.nih.gov/publicat/ Interpretation Guide. Boston, MA: Nimrod Press.
harmaway.cfm. Weiss, D., & Marmar, C. (1997). The impact of event
Nunnally, J.C., & Bernstein, I.H. (1994). Psychometric scale-revised. In J. Wilson & T. Keane (Eds.),
theory. 3rd edition. New York: McGraw-Hill. Assessing psychological trauma and PTSD (pp.
Sundin, E.C., & Horowitz, M.J. (2003). Horowitz’s 399–410). New York: Guildford.
impact of event scale: Evaluation of 20 years use. Williams, J.R. Jr. (2005). Depression as a mediator
Psychosomatic Medicine, 65, 870–876. between spousal bereavement and mortality from
Ursano, R.J., Fullerton, C.S., Kao, T.C., & Bhartiya, cardiovascular disease: Appreciating and managing
V.R. (1995). Longitudinal assessment of posttrau- the adverse health consequences of depression in an
matic stress disorder and depression after exposure to elderly surviving spouse. Southern Medical Journal,
traumatic death. Journal of Nervous and Mental 98, 90–95.
Disease, 18, 36–42. Zilberg, N.J., Weiss, D.S., & Horowitz, M. (1982).
Ursano, R.J., Kao, T.C., & Fullerton, C.S. (1992). Impact of event scale: A cross-validation study and
Posttraumatic stress disorder and meaning: Structur- some empirical evidence supporting a conceptual
ing human chaos. Journal of Nervous and Mental model of stress response syndromes. Journal of
Disease, 180, 756–775. Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 50, 407–414.

Research in Nursing & Health

You might also like