Curated by Keira Nelson, PSIII Intern Teacher at the University of Lethbridge
Looking for some more sources about Imposter Syndrome? Look no further!
Brems, C., Baldwin, M. R., Davis, L., & Namyniuk, L. (1994). The Imposter Syndrome as Related to Teaching Evaluations and Advising Relationships of University Faculty Members. The Journal of Higher Education, Mar. - Apr. 1994, Vol. 65(2), 183-193. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2943923 Brems et al. conducted a study regarding the efficacy of university instructors when impacted with Imposter Syndrome, and how feelings of self-doubt can impact the effectiveness of a teacher’s lessons. Brems et al. found that teachers who are more doubtful of their own performance of a teacher are likely to be less effective teachers, with less beneficial relationships with students, a lessened ability to answer student questions, and a lower level of enthusiasm in the classroom. The study did not contain any strategies of how to address Imposter Syndrome, since it was more about the data of what impact it has on students, but it is interesting to note that students can unconsciously pick up on a teacher’s Imposter Syndrome.
Clance, P. R. (2013). Dr. Pauline Rose Clance - IMPOSTER PHENOMENON. Dr. Pauline Rose Clance. https://paulineroseclance.com/impostor_phenomenon.html Pauline Clance is one of the originators of the term “Imposter Syndrome.” Spurned by her experiences in graduate school, Clance dove into research regarding the feeling that everyone secretly felt. Also found here is Clance’s “Clance Imposter Phenomenon Scale,” or CIPS. CIPS is a 2 page test of sorts where the test-taker can rank their feelings of self-doubt in various scenarios, and add up the numbers at the end to calculate their Imposter Phenomenon score. There is no official diagnosis offered, but it is noted that “the higher the score, the more frequently and seriously the Imposter Phenomenon interferes in a person’s life.” As teachers, knowing how often we experience Imposter Syndrome even subconsciously can be an important start in ridding oneself of the feeling entirely.
Dalla-Camina, M. (2018, September 3). The Reality of Imposter Syndrome. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/blog/real-women/201809/the-reality-im poster-syndrome Dalla-Camina’s article for the “Real Women” column of Psychology Today is more a recognition of Imposter Syndrome rather than a list of solutions or of personal experiences. She focuses on how it impacts women every day, and how it’s based on the inherent reactions of women to circumstance. The solutions provided include speaking out about the feeling, getting feedback for validation, and reaffirming a woman’s position within her workplace through feedback. Dalla-Camina also writes about confidence, and how an imposter’s courage in themselves can be hindered, thus keeping them from future opportunities that are within reach, but appear to be too far away. There are also links to find opportunities for therapists near the reader’s location, which is a helpful and meaningful connection to make.
Ellis, M. (2019, May 23). Five Ways Teachers and Trainers Can Manage Imposter Syndrome. The Teaching Space. https://www.theteachingspace.com/blog/imposter-syndrome Ellis’ blog post is based on a podcast she writes and produces, entitled “The Teaching Space.” Podcasts are a great way to gain valuable information without having to sit and read for a long period of time, since everyone knows that a teacher’s time is so valuable. Ellis provides her own experience with Imposter Syndrome, and references several possible causes of the feeling. She also provides many strategies for managing Imposter Syndrome, and they are more practical than just “pull yourself up by your bootstraps,” which we all know isn’t helpful.
Hillsmith, C. (2020, Feb 7). Imposter Syndrome - Life as an English Teacher. Life as an English Teacher. https://misshillsmith.com/2020/02/07/imposter-syndrome/ Hillsmith’s attitude towards Imposter Syndrome is more conversational and describes her personal experiences with the condition. Her language is easy to follow, and she is very personal in describing a situation in which she felt like an imposter. However, her suggestions for beating Imposter Syndrome are only scratching the surface of what actually helps, with the first suggestion being “believe in yourself.” This is a surface level addressing of a greater systemic issue, and still places the onus on the teacher that they are somehow doing something wrong in their thought practice.
McGregor, L. N., Gee, D. E., & Posey, K. E. (2008). I Feel lIke a Fraud and it Depresses Me: the Relation Between the Imposter Phenomenon and Depression. Social Behaviour and Personality, 36( 1), 43-48. https://doi.org/10.2224/sbp.2008.36.1.43 McGregor et al.’s 2008 study of college students and their experiences with Imposter Syndrome is enlightening, but can provide a false sense of connection between Imposter Syndrome and depression. The study found a “positive correlation between IP (Imposter Phenomenon) scores and BDI (Beck Depression Inventory) scores” (46). However, this does not mean that every imposter is depressed, or that every depressed person is an imposter. There is also no connection between Imposter Syndrome causing clinical depression. The only conclusion made is that there is a connection in the symptoms of both conditions, because the negative thoughts of Imposter Syndrome are similar to the negative thoughts of depression. The research can be interpreted to suggest that individuals of Imposter Syndrome cannot withstand the symptoms of Imposter Syndrome for extended periods of time. Those with depression often seek professional help due to the same symptoms, so it is reasonable to assume that individuals with Imposter Syndrome might feel a similar way, but without the acceptance often found with other mental illnesses.
Nance-Nash, S. (2020, July 27). Why imposter syndrome hits women and women of colour harder. BBC Equality Matters. https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20200724-why-imposter-syndrome-hits- women-and-women-of-colour-harder Nance-Nash’s exploration of the power disparity of women in professional environments, which would include schools as well: it is worth noting that there are more women at the teacher level and more men in administration levels of school, which has the potential to spurn a teacher’s Imposter Syndrome to an even higher extent. Nance-Nash is writing from a broader perspective, looking at the woman’s stance in corporate life in general, but the sentiment of Imposter Syndrome as an issue for those lacking power holds true in education.
UConn Center for Excellence in Teaching and Learning. (n.d.). What? So what? Now what? model. Centre for Excellence in Teaching and Learning. https://cetl.uconn.edu/what-so-what-now-what-model/# Rolfe, Freshwater and Jasper originally created the What? So What? Now What? Model to help reflect on one’s thought process regarding transformative thinking. The University of Connecticut’s walkthrough of the thoughts, including questions and prompts to ask yourself when going through the process, is a helpful resource in attempting to overcome Imposter Syndrome. The focus is moved from looking at the event (the “What”), describing why the event mattered (“So What”), and finally looking at the next steps (the “Now What”). Even if someone does not use this strategy for Imposter Syndrome specifically, the process of breaking down an event into something more manageable with guiding questions is a therapeutic and helpful process.
Watson, A. (2017, Nov 12). 7 ways teachers can push past imposter syndrome. The Cornerstone for Teachers. https://thecornerstoneforteachers.com/truth-for-teachers-podcast/imposter-sy ndrome/ Angela Watson’s blog and podcast, The Cornerstone for Teachers, provides a reflection on Imposter Syndrome in teachers and how teachers can push past it. Watson’s linked blog post about how “your classroom does not have to be Pinterest-worthy” is a refreshing change from the ever-present toxic positivity often found in teacher self-help blogs. Watson also presents her material in a podcast format, so teachers can listen on the commute or while doing something else. The strategies feel realistic and attainable for teachers to implement when they can, instead of becoming an extra “thing” to add to a busy schedule. Watson’s focus is often on anxiety and freeing yourself from those types of feelings, so Imposter Syndrome fits under the umbrella of her expertise.
Weir, K. (2013). Feel like a fraud? gradPSYCH Magazine, 2013(11), 24. https://www.apa.org/gradpsych/2013/11/fraud Focusing on graduate students and the specific experience they may have with Imposter Syndrome, Weir compiles stories of various students at universities across the United States. Weir also provides some helpful strategies for facing imposter feelings, and how graduate students (and more) can try to overcome the pressure to achieve. Weir’s compilation of stories make the reader feel like they are not alone in feeling these self-doubt feelings- a reassurance to all.