Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Exit Blade Angle and Roughness Effect On Centrifugal
Exit Blade Angle and Roughness Effect On Centrifugal
Exit Blade Angle and Roughness Effect On Centrifugal
GTINDIA2013
December 5-6, 2013, Bangalore, Karnataka, India
GTINDIA2013-3531
EXIT BLADE ANGLE AND ROUGHNESS EFFECT ON CENTRIFUGAL
PUMP PERFORMANCE
Sayed Ahmed Imran Bellary Abdus Samad*
Department of Ocean Engineering Department of Ocean Engineering
Indian Institute of Technology Madras Indian Institute of Technology Madras
Chennai-600036, India Chennai-600036, India
Email: ibellary@gmail.com Email: samad@iitm.ac.in
ABSTRACT Stepanoff [3], Telow [4], Ippen [5] and Itaya and Nishikawa
Exit blade angle and impeller surface roughness has a [6] experimentally studied the influence of viscosity on
significant effect on the performance of a centrifugal pump performance of pump. Aoki et al.[7], Ohta and Aoki [8] and Li
impeller handling different viscosity fluids. In this paper, a [9] conducted experiments for handling water and viscous oils.
three-dimensional flow simulation using Reynolds averaged For pump handling both water and viscous oil the blade exit
Navier Stokes (RANS) equations for the performance analysis angle has substantial effect on both head and efficiency of the
of the impeller is reported. The analysis using water and impeller. The results show that the large discharge angle exhibit
viscous liquids has been accomplished for different flow an improvement in both head and efficiency for a liquid with
conditions, exit blade angle and roughness values. Standard k-ε higher viscosity and water [9].
two equation model is used for the turbulent closure of steady Experiments with impeller for two different surface
incompressible flow. The investigation shows that the blade roughness values were conducted by Varley [2] but did not
exit angle has influence on the head, shaft power and efficiency report the interdependency of exit blade angle with surface
of the impeller for different liquids. Rise in head, increase in roughness. Fard and Boyaghchi [10] studied the influence of
shaft power and decrease in hydraulic efficiency have been various blade outlet angles in a centrifugal pump when
observed with increasing roughness. handling viscous fluids by computational and experimental
methods. These investigations did not include roughness of wet
Keywords: Centrifugal impeller, Exit blade angle, Viscosity, wall. Although, Li [11] reported computations on effect of exit
Roughness, Slip factor. blade angle, viscosity and roughness in centrifugal pumps by
CFD simulations, but the results do not reveal the effect of
INTRODUCTION discharge angle on roughness.
Nowadays centrifugal pump either as single stage or Johnston and Rothe [12], Johnston et al.[13] and Bayly and
multistage is extensively used in almost all industries like Orszag [14] observed a low energy separated region i.e. a
agriculture, chemical, mining etc. and as an artificial lift in boundary layer on pressure side which is unstable and tends to
petroleum industry. Performance characteristics of pump propagate from the hub and shroud surfaces to the suction side
greatly depend on geometry of impeller. For better performance in the impeller. This kind of flow pattern develops jet wake
of pump, design parameters like impeller blade width, exit flow.
blade angle, blade height, number of blades, impeller diameter Dean and Senoo [15] and Tuzson [16] have reported from
and curvature of blade plays key role and must be determined their analytical and experimental results that a separated region,
accurately. due to acceleration and corresponding pressure increase from
From literature, it was found that the researchers like suction side to pressure side forming a separated region has its
Kamimoto and Matsuoka [1] experimentally investigated with limitations. This kind of jet wake flow pattern is exhibited only
the constant angles of 30o, 50o, 70o and 90o for different model under certain conditions.
centrifugal impellers. Varley [2] investigated the effect of blade In this paper an attempt has been made to understand the
exit angle on performance of double suction centrifugal pump. combined effect of exit blade angle and surface roughness on
Kamimoto and Matsuoka [1] presented 40% improvement in head and efficiency by numerical simulation for different iquids
hydraulic efficiency whereas the experiments by Varley [2] at different flow rates. The flow mechanism inside impeller by
shows an improvement of 1.6% for variable exit blade angle. varying the exit blade angle is reported.
Outlet
∂ρ ∂
+ ( ρU i ) = 0 (1)
b1 r2 ∂t ∂xi
ρgQu2cu2
P= (7)
H
44
g
H, P
55
η
70
85
η
75
H, P
55 40
75
40 25 65
0.085 0.105 Q 0.125 0.145
25 65
e) Kerosene
0.085 0.105 0.125 0.145
Q
a) Normal water Fig.4 Performance curves for different fluids
smaller exit angle. The maximum change of the head curve due
55
η
crude oil and saline-water is due to the disc friction losses over
75 the outsides of the impeller shroud and hub generated due to
40
viscosity. These results agree with the results of Gulich [24]
and Li [28].
25 65 Figures 5 and 6 demonstrate the contours of static pressure
0.085 0.105 Q 0.125 0.145 and liquid flow velocity for design point ( Q=0.1003 m3/s) at
50% span. It is clear from these figures that static pressure
d) Gasoline
Rotational
direction
a) Normal water a) Normal water
b) Saline-water b) Saline-water
d) Gasoline d) Gasoline
e) Kerosene e) Kerosene
Fig.5 Static pressure contours at 50% (Q=0.1003 m3/s) Fig.6 Flow velocity contours at 50% span (Q=0.1003 m3/s)
45
mechanical energy given in the form of impeller rotation is
converted into the pressure energy. Minimum pressure exists at
40 the suction side and near the leading edge of the blade. The
difference in pressure between outlet and inlet increases with
increase in blade angle. Liquids with large exit blade angle
35 have more difference in pressure between inlet and outlet. It is
0 50 100 due to a decrease in the velocity at the impeller outlet for large
ks discharge angle as depicted from Fig.4. It shows the relative
(a) Head vs sand roughness velocity of fluid between blade passages. The relative velocity
65 in blade channel has a smooth distribution and declines from
inlet to outlet. This agrees the analytical results; as fluid flows
from inlet to outlet of the impeller, the relative velocity
decreases [18].
55
Jet wake flow pattern
For radial blade impeller jet wake flow pattern is observed
P
45 if Eq. (9) and (10) are satisfied but with backward curved vanes
the blades lean strongly backwards making sin(β) relatively
large and these equations does not hold good. Hence jet wake
flow pattern shown in Fig. 3 is not observed in pumps [26].
35
0 50 100 Effect of surface roughness
ks To find the effect of roughness and viscosity with exit blade
(b) Power consumption vs sand roughness angle on the performance of pump, properties of water, saline-
water, crude oil, gasoline and kerosene were used.
95
Characteristic curves for different fluids at design point and
1470 rpm have been shown in Fig. 7 with sand roughness ks as
90 0, 50 and 100 µm at 25o, 40o and 70o as exit blade angle β2.
Increase in surface roughness increases the head (H), power
consumption (P) with decrease in hydraulic efficiency (η) [2,
85
η
CONCLUSIONS
The Centrifugal pump impeller performance under the
influence of exit blade angle at different mass flow rate has
been evaluated by numerical simulations for five different
fluids. The conclusions are:
• The blade exit angle has substantial influence on the head,
shaft power and hydraulic efficiency of the impeller for
different liquids. c) Crude oil
• Increase in exit blade angle increases the hydraulic efficiency
till design point and it is maximum. At off design points,
increase in exit blade angle does not influence hydraulic
efficiency, instead decreases due to different losses.
• Higher viscosity liquids have lower head generation at same
exit blade angle. An increase in the density of fluid results in
increased power consumption at various blade exit angle.
• Hydraulic efficiency of impeller reduces with increase in
surface roughness. This is due to roughness effect, flow
losses in impeller passage and external disc friction. d) Kerosine
• Jet wake flow is absent in the impeller for all fluids due to.
Increase in surface roughness increases the head generated
and power consumption with decrease in hydraulic
efficiency.
• Combined effect of increase in exit blade angle and surface
roughness is an in increase in head generation with little
increase in hydraulic efficiency.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS e) Gasolene
The authors would like to acknowledge Indian Institute of Roughness= 50 µm Roughness= 100 µm
Technology Madras for the NFSC grant (Grant code: OEC/10-
11/529/NFSC/ABDU) to conduct this research.
REFERENCES
[1] Kamimoto, G. and Matsuoka, Y., 1956, “On the Flow in the
Impeller of Centrifugal Type Hydraulic Machinery (The 2nd Fig.8 Meridional velocity contours for different fluids at
design point