St.

PETER’S COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY

(Approved by AICTE, New Delhi, affiliated to AU, Chennai, ISO 2008:9001 Certified)
NAAC Accredited with ‘A’ Grade
College Road, Avadi, Chennai-600054.
Phone: 044-26558089, 26558091 Website:www.spcet.ac.in/icsss2017 E-mail: icsss2017@gmail.com

CSIR and ICMR SPONSORED

IEEE THIRD INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON
SENSING, SIGNAL PROCESSING AND SECURITY-ICSSS 2017
Reviewer Form
ECE-ICSSS-2017-125
Paper id & Title Performance Analysis Of Vascaded Optical Fibers
Using DP-16 QAM Modulation
Reviewer Information The quality is average
Reviewer Report
S. Criteria Ratings
5 4 3 2 1 0
No.
1. Originality of the Paper √
2. Technical Relevance to the Conference √
3. Adequacy of Paper Title and Abstract √
4. Quality of Technical Content √
5. Appropriateness of Figures and Tables √
6. Suitable Literature Citations √
7. Adequacy of Experimental Analysis √
8. Soundness of Conclusions and Interpretations √
9. Adherence to the Instructions to Authors √
10. Overall Structure of the Paper √

Paper Status: 2

1. Strongly Recommended

2. Recommended with minor Changes

3. May be considered with major revisions after resubmission

4. Not Recommended

Review Comments (if any): Author may compare the performance with some existing
method.