Professional Documents
Culture Documents
When Non-Engineering Students Work On An International Service-Learning Engineering Project - A Case Study
When Non-Engineering Students Work On An International Service-Learning Engineering Project - A Case Study
When Non-Engineering Students Work On An International Service-Learning Engineering Project - A Case Study
Abstract — Service-learning has been proven to be a high- Since the 1990s, universities and engineering organizations
impact educational pedagogy in many disciplines. It addresses have developed engineering-related service-learning projects
human, and community needs through engaging in community that often bring students from first world countries to serve in
activities. With professional engineering expertise, integrating developing regions, particularly first-year design course or
engineering into service-learning not only can make particularly
capstone project [4,5,6]. For example, in 2013, a freshman-
impactful community service, especially in developing countries
where engineering expertise is not always available but also level mechanical engineering course was offered at
provides an effective way for students to apply their theoretical Mississippi State University in which students were required
knowledge to solve real-world problems. Service-learning in to participate into one of the five engineering projects [7].
engineering has been documented in the last 20 years, and it was Also, Gannon University integrated service-learning into the
implemented as extracurricular activities followed by integrating first-year seminar in engineering [8]. Service-learning has also
into core curriculums. However, most of the programs are only been used in a course at George Washington University [9],
offer to the engineering students and less consider implementing Purdue University [10] and University of Massachusetts [11].
as a form of general education with applying multidisciplinary Riding on the success of the positive experiences, substantial
approach.
literature exists on the student learning outcomes [4,6],
This research examines how to integrate students from very community impact [12], pedagogy design [9] and integration
different disciplines into the same project. Our case study is a of service-learning into engineering education [4,13]. Also,
credit-bearing service-learning subject offered by the research has shown that one key element to maximizing the
Department of Computing which is open to all undergraduate student learning outcomes and the community impacts, is to
students and the projects were conducted in Rwanda and involve different disciplines in the same project [14,15,16]. In
Cambodia in 2015 and 2016. engineering service-learning, multidisciplinary approach not
only enriches engineering projects with complementary skills
Keywords— Education; Service-Learning; Training.
such as community assessment but also empowers non-
I. INTRODUCTION engineers to work in engineering projects, which is
particularly satisfying for non-engineers who thought such
International service-learning is defined as a structured skills are beyond them. However, existing programs are
academic experience in another country in which students generally carried out by engineering students trained in
apply theoretical knowledge and exploit hands-on field relevant skills.
experience to address human needs in an organized service
activity [1]. These projects require students to leave their In our case study, we implemented the service-learning in
communities and be immersed in a different culture and engineering programs in general education approach which is
environment for a period [2]. Together with structured available to all undergraduate students. Challenges that we
reflection and direct interaction with others, students can not encountered are discussed, followed by the outline of the
only reflect on the experience, gain further understanding of course model and the involved teaching activities. We believe
course content, global situation and intercultural issues but that our experience will be of value to other educators in
also appreciate their discipline [3], and improve their developing a course to maximize students’ potential in
awareness of community-civic responsibility. In engineering international engineering service-learning programs. To
terms, integrating appropriate technology into service-learning compare the learning outcomes of engineering and non-
projects can bring in different engineering solutions in a engineering students, a series of paired-sample t-tests were
global and societal context. Also, it helps the engineering conducted to examine if there were any significant differences.
students to develop a greater sense of professional skills and Finally, we conclude this paper with the benefit of integrating a
ethical responsibility, especially about use and deployment of multidisciplinary approach into an engineering service-learning
technological solutions. project.
Figure 1 Solar Charging Station (Left) Community Learning Centre (Middle) Computer Library inside the Learning Centre (Right)
center and computing lab for a local Cambodian school learning project, and reflects on the linkage between the
besides in a local school. observations from the service project and the academic topic.
1. Solar Energy System for villagers: Following the Some key challenges for teachers throughout the project
principle of appropriate technology, the solar power include:
solutions took the form of a public charging station
shared between a group of nearby households. 1. Equipping students with the necessary knowledge,
Families could recharge their battery from the station, technical skills, and hands-on experience. Since most of
and each station could charge up to 6 batteries at the the students were not from engineering disciplines and
same time. Our students assembled the solar panels did not have any technical training before, the teaching
and wired up homes with basic electrical appliances. context must start from elementary level. With the time
Also, with using the local sustainable materials, such limited and the technical gap within the team, training
as coconuts or palm branches, we assembled LED must be practical.
lights for the villagers.
2. Empowering the non-engineering students to work on the
2. Community Learning Centre: The objective of the different aspects of the projects, such as product design
community learning center is to provide an informal and system testing, that are more human-oriented and
learning space for village children and youths, both to multidisciplinary.
supplement their regular school education, as well as
to serve as a resource for continued education and 3. Strengthening the teamwork between students from
self-guided study. Two 20-foot-long empty recycled different disciplines and cultural background. Since the
shipping containers were transformed into a computer working practices and way of communication can be
learning center and library respectively. This learning different from one discipline to another one, conflicts
center, placed on the playground of a local school, may easier happen. Therefore, how to develop their team
have improved the educational facilities of the school. spirit and encourage them works on the same goal is
We anticipate that the community learning center will another trial for the teaching team.
also provide a platform for the local people and
enhance the cohesion of the community. A rooftop IV. COURSE AND TRAINING OUTLINE
photovoltaic generator, a rainwater collection system, Recent observation suggests that the typical lecture-based
and ten low-cost computers were installed. In learning as a teaching method seems not to be the most
conjunction with the learning center, students effective and efficient way to equip students, engineering or
deployed a customized computer library with otherwise, with the necessary knowledge and hands-on skills
electronic learning resources to teach the local within a short period. Therefore, problem-based learning
children about science and engineering. pedagogy has been used. It is an instructional learner-centered
approach that encourages the students to conduct research,
To emphasize the long-term gain and ensure the project integrate theory, and apply knowledge and skills to develop a
sustainability, we involved local institutes from Cambodia and solution to resolve a defined problem [17]. For example, when
Rwanda. Orientation and intensive training were provided to we taught students about the abstract concept of electrical
them before working on the field. We have managed to circuits, such as series and parallel connection, students were
empower local youths with the relevant skills, transferring easily confused by the concepts of voltage and current.
such skills to communities where skills are scarce and sorely However, students could easily associate the characteristics
needed. with the phenomenon of light after experimenting with real
circuits and real connections.
III. CHALLENGES
A service-learning project can be divided into three phases: Therefore, apart from the lectures, different components
preparation, execution, and evaluation. Prior to going on their were integrated into the training, for example, discussions on
project, students will study the situations of the communities various case studies, practical workshops, site visit and
involved, and prepare project proposals. The training usually intensive training. The training was carried out in a group
starts at the beginning of the preparation phase and is a critical approach; students were divided into groups by the teaching
factor that directly affects the results of the project, especially team, and each group consisted of students from different
when engineering solutions are involved, and non-engineering disciplines, nationalities, and seniority. Hence, each team
students are participating. included students with an engineering background, which they
acted as a mentor to the others. For those students without
Throughout the project execution, students would reflect technical experience, they contributed to the other aspects,
upon their experience in discussion groups and required to such as community assessment, system testing, product design
write three reflective journals. After the completion of the or preparation of the training material. With clear
projects, students were required to write a reflection report responsibility and task allocation, each member can
that summarizes their personal impact from the service- complement the others.
solar panels. Since the international students arrived in Hong
Kong 2 weeks before the project, they only participated in the
2-week intensive training and completed the eLearning
module. During the intensive training, with the guidance of
instructors, each group attended five sessions, during which
they implemented, tested and evaluated their design of the
solar charging system, LEDs and learning center accessories.
(10 hrs)
4. Safety precautions on conducting engineering project in
rural area, for example, risk assessment; Workshops
√
(15 hrs)
5. Installation of solar system; and
Intensive Training &
6. The introduction of Raspberry PI, a single-board Preparation √
(15 hrs)
computer was used as a server hosting e-Learning
resources such as electronic books. Orientation
√ √
(3 hrs)
During the workshops, instructors presented a problem
Cambodia
Variables Std. Figure 3 A student from Faculty of Business was teaching a local
Sig. (2- Mean Effect volunteer to install a solar controller on the charging station
included in the t df Err.
tailed) Diff Size
study Diff
GRADING (Scale from 1-4) From students’ reflective journal, it reflects the advantage
of integrating a multidisciplinary approach into an engineering
Preparation 1.18 68.49 0.24 0.17 0.15 0.14 service-learning project and how this can benefit the students.
Execution 0.72 83.00 0.48 0.08 0.11 0.08 Many of them suggested that the tangible nature of the
Reflection 0.93 66.72 0.36 0.11 0.11 0.11
engineering-type project was rewarding and this can motivate
them to continue working on the engineering project:
Overall 1.09 83.00 0.28 0.11 0.10 0.12
LEARNING OUTCOMES (Scale from 1-7) “As a physics student, I learned circuit diagram before.
If I had not participated in the SL, I would never know how
Application of the circuit diagram is different from the real situation. In
knowledge and 0.53 83.00 0.60 0.07 0.14 0.06
skills the diagram, all I need to do is to draw lines to connect
electronic elements in series or parallel as long as it will
Understanding not lead to short circuit. When I did the indoor wiring for
of the linkage
between SL -0.74 83.00 0.46 -0.14 0.19 0.08 a house or solar panel installation, I realized the real
and academic situation was much complicated. The diagram is only two
learning dimensional, but the indoor wiring is three dimensional. I
Self-reflection -0.03 83.00 0.98 0.00 0.13 0.00 had splitters, wires, clippers, lights, displays and switches
on my hand, some of which I even hadn’t heard in electric
Demonstration
of empathy
0.34 63.87 0.73 0.05 0.15 0.04 diagram before. I needed to design where I would place
this stuff and connect them together to make all the lights
Intellectual -0.53 83.00 0.60 -0.08 0.16 0.06 function.”
Social -0.90 83.00 0.37 -0.14 0.16 0.10
The engineering students felt that they had learned more
Civic 0.00 83.00 1.00 0.00 0.15 0.00 about the human factors aspect of technology:
Personal -0.65 83.00 0.52 -0.10 0.16 0.07
“We were acting as a human factor in three layers:
utilization, development, and popularization. First, to act
the utilization layer, we were trying to adapt the
A series of independent t-tests were conducted to examine technology into a practical form that can benefit the
is there any significant differences in the grading and learning villagers. Secondly, I had a responsibility that I should
outcomes between the engineering and non-engineering help develop the current technology to make it become
friendlier and bring more benefit to us. The last point, outcomes followed by presenting the students' reflection. In
which is also the most important thing is that this factor concluding, statistically, no significant differences exist
should help ordinary people who have no engineering or between the group and from the reflection journals, it shows
science background understand how to use those the multidisciplinary approach can benefit both the
technologies properly. The last step is the most important engineering and non-engineering students.
one. When I worked with my groupmate from design or
business, they helped me to understand how non-engineer References
think about the solutions, which made me think out of the [1] B. Jacoby, “Service-learning in today’s higher education,” in Service-
Learning in Higher Education: Concepts and Practices, San Francisco,
box." CA: Jossey-Bass, 1996.
[2] G. Ngai and S. C. F. Chan, “How much impact can be made in a
Moreover, one of the students from design major reflected week?,” in Proceedings of the 46th ACM Technical Symposium on
on the teamwork and personal changes in the project: Computer Science Education - SIGCSE ’15, 2015, no. February, pp.
645–650.
“I used to doubt what tasks I could contribute to the [3] R. Bringle and J. Hatcher, “Innovative practices in servicelearning and
team, being a design student, I did not have any technical curricular engagement,” New Dir. High. Educ., 2009.
or science background. At the beginning of the course, I [4] J. Duffy, E. Tsang, and S. Lord, “Service-Learning in Engineering :
What , Why , and How ?”
could barely understand the circuit design and even could
[5] E. Tsang, “Design that matters: Service-learning in engineering,”
not connect the components on the breadboard. From time Washingt. DC Am. Assoc. High., 2000.
to time, I only relied on my teammate and tried my best to [6] A. R. Bielefeldt and J. M. Pearce, Service Learning in Engineering.
work on the design of the solar station. Followed the Convergence: Philosophies and Pedagogies for Developing the Next
instructions from the engineering students, I drew the Generation of Humanitarian Engineers and Social Entrepreneurs, 2012.
three-dimensional diagram with precise measurement. [7] A. Knizley and T. Coleman, “Implementing Service-Learning into an
Introductory Mechanical Engineering Course,” in American Society for
With discussions and revisions, we finally completed the Engineering Education, 2014.
design. Throughout the execution, I became the only one [8] Lin Zhao and K. Vernaza, “Teaching first year engineering students
who understood the whole setting and measurement; engineering design process and problem solving through service
therefore, I stepped beyond my confront zone and took the learning projects,” in 2016 IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference
role of leader to build the solar station. My teammates (FIE), 2016, pp. 1–7.
were appreciated what I did and felt grateful that I was [9] B. Ropers-huilman, L. Carwile, and M. Lima, “Service-learning in
engineering : a valuable pedagogy for meeting learning objectives,” Eur.
part of the team. Engineering to me is an auxiliary to other J. Eng. Educ., vol. 30, pp. 155–165, 2005.
dimensions, and an important way of making a difference, [10] E. J. Coyle, L. H. Jamieson, and W. C. Oakes, “EPICS: Engineering
no matter on the rural villagers or me.” Projects in Community Service,” Int. J. Eng. Educ., vol. 21, 2005.
[11] J. Duffy, L. Barington, W. Moeller, C. Barry, D. Kazmer, C. West, and
Students work on multidisciplinary teams and integrate V. Crespo, “Service-Learning Projects in Core Undergraduate
them into an engineering project was found to impact Engineering Courses,” Int. J. Serv. Learn. Eng. Humanit. Eng. Soc.
Entrep., vol. 3, no. 2, Sep. 2008.
positively, not only on the project but also on students. With
[12] M. Lima, W. Oakes, and J. Gruender, Service-learning: Engineering in
structured training schedule, clear task classification and your community. MO: Great Lakes Press, 2006.
substantial support from the teaching team, both engineering [13] P. Martin and J. Coles, How to institutionalize service-learning into the
and non-engineering students can achieve the same learning curriculum of an engineering department: Designing a workable plan.
outcomes. Also, this mixed group approach can offer other 2000.
learning experiences to the teams, including tolerance for [14] S. Billig and A. Furco, Service-learning through a multidisciplinary
lens. Information Age, 2002.
diversity, interpersonal development, and stimulate their
[15] M. Stebleton, M. Jensen, and G. Peter, “Enhancing Student Engagement
concept and impression towards engineering. in a Multidisciplinary, First-Year Experience Course,” Coll. Teach.
Methods Styles J., vol. 6, pp. 1–6, 2010.
VI. CONCLUSION [16] A. Zeidmane and S. Cernajeva, “Interdisciplinary approach in
This paper has presented the challenges and solutions of engineering education,” 2011 IEEE Glob. Eng. Educ. Conf. EDUCON
2011, pp. 1096–1101, 2011.
guiding a mixed group of engineering and non-engineering
[17] J. R. Savery, “Overview of Problem-based Learning: De?nitions and
students to conduct an engineering project. We have described Distinctions,” Interdiscip. J. Probl. Learn., vol. 1, no. 1, May 2006.
the necessary teaching and learning activities that were used to [18] L. J. Cronbach, “Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests,”
help students understand the theory and concept of service- Psychometrika, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 297–334, Sep. 1951.
learning, motivate them to conduct the projects and workshops [19] P. Kline, The handbook of psychological testing, 1993. Routledge,
and equip them with the necessary technical skills while London, 1993.
strengthening the intra-team communication and rapport. [20] J. Cohen, “A power primer.,” Psychol. Bull., vol. 112, no. 1, pp. 155–
Then, an independent t-test is computed to examine are any 159, 1992.
differences regarding the course grading and learning