Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BS 5728 - 3 Cold Potable Water
BS 5728 - 3 Cold Potable Water
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
Measurement of flow of
cold potable water in
closed conduits —
Part 3: Methods for determining
principal characteristics of single
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
ICS 17.120.10
BS 5728-3:1997
The following bodies were also represented in the drafting of the standard
through subcommittees and panels:
Contents
Page
Committees responsible Inside front cover
Foreword ii
1 Scope 1
2 Normative references 1
3 Definitions 1
4 General considerations affecting all tests 1
5 Measurement error tests 2
6 Pressure tests 5
7 Pressure loss tests 8
8 Accelerated wear tests 16
9 Test report 17
Annex A (informative) Summary of requirements and
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
© BSI 10-1999 i
BS 5728-3:1997
Foreword
A British Standard does not purport to include all the necessary provisions of a
contract. Users of British Standards are responsible for their correct application.
Summary of pages
This document comprises a front cover, and inside front cover, pages i and ii,
pages 1 to 20, an inside back cover and a back cover.
This standard has been updated (see copyright date) and may have had
amendments incorporated. This will be indicated in the amendment table on the
inside front cover.
ii © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
3 Definitions N k 100 3
100 < N k 1 000 2
For the purposes of this Part of BS 5728, the
definitions given in BS 5728-7:1997 apply, together 1 000 < N 1
with the following. NOTE The number of water meters in Table 1 may be regarded
3.1 as the minimum to be tested; the authority responsible for
pattern approval may request additional water meters.
measurement error
4.1.2.2 Pattern approval tests
the difference between the indicated value of the
volume and the conventional true value of the Before tests commence, each water meter and
volume of water passed through the meter during a accompanying certificates shall be inspected to
test check that the meter conforms to the regulations in
NOTE 1 Measurement errors are conventionally expressed as
force, and also to the specifications (e.g. model,
relative errors, calculated as a percentage, and equal to: identification, size and material) and drawings
Vi – Vc submitted when approval was requested.
- × 100
----------------
Vc The tests shall include the following, carried out in
where the order indicated:
Vc is the value accepted as true of the volume passed; a) pressure tests (see 6.4);
Vi is the volume indicated by the water meter at the time b) determination of the error curves as a function
of measurement of the same volume, both expressed in
the same units. of flow-rate (see 5.9);
NOTE 2 The values for maximum permissible errors (MPE) are c) pressure loss tests (see 7.5);
specified in 5.1 of BS 5728-7:1997. d) accelerated wear tests (see 8.3).
3.2 4.1.3 Initial verification
test flow-rate
NOTE Initial verification consists in verifying that all the
the mean rate of flow of water through the meter water meters submitted conform to the approved model and to
under test during the period of a test the standards and regulations in force. The initial verification
programme may authorize total or partial statistical control
NOTE The test flow-rate is usually measured and indicated by procedures.
a calibrated reference device (see 5.2 and 5.4).
4.1.3.1 Check for conformity to the approved model
4 General considerations affecting all The meters shall be inspected to check that they
tests have the same technical characteristics (dimensions
4.1 Test programme of the constituent parts, materials, surface
finish, etc.) as the approved model.
NOTE Water meters are subject to a variety of different test
programmes. For the purposes of pattern approval and initial NOTE This check is normally carried out by sampling.
verification, water meters are covered by the requirements of
EC Directive 75/33/EEC of 17 November 1974.
© BSI 10-1999 1
BS 5728-3:1997
4.1.3.2 Initial verification tests NOTE Within this temperature range, temperature correction
of the results is not required.
Initial verification tests shall include at least the
following: 4.3.4 Location
a) in principle, on all meters: The test rig shall be isolated from any other activity
(for example, manufacture, repairs) and from
— pressure tests (see 6.5); environmental disturbances (for example,
— determination of the measurement fluctuations in ambient temperature, vibration).
errors (see 5.10);
b) normally, by sampling, as required by the 5 Measurement error tests
inspector: NOTE The method described in this Part of BS 5728 to
— a check that the meter conforms to the determine measurement errors is the so-called “collection”
method, in which the quantity of water passed through the water
approved pattern (see 4.1.2.2); meter is collected in one or more collecting vessels, and the
— pressure loss measurement (see 7.6). quantity determined volumetrically or by weighing. Other
methods may be used, provided the accuracy levels stated in this
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
2 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
5.3.2 Test section In order to counteract these effects, the meter shall
The test section shall include, in addition to the be installed for test in a straight length of pipe. The
meter(s): connecting pipework shall have the same internal
diameter as the bore of the meter inlet.
a) one or more pressure tappings for the
NOTE 3 It may also be necessary to put a flow straightener
measurement of pressure, of which one pressure upstream of the straight length.
tapping shall be situated upstream of, and close
5.3.4.3 Common causes of flow disturbance
to, the (first) meter;
b) if necessary, means for measuring the Flow can be subject to two types of disturbance:
temperature of the water at the inlet of the (first) velocity profile distortion and swirl, both of which
meter. affect the accuracy of the water meter.
The different devices placed in the measuring Velocity profile distortion is typically caused by an
section shall not cause cavitation or flow obstruction partially blocking the pipe, for instance
disturbances capable of altering the performance of the presence of a partly closed valve or a misaligned
flange joint. This can easily be eliminated by
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
© BSI 10-1999 3
BS 5728-3:1997
5.4 Calibrated reference device During measurement error testing, the volume to be
5.4.1 Overall error of the method employed passed shall be chosen to be sufficiently large, so
that the maximum error in the reading of the
For pattern approval and initial verification, the volume indicated by the meter does not
total error in the method used for the determination exceed 0.5 % (see 4.5.4 of BS 5728-7:1997).
of the volume of water passed through the water
In the reading of a meter having circular scales with
meter shall not exceed 1/10 of the relevant
pointers, in order to avoid errors due to eccentricity
maximum permissible error.
or uneven scale graduations, the volume to be
5.4.2 Minimum volume of the calibrated vessel passed shall be chosen such that whole revolutions
Where a calibrated volumetric vessel is used, the of the pointer or scale are used.
minimum volume permitted depends on 5.7 Major factors affecting measurement error
requirements determined by the test start and end checks
effects and the design of the indicating
NOTE Variations in the pressure, flow-rate, and temperature
device (verification scale division) (see BS 5728-7) of in the test rig, and uncertainties in the precision of measurement
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
the meter under test. of these physical quantities, are the principal factors affecting the
measurement error test results.
5.5 Test methods
5.7.1 Pressure
5.5.1 Standing start/stop test method
The pressure shall be maintained at a constant
The flow is established by opening a valve, value throughout the test at the chosen flow-rate.
preferably situated downstream of the meter, and it
is stopped by the closure of this valve. The meter is For testing water meters of N10 or smaller, at test
read whilst completely stationary. flow-rates k 1 m3/h, constant pressure at the inlet
of the meter (or at the inlet of the first meter of a
Time is measured between the beginning of the series being tested) can be achieved if the test rig is
movement of the valve at opening and at the supplied through a pipe from a constant head tank.
beginning of closure.
Any other methods of supply which can be shown
5.5.2 Flow diversion method not to cause pressure pulsations exceeding those of
The measurement is carried out when the flow a constant head tank may be used.
conditions have stabilized. For all other tests the pressure upstream of the
A flow diverter switches the flow into a calibrated meter shall not vary by more than 10 %.
vessel at the beginning of the measurement and The maximum uncertainty in the measurement of
diverts it away at the end. The meter is read in pressure shall be 5 % of the measured value.
motion. Pressure at the inlet to the meter shall not exceed
The reading of the meter is synchronized with the the nominal pressure for the meter.
movement of the flow diverter. 5.7.2 Flow-rate
The volume collected in the vessel is the volume The flow-rate shall be maintained constant
passed. throughout the test at the chosen value.
NOTE The volume collected may be determined by measuring
its mass and converting this to volume from a knowledge of the The relative variation in the flow-rate during each
water density. test (not including starting and stopping) shall not
The uncertainty introduced into the volumes exceed:
measured shall be considered to be negligible if the ± 2.5 % from qmin to qt (not inclusive);
time of motion of the flow diverter in each direction ± 5.0 % from qt (inclusive) to qs.
is identical within 5 % and if each time is not less
than 1/50 of the total duration of the test. The flow-rate value used in plotting the error curve
shall be the volume passed during the test divided
5.6 Precautions to be taken when reading a by the duration of the test.
meter
The relative pressure variation (in flow to free air)
NOTE The maximum reading error of a scale does not exceed or the relative variation in pressure loss (in closed
half a scale division per observation. Thus in the measurement of
a volume of flow delivered by a water meter (consisting of two circuits) shall not exceed:
observations of the water meter) the total reading error can reach ± 5 % from qmin to qt (not inclusive);
one scale division or, in the case of discontinuous movement of
the control element, 2 digits. ± 10 % from qt (inclusive) to qs.
5.7.3 Temperature
During a test the temperature of the water shall not
change by more than 5 °C.
4 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
The maximum uncertainty in the measurement of If the error determined lies outside the tolerance
temperature shall not exceed 1 °C. band, the test may be continued. It shall then be
5.8 Interpretation of results repeated twice. If the arithmetical mean of the three
test results is within or at the limits of the tolerance
5.8.1 Single test band, the test results shall be declared to be
Where the test programme specifies a single test, satisfactory.
the meter shall be considered to have passed this 5.10 Initial verification tests. Determination of
test if the measured error does not exceed the the measurement errors
maximum permissible error at the chosen flow-rate.
Test methods and equipment shall be as described
5.8.2 Repeated tests in 5.1 to 5.7.
Where the test programme specifies that the test The measurement errors of each water meter shall
may be repeated, the programme shall specify the be determined at not less than three flow-rates.
rules to be applied for combining the errors
The flow-rates shall be chosen with regard to the
obtained.
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
© BSI 10-1999 5
BS 5728-3:1997
Before being submitted for pattern approval or 6.4 Pattern approval tests. Pressure tests
initial verification tests, the meter shall be sealed at The requirement for these tests is that each meter
a point above the location of the inner seal by a withstand, without leakage or seepage through the
means suited to the meter design. When the walls, and without damage, a pressure equal to:
concentric meter is fitted to the pressure test
manifold and pressurized, it shall be possible to a) 16 bar, or 1.6 times the nominal pressure if it
see the source of any leak flowing from the pressure exceeds 10 bar, applied for a period of 15 min;
test manifold outlet and distinguish between it and and
that issuing from an incorrectly fitted sealing b) 20 bar, or twice the nominal pressure, applied
device. for a period of 1 min.
Figure 2 shows an example of a design of plug suited
to many meter designs, but any other means of
sealing may be adopted.
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
A B C
19.65
N1 to N2.5 8
15.13 19.60 1.40
15.03 31.95 1.30
N2.5 to N3.5 8
31.90
Dimensions in millimetres.
Figure 1 — Pressure test manifold for concentric meters
6 © BSI 10-1999
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
© BSI 10-1999
Figure 2 — Example of plug for pressure test of concentric meters
7
BS 5728-3:1997
BS 5728-3:1997
6.5 Initial verification tests. Pressure tests 7.2 Pressure loss test equipment
Each meter shall be subjected to a pressure equal NOTE The equipment needed to carry out pressure loss tests
to 16 bar or 1.6 times the nominal consists of a measuring section of pipework containing the water
meter under test and a system for producing the specified
pressure (see 3.21 and 4.12 of BS 5728-7:1997). The constant flow-rate through the meter. The same method of
meter shall then be inspected for leakage, seepage achieving constant flow-rate as that employed for the
through the walls and damage. measurement error tests described in clause 5 may be used for
the pressure loss tests.
NOTE P1 and P2 are the planes of the pressure tappings and C is the water meter, or for concentric meters, C is the water meter
plus manifold.
L U 15D, L1 U 10D, L2 U 5D D = internal diameter of the pipework
Figure 3 — Layout of the measuring section
8 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
7.2.1.4 Design of measuring section pressure Slits shall be perpendicular to the pipe axis and
tappings shall have dimensions as follows (see Figure 6).
Pressure tappings of similar design and dimensions a) Width i shall be equal to or less than 0.08D or
shall be fitted to the inlet and outlet pipes of the less than 4 mm whichever is the smaller.
measuring section. b) Depth k shall be greater than 2i.
NOTE 1 Pressure tappings may consist of holes drilled through
the wall of the pipe or be in the form of an annular slit in the pipe
7.2.1.6 Measurement of static differential pressure
wall, in either case perpendicular to the pipe axis. There should Each group of pressure tappings in the same plane
be at least four such pressure tapping holes, equally spaced in
one plane around the pipe circumference. Examples of both types
shall be connected by a leak-free tube to one limb of
of pressure tapping as specified in 7.2.1.5 are shown in Figure 4, a differential pressure measuring device, for
Figure 5 and Figure 6. example, a manometer. Provision shall be made for
NOTE 2 Four or more pressure tapping holes may be bleeding air from the installation.
interconnected by means of tee-shaped connectors which connect
up the pressure tappings, forming an annulus to give a true mean 7.2.2 Design of pipe lengths and test
static pressure at the pipe cross-section (see Figure 5). manifold (concentric meters only)
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
Figure 4 — Example of drilled hole type of pressure tapping with ring chamber,
suitable for small/medium diameter test sections
© BSI 10-1999 9
BS 5728-3:1997
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
Figure 5 — Example of drilled hole type of pressure tapping with loop mean static
pressure interconnections, suitable for medium/large diameter test sections
10 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
© BSI 10-1999 11
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
12
BS 5728-3:1997
© BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
pipe lengths (%P1) shall be determined prior to the meter (measurement 2) (concentric meters
tests proper, and checked periodically. This shall be only)
done by joining the upstream and downstream pipe
faces together in the absence of the meter (carefully At the same test flow-rates used to determine the
avoiding joint protrusion into the pipe bore or pipe and test manifold pressure losses, in the same
misalignment of the two faces), and measuring the installation, with the same pressure tappings and
pipe pressure loss of the measuring section for each the same manometer, but with the manifold cap
test flow-rate. removed and the water meter in position, the
differential pressure (%P2) across the metering
The absence of the water meter will shorten the section shall be measured. (See Figure 9.)
measuring section. If telescopic sections are not
fitted on the test rig, the gap may be filled by The actual pressure loss, %P, of the water meter at
inserting, at the downstream end of the measuring a given flow-rate shall be calculated from the
section, either a temporary pipe of the same length following equation:
and internal diameter as the water meter, or the %P = %P2 – %P1
water meter itself. The value arrived at shall be converted to the
7.3.3 Measurement and calculation of the pressure loss corresponding to the value of qs of the
actual pressure loss of the water meter water meter using the formula given in 7.6.
(measurement 2) (in-line meters only) NOTE If the test flow-rates with and without the meter present
differ, they may be adjusted to the same value by the square law
At the same test flow-rates used to determine the formula given in 7.6.
pipe pressure losses, in the same installation, with
7.4 Measurement uncertainty
the same pressure tappings and the same
manometer but with the water meter in position, The maximum relative uncertainty in the results of
the differential pressure %P2 across the metering the measurement of pressure loss shall be ± 5 %.
section shall be measured. 7.5 Pattern approval test. Pressure loss tests
The actual pressure loss, %P, of the water meter at Test methods and equipment used to determine
a given flow-rate shall be calculated from the pressure loss shall be as described in 7.2 and 7.3.
following equation:
The value of pressure loss shall be determined at not
%P = %P2 – %P1 less than the maximum flow-rate so that the water
The value arrived at shall be converted to the meter may be classified in accordance with clause 6
pressure loss corresponding to the value of qs of the of BS 5728-7:1997.
water meter using the formula given in 7.6.
NOTE If the flow-rates with and without the meter present
differ, they may be adjusted to the same value by the square law
formula given in 7.6.
© BSI 10-1999 13
BS 5728-3:1997
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
14 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
© BSI 10-1999 15
BS 5728-3:1997
16 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
with a minimum of 1 s
qs Continuous 100 h
N > 10 qp Continuous 800 h
qs Continuous 200 h
a (q ) is the number equal to the value of qp expressed in m3/h.
p
© BSI 10-1999 17
BS 5728-3:1997
9.1.2 Identification data to be included in all b) the signature of the officer accepting technical
reports and test registers responsibility for the test report;
The report on pattern approval tests for a particular c) the date of issue of the test report.
type of meter, and the register concerning the initial 9.2.2 Additions to test reports
verification tests, shall include as a minimum:
Additions to a test report after issue shall be made
a) identification of testing laboratory: only by a further document marked: “Supplement to
— name and address; test report. Serial No...”, and shall meet the relevant
b) identification of meter tested: requirements of the preceding subclauses.
— the name and address of the manufacturer 9.2.3 Publication of test reports
or the trademark used; When issued, the test report shall only be
— the metrological class and the rated flow qp; reproduced in its entirety.
— the type or model (only in the case of 9.3 Initial verification register. Required
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
18 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
© BSI 10-1999 19
BS 5728-3:1997
Annex A (informative)
Summary of requirements and permitted tolerances in the measurement of
physical quantities associated with water meter test methods and equipment
A summary of requirements and permitted tolerances for water meter test methods and equipment is given
in Table A.1.
Table A.1 — Summary of requirements and permitted tolerances
Clause
Quantity Details Specified tolerance
referencea
Measurement error checks
Time Flow diversion method. Time of motion of flow switch Identical within 5 % 5.5.2
in each direction. in each direction
and < 2 % of total
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
duration of test
Volume Maximum error in the measurement of the volume of k 10 % of relevant 5.4.1
water passed through the meter under test (as maximum
measured by calibrated reference device). permissible error
Meter reading Maximum error in the reading of the volume indicated k 0.5 % 5.6
by meter under test.
Pressure Flow created by means other than a constant head
tank:
— Pressure variation upstream of meter. k 10 % 5.7.1
— Precision of measurement of pressure. k5% 5.7.1
Flow-rate Relative variation in flow-rate during each test:
— qmin to qt (not incl.) ± 2.5 % 5.7.2
— qt to qs ±5% 5.7.2
This is equivalent, in terms of pressure, to a pressure
variation upstream of the meter (flow to free air) or a
pressure loss variation (flow in closed circuits) of:
— qmin to qy (not incl.)
— qt to qs
Temperature Water temperature change during a test. < 5 °C 5.7.3
Uncertainty of measurement of temperature. < 1 °C 5.7.3
Pressure loss tests
Pressure Maximum uncertainty in the results of pressure loss ±5% 7.4
measurement.
Accelerated wear tests
— Continuous flow test
Flow-rate Relative variation in flow-rate during each test. ± 10 % 8.1.4
Time Tolerance on specified duration of test. Value is a min. 8.1.5
Volume Tolerance on volume discharged during test. Value is a min. 8.1.6
— Discontinuous flow test
Flow-rate Relative variation in flow-rate during constant test ± 10 % 8.2.4
flow phase.
Time Tolerance on specified duration of each test phase. ± 10 % 8.2.5.2
Tolerance on total test duration. ±5% 8.2.5.2
Number of Number of cycles of test. + 1 % and – 0 % 8.2.5.3
cycles
Volume Tolerance on volume discharged during test. ±5% 8.2.6
a
The references are to the subclauses in this Part of BS 5728.
20 © BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:1997
Normative references
BSI publications
BRITISH STANDARDS INSTITUTION, London
© BSI 10-1999
BS 5728-3:
1997
BSI — British Standards Institution
BSI is the independent national body responsible for preparing
British Standards. It presents the UK view on standards in Europe and at the
international level. It is incorporated by Royal Charter.
Revisions
It is the constant aim of BSI to improve the quality of our products and services.
We would be grateful if anyone finding an inaccuracy or ambiguity while using
this British Standard would inform the Secretary of the technical committee
responsible, the identity of which can be found on the inside front cover.
Tel: 020 8996 9000. Fax: 020 8996 7400.
BSI offers members an individual updating service called PLUS which ensures
that subscribers automatically receive the latest editions of standards.
Licensed Copy: lbocvzr lbocvzr, University of Loughborough, 26 June 2003, Uncontrolled Copy, (c) BSI
Buying standards
Orders for all BSI, international and foreign standards publications should be
addressed to Customer Services. Tel: 020 8996 9001. Fax: 020 8996 7001.
Information on standards
Copyright
Copyright subsists in all BSI publications. BSI also holds the copyright, in the
UK, of the publications of the international standardization bodies. Except as
permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 no extract may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any
means – electronic, photocopying, recording or otherwise – without prior written
permission from BSI.
This does not preclude the free use, in the course of implementing the standard,
of necessary details such as symbols, and size, type or grade designations. If these
details are to be used for any other purpose than implementation then the prior
written permission of BSI must be obtained.