Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lectura Organic Cotton Helps To Feed The World PDF
Lectura Organic Cotton Helps To Feed The World PDF
Lectura Organic Cotton Helps To Feed The World PDF
cotton
helps to
feed the
world
The Soil Association’s ‘Have you Cottoned on
Yet?’ briefing1 highlighted the 5 key benefits
of organic cotton. This briefing expands on
its benefit to food security, illustrating
through case studies how organic cotton
helps farmers feed their families.
2 SOIL ASSOCIATION
The Need for Change
Around one in eight people in the world suffer from
chronic hunger2, 98% of whom live in developing
countries2. These countries are also home to 99% of
the world’s cotton farmers3 - indicating a clear need for
methods of cotton production that better promote food
security.
Nitrogen is essential for soil fertility and leguminous crops have roots systems that
contain nodules of nitrogen-fixing bacteria7. Therefore, effective crop rotations must
LEGUMES include legumes, which also happen to be nutritionally beneficial due to their high protein
content. Important legumes in agriculture are alfalfa, beans, clover, cowpea, lupines,
peanut, soybean, and vetches8.
Intercropping involves planting alternate rows of different crops. This has multiple
benefits, primarily increased productivity due to having slightly different resource use
INTERCROPPING patterns – maximising efficiency. In Zimbabwe, for instance, cotton is often intercropped
with cowpea9, which has the added benefits of deterring pests, fixing nitrogen and
providing a protein source.
Trap crops, usually planted around the border, are grown specifically to attract unwanted
pests away from main crops. In south-eastern United States, sorghum, millet, buckwheat
TRAP CROPPING
and sunflower are recommended for managing Stink Bugs – a common cotton pest in this
region10.
Planting cover crops when land is not in use protects soil from harsh weather conditions
COVER CROPS - reducing erosion, evaporation and nutrient loss11. Cover crops also reduce weed growth
and, if leguminous (which they often are), improve soil fertility.
Food Security
The FAO identifies four dimensions of food security;
availability, stability, access and utilization2. These are
used in the diagram below to illustrate the association
between organic cotton and food security:due to the
significantly reduced input costs6.
Figure 2
Access to food improves not only for farmers but also at local
ACCESS markets, as organic cotton farmers often sell their excess
food produce locally.
4 SOIL ASSOCIATION
Cotton Farming Karnataka, India
around the World India is by far the world’s largest producer of organic
cotton, accounting for 74% of global production13.
However, this is marginal in relation to India’s
The nature of cotton production varies enormously production of Bt Cotton - a controversial genetically
around the globe, from levels of irrigation, modified (GM) variety. Introduced in 2002, Bt Cotton
mechanisation and chemical usage12 to farm size, now accounts for almost 90% of India’s
the structure of local markets and its economic total cotton production14. This is due to
importance. This section explores these differences its heavy promotion by seed companies,
by looking at what cotton farming is like in different who make it virtually impossible to
regions of the world. obtain non-Bt cottonseed15.
6 SOIL ASSOCIATION
Texas, United States Benin, West Africa
Conventional cotton farming in Texas is characterised Cotton is Benin’s most important commodity,
by large-scale monocultures, heavy use of accounting for 64% of the country’s exports34. It is
agrochemicals and the widespread growth of Bt Cotton. therefore of vital importance to rural welfare and food
However, the state is also home to 90% of the US’ security.
organic cotton output, which accounts for 1.14% of
global production14 - making it As in much of Africa, cotton in Benin
the 5th largest organic cotton is grown almost exclusively by small-
producing country. Organic scale farmers35. Average farm size is
cotton is by no means a new estimated to be 2.5 hectares36 and
trend in Texas - the average cotton is generally harvested by hand.
organic cotton farmer has For both organic and non-organic
been certified for 15 years31. farmers in Benin, cotton is usually
Farm sizes are considerably grown as a cash crop in rotation with
larger than the majority of subsistence food crops. However, in
those in developing countries, recent years, the costs of artificial
averaging 180 hectares35. inputs have risen to such an extent
Most farms are too large that many conventional farmers have
to harvest by hand and so resorted to planting a higher ratio of cotton
mechanical pickers are almost always used13. to food. This is in an attempt to cover the rising cost of
agrochemicals37, since cotton is more lucrative than
The majority of organic cotton in Texas is rain-fed14 food produce. This trend has significantly reduced local
and so when a severe drought hit in 2011, production food availability in conventional cotton growing areas
dropped by 45%. However, the US offers substantial to the extent that women are forced to travel much
federal subsidies that further afield to purchase food42.
provide a safety net for
farmers. These subsidies are Such situations, in addition to the
highly controversial as they many health risks that accompany the
artificially depress global heavy use of agrochemicals, spurred
market prices, reducing local NGOs to push promotion of
the ability of unsubsidized organic production methods in 1996.
producers in developing Consequently, production of organic
countries to fairly compete on cotton rose from 5mt in 199736 to 328mt
the global marketplace32. in 201214 – making Benin the 11th largest
organic cotton producer in the world,
The most common crops despite its comparatively small size.
grown in rotation with organic cotton in Texas are
wheat, rye and peanut33 - the latter of which is As part of their crop rotation systems, organic cotton
important for fixing nitrogen in the soil. The majority farmers in Benin typically grow a combination of the
of these food crops are sold locally or exported, following in addition to cotton: maize, yam, cassava,
receiving a premium price for being organic – a benefit cowpea, peanut, cashew, soybean and pigeon pea38.
that cotton farmers in developing countries rarely Cashew nuts are generally exported since they are high
experience. value and not part of the local diet. Other food crops
are consumed by the household, with any surplus sold
at local markets44.
AN ORGANIC FARMER WITH HIS MAIN TOOL, THE HAND HOE, BENIN.
UNGINNED ORGANIC COTTON AFTER HARVEST IN BENIN.
CREDIT: SIMON FERRIGNO
Li Fanfan, China
Li Fanfan is 74 years old and lives with Li Fanfan practices both crop rotation
her husband and daughter. She runs a and intercropping. She plants majority
small cotton farm in ChenCun village in cotton for 4 years and then changes to
the south-western tip of ShanXi province, majority wheat for at least one year. These
northern China. Li Fanfan only began cotton are intercropped with a wide range of vegetables
farming in 2005 and initially had little choice and pulses, which make up approximately 15%
but to base her practises on the advice of of her growing area. These typically include
pesticide sellers, who advocated the use pepper, cabbage, turnip, onion, green
of unnecessarily large quantities of bean and sweet potato. Previously, this
pesticides. The frequent spraying technique of intercropping cotton
and irrigation required was with food crops was not an option
physically demanding for Li Fanfan for Li Fanfan because the food
and yet the results were meagre. would have become contaminated
Therefore, when a local Farmer’s with harmful chemicals.
Association recommended she
convert to organic production, she
‘I [now] have extra organic
was keen to try it. She was taught the
vegetables to eat without worrying
necessary techniques to manage cotton
about the pesticides [which] harm
without chemicals and found it much
your health’
easier, particularly since organic cotton requires
Li Fanfan
less irrigation.
8 SOIL ASSOCIATION
Case StudY
BARNABAS PAUL GUERRA, BENIN CASE STUDY PARTICIPANT. MAIZE PRODUCED AS PART OF AN ORGANIC COTTON ROTATION SYSTEM. CREDIT: SIMON FERRIGNO
10 SOIL ASSOCIATION
Author: Lisa Emberson
1
Leech, A. (2012) Have you cottoned on yet?
19
USDA (2013) Turkey cotton and products annual 2012.
(http://www.cottonedon.org/Portals/1/Briefing.pdf) (http://gain.fas.usda.gov/Recent%20GAIN%20Publications/Cotton%20and%20
Products%20Annual_Ankara_Turkey_4-4-2013.pdf)
2
FAO, IFAD and WFP (2013) The State of Food Insecurity in the World 2013.
The multiple dimensions of food security. Rome, FAO.
20
Basal, H., Sezener, V. (2012) Turkey cotton report. International Cotton
(http://www.fao.org/docrep/018/i3434e/i3434e.pdf) Advisory Committee
(https://www.icac.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/03-HBASAL_TURKEY-
3
EJF (2007). The Deadly Chemicals in Cotton, Environmental Justice
COTTON-REPORT2.pdf)
Foundation in collaboration with Pesticide Action Network UK, London,
UK.
21
International Trade Centre (2011) Cotton and Climate Change: Impacts
(http://ejfoundation.org/sites/default/files/public/the_deadly_chemicals_in_ and Options to Mitigate and Adapt. Technical paper. Geneva.
cotton.pdf) (www.intracen.org/cotton-and-climate-change.pdf/)
4
YouGov Plc. (2013) Total sample size was 2276 adults. Fieldwork was
22
Kendal, E., Tekdal, S. (2012) Saddle planting system, a new wheat sowing
undertaken between 16th-18th January 2013. The survey was carried out method in Southeaster Anatolia environment condition. Mesopotamia
online. The figures have been weighted and are representative of all UK Journal of Agriculture, vol. 10, pp. 1-10. Mosul University. Diyarbakır,
adults (aged 18+). Turkey.
5
UNCTAD (2009) Sustaining African Agriculture: Organic Production. Policy
23
Karaaslan, D., Kiliç, H. (2001) A study on the effect of different rotation
Briefs, No.6, Rev.1. systems on some quality features of Maraş-92 cotton cultivar. Online
(http://unctad.org/en/docs/presspb20091rev1_en.pdf) Journal of Biological Sciences, vol. 1, no. 12, pp. 1171-1174. Diyarbakɪr,
Turkey.
6
Forster D, Andres C, Verma R, Zundel C, Messmer MM, et al. (2013) Yield
and Economic Performance of Organic and Conventional Cotton-Based
24
Candemir, M. (2014) Email to L Emberson, 8 April. 25 International Cotton
Farming Systems – Results from a Field Trial in India. PLoS ONE 8(12): Advisory Committee (2014). Cotton this month: 1 April 2014
e81039. oi:10.1371/journal.pone.0081039 (https://www.icac.org/cotton_info/publications/updates/ 2014/English/ectm4_14.
pdf)
7
Bot, A., Benites, J. (2005) The importance of soil organic matter: Key to
resistant soil and sustained food production. FAO.
26
Zhao, X., Tisdell, C. (2009) The Sustainability of Cotton Production in
China and in Australia: Comparative Economic and Environmental Issues
(ftp://ftp.fao.org/agl/agll/docs/sb80e.pdf)
(http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/55338/2/WP%20157.pdf)
8
Wagner, S. C.. (2011) Biological Nitrogen Fixation. Nature Education
27
Adams, G., Boyd, S., Huffman, M. (2014) The economic outlook for U.S
Knowledge. 3(10):15
Cotton 2014. National Cotton Council of America.
9
Rusinamhodzi, L., Murwira, H. K., Nyamangara, J. (2006) Cotton–cowpea (http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/china/2012-10/14/c_131905502.htm)
intercropping and its N2fixation capacity improves yield of a subsequent
maize crop under Zimbabwean rain-fed conditions. Plant and Soil. 287 (1)
28
Ma, M. (2014) Email to L Emberson, 3 January.
pp. 327-336. 29
Ma, M. (2014) Email to L Emberson, 22 February.
10
Mizell, R. F., Riddle, T. C., Blount, A. S. (2008) Trap cropping system to 30
Ma, M. (2013) Email to L Emberson, 28 November.
suppress stink bugs in the southern coastal plain. Proceedings of the 31
Organic Trade Association ( 2012) 2010 and Preliminary 2011 U.S.
Florida State Horticultural Society. 121, pp. 377–382 Organic Cotton Production & Marketing Trends
11
Baldwin, K., R., Creamer, N., G. (2009) Cover crops for organic farms. (http://www.ota.com/pics/documents/OTA-2011-Organic-Cotton-Report.pdf)
Centre for Environmental Farming Systems. 32
International Centre for Sustainable Trade and Development (2012) The
(http://www.cefs.ncsu.edu/resources/organicproductionguide/
2012 US farm bill and cotton subsidies: An assessment of the stacked
covercropsfinaljan2009.pdf)
income protection plan.
12
UNCTAD (no date) Market information in the commodities area: World (http://ictsd.org/downloads/2012/12/us-farm-bill-2012-and-cotton-subsidies.
cotton chain. pdf)
(http://r0.unctad.org/infocomm/anglais/cotton/chain.htm) 33
Pepper, K. (2014) Email to L Emberson, 7 January.
13
Textile Exchange (2013) Farm & Fibre Report 2011-12. 34
Baier, A. (no date) Organic Cotton Projects in Africa
(http://farmhub.textileexchange.org/upload/library/Farm%20and%20fiber%20 (http://www.pan-germany.org/download/africaprojects.pdf)
report/Farm_Fiber%20Report%202011-12-Small.pdf) 35
Cotton Made in Africa. African Cotton. (http://www.cotton-made-in-
14
Kalamkar, S., S. (2013) Biotechnology in Indian Agriculture: Review of africa.com/en/african-cotton.html)
Adoption and Performance of Bt Cotton. Millennial Asia, 4(2) pp. 211–236. 36
World Bank (2009) The cotton sector of Benin. Africa Region Working
(http://mla.sagepub.com/content/4/2/211.short) Paper Series No. 125
(http://www.worldbank.org/afr/wps/WPS125_Benin_Cotton_Study.pdf)
15
Nandi, J. (2013) Karnataka farmer develops non-Bt cotton seed bank.
Times of India online news article 37
PAN UK (2009) Cotton farmers grow food as well as fibre. Pesticide News
(http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Karnataka-farmer-develops-non-Bt- 83.
cotton-seed-bank/articleshow/21853172.cms) (http://www.pan-uk.org/pestnews/Free%20Articles/PN83_p4-6.pdf)
16
Niggli, U., Slabe, A., Schmid, O., Halberg, N., and Schlüter, M. (2008) Vision 38
PAN Germany (no date). Can organic cotton feed Africa? A short guide to
for and Organic Food and Farming Research Agenda to 2025: Organic the issues.
Knowledge for the future. Technology Platform Organics. (http://www.pan-germany.org/download/cotton/Can_Organic_Feed_Africa_
(http://www.tporganics.eu/upload/TPOrganics_VisionResearchAgenda.pdf) EN.pdf)
The Soil Association was founded in 1946 by farmers, scientists, doctors and nutritionists to promote the connection between the
health of the soil, food, animals, people and the environment. Today the Soil Association is the UK's leading membership charity
campaigning for healthy, humane and sustainable food, farming and land use. To find out more visit www.soilassociation.org