Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Top+Ten+Mistakes+Leaders+Make Finzel EBS PDF
Top+Ten+Mistakes+Leaders+Make Finzel EBS PDF
Top+Ten+Mistakes+Leaders+Make Finzel EBS PDF
By Hans Finzel
EXECUTIVE BOOK SUMMARY
Summary
Who is a leader? lack good models and Since leaders are learning
mentoring. by ―winging it‖ it is important
Finzel spells leadership: that one takes time to review
I-N-F-L-U-E-N-C-E ―Great lack formal training in bad habits that can lead to
leaders challenge people to leadership. ineffectiveness and impact
attempt things they would suffer confusion over the personal and organizational
never try on their own...and to secular and biblical lead- accomplishments.
attempt things we never ership values (servant
thought we had in us‖ (p. 14). hood approach vs. top- This solid, practical book is
Therefore ―anyone who influ- down control.) filled with insightful quotes
ences someone else to do and excerpts from others
something has led that per- The book‘s remaining chapters and the Christian teachings.
son‖ (p.16). highlight, for those called to
Caption describing picture or lead and willing to take on the
graphic.
What contributes to leaders adventure, ten areas where a
failures? leader might blow it. Each
Finzel states ―the average chapter defines the mistake
Have you ever made a mis- leader faces at least five and gives possible solutions or
take? Did you learn some- problems in learning to strategies to avoid making that
thing from the experience? lead‖ (p. 17) and attempts to mistake. The intent is ―an once The Top Ten Mistakes
Hans Finzel‘s book builds on give solutions, often with a bib- of prevention is worth a pound
the premise that we all make lical reference, within the of good leadership. Thus our
mistakes and those in leader- frame work of ten mistakes. need to take a look at some THE TOP DOWN 2
Today‘s leaders: common leadership mis-
ship roles, unfortunately, are ATTITUDE
takes‖ (p. 19). Finzel cautions
no exception. He believes, replicate the poor leader- that all the good done by a 3
PUTTING PAPERWORK
based on his own experience, ship skills or habits ob- leader can be lost if precau- BEFORE PEOPLE WORK
that few choose to be leaders served in others. tions are not taken.
but simply fall into leadership THE ABSENCE OF 4
roles because of skills and often lack basic skills and AFFIRMATION
willingness. This can lead to attitudes for common lead- NO ROOM FOR 4-5
―winging it.‖ ership demands. MAVERICKS
Page 3
The Top Ten Mistakes Leaders Make
Mistake 3: The Absence of Affirmation (pp.53-63)
The third mistake is the absence of affirmation. How do leaders encourage?
Finzel reminds his readers that everyone thrives
Finzel has tips on encouragement that come
on affirmation and praise and that leadership
from the scriptures.
Praise: That shot in the has as much to do with relationships as with
arm that everyone getting things done. He encourage us not to Listening (James 1:19)
needs at differing times. underestimate the power of personal touch of The L in leader stands for listening.
kindness. He then challenges aspiring leaders
―Good supervisors are to learn to read the varying levels of affirma- Empathizing (Romans 12:15)
people who...give people tion for those one leads needs. People in vary- Share joy and share tragedy.
a shot in the arm without ing stages of their career and/or personal life
letting them feel the nee- will need encouragement more than at other
dle‖ (p.60).
Comforting (2 Cor. 1:3-4)
times. There are the desperadoes (always need Our experiences give us richness to share with
encouragement), up-and-downers (need encour- others when they need it.
agement regularly), normal people (an occa-
sional boost works) and the auto pilots (maybe Carrying Burdens (Gal. 6:2)
be jaded against empty praise.) This is the way that one fulfills the law of Christ.
Page 5
The Top Ten Mistakes Leaders Make
Organizational Structures
In Finzel‘s opinion, ―flat‖ or- The Servant Model One of Finzel‘s cautions is
ganizations are the model of that by making top-down
the future. ―Leadership is decisions you will delight
team work, coaching, creativ- workers by taking ownership
ity– and the synergy of a of the decision. Sometimes
group of people inspired by decisions will not be made
their leader‖ (p. 92) the way the leader might
Servant have but then one learns
Leader You do not lead by hit-
there is a better decision out ting people over the
Traditional Model there. Letting others make head– that is assault, not
decisions leads to ownership leadership.
The Flat Dwight D. Eisenhower
and enthusiasm.
Organiza-
tional ―Great leaders are those
Chart who truly feel that the led
are just as important as the
leader‖ (p. 95).
FOUR QUESTIONS
Mistake 6: Dirty Delegation (pp. 97-112) EVERY FOLLOWER
―Overmanaging is one of the ing done better, unwillingness to do it faster oneself. Fi- ASKS
greatest sins of leader- to take the necessary time, nally, vision to develop others WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO
ship‖ (p. 103) Dirty delega- fear of depending on others, with ones delegation free- DO?
tion is when you give some- and lack of training and posi- dom. WILL YOU LET ME DO IT?
one a job and then take it tive experience. Finzel offers
WILL YOU HELP ME WHEN I
back. Finzel observes that five essential ingredients for
NEED IT?
nothing frustrates those who clean delegation. First, faith Four Stages of Delegation
work for the leader more in the one whom you dele- (p. 102) WILL YOU LET ME KNOW
than sloppy delegation. He gate. Second, release from 1. Assignment HOW I‘M DOING?
states that there are several the desire to do it better DR. LORNE SANNY, THE
2. Authority
reasons leaders do not dele- yourself. Third, relaxation BUSINESS MINISTRY JOURNAL,
gate: fear of losing author- from the obsession that is has 3. Accountability 1992
ity, fear of work being done to be done the leader‘s way.
4. Affirmation
incorrectly, fear of work be- Fourth, patience in the desire
Delegation Continuum
Leaders can fail at delega- through styles for each someone comes in with a
tion because of a lack of worker, but always keep in problem, a monkey, be sure ―...I have an imaginary
empathy for what it means to mind some level of supervi- they leave with it. Likewise sign…‘Did they take their
be a follower, never really sion is necessary. ―The great- when you hand over a job, a monkey with them?‘ ― (p.111)
giving the work to others, not est mistake we can making in monkey, think of it as the
staying in touch with the supervising is to treat every- person leaving
work, short circuiting the deci- one the same‖ (p. 109). with the monkey Telling—Selling---Participating---Delegating
sion-making process, or play- on their back.
Finzel illustrates the handing Low Interest High Interest
ing the inner circle game.
over of control as ―taking on Low Motivation High Motivation
Finzel address the impor- Low Skill High Skill
monkeys.‖ He points out if
tance of differing follow (p. 110)
Page 6
The Top Ten Mistakes Leaders Make
Mistake 7: Communication Chaos (pp. 113-131)
Finzel labels the seventh mis- importance of everyone concern), the organizational
take as communication chaos. knowing the ―rules of the chart or people map of rela-
He states that communication game‖ so even though things tionships in the organization
must be that passionate ob- may change people are all (should be simple and flexi-
session of effective leader- going in the right direction. ble), and job descriptions.
ship. He observes the bigger The higher one goes in the He outlines three basic ingre-
the groups, the more atten- leadership chain the more dients of a job description to
tion must be given to commu- they need to be cognizant of include the primary responsi- ―Communicate the big
picture with passion...I
nication and when left unin- who needs to be communi- bilities, the key tasks to com- encourage leaders to spell
formed, people tend to cated with. Finzel calls con- plete those responsibilities, out their purposes, key
dream up wild rumours. His nections the ―communication and whom to report. He con- goals, and core values,
and to ‗preach them from
advice, ―never assume that linkages‖ and encourages cludes with ―have a passion the housetops‘ ― (pp. 124-
anyone knows anything‖ (p. leaders to ask, ―What peo- to communicate, communicate, 125) .
115), encourages leaders to ple are affect by this?‖ (p. communicate. One really
communicate the mission and 119). The necessary as- cannot over-communicate‖ (p.
vision of the organization to pects to communicate are the 130)
the far extremities of an or- vision and values, the chain of
ganization. He stress the command (who handles the
Page 7
The Top Ten Mistakes Leaders Make
Mistake 9: Success without Successors (pp. 157-178)
Finzel, in chapter nine, dis- people, to loss of investment.
“Pride tightens the cusses the issue of mentorship. Who is your mentor?
There is upward mentoring,
In essence, Finzel educates Who stimulates you to
looking up to those who have
grip on leadership; leaders how to prepare to
gone before us, downward
do your best? Who
transition leadership to an- challenges you to go in
mentoring, preparing those
humility relaxes and other. He states that
who will one day replace us, directions you might
―finishing well is an important
lets go.” measure of success in leader-
internal peer mentoring, peers not go?
(p. 157) who challenge us to do bet-
ship‖ (p. 157) and leaders
ter, and external peer mentor- Whom are you mentor-
make two common mistakes:
ing, individuals outside of the ing? What skills are you
staying too long in a position
organization with whom net- modeling? Have you
rather than long enough and
working is possible. Mentors directed individuals to
leaders who stay too long do
provide timely advice, infor-
much more damage than resources that will fur-
mation from other perspec-
those who do not stay long ther develop them?
tives, finances and the free-
enough (Lyle Schaller). He
dom to grow.
covers several reasons why
leaders can‘t let go from job
security, fear of retirement,
―...keep in mind that day
down the road when with resistance to change, self-
humility we will have to pass worth, lack of confidence in
the torch to our successor...the successor, love for job/ ― A VISION IS A
ultimate measure of our lead-
ership success‖ (p.177). PICTURE OF THE
FUTURE STATE FOR THE
ORGANIZATION...AS
SEEN BY ITS
Mistake 10: Failure to Focus on the Future (pp. 179-195)
LEADERSHIP...IT IS A
Finzel‘s tenth mistake states complete a task.) COMMITMENT‖ (P.195)
that leaders fail to focus VISION AUDIT RICHARD BECKHARD & WENDY
Finzel‘s advice for the future
enough on the future. The What are the strengths PRITCHARD, CHANIGING THE
is to set time to think about
effective leader‘s chief pre- of our group? ESSENCE, 1992:25
directions or create a future
occupation should be on pro-
file, perform a vision audit, What are our greatest
viding vision for the organi-
develop a fresh vision state- weaknesses?
zation. He believes the con-
ment, work together to create
stant is change and it is com- What should be our
short and long term (SMART)
ing at a faster pace each highest priorities?
goals, focus and eliminate
decade. ―Leadership must
resources, read about trends, What do we do well?
be devoting itself to the issue
and attempt great things and
of goals and strate- What do we do
take risks.
gies...Managers ask, how, poorly?
leaders ask where and why?
We need a balance of vi- What barriers do we
sionary leadership and effec- need to remove to fun-
damentally enhance ―...if leadership is about the
tive management‖ (pp. 186- future, then the worst thing a
187). He cautions about our effectiveness for leader can do is fear that
approaching the future in two the future? p. 192) future...The future is rushing
towards us and past us with
ways: learner (open to new an awesome power that no
ideas and change) or as a man can stop…‖
closed expert (knowing every- (pp. 180-181)
thing and the best way to Page 8
EdAdmin 834: Case Studies in Educational Leadership
Finzel effectively provides a practical application for each of the issues he raises. He identifies the problem and provides direction to
avoid each of the ten mistakes. The chapter end “PowerPoint's” provide concrete actions to avoid or alleviate each of the identified
mistakes leaders may make. He alludes to the Biblical principles throughout his writing making this a valuable resource for church
leaders. However, each of the mistakes identified can be applied to the business and education world. His anecdotes clearly illustrate
his points. His insight and frankness contribute to the ease of reading.