Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A98 - Case-Edita-Foods PDF
A98 - Case-Edita-Foods PDF
This case was prepared for inclusion in SAGE Business Cases primarily as a basis for classroom discussion
or self-study, and is not meant to illustrate either effective or ineffective management styles. Nothing herein
shall be deemed to be an endorsement of any kind. This case is for scholarly, educational, or personal use
only within your university, and cannot be forwarded outside the university or used for other commercial
purposes. 2019 SAGE Publications Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
This content may only be distributed for use within PENN STATE.
http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781473974555
Abstract
The case discusses Edita Foods, an Egyptian company that produced a variety of bakery prod-
ucts such as cakes, croissants, and crispy crackers. The company was able to establish itself
in the Egyptian market and build a strong reputation. Moreover, Edita started exporting its prod-
ucts to different markets in the Middle East and became available in 15 countries. The company
employed more than 2,000 employees and became a market leader in Libya, Yemen, Palestine,
and Iraq.
In order to sustain its position in the market and develop its regional existence, Edita decided to
consider expanding further to new markets internationally. The company was considering Jor-
dan due to its close location, and the similarity between the Egyptian and Jordanian markets as
they share similar languages, cultures, and religions. On the other hand, Edita was consider-
ing expanding to South Africa to increase its revenues, explore a new market, and benefit from
the trade agreements signed between South Africa and Egypt. How should Edita Foods decide
where and how to grow internationally? What kinds of questions should the company consider
in doing so?
Case
Learning Outcomes
The case can help students to familiarize themselves with relevant analysis for choosing among possible new
markets for expansion, as well as evaluating and prioritizing critical variables. It also encourages students to
compare different entry modes and choose the most suitable for the company and the country.
Introduction
“[The food industry in Egypt] has one of the best-managed export councils run by some of the most
outstanding, experienced, and dedicated businesspeople in the country.”
—Eng. Rachid Mohamed Rachid, Egypt's former minister of trade and industry
Edita Foods produced an array of bakery products from cakes and croissants to crispy crackers. In Egypt,
it managed to create a solid reputation and an unparalleled position in consumer minds. By 2014, the com-
pany employed more than 2,000 employees in two production facilities in 6th of October City and 10th of
Ramadan City. The company had done spectacularly well in the Egyptian market and had gained a big share
of that market. This allowed Edita Foods not only to effectively satisfy the Egyptian market but also to export
15 percent of the total company production to other countries. It currently exports to 15 countries in the re-
gion, including Iraq, Libya, Palestine, Syria, Yemen, Oman, Tanzania, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Kenya, Morocco,
Tunisia, Albania and Lebanon, and it is the market leader in a number of them, including Libya, Yemen, Pales-
tine, and Iraq. Edita Foods was looking forward to developing its regional existence and covering the whole
region. As a result, Edita Foods might consider further international expansion in Jordan and South Africa.
The key element that made going to Jordan a worthwhile decision was the relative geographical proximity
to Egypt, as this was a key aspect for the fresh delivery of food products. Moreover Jordan had a culture,
language, and religion that was similar to that of Egypt. On the other hand, South Africa had many trade
Edita Foods: Prospects for International Expansion to Jordan and South
Page 3 of 17 Africa
SAGE SAGE Business Cases
© Marina Apaydin and Hend Mostafa 2016
agreements with Egypt which minimized tariffs and made it an attractive market for Edita. Moreover, the com-
pany could build on its success in Kenya and Tanzania to expand to other similar markets such as South
Africa. The potential to realize significant revenues in South Africa also encouraged Edita to consider expand-
ing there. The business environment of both Jordan and South Africa was expected to improve in the long
run. Furthermore, the gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate in these two countries was higher than the
population growth rate, meaning that there would be room for economic development. This implied that the
standards of living will improve, which potentially enlarges Edita Foods' target market. In order to take such
a step, Edita Foods needed to address the following questions: Where and how should the company grow
internationally? What kinds of questions should the company consider in doing so?
In 2014, Egypt's population was approximately 87 million with about 19 million living below the poverty line,
which was a large percentage of the population. The CIA Factbook estimated the labor force to be 28 million
people, but 13.4 percent of them were unemployed. Unemployment was a well-known problem in Egypt; it
ranked 137th out of the 203 countries in the world in 2014 with respect to unemployment, according to the
CIA Factbook. That unemployment rate of 13.4 percent was an increase from the 2013 rate of 13.2 percent.
As a result of the increase in unemployment and the increase in the population under the poverty line, the
literacy rate reached only 73.9 percent in 2014.
In 2013, Egypt was faced with an increase in the inflation rate, which reached 9 percent as compared to 7.1
percent in 2012, making Egypt 205th out of the 223 countries. The Egyptian government exerted significant
efforts to solve its external debt problem by encouraging exports and enhancing trade. Additionally, Egypt
was able to benefit from large, external debt relief that had reduced this debt from 103 percent of the GDP in
2004 to about 87 percent of GDP in 2008 and enhanced the country's macroeconomic situation as a whole.
However, due to the political instability in Egypt since 2011, the public debt increased from 88 percent of GDP
in 2012 to 92.2 percent in 2013.
Bread was a favorite food of the ancient Egyptians. Barley, emmer (a type of wheat), and spelt were the main
grains used in making bread. After the grain crop was harvested, it was threshed to remove the outer chaff.
After the threshing, the wheat was placed in a bowl and pounded with a pestle to make coarse flour. To make
fine-grade flour, the grain was ground between two stones. Then, ingredients were added to make dough that
Edita Foods: Prospects for International Expansion to Jordan and South
Page 4 of 17 Africa
SAGE SAGE Business Cases
© Marina Apaydin and Hend Mostafa 2016
was fried or baked into bread. The food industry continued to be of great importance in Egyptians' lives across
many millennia and has developed ever since.
The Egyptian food processing industry accounted for 17.1 percent of the country's manufactured value added
in 2002 compared to 12.6 percent in 1992. Although this was considered lower than the average for the Mid-
dle East region (20.2 percent), the rate of growth in Egypt (7 percent) was higher than that in the region (4
percent).
In 2009, many multinational food-producing firms operated in or exported to Egypt. “With 117 new factories
and LE 4 billion worth of new investments in 2004–05, processed food was one of our fastest growing in-
dustrial sectors and the best turnaround of the year,” explained Helmy Abouleish, managing director of the
Industrial Modernization Center under the Ministry of Trade and Industry. The largest share of the industry
expansion came from new Egyptian ventures, many of them funded by the investors from the Gulf countries.
Food-processing firms adopted an ambitious export-led growth strategy that could serve as a blueprint for
other manufacturing sectors. This strategy was based on highly targeted government assistance to this sec-
tor and on private-sector know-how in food processing. Over the past 20 years, many international players
entered the market through either direct investments or partnerships. These international companies have in-
cluded Nestlé, Cadbury, Kraft, Hero, and many more.
Many changes occurred in the F&B industry in Egypt. The large competition from international brands forced
Egyptian companies to increase their production efficiency to be able to compete. Moreover, consumers be-
came more aware of the quality, safety, and packaging of the product.
Edita then introduce its second innovative product, Bake Rolz, a healthy salty snack. In 2003, Edita bought
Hostess, the snack cake factory in Egypt, and introduced its snack cakes in the market. Since its establish-
ment, Edita has become known for its consistently high-quality products that include Molto croissants (with
sweet or savory fillings); Hostess and Todo snack cakes; and flavored toffee, candy, and jelly sold under the
Mimix brand. Its products are sold in 15 countries in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia
The competitive advantage of the company lies in its high-quality products, which were made in the state-
of-the-art production facilities located in both 6th of October City and in 10th of Ramadan City, both on the
outskirts of Cairo. The factories were designed to accommodate the demand for a wide and growing market
while supporting the company's mission of high-quality and efficient production.
Edita Foods factories were equipped with 11 automated, high-tech production lines and produce 34 different
products. The manufacturing sector in the company was established and organized to meet high standard
levels in both quality and productivity. Edita Foods had well-established laboratories equipped with the most
recent technology and instruments subjected to regular calibration in order to revise and inspect all materials
delivered to the production facilities and then inspect them during each stage of production.
Edita Food's vision was “to be a pioneering company in bakery products in Egypt and the Middle East.” The
company was certified for the hazard analysis and critical control point procedure (HACCP), which was used
in the food industry to identify potential food safety hazards, so that key actions, known as critical control
points (CCPs), can be taken to reduce or eliminate the risk of the hazards. The company also implemented
the ISO 22000 food safety management system requirements to meet and exceed global food safety regula-
tions.
Edita's products were consumed by different age brackets. Each product was targeted at a different market
segment. For example, Molto, the chocolate filled croissant and Todos the snack cakes were targeted at
school and university students between the ages of 5–17. Bake Rolz, the salty snack however, was target-
ed at university students and young working graduates between the age of 15–35. Mimix was targeted at
younger age groups, mainly school students between the ages of 4–14. Edita's target market was affluent,
outgoing people, who spent a lot of time outside their homes and needed a filling, tasty snack to grab on the
go.
Demographic Factors
Jordan
(2014)
Population 7,930,491
Population growth
3.86%
rate (%)
Age structure:
• 35.8%
• 0–14 years
• 20.4%
• 15–24 years
• 35.7%
• 25–54 years
• 4.2%
• 55–64 years
• 5.1%
• 65 years and
over
Literacy: • 95.9%
• 97.7%
• Overall • 93.9%
• Male
• Female
Economic Factors
Jordan
(2013)
The market for premium food in Jordan was still emerging. The country's imports in this category were second
after grains and oilseeds. The Jordanian market was considered an attractive market as it also provided ac-
cess to the Iraqi market through Jordanian companies that exported to Iraq or through Iraqi companies based
in Jordan. Jordan imports processed food products from different countries, such as Bulgaria, Turkey, China,
Switzerland, Canada, and other Middle Eastern countries.
Another leading company in the F&B sector in Jordan is Alfayoumi Fruits, Vegetables, Foodstuffs Trading
Establishment. The company sold its products to different countries such as North America, South America,
western Europe, eastern Europe, eastern Asia, and other regions around the world.
South Africa was considered an emerging market with a large supply of natural resources. The country's well-
established infrastructure allowed for efficient distribution of goods and services. However, its unstable elec-
tricity supply had hindered the country's growth. South Africa also has faced many challenges including un-
employment, poverty, and inequality. The unemployment rate reached 24.9 percent in 2013. The GDP growth
rate decreased from 3.5 percent in 2011 to 2 percent in 2013. The GDP per capita reached $11,500 in 2013.
Economists forecast that growth wouldn't exceed 3 percent until newly built power stations come online. Table
2 outlines key demographic and economic indicators in South Africa.
Demographic
South Africa
Factors (2014)
Population 48,375,645
Population
−0.48%
growth rate (%)
Age structure:
• 0–14
years
• 15–24
• 28.3%
years
• 20.2%
• 25–54
• 38.2%
years
• 7.1%
• 55–64
• 6.1%
years
• 65
years
and
over
Urban : rural
62% : 38%
composition
Below poverty
31.3% (2009)
line (%)
Infant mortality
41.61 deaths per 1000 births
rate
Number of
adults living with 6 million
HIV/AIDS
Ethnic groups Black Africans (79%); white (8.9%); colored (8.9%); Indian/Asian (2.5%)
Religions Protestant (36.6%); Catholic (7.1%); Muslim (1.5%); other Christian (36%)
IsiZulu (22.7%); IsiXhosa (16%); Afrikaans (13.5%); Sepedi (9.1%); English (9.6%);
Languages
Setswana (8%); Sesotho (7.6%); Xitsonga (4.5%); other (1.6%)
Literacy:
• 93%
• Overall • 93.9%
• Male • 92.2%
• Female
Demographic
South Africa
Factors (2013)
growth rate)
Unemployment
24.9%
rate
Inflation rate
(consumer 5.8%
prices)
Major trading
China, United States, Germany, Japan, the UK, India, and Saudi Arabia
partners
tive market internally and a player in the global F&B industry. The food-processing sector was considered the
largest category of the South African manufacturing industry. Most food-processing companies in South Africa
partner with international companies that provide them with new technology and expertise, while these inter-
national companies were granted access to the attractive South African market. These international players
included Cadbury, Schweppes, Coca Cola, Danone, H. J. Heinz, Kellog, McCain Foods, Minute Maid, Nestlé,
Parmalat, Pillsbury, Unilever, and Virgin Cola.
The F&B sector was considered one of the most important components of South Africa's manufacturing sec-
tor. The beverages accounted for 4 percent of manufacturing sales, while food accounts for 13 percent. In
2009, the F&B sector increased the gross value added in the manufacturing sector by 17 percent and em-
ployed 230,000 people. The food processing segment accounted for one-quarter of the 37 percent of na-
tional GDP generated by agricultural industries. Moreover, 60 percent of South Africa's processed potatoes,
435,000 tons per year, were made into chips. South Africa also has 650 commercial potato farms.
Tiger Brands was the leading company in the F&B industry in South Africa. The company manufactured in
South Africa, Nigeria, Kenya, as well as other countries. Tiger Brands firm distributed its products to more
than 66 countries around the world. The company manufactured a variety of products such as baby care
items, beverages, grains, grocery staples, and snacks and treats. The company produced various brands in
the snacks and treats section, including All Sorts, Anytime, Black Cat, Jelly Tots, and so on. The company's
mission was to “be a highly performing, fast-moving consumer goods company with leading brands, operat-
ing across the globe in several selected emerging territories” (Tiger Brands website). In 2012, Tiger Brands'
turnover reached $2 billion, as compared to $1.8 billion in 2011. In 2012, the company purchased Dangote
Flour Mills in Nigeria for $200 million as well as South Africa's favorite brand, Mrs. Ball's Chutney, for $43
million.
Pioneer Foods was one of the largest producers and distributors of food and beverages in South Africa. The
company aimed at providing food products at affordable prices while complying with high safety and quali-
ty standards. The company produced a number of different products, such as cereals, dried fruit products,
baking ingredients, rusks, juices, and eggs. The company owned many famous brands such as Bokomo
Maltabella, Nulaid eggs, Ceres and Liqui-fruit juice, Heinz ketchup, Safari dried fruits, and Moir's cake mix.
Pioneer Foods was divided into three main sections: essential foods (which includes wheat, rice, and dried
vegetables), groceries (which includes cereals, biscuits, cake mixes, mashed potatoes, dried food products,
etc.), and Pioneer Foods International. Pioneer Foods International included a joint venture with Heinz food,
through which Pioneer Foods manufactures tomato sauces and ketchup, frozen foods, seafood-tinned prod-
ucts, tinned food, instant meals, and noodles. In 2012, Pioneer Foods had a turnover of $1.7 billion.
AVI produced a wide variety of products such as hot and cold beverages, sweet and savory snacks, fresh and
convenience foods, cosmetics, shoes, and accessories. The company had more than 33 owned brands and
more than 20 brands under licensing agreements. Some of these brands included Five Roses in the bever-
age section, Willards Chips, and Bakers and Pyotts biscuits. The F&B division accounted for 75 percent of
the company's revenues.
Edita would consider importing beef in particular because, unlike chicken, beef was not abundant locally in
Jordan. Food represents 14% of Jordan's imports and accordingly importing processed beef would be rela-
tively simple. Although Edita Foods would be competing with other importers, the company would face mini-
mal competition in the local market due to the small number of competitors in the processed meat sector.
Although the Jordanian government imposed tariffs on products in the F&B industry that could reach 180%,
free trade agreements were forcing Jordan to limit the tariff barriers to 20% maximum for products other than
alcohol and tobacco. Accordingly, the imported beef would undergo a maximum of 20% import tax only. How-
ever, the Jordanian government may only require a license as it required an import license on some food
stuffs.
For South Africa, Edita may consider importing Halal and Kosher bottled baby food from Gerber. Halal prod-
ucts use ingredients that comply with the Islamic religion and accordingly are highly demanded by Muslims.
The increasing number of Muslim residents in South Africa, around 700,000 Muslims, would increase demand
for Halal food. Moreover, importing an organic baby product would also be appealing to health conscious cus-
tomers. As for the brand name, Gerber was a major player in the worldwide baby food market, exporting to
over 80 countries more than 190 products. It owned over 83% of the baby food market share in the United
States and was sold to Nestlé company in 2007.
Regarding the government's regulations, South Africa was in the process of decreasing its tariff and non-tariff
barriers to entry. This was mainly due to the fact that South Africa was a member of the World Trade Organi-
zation and has been a supporter of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade.
the other hand, the Nabulsi cheese was considered new to the other markets and customers could be resis-
tant to try it.
Wafeer was the market leader in Jordan for the production of food products. The company produces a wide
variety of food products and is known for its Nabulsi cheese. Wafeer exported its products to Saudi Arabia and
was able to develop packaging and transportation methods to preserve its dairy products. The opportunity
of exporting Wafeer's Nabulsi cheese would be successful especially after the current negotiation with multi-
national companies to supply their foods in the foreign markets under their names and packaging. Currently,
Wafeer was supplying McDonald's and Burger King with many food products that they use in their sandwich-
es.
For South Africa, Edita was considering Sally Williams nougat as a product to export. The luxury confectionary
product was demanded around the world and in the US and Canada in particular. It was also considered the
finest nougat in the world. All Sally Williams products were with no added cholesterol, no preservatives and
were free from gelatin or gluten. Besides the indulgence in the sweetness and lavishness of the nougat, there
were many recipes for desserts that could be made using Sally Williams nougat which made it a good product
for exporting to the most exquisite restaurants, confectioners and individuals in the world.
What made this a really good export opportunity was the fact that Sally Williams used ingredients from around
the world to produce its well renowned nougat; from Morocco and Tunisia to France and Italy. The company
was currently exporting to some countries but it could consider expanding its exports further.
However, some questions needed to be considered in the analysis of both countries. For instance, what fac-
tors should be kept in mind while choosing possible new countries for expansion: demographics, government,
economics, and/or physical and communications infrastructure. Looking at the food industry in Egypt, what
are some possible products that Edita Foods can export to Jordan and South Africa? What are some export
opportunities, related to Edita Foods' industry to Jordan, South Africa, and the world market? How can the
attractiveness of these import and export opportunities be rated? What are the possible modes of entry (ex-
porting, joint ventures, licensing, or foreign direct investment) Edita Foods should consider when expanding
internationally? Out of the possible entry modes, which one is the most suitable? What is the target market of
Edita Foods in the two countries of Jordan and South Africa? Who are their local and international competi-
tors? What is the target market estimate in dollars? What may be the forecast sales for each country?
Discussion Questions
1. What factors should Edita Foods consider when choosing possible new countries for ex-
pansion (demographics, government, economics, and physical and communications in-
frastructure)?
2. Rank the import and export opportunities in terms of their attractiveness, and explain the
rankings.
3. Identify the possible modes of entry (exporting, joint ventures, licensing, or foreign direct
Edita Foods: Prospects for International Expansion to Jordan and South
Page 15 of 17 Africa
SAGE SAGE Business Cases
© Marina Apaydin and Hend Mostafa 2016
investment) that Edita Foods should consider when expanding internationally. Out of the
possible entry modes, which one is the most suitable?
4. What is the target market for Edita Foods in the two countries of Jordan and South Africa?
Who are their local and international competitors? Estimate the target market in dollars.
5. Prepare a financial forecast for future Edita sales in each country.
Further Reading
Alfayoumi Fruits, Vegetable, Foods. Trade Bank. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.tradebanq.com/company/
1684807/Alfayoumi-Fruits-Vegetable-Foodstuffs-Trading-Est-.html
Agriculture and Agri-food Canada. (2010). Government of Canada. Retrieved from http://www.ats-
sea.agr.gc.ca/afr/4002-eng.htm
AVI. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.avi.co.za/our_company
Mostafa, H. (2006). Kneading exports. Business Today. Retrieved from http://www.businesstodayegypt.com/
article.aspx?ArticleID=6641
Nabil Food. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.nabilfood.com/en/about-nabil/history
Pioneer Foods. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.pioneerfoods.co.za/who-we-are/business-profile/
Siniora Food Industries: Food & beverages. (n.d.). Oxford Business Group. Retrieved from http://www.oxford-
businessgroup.com/analysis/siniora-food-industries-food-beverages
Tiger Brands. (2013). Retrieved from http://www.tigerbrands.co.za/
Young, John. (n.d.). Expanding the food and beverage sectors in South Africa. Frontier Market Network. Re-
trieved from http://www.frontiermarketnetwork.com/article/2361-expanding-the-food-and-beverage-sectors-
in-south-africa#.VHWd2IuUdbE
Bibliography
Agriculture and Agri-food Canada. (2010). Government of Canada. Retrieved from http://www.ats-
sea.agr.gc.ca/afr/4002-eng.htm
AVI. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.avi.co.za/our_company
CIA. (2009). Egypt. The World Factbook. Retrieved from www.cia.gov
CIA. (2009). Jordan. The World Factbook. Retrieved from www.cia.gov
CIA. (2009). South Africa. The World Factbook. Retrieved from www.cia.gov
Edita Food Industry. (n.d.). Retrieved from www.edita.com.eg
Industrial Modernisation Centre. (2005). Egyptian Processed Food Sector Review. Retrieved from Industrial
Modernisation Center. (2005). Egyptian Processed Food Sector Review. http://www.imc-egypt.org/index.php/
en/studies/finish/59-executive-summery/8-egyptian-processed-food-sector-development-strategy
Food and Beverages Industry. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.thaiembassy.org/pretoria/contents/images/
text_editor/files/BIC-South%20Africa-F%20Industry.pdf
Mostafa, H. (2006). Kneading Exports. Business Today. Retrieved from http://www.businesstodayegypt.com/
article.aspx?ArticleID=6641
Pioneer Foods. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.pioneerfoods.co.za/who-we-are/business-profile/
Rymer, E. (2008). “Food Processing in Ancient Egypt”.
Siniora Food Industries: Food & Beverages. (n.d.). Oxford Business Group. Retrieved from http://www.oxford-
businessgroup.com/analysis/siniora-food-industries-food-beverages
Edita Foods: Prospects for International Expansion to Jordan and South
Page 16 of 17 Africa
SAGE SAGE Business Cases
© Marina Apaydin and Hend Mostafa 2016