Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Forgotten But Not Gone? A Probable Case of Wet Beriberi
Forgotten But Not Gone? A Probable Case of Wet Beriberi
Thiamine deficiency may be more prevalent than is recognized. These authors describe
a case of probable wet beriberi, outline challenges in making this diagnosis, review
factors that may precipitate the disorder, and discuss treatment.
I
n the United States, malnutri- beriberi dates back to ancient times, Given the prevalence of thiamine
tion is a common and severe and until recently it was well recog- deficiency, it may seem odd that wet
medical problem. The obesity nized. At the end of the 19th century beriberi is not seen more often. This
epidemic is well recognized. But in Japan, for instance, the prevalence may be due to failure to recognize
overconsumption of calories does of beriberi among Japanese naval per- factors that may contribute to a thia-
not guarantee adequate nutrition. sonnel was 50% of those at sea.2 mine deficiency, the frequent pres-
Many Americans are deficient in im- The beginning of the end for beri- ence of stressors that may unmask a
portant micronutrients. Cordain and beri as a disease without a cure was thiamine deficiency yet be mistaken
colleagues report that one-third of in the 1890s, when Christiaan Eijk- as the etiology of the subsequent
Americans are deficient in folate, as man discovered that polished rice— findings, and the symptoms of beri-
defined by the U. S. recommended di- but not rice with remnant of the hull beri. The following case illustrates
etary allowances from 1989, and 30% still attached—caused the disease in some of the factors that may both
of Americans are deficient in thia- chickens. This precipitated a search confound and clarify the presence of
mine by the same criteria.1 Recogniz- for the antineuritic factor contained wet beriberi.
ing micronutrient deficiencies can be in the hulls, resulting in the discovery
difficult. The authors present a case of the first “vital amine,” or vitamin: CASE REPORT
of thiamine deficiency, or beriberi, thiamine.3 In the West today, vitamin A 50-year-old Hispanic man with
which was not clearly identified until deficiencies such as beriberi are often type 2 diabetes mellitus, diabetic neu-
its response to thiamine replacement. considered uncommon. This may ropathy, hypertension, alcohol depen-
Beriberi is a Sinhalese phrase that result in underrecognition of poten- dence, and tobacco abuse presented
means “I cannot, I cannot,” in refer- tially treatable cases. with a 25-pound weight gain over 2.5
ence to the profound weakness that O’Keefe and colleagues found that months, abdominal distention, and
may accompany the disorder. Beriberi among 36 geriatric patients without lower extremity edema. On physical
is recognized as having 2 potential dementia 31% had marginal evidence examination, his lungs were clear, he
subtypes—a “wet” subtype, in which of thiamine deficiency, and another had a regular cardiac rate and rhythm
congestive heart failure is present, 17% had frank thiamine deficiency.4 with no murmurs, rubs, gallops, or
and a “dry” subtype, in which the pe- In a study of 50 terminally ill patients third heart sounds. His abdomen
ripheral or central nervous system is on a palliative care unit, borderline was distended and 1+ peripheral as
primarily symptomatic. The origin of thiamine deficiency was found in well as sacral edema was noted. He
36% of patients and frank deficiency was tested for alcoholic cirrhosis and
Dr. Alvarez is a post-graduate year-1 intern in in another 28%.5 The elderly, the very edema of unknown origin, and dis-
obstetrics and gynecology at the University of
Texas Medical Branch in Houston. Dr. Shaw is ill, and alcohol-dependent patients charged on furosemide 40 mg twice
a postgraduate year-4 resident in psychiatry at are among those at high risk for nu- a day and spironolactone 25 mg daily.
the University of Texas Health Care Center in San tritional deficiencies; 30% to 80% of Three weeks later, the patient re-
Antonio. Dr. Brown is the section chief of psycho-
somatic medicine at the Audie L. Murphy Memo- alcoholics may have some degree of turned with worsening edema and
rial VA Medical Center in San Antonio, Texas. thiamine deficiency.6 abdominal distention, and new-on-
Causes Pathophysiology
High-calorie carbohydrate diet Increases demand for thiamine and can, over time, cause deficiency
Alcoholism Alcohol is a source of calories but lacks thiamine. Often accompanied by
reduced food intake
Loop diuretics Markedly increase thiamine excretion26
Anorexia Reduced oral intake of thiamine occurs in anorexia of all kinds, including
chronic illness and psychiatric disease27
Hyperthyroidism A hypermetabolic state increases demand for thiamine28
Parenteral nutrition May contain inadequate thiamine, or be a marker for a hypermetabolic
state29
Dialysis Hemodialysis, and possibly other forms of dialysis, may remove thiamine
or its metabolites from the circulation30
Diabetes Over 70% of patients with type 1 and 2 diabetes have low serum thiamine
levels due to increased renal thiamine losses31
Folate deficiency Folate deficiency causes the intestinal thiamine transporter to take up
folate, which can reduce thiamine uptake32
Coffee, tea, raw fish, shellfish Thiaminases in these foodstuffs inactivate thiamine9
activity, and subsequent congestive activities of alpha-ketoglutarate de- sitive to 2 important facts: (1) The
heart failure.13 hydrogenase and of mitochondria, in 2 forms of beriberi tend to travel to-
Another factor affecting both the general, are impaired by the excess gether. (2) It is much more likely not
brain and the heart is the effect of release of NO from eNOS.16 to see a full, classic example of wet
thiamine deficiency on endothelial In addition, congestive heart fail- or dry beriberi than it is to see a few
function. In both the brain and the ure may selectively injure brain struc- symptoms, which if untreated, may
vasculature, enhanced inflamma- tures already sensitive to thiamine progress to an unmistakable picture
tory activity, including the increased deficiency, such as the mammillary of thiamine deficiency.
synthesis and release of nitric oxide bodies and fornix.17 It is unknown The initial difficulties in recogniz-
(NO) by endothelial nitric oxide syn- why, in some cases, thiamine defi- ing beriberi were well described by
thase (eNOS), contributes to inflam- ciency tends to affect the cardiovas- Igata. Between 1973 and 1975, Igata
matory injury and edema.14 Within cular system more than the nervous identified 73 cases of beriberi in a
the heart, NO may affect both the system, and vice versa. Figure 1 small area of Japan.19 Detective work
timing of myocyte relaxation as well graphically depicts some of the key was required by Igata to determine
as the ability of myocytes to utilize steps in the induction of beriberi. that he indeed was seeing thiamine
oxygen.15 Disturbances in NO syn- deficiency. Pretibial edema was al-
thesis and release may impair both Presentation and Diagnosis most always the sentinel complaint
of these functions. In the periphery, Beriberi is classically divided into wet and was identified in all patients. Ab-
excessive release of NO by eNOS may and dry forms. In wet beriberi, car- normal, deep tendon reflexes were
promote dependent edema. In the diovascular symptoms predominate. observed in 72 of the 73 patients.
brain, excess release of NO by eNOS In dry beriberi, the nervous system is Weakness was noted in 80%, sen-
appears to contribute to the selective mainly affected. This distinction does sory disturbances in just over 60%,
damage typical of thiamine deficiency seem to capture some clinical cases.18 and heart dilatation in about 50%.
and Wernicke’s encephalopathy. The However, the clinician must be sen- Reassuringly, Igata reported that “all
Factors Pathophysiology
Infection May increase metabolic activity and thus demand for thiamine
Surgery May increase demand for thiamine through increased metabolic activity, as well
as reduce intake of thiamine in cases of bowel rest
Pregnancy Increased metabolic activity may be accompanied by anorexia, nausea, and
vomiting
Diarrheal illness Can markedly reduce oral thiamine bioavailability
Liver disease Reduced albumin synthesis may independently produce or aggravate edema
Glucose given before Can stimulate metabolic pathways requiring thiamine and unmask a thiamine
thiamine deficiency33
symptoms disappeared promptly by factor in diagnosing wet beriberi. Elic- mine demand is sensitive to many
the administration of thiamine.”19 iting a history of thiamine deficiency types of physiologic stress. Before
The presence of edema as the ini- involves recognizing the many ways the role of thiamine in causing beri-
tial or only finding has previously in which the uptake of thiamine may beri was recognized, it was assumed
been reported, and in prior case se- be blocked or its use abnormally in- that an unknown bacillus must be
ries “isolated involvement of the car- creased. This is important of course, involved, due in part to the associa-
diovascular or nervous system was not just in helping to recognize the tion of beriberi with prior infections
infrequent.”20 The challenge of recog- illness, but in treating it and establish- or other stressors. As noted by H.
nizing mild or early beriberi is great. ing ways of preventing its recurrence. Wright in 1905, “Therefore, we not
The development of symptomatic Table 3 is a brief outline of some of infrequently see beriberi after surgi-
thiamine deficiency is often gradual.21 the causes of thiamine deficiency. cal operation, in chronic ulcer cases,
Wet beriberi is usually a high-output A simple way to conceptualize a and in parturient women.”21 For the
form of subacute or chronic cardiac patient at risk for thiamine deficiency modern clinician, who is less likely
failure. A fulminant form of wet beri- is to think of someone who is poten- to encounter severe and untreated
beri also exists. This is called Shoshin tially malnourished, as well as cata- thiamine deficiency, the challenge has
beriberi and is characterized by acute bolic. Igata emphasized this interplay evolved to recognizing beriberi after
hypotension, tachycardia, and lactic of diet and activity in his work, and a precipitating insult has been identi-
acidosis.7 A thorough physical exami- railed against the carbohydrate-rich, fied, rather than stopping at the diag-
nation and medical history, as well as thiamine deficient diet of the vigor- nosis of the precipitating insult. Table
considering the possibility of malnu- ous young men whom he saw as the 4 outlines factors that may precipitate
trition, are required to make the di- face of thiamine deficiency. “Some or worsen wet beriberi.
agnosis of wet beriberi. Other causes young men, living alone,” Igata
of high-output cardiac failure, such as wrote, “took ‘instant noodle’ at every Treatment
anemia and hyperthyroidism, should meal, and then finally suffered from The treatment of any thiamine defi-
be considered, even though they do beriberi in a few months.”19 The med- ciency begins with thiamine replace-
not exclude a diagnosis of wet beri- ically ill patient with an inadequate ment. As a water-soluble vitamin,
beri. Table 1 lists some of the features diet faces a similar risk. thiamine is not stored in the body
and factors that help in making the The role of catabolism in produc- as well as fat-soluble vitamins. The
diagnosis, and Table 2 lists features of ing beriberi, if not recognized, may body stores about 30 mg of thia-
dry beriberi; note the overlap. actually cause the clinician to miss mine. Roughly 0.5 mg of thiamine
As mentioned previously, the pa- the diagnosis. Because of its role in is needed for every 1,000 calories of
tient’s medical history is an important producing energy substrates, thia- food. Symptomatic deficiency can
develop in as little as 3 weeks of re- edema or high-output cardiac failure ment of the glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase
deficient patient: A review of literature. Anesth Prog.
moving thiamine from the diet.9 In be routinely considered for thiamine 2009;56(3):86-91.
the authors’ institution, 100 mg daily replacement. l 13. Gioda CR, Roman-Campos D, Carneiro-Júnior MA,
et al. Impaired cellular contractile function in thia-
of thiamine is the usual minimum mine-deficient rat cardiomyocytes. Eur J Heart Fail.
replacement dose, and this may be Author disclosures 2009;11(12):1126-1128.
14. Shi Q, Karuppagounder SS, Xu H, Pechman D, Chen
given orally, intramuscularly, or in- The authors report no actual or poten- H, Gibson GE. Responses of the mitochondrial al-
travenously. The idea is to flood the tial conflicts of interest with regard to pha-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase complex to thia-
mine deficiency may contribute to regional selective
systemic circulation with thiamine to this article. vulnerability. Neurochem Int. 2007;50(7-8):921-931.
overcome factors that may limit its 15. Seddon M, Shah AM, Casadei B. Cardiomyocytes as
effectors of nitric oxide signalling. Cardiovasc Res.
uptake or enhance its excretion, as Disclaimer 2007;75(2):315-326.
well as the possibility of weak thia- The opinions expressed herein are those 16. Hazell AS, Butterworth RF. Update of cell damage
mechanisms in thiamine deficiency: Focus on oxi-
mine binding by the enzymes for of the authors and do not necessarily dative stress, excitotoxicity and inflammation. Alco-
which it is a cofactor. reflect those of Federal Practitioner, hol Alcohol. 2009;44(2):141-147.
17. Kumar R, Woo MA, Birrer BVX, et al. Mammillary
At some point in the patient’s care, Quadrant HealthCom Inc., the U.S. bodies and fornix fibers are injured in heart failure.
a discussion about diet should occur. Government, or any of its agencies. Neurobiol Dis. 2009;33(2):236-242.
18. Brigden W, Robinson J. Alcoholic heart disease. Br
This discussion begins with a dietary This article may discuss unlabeled or Med J. 1964;2(5420):1283-1289.
history and, if necessary, ends with investigational use of certain drugs. 19. Igata A. Clinical studies on rising and re-rising
neurological diseases in Japan—A personal con-
nutritional counseling. For high-risk Please review complete prescribing in- tribution. Proc Jpn Acad Ser B Phys Biol Sci.
patients, such as pregnant women, formation for specific drugs or drug 2010;86(4):366-377.
20. Pantridge JF. Beriberi: Etiological and clinical con-
the chronically ill, or patients with a combinations—including indications, siderations. Ulster Med J. 1946;15(2):180-186.
history of thiamine deficiency, ongo- contraindications, warnings, and ad- 21. Wright H. The cause, course, prevention, and treat-
ment of beriberi. Public Health Pap Rep. 1905;31(Pt
ing thiamine supplementation can be verse effects—before administering 1):289-299.
helpful. pharmacologic therapy to patients. 22. Fozi K, Azmi H, Kamariah H, Azwa MS. Prevalence
of thiamine deficiency at a drug rehabilitation centre
in Malaysia. Med J Malaysia. 2006;61(5):519-525.
CONCLUSION REFERENCES 23. Lonsdale D, Shamberger RJ. Red cell transketolase
1. Cordain L, Eaton SB, Sebastian A, et al. Origins and as an indicator of nutritional deficiency. Am J Clin
Wet beriberi is not yet a disease of evolution of the Western diet: Health implications for Nutr. 1980;33(2):205-211.
the 21st century. Am J Clin Nutr. 2005;81(2):341-354.
the past. And in retrospect, this pa- 2. Aoki K. Short history of epidemiology for noninfec-
24. Lu J, Frank EL. Rapid HPLC Measurement of thia-
mine and its phosphate esters in whole blood. Clin
tient was a prime candidate for it: he tious diseases in Japan. Part 1: Selected diseases and Chem. 2008;54(5):901-906.
related episodes from 1880 through 1944. J Epide-
was an alcoholic and diabetic with a miol. 2007;17(1):1-18.
25. Derer W, Elitok S, Claus T, et al. Lactate in a Lauben-
pieper. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2005;20(12):2851-
low serum folate level who was tak- 3. Carpenter KJ, Sutherland B. Eijkman’s con- 2854.
tribution to the discovery of vitamins. J Nutr.
ing furosemide for edema. He was at 1995;125(2):155-163.
26. Seligmann H, Halkin H, Rauchfleisch S, et al. Thia-
mine deficiency in patients with congestive heart
high risk for a low thiamine intake, 4. O’Keeffe ST, Tormey WP, Glasgow R, Lavan JN. Thi- failure receiving long-term furosemide therapy: A
amine deficiency in hospitalized elderly patients.
reduced gut thiamine uptake, and Gerontology. 1994;40(1):18-24.
pilot study. Am J Med. 1991;91(2):151-155.
27. Wang AY, Sea MM, Ip R, et al. Independent effects
iatrogenic enhancement of thiamine 5. Barbato M, Rodriguez PJ. Thiamine deficiency in pa- of residual renal function and dialysis adequacy on
tients admitted to a palliative care unit. Palliat Med.
excretion. The patient’s diagnosis of 1994;8(4):320-324.
dietary micronutrient intakes in patients receiving
continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis. Am J
beriberi was based on his history and 6. Manicelli R, Ceccanti M. Biomarkers in alco- Clin Nutr. 2002;76(3):569-576.
hol misuse: Their role in the prevention and de-
physical examination, and confirmed tection of thiamine deficiency. Alcohol Alcohol.
28. Bonucchi J, Hassan I, Policeni B, Kaboli P. Thyro-
toxicosis associated Wernicke’s encephalopathy. J
by his robust response to thiamine. 2009;44(2):177-182. Gen Intern Med. 2008;23(1):106-109.
7. Ito M, Tanabe Y, Suzuki K, Kumakura M, Aizaway
The incomplete resolution of his Y. Shoshin beriberi with vasospastic angina pectoris
29. Francini-Pesenti F, Brocadello F, Manara R, Santelli
L, Laroni A, Caregaro L. Wernicke’s syndrome dur-
symptoms may have been due to the possible mechanism of mid-ventricular obstruction: ing parenteral feeding: Not an unusual complica-
Possible mechanism of mid-ventricular obstruction.
brief period of thiamine treatment, Circ J. 2002;66(11):1070-1072.
tion. Nutrition. 2009;25(2):142-146.
30. Ihara M, Ito T, Yanagihara C, Nishimura Y. Wer-
ongoing use of furosemide, chronic 8. Rathi G. Iatrogenic infantile beriberi. Indian Pediatr. nicke’s encephalopathy associated with hemodialy-
2006;43(11):1006-1007.
liver disease, and possibly mild al- 9. Londsale D. A review of the biochemistry, me-
sis: Report of two cases and review of the literature.
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 1999;101(2):118-121.
coholic cardiomyopathy. Given the tabolism and clinical benefits of thiamin(e) and its 31. Thornalley PJ, Babaei-Jadidi R, Al Ali H, et al. High
derivatives. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med.
substantial risk among some patient 2006;3(1):49-59.
prevalence of low plasma thiamine concentration
in diabetes linked to a marker of vascular disease.
populations of thiamine deficiency, 10. Hazell AS. Astrocytes are a major target in thiamine Diabetologia. 2007;50(10):2164-2170.
deficiency and Wernicke’s encephalopathy. Neuro-
the safety of thiamine replacement, chem Int. 2009;55(1-3):129-135.
32. Shenoy VV, Patil PV, Nagar VS, et al. Congestive
cardiac failure and anemia in a 15-year old boy. J
and the diagnostic value of a swift re- 11. Strumiło S. Short-term regulation of the mammalian Postgrad Med. 2005;51(3):225-227.
pyruvate dehydrogenase complex. Acta Biochim Pol.
sponse to thiamine, the authors rec- 2005;52(4):759-764.
33. Corcoran TB, O’Hare B, Phelan D. Shoshin beri-beri
precipitated by intravenous glucose. Crit Care Re-
ommend that patients with severe 12. Elyassi AR, Rowshan HH. Perioperative manage- susc. 2002;4(1):31-34.