Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CASE ANALYSIS GlobalizatrionAPPROVED
CASE ANALYSIS GlobalizatrionAPPROVED
By:
2020
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
EXECUTIVE BRIEF
because of race. Race can mean the color, ethnic or national origins, nationality or citizenship.
Race includes American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, Black or African American, Hispanic or
Latino, Native Hawaiian and White. And there is racial discrimination, when a landowner refuses
to rent an apartment to person because of skin color, or of different racial background. Another
form of racial discrimination is harassment, when someone makes you feel humiliated, offended
or degraded because of your racial or ethnic groups. Race also covers racial or ethnic groups
who all share the same protected characteristics of ethnicity or race. In the Philippines, the
largest ethnic groups include the Ilocano, Bicolandia, Cebuano, Kampampangan, Maranao ,
Maguindanao, Tausug and Tagalog. Aside from the original people of their own country, there
are other nationalities living in the place because of migration. Migrants seek for a greener
pasture and others move because they chose to have a new home brought about by travel or
vacation that they learn to love the place at first sight, culture and find true identity in the country.
They made up another racial group or mixed group because of change in citizenship or
nationality. As a result, this group can also be made up of two or more distinct racial groups, for
example in Great Britain, there are Black Britons, British Asians, British Sikhs, British Jews,
Romany Gypsies and Irish Travelers and having one or more aspects of race, a person can
experienced racial discrimination. Take for example, a person born in Germany to Filipino
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
parents could be discriminated because they are German citizens, or because of their Filipino
national origins. The same fate goes with Chinoy especially if a Chinese Woman married a
Filipino Man. Also, racial discrimination could be as a result of a rule or policy based on race. In
terms of employment, there is an occupational requirement that a particular race is essential for
the job, for example, an agency or organization wants to recruit a support worker for a domestic
violence advice service for South Asian women. The organization can say that it only wants to
employ someone from South Asian origins. Another example, in broadcasting or communication
industry, they need an Africans reporter or researcher, however, there is no applicant or it’s hard
to get one. It sets up an on-the job training and mentoring program to gain skill and encourage to
join the industry. Still, there is racial discrimination and it has unfair effect on the people of
different race. As the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
based on race, color, descent, or national or ethnic origin which has the purpose or effect of
rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural or any other field of
public life.
normal. In economic aspect, according to Kua Kia Soong (2015), racial discrimination remains
the most serious issue dividing the Malaysian nation and standing in the way of progress toward
a high-income society at peace with itself. While Asia continues to set the pace as the world’s
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
largest growing region, Malaysia is among the Asian middle income countries showing sign of
economic slowdown and faces stiff competition from lower-cost economies and ranked second
in terms of crony capitalism behind Russia on the 2016 Index of Crony Capitalism. Mahathir’s
privatization of state assets ensured the divestment of state capital into the hands of favored
Malay crony capitalists, in the process, increased class differentiation within the Malay
community. Another form of racial discrimination faced by the indigenous people, in recent
years, is the Sarawak capitalist class investment in the 2,400MW Bakund dam project that
displaced them from their traditional ancestral land to the slum conditions of their resettlement
scheme at Sungai Asap. Global economic downturn has also increase racial discrimination in
the world of work as indicated by unemployment rate, a lagging indicator to changing economic
conditions, when the economy experienced recession it tends to rise as a result of lack of jobs.
For example, the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2015),
notes that unemployment rates among native-born children of immigrants (aged 15 to 34) were
around twice as high as those of their peers from the white majority group in Belgium, France,
Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, and the United Kingdom; these patterns are
strikingly similar to the disparities in unemployment rates between African Americans and whites
in the United States. Sadly, in South Africa, there is a higher level of unemployment for blacks
compared to the white minority, and lower representation of blacks in top management
positions. Based on the 2020 World Population Review on Unemployment rate, first on the list is
Burkina Faso, a landlocked and poor country in West Africa that faced domestic and external
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
concern over the state of its economy and human rights, while Senegal ranked third behind
Syria as the top three countries with highest unemployment rate. While In political aspect, racial
discrimination leads to the domination of one group by another, and take the form of the denial
of the right to vote, the right to organize political parties, stand for election, or enter the civil
service. A few countries still have legalized discrimination of this kind, but in a larger number it is
more discrete, taking the form of voting qualification, the violation of electoral procedure, or
intimidation by employers and other members of a dominant group. In the civil service top posts
may be withheld from naturalized citizens, or a 'national' policy may be followed, as in Kenya's
Africanization policy. There is also racial discrimination by security forces and it appears in
internment practices.Racial discrimination is a serious human rights problem that overlap with all
of the US domestic issues covered by Human Rights Watch—from over-custody of Black and
Latin people fueled by the unreasonably harsh sentences meted out for all categories of crime,
including violent offenses, failed War on Drugs, to prosecution and bail policies that force people
into guilty pleas, surveillance of specific groups, such as Muslims or political activists from other
subject asylum seekers and refugees to disparate treatment based on their national origin. Legal
systems discriminate racially even on public places like in many nations a disproportion of
prisoners are of oppressed races, for example, in Australia, Aborigines make up less than 1.5%
of the population but account for 14.8% of the prison population and 21% of all deaths in
custody. And in social aspect, because of race, color, national or ethnic origin, leads to
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
especially with immigrant workers. Take the case of most Roma who remain social outcasts
within their societies. They live in segregated neighborhoods, attend segregated classrooms and
still subject of frequent racial profiling by the police. According to UNDP report (2015), the Roma
were described as Europe’s most vulnerable group in terms of poverty or the risk of falling into
The social construct of race is the foundation of racial discrimination. All human beings
belong to a single species and share a common origin. They are born equal in dignity and rights
and all form an integral part of humanity. All peoples of the world possess equal faculties for
attaining the highest level in intellectual, technical, social, economic, cultural and political
development. The differences between the achievements of the different people are entirely
attributable to geographical, historical, political, economic, social and cultural factors. Such
differences can in no case serve as a pretext for any rank ordered classification of nations or
peoples. This may indicate that discrimination is occurring, that the historical effects of racial
exclusion and discrimination continue to influence current outcomes that other factors are at
work, or some combination of current and past discrimination and other factors is operating.
They can be seen in higher rates of poverty, unemployment, and residential segregation and in
lower levels of education and wealth accumulation for some racial groups compared with others.
Racism also fosters racial discrimination globally. This is any action or attitude, conscious or
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
unconscious that subordinates an individual or group based on skin color or race. This is an
ideology that either directly or indirectly asserts that one group is inherently superior to others. It
can be openly displayed in racial jokes and insults or hate crimes but it can be more deeply
rooted in attitudes, values and stereotypical beliefs. In some cases, these are unconsciously
held and have become rooted in systems and institutions that have evolved over time. This
political concept of race was created as a classification of human being with the purpose of
giving power to white people and to legitimize the dominance of white people over non-white
people. Their differences in background, culture, language and interest have resulted to fight for
power, slavery and inequality making wider space for racial discrimination.
Racial Discrimination exists globally as to when it’s daily. In every country, there is
significant discrimination against the non-white natives in hiring process. According to Narcity
(2019) Canada, for example, is ranked fourth behind France, Sweden and Great Britain around
the globe for racial discrimination during the hiring process. About 69 % percent of those
interviewed in the survey claimed that they have considered leaving their jobs or workplace due
to an increase of stress in which they believe is related to their race. This separation creates
vacancy, however, non-whites who apply did not receive call backs or information if they were
hired or not. Racial discrimination occurs because of overt prejudice, hostility or negative
feelings held by someone about a racialized person or group. Unfortunately, people are still
treated unequally, such as by being refused a job simply because of overt bias towards them
based on race and related grounds. In United Kingdom , as reported by Independent (2020), a
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
Black African Nurse was pulled and surrounded by Metropolitan Police Officer during a hard
stop and was wrongly arrested and held for 18 hours because she is black. This is case of racial
profiling or a form of stereotyping that has particular implications for racialized persons. The
Human Rights Commission has defined racial profiling as any action undertaken for reasons of
safety, security or public protection that relies on stereotypes about race, color, ethnicity,
ancestry, religion or place of origin rather than on reasonable suspicion, to single out an
individual for greater scrutiny or different treatment. Race only needs to be a factor in the
conduct alleged to constitute profiling. Just this year, George Floyd’s death in the custody of
Minneapolis police has brought new attention to questions about police officers’ attitudes toward
black Americans, protesters and others. Floyd’s killing has galvanized people into the streets to
protest white supremacy, police brutality and extrajudicial killings. The application of the Jim
Crow Law on racial segregation requires the separation of whites from persons of color in public
transportation, schools, parks, cemeteries, theaters and restaurants to prevent any contact
between black and whites. Half - French are favored in this situation wherein racism plays a
major role in fostering racial discrimination. In the field of public services like on health services,
it may occur in the quality of service given against racial groups in a lower income bracket if the
system is mainly private. Some social security and pension schemes require eligibility standards
which may exclude certain racial groups, especially if related to income or property. We cannot
deny that during this pandemic situation different minorities globally are experiencing racial
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
discrimination in terms of health services, food and housing which leave them no choice but to
-American Indians or Alaska Natives, Asians, Native Hawaiians or other Pacific Islanders, and,
in some cases, Hispanics. Members of these groups have more often been discriminated
against in various social and economic arenas. The Black or African American or called as
Negro or Haitian having origins in any of the black racial groups of Africa. South Africa is a
colony of the Britishers for a long period. So, all the British who were there as administrators
stayed there for generations and had their offspring and it was considered as a country where
blacks and whites lived together but blacks were like slaves and whites were the ruling people.
They are the disadvantaged racial group or minorities among the races. In America, there are a
number of American blacks, whose origin is from Africa, from where they migrated generations
back and settled there for quite a few centuries. Now they became original population of
America. The American blacks have contributed immensely to the development of the country.
Modern technology through social media and the Internet, images of anti-black violence in
America now instantly circulate globally. Black people in Canada, England and France are
employing the symbolism and language of America’s anti-black racism protests to demand
equality. Across Africa, in countries like Kenya, Nigeria and South Africa, in many developing
countries victims of racial discrimination live in conditions of extreme poverty without hope of
obtaining qualifications and, therefore, no opportunity of entering the formal labor market. The
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
case of indigenous peoples who are often remote from where work might be available , poor
women without skills who are exploited in low-paid jobs, including as domestic servants, or who
work out a living in the informal sector. While the Whites or person having origins in any of the
peoples of Europe, the Middle East, or North Africa. They are usually favoured in terms of
everything because of race, status symbol and power.There are also mixed group. Migration of
these groups caused racial intermixture that caused genetic admixture thereby formulating
mixed racial groups and cause of formation of the new races. Migrants are everywhere in the
world, they move because of work and better living conditions and finally settle in their new
found home. Aside from the racial groups, there are Incumbent leaders who treated people
differently be in economic, social or political aspects in the government that resulted to racial
discrimination. On the other hand, the authorities from International Labour Organization, United
Nations, UNESCO, World Bank are helping the country in combating racial discrimination.
Index Mundi, a comprehensive data portal with country level fact and statistics,
conducted Racial Discrimination Survey which aims to measure how much racism exists in a
given country as perceived by its residents. The question asked: How big of a problem is racial
discrimination in the country where you live? Based on result of survey, South Africa is at the
top followed by Malaysia (2 nd), Guatemala (3rd), Peru (4th), Trinidad and Tobago (5th), Bolivia
(6th), Afghanistan (7th), Saudi Arabia (8th), France (9th) and Brazil completing the top ten
countries. Other countries with the presence of racial discrimination arranged according to their
ranks are Mexico, Greece, United States, Indonesia, Austria, Italy, India, Pakistan, Azerbaijan
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
and Chile. Aside from the twenty (20) countries mentioned, there are still fifty-six (56) more
According to the 2017 survey conducted by SA Institute for Race Relations in South
Africa, on how South African see relations since 1994, survey revealed 60% of the respondents
said that it improved while 16 % showed that it is still the same but 21% of the respondents
revealed that race relation became worse and the remaining 3% said that they don’t’ know
anything. It only shows that those incidence pertaining to racial discrimination like harassment
or insult by using the “k –word to humiliate the Blacks happened in South Africa is not a rainbow
The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) works
with teachers, museums and publishers to try to combat stereotypes that stigmatize individuals
and peoples because of the color of their skin, their origin or their affiliation. At a time of
economic crisis and social uncertainty, “the other” is always a convenient scapegoat, and racial
discrimination a dangerous temptation that manufacturers of hatred know all too well how to
exploit. According to Ms Audrey Azoulay (2020), Director of UNESCO, that recent events this
year have shown all too often, in particular during the COVID-19 crisis, racist ideologies,
hate speech, scapegoating and the deadly acts that result from them continue to jeopardize
world peace. According to the United Nations, racial and ethnic discrimination occur on a daily
basis, hindering progress for millions of people around the world. From denying individuals the
basic principles of equality and non-discrimination to fuelling ethnic hatred that may lead to
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
genocide, racism and intolerance destroy lives and communities. The struggle against racism is
a matter of priority for the international community and is at the heart of the work of the Office of
the High Commissioner for Human Rights. The United Nations has been concerned with this
issue since its foundation and the prohibition of racial discrimination is enshrined in all core
international human rights instruments. It places obligations on States and tasks them with
eradicating discrimination in the public and private spheres. The World Bank (2020), i n the last
few weeks, group’s staff and management have come together to discuss how this organization
can contribute to the movement for more just and fair societies. The heightened global
awareness around racial injustice and systemic racism has sparked valuable discussions about
the need to enhance how we value diversity, dignity, respect, and inclusion. Departments and
teams across the Bank Group have held virtual town hall discussions to allow staff and
management to share their voices and ideas. Staff comments revealed a range of issues, such
as disparities in career paths linked to race/ethnicity, lack of accountability for those who have
perpetrated racist or discriminatory behavior, and other systemic challenges. According to the
World Bank Group President Malpass, what happened to George Floyd is beyond
reprehensible. The scourge of racism is deep and pernicious and must be confronted and
ended. Racial discrimination and social injustice have no place in our institution, our programs,
or any of the communities we work in around the world. According to the International Labour
Organization, failure to deal with racial discrimation in the world of work makes it more difficult
to deal with the challenges posed by the current global financial crisis. Racial discrimination
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
PROBLEM STATEMENT
This analysis aims to answer the problem on racial discrimination that continue to exists
and affecting individual/s or racial group around the world . This is a situation where one is
treated differently or unfavorably because of race, skin color, ethnic or national origins,
nationality or citizenship that occurs because of overt prejudice, hostility or negative feelings
held by someone about a racialized person or group in the form of direct or indirect
discrimination, harassment and racial profiling. This is also a problem that restricts and excludes
person/s or racial group from enjoyment of human rights and freedom in the economic, political,
STATEMENT OF OBJECTIVES
different parts of the world as evidenced by the result of survey that involves 76 countries with
South Africa on top ranking. And to better understand its existence from centuries to present
day , this analysis aims to analyse the impact of racial discrimination in economy , government
system, society and culture of the minority group. This is also directed in analyzing the effect of
racial discrimination on individual and racial group in the aspect of economic, political and social
life. Towards this, it also targets to solve the problem by considering solutions or options to
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
eliminate the different forms of racial discrimination affecting individual/s belonging to minority
AREAS OF CONSIDERATION
This analysis will look into the actors that are involved and identified in the problem of
Strengths
2.Ability to represent,plan and decide as part of the top management around the world
3.Produce many offsprings from different races that will help understand situations of different
countries
Weaknesses
1.Lack knowledge that they become slaves of one or more races in the world
2.Poor skills that make them exploited and deprive of the opportunity to enter labour market in
the world
3.Live in extreme poverty faced with domestic and external concern over the state of its
economy and human rights in the world and lose hope of gaining qualification to work and
Opportunities
1.Inherit political, economic and social life of colonizers to gain knowledge, attitudes and skills
to have equal footing with all countries and gain world recognition
2.Programs and projects of different organization for racially discriminated people in order to
3.Organize rally or protest for equality in civil rights, political rights and religion as human
Threats
2. Victimize by racial profiling that may result to police brutality and extrajudicial killings and
The Whites or person having origins in any of the peoples of Europe, the Middle East, or North
Africa
Strengths
1.Influence the decision of Politicians , Authority and people as well as government system
globally to favor them and make them powerful and profitable human being in the world
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
2.Dominate people and different minority groups of the government in all aspects of life –
3.Own big companies and capitalize in different business ventures around the world
Weaknesses
1.Violate human rights that creates differentiation among races that lead to inequalities and
economic slowdown
2.They experience loss in global downturn or economic slowdown that increase unemployment
3.Overt prejudice, hostility or negative feelings about a racialized person or group that result to
Opportunities
1.Be a crony to Politicians , Authority or Police Officer and businessman and establish good
2.Influence decision-making in terms of hiring process to create more jobs in private and public
3.Can employ people or increase their employment in organizations or company to help the
Threats
2.Large number of anti-black rallyist or political activists in different countries that create chaos
3.Lost representation in management and ownership of properties and companies in the world
Migrants
Strengths
1.Mix with two or more distinct racial groups to enrich culture of different countries
2.Skills, knowledge and drive to bring political or social change in lives of people in in the world
3.Ability to transfer place of their choice around the world for greener pasture and new home
Weaknesses
1.Blame for wrong doings that bring anxiety to people in different places around the world
2.Consider as political activists and subject of violent acts that hamper peace and aggrevate
3.Consider as Social Outcasts and be on exile in the different country in the world
Opportunities
1.Change citizenship or nationality to improve living of people and contribute in economy of the
world
2.Modern technology help spread the news and concerns of the different flight of Migrants in
the world
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
3.Cause genetic admixture and formation of the new races that will breed new generations of
Threats
2.Unequal treatment of people based on national origins or descent in the world that may lead
Incumbent Leaders
Strengths
1.Currently holds office in the government to perform duties and responsibilities and lead
people politically , economically and socially in all countries around the world
2.Political skills and will to implement law, programs and projects for the betterment of the world
3.Ability to decide what is deem necessary for the people and government to maintain world
peace
Weaknesses
1.Violate the right to dignity of people in a hate speech that can discriminate people and affect
2.Commit errors in judgment of situation that can lead to global economic downturn
3.Underestimate people that may lead to political downfall in career and in political stability of
Opportunities
1.Influence other world leaders to plan, decide on political matters and invest on economic
2.Influence people to hear, follow and support programs , activities and projects toward
3.Declare all out war against poverty , unemployment and inequality in the world
Threats
1.Incumbency is temporary in nature and can be replaced any time by the voice of the people
2.Experience global economic problem during incumbency that may lead to end of political
3.Underestimate the economic, political and social situations that may lead to world instability
The Authorities from International Labour Organization, United Nations, UNESCO, World Bank
Strengths
Weaknesses
1.Reveal range of issues, such as disparities in career paths linked to race/ethnicity, lack of
Opportunities
2.Gather teachers, museums and publishers in the different parts of the world to participate in
the endeavour
3.Come together as one world and contribute to the movement for more just and fair societies
Threats
3.Deny individuals the basic principles of equality that destroy lives and communities in the
ASSUMPTION
There are many moves to eliminate or combat racial discrimination around the
world .The disadvantaged racial groups work for people in different countries and has the ability
to represent, plan and decide as part of the top management. If they will only inherit political,
economic and social life of colonizers to gain more knowledge, good attitudes and rights skills
and produce many offspring from different races with better understanding of their situations
then they will be more competent workers. And with the Migrants’ ability to transfer place of their
choice and mix with two or more distinct racial groups armed with their skills, knowledge, and
drive to bring political or social change in lives of people and enrich culture of countries. If
modern technology spread the news and concerns of the different journey of migrants in the
world, there will no longer social outcasts, criminals or asylum or refugees and political activists.
While the Whites who own big companies that capitalize in different business ventures and
have influence around the world. If they can make the hiring process to be competitive
regardless of race then they can create more jobs in private and public sphere around the
world, employ competent people and encourage share in stocks with all racial group in
organizations. Having the Incumbent Leader who currently holds office in the government
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
because of their political will, skills and ability to decide, implement law, programs and projects
and lead people. If during their incumbency, they will implement laws and call other world
leaders to plan, decide on political matters and invest on economic programs that declare all out
war against poverty, unemployment and inequality in the world, and influence rich and poor
people to hear, follow and support these programs, activities and projects then we can move as
one towards development and improvement politically, economically and socially in all
countries. And with the support of the Authorities from International Labour Organization, United
Nations, UNESCO, World Bank who work against racial discrimination world-wide by preserving
all core international human rights instruments in the world to resist racism as a matter of
priority for the international community. If all organizations will come together and work as one,
then they can contribute to the movement for more just and fair societies through their shard
voices and ideas. There will be no problem of racial discrimination with more knowledge, good
attitudes, right skills, and good habits to eradicate racial discrimination in the public and private
spheres of the world. There will be increase in employment rate, less poverty, equality of
people, boost economy and more progress will put the world in peace.
programs and projects on 2. Identify what works well and 2. Divert financial
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
racial discrimination what does not work in the resources away from
and effectiveness of
formulation of better
discrimination
and rules on racial 2. Eliminate police brutalities to policy , rules and law
advocacy content
minority group
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
innovations
The most appropriate Alternative Course of Action is ACA number 1. It is the most
appropriate and possible way to solve the problem on the current existence of racial discrimination
and its forms from centuries. By conducting review of past and current United Nations’ programs
and projects on racial discrimination, it will help identify what is the most effective program to
eliminate racial discrimination worldwide and reveal flaw that needs improvement.
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
PLAN OF ACTION
Incumbent Leaders
World Bank
Universidad de Manila
Antonio J. Villegas St. Mehan Gardens, Manila
College of Public Administration
discrimination in
economy,
government
system, society
minority group.
● To analyze the
effect of racial
discrimination on
individual and
aspect of
economic, political
worldwide effectiveness of
UN programs and
projects
Discuss results and ● Aims to answer Office ( Human Rights One (1) year
problem by
considering
solutions or
options to
eliminate the
different forms of
racial
discrimination
affecting
individual/s
belonging to
minority group
country-wide that
world.