Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Points 91: Clinical Practice Evaluation 1
Points 91: Clinical Practice Evaluation 1
Maryland
SCHOOL STATE: ___________________________________
Kathryn Gardner
COOPERATING TEACHER/MENTOR NAME: _______________________________________________________________________________________________
Toni Melton-Trainor
GCU FACULTY SUPERVISOR NAME: ______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Evidence
(The GCU Faculty Supervisor should detail the evidence or lack of evidence from the Teacher Candidate in meeting this disposition. For lack of evidence, please provide suggestions for
improvement and the actionable steps for growth. )
Ms. Shumaker models integrity by their words and actions. This is evident in her use of Zoom. She lets students know if there is a problem, but also shows them that she is a problem solver and can
keep the lesson running without an issue. She appears comfortable with being in the classroom and she is a positive role model for students. She uses professional vocabulary and demonstrates
professionalism in her words and actions.
Evidence
(The GCU Faculty Supervisor should detail the evidence or lack of evidence from the Teacher Candidate in meeting this disposition. For lack of evidence, please provide suggestions for
improvement and the actionable steps for growth. )
Ms. Shumaker has shown to be developing into a student advocate. She is willing to help out the whole first grade team to prepare and pass out materials for virtual learning. She shared her virtual
content lesson with the whole team, so the lesson could be used in other 1st grade classrooms. Ms. Shumaker has attended the virtual Open House which will help build a stronger home and
school connection. Ms. Shumaker should plan to attend committee meetings help build an impact on community involvement and servant leadership.
INSTRUCTIONS
Please review the "Total Scored Percentage" for accuracy and add any attachments before completing the "Agreement and Signature" section.
Attachment 2:
(Optional)
I attest this submission is accurate, true, and in compliance with GCU policy guidelines, to the best of my ability to do so.
12:59 p.m. – The virtual observation began with Ms. Shumaker welcoming students back from lunch.
She smiles and tells the children she is waiting for others to join in, so they can get started. She tells the
children, “Welcome Back! We are waiting for a few more friends to join us and we will get started.”
The teacher tells the children that it is okay if their video is turned off and to leave it off.
She states the learning objective, “Today in Social Studies, we will be learning about how families can be
similar and different.” The teacher asks the students the meaning of similar. The teacher calls on A.G.
and he says, “That means you’re the same.” Ms. Shumaker complimented A.G. for his response. She
then asks who can tell her the meaning of different. She calls on W.S. and he states, “You’re different
people.” The teacher explains that that is an example of different, and asks, “What does the word
mean?” Ms. Shumaker calls on C.Y. and she states, “Because something is different.”
1:03 – Ms. Shumaker explains to the students that similar means the same and different means not the
same. Next, the teacher explains that the students will be playing a game called, “Stand Up; Sit Down.”
The teacher informs the students that they will find out if their families are similar or different, the same
or not the same. The teacher told the students to stand up if they have siblings, brothers or sisters. The
teacher informs the students that, if their videos are not on, they can use thumbs-up. Ms. Shumaker
states, “Sit down or use the heart reaction, if you are the only child.” She then encourages the students
to look around for students sitting down or a heart as a reaction. The teacher points out students who
have siblings or are an only child. Ms. Shumaker states, “Stand up or thumbs up if you live with just your
parents. Sit down or heart reaction if your grandparents, aunts or uncles live with you. So, if you have
grandparents, aunts or uncles living with you, you should be sitting down. If you live with just your
parents, you should be standing up or thumbs up.” The teacher examines the screen as she speaks to
the children and holds up a model of “Stand Up” and “Sit Down”. This continues with statements like:
The teacher directs the students to sit back down because the game is over. Next, she presents a book
called, Dance at Grandpas, by Laura Ingalls Wilder. She reminds the children that they read the book on
Tuesday. She asks the children if they remember reading the book and to put a thumbs up if they recall
it. She calls on students who remember. She reminds the students that the book took place along time
ago and Laura and her family went to celebrate. She asks, “Does anyone remember how they
celebrated?” The teacher points out the dancing, eating food and listening to music. Next, the teacher
presents another book called, Saturday by Oge Mora. She informs the students that this book takes
place in today’s time. She opens the book and begins reading it to the students. The teacher points out
Ava and her mom sitting at a table eating breakfast. (Note: Periodically, the screen will move to students
who have their screen off or making noises, which causes the screen to focus on them.) The teacher
stops to ask the class who spends time with their family on Saturdays. She puts up a thumb to
encourage students to participate and calls on the names of students who spend time with their families
on Saturday.
1:12 – The teacher stops reading and asks the students what they think will happen when they get to
the library. The teacher calls on M.B and told her to unmute herself. M.B. said, “Something is going to
happen in the picture with the kid.” Another student asks for assistance because she feels everyone is
glitching on her computer. The teacher asks if she can hear her and it is fine as long as she can hear the
teacher. Ms. Shumaker continues to read the story to the students with enthusiasm and expression. Ms.
Shumaker asks a student to put a toy away and pay attention to the story.
1:18 – Ms. Shumaker continues reading the story and stops to ask, “What idea do you think they have?”
She calls on W.S to respond. The student shares, “They can make their own puppet show.” The teacher
says, “Let’s see. I think you’re right!” After the story, the teacher reminds the students of similar and
different. She has the students compare the two books, Saturday and Dance at Grandpas. On the chart
students are comparing the two stories for the following:
The family spent time together.
The family went shopping.
The family went dancing.
The family spent time with their grandparents.
The family road (spelling error) on the bus.
The family rode on the sled.
Students raise their hands to share answers. C.H shares that in both books they spent time with their
families. The teacher places both icons under the word, “Yes.” When a student did not know the answer,
the teacher calls on another student to help. Ms. Shumaker continues to call on students to share their
answers for each item. The teacher points out that the chart shows that each family is different.
1:26 – The teacher directs the students to take out a journal or piece of paper and a pencil. In their
journals, students complete a writing assignment. The teacher asks the students how their family is
different from Ava’s family. She shares in the Word Bank how her family is different. She wrote, “watch
movies.” The teacher calls on students to share how their families are different and the teacher wrote
their input into the Word Bank, like:
Comments and Recommendations from GCU Faculty Supervisor (Discussed during Post Conference):
Continue to greet and welcome students with a smile and a warm demeanor. This creates a
positive learning climate for the students.
Is it possible to mute all students upon arrival? If so, you may want to consider muting all
students to ensure the camera remains on you when students enter the virtual classroom and
during the lesson where verbal responses are unnecessary.
Continue to inform students of the learning objectives. It is an important to give students a clear
purpose to focus their learning.
Consider providing models of similar and different. For instance, students can examine pictures
and tell you if they are similar or different. For instance,
Different o Similar
This
Continue to call on student names and include them in the activity be pointing out who is
standing and sitting down. This makes a virtual learning situation feel more inclusive and
engaging for the students.
When presenting a new book, consider pointing out the title, author, illustrator, and main
character. This helps with connecting the students to the story as well as their listening
comprehension.
Virtual learning can be challenging for some students. Continue to support and validate student
concerns and redirecting distracted students back to the lesson.
Continue to read stories to children with expression to help bring the story alive.
Consider providing brain breaks when student have been engaged in a task for some time, like a
story. A brain break will help students rejuvenate and return to the learning more successfully.
Take a look at this resource: https://www.flvs.net/brain-breaks-for-online-elementary-students
Consider posing the question of whether the families are similar or different from each other
and why. The closing discussion and the writing task focused on differences.
Continue encouraging and reassuring students that they will have time to complete their writing
assignment.
Overall Feedback from Cooperating Teacher
Date: 9/17/2020
Lesson Summary and The students will build interest by playing a game to determine if their family is
Focus: similar or different to their classmate families. The students will review a story
read the day before and listen to a different book to complete a yes/no chart to
determine if the families are similar or different. The students will learn that every
family is a little different and that is okay.
Classroom and Student The lesson will be completed in a whole group setting as well as independent. In
Factors/Grouping: the class there are students who have IEPs and 504 plans. I will be using
pictures/ and oral instruction as well as examples to help them commonalities
between families.
2.B1.a Identify how families choose to share and borrow traditions from other
cultures
Reading Standard:
RL7 Use illustrations and details in a story to describe its characters, setting, or
events.
Writing Standards:
W8 With guidance and support from adults, recall, information from experiences
or gather information from provided sources to answer a question.
Specific Learning Students will be able to explain and understand how families are similar and
Target(s)/Objectives: different.
By the end of the lesson, students will explain how their family is the
same/different from other families.
-Different
-Family
Resources, Materials, List all resources, materials, equipment, and technology you and the
Equipment, and students will use during the lesson. As required by your instructor, add or
Technology: attach copies of ALL printed and online materials at the end of this
template. Include links needed for online resources.
-Visual Cards
-PowerPoint
-Journal
-Pencil
Early finishers (those students who finish early and may need additional
resources/support):
N/A This will be a whole group activity so there will be no early finishers.
Stand up if your family likes to go on walks sit down if your family likes to play games.
Stand up if your family likes to travel sit down if your family likes to stay home.
Stand up if you have a big family sit down if you have a small family.
Stand up if your family has pets sit down if your family has no pets.
Stand up if there are more than 4 people in your family sit down if there are less than 4 people in
your family.
Explain how you will differentiate activities for each of the following groups:
English language learners (ELL):
N/A There are no ELLs in our class.
Early finishers (those students who finish early and may need additional
resources/support):
N/A This will be a whole group activity so there will be not early finishers.
Explain if you will differentiate assessments for each of the following groups:
English language learners (ELL):
N/A There are no ELLs in our class.
Early finishers (those students who finish early and may need additional
resources/support):
The students who finished early will be encouraged to color and add more details to their picture.
Rationale/Reflection
Yes/No Chart promotes critical thinking, collaboration and communication because the
students will have a chance to think about the story and work together as a whole group
to communicate if the answer is yes or no.
Stand up/Sit Down promotes engagement and communication. Students will be
engaged in the game to communicate and understand that every family is different.
Writing in Journals promotes critical thinking, and creativity. This will allow students to
explain and show why they think the two families in both books are similar or different.
Stand up
Sit down