Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Wall Street Journal - Vol. 276 No. 126 (27 Nov 2020) PDF
The Wall Street Journal - Vol. 276 No. 126 (27 Nov 2020) PDF
00
DJIA Closed (29872.47) NASDAQ Closed (12094.40) STOXX 600 391.63 À 0.1% 10-YR. TREASURY Closed (0.878%) OIL Closed ($45.71) GOLD Closed ($1,805.70) EURO $1.1914 YEN 104.26
To Decline Further
MARK LEECH/OFFSIDE/GETTY IMAGES
#1 CRM.
from a clinical trial of its BY PATRICIA KOWS The monitors, appointed by analysis for several countries,
Covid-19 vaccine this week. A7 AND JENNY STRASBURG New York state’s Department of including Russia. “As we work
The Army Corps of Engi- Financial Services, told the to continuously improve our
neers rejected environmental Deutsche Bank AG executives bank in October that efforts to controls in combating financial
permits for the massive Peb- want to expand in Russia de- improve its operation weren’t crime, our risk appetite must
ble Mine in Alaska, a likely spite a legacy of missteps and enough to make up for the large be in line with the maturity of Ranked #1 for CRM Applications based on
death blow for the project. A2 massive fines. Outside monitors risks of doing business with those controls,” he added. IDC 2020H1 Revenue Market Share Worldwide.
who watch over the bank’s Russian clients, the person said. A Department of Financial 19.8%
Ethiopia’s government money-laundering controls said A Deutsche Bank spokes- Services spokeswoman de-
began what it called the final it should shut the business in- man declined to comment on clined to comment.
phase of a military operation stead, a person familiar with its dialogue with monitors, but The monitors are attorneys
on the encircled capital of the the communications said. said it is conducting a risk Please turn to page A8
rebel-run region of Tigray. A8
Saudi Arabia transferred
the case of women’s rights Move Over Tofurky, Now There’s Something Weirder
activist Loujain al-Hathloul
to a terrorism court. A8 i i i
5.3%
4.8%
CONTENTS Markets..................... B11
Faux-meat market concocts new names; YamChops, Incogmeato 3.9%
Arts in Review A10-11 Opinion.............. A13-15 3.8%
Banking & Finance B10 Sports........................ A12 BY JACOB BUNGE Brands Group Inc. menus and
Business News.. B3,5 Technology............... B4 AND HEATHER HADDON in Kroger Co. and Walmart Inc.
Crossword............... A11 U.S. News............. A2-7 meat sections over the last few 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020H1
Heard on Street. B12 Weather................... A11
Mansion............. M1-10 World News...... A8,16
Food scientists for decades years. The race for a piece of Source: IDC, Worldwide Semiannual
Software Tracker, October 2020.
have tinkered with plant pro- the plant-based surge also
teins, starches and oils to make tests companies’ ability to con-
> burgers that sizzle, bleed and coct names that are appealing,
taste like real beef, without Just call me delicious memorable, and not too corny.
harming a single steer. Last year MorningStar salesforce.com/number1CRM
Then comes the hard part: oil are well on their way to Farms, a division of Kellogg
s 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
formulating a name. ubiquity, with new and more- Co., introduced “Incogmeato” CRM market includes the following IDC-defined functional markets: Sales Force Productivity and Management,
Marketing Campaign Management, Customer Service, Contact Center, Advertising, and Digital Commerce
Applications. © 2020 salesforce.com, inc. All rights reserved. Salesforce.com is a registered trademark of
All Rights Reserved Burger patties made from convincing versions landing on and Spam maker Hormel Foods salesforce.com, inc., as are other names and marks.
soy, yellow peas and coconut Burger King and Dunkin’ Please turn to page A9
A2 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
Hawaii Treads Gingerly to Revive Tourism
BY KIM MACKRAEL Daily arrivals in Hawaii,
change from previous year* Unemployment rate†
Hawaii is seeking a careful 25% 25 %
balance as the holiday travel
season kicks off: Allow enough Hawaii
visitors to help struggling, 0 20
tourism-reliant businesses
without causing a new wave of Domestic
coronavirus cases. passengers
SHAFKAT ANOWAR FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
–25 15
The state last month began International
allowing U.S. visitors to skip a Total
mandatory 14-day quarantine
–50 Note: Seven-day 10
if they get tested for Covid-19 moving average
through an approved provider U.S.
within three days of their
–75 5
flight and the test comes back
negative. The change
prompted some businesses on
–100 0
the islands to reopen, and
many are hoping for a pickup J F M A M J J A S O N J F M A M J J A S O
in December. *International passengers and total data exclude arrivals from Canada. †Seasonally adjusted.
But with surging coronavi- Source: Hawaii Department of Business, Economic Development & Tourism (arrivals);
rus cases across most of the Sparse crowds made social distancing easier at the Alohilani Resort in Waikiki earlier this month. Labor Department (unemployment)
mainland U.S., Hawaii tight-
ened its rules this week so vis- Efforts to restart the tour- average number of new president of operations for effort to help the unemployed tainable,” said Shannon Edie,
itors must have proof of a ism economic engine may be Covid-19 cases held roughly in Hawaii. A third is being used and struggling restaurants. president of the Native Hawai-
negative test result by the coming too late for some busi- line with the number of daily as a quarantine facility. Over- Ms. Dela Cruz made about ian Chamber of Commerce.
time they land. Those who nesses. A survey conducted by cases reported a month ear- all, the hotels that remain $200 selling pineapple upside- “This is giving us an opportu-
don’t will need to quarantine the state and consulting firm lier, according to data from open to tourists are averaging down cakes to friends in Octo- nity to look at our economy
for 14 days or the full length Island Business Management Johns Hopkins University. And about 25% to 30% occupancy. ber, and is hoping to branch and reshape things.”
of their trip, whichever is in September found 41% of the rate per 100,000 residents State officials have said it out to sell more desserts. “I’m Still, some businesses are
shorter, even if a negative test businesses expected their on the islands this month has could take until 2025 for the a little worried [because optimistic that the return of
result becomes available after 2020 revenue to be less than been a fraction of the number number of visitors to return to things are] still shut down,” tourists can keep their opera-
their arrival. The stricter rule half of what it was last year. reported elsewhere in the U.S. pre-pandemic levels. she said. “I’m not sure if I can tions afloat.
could weigh on holiday travel. More than a third indicated When the pandemic hit in After losing her job as a find a job later.” Marn Zeeb reopened his ice
Hawaii suffered one of the they had significant difficulty the spring, the decline in visi- prep cook at a Honolulu sea- The downturn hurt tax rev- cream shop in Koloa, a small
most severe economic down- covering costs. tors to Hawaii quickly rippled enue, as well. The state will town on the island of Kauai, in
turns of any state from the ABC Stores, a Honolulu- across the islands. Many ho- have an estimated $1.7 billion early October and ramped up
pandemic. Hawaii’s unemploy- based retail chain serving re- tels and restaurants closed shortfall in its general fund to nearly full-time hours this
ment rate was the highest of sort areas, kept open about 20 temporarily, and tens of thou-
Hawaii has suffered revenue for the fiscal year month.
any state in October, at 14.3%, of its 65 Hawaiian locations, sands of musicians, servers, one of the most ending in June 2021, according Sales at Koloa Mill Ice
the Labor Department said. including a fulfillment center bartenders and others were to Hawaii’s Department of Cream & Coffee are less than a
Relatively strict Covid-19 for online orders, throughout unemployed. Roughly half of
severe downturns of Business, Economic Develop- third what they were during
prevention measures and the the pandemic. It gradually re- the hospitality jobs that ex- any state. ment and Tourism, and offi- the same period last year.
fact the Hawaiian Islands can’t opened other stores and has isted before the pandemic cials have raised the possibil- Still, the state’s partial re-
be reached by car meant the about 45 in operation, Chief hadn’t returned by October, ity of furloughs that would see opening is making a differ-
state didn’t see a summer up- Executive Paul Kosasa said. the U.S. Labor Department most state employees work ence, Mr. Zeeb said, and sup-
tick in tourism that some Roughly two-thirds of the said. Hotel occupancy in Octo- food restaurant, Abigail Dela two fewer days a month, with port programs including a
mainland destinations en- chain’s pre-pandemic 1,000 ber was less than 20%, versus Cruz said it took about six a pay cut of about 9%. loan earlier this year through
joyed. And many travelers re- Hawaii employees remain on 79% in the same month last months to get her unemploy- The drop in visitors re- the federal Paycheck Protec-
main worried about the risk of furlough. year, according to state data. ment benefits. They came newed longstanding calls to tion Program helped his busi-
infection while flying. Getting a store ready and One of Highgate Hotels through in September, allow- focus on fewer, higher-spend- ness survive. He said he hopes
Travel to the islands plum- calling back workers takes LP’s seven hotels in Honolulu’s ing her to cover rent and start ing tourists and diversify the Kauai doesn’t leave the pre-
meted in March, and remains about two weeks, Mr. Kosasa Waikiki tourist hub remains repaying friends. economy, including through an travel testing program.
about 70% below its year-ago said. Sales are about 70% below closed and another is being Ms. Dela Cruz, 36 years old, expansion of the tech sector “Every day seems to be a
level even after the preflight their year-ago levels. If tourism used to house military and also received a $500 restau- and the defense industry. trickle better,” Mr. Zeeb said.
testing measures were imple- drops off again, he said, he may health-care staff involved in rant gift card, which was “The level of tourists that “If the trickle continues to be
mented, according to state need to close stores. the pandemic response, said mailed by the state to out-of- were coming in daily [before positive, if the island continues
data. In recent weeks, Hawaii’s Kelly Sanders, senior vice work residents in the fall, an the pandemic] was not sus- to be safe, we can make it.”
U.S. dollar versus a trade-weighted basket Change in foreign investors’ U.S. WATCH
of currencies in the U.S. Dollar Index use of dollar hedges on their
holdings of U.S. bonds*
Lehman Brothers fails Covid crisis EMPLOYMENT ECONOMY ALASKA
120 100 Jobless Claims Rise Consumer Spending Army Corps Rejects
For a Second Week Continues to Grow Huge Mine Project
100 80 Jobless claims rose for the The U.S. economy is recover- The Army Corps of Engineers
second straight week, to 778,000, ing at a sturdy but slowing pace rejected environmental permits
a sign the nationwide surge in vi- heading into the holidays. for the massive Pebble Mine in
rus cases was starting to weigh Consumers stepped up their Alaska, a likely death blow for
60
on the labor-market recovery. spending by a brisk 0.5% in Octo- plans to excavate hundreds of bil-
80
Claims haven’t risen for two ber, down from a gain of 1.2% the lions of dollars worth of gold and
consecutive weeks since July. month before, the Commerce De- copper in a pristine wilderness.
Worker filings for unemployment partment said Wednesday. Factory Pebble Mine had drawn oppo-
insurance are down sharply from a orders for long-lasting goods rose sition from environmentalists,
60 40 peak of nearly seven million in late a solid 1.3%, in part because busi- who were joined by some conser-
2001 ’05 ’10 ’15 ’20 2015 ’16 ’17 ’18 ’19 ’20 March. But they remain higher nesses shelled out more for long- vatives who said the open pit
*Indexed ratio of dollar hedges to total holdings of U.S. bonds. Feb. 15, 2016 = 100 than in any previous recession for term projects, the agency said. mine would jeopardize one of the
Source: FactSet (dollar versus currencies); Citigroup (dollar hedges) records tracing back to 1967. Sales of newly built homes slipped world’s largest wild salmon popu-
Unemployment filings can be last month but remained near the lations in the Bristol Bay region.
CORRECTIONS AMPLIFICATIONS
tions in their existing U.S. Reserve flooded global markets that investors will shift out of
holdings. with dollars through a string of the U.S. and sink the dollar. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Other forecasts for the dol- facilities to support bonds and Francesca Fornasari, head of (USPS 664-880)
lar vary but mainly in terms of corporate credit in the U.S. and currency solutions at Insight (Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
(Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935)
how far it will fall. Goldman through currency swap lines Investment, which is part of The U.S., taking part in an an accompanying graphic. (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
Sachs analysts, for example, with foreign central banks. The Bank of New York Mellon international donors’ confer- Editorial and publication headquarters:
predict a 6% decline over the dollar’s fall continued with the Corp., said she thinks the dol- ence for Afghanistan, said it Ed Stack, the chief execu- 1211 Avenue of the Americas,
next 12 months; ING analysts reopening of economies over lar could weaken but believes has made available $600 mil- tive of Dick’s Sporting Goods New York, N.Y. 10036
forecast as much as a 10% the summer. currencies in general are set to lion for civilian aid for the Inc., enjoys target shooting. A Published daily except Sundays and
drop. The Fed’s largess last spring become more volatile. country for next year, of which Business & Finance article general legal holidays. Periodicals postage
“The dollar appears mean- pushed investors into stock While interest rates are it pledged $300 million and about the company published paid at New York, N.Y., and other mailing
offices.
ingfully overvalued and inves- markets, but mostly they stuck at very low levels in made the other half dependent on Dec. 5, 2018, incorrectly
tors are overweight U.S. as- bought growth and defensive most developed markets, it is on progress in the peace pro- said he enjoys hunting. Postmaster: Send address changes to
The Wall Street Journal, 200 Burnett Rd.,
sets,” said Christian Mueller- stocks. currencies that will be the cess, which would be reviewed Chicopee, MA 01020.
Glissmann, multiasset Big U.S.-listed technology main outlet for changing inves- during 2021. A World News ar- The #MeToo movement All Advertising published in The Wall
strategist at Goldman Sachs companies and large, invest- tor views of the relative eco- ticle on Wednesday about the gained momentum in 2017. In Street Journal is subject to the applicable
Group. High valuations for U.S. ment-grade corporate-bond is- nomic outlooks for different conference said the U.S. had some editions Monday, a Per- rate card, copies of which are available
stocks, interest rates that don’t suers, a global market also countries. pledged $600 million, with sonal Journal article about of- from the Advertising Services Department,
Dow Jones & Co. Inc., 1211 Avenue of the
keep up with inflation and a dominated by U.S. companies, “It’s not obvious that you’ll half of that dependent on fice romance incorrectly gave Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036. The
recovery of global growth benefited. have the emergence of a clear progress in the peace process. the year as 2016. Journal reserves the right not to accept
should all weigh on the dollar, Many believe that investors winner among economies,” she an advertiser’s order. Only publication of
he said. will buy riskier and underval- said. “The dollar has been very In some editions Wednes- A Business News article an advertisement shall constitute final
acceptance of the advertiser’s order.
There have been great ex- ued assets as economies keep sensitive to changes in growth day, a graphic with a Page One about Merck & Co.’s plans to
amples of the dollar surprising recovering. expectations in different coun- article about the Dow Jones acquire OncoImmune appeared Letters to the Editor:
Fax: 212-416-2891; email: wsj.ltrs@wsj.com
investors. Some see the current “Excess dollar liquidity tries.” Industrial Average incorrectly in the print edition on Tues-
situation as similar to the early [from the Fed] is still in the For Mr. Riley at BlueBay, included a stock performance day. A correction published Need assistance with your subscription?
By web: customercenter.wsj.com;
2000s when the U.S. had high system,” said Salman Ahmed, money leaving U.S. stock mar- chart for former Dow compo- Wednesday incorrectly said By email: wsjsupport@wsj.com
budget and current-account global head of macro at Fidel- kets may head to the DAX, Ger- nent Bank of America Corp. the article ran Monday. By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL
deficits and investors moved ity International. “Once things many’s industry-heavy stock- and omitted one for current (1-800-568-7625)
out of U.S. stocks and bonds improve and reflation returns, market index, and to bank component Boeing Co. Notice to readers Reprints & licensing:
into global markets. The dollar that liquidity can go back into stocks. Wall Street Journal staff By email: customreprints@dowjones.com;
By phone: 1-800-843-0008
index fell nearly 20% in 2002. riskier assets.” Both have rallied in recent ASER Centre, a New Delhi members are working remotely
In 2008, many expected the Investors are still heavily in- weeks while the dollar has think tank, was incorrectly during the pandemic. For the WSJ back issues and framed pages:
wsjshop.com
dollar to keep weakening vested in the U.S., a situation weakened. European and Japa- identified as ACER Centre in a foreseeable future, please send
against the euro, but the un- that could reverse if growth nese stocks have done better World News article Wednes- reader comments only by Our newspapers are 100% sourced from
sustainably certified mills.
folding financial crisis threw elsewhere bounces back. than the S&P 500 over the past day about remote learning in email or phone, using the con-
that sharply into reverse from Money managers have kept a month. Both are filled with India and in the credit line in tacts below, not via U.S. Mail.
July onward. Currencies are high proportion of funds in companies that benefit from an GOT A TIP FOR US?
notoriously difficult to predict U.S. assets, according to inves- expanding economy: cyclical Readers can alert The Wall Street Journal to any errors in news articles by SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS
because their behavior is the tor surveys from Bank of and value stocks. emailing wsjcontact@wsj.com or by calling 888-410-2667.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | A3
U.S. NEWS
BING GUAN/REUTERS
Small businesses have been hit with new Covid restrictions. A restaurant in Madison, Wis., has shifted to takeout-only orders.
Jardin Triple Drop Earrings
JUDITHRIPKA.COM
BY KRIS MAHER and shut businesses like movie Nationwide, states face the taxes, and that lawmakers
theaters and bowling alleys. biggest cash crisis since the would “work expeditiously” to
A growing number of gover- “Our resources are Great Depression, with total get more federal aid to small-
nors are calling for another strapped, just like every state budget shortfalls potentially business owners if Congress
round of coronavirus-relief leg- in the nation,” Ms. Whitmer, a reaching $434 billion from passed a new package.
islation from Washington, say- Democrat, said earlier this 2020 to 2022, as the economic The governors of Minnesota
ing they are unable to provide month. “And that’s why this slowdown from the pandemic and Ohio also have called for
additional funds to small busi- stimulus is so important.” cuts into state revenues. more federal relief.
nesses amid budget shortfalls. Rich Studley, president and In March, the federal gov- Michigan has distributed
The issue is gaining urgency CEO of the Michigan Chamber ernment provided relief to nearly all of the $3.1 billion in
as money from federal relief of Commerce, has criticized states through the $2.2 trillion coronavirus-relief funds it re-
passed earlier this year runs Ms. Whitmer’s shutdown or- Cares Act. But Congress hasn’t ceived. The state provided
out ahead. ders as causing unnecessary passed a new round of relief, about $150 million to help
States have funneled hun- economic damage. The latest with some members citing a small businesses, including $10
dreds of millions of dollars in round will cause many busi- growing federal deficit, which million given out as $10,000
federal aid into everything nesses to close permanently, hit a record $3.1 trillion in fis- grants to individual businesses.
from personal-protective he said. cal 2020. “We’re just looking at how
equipment and hazard pay for The Cares Act requires the do we keep all these things go-
front-line health-care workers funding be spent by the end of ing on January 1st,” said Kyle
$434B
to schools and food banks. the year, and a survey by the Jen, Michigan’s deputy budget
Businesses, which generally National Governors Associa- director.
got a smaller slice of the aid tion found last month that To balance Michigan’s bud-
than programs directly tied to states had allocated nearly get for the year that ended
the public-health emergency, Potential total state budget 90% of the money. Sept. 30, the state withdrew
are in a particularly precarious shortfalls from 2020 to 2022. In Pennsylvania, lawmakers $350 million from its rainy-day
spot. In addition, federal loans and Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf fund to make up for lost reve-
to businesses during the shut- used the state’s remaining $1.3 nue, among other moves.
down earlier this year—known billion in coronavirus-relief Jean Stelten-Beuning, who
as the Paycheck Protection Yet he favors a new round money this month to fund sal- owns Top Dog Country Club, in
Program—have since run out. of federal relief targeted to aries for state health and pub- New Germany, Minn., which
The crunch is tough in the help businesses and unem- lic-safety employees so they charges $69 to $89 a night to
Midwest, where some of the ployed workers. A priority, he could balance the state’s bud- board dogs, said half her reser-
nation’s strongest coronavirus said, should be funding state get through the end of June, a vations over Thanksgiving
restrictions have been imple- unemployment insurance trust move that angered some small- were canceled when people GMT EARTH
mented amid increases in funds that have been depleted. business groups. backed out of travel plans.
Covid-19 cases, hitting busi- That would help laid-off work- “Instead of throwing the in- Ms. Stelten-Beuning, who In platinum
nesses just ahead of the holi- ers and also prevent states dustry a lifeline, they’re described herself as a fiscal
day season. from raising payroll taxes on throwing an anchor,” said John conservative, said a Paycheck
Michigan Gov. Gretchen businesses, which could deter Longstreet, president and CEO Protection Program loan of CELLINI - NEW YORK
Whitmer said the state had them from rehiring people. of the Pennsylvania Restaurant $174,000 helped keep her busi- www.cellinijewelers.com
used up all of its federal stimu- “Simply dropping money & Lodging Association. ness afloat this spring. “I
lus funding from the spring out of airplanes and hoping Pennsylvania Rep. Stan Say- would never want a handout,”
STEPHEN SILVER - SAN FRANCISCO
www.stephensilverfinejewelry.com
and now faces a $1 billion politicians will spend it wisely lor, a Republican, said the bud- she said. “If small businesses
shortfall. She recently banned is not a very good strategy,” he get kept core government func- are to survive there needs to SYDEL & SYDEL - CHICAGO, IL
www.sydelandsydel.com
indoor dining for three weeks said. tions operating without raising be a second round.”
FOR INFORMATION ∙ TIME ART DISTRIBUTION LLC
Phone +1 212 221-8041 ∙ info@timeartdistribution.com
U.S. NEWS
WASHINGTON—During his
As Senate Firewall
campaign, President-elect Joe BY SIOBHAN HUGHES
Biden highlighted his intention AND LINDSAY WISE President Ties Exit
to work closely with America’s
allies to ease trade tensions WASHINGTON—With Presi- To Electoral College
and pressure China to abide by dent Trump’s drive to remain
international rules. in office hitting a dead end,
He will have several early Senate Republicans are redou- WASHINGTON—President
chances to do that after being bling their efforts in Georgia, Trump said he would leave
sworn in Jan. 20. where a pair of runoffs will the White House if the Elec-
The new president will have determine which party con- toral College elects Joe Biden
an opportunity to try to re- trols the Senate. but was noncommittal about
solve a leadership dispute at Senate Majority Leader attending the inauguration
the World Trade Organization Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.) and ceremony.
pitting the U.S. against most Sen. Todd Young (R., Ind.), the He said the Electoral Col-
MARK MAKELA/GETTY IMAGES
other members. He also could outgoing chairman of the Na- lege would be making a mis-
remove Trump administration tional Republican Senatorial take to elect Mr. Biden but
tariffs on imported steel and Committee, have told col- indicated he would depart
aluminum that have riled trad- leagues that each of them without further challenge.
ing partners. needs to help Sens. David Per- “Certainly I will, and you
Moreover, he could com- due and Kelly Loeffler keep know that,” he told reporters
mand the world economic their seats in the Jan. 5 races, Thursday evening after deliv-
stage by calling an emergency GOP aides said. Senators are ering a Thanksgiving message
meeting of the Group of 20 President-elect Joe Biden says he intends to ease trade tensions. traveling to the state to rally to troops.
nations early next year, as voters and tapping their own Asked about attending Mr.
some former economic offi- candidate. The Biden transition Import volumes of steel simply repeal [the tariffs]. donor lists to raise money for Biden’s inauguration, he said,
cials have suggested, a poten- team didn’t respond to ques- products from major trading That’s absolutely within his the Republican incumbents in “I know the answer, but I just
tial setting for an unofficial tions on the WTO leadership partners fell in 2019 after the authority,” said Michael Smart, the races, where spending is don’t want to say it yet.”
summit with Chinese Presi- and other trade-related issues. U.S. imposed tariffs in 2018. managing director at Rock already set to hit $300 million. “It’s going to be a very
dent Xi Jinping. Brian Pomper, executive di- Creek Global Advisors and a “Failure is not an option” hard thing to concede,” the
Imports of steel products,
Mr. Biden this week showed rector of Alliance for Trade former Democratic congressio- has emerged as the party president said.
in millions of metric tons
his intent to reverse President Enforcement, a group of trade nal and White House aide. mantra, according to a person The Associated Press has
Trump’s pivot away from some associations that advocates for 5.6 Meantime, the new adminis- familiar with GOP conference declared Mr. Biden the winner
international agreements by foreign governments to end tration must decide what to do calls on messaging and fund- of the election, with 306 elec-
5.0 5.0 Canada*
appointing former Secretary unfair trade practices, believes with trade promotion author- raising. toral votes to 232 for Mr.
of State John Kerry as a spe- that Mr. Biden is likely to go ity: special legislation that al- Mr. Trump said Thursday he Trump.
4.1 EU
cial envoy for climate change, with the consensus choice. 4.0
3.8 Brazil*
lows trade officials to submit would travel to Georgia, likely —Alex Leary
a new position that will be fo- “It would make sense as a 3.5 any trade agreements to Con- on Dec. 5, to campaign for Mr.
3.3 Mexico*
cused on global policy. way to show that he is more gress for expedited approval. Perdue and Ms. Loeffler.
One of the first steps Mr. multilateral, and willing to take 2.5 The current authority is set The formal start of the is running against Mr. Perdue,
Biden can take is to end the account of these multilateral 2.3 2.3 Korea* to expire July 1, and the re- presidential transition helps said in a recent interview that
deadlock over the selection of institutions,” Mr. Pomper said. newal process will be conten- Republicans make their case the nationalization of the race
the WTO’s new leader. He and others say Mr. Biden 1.4 1.1 Japan tious because of partisan dif- that denying Democrats a Sen- could help him and fellow
The Trump administration should also start taking steps 1.0 1.0 Russia ferences over worker and ate majority will serve as a Democrat the Rev. Raphael
has opposed the candidate to allow the WTO to resume 0.6 0.8 Taiwan environmental protection in check on President-elect Joe Warnock, who is trying to oust
backed by most member coun- its role as the arbitrator of 0.5 China future trade agreements, par- Biden’s agenda. Republicans Ms. Loeffler. The two are cam-
tries, Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, a trade disputes. Mr. Trump has ticularly if the Republicans will hold at least 50 seats next paigning in large part on being
former Nigerian finance minis- said the WTO is unfair, and his 2018 2019 maintain Senate control. year compared with 48 for central to Mr. Biden’s ability
ter and former World Bank ex- administration has blocked the *Countries that received exemptions TPA’s expiration will also in- Democrats, and need to win at to mount a robust Covid-19 re-
ecutive. The administration appointment of new judges to from U.S. tariffs. fluence the Biden administra- least one of the two Georgia sponse, he said.
maintains that Ms. Okonjo- the group’s appellate body, ef- Source: Census Bureau tion’s stance on the continuing runoffs to prevent Vice Presi- So far, Democratic candi-
Iweala doesn’t have enough ex- fectively disabling its dispute- negotiations for a bilateral dent-elect Kamala Harris from dates Warnock and Ossoff are
perience in world trade, and is settlement function. companies, however, and hurt trade agreement with the U.K. being able to cast tiebreaking outspending Republican candi-
instead backing South Korean On tariffs, among the most U.S. manufacturers that either started by the Trump adminis- votes in a 50-50 Senate. dates Loeffler and Perdue. But
Trade Minister Yoo Myung- significant of those imposed by faced retaliatory tariffs or tration based on the authority. “We are the last line of de- Republican super PACs Ameri-
hee. Either candidate would be Mr. Trump are on imported higher costs for imported The negotiations are believed fense,” Mr. Perdue said Tues- can Crossroads and Senate
the first woman to lead the or- steel and aluminum. The levies steel. Washington has ex- to be in their late stages. day on Fox News. “These two Leadership Fund are outspend-
ganization, and Ms. Okonjo- of 25% on steel and 10% on empted several friendly coun- Several former officials seats here will determine the ing Democratic Party commit-
Iweala would be the first WTO aluminum were imposed on tries such as Australia, Mexico from Democratic administra- majority in the Senate. We are tees and other left-leaning out-
leader from an African nation. national security grounds, with and South Korea from the tar- tions have called on Mr. Biden going to…protect everything side groups, the data show. The
Traditionally, the choice of Mr. Trump saying they were iffs, but kept others on the to push for an emergency sum- that President Trump has ac- two super PACs, run by allies of
WTO leader has been by unani- needed to protect an industry list, including the European mit meeting of G-20 nations complished in the last four Mr. McConnell, have committed
mous vote, so a Biden adminis- vital to national defense. Union and Japan. early next year to set a global years, and make sure that the at least $90 million in televi-
tration could end the deadlock The tariffs have provided “The strongest signal Presi- agenda for recovery from the people of Georgia know that.” sion and radio ads for the
by agreeing to the Nigerian mixed benefits for U.S. steel dent-elect Biden can send is to coronavirus pandemic. Democrat Jon Ossoff, who Georgia runoffs through Jan. 5.
Transforming
patients’ lives
through science
In a year of unprecedented global
challenge, our shared vision drives
our company forward. We’ve advanced
our pipeline, developed new medicines,
and ensured uninterrupted supply
to patients around the world.
U.S. NEWS
ANDREW KELLY/REUTERS
states seeking to overturn simi- of worship in areas most se- with the Supreme Court to tained only to a specific Brook-
lar rules on houses of worship. verely affected by the corona- block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s lyn “red zone” that was no
Up to 20 cases involving virus: limiting capacity by 25% coronavirus restrictions while longer under such restrictions.
or 10 people in red zones and the case is being appealed. “It’s irrelevant from any
By Stephanie 33% or 25 in orange zones. Wednesday night’s ruling practical impact because the
Yang, Josh Mitchell Some groups condemned by the Supreme Court was a zone that they were talking
and Alicia A. Caldwell the decision. “The freedom to Gov. Andrew Cuomo called the ruling irrelevant for New York, but hopeful sign, said Mat Staver, about has already been moot,”
worship is one of our most others said it would help religious groups suing in other states. founder and chairman of the Mr. Cuomo said. “I think this
houses of worship in states in- cherished fundamental rights, Liberty Counsel and the lead was really just an opportunity
cluding Nevada, New Jersey, but it does not include a li- governors to rethink how they Churches have been hubs of attorney in the case. for the court to express its
California and Oregon could be cense to harm others or en- impose Covid-19 restrictions the coronavirus’s spread world- “I think it’s very important philosophy and politics.”
affected by the Supreme Court danger public health,” said so they are not making differ- wide. In the U.S., religious that we get these rulings However, Eugene Volokh, a
decision, legal experts say. Daniel Mach, director of the ent rules for different groups. gatherings have turned into su- now,” said Mr. Staver, who professor at University of Cali-
“It will undoubtedly have a American Civil Liberties “The virus doesn’t care if it’s perspreader events in states said his litigation includes fornia, Los Angeles School of
major effect and probably Union’s Program on Freedom infecting people at a Little across the country, including roughly 170 California Law, said the Supreme Court’s
have a decisive effect,” said of Religion and Belief. League game or in a church,” he Washington, California and Ken- churches. “Two weeks has now decision was significant be-
Christopher Ferrara, special Perry Dane, a Rutgers Uni- said. “So it should be possible tucky. moved into nearly eight cause of its implications for
counsel to the Thomas More versity law professor, said the to come up with criteria that The Diocese of Brooklyn, one months, and there doesn’t other cases and the fast-chang-
Society, a law firm that repre- court ruling will likely force are more technically neutral.” of the plaintiffs in the suit, lost seem to be an end in sight in ing nature of the pandemic.
ADVERTISEMENT
Member Voices
The Wall Street Journal CMO Network connects leaders of the world’s most influential brands to examine
what — and who — is driving trends and provide the facts they need to chart the path forward.
What is the biggest change in Secondly, our purpose is to make an long week. I wanted to go home, but I
consumer behavior you’ve impact that matters, for our clients thought we needed to say yes. After
witnessed in the past ive years? and our communities, and we’re seeing all, it happened to be our CEO and
an opportunity to do that when it COO asking. But Cathy astonished me
Primarily, I’ve noticed two things: comes to helping organizations come by responding that she could not go
the consumer’s ability to, and their back stronger and more resilient. We because it would break a commitment
insistence on, shaping a brand’s launched our Women’s Initiative in she made to her son — which was to take
behavior through their wants and 1999, and our irst IMPACT Day (our him to his favorite place in the world,
needs. Alongside this notion, as a B2B commitment to giving back to our Chuck E. Cheese. I was so impressed by
CMO, I see consumers unwilling to be communities through service) was how she recognized her family’s needs
boxed into personas that organizations 20 years ago, but we are now more and then quickly pivoted to developing a
have put them into in the past. In short, committed than ever before. plan that would still allow us to meet the
consumers are more vocal and brands client’s needs. The moral of that story is
Suzanne Kounkel are listening more closely than ever Third, I believe that life is lived in the simple: Speak up for yourself, and when
CMO, Deloitte before. Even more, trust plays a key small moments of each day. One day, Kim you’re centered on shared outcomes,
role here. For organizations navigating McNeil-Downs, who runs our internal there are many ways to get to a solution.
challenges, building and understanding agency in the U.S., was explaining what
trust lays the groundwork for aligning the team had accomplished when her When it’s time to get creative,
to the values that drive human emotion voice broke and tears came into her eyes what do you do to get inspired?
and ultimately human behavior. on screen. She said something along the
lines of, “I am so proud of what we have Nothing clears the mind like fresh air and
What are you most proud of in accomplished, how committed the team a brisk walk. Then, to get inspired, I listen
your current role? is, how we have treated each other along to a variety of different voices through
the way, and how we inspire each other music and podcasts. I center on how I
First, I’d recognize the Deloitte team for when we need it most.” The humanity of want the outcome to feel and I start to
the way we were able to pivot when the these times will always be something I outline what I am creating.
pandemic began. When COVID19 hit, we am in awe of.
needed to do some ridiculously dificult Imagine you’re not a CMO and you
things quickly in order to respond — like What’s the biggest learning have the talent to do anything —
transition 175,000 employees to virtual experience you’ve had? what would you do?
work in less than 48 hours. Of the over
670 events on the books, we had to Earlier in my career, I was in New York If I had the talent required to be great, I
Membership is by invitation: cancel 453 and immediately convert 225 with a mentor of mine, Cathy Benko, would absolutely be a professional tennis
CMONetwork@wsj.com to virtual. In a time of great change and who was at the time a young principal, player. If not that, I would love to be a
uncertainty, our immediate focus was on for a weeklong client meeting. At the writer or host a talk show along the lines
Read the extended version: people — our employees and our clients’ end of it, we were asked to ly directly of David Letterman’s “My Next Guest
CMONetwork.wsj.com/ employees — and making sure they to Georgia for another meeting. I was Needs No Introduction.” I am fascinated
membervoicesdeloitte were safe. not eager to say yes — it had been a by people’s stories and unlocking them.
The Wall Street Journal news organization was not involved in the creation of this content.
© 2020 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ7931
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Friday, November 27, 2020 | A7
U.S. NEWS
lives. Manufacturers say their Some officials and medical MSA Safety Inc., recently won codeveloping with the Univer-
new masks follow recommen- experts are encouraging people regulatory approval for a mask sity of Oxford was on average
dations from public-health au- to wear masks that offer more without an exhalation valve. about 90% effective in pre-
thorities and typically include protection than simple cloth. The company said elastomer- venting Covid-19 when volun-
a combination of reusable lay- Canadian public health offi- ics can save hospitals space teers were given a half-dose
ers and a replaceable filter. cials this month said people and money on their stockpiles shot followed by a full dose a
Despite big increases in do- should wear masks in public because they are reusable. month or more later, but only
mestic production, N95s have that contain three layers: two Some hospitals say using elas- 62% effective when two full
been in short supply since the fabric plus a filter layer. The tomerics instead of disposable doses were given. The data
pandemic began. The surge in U.S. Centers for Disease Con- N95s can be complicated be- pooled trial results from the
cases is putting fresh strain on trol and Prevention updated cause of the cleaning protocols U.K. and Brazil.
U.S. stockpiles of a critical its guidance on Nov. 10 to say necessary to reuse them. U.S. regulators have set the
piece of equipment for doctors masks offer some protection ThermoPore Materials bar for authorizing vaccines at
and nurses treating patients to the wearer in addition to Corp. secured government ap- 50% effectiveness, but vac-
with Covid-19. people nearby. it is to breathe through. The People have been buying proval in September to make a cines in development by Mod-
The new masks aimed at Emiel DenHartog, a professor CDC has said that a mask with the masks to protect against new type of N95 that uses a dif- erna Inc., and partners Pfizer
everyday consumers aren’t who studies respiratory protec- multiple layers of higher- the coronavirus, so Sleepnet ferent filtration material than Inc. and Germany’s BioNTech
subjected to the same federal tion at North Carolina State thread cloth offers more pro- this month started selling a the standard polypropylene, SE have set the benchmark
certification process as N95s University, welcomed the work tection than a mask with one plug for the valve that pre- which has been in short supply. even higher with study results
intended for medical workers. to make new kinds of masks for layer of lower-thread cloth. vents droplets that could con- President Ken Milam said showing greater than 90% ef-
Getting certified to produce the public. He cautioned, Hampton, N.H.-based Sleep- tain the virus from being ex- the material ThermoPore is fectiveness.
N95s is a long and rigorous though, that there isn’t a con- net Corp., which makes masks haled out of the mask. using, sintered polyethylene, Those vaccines use a new
process, manufacturers said. sensus on how manufacturers for people with sleep apnea, “In a pandemic, what are looks under a microscope like gene-based technology that,
The National Institute for Oc- should test these products. also sells a reusable N95-style you worried about? Effective- BB pellets stuck together, despite its impressive clinical
cupational Safety and Health “It’s hard for people to mask that was designed only ness and availability,” said Rob- compared with the tangled results so far, requires the
has approved about 20 addi- judge what is reliable,” he said. to protect the wearer during ert Skaff, business unit man- spaghetti of polypropylene. shots to be stored at subzero
tional makers of N95s and Respiratory-protection ex- work on dusty construction ager for Sleepnet’s N95 mask. The company is trying to scale temperatures. AstraZeneca’s
similar products this year, ac- perts say how much protection sites or home-improvement The New York City Fire De- up production of masks made vaccine can be stored in a
cording to the agency, increas- a mask provides—to both the projects. It includes a valve partment recently said it with the material at its factory more standard refrigerator,
ing the number of certified wearer and people nearby— through which people exhale would buy a type of reusable in Newnan, Ga. “I wish we which could make it attractive
companies around the world depends on how well it filters, unfiltered air, which could in- mask made by 3M Co. so as could bring it to more people to low- and middle-income na-
by about one-third. how well it fits and how easy clude virus particles. not to use up medical-grade faster,” Mr. Milam said. tions.
Seeks Boost 40
$300 million
200
From Slack 20
100
0
Continued from Page One
business-focused social-media 0 –100
network. The loss stung.
Salesforce responded by urg- –200
ing regulators to examine Mi- –20
crosoft’s proposed purchase on –300
antitrust grounds; the deal Slack Technologies
passed regulatory scrutiny. –40 –400
Landing Slack, which Micro- June July Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. FY2019 ’20 ’21
soft also once tried to acquire, Note: Slack’s 2Q fiscal year 2021 ended July 31
could amount to a bit of re- Sources: FactSet (shares); S&P Capital IQ (results) 40 carats of sapphires
venge for Mr. Benioff.
San Francisco-based Slack pany a valuable currency to use than 130,000 paying customers. in a parade of royal style
makes instant-messaging soft- for takeovers. Shares of Slack Salesforce is pursuing Slack
ware that it pitches as a solu- rose 38% to $40.70 each on as competition in its core busi-
tion to what it says is cluttered Wednesday, while Salesforce re- ness of customer relationship- Drape yourself in our undeniably
and intrusive office email. It treated 5.4% to $246.82. management soft ware is inten- elegant necklace. The regal style
launched in 2009 as a gaming Mr. Benioff has long been sifying. Adobe Inc. this month
company called Tiny Speck, but among the highest-profile and said it would buy Workfront, a showcases a glorious procession
pivoted to the messaging app it most outspoken executives in platform for marketers, for $1.5
had developed for internal use. tech, using venues like the billion. Microsoft also has been of 40.00 ct. t.w. oval sapphires,
Microsoft in 2016 launched World Economic Forum in Da- pushing its rival product, called
its own workplace collaboration vos, Switzerland, to champion Dynamics. Salesforce still has
set in shining sterling silver.
tool, Teams, spurring a some- causes and burnish his profile. the largest share with 20.1% of A truly head-turning design,
times heated battle between the He set up Salesforce with a the world-wide market in 2019
two companies. “They want to pledge of corporate giving and compared with 2.6% for Micro- our blue beauty will be the
kill us,” Slack CEO Stewart But- bought himself an even larger soft Dynamics, according to re-
terfield told the Journal this platform with his acquisition of search firm Gartner Inc. crown jewel of your collection!
year. This summer, Slack filed a Time Magazine two years ago. Slack’s Mr. Butterfield has
complaint with the European The San Francisco-based been trying to turn Slack into
Union over alleged antitrust be- more than a communications
havior by Microsoft in using its tool for business. Slack has
dominance to push Teams. partnered with other software
Slack “extends the footprint
Landing Slack could vendors to transform itself into
of what Salesforce goes after,” amount to a bit of a platform through which com-
Jefferies analyst Brent Thill panies can access a variety of
said. “Not everyone uses a sales
revenge for services they need to run their
system, but everyone can use Salesforce’s CEO. operations, offering interfaces
collaboration. ” for other business-tool provid-
Mr. Benioff has a history of ers such as Workday Inc., cloud-
deal making since he co- storage vendor Dropbox Inc.
founded Salesforce 21 years ago company also has made a big and Salesforce.
and turned it into one of the push into the emerging field of Even with Slack, Salesforce
most successful companies in artificial intelligence, develop- would remain comparatively
the then still nascent market of ing tools to help customers small next to Microsoft. The Also available
providing software as a service. make better use of their data. Redmond, Wash., company had
Salesforce completed its big-
gest-ever purchase last year,
paying around $15 billion in
Breaking into the market of
workplace collaboration has
long been on Salesforce’s
sales of $143 billion in its latest
financial year, generated by
business enterprise software,
$
895
Plus Free Shipping
in Ruby
stock for data-analytics plat- agenda. In 2010, it launched its cloud-computing infrastruc-
form Tableau Software Inc. Chatter, a private social net- ture, and consumer-facing busi- 40.00 ct. t.w. Sapphire Tennis Necklace in Sterling Silver
A year earlier, it splashed work for companies to collabo- nesses, such as videogaming. Its
out more than $5 billion for rate. And in 2016, it bought sales are roughly nine times 18" length. Double-latch safety. Box clasp.
cloud-application provider cloud-document collaboration Salesforce’s annual revenue. Mi- 44.50 ct. t.w. Sapphire Tennis Necklace 20" $995
MuleSoft. Inc. This year Sales- app company Quip Inc. for more crosoft’s market valuation tops
force said it was buying cloud- than $500 million. Neither $1.6 trillion, about six times Also available in Ruby. Item #937050
software provider Vlocity Inc. product attracted a wide follow- that of Slack and Salesforce
Salesforce has a market ing. Acquiring Slack, which combined.
value of some $230 billion after Salesforce had previously ex- Last year, Salesforce said it Ross-Simons Item #937051
years of big gains and its rich plored buying, would immedi- was seeking to reach $28 billion To receive this special offer, use offer code: ROYALTY1
stock price—which trades at ately make the company a big in annual sales in the 2023 fi-
1.800.556.7376 or visit ross-simons.com/royalty
nearly 100 times its trailing- player in the workplace-collabo- nancial year. It had $16 billion
year profits—gives the com- ration market. Slack has more in sales in its most recent year.
A8 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
Ethiopian Military Moves on Rebel Capital
Government encircles
Mekelle after three
weeks of fighting with
northern region
BY NICHOLAS BARIYO
international pressure to re- her body shaking and voice U.S. relationship with Saudi Marco Rubio on Monday called
lease her. faint, according to her family. Arabia and protect the right of for the women to be released
Ms. Hathloul was picked up The 31-year-old, who was activists around the world to “on the merits of their case,
more than three years ago just nominated this year for the speak freely, after President but today…on health and hu-
as the conservative kingdom Nobel Peace Prize, earlier this Trump stood by Prince Mo- manitarian grounds.”
allowed women to drive, month ended a two-week hun- hammed in the face of accusa- Saudi Arabia has so resisted
something she and other de- ger strike to protest her tions that he ordered the 2018 Western calls to release Ms.
tained activists had long prison conditions. Loujain al-Hathloul had lobbied for women to be allowed to drive. killing of dissident Saudi jour- Hathloul, which crescendoed
pushed for. She was charged A spokesman for the Saudi nalist Jamal Khashoggi. last week ahead of the Group
with aiding an enemy country public prosecutor didn’t an- Court was established in 2008 Salman, the kingdom’s day-to- Saudi Arabia has congratu- of 20 summit hosted by Saudi
but also speaking with foreign swer calls or messages, and to try terrorism suspects but day ruler who has accused her lated Mr. Biden on his election Arabia. Minister of State for
journalists and diplomats, con- the media ministry didn’t im- has since been used to prose- and others arrested around victory, which Mr. Trump is Foreign Affairs Adel al-Jubeir
tacting Saudi dissidents living mediately respond to ques- cute human-rights activists the same time of spying for trying to overturn, but re- told CNN the matter was up to
abroad, and applying for a job tions about the trial. Western and perceived dissidents. regional rivals Iran and Qatar. mains concerned about the the courts and denied that the
at the United Nations. journalists have been denied Ms. Hathloul’s supporters “How is it possible for the president-elect’s plans to re- activists were arrested for ad-
On Wednesday, the Riyadh permission to enter the court- fear the change of venue rep- judge to realize the court lacks turn to the Obama-era nuclear vocating the right to drive cars.
Criminal Court ruled that it room. resents a doubling down by jurisdiction after dealing with deal with Iran. Mr. Biden has —Summer Said in Dubai
lacked jurisdiction and sent The Specialized Criminal Crown Prince Mohammed bin the case for 1 year and 8 begun assembling a team of contributed to this article.
Breakthrough
Heat &
Russia lators over risk controls in its
U.S. operations. It received a
fresh rebuke from the Fed this
such as London, Zurich and
Frankfurt. It has more than
1,000 employees in the country.
In 2017, Deutsche Bank paid
$629 million to end investiga-
tions by New York’s DFS and
Massage Chair -
year over similar matters. The monitors told the bank U.K. regulators into the mirror
Available Now! Continued from Page One The bank has also faced it should withdraw from the trades. By trading stocks in
Lee Wolosky and Dawn Smalls questioning from Democrats in business completely, including two locations at once,
from the law firm Jenner & Congress about Deutsche services to Russians outside of Deutsche Bank helped rich
Block LLP. A Jenner & Block Bank’s role as a leading lender the country, the person familiar Russians take billions of dol-
spokesperson didn’t respond to President Trump. with the communications said. lars out of the country unmon-
to requests for comment. Deutsche Bank has said it has Not doing so, they said, posed itored. The bank reported to
The monitors can’t directly committed significant resources the regulators about the
order changes at Deutsche to improving its money-laun- trades, made between 2011 and
70
Bank. They make recommenda- dering controls and has fully co- 2015, which violated U.S. anti-
tions that are shared with the operated in investigations. money-laundering laws. A sep-
New York regulator, which can Mr. Sewing is under pressure arate investigation by the Jus-
threaten fines and remediation. to make the troubled lender tice Department into the same
The monitors have been in profitable despite negative in- Millions of dollars of Deutsche issue was continuing, accord-
place since Deutsche Bank set- terest rates in Europe and a Bank’s annual revenue in Russia ing to Deutsche Bank’s annual
tled a case in 2017 related to brutal pandemic that has hurt report published in March.
“mirror trades,” in which the the financial position of bor- As part of the settlement,
bank moved $10 billion of Rus- rowers. He launched a sweep- DFS appointed the team of
sian client money out of the ing overhaul of the bank in a threat to the bank and raised two independent monitors to
country. They told Deutsche 2019, with plans to reduce head questions as to whether it had check on the bank’s efforts to
Bank that a 2018 deal to sell a count by nearly a fifth and to learned from its past mistakes. improve its controls, reporting
property in Silicon Valley to a pull back its presence as a com- Deutsche Bank executives directly to the regulator.
Russian businessman, despite petitor to Wall Street giants have discussed expanding the The monitors were surprised
the objection of the bank’s U.S. such as Goldman Sachs Group Russian business for several by Deutsche Bank’s wish to
reputational-risk committee, Inc. and JPMorgan Chase & Co. years. The monitors learned widen its Russia business given
Save up to $400 played a role in forming their
views. The Wall Street Journal
He has also looked to mar-
kets where Deutsche Bank can
about the plans in May, the
person familiar with the com-
how little it helps the bottom
line. Last year, operations in
reported about the deal last grow. A renewed push into munications said. Russia generated less than $70
year, citing documents and Russia would be part of a Deutsche Bank would be million in revenue—a tiny frac-
during our Black Friday and people familiar with the matter. broader plan by the bank to ex- betting on a business that has tion of the $27 billion the
The call by the monitors to pand in emerging markets, long been a reputational and whole bank made, according to
Cyber Monday Sale! quit Russia creates a high- people familiar with the moves financial headache. A Russia the bank’s annual report. The
stakes dilemma for the bank said. Most global investment working group inside the bank figure, however, doesn’t include
N O V 2 6 t h
- 3 0 t h
and Chief Executive Officer banks reduced their presence was meant to meet this month all business with Russian cli-
Christian Sewing. He has in Russia after the U.S. imposed to consider a limited expan- ents done outside the country.
promised to restore Deutsche sanctions for Moscow’s 2014 sion plan, which will be pre- —Jimmy Vielkind
Bank’s tarnished reputation invasion of Eastern Ukraine sented to the management contributed to this article.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | A9
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT: KRISTIN SIEGLE; COSETTE RINAB; MATT FITZGERALD
with a preliminary deal still sault, the people said, betting lawyer TikTok pointed them to,
under negotiation that involves that key officials would likely said she felt they had a strong
Oracle Corp. and Walmart Inc. become increasingly distracted case because she believed the
taking stakes in TikTok. as the election approached. Trump administration had
ByteDance and its potential The TikTok review by the overreached its authority. She
U.S. partners are optimistic administration began with the was also aware they might find
about completing a deal in the U.S. Committee on Foreign In- it intimidating to take on the
coming weeks, according to vestment, which evaluates U.S. government.
people familiar with their dis- deals for national security “It’s unprecedented for the
cussions and internal thinking. risks. That committee has or- government to shut down an
On Wednesday, the Trump ad- dered ByteDance to divest its entire forum for free speech,
ministration granted Byte- U.S. operations of TikTok, out no matter what the reason,”
Dance a one-week extension to of concern that user data could said Ms. Doran, who focuses on
complete a deal, putting the be shared with the Chinese free-speech issues and technol-
new deadline at Dec. 4. government given regulations ogy. She declined to discuss
In August, President Trump there that require companies how the litigation came to-
signed an order calling for Tik- to hand over huge swaths of gether or was financed.
Tok to be shut down or, alter- information. ByteDance has
natively, sold to a U.S. com- said it would never share data
pany. The administration said with the Chinese government, Stick with TikTok?
it feared ByteDance could though analysts and experts TikTok stars turned plaintiffs, from top left: comedian Doug Marland; University of Southern She filed the lawsuit on
share information about U.S. say companies have little California student Cosette Rinab; and musician Alec Chambers. The three sued the federal their behalf on Sept. 18, two
users with the Chinese govern- choice but to comply if asked. government over its proposed ban of the app in the U.S., an effort that proved key. days before the Commerce De-
ment, which the company said ByteDance’s legal efforts partment was initially set to
it would never do. were designed to chip away at Oracle as its partner to secure ByteDance kept its lawsuits data, according to people fa- ban TikTok downloads. A judge
the more punitive efforts by its data in the U.S., with the against the U.S. government miliar with the matter. in the parallel lawsuit on Tik-
the Trump administration, software giant and Walmart active in part to ensure that A deal must ultimately get Tok’s behalf blocked that ban
Two rulings even while it pursued a deal Inc. taking ownership stakes in the app didn’t face a shutdown signoff from the U.S. Commit- hours before it was to go into
The first ruling in TikTok’s that would satisfy the Cfius or- a new company that would run as the negotiations took place. tee on Foreign Investment and effect.
favor came with its own law- der, which also has bipartisan TikTok’s U.S. operations. Mr. Trump would still prefer Mr. Trump, as well as the Chi- While they waited for their
suit, which argued that an ini- support in Washington. Any A key sticking point that to get rid of TikTok in the U.S. nese government. own court hearing, the month
tial Commerce Department ban deal will ultimately require si- still needs to be ironed out is altogether, though his attention of October was stressful, the
on downloading or updating gnoff from the U.S. president. the size of the ownership has shifted to other matters, plaintiffs said. Some days Mr.
the app would harm the com- Although President-elect Bi- stakes for ByteDance and its the senior administration offi- ‘Regular kids’ Marland refreshed the news
pany’s business. On Sept. 27, den has not made clear his po- new U.S. investors, according cial said. The official said that The lawsuit was designed in and Twitter all day, hoping to
Judge Carl Nichols in the U.S. sition on TikTok, the commit- to people familiar with the dis- even though Mr. Trump gave part to put a human face on hear a deal would save TikTok.
District Court in Washington, tee’s divestiture order would cussions and internal thinking. his preliminary approval to a TikTok. Mr. Chambers, the mu- Ms. Rinab, who posts about
D.C., determined that the gov- still likely stand under new ad- The negotiations have al- deal, he has never been fully sician, joined the app in late fashion and lifestyle and said
ernment likely overstepped its ministration. ready helped Walmart forge sold on the idea because he 2018, and a cover version of she earns between $5,000 to
authority under national-secu- For now, an outright ban of closer ties to TikTok, some- doesn’t want a transaction that Halsey’s “Without Me” re- $10,000 per video from en-
rity law. The government ap- TikTok appears off the table: thing that has motivated the could be perceived as benefit- corded in the basement studio dorsements, heard fellow stars
pealed the decision, and the On Nov. 12, the Commerce De- retailer from the beginning, ac- ing China. at his parents’ house earned discussing whether to transfer
case is still ongoing. partment said it wouldn’t en- cording to people familiar with Inside the Trump adminis- him thousands of early follow- to other platforms such as You-
On Oct. 30, Judge Wendy force the order that would the situation. Walmart is work- tration, Treasury Secretary ers. Tube.
Beetlestone, in federal court have effectively forced TikTok ing toward partnering with Steven Mnuchin, Attorney Gen- Now more than two million On Oct. 28, Ms. Rinab set
for the Eastern District of to shut down, citing the ruling TikTok on providing warehouse eral William Barr and White users follow his videos, many her laptop up in the kitchen,
Pennsylvania, ruled on the in- in the stars’ lawsuit, and the and shipment support for sales House economic adviser Larry of which feature his own origi- grabbed a coffee and sat down
fluencer lawsuit. She blocked administration’s legal options made through the app, and Kudlow have all said in meet- nal music or his covers of radio to testify via videoconference.
Commerce Department restric- are dwindling. Walmart CEO Doug McMillon ings at times that they believe hits. The 25-year-old from Con- She and Mr. Marland an-
tions that would have barred While TikTok was aggres- now has relationships with Tik- a deal could work, while White necticut has earned endorse- swered a series of questions
U.S. companies from listing sively pushing back on the pro- Tok’s executive leadership, House adviser and China hawk ment deals to promote Extra from lawyers on both sides,
TikTok in their app stores—a posed bans in the courts, it some of the people said. Peter Navarro has advised Mr. gum and Cinnamon Toast mostly about how TikTok
move that would effectively also pledged to work coopera- Executives at Oracle, who Trump to avoid a deal, accord- Crunch cereal. works.
make it inoperable in the U.S. tively with national-security see TikTok as a major cus- ing to the senior administra- “TikTok has allowed regular Two days later, Judge
“Without access to the Tik- regulators on the potential deal tomer for its cloud business, tion official. kids like me, who don’t have Beetlestone sided with the
Tok app, Plaintiffs would lose that would address the govern- expect the deal to be com- TikTok believes it will still access to a lot of money or plaintiffs.
access to all of these followers, ment’s data-security concerns. pleted before the end of the likely need to divest its Ameri- connections to people who are —Alex Leary, Sarah Nassauer
as well as to the professional In mid-September, the com- year, a person close to the can operations or face ques- high up in the industry, to and Aaron Tilley contributed
opportunities afforded by Tik- pany announced it had chosen company said. tions about its handling of U.S. make a stamp in the music to this article.
ARTS IN REVIEW
than have it played wrong,” he says,
the conflict always being the lim-
ited rehearsal time available versus
the difficulty of his scores. In a BBC
interview preceding a performance
of his work later in London, he’s
asked whether he’s going to make
any money—and, if not, why do it?
“Any artistic decision based on
whether you’re going to make money
isn’t an artistic decision, it’s a busi-
ness decision,” he says. “I came here
to spend money on an English or-
chestra. To record my music. So I can
take it home. And I can listen to it.”
If anyone else is interested, he adds,
there will be a recording available.
But no, he says, he didn’t expect to
make any money.
Mr. Winter, whom some will know
as the non-Keanu Reeves half of the
“Bill and Ted” franchise, gives us the
whole Zappa story, from his child-
hood in Lancaster, Calif., where his
friends included avant-gardist-musi-
cian-to-be Don Van Vliet (aka Captain
Beefheart) and his father was a gov-
ernment meteorologist and history
teacher. At some point, he discovered
YORAM KAHANA/MAGNOLIA PICTURES
ROTATIONAL VENT
TO DIRECT
STERILIZED AIR
WHISPER QUIET
AXIAL FAN
Aerosolized
A virus cells can remain
suspended
s in air for up to 6 hours. The
Code
C Blue Air Sterilizer was first developed
in 2003 to combat airborne bioterrorism,
SARS
S CoV-2, influenza and tuberculosis. Its
performance
p has been tested, evaluated
and
a validated by public health authorities
and
a independent scientists.*
HBO MAX (2)
SAFE
S AND EFFECTIVE DESIGN KILLS
GERMS
G
ULTRAVIOLET C
EMITTER Germicidal
G irradiation destroys virus
and
a bacteria cells by altering their DNA, TELEVISION REVIEW | DOROTHY RABINOWITZ
ELECTROSTATIC
rendering
re them harmless. The Code
AIR FLOW INTAKE
Blue
B air sterilizer eliminates germs in its
ARTS IN REVIEW
THEATER REVIEW | TERRY TEACHOUT definitely qualifies. their privileged lives, least of all
L
ydia R. Diamond’s “Smart Peo- see it taken up in short order by Clockwise from top left: Amy Kim erie: “Wow…that’s kind of hot when Smart People
ple,” a hard-edged satire of regional theaters. A four-character Waschke, Rasell Holt, Jeb Burris a white guy says that.”) American Players Theatre, Spring
life among the academic mul- play with minimal scenic require- and Cassia Thompson What makes “Smart People” Green, Wis. (viewable online through
ticulturati, was first performed off ments, it also lends itself to small- more than just a brilliant hatchet Dec. 31, free). To watch, go to pb-
Broadway in 2016 in a production scale bare-bones production, which job is that Ms. Diamond clearly swisconsin.org/out-of-the-woods
directed by Kenny Leon. I praised makes it ideally suited to webcast- online as part of the company’s feels for her characters, who are
the play at the time as “intelligent ing. Accordingly, Wisconsin’s “Out of the Woods” series of imprisoned by the stereotypes they Mr. Teachout, the Journal’s drama
and provocative enough to put you American Players Theatre, Amer- Zoom-based play readings. embody. They are—so to speak— critic, is the author of “Satchmo at
in mind of Tom Stoppard,” and I ica’s finest classical theater festi- True satire leaves no sacred cows human beings beneath the skin, the Waldorf.” Write to him at
wasn’t even slightly surprised to val, has now put “Smart People” unbutchered, and “Smart People” and none of them are happy with tteachout@wsj.com.
FILM REVIEW
JOANNA HARCOURT-SMITH/SHOWTIME
prison, was what was usually
IN APPROACHING Errol Morris’s termed a jet-setter, a happy vaga-
“My Psychedelic Love Story,” it bond with an ornate pedigree, a lux-
doesn’t hurt to have some familiar- urious lifestyle and no visible means
ity with “Wormwood,” the 2017 of support. She delivers a veritable
Netflix docudrama miniseries. In it, torrent of stories for Mr. Morris,
the fabled documentarian told the who for all his cerebral meditations
story of Frank Olson, a CIA em- on objective truth is essentially a
ployee who mysteriously fell to his storyteller himself. She also won-
death in 1953 nine days after being ders, 40 years later and after having
slipped LSD as part of an agency ex- seen “Wormwood,” whether her Still from ‘My Psychedelic Love Story’ showing Timothy Leary and Joanna Harcourt-Smith
periment. Was he pushed or did he role in Leary’s downfall had been a
jump? Was hippie socialite Joanna part of the War on Drugs.
Harcourt-Smith being used as a CIA Based on Ms. Harcourt-Smith’s ing bridge. She claims her stepfa- Interrotron, which enables him to Massachusetts interview location.
tool when her boyfriend, Timothy 2013 memoir, “Tripping the Bardo ther, Árpád Plesch, who married interview a subject eye-to-eye while There are virtually no interruptions
Leary, became a government infor- With Timothy Leary: My Psyche- both her grandmother and mother, still having that subject look di- to her story or statements, none of
mant in the mid-’70s? And what in delic Love Story” (she died in Octo- swindled and then denounced fellow rectly into the camera. (It was first the conventional cuts. Even as she’s
the world is the connection? ber), the Morris film is basically one Jews during the Holocaust. She and used on the Oscar-winning “The telling some tale, the perspective
LSD, for one thing. Leary, a psy- long narrative, a name-dropping ex- Leary took acid while inside Folsom Fog of War.”) In “My Psychedelic moves around the room, the effect
chologist who’d been fired from travaganza: Those with whom Ms. Prison (where Leary had the cell Love Story” (available Sunday at 9 being a further fragmentation of
Harvard for his early experimenta- Harcourt-Smith enjoyed fewer than next to Manson’s). The tales are p.m. on Showtime), he has taken the reality being recounted, or cre-
tion with psychedelic drugs, was six degrees of separation include flamboyant. They may even be true. the mechanics of movie journalism ated. It’s not an entirely new thing,
considered the “high priest” (all the Rolling Stones, Diane von Furst- Mr. Morris is among the most a step further: Ms. Harcourt-Smith, but it’s a film-nerd treat and a fas-
puns intended) of hallucinogens and enberg, Francis Ford Coppola, Ad- intellectual of documentary makers, who is a captivating narrator and cinating technique, almost as fasci-
at one point was dubbed the most nan Khashoggi, Andy Warhol, but on an artisanal level his trade- knows how to balance shameless nating as the subject herself.
dangerous man in America by Rich- Charles Manson and Benito Musso- mark is the head-on confrontation, charm and self-effacement, is shot
ard M. Nixon. Ms. Harcourt-Smith, lini. Her mother gave birth to her in the face-to-face interview. In refin- with four cameras and shown from Mr. Anderson is a Journal TV critic.
who became involved with Leary in St. Moritz, Switzerland, while play- ing that process, he developed the various angles inside the film’s Joe Morgenstern is on vacation.
Kansas City 51 30 s 55 33 s Amsterdam 48 39 sh 46 34 pc San Juan 85 74 pc 84 73 s 20 Home of the 36 Mammoth snarer publication? F E T A A N N A L S E MU
S MA R T C O O K I E T O P
Las Vegas 60 38 s 59 41 s Athens 64 47 s 64 56 s Seoul 46 24 pc 38 25 s WNBA’s Aces 37 “Really, it’s my 61 Best Actress O O H O O H B E E F C A K E
Shanghai 56 46 c 53 44 pc treat!” L A O N U L L
Little Rock 62 39 c 54 37 pc Baghdad 72 55 pc 67 55 sh 22 Pie chart nominee for L OWE S B O G L O C H S
Los Angeles 70 45 s 72 47 s Bangkok 91 76 pc 90 76 c Singapore 82 76 t 82 76 t dividers 39 Goods carrier “Bombshell” SWE E T I E P I E D R O P
Miami 81 70 pc 82 69 pc Beijing 44 21 pc 40 25 pc Sydney 85 76 s 100 83 pc A N A D R I L L AWE
Milwaukee 46 30 pc 49 36 s Berlin 44 33 c 41 33 c Taipei City 74 65 r 70 63 r Email your answer—in the subject line—to crosswordcontest@wsj.com
s
T I R E S T U DMU F F I N
Minneapolis 38 30 s 48 32 s Brussels 48 35 sh 48 33 pc Tokyo 56 52 r 60 48 s S T A R Z HM S H A T E D
by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time Sunday, Nov. 29. A solver selected at random S I S I S A N
Nashville 66 41 c 57 34 s Buenos Aires 81 71 s 81 71 t Toronto 46 35 c 44 34 pc
New Orleans 77 65 sh 70 63 t Dubai 85 72 s 85 69 pc Vancouver 48 40 r 47 35 pc will win a WSJ mug. Last week’s winner: Brian Egleston, Colorado Springs, A R M C A N D Y C U B I S M
X I I Z E R O C A L O R I E
New York City 60 48 pc 56 40 s Dublin 44 38 pc 49 42 pc Warsaw 43 33 sh 36 30 sh CO. Complete contest rules at WSJ.com/Puzzles. (No purchase necessary. I L L S E A G O D Y O R E
Oklahoma City 56 34 pc 52 36 sh Edinburgh 44 32 sh 42 37 pc Zurich 42 27 pc 42 31 c Void where prohibited. U.S. residents 18 and over only.) S E E A DM I T S S N I T
A12 | Friday, November 27, 2020 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
Argentine Was Soccer’s Flawed Genius
The unlikely superstar was dazzling and outrageous and led his country to a World Cup title with the ‘Hand of God’
BY JOSHUA ROBINSON
D
iego Maradona, the
outlandish and daz-
zling Argentine soccer
star considered among
the greatest of all
time on the field and the most
outrageous off of it, died on
Wednesday following a cardiac ar-
rest. He was 60.
News of his death was con-
firmed by Argentina’s national soc-
cer federation. Maradona had un-
dergone surgery to
OBITUARY remove a blood clot
DIEGO from his brain ear-
MARADONA lier this month. He
1960-2020 had also struggled
for decades with
drug abuse and weight issues.
making house calls in a Winnebago by this odd fortune of quarantine, from home) and my children (who more time with them in the past I love the most. These past few
to give tennis lessons, or the frus- or semi-quarantine, or whatever are mostly doing virtual school). eight months than I would have. months have underlined an obvi-
trated towel police at the All Eng- you want to call how it is we live We’re jammed up here for hours, My sons know what’s happening ous truth: parenting is hard. Fam-
land Lawn Tennis Club. But it was today. in each other’s laps, in each with their father, but they might ily life can be hectic. It’s meant a
not uncommon for me to be away In ordinary times, I’d be walking other’s business. It might drive not fully grasp why this is so pow- lot of chaos around the house, but
from my wife and children for my sons—they are 11 and 8—off to other parents crazy. I think it’s the erful to me. It’s my everything. I wouldn’t have it any other way.
weeks, covering tournaments as school in the morning, then wait- greatest. I hope there are other people For me, chaos is life.
far away as Australia. It was a ing around at home for them to I call it my unexpected blessing. out there like me, finding silver
dream job, but I missed my family. finish. Time alone is not what I’m I’m trying to savor every minute of linings amid a pandemic. This sit- Tom Perrotta has written about
Then my life changed. Not long craving right now—that’s when my it: every interaction, every game of uation has caused tremendous tennis and other sports for the
after my 40th birthday, I was diag- mind races. Uno, every book, every homework stress and difficulty, but it has Journal for more than a decade.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | A13
OPINION
Justice for Michael Flynn BOOKSHELF | By Howard Schneider
Chief Justice
John Marshall
once de-
making such calls now. The
FBI nonetheless debated a lu-
dicrous Logan Act charge, be-
liam Barr’s 2020 decision to
review the case. But even as
the executive branch moved to
Trump might have waited, in
hope that Judge Sullivan
would feel mounting pressure
Great
scribed the
presidential
pardon as “an
fore settling on a simpler
course. As former FBI coun-
terintelligence head Bill Prie-
right its wrongs, a federal
judge took up the persecuto-
rial torch. In May the Justice
to regain some credibility by
dismissing. Then again, there
was every reason to believe
Expectations
POTOMAC act of grace.” stap put it in handwritten Department moved to drop its the judge would string this
WATCH In the case of
Mike Flynn,
notes, one FBI option was “to
get [Mr. Flynn] to lie, so we
case, presenting Judge Emmet
Sullivan with veteran prosecu-
out beyond Jan. 20. He’s made
clear all along he wants Mr.
Escape Artist
By Kimberley
D o n a l d can prosecute him or get him tor Jeffrey Jensen’s assess- Flynn subject to an avenging By Joseph McAleer
A. Strassel
Trump’s par- fired.” ment that the FBI never had a Biden Justice Department. Not (Oxford, 368 pages, $25.95)
I
don was The FBI didn’t need to in- legitimate purpose in inter- because Mr. Flynn broke the
something more. It was a re- terview the National Security viewing Mr. Flynn, that he law, but because Mr. Flynn is a n “Escape Artist,” Joseph McAleer’s premise is that his
quirement of justice. Agency about his conversa- should never have been prose- stand-in for a president the uneminent subject was in fact a remarkable fellow who
Mr. Trump announced on tion; it had the transcript. Yet cuted. The department also judicial, prosecutorial and me- deserves to be much better known. He calls Harry Perry
Twitter Wednesday that he’d the bureau’s then-Deputy Di- presented papers document- dia elites despise. Robinson (1859-1930) “a latter-day Tocqueville” whose
granted Mr. Flynn a full par- rector Andrew McCabe sand- ing the FBI’s shocking behav- That’s the sad reality of the “march through history, a near-epic story,” exemplified
don. Liberals and the media bagged Mr. Flynn, arranging ior. Flynn mess. In a better world, “an exciting personal story worthy of Horatio Alger.”
are (as per their tedious for him to meet with FBI the Flynn case would have Whether readers of this book will enjoy it depends, I
usual) claiming the president agents without a lawyer. For- been dismissed with prejudice, suspect, on whether they agree with Mr. McAleer’s thesis.
stepped in to aid a corrupt mer FBI Director Jim Comey Trump’s pardon for an on-the-record censure of Robinson’s father was a Church of England clergyman who
crony. This has it exactly back- later gloated over the setup. appalling FBI and Justice De- served in India and eventually ran a newspaper there.
ward. The Flynn pardon was The FBI also chose not to pro- his onetime national partment behavior. But that’s Harry spent his first two years in India before moving to
necessary—to correct a cor- vide Mr. Flynn a standard security adviser rights why the judge refused to do it. England with his mother and five siblings. He attended the
rupt Federal Bureau of Inves- warning against lying, to keep It had nothing to do with guilt elite Westminster School and won a scholarship to Oxford,
tigation, a rogue special coun- him comfortable. Despite all a grievous wrong. or innocence—but rather rep- where he studied classics, receiving “a class IV degree,
sel, an unprincipled federal this, the agents reported—ac- utation. We remain in the last the lowest.”
judge, and an embarrassingly cording to government gasps of Never Trump world, After graduation Robinson moved to the United States to
complicit media. notes—that they “believe that The Justice Department, where people of power told make his mark in the world. His assets? Good looks, charm,
This story dripped out over F. believes that what he said not judges, makes the call on themselves it was OK to break an admirable work ethic and, one presumes, a tony English
years, so it took until recently was true.” He didn’t intention- whom to prosecute. Yet Judge rules, norms, standards—even accent, which invariably induces robust forelock tugging
to get a full accounting of the ally lie. Sullivan refused to accept the the law—in their quest to take in Americans. Also, a talent
government’s Trump-by-proxy Fast forward to Robert withdrawal, instead indulging the president down. To dis- for endearing himself to
takedown of Mr. Flynn. A dec- Mueller, who didn’t care. The his politics and his inner petty miss the Flynn case would powerful men. He became a
orated veteran, Mr. Flynn ad- FBI knew in January 2017 that tyrant. He went so far as to have been to acknowledge journalist in New York and
vised the Trump campaign its collusion investigation was appoint a fellow conspiracy that this behavior was wrong. subsequently traveled west
and in November 2016 was a bust; it confirmed the Steele theorist, retired Judge John And that would have been too (a proto-environmentalist,
named national security ad- dossier was a fabrication. So Gleeson, to spout evidence- painful, too embarrassing, too he reveled in the landscapes)
viser. The FBI had spent Mr. Comey engineered a spe- free claims that prosecutors galling for the haters. to report on the completion
months monitoring him as cial counsel to salvage the were giving special treatment So it was left to the White of the third transcontinental
part of its Russia-collusion FBI’s reputation by ginning up to Mr. Flynn. Judge Sullivan’s House to make this right, to railroad and a gold rush in
fantasy, yet by Jan. 4, 2017, it unrelated “crimes.” Mr. Muel- behavior was so outrageous take a wrecking ball to a the Idaho territory. He then
had found nothing and moved ler dredged up the Flynn in- that a federal appeals panel in rigged system. Mr. Trump moved to Minneapolis, where
to close its case. terview and threatened to June ordered him to dismiss acted correctly. And there he published his first short
In rushed Peter Strzok—the prosecute the former national the case. The full appellate could have been no more fit- story. There were others, and
now-disgraced then-FBI security adviser’s son unless court in August agreed to let ting, final rebuke to four years eventually novels and
agent—to keep the investiga- Mr. Flynn pleaded guilty to ly- him hold a hearing while of drive-by shootings than to nonfiction books. (Based on
tion open. The FBI had ing. Facing bankruptcy, Mr. warning him to get his act to- release the man the cabal excerpts in “Escape Artist,” I
snooped on a Flynn call to the Flynn succumbed to this na- gether. claimed as its very first vic- don’t think the world has
then-Russian ambassador to ked abuse of power. Judge Sullivan held his tim. Justice indeed, and on overlooked a gifted fiction writer.) He founded a trade
the U.S. This is perfectly legal; Hope came with a new law- hearing in September but by many levels. newspaper, the Northwestern Railroader, in 1887, organized
ask Joe Biden’s team, which is yer and Attorney General Wil- this week had yet to rule. Mr. Write to kim@wsj.com. Railway Employes [sic] Clubs (pro workers, anti union)
and became “the voice and even conscience of the railroad
industry in America”—a most important industry at the
Woke Capitalism in a Secular World time. In 1891 he married Mary Lowry, the daughter of a
railroad magnate. He had come a long way.
Robinson became an American citizen in 1888 and by
HOUSES OF This week’s panies that play along is that a narrowly rationalist form of some other lasting, existential 1896 was a committed member of the Republican Party.
WORSHIP e m o t i o n a l the proponents of many pro- scientific management, Saul commitment. They can be re- He deployed his Railway Employes Clubs to help William
By Andrew V. response by gressive causes are hostile to observed in “Voltaire’s Bas- inforced by a healthy corpo- McKinley’s presidential campaign, and when McKinley won,
Abela employees at free enterprise itself. The best tards” (1992). By reducing all rate culture, but there is no the new president expressed his gratitude for Robinson’s
Penguin Ran- that such companies can hope of morality to the latest pro- substituting for internally campaign assistance.
dom House for is short-term appease- gressive causes, the woke cap- grounded habits such as hon- Robinson’s personal life was less happy by then. He and
Canada when they learned ment. italists have unintentionally esty, trustworthiness, and Mary had grown apart, a situation probably exacerbated
that their company would The Business Roundtable become Friedman’s bastards— self-discipline. We used to call by the very early deaths of their two children. In 1900 he
publish best-selling author statement arguably was a re- replacing one narrow rational- that virtue. returned to England—without Mary—and eventually
Jordan Peterson’s next book pudiation of the Friedman ism with another. This straightforward and regained his British citizenship. The next few years were
follows Target’s flip-flop last doctrine, as explained by Another problem with woke principled approach to entre- difficult for Robinson. He failed as a book publisher, caught
week on whether to sell Abi- economist Milton Friedman in capitalism is that it simply preneurship and management diphtheria and suffered financially. But his luck changed in
gail Shrier’s book, “Irrevers- his 1970 article “The Social doesn’t work. One of my stu- is the best alternative to woke 1905. He married Florence Tester (19 years his junior), with
ible Damage: The Transgender Responsibility of Business Is dents recently reviewed 30 capitalism. It grounds busi- whom he had a son. He also established a relationship with
Craze Seducing Our Daugh- to Increase Its Profits.” He cases of companies engaging ness in lasting principles that influential voice of the British establishment, the Times
ters.” They are the latest ex- wrote that corporate execu- in political activism. Twenty- while recognizing that the of London, where he would remain for virtually the rest of
pressions of the new religion tives should “conduct the seven generated a “negative creation of goods and services his life. The paper found Robinson’s great lifetime causes
of wokeness that is spreading business in accordance with outcome,” or backlash. This for society is good in itself. congenial: devotion to the British Empire and a belief that
through corporations at a their [shareholders’] desires, When done fairly and hon- only the United Kingdom and the United States could guide
staggering pace, filling the which generally will be to estly, commerce does not have the world to stable peace and prosperity. Robinson reported
vacuum left by the decline in make as much money as pos- Principles grounded to be apologized for or justi- on an array of subjects for the Times, from the 1912
traditional belief and practice. sible while conforming to the fied through “woke-washing.” Olympics to World War I to the unsealing of King
Some 18 months ago the basic rules of the society, both in faith or existential Instead of using business to Tutankhamun’s tomb and—perdition!—wrote book reviews.
Business Roundtable pro- those embodied in law and commitment should further divide the country and
posed redefining the purpose those embodied in ethical cus- sideline people of faith, com-
of a corporation. Rather than tom.” Friedman didn’t address guide companies. panies can take a “live and let As a journalist in the early years of the 20th
simply working in the inter- what to do when “ethical cus- live” approach. century, Robinson played eyewitness to many
est of shareholders, the or- tom” is inimical to free enter- One point in particular
ganization affirmed that prise itself. shouldn’t be surprising. The from Friedman’s famous arti- historical events. Does that make him ‘great’?
companies also should com- As any CEO knows, simply U.S. is sharply divided on po- cle remains salient: It is not
mit to delivering value to making as much money as fast litical and social issues. There the role of unelected business
customers, investing in em- as possible won’t ensure that a isn’t much upside for a com- leaders to involve public com- In 1920, Harry was knighted for his work as a war
ployees, dealing fairly and company can flourish over pany to take a stand on abor- panies in controversial politi- correspondent. He continued at the Times and ventured
ethically with suppliers, and time. A corporation is a com- tion, same-sex marriage or cal or social issues. They around the globe when his health permitted. In 1923 he
supporting local communi- plex human organization, ani- complex racial issues, espe- should instead work on the traveled to Algiers to report on an auto race. He died of
ties. mated by a vision of the good cially when such themes are good that they were estab- pneumonia in 1930 at the age of 71.
The admirable—if platitudi- it can do for its customers. irrelevant to its business. lished to do, in a principled “Escape Artist” is well researched and, for the most part,
nous—idea quickly has been Success cannot be reduced Principles guide good man- fashion. And they should look well written. Mr. McAleer—the author, most recently, of
perverted to mean that busi- solely to profitability. agers when making decisions. closely at the source of these “Call of the Atlantic: Jack London’s Publishing Odyssey
nesses ought to obey orders The problem is analogous Yet these principles do not principles to make sure that Overseas, 1902-1916”—occasionally lapses into hyperbole.
from the progressive elite, re- to one identified by philoso- come from external norms of what they are following is a “In spite of all his flaws,” he writes, “Harry had ‘real
gardless of how thin its con- pher John Ralston Saul. Vol- “ethical custom,” especially moral compass, not a wind greatness.’ ” I grant that Robinson was an astute careerist,
nection to any company may taire and his Enlightenment not if the custom derives from vane. but I’ve searched my notes and memory of this book in
be. In practice, “woke capital” colleagues championed reason the progressive beliefs of the vain for signs of greatness.
does little more than pay trib- as the way to free people from moment. Principles, if they Mr. Abela is dean of the Conclusions about Robinson’s distinction must be based
ute to progressive causes arbitrary power and the “su- are to be effective in guiding Busch School of Business at on his journalism. I don’t doubt that the bulk of his
through marketing and pos- perstition” of religion. But any organization, must be the Catholic University of reporting was competent. But when Mr. McAleer states,
turing. The problem for com- reason has been degraded into grounded in faith or at least America. apropos of King Tut, that “the scoop of the century was
about to drop into [Harry’s] lap” it seems far-fetched.
Lord Carnarvon, who funded the Tut expedition, contracted
Covid Lockdown at the North Pole with the Times to sell articles to other newspapers about
the investigation—not even the discovery—of the tomb.
Robinson served as Carnarvon’s flack. (Even if Harry had
By Bob Greene time in 159 years, its depart- morning, before I departed and their children would scooped his competitors about all things Tut, were they
I
ment stores won’t have a for the courthouse, we were shyly approach and whisper journalistic coups comparable to, say, Watergate?)
can see him now, sitting Santa on site for children and both taking the remnants of their Christmas wishes to As for his war correspondence, Mr. McAleer maintains
by himself in the their families to visit. Covid, our breakfasts to the trash him. “I see amazement in the that Robinson, “had few rivals.” I hope that wasn’t the case.
cramped but clean break- of course—that’s the reason, and I asked him how long he faces of the children,” he Robinson believed that a reporter’s job was “to help to win
fast buffet area of a roadside and we should have seen the was staying at the hotel. said, “and hope, and excite- the War . . . build up the nation’s pride in the Army, and to
hotel near the Fox River in new policy coming. “Forty nights,” he said, ment.” Greeting all those strengthen the general moral [sic].” And so after the Battle
eastern Wisconsin. Baggy red smiling, and that is when he boys and girls for 40 days, of Passchendaele, one of the most brutal battles of World
trousers with suspenders, full told me his story. he said, meant he knew that War I, he wrote, “everywhere there is the undefinable
white beard, big belly, he I met Santa once in a He was 60, he lived in a by the time he returned to thrill of victory,” not least among the wounded, who were
would sometimes read the small town in Montana, and Montana he would have “dreadfully dirty and disreputable to the eye, but every man
morning paper, sometimes Wisconsin hotel. Now each year he found work, made thousands of children cheery and full of hearty laughter, knowing we have won.
glance at the television set kids won’t be able to though an agency, at a mall happy. It is good even to be wounded on such a day.” Yes, it was
bolted to the wall above the or store somewhere in the Covid has robbed us all of a different era, different journalistic rules, different norms.
miniboxes of cereal. find him at Macy’s. U.S. that needed a full-time a lot, and you can’t blame Nevertheless, I find Robinson’s statement hateful.
He seldom spoke, not that Santa. The definition of sea- Macy’s and the other stores This book prompted me to think of David Livingstone
the place was busy in the sonal labor. That particular for being cautious. But the andRichard Francis Burton, two 19th-century British
days leading up to Christmas. Across the country, de- year he was assigned to the days of pure wonder in a explorers who also boldly forayed into the world—and
This was more than 20 years partment stores and malls Fox River Mall, near the ho- young child’s eyes are finite whose achievements still impress. “Escape Artist” has
ago; I was covering a court have agonized about what to tel. Ten in the morning until and nonrenewable. “It fills many virtues, but its subject is more Zelig than exemplar.
case in rural Wisconsin, and do with Santa. Some are of- the mall closed each night, me with cheer every day,”
this was the closest place to fering online visits and Zoom no days off. the Santa at the breakfast Mr. Schneider reviews books for newspapers and magazines.
the courthouse I could find calls, some are putting Santa He was a little lonely, he buffet told me before head-
to spend the week. There behind plexiglass or inside a said—he missed his own ing off to work, in a Christ-
were some construction see-through globe. There’s a grandchildren—but what he mas season that suddenly Coming in BOOKS this weekend
workers staying there, and built-in chilliness: Social dis- saw and heard each day was feels very far away. Thorstein Veblen vs. the leisure class • The British Empire
me, and Santa Claus. tancing and Santa Claus are a gift beyond monetary and the historian’s pen • Phil Ochs: The voice of protest •
I’m thinking about him to- concepts that clash. value. The mothers and fa- Mr. Greene’s books include ‘Harriet the Spy’ and her creator • Alternative media,
day because of the decision That fellow in Wisconsin thers of the surrounding “Chevrolet Summers, Dairy from talk radio to Twitter • Sam Sacks on fiction • & more
by Macy’s that, for the first always dined silently, but one communities would arrive, Queen Nights.”
A14 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Fireworks Over Religious Liberty Debating the Integrity of the 2020 Election
W
ow. That word rarely applies to Su- necessary because Mr. Cuomo has already re- Regarding your editorial “Georgia state legislatures choose to overrule
preme Court opinions. But it does in scinded his orders. But the majority explains Certifies: Donald Trump Lost” (Nov. the state’s vote it would have grave
21): The Journal spent much of the consequences for the GOP. But it
our view to the Court’s order on that Mr. Cuomo could reinstate or change them
last year running several editorials goes far beyond a danger to the GOP.
Thanksgiving eve enjoining at any time, as he often has, outlining the many troubles with Without proof of fraud, and putting
New York’s Covid-19 order re- The Supreme Court says and the plaintiffs would suffer mail-in voting, its easy susceptibility aside the legality of the decision, by
stricting attendance at reli- Cuomo’s orders violate immediate injury as they wait to fraud and the concerted Demo- overruling the vote and ensuring a
gious services. The Court is for courts to grant relief. Any- cratic efforts through lawsuits to Trump presidency, state legislatures
back as a sentinel protecting the First Amendment. one who has watched Mr. overturn state laws as written by would be threatening the foundation
the free exercise of religion, Cuomo operate in the pan- the legislature to force mail-in vot- of democracy. There is simply no
even in a health emergency. demic knows he relishes his ing, especially in the swing states. reason for citizens to participate in
The Court’s order is a temporary injunction role as master of the universe. On bullying Over the four years before that, the elections if the vote can be ignored
pending review on the merits by lower courts and brand as always, he dismissed the Court's order Journal editorial pages (but not the by a state legislature that doesn’t
perhaps eventually the Justices. But the rhetori- as “philosophy and politics.” news pages) shone the spotlight on like the result.
the phony Russia hoax that started MATT ELBERT
cal firepower unleashed in six separate opinions The order shows that new Justice Amy Co-
with the false Steele dossier. Houston
shows that convictions run hot at the Court on ney Barrett’s vote was decisive. The Court had The attitude of 95% of the media
this subject, as well they should given the stakes split 4-4 on previous religious appeals in the is that no one better ask any ques- Whether Mr. Trump’s attorneys
for American liberty that has itself been enjoined pandemic, and Justice Gorsuch unloads on the tions or doubt the absolute veracity can prove their claims in court re-
by politicians in the pandemic. Chief Justice’s May opinion in a California case of the vote count, and we are ex- mains to be seen, but serious ques-
In an unsigned 5-4 per curiam decision, the (South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. pected to disregard the testimony of tions have been raised about the va-
Court blocked as discriminatory Gov. Andrew Newsom). The Chief had cited a precedent from many eyewitnesses to what went on. lidity of the ballots tabulated in a
Cuomo’s arbitrary limits of 10 or 25 people in a century ago to argue for deferring to the au- What will keep the same thing from handful of states. In order for the
houses of worship in certain Covid hot spots. thority and expertise of local officials in an happening in future elections? electorate to have faith in the out-
The petitions came from the Catholic Diocese emergency. JOHN M. BLUST come, these questions must be ad-
Greensboro, N.C. dressed and fully answered.
of Brooklyn and Agudath Israel of America, “Even if the Constitution has taken a holiday
RICHARD REINITZ
which represents Orthodox Jews (Diocese of during this pandemic, it cannot become a sab- You are absolutely correct that if Houston
Brooklyn v. Cuomo). batical,” Justice Gorsuch writes. “Rather than
“Members of this Court are not public health apply a nonbinding and expired concurrence
experts, and we should respect the judgment from South Bay, courts must resume applying
of those with special expertise and responsibil- the Free Exercise Clause. Today, a majority of
Child-Care Access Is Good Policy for Families
ity in this area. But even in a pandemic, the the Court makes this plain.” Your editorial “A Family Policy school, the city’s maternal labor-force
Constitution cannot be put away and forgot- The Chief replies that Justice Gorsuch makes Warning” (Nov. 20) cites a single participation rate increased by about
ten,” the Court writes. “The restrictions at is- too much of a single sentence in his South Bay study about Austria to make the 12 percentage points, with 10 percent-
sue here, by effectively barring many from at- opinion. But the sharp exchange highlights the broad claim that child-care afford- age points attributable to preschool
tending religious services, strike at the very differences on the Court between the Chief’s ability “likely won’t have the trans- expansion. On Nov. 3, over two-thirds
formative effects that proponents of Coloradans voted for Proposition
heart of the First Amendment’s guarantee of re- political pragmatism and the majority’s adher-
hope” in the U.S. One study on Aus- EE. This initiative will generate over
ligious liberty.” ence to first constitutional principles. The opin- trian maternal employment is slim $2 billion over 10 years to support
The Court explains that New York’s order ions also make clear the frustration of the con- evidence to claim that American ini- universal preschool for four-year-olds
treats houses of worship more harshly than servative Justices with the Chief’s restraint in tiatives for affordable and high-qual- in the state.
what Mr. Cuomo considers “essential” busi- protecting core constitutional rights. ity early child care will fail. Despite decades of well-inten-
nesses. Those include liquor stores, bike shops, i i i American children need high-qual- tioned philanthropic interventions
acupuncturists, lawyers, accountants, and While the 5-4 order is welcome, it is disap- ity child care, but hardworking fami- and state-by-state initiatives, many
more. pointing that the ruling wasn’t 9-0. New York’s lies struggle to afford it. Over 80% of American families are still priced out
As Justice Neil Gorsuch puts it in a corker restrictions on religious worship are so over- parents shoulder the full cost, which of high-quality child care. Lawmakers
of a concurrence: “So, at least according to the broad, and so arbitrary, that their violation of exceeds $20,000 a year in 22 states. must consider implementing policies
Governor, it may be unsafe to go to church, but the Free Exercise Clause should be an easy call. The current system isn’t working. like Proposition EE nationally. Is soci-
Over 86% of child care is market ety not responsible for the well being
it is always fine to pick up another bottle of Americans have tolerated extraordinary re-
based, but the child-care market of our next generation? One study
wine, shop for a new bike, or spend the after- straints on their freedom in the pandemic, but doesn’t respond to typical supply and may highlight issues with Austria’s
noon exploring your distal points and meridi- it’s increasingly clear as we learn more about demand forces. The supply would in- policies, but much other evidence
ans. Who knew public health would so perfectly the virus that too many Governors have need- crease if parents could choose their points to significant educational and
align with secular convenience?” This disparate lessly infringed on basic rights. provider based on quality, rather than socio-economic benefits of high-qual-
treatment discriminates against religion. And too many judges have acquiesced. Amer- solely on cost. ity child care and we must provide it.
The four dissenters, including Chief Justice icans should welcome the Supreme Court back After Washington, D.C., began of- DAVID MERAGE
John Roberts, argue that an injunction isn’t at the ramparts as a defender of liberty. fering two years of universal pre- Englewood, Colo.
A Pardon for General Flynn Hard to See Something Like the Draft Again
P
resident Trump’s decision Wednesday vantage of the unsuspecting Mr. Flynn and a Michael Sanger expresses a worthy Will the American people accept an
to pardon former national security ad- trusting White House to have his agents inter- and honorable sentiment in his Nov. active-duty military of more than 10
viser Michael Flynn is an overdue act view him without courtesies normally ex- 18 letter regarding the value of mili- million service members, much less
of justice that ends four years of political ha- tended to criminals. tary service toward promoting a pay the costs demanded?
rassment, unjustified prosecution and judicial Justice finally moved to dismiss the charges stronger sense of civic virtue within Perhaps a better solution would be
abuse. If it sounds like we feel strongly about this year, but then federal Judge Emmet Sulli- our nation. Unfortunately, whatever a strengthened system of locally
this one, you’re right. van opted for political revenge by refusing to its virtues, a reinstitution of the draft based reserve components, a reconsti-
We’ve never met the former general and agree to the dismissal. He even tried to investi- is neither practicable nor consistent tuted structure of the militia within
decorated veteran. But every American should gate the case himself—an extraordinary intru- with the deeper military traditions of the several states. This would be
the American experience. more in keeping with the Founders’
be worried about his mistreatment by a politi- sion by a court into the executive branch’s
In 2017 the U.S. population of 18- original concept of civil-military rela-
cized system of justice that could happen to prosecutorial power. His obvious goal was to to-24-year-olds was approximately 31 tions and promote the positive civic
anyone on the wrong side of vindictive people stall long enough for a Biden Administration million. The Army currently rejects virtues Mr. Sanger rightly advocates.
with power. to take power and reinstate the charges. What about 70% of volunteers for being un- COL. CLARK SUMMERS, USAR (RET.)
The FBI and Justice pursued him though a disgraceful performance. fit due to one reason or another, so Belmont, N.C.
they knew there was no basis for an investiga- Mr. Flynn should have been vindicated in how universal would universal na-
tion. They coerced a plea of lying to the FBI court, but Judge Sullivan was never going to tional service, military or otherwise,
though the interviewing agents thought he give him a fair hearing. A pardon was the only really be if only nine million of 31 mil- Hong Kong’s Government
was telling the truth. A later re-examination avenue left to prevent Mr. Flynn from more lion potential recruits can pass the
entrance requirements? Given that
Misunderstands U.S. Oath
ordered by Attorney General Bill Barr found years of punishment. Congratulations to Mr.
that Justice and the FBI had withheld exculpa- Trump for sparing an innocent man who our current active-duty military is 1.3 In his letter of Nov. 24, Hong
million, conscripting only those rea- Kong Chief Secretary for Administra-
tory evidence. Former FBI director James served his country well but was ill-served by
sonably fit to serve would require ex- tion Matthew Cheung Kin-chung
Comey crowed about how the bureau took ad- too many of his countrymen. panding our current military infra- wrongly states: “Members of the U.S.
structure by a factor of about seven. Congress are required to swear to
C
Here is the exact oath: “I do sol-
EOs are offering alms to win favor with complementary policies.” That standard will Burning for Non-PC Books emnly swear (or affirm) that I will
their future federal regulators. This now be dictated by California, which has banned support and defend the Constitution
week’s aim-to-please prize goes to CEO sales of gas-fueled cars by 2035. In his letter of Nov. 20, Jordan Sil- of the United States against all ene-
Mary Barra, who pulled the “We believe the ambitious verman asserts that Abigail Shrier’s mies, foreign and domestic; that I
Mary Barra drops “Does the ACLU Want to Ban My will bear true faith and allegiance to
plug on GM’s support for the electrification goals of the
Book?” (op-ed, Nov. 16) confuses “a the same; that I take this obligation
Trump Administration in its support for a Trump suit President-elect, California, right to freedom of speech with a freely, without any mental reservation
legal challenge to California’s and General Motors are right to have people listen to your or purpose of evasion; and that I will
electric car mandate. against California. aligned, to address climate speech.” He misapprehends the issue. well and faithfully discharge the du-
The Trump Environmental change by drastically reducing The Twitter mob didn’t want to read ties of the office on which I am about
Protection Agency last year automobile emissions,” wrote Ms. Shrier’s book; it objected to the to enter: So help me God.”
revoked the Obama Administration’s Clean Air Ms. Barra. She made this announcement after content and wanted Target to keep There are no caveats providing for
Act waiver that allowed California to set its meeting with California Air Resources Board others who might want to read the prosecution if the oath is not ful-
own auto greenhouse gas emission standards. chair Mary Nichols, who has been floated as a book from accessing it. Mr. Silverman filled. Mr. Cheung’s statement that it
Car makers complained that California’s elec- possible Biden EPA Administrator. is also wrong to suggest that the dan- is an international norm is flat out
tric-vehicle mandate and stringent emissions GM last week said it expects EVs to be- gers of book banning stem only from wrong. I hope all Americans under-
governmental actions. In many ways, stand the oath: We swear to defend
rules balkanized the national car market. come more profitable as battery costs decline
a book ban coerced by a Twitter mob ideals on a piece of paper, not a
If auto makers had to sell more EVs in Cali- and driving range improves. That would be is a greater danger to free speech, king, queen or dictator. That is what
fornia—which most currently do at a loss— fantastic, literally—but dealers who don’t since it is less controllable by judicial makes us different.
they’d have to raise prices on gas-fueled cars want to be stuck with unmovable inventory or democratic means. CDR. NORM FITZPATRICK, USN (RET.)
they sell in other states to compensate. Fed- aren’t buying Ms. Barra’s electric hype. Hence MARK WORCESTER Berwyn, Pa.
eral law explicitly prohibits states from setting GM is offering $500,000 buyouts to Cadillac Anchorage, Alaska
their own fuel economy standards, and the dealers that “choose not to participate on our
Constitution grants Congress the power to EV journey.” Pepper ...
regulate interstate commerce. GM is trying to ingratiate itself with regula- Remember Those Primitive And Salt
Republican states along with GM, Toyota tors so it can steer future fuel-economy stan- Videocalls of Long Ago? THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
and Fiat Chrysler intervened in support of the dards. Two years ago, GM called for a national
Jason Zweig’s “Back in Business:
Trump Administration in its legal standoff electric-car mandate with juiced-up regulatory
The Videocall Is So Last Century”
with California. A Biden Administration is ex- credits for its trucks and driverless cars. GM (Exchange, Nov. 14) reminds us that
pected to reverse the Trump fuel-economy also proposed to replace the 200,000 per man- fortune favors the lucky as well as
rules and reissue California’s waiver, but both ufacturer cap for the federal $7,500 EV tax the prepared and the bold. It’s a re-
will require new regulations that take time. credit—which it no longer qualifies for though minder, too, that success requires pa-
This means a legal challenge to California's most of its competitors do—with an industry- tience and persistence. Many of to-
authority to set its own rules may not be wide phase-out once electric cars exceed 5% day’s problems already have
moot if auto makers and GOP states continue of the U.S. light-duty fleet. technological solutions but are wait-
to fight. Yet Ms. Barra in a letter to environ- Other ideas include a mandate for EV char- ing for broad adoption.
mental groups on Monday said she is pulling gers in new homes and federally funded “K-12 MARK HOLMAN
Davis, Calif.
the plug on GM’s defense of the Trump Ad- education programs, and media programs
ministration and urged other auto makers to that highlight the benefits of driving elec-
Letters intended for publication
do the same. tric.” Perhaps China, which dominates bat- should be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com.
In joining the legal fight, GM had hoped to ne- tery production, could assist with the propa- Please include your city, state and
gotiate a settlement between the two sides, she ganda. We don’t want to hear GM caterwaul telephone number. All letters are sub-
explained, but “we believe there is now a path when it gets thrown by regulators under its ject to editing, and unpublished letters “Now that I’m here, could you tell me
cannot be acknowledged.
to achieve agreement on a national standard and own electric bus. what that was all about?”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | A15
OPINION
V
the entry exam, and instead ad- tive-entry high schools. But tack-
irginia Attorney General mit top students from every mid- ling that problem by abolishing
Mark Herring has fired the dle school in the city. tests and randomizing admission
latest salvo in America’s But is every middle school forfeits excellence in favor of
assault on meritocracy: a churning out eighth-graders with fake equity.
61-page opinion holding the requisite skills and knowl- Developing talented students
that the suburban Loudoun County edge to succeed at Bronx Sci- is the right approach, but that
school system discriminated against ence? Are all children who make means starting “gifted and tal-
black and Hispanic youngsters be- good grades eager, motivated ented” programs in many more
cause its selective-admission high learners ready to make the most elementary and middle schools.
school, the Academies of Loudon, of what these high-powered School systems would also have
hadn’t admitted enough of them. schools have to offer? to face the reality that some kids
Never mind that—as Mr. Herring ac- Instead of repairing the ele- are smarter and more motivated
knowledged—the school’s test-based mentary and middle schools at- than others, no matter their
admissions process is open to all and tended by poor and minority kids color. That’s anathema to “pro-
fairly managed. Because its results so that more of them will be pre- gressive” reformers, who prefer
have a “disparate impact,” the school pared for places like Stuyvesant, to abolish accelerated classes for
system must scrap it. and creating more such schools high achievers. Ithaca, N.Y., is one
Nationwide, selective-admission for bright children from every of several communities that has
public schools, also known as “exam background to get a top-notch moved to make all sixth- and sev-
schools,” are under attack because education, New York’s equity enth-graders take the same math,
DAVID KLEIN
the demographics of their student seekers are pressing to reallocate no matter how adept some are.
populations don’t match those of an extremely scarce resource. Mr. It is the job of schools to cre-
their communities. Much like elite de Blasio and colleagues overlook ate opportunities for all young
universities, critics allege, these the educational tragedies that people, regardless of background,
schools have been admitting far too the city’s schools routinely inflict on application fee. The superintendent Ellington School of the Arts, School to make the most of themselves.
many whites and Asians and not so many of the girls and boys they proposed moving to a lottery system Without Walls and others). All have Teachers can encourage the kid with
nearly enough blacks and Latinos. claim to be looking after. that would place every eighth-grader a small number of highly regarded a gleam in her eye to take harder
The impulse is spreading. Con- with good grades into the admis- exam schools with enrollments that classes. They can spot the shy 8-
sider another furor in Virginia, over sions pool. For now the Fairfax don’t mirror their communities and year-old from a troubled home who
Instead of fixing public admission to the esteemed Thomas County School Board has shunned are therefore deemed retrograde, if loves to read and hustle him into a
Jefferson High School for Science the lottery. An Asian-American fa- not discriminatory. program for gifted students. They
education, the left tries and Technology in Fairfax County, ther, testifying before the board Yet the remedies being sought in can’t overcome every innate differ-
to end testing at schools regularly ranked the country’s top called that plan “government-spon- every case are wrongheaded. They ence or compensate for every disad-
high school by U.S. News. Thomas sored discrimination against Asians.” fiddle with the rationing system in- vantage at home. But the best of to-
it deems inequitable. Jefferson is in such demand that it Lotteries signal a sort of superfi- stead of adding to the supply of se- day’s charter schools, such as New
can accept fewer than 1 in 6 appli- cial fairness, but in practice they’re lective schools—fewer than 170 na- York’s Success Academy, show that a
cants. It’s been using its own special worse than taking every middle tionwide at last count, among more lot can be overcome.
The ruckus began in New York, exam and a “holistic” admissions school’s best students. Their effect than 20,000 U.S. high schools—or The progressive assault on educa-
where admission to nine of the city’s process that considers essays, inter- will be to encourage grade inflation ensuring that more poor and minor- tion in the name of equity ends up
hundreds of high schools is governed views and teacher recommendations across the system—to get more kids ity kids are prepared to compete for denying smart kids from every back-
by the eighth-grader’ scores on a as well as grades and test scores. into the “pool”—and favor students entry. ground the kind of education that
specialized admission test. Topping Thomas Jefferson’s minders have who may be ill-prepared or indiffer- Achievement gaps are widespread will assist them to make the most of
the list are Stuyvesant and Bronx tried various strategies to bring in ent over hundreds who yearn for the across America among kids from dif- their abilities. That denies America
Science, and there’s no denying that more pupils of color but none has opportunity, many of them Asian- ferent backgrounds. On the National human capital for a robust economy,
they’re full of Asian and white kids, worked very well. Among the 486 Americans from low- or middle-in- Assessment of Educational Progress, while keeping a fraught society from
many from low-income and middle- students in the most recently admit- come families bent on getting their 13% of white eighth-grade students producing the opportunities that al-
class families. This has raised hack- ted class, fewer than 25 were black children the best possible education. reached the “advanced” level in low true equity to flourish.
les for decades, but Mayor Bill de or Hispanic—and few were low-in- Much the same thing is happening math last year, as did 31% of Asian
Blasio and his schools chancellor come. elsewhere, including Boston (Boston kids, compared with only 2% and 4% Mr. Finn is president emeritus of
have recently pushed to make the The Fairfax County superintend- Latin School), Philadelphia (Central of black and Hispanic children. Stu- the Thomas B. Fordham Institute
admissions process more “equita- ent and board last month moved to High School), San Francisco (Lowell dents who aren’t doing advanced and a senior fellow at Stanford’s
ble.” They want to reserve places for abolish the qualification exam and High School) and Washington (Duke math by the end of middle school Hoover Institution.
M
ects. Thanks to them, the prover- pandemic is now worse than it was gage-backed securities under quan- protective equipment. State and lo-
ajority Leader Mitch bial light at the end of the tunnel then. Yet Mr. McConnell is a road- titative easing. Another is moving cal governments, which are on the
McConnell sent the Senate is dimly visible. But only dimly. block to more relief funds. those purchases out to longer ma- front lines in the battle against the
home for recess without Widespread vaccination is many Remember, it was Cares, plus a turities. The Fed may and should virus, urgently need several hun-
passing a new coronavirus relief months away. As Yogi Berra might few other laws, plus rapid actions do both. But no one should seri- dred billion dollars in federal aid.
bill. Treasury Secretary Steven have said, this horror show “ain’t by the Fed, that enabled the econ- ously think such policies will have They must balance their budgets
Mnuchin has said he will pull the over.” omy to make what looks like a V- large effects on the economy. even as they shoulder huge new
plug on several of the Federal Re- When Congress passed the Cares shaped recovery—so far. The ex- costs for health care, school safety,
serve’s emergency lending facilities. Act in March, the pandemic looked pected tsunami of bankruptcies security and more—and watch their
What are these men thinking? absolutely frightening. The act was hasn’t materialized—so far. It even The economy can’t wait tax receipts wither.
Yes, the recent news on the vac- a sloppy piece of legislation with looks possible—so far—that the With light now showing at the
cine front is wonderful. We are all many flaws. But it had two huge feared scarring of both workers until January for more end of the tunnel, it makes sense to
indebted to the scientists who have virtues: It was big, and it came and businesses may be limited. help for states, businesses help small businesses survive with
worked so long, hard and success- fast, both of which helped pull the Senators and the public need to more grants and soft loans. Econo-
understand that it was Cares and and the unemployed. mists generally view bankruptcy as
the rest that propped up the econ- a normal and necessary part of
omy “artificially” as the virus was capitalism. But most of the small
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY pulling it down. But now, with Another option would be switch- businesses now on the brink didn’t
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Executive Chairman, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp
Covid-19 raging uncontrolled, most ing to yield-curve control, as prac- get there through poor business de-
Matt Murray Almar Latour
of the Cares money has been spent ticed in Japan. That means replac- cisions.
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher and more will expire in late Decem- ing QE with pegging the yield on Last but certainly not least, tens
Neal Lipschutz Karen Miller Pensiero DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: ber; the Centers for Disease Control one or more Treasury maturities of millions of Americans need a
Deputy Editor in Chief Managing Editor Ramin Beheshti, Chief Technology Officer; and Prevention moratorium on for a while. I’m sympathetic. But lifeline. It isn’t prosperous, white-
Jason Anders, Chief News Editor; Louise Story, Chief Kamilah Mitchell-Thomas, Chief People Officer; evictions will end Dec. 31; and again, how much effect can yield- collar workers like me—and proba-
News Strategist, Product & Technology Officer Edward Roussel, Chief Innovation Officer; Treasury intends to end its lending curve control have when yields on bly you, dear reader—who need
Thorold Barker, Europe; Elena Cherney, Coverage; Christina Van Tassell, Chief Financial Officer
facilities by the end of the year as long-term Treasurys are already so help. It’s society’s underdogs: the
Andrew Dowell, Asia; Anthony Galloway, Video &
Audio; Brent Jones, Culture, Training & Outreach; well. low? Will U.S. borrowing rates go unemployed, people of color, the
OPERATING EXECUTIVES:
Alex Martin, Print & Writing; Michael W. Miller, Jason P. Conti, General Counsel; Americans are suffering from the negative? I doubt it. poor and so on.
Features & Weekend; Emma Moody, Standards; Frank Filippo, Print Products & Services; tragic results of the Trump admin- So it’s up to Congress and what’s These folks have pretty straight-
Shazna Nessa, Visuals; Matthew Rose,
Enterprise; Michael Siconolfi, Investigations;
Kristin Heitmann, Chief Commercial Officer; istration’s malign neglect of the vi- left of the Trump administration. forward needs: cash income, food,
Stephen Wisnefski, Professional News
Nancy McNeill, Corporate Sales; rus. Will we now have to suffer They should be working overtime shelter and health care. The federal
Thomas San Filippo, Customer Service; from malign neglect of the econ- on a compromise fiscal package in government knows how to provide
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large Josh Stinchcomb, Advertising Sales;
Paul A. Gigot, Editor of the Editorial Page;
omy? Don’t think the Federal Re- the range of, say, $1 trillion to $2 these things. If it fails, the light at
Suzi Watford, Chief Marketing Officer;
Daniel Henninger, Deputy Editor, Editorial Page Jonathan Wright, International
serve can ride to the rescue if Con- trillion. As Jason Furman recently the end of the tunnel may prove to
gress fails. Not because the Fed argued on these pages, the econ- be an oncoming freight train.
WALL STREET JOURNAL MANAGEMENT:
Joseph B. Vincent, Operations; Professional Information Business: doesn’t want to help. But because omy can’t wait until the Biden ad-
Larry L. Hoffman, Production Ingrid Verschuren, Deputy Head there isn’t much more it can do. ministration takes office. Mr. Blinder, a professor of eco-
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS: Think about the additional policy The package should have many nomics and public affairs at Prince-
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 measures that have been men- components. Most obviously, the ton, served as vice chairman of the
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES
tioned. One is increasing purchases country is still short on critical Federal Reserve, 1994-96.
A16 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
that some local authorities are ily-planning policies in western latory authorization and gear ary, when it hopes interim re-
quietly allowing families to Beijing said parents having up distribution plans for wide- sults from ongoing trials in the
have a third child without the more than two children won’t spread vaccination. country will be available.
usual repercussions. be punished in his district, un- Chinese vaccine makers Indonesian authorities are
China’s leaders, including Zhang Yiqiu and her family in Beijing this year. less they are state employees. kicked off late-stage clinical
President Xi Jinping, have said For those working in the public trials in July, around the same
they are concerned about the second in 2016, the first year one eye closed,’ ” she said. sector, there will still be conse- time as Western vaccine devel-
country’s demographic trajec- of the two-child policy. Preg- No local government will quences, the official said. opers Pfizer Inc. and Moderna
Indonesia is holding
tory. Abolishing the one-child nant again in 2018, “I wasn’t openly acknowledge that it is Many former family-plan- Inc. One reason China is hav- back approval
policy in 2016 to let all cou- clear about the policies and I allowing third children. And in ning officials want to hang on ing to wait longer for results,
ples have two children did didn’t ask,” said Ms. Zhang, many places, restrictions con- to some version of restrictions. public health experts say, is
because of a lack of
next to nothing for China’s who sells baby products online. tinue to be strictly enforced. Even if it scraps birth limits, that the countries where Chi- clinical evidence.
sagging birthrate. A once-a- She said that after the birth, “Birth policy in China is in a China may not be able to allevi- nese researchers sought out
decade census this year is local Beijing officials told her logjam now,” said Wang Feng, ate its demographic bind, econ- volunteers—in places such as
likely to show that the number they didn’t have the bandwidth a sociology professor at the omists and demographers say. the United Arab Emirates and
of babies being born is far to pursue her birth violation. University of California, Irvine. Demographic challenges Brazil—haven’t seen Covid-19 looking to follow the U.A.E. by
from making up for the rapid Some other parents of more The National Health Com- mean China’s underlying po- spread as quickly of late as it approving Chinese vaccines
aging of the workforce. than two children say they mission, which supervises how tential economic growth rate has in the U.S., which is the for emergency use.
Even so, leaders have given have also gone penalty-free. birth policies are handled is likely to slow to about 5.5% key testing ground for leading Sinovac’s late-stage trials
no indication they are ready to A 30-year-old stay-at-home across China, didn’t respond over the next five years from Western vaccine makers. are also under way in Bra-
scrap birth restrictions, though mother in Yangzhou in south- to requests to comment. around 6.2% over the 2016-20 Trials need to accumulate a zil. Researchers helping run
the Communist Party’s latest eastern China—who wanted to Rising living costs, especially period, wrote Cai Fang, deputy certain number of infection that trial say they now have 74
five-year plan talks of improv- be identified only by her sur- high home prices, have de- chief of the Chinese Academy cases before researchers can confirmed Covid-19 cases
ing birth policy. Meanwhile, name, You—had three children terred young Chinese, most of of Social Sciences, a top gov- justify revealing which partici- among participants, enough to
parents like Ms. Zhang aren’t in four years and is pregnant whom grew up as only children, ernment think tank, in an es- pants received vaccines versus do an interim analysis, and
quite sure what to expect. with her fourth. She said offi- from having a second child, let say this week. He called for a placebo to calculate efficacy that they are likely to release
She had prayed for children cials haven’t come after her. alone four. Ms. You said most of change in birth policies and rates. early results in December.
at Buddhist temples and had “I think they are adopting her friends can’t fathom her de- “family-based decision-making “China has said it would Chinese vaccine developers
her first child in 2013 and her an attitude of ‘one eye open, sire to have so many children. on births” as soon as possible. make its vaccine a global public have had to go abroad to con-
good but we need details and duct clinical trials because
WORLD WATCH
accountability,” says Peter May- Covid-19 has been mostly un-
barduk, director at nonprofit der control within China for
consumer advocacy group Pub- months. Their Western rivals
lic Citizen in Washington, D.C. are running clinical trials
MEXICO dering charges. The ex-minister, IRAN SOUTH KOREA Chinese authorities didn’t abroad too, although they
Gen. Salvador Cienfuegos, was wait for late-stage clinical re- have recruited tens of thou-
Suspect Arrested in released this month after Mex- Western Academic Recovery on Track sults to begin vaccinations sands of volunteers in the U.S.
Killing of Americans ico vigorously complained that it Freed After 2 Years Despite Covid Surge outside of trials. They have in- and U.K. Chinese researchers
hadn’t been advised of the in- oculated nearly one million have been shut out from such
Mexican security forces cap- vestigation and said it would re- Iran released a British-Austra- A jump in Covid-19 cases Chinese people with shots by places amid rising tensions be-
tured the alleged mastermind of view and revise its security co- lian academic imprisoned on espi- won’t knock South Korea’s eco- state-owned Sinopharm, with- tween Beijing and the West.
the massacre of nine members operation with the U.S. onage charges, ending an ordeal nomic recovery off track, the
of a breakaway Mexican-Ameri- Officials said 17 people have that lasted more than two years country’s central bank said.
can Mormon community a year been arrested in connection with and strained diplomatic ties. The Bank of Korea on Thurs-
ago, an attack that shocked the the November 2019 massacre, in Australian Prime Minister day forecast the economy would
U.S. and Mexico and strained bi- which six women and three chil- Scott Morrison said the govern- contract 1.1% this year, an im-
WU YILU/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES
lateral relations. dren were killed. Authorities say ment had been informed late provement on its earlier expecta-
The suspect was identified by the attackers belong to La Línea, Wednesday of the release of tion for a 1.3% drop.
a senior official as Roberto an armed wing of the Juárez Kylie Moore-Gilbert, a specialist The brighter outlook came as
González, who is known as “The cartel known for its hyperviolent in Middle Eastern politics at the the country recorded its highest
32” and is considered one of the tactics. The motive behind the University of Melbourne. number of daily coronavirus
chieftains of Mexican gang La killing isn’t clear yet as the in- He declined to say whether it cases since March 1. The rise in
Línea. Authorities said the sus- vestigation continues, a Mexican was part of a prisoner swap. infections was factored in, the
pect was arrested this week prosecutor said. Dr. Moore-Gilbert was ar- bank said. The bank said it ex-
with two other members of his Julián LeBarón, whose rela- rested at Tehran airport in Sep- pects the recovery to continue
gang in the state of Chihuahua. tive Rhonita Miller and her four tember 2018 as she prepared to into the end of the year as
The arrest comes after rela- children were killed in the attack, leave the country following a strong overseas demand for
tions were strained by the re- said he believes without U.S. conference. She was tried, con- South Korea’s tech goods and in-
cent U.S. detention of a former pressure, Mexico wouldn’t have victed and sentenced to 10 creasing industrial investment
Mexican defense minister on detained a single suspect. years in prison. continue to pull up the economy. China began giving vaccinations without waiting for the results
drug trafficking and money-laun- —José de Córdoba —David Winning —Eun-Young Jeong of late-stage clinical Covid-19 vaccine tests.
TECHNOLOGY: AMAZON WEB SERVICES HIT BY OUTAGE B4
DJ TRANS Closed
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
tine in recent years, while has retailers worried about month ventory constraints for some safety practices meant to pro- Walt Disney Co. plans to lay
many shoppers are seeking so- new restrictions that could products are expected to pose tect store employees and reas- off a total of 32,000 employees
cially distanced ways to discourage store trips. challenges, executives said. sure customers. by March, the company said, a
browse and buy. Executives at On Tuesday, American Ea- “Much uncertainty still re- Consumer spending in the further reduction in its work-
retail chains believe they are gle Outfitters Inc. executives quarter, which includes this mains around the depth and U.S. rose 0.5% in October, the force that comes as the pan-
nevertheless poised to reach said coronavirus hot spots month and December, will slow duration of the pandemic as sixth straight monthly in- demic hits the entertainment
consumers, even if surging were having an effect on visits compared with recent demand well as economic impacts of Please turn to page B10 company’s theme-park busi-
Covid-19 cases may result in to its shops. Gap Inc. warned levels. sustained high unemployment nesses especially hard.
weaker store visits and esca- that the recent jump in coro- “Our historically largest vol- rates,” Corie Barry, Best Buy’s Heard on the Street: Covid-19 The number of layoffs is
lating digital orders. navirus cases was a concern, ume weeks are ahead, and we chief executive, said. won’t steal Christmas........ B12 about 4,000 more employees
than the 28,000 job cuts an-
nounced in September. Most of
the job losses will come in the
company’s theme-park ranks,
where thousands of workers
have already been furloughed
or laid off.
The severe cuts to Disney’s
theme-park division accentu-
ates a new reality at the com-
pany since the pandemic can-
celed most live entertainment.
Once a reliable moneymaker,
the Disney theme parks are now
either operating at reduced ca-
pacity or closed altogether, with
one location—Disneyland in
Anaheim, Calif.—not expected
to reopen until at least next
year.
That has forced Disney exec-
utives to reorganize the com-
pany and shift focus toward its
year-old streaming service, Dis-
ney+. The service’s success in
finding early subscribers has
REBECCA DROKE FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
INSIDE
Exxon Mobil Corp. has low- Brent West Texas lowered that forecast to be-
Intermediate
ered its outlook on oil prices $70 tween $50 and $55 a barrel for
for much of the next decade, the next five years, before
according to internal company eventually topping out at $60
60
documents reviewed by The a barrel in 2026 and 2027, ac-
Wall Street Journal. cording to the documents,
As part of an internal finan- 50 which were dated September.
Lauren Hobart, in 2019, is the new CEO of Dick’s Sporting Goods. cial-planning process con- Brent oil is currently trad-
ducted this fall, Exxon cut its 40 ing for about $47 a barrel af-
A
Amazon.com ............... B4
Ascena Retail Group...B2
Highgate Hotels ......... A2
Honeywell...................A7
Hormel Foods ............. A1
S
Salesforce.com ........... A1
Shanxi Antai Group..B11
Ann Taylor, Sister Brands Draw Bid
AT&T............................B4 I Slack Technologies.....A1 BY ANDREW SCURRIA sold its Justice and Catherines closing all its stores in March, its store count, exit Canada,
B Iberdrola....................B12 Sleepnet......................A7 brands out of bankruptcy as reducing capital expenditures Puerto Rico and Mexico, and fo-
Suburban Propane
Barclays.....................B11 J Partners....................B3
Sycamore Partners has online-only businesses. and assessing vendor-payment cus more on e-commerce.
Best Buy................B1,B5 agreed to pay $540 million to Permanent closures of retail terms. The retailer entered chapter
J.C. Penney..................B2 Sycamore Partners.....B2
BlackRock..................B11 buy Ann Taylor, Lane Bryant stores in the country hit a re- Ann Taylor, the company’s 11 with support from the bulk
J.Crew..........................B5
Boeing....................A2,B1 T
Burger King.................A1
JD.com.......................B11 and other store brands from cord in the first half of 2020 as flagship chain, was once a re- of its senior lenders, which had
Telia.............................B5
K Ascena Retail Group Inc., the pandemic lockdowns and shop- tailing bellwether, selling many agreed to a roughly $1 billion
C ThermoPore Materials
Kellogg........................A1 .....................................A7
brands’ bankrupt parent com- pers’ fear of disease curbed women their first suits as they debt-for-equity swap that
China Evergrande......B11
Kohl's...........................B1 3M...............................A7 pany said Thursday. foot traffic, pushing Ascena and entered the workforce. The re- would hand them a controlling
China Resources Land
...................................B11 L TJX.............................B10 The proposed deal would dozens of other retailers into tailer tried for years to manage stake in the company.
Citigroup......................B5 Lloyds Banking Group Toys “R” Us .............. B12 also deliver the Loft and Lou & bankruptcy. the shift to casual dressing, The lenders have instead
Clorox .......................... B5 ...................................B11 U-V Grey brands to Sycamore, sub- Some, such as Brooks Broth- launching the Loft brand in agreed to support the proposed
CVS Health..................B1
M UGI...............................B3 ject to approval from the ers Group Inc. and J.C. Penney 1998, but never recaptured its sale to Sycamore and an agreed
D Unibail-Rodamco- bankruptcy court where As- Co., found buyers. Others in- former glory. framework for divvying up the
Microsoft .................... A1
Deere...........................B2 Westfield................B12 cena filed for chapter 11 pro- cluding Neiman Marcus Group Last year, Ascena wound proceeds, according to court
N United Parcel Service.B5 tection in July. Inc. and J.Crew Group Inc. down its Dressbarn business, papers. “Ann Taylor, Loft, Lane
Delta Air Lines ........... B2
Deutsche Bank............A1 Nordstrom.................B10 Vlocity.........................A7 Ascena said Sycamore “has handed themselves over to with more than 650 retail Bryant and Lou & Grey are
E O W committed to retaining a sub- lenders. A few, like discount re- stores, to eliminate debt while well-known brands, each with
Enel............................B12 Outdoor Research.......A7 Walmart......................A1 stantial portion of the retail tailer Stage Stores Inc. and selling Dressbarn’s e-commerce passionate associates and loyal
Ernst & Young...........B10 R Walt Disney................B1 stores and associates” affili- women’s brand New York & Co., rights for about $5 million. customers,” said Sycamore
Exxon Mobil................B1 Radio Shack .............. B12 Wirecard....................B10 ated with the brands it is buy- simply had to liquidate. Following the bankruptcy fil- managing director Stefan Ka-
F-H Repsol........................B11 Y ing. As of late August, Ascena Before filing for chapter 11, ing, Ascena said it would shut luzny, a veteran retail deal
Facebook......................B5 Rite Aid.......................B1 Yongcheng Coal & operated 1,500 stores through- Ascena tried several steps to some Ann Taylor, Loft, Lane maker.
Ferrellgas Partners.....B3 Roku ............................ B4 Electricity................B11 out the U.S. soften the pandemic’s financial Bryant and Lou & Grey loca- —Aisha Al-Muslim
The company has already impact, including temporarily tions with the aim of reducing contributed to this article.
INDEX TO PEOPLE
A K R
Ahmed, Salman..........A2 Kaluzny, Stefan .......... B2 Riley, David.................A2
B Kilar, Jason ................. B4 Roth, Peter..................B4
Kosasa, Paul...............A2
Bauer, Daniel ............ B10 S
Kruger, Joel...............B11
Benioff, Marc..............A1 Sanders, Kelly.............A2
L
Bloys, Casey................B4 Sewing, Christian.......A8
Lange, Will..................A7
Bressler, Léon...........B12 Skaff, Robert..............A7
Laughter, John............B2
Butterfield, Stewart...A7 Stankey, John.............B4
Layson, Keith..............A7
D Little, Joe..................B11 T
DenHartog, Emiel.......A7 Littleton, Stephen......B2 Thill, Brent..................A7
Dufossé, Nadège.......B11 M-P Tsui, Frank.................B11
F McMillon, Doug.........B12 W
Fornasari, Francesca...A2 Milam, Ken ................. A7 Woods, Darren............B2
Mueller-Glissmann,
J Christian...................A2 Z
Exxon Is
Pessimistic SAVE
On Pricing $
100
Reg. $29999 | SALE $19999
LUKE MACGREGOR/BLOOMBERG NEWS
Exxon evaluates capital invest- much as 15% of its global work- natural-gas assets valued at as prices were to remain around
ment over a decadeslong time force, which would total about much as $30 billion, but said $50 a barrel for years, a sce-
horizon, and that the corona- 14,000 jobs including contract that doesn’t indicate changes to nario Mr. Woods then called
virus hadn’t changed its long- employees. Exxon also said it its long-term price views. In re- unlikely, Exxon’s debt levels
term view. Exxon hasn’t can- would reduce its capital budget cent decades, the company has would still be manageable. Great Sound. Made Simple.
celed any projects because of to between $16 billion and $19 seldom written down the value “I would also tell you, if we 866-367-9869
the pandemic, only delayed billion next year. of any assets. Executives have found ourselves in this un- 60-Day Home Trial | Free Shipping
them, he said. Even with those cuts, Exxon for years argued that the com- precedented environment for ® ZVOX & AccuVoice are registered trademarks of ZVOX Audio.
“The fundamentals haven’t would need oil prices to be be- pany is extremely conservative five years, we would change ORDER THE AV157 AT ZVOX.COM
changed; the only thing that tween $55 and $65 a barrel in with its investment decisions, our plans,” Mr. Woods said.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | B3
BUSINESS NEWS
LEARNING EVENTS
Curriculum focused on Join the new Facilitated discussions,
purpose-based leadership
and inclusion
purpose-driven Fortune-moderated editorial
conversations with experts
leadership and provocateurs, and
CONTENT group coaching sessions
Fortune Conferences community
COMMUNITY
on demand and executive
sessions with CEOs from Fortune. Peer-to-peer networking,
brainstorming,
FORTUNE.COM/ and meetups
CONNECT
PHIL CARUSO/HBO
broader than what HBO would In reality, Max is trying to but they can’t price HBO Max age. A Roku spokeswoman said
do,” Ms. Aubrey said. be both. Subscribers receive competitively without under- users could still stream con-
“The Flight Attendant” is not only HBO content but also mining their traditional HBO tent. Insteon, which sells prod-
WarnerMedia’s latest hope to Max originals and a vast li- business,” said analyst Craig ucts for homes like thermo-
draw new viewers to HBO Max brary of movies and TV shows Kaley Cuoco portrays the title character in ‘The Flight Attendant.’ Moffett, of MoffettNathanson. stats and fan controllers, said
or prompt those with existing from Warner Bros. and else- An HBO Max spokesman in a tweet that Alexa voice
HBO accounts to switch over where, as well as children’s wants to make sure HBO fans shows aimed at younger view- said the service is already commands for one of its hub
to the service, which doesn’t content. and the talent community know ers such as reboots of “Gossip ahead of the subscriber pro- systems may fail because of
require a cable TV package. In an interview, Mr. Bloys the service and its distinctive Girl” and “Pretty Little Liars” jections it made to analysts in the outage.
Episodes of “The Flight Atten- said as consumers continue to and critically acclaimed shows and creating content from 2019. Executives have targeted The Chicago Tribune said in
dant” won’t appear on tradi- cut the cord from traditional won’t be swallowed up by Max. Warner Bros.’ DC Comics su- 50 million combined custom- a tweet it would post news up-
tional HBO channels. pay-TV packages, the $14.99-a- “HBO is healthy and funded perhero characters including ers for HBO and HBO Max by dates to social-media sites be-
HBO Max, which includes month Max serves as its own and its future is secure within “Green Lantern” and “Peace- 2025. cause it is “experiencing inter-
all HBO programming plus stand-alone bundle to keep Max,” he said. maker.” Mr. Bloys said Max “The Flight Attendant” was mittent issues with our
new originals and popular HBO healthy as well as a plat- Known for being a talent will be able to spend more on set to debut when HBO Max website and publishing system
older shows and movies, form for all the other Warner whisperer, Mr. Bloys plans to the DC shows than its sister launched in May, but produc- because of the AWS outage.”
launched with great fanfare in Bros. properties, including fea- bring the same nurturing ap- CW network has in previous tion stopped in March and Operations at The Wall Street
May. But it has signed up only ture films. proach to Max so it’s not seen incarnations. didn’t resume until August be- Journal were affected.
8.6 million subscribers so far. The highly anticipated War- as a soulless content factory. “We’re going to produce cause of the coronavirus. Cloud-computing services
WarnerMedia executives say ner Bros. movie “Wonder “I want to deploy the culture those at a scale similar to “Luckily, we got most of the have become more pivotal dur-
initial confusion between the Woman 1984” will debut in of putting talent first across `Westworld,’” Mr. Bloys said, airport scenes completed early ing the coronavirus pandemic
new service and other HBO theaters and on Max at the the organization,” he said. referring to the expensive HBO on,” said Ms. Cuoco. When the as many companies have em-
online platforms, such as the same time this Christmas. HBO is considered the most drama. show resumed production it braced remote hardware and
now-retired HBO Go and HBO While the rollout is happening talent-friendly programmer in “The Flight Attendant” is had to build sets that resem- software services to allow em-
Now, likely slowed sign-ups. out of necessity—the movie the industry, due to both its generating warm reviews for bled some of the location ployees to work from home.
For Max, as it is known in- theater business remains in large programming budget and its stylish look and Hitchcock- shots and relied on a small Amazon, on its cloud-com-
ternally, buzz has been sorely shambles because of Covid-19— collaboration with producers like pacing. Ms. Cuoco is being group of extras for crowd puter site, had earlier said a
lacking. The service planned to it’s also expected to help Max and cast on marketing and praised for her semi-comic, scenes. “If you look closely, programming interface for its
kick off with a “Friends” cast attract new customers. awards campaigns. semi-tragic portrayal of an al- you might see a few over and Kinesis Data Streams product
reunion to complement reruns At the same time, Mr. Bloys The priorities for Max are coholic spiraling out of con- over again,” she said. was impaired.
©2020 Dow Jones & Co. Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ8182
Bull
or
Bear.
Boom
or
Bust.
There for you from 100
to 30000—and beyond.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | B5
BUSINESS NEWS
10
Number of women CEOs of
In a survey of more than
40,000 North American em-
ployees this summer, research-
ers at McKinsey & Co. and Lea-
It isn’t the first problem
Facebook has discovered in its
systems to measure advertis-
ers’ campaigns, and it isn’t
done and make sure it doesn’t
happen again.
“If there is no governance
or third neutral party looking
comes more difficult to justify
spending dollars when clients
are trying to manage their costs
as effectively as possible—and
The Wall Street Journal.
Facebook, which said it
fixed the error in September,
told advertisers about it this
Fortune 500 retail chains nIn.org found one in four likely to dent Facebook’s ad at our investment tools, I can’t media spend is a cost that month, according to a memo
women were considering leav- revenue. sleep well at night and my cli- needs to generate revenue.” that Facebook sent clients.
ing or downshifting their ca-
reers because of the work-life
world to put women into roles crunch, compared with one in Walt Disney’s employee count
where they gain the broad op- five men.
225 thousand
erating experience needed to Meanwhile, companies have
advance to the highest eche- indicated a more cautious ap- 200
lons. Joining Dick’s Sporting proach to changes at the helm 203,000*
Goods in 2011 as chief market- in the initial months of the 175
ing officer, Ms. Hobart was a pandemic. A new report from
driver in the launch of one of executive-recruitment firm 150
155,000
the retailer’s top private labels, Heidrick & Struggles shows 125 Parks,
Calia by Carrie Underwood. that between March 11 and
Experiences
dog•ged FROM
/'dôg d/
adjective
YOUR TABLE
TO THEIRS
Despite spending my early life in a shelter, there’s no dog more
determined than me. Thanks to the National Disaster Search Dog
Foundation, if you’re ever trapped under rubble after a disaster,
I’ll find you. That’s my job, and what I was born to do. You’ll never find
a dog more dogged.
Victor
Active Search Dog
Rescued from Redding, CA.
Photographed by Shaina Fishman
at SDF’s National Training Center.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Marketplace
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
+ 4*, H$ <</??H'!
!!<" '$ H!!!!!
H? <</??H
?
!!<" '? !!!!!!
1 2" & 3 )&4"& * " %&
,
(
H/ <</??J
?
!!<" '? %!!!!!
>+ #& #=+ #* #&
? %! <</??M'?
!!<"# '$ !!!!!!
- )- 5"!%&- & & & &
O 2) 2
)1)*
. &34
%
%
<</??M
<
<%%#<
<
!!<"# '? #%!!!!
!!<
H!!!
! "
$% 5&+& 2" & & 6& 7& 3' !$?H% / 5 J !!<" #!!!!!! M
'/
/#/%! !!%" H!!!!!! %# $##<($ !!%"< 'H HH!!!
3
!!<" %H $H//'? !!<" '# %!!!!!
#$%&&$%'&
3 8& 76- $%!% 6& 9" + # <HH
?
! 5
H !$# HA # 5A !!<" 5
!!!!!!
H!!!!!
%%
%<
$H//
$%%5H
!!<"# ' #!!!!!!
!!<"N% '/ #!<!!!
7 "*" - . & /&+ - . % <$4< '' !!%"< I !!!!!! %$ $H/ '
!!<"N< '/ !!!!!!
< %#/HH
/
!!%"
%!!!!! ' !!%"
%? $< 5JG%
'/ #$ $!!!
' !!<"
$ $#!$I J/ <<?!!! 4 !!%"
M
'? %/ $%#/!H %!!!!!
? %H%?'< 4
5 !!%"
' H!!!!!!
<! $<#<
4 '$
4 !!<"4 '? !!!!!!
/ ?<#%$<< 44 !!%"M
H '/ % $!!!
< $<#53H 4 !!<"4# '/ #!!!!!!
,
(
NOTABLE
< ?#$%M( 45 !!<" 5# <?!!!!
$%& % '(#
><
) @ #=+? <# $?%?3H 4 !!<"% 5# ??%!!!
)1)* <H ?<#%?G 4 !!%"# '? #%!!!!!
COMMERCIAL
2) 2
.
!"# O <% ?<#<!
#
44 !!<"
#!!!!!!
:;,!""" &34 N '?
<$H '' !!%"< !!!!!! << ?<#<!
< 44 !!<"M
'/ !!!!!!
<
3 .
PROPERTIES
54 !!<" <$ ?<#<< 44 !!<"M
# '/ !!!!!!
!H%HH
/
% '?
!!!!!!
5
<? ??%<3< '4 !!<"? 5H #!!!!!!
# !!HHN
/ !!<"M '? H%H!!! </ /H/$3N! M
!!<" '? #!!!!!!
H !!HH N# !!<" '/ %!!!!
% !!$!#<($ ' !!%"? 5< H!$H!!!
$! /H/$
M
!!<" '/ #!!!! EVERY WEDNESDAY
$
% %
) !& * & '&+ # < !!$!#H55< ' !!<" 5# #%$%!!! $ / /$?'<
M' !!<"
'
5#
#%</!!!
$ !H!!H 4 !!<"MH '? !!!!!!
&'()
* ? !$#?<G? 5 !!%"? 5H H# !! .6 4 )* '1- *7
+ ,""- . /+ ,"+" 6
/ !$#?<G 5 !!%"? 5% %!!!! 7 M**
1 56
)* .)) )
6
! !$#?<H% 5 !!<"# #5# #!!!!!!
5454 !!<"
) ..)+ 2 & 92: C)**
.,2.)1 2*). * 7 .) .*** LIST YOUR
PROPERTY TODAY
!$#?/' !!!!!
/ '/ *,1, 2 *** & ,9,
) C)** 77, , *, + 2
!!<"
# ,"&+
- .. 6
5 HH%#
'/
%!!!! C)2 .2 ) .0
8 )-*), )1 -, + 2
% %
5 !
&'()2 # $#!?
# ' !!%" 5# % !!!
C) . *** &8. )*
H $#!$I
?$ ' !!%"/ 5# $#<!!!
$
%
' !!%" *** C) . +
% $#!$I3/ $$<!!! )7-) ) 2B )
01
3 . 5
5 H '/
' !!<" ).*2,)1 C)2 *)-)) + 77)1 .).2* (800) 366-3975
2
< $#!/$
< 'H
#H?$!!! 9.)* )7-) (
* C)** *, %$%"5 )0), 02 sales.realestate@wsj.com
$%& & + *%# $ $#!/N
H
' !!<"
!!!!!! M !<??! ( %( (
3 ?
M
# '/
%H$!MH 4' !!<" 5# !!!!!! * ,0), * 7 . .2)+ For more information visit:
*), 0 -+ -, *+ ),,
1 =5
/
!
%H$!MN 4' !!<" 5H !!!!!!
%H$!J? 4' !!<" 5# #%%?!!!
C ) * :2*)9, ),, , -+ 2E. wsj.com/classifieds
0 *0*
,,))* )7-)
3 14
"
<#$53 4' !!<"H 5< ?$?!!! ).*2,)1 C) . :2*)9, ),, 2
<#$5J/ 4' !!<"H 5$ H#/!!!
01 5 34
# /H (A/ 4' !!<"< 5# # $/!!!
, ) .) 7 0 )
, 9,)*)+ 1- .. 0),
3
%
H /H 4' !!<"$ 5% <$!!! C* (77+ *- + -)* ,.C*K
% /H % 4' !!<"$ 5< H?/!!! ,.6..- E*-K,.6.
>2
< <<?$ M !!%"( 5 #< !!!! .- .)0*+ + & H%$"? %?
M !!<"
!"#
>2
$ ! H<!
!
<5 5
?/!!!! + 7.)-)* & H%$"? </ + -)*
,,, %$%"5 )0), 02 M
'
? # H M5 M !!<"(H 5 <H%!! !<??!
2 ) 2)F,
/ # ! $?'<
' !!<"
NOTICE OF SALE
+ 4*, H <<?5 M !!<" ' H !#!!! / %$<H##? '' !!<" ' H?!!!
H <<?5 / M !!<" '# << !!! ! %$<H##/! '' !!<" ' $#?/!!!
!8
9 ! H# <<?5'$ M !!<" 'H </ !!! %$<H##( # '' !!<" '# H#/%!!!
HH <<?5
% M !!<" '% H% /!!! %/! #'H ' ' !!<"# ' #%$<!!!
THE MARKETPLACE
"!:
; #$% %
&'( )
H% <<?5! M !!<" '< $#?!!! # %/! #
' ' !!<"# ' !!!!!
!%/%J 5
!!<" H % #H!!! H< ! H<HI$ M !!<"# ' /$?$!!! H <$H? % '4' !!%" ' %<!!!
!%/% H 5
!!$"5 $?%!!! H$ ! H<H% M !!<"# ' H$ H!!! % <$H?'# '4' !!%" ' ?%$<!!!
# <<?M M !!%"%/ #!!!!!!! H? ! H<H( M !!<"# '# /<<$ < <$H?< '4' !!%" 'H #H?%!!!
H/ ! H$? M !!<"% 'H #H#H!!! $ <$H?NH '4' !!%" '% <?!!!!
H ! %(/ M !!$"A< !!!!!! %! ! H$ < M !!<"% '% !!!!!! ? <$H?5/ '4' !!%"/ 5 </ /!!!
% #< H H? I4 !!%"< 'H %#!!!!! % ! H$'H M !!<"% '< !!!!!! / <$H?$ '4' !!%"/ 5 %!%<!!!
< #< ##HI4$ I4 !!<"% H!!!!!!! % # H# H M !!<"< 'H <<?!!! #! <$H/
$ '4' !!<" G4 'H ?<$!!!
$ H% %H
'MH '' !!%" '< %!!!!! %# # H#' M !!<"< '% H$!?!!! # <$%!AH '4' !!<"%G4 'H #$#!!!
? H% %H
? '' !!%"# $!$%!!! %H # H#
! M !!<"< '< <#/!!! # <$H?$! '4' !!<"<G #' #?#!!!
/ </%H ' !!%" / <# %% <</HM M !!<"A5 5 <%/?!!! ## <$H?3! '4' !!<" ' <$/<!!!
! <$H?3
< '4' !!<" $H!!!!! %< <</HM4# M !!<"A5 ' $$$$!!! #H <$H?34? '4' !!<" ' %%%!!!
<$%HJH '4' !!$" < !!!!!!! %$ <</H !B M !!<"A5 ' $//!!! #% <$H?3< '4' !!<" '# H ?!!!
<%%#%J'?
!!%"H H H??!!! %? %H#(% M !!<"A5H $ %$!!! #< <$H?33# '4' !!<" 'H !/!!!
# <%%#%J34%
!!<" # #%$!!! %/ %%! < 5 !!<" ' H%<!!! #$ <$H?3J '4' !!<" '% ?$%!!!
H <%%#$
!!<"# %%!!!!! <! %%! NH 5 !!<" ' <!!%!!! #? <$H?3M/ '4' !!<" '< ?$H!!!
% $%H$ !!<"N# %%!!!!! < %%! 5 !!<" '# H</!!! #/ <$H?J< '4' !!<" 5 #<%$!!!
< ??%<
! '4 !!<"% 5 !!!!!!! < %%! 4! 5 !!<" 'H H!!#!!! H! <$H?MA# '4' !!<"# ' <!?!!!
$ ?<#%?'A! !!"5< #</H <H <# %%! ? 5 !!<" '% #!$/!!! H <$H?M! '4' !!<"# ' $H<!!!
? !H! 'N 4 !!<"' %!!!!!! <H %%! 3% 5 !!<" '< #!$/!!! H <$H?GH '4' !!<"# '# %$!!!
/ $#!$IJ? ' !!%"M
'JH %??#/ <% # !%IMH
'4 !!%"? # H/##!!! H# <$H?G5 '4' !!<"# 'H /< !!!
! <<$!(! M !!<"< ' %$!#!!! << # !% 5%
4 !!<"# <?H$!!! HH <$H?G! '4' !!<"# '% %</!!!
# ! //
' !!<"
? #%!!!!! <$ #< #H# I4 !!%" 'H H%%!!! H% <$H?G? '4' !!<"# '< $$!!!
HH# ?5! 4 !!<" H/!!!!! <? #< #H% I4 !!<" ' %!!!!!! H< <$H?A '4' !!<"% ' !%$ !!!
# %/! !3J3< ' ' !!%"# ' H$!?!!! </ #< #H</ I4 !!<" ' !%H!!! H$ <$H?A3/ '4' !!<"% ' #//!!!
H %/! !JJ% ' ' !!<" %!!!!!! $! #< #H$$ I4 !!<" '# %%H!!! H? <$H?AJ$ '4' !!<"% '# ###?!!!
% <H#% JN%
!!<" 5 !!!!!!! $ #< #H?% I4 !!<" 'H ?$!!! H/ <$H?AM% '4' !!<"% 'H #!<!!!
< ?#$<%5! 45 !!<"
# #%!!!!! $ #< #H/# I4 !!<" '% <$!!! %! <$H?AG# '4' !!<"% '% %!H!!!
$ ?!%%< 44 !!<"# # %!!!!!! $# #< ##H53$ I4 !!<"# ' !!!!!! % <$H?AA '4' !!<"% '< /H$!!!
? ?H$%
H 43
!!<"5% % %!!! $H #< ##H5J% I4 !!<"# ' %!#?!!! % <$H/? '4' !!<"< 'H H % !!!
$% #< ##H
/ I4 !!<"H %!!!!!! %# <$H/3% '4' !!<"< '% #/H?!!!
$< #< ##H
# I4 !!<"H 5 #!H!!! %H <$H/J# '4' !!<"< '< ##H!!!
<
) ! *=+ $$ #< #H?< I4 !!<"? ' <#!/!!! %% <%%#%J
!
!!%"< ' $ H?!!!
; #$% %
&'( )
$? #< #H?H I4 !!<"? ' /#!/!!! %< <%%#%J33!
!!<" #' H$H#!!!
! <<!MI ' !!<" ' #%H!!! $/ #< #H?
I4 !!<"? '# /##!!! %$ <%%#%J3J?
!!<" #' #%#<!!!
! <<!M/ ' !!<" '# %!!!!! ?! #< ?
I%/ I4 !!H"#
/HH/!/! %? <%%#%J3M<
!!<" #'# % <!!!
# %H$!#% ' !!<" <' <%%%!!! ? #< #H#! I4 !!<" <% !!!! %/ ?H$%G( 43
!!<"5# '% $%!!!!
H %H$!H# ' !!<" <' # %!!! ? #< #HH<B I4 !!<" % H/%?#!!! <! /H/?#(% M
'54 !!<" < <<!!!
% %H$!$< ' !!<" 5 ?$ $!!! ?# #< #HHI I4 !!<" # H<<<!!! < /H/?#(( M
'54 !!<" 5 #<!!!!!
< !!$!#H4! ' !!<" <' <$#!!! ?H H<'/ J' !!<"H 5 $ !!!!! < /H/?#(? M
'54 !!<" 5 $!!!
$ !!$!#H? ' !!<" <' H%!!! ?% H<'
! J' !!<"% 5 %H% !!! .6 4 )* '1- *7 7 56 7
C
? !%/% % 5
!!$" < <!!! ?< H<'% J' !!<"% 5 %%/ !!! A6 '** 2 -+
)* .)) ) ) ..)+
/ !$#?<! 5 !!%"! H #!!!!! ?$ H<'N# J' !!<"% 5# //!$!!! .*** 1 & 9*** 1: C)** .,2.)1 *
! !$#?<5#H 5 !!<" ' %!!!!!! ?? H<#! J' !!<"53 ' ?%H!!! 7 .) .*** *,1, *** 1 ***
!$#?<5H 5 !!<" ' %? <!!! ?/ H% %HN$ '4 !!<" ' ?%$H!!! & ,9, ) C)** 77, , *, + *** 1
!$#?<$/ 5 !!<" ' <H< !!! /! H% %H% '4 !!<" ' /<?!!! C)2 .2 ) .0 8 )-*),
# !$#?<I$! 5 !!<" 5 #H /!!! / H% %H4# '4 !!<" '# # /?!!! )1 -, + *** 1 C) . ***
H !$#?< H 5 !!<"# /?$%!!! / H% %H '4 !!<" 'H <H/!!! &8. )* *** C) . +
% !$#?< $H 5 !!<"# # # #!$!!! /# H% %%A# '4 !!<"# <' $%!!!!! )7-) ) *** 1B ) ).*2,)1
< !$#?<#$ 5 !!<"# #5 $%!!!! /H H<< $' ? ( !!<" ' /!!!! C)2 *)-)) + 77)1 .).2* 9.)* )7-)
$ !$#?$3I$ 5454 !!<" ' %? ?!!! /% H<< ?IJ ( !!<" ' $#!!!! (
* C)** *, %$%"5 )0), 02
? !$#?$3I% 5454 !!<" ' %<$!!! /< H<< ?IM/ ( !!<" ' /H$!!! M !<??! ( %( (
* ,0),
/ !$#?$3I
5454 !!<" '# /HH!!! /$ H<< H$
# ('' !!%"? 5 %%!/%!! * 7 .2)) *), 0 -+ -, *+
! !$#?$3
# 5454 !!<"' ' H%!!!!! /? H<< H$N ('' !!<"4 G /?HH? ),, C ) * :2*)9, ),, , C)** 2E.
!$#?$3
I 5454 !!<"' ' ##!!!!! // % %
4 G4 !!%"! ' H#//!!! 0 *0*
,,))* )7-) ).*2,)1 C) .
!$#?$3
/ 5454 !!<"' '# H!!!!! !! % %
/ G4 !!%"! ' H?##!!! :2*)9, ),, 2 , ) .) 7 0
# !$H!M# 54' !!$"H $%!!!!! ! % %
3< G4 !!%"! '# #$!!! ) , 9,)*)+ 1- .. 0), C*
H <<?( M !!%"$ 5 /%#!!! ! % %
$ G4 !!%"# ' #!% !!! (77+ *- + -)* ,.C*K,.6..-
% <<?<H M !!%"? ' # !!!!! !# % % (H G4 !!<"# ' <!#!!! E*-K,.6..- .)0*+ + & H%$"
< <<?55H M !!%"?H 5 /#!!!! !H % % ( G4 !!<"# ' %# ?!!! ? %? + 7.)-)* & H%$"? </ + -)* ,,, %$%"5
$ <<?53 % M !!<"A! # /?H?!!! !% % % (
? G4 !!<"# 'H # ?!!! )0), 02 M !<??!
***
? <<?53
M !!<"A! H #%!#!!! !< % % (# G4 !!<"# '% %#H !!! 1 ) 2)F, 2. * )7 *** 1 ,- )
/ <<?53 M !!<"A! 5 $%%<!!! !$ % % H G4 !!<"% ' <<#%!!! ,0)* ) :2), + *).* *C , &) ).
#! ! H/IH M !!<"A# # %% ?!!! !? % % 5 G4 !!<"% ' <!!!!!! .)0 ),, 2. 7 0 ),)9, .2)+
# ! H<A'? M !!<"/ ' H#/!!! !/ % % ! G4 !!<"% '# !!!!!! & 9***: *, C C)** , 1
# ! H<A
< M !!<"/ '# %<#!!! ! % % < G4 !!<"% '% $$/$!!! + 2.)1 7 ) C ..2 7 )0- ,
## ! H<A M !!<"/ 'H H??!!! % %
# G4 !!<"% '< < #?!!! C) 0)C ,))2) * 7 + 7 2. &))
#H <<?5(I/ M !!<" ' %H!$!!! % % N% G4 !!<"? ' # !#!!! 0)7+ . .)9. 7 .2)+ *, *1,
#% <<?5($ M !!<" ' %%!$!!! # % % # G4 !!<"? '# /H#!!! 2)**+ 77. 2. .2)+ 1),
#< <<?5((# M !!<" '# #H!H!!! H % % 4 G4 !!<"? 'H %?$ !!! 2, 4.2)) . 7 /## -,, , -+
#$ <<?5(! M !!<" 'H /!!#!!! % % % / G4 !!<"? '% /#<!!! ,), 7 ) 0)*) 7 0)) 7 ), . &))) ,).*)-
#? <<?5( ? M !!<" '% H! !!!! < % % 3< G4 !!<"? '< /#<!!! , 72 1)0 + C+ & )* , &)0
#/ <<?5('< M !!<" '< <!#!!! $ % % #(/ G4 !!<"/ '% H#%!!! )- 2. *)-)) .,)) ) ..) C) +
H! <<?5(H M !!<" ' / /!!! ? % % #< G4 !!<"/ '< #$%/!!! 2. * *** 1 ,- .+ ,0)*
, 6 6 .
, .
.
. 6 .
. 6 7
/4 .4"4. ./@4.
"
( 2:39:97
" J)"- ==.. )( K L( *
%
=
K . ( H
!"##$% &'
( &()*+ ,-)),
@4)@ - )* -. *4 ( 4 "*(
(
69
,-+ .
+
9 +
.
.6= 6
-
> -
*
. / ! ! '0) 12 3), 4 562.+ (2,1
*
+, ,-+ .
+ 7 3), 4 562.+ 2 7 42 )). 7 8 & 92: ,
E +, !
%
!
$
!
!
$!
$
$
!
!! " #
# $%
;.6
<!!= &
/! $0 ' "$ $) !& !&1 23# "$4$## & 9>
> >
5$! ' &!" 35$&!) & ' 4$! & )$ 5"$
!
!! " #
# $%
;.6
%??= & 9*:
!" !## $%
)5$25"" ) 0&' $! ' &$5 &0 "$) - 6 !# &5#)
>
** ,.2-
!
0& $$!( &&0 &0 "$ > @@.)-.*6.-@
66
.+
6 .
+
.+ . A2 -+ * ) .) 7 + *,)1 + 0)))1 2B C) @@.78
! "!
! # 2.210 ) ..,. C) .,2 , 7 7 )
!
!
$
7-
77.)0 7 * ..2,
0- # ! !
!$ $ 4
! =
! %
>
!
%
! &! .!
%
! %
! &! !$ + *).* , 7 562.+ 2 1, + *, 7 **C, ,-))"
$
'$ #
$ #
!
! C
F !&'$#(5$/ D >
!
( "$3!)5&( * ! & 9,-)))0 *)- 5 : "#$%& "'
$())&*
&'$#( !$$) *
6 *
.
,-+ .
+ ++),% #)(& +-+ % %.)%$ +" /#% $ &%,% %.%&+ '" 0(%+ "' &1-
$())&++),% #)(&
)
*(+ "!# " $ !
%
! &! #
+-+ $" "+ /#% $ &%,% &1- %.%&+ 2 +-%
$())&++),% #)(& +% &-## 2% '"%,%
)
*(%(+ , ! -
!
!
!$ $ !
2%$ %&+"00%$ $ %3")%$ '"( &&%+)4 &1-
$())&++),% #)(& 4)&+ +-% %2+"& "
*(
)
*(+ -
@
G
! "
! $ +-%) 0"0%+ $ &1-
$())&++),% #)(& &-## 2% $%%(%$ $)&1-4%$ & "' +-% ''%1+),% +%5
! - *(+ .
)
!
!
2* C) 0),, + , 7 562.+
*(+ /
$ ! - *(+ )
;<37 " . H 677 4H 79;38 2 + 7 7 *)- , 2 E.) 7 B 8.2+ . 38),
0
!
123
$
! " >
> !"#
*
*
!
%
+ 123 *
4
!
$ !
!, $% ! >
& '
526782+ 93:7 *
!
%
+
! +
!
* , ) 0)) ),)1
99;< )$ %, *
!
%
+ 231
I
H(!( 1)F, + *, 7 *)- 1) ) , 2. *,B
.$ *
!
%
+ 231 .$ .)0 2.. , )1 1,* 7 C 2. *, & C)** .)0 + +
%
! &! 0 #
!( > )
4 5283;:+ 912 %,
*
!
@
#
%
+ 28: = *
!
%
+ !" & > & '
$
$ @
,
0- # ! ! 2 8 && ' $ (
6
555
28: = 4 52;199+ 26: "
*
!
$ %
! 0 #
$
%
+ "> - **+ 'C 021 &G 5
H!< <%< )+ ' 12 &G 5
H! $< I0)0
!
( I- &G 5
H!?%#H! J). *).6 &G 5
H!$/H? H! '.)+
*
!
%
+ -?!+ &!
$
*
!
%
+ = %
?!+
8,
,.
,-+ .
. 6 +9 4 42) /!! 2 8 $$!! * &$# $% "H !!
.)-)* &$# $% "H
ADVERTISE TODAY
*
!
%
% .
+ -9
+ -. 6 -)* -.021KEC.- 612KEC.- 11-KEC.- 0*).6KEC.- "," (2
- *
!
%
+ @
# -
$ B
!
%
! $ 421 &,-),
( 'C
1 &,-),
(
.) )
*
!
%
+ 4
! *, "!
! $
&,-),
(
7
7
<!
**+ " *
!
%
+ A
'
H # $ 8)1 02
C A6
C A6 !! * & HH<"H?!!
.)-)* & HH<"
*
!
%
+ )# *
!
#
!
$ ! $
!
$
$
@
H/!! -)* E221K6)6*,.- -C71K6)6*,.- 7.))K6)6*,
.-
)
$%
$%
(800) 366-3975
%
+ 4
! *, . "
$
!
For more information visit:
*
!
%
+ 4
! *, . ) . . *1 C) * 72 ,)1) 7 . B 7,* 8
"
*
!
%
+ @
' $
> * ++ , )' !#-("L ++ ,
4# .B = ! *(+ C
# $ @
( & @
)' !./#-L , 0 )' !(./-L , 0 !"1"-L , 0 2 )' !-31L ,
, D *
!
%
+
%,#$ , 4 !$ *
$ @
! $
$ #
4 !5-L , 6 !"-.L , 78 !"13.' 7
B 0). ,, ) ?% C 52*0, ,, 5. *)7) /! $? wsj.com/classifieds
4 ! 28231+ )
, ("( *
!( + >
4 ! )427<1+ =
# 4# /
$"$:# ) $! '$) !&$5 )'"" '/ ' !$!( ) #2!# >
'
)2336 %
**+ 4
!# '$! & $0 !& #2!# '$! '! ) ) 0&' $! ' "$) © 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
@
( +&$&! 1'$5' 5! 0&!# $! '$) 5) 6&5; < All Rights Reserved.
9& 1$)' & 5&!)" ! &! 5&!5!$!( '$)
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | B7
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
29872.47 t 173.77, or 0.58% Trailing P/E ratio 29.65 20.96 3629.65 t 5.76, or 0.16% Trailing P/E ratio * 41.34 24.16 12094.40 s 57.62, or 0.48% Trailing P/E ratio *† 37.92 25.77
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 24.58 18.52 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 25.95 18.93 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 31.45 22.65
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.05 2.21 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.65 1.87 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.74 0.98
All-time high 30046.24, 11/24/20 All-time high 3635.41, 11/24/20 All-time high: 12094.40, 11/25/20
Close Open
t
4.00% t 5 Yen
s
Get real-time U.S. stock quotes and track most-active stocks, new highs/lows and mutual funds. Available free at WSJMarkets.com
B8 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Pressure
Mounts on
Stocks Slip in Europe, Gain in Asia
Spanish energy firm world economy to reopen and economy is on course to record between the current situation LMAX Group.
JD Health IPO
deadline earlier this month to Initial public offerings and
repay 1 billion yuan, equivalent other new listings in Hong Kong
to $152 million, in 270-day
$60 billion
commercial paper that ma-
tured Nov. 10, after having sold
new debt just weeks earlier.
The company had also trans-
ferred some assets, including
Adds to Banner As of Nov. 25
and the main underwriters of the EU on future banking reg- for the contract that had an engineered the windfall won’t Recently, with inflation
its commercial paper said in ulations. estimated value of €550,000, be getting a Wall Street-style stuck around zero, some ana-
regulatory filings that all 31 “An application by a com- according to the ombudsman’s bonus, and some have even lysts are questioning whether
holders of the debt have pany to carry out a study report. started saying he shouldn’t the program is doing much
agreed on a repayment plan. meant to feed into policy that While the ombudsman rec- play the market so much. good—especially during a pan-
The company, whose parent is will regulate that company’s ommended updating the con- That is because the hot-hit- demic, when other factors are
owned by the Henan provincial business interests should have flict-of-interest guidance, her ting portfolio manager is Gov. weighing on the psychology of
government, said it would re- resulted in significantly more report said awarding the con- Haruhiko Kuroda, head of consumers and businesses.
pay half of the 1 billion yuan to critical scrutiny by the Com- tract didn’t rise to the level of Japan’s central bank. Mr. Also, the central bank now
creditors and roll over the rest mission,” said European Om- maladministration, or wrong- Kuroda has led the Bank of owns more than 6% of the to-
for another 270 days. budsman Emily O’Reilly, an The EU’s Emily O’Reilly doing, by the commission. Japan’s push, unusual among tal value of the Tokyo stock
The 4.39% interest rate on oversight officer. A spokesperson for the Eu- global central banks, to invest market, leading some to won-
the debt will remain un- She urged the commission management. ropean Commission said Ms. in the Tokyo stock market. der whether the premier sym-
changed during the extension to update its guidance over “The European Commission O’Reilly’s report confirmed In March, he doubled the bol of capitalism could be un-
period, and repayment of the hiring contractors with poten- has already publicly stated they “applied the rules fully BOJ’s annual ceiling for its dermined by state influence.
rest of the principal and inter- tial conflicts of interest that that the technical quality of and fairly,” but they will study purchases of exchange-traded NLI Research Institute
est will be done in a lump sum. could affect their work and FMA’s [BlackRock’s financial the suggestions and reply to funds to the equivalent of $115 strategist Shingo Ide said the
The company still has li- forwarded her report to law- markets advisory unit] pro- the ombudsman’s office by the billion. That was the month central bank’s outsize role
quidity problems. Yongcheng makers in the European Parlia- posal was the basis for their deadline of the end of March the stock market began surg- could hurt corporate gover-
Coal separately said earlier ment. The ombudsman investi- decision in awarding the man- next year. ing after a pandemic-induced nance because it can’t act like
this week that it wasn’t able to gates potential malpractice in date,” said BlackRock spokes- “The Commission is com- dip. It closed Thursday at a other shareholders in moni-
repay two other short-term EU institutions, but the office’ man Marc Bubeck. “FMA has mitted to transparency,” the 29-year high, up 60% from this toring company strategy.
debt issues totaling 2 billion s findings have no binding taken a wide-ranging and in- spokesperson said. “It is in year’s low. “Because such a large unre-
yuan that recently matured. power. clusive approach, including ac- this spirit that the Commis- The superb timing helped alized profit means the bank’s
The company said the corona- In early March, the Euro- ademia, civil society, banks, sion will shortly publish Black- the central bank report a re- holdings are also getting bigger
virus pandemic has taken a pean Commission hired a supervisors and market practi- Rock’s interim report, once cord jump for a six-month pe- and bigger, there will likely be
negative toll on its business BlackRock arm to prepare a tioners, and looks forward to submitted by the contractor.” riod in its stock portfolio’s more demand from outside the
operations and that it has had technical analysis on how to completing its work and deliv- The ombudsman report gains when it released its semi- BOJ to sell the stocks or start
difficulties raising funds in the create a regulatory framework ering its final report to the comes in response to three annual financial report Thurs- thinking about an exit policy,”
bond market. that would account for envi- Commission.” complaints from a coalition day. It said the market value of said Naomi Muguruma, an
Chang Li, a Beijing-based di- ronmental and social risks for The ombudsman’s decision led by the nonprofit Change its holdings stood at the equiv- economist at Mitsubishi UFJ
rector at S&P Global Ratings, banks. BlackRock counts banks report highlighted two areas Finance and two members of alent of nearly $400 billion as Morgan Stanley Securities.
said he expects regulators to among its clients. of concern—that BlackRock the European Parliament. of Sept. 30, which represented Mr. Kuroda said last week
take further steps to address The company’s financial has a financial interest in de- Damien Carême, one of the an unrealized profit of $56 bil- that he wasn’t thinking of any
investor concerns on informa- markets advisory arm, which is velopments in the market it European Parliament members lion over what it paid. quick changes in the program.
tion disclosure and poor gover- different from its asset-man- was being hired to advise on, who lodged a complaint, said Six months earlier, the BOJ Still, there are signs a re-
nance at companies, including agement arm, has worked with and that BlackRock was able he and other colleagues in the had barely any unrealized think is in its early stages. One
state-owned enterprises, as various governments on poli- to underbid other companies. Greens alliance sent a second profit left, and at one point in of the bank’s nine policy board
market confidence has been cies over the past year because “One cannot adopt a tick letter following the ombuds- March Mr. Kuroda said it was members said last week that
shaken by the recent string of of its experience working with box approach to the awarding man’s report to European carrying large losses. the bank might have to con-
credit events. central banks. BlackRock is the of certain contracts. Treating Commission President Ursula The stock-buying program, sider tweaking its purchases
—Xie Yu largest asset manager in the contract bidders equally is im- von der Leyen asking her to which began under Mr. and alluded to the uncomfort-
contributed to this article. world, with $7.8 trillion under portant, but not taking other cancel BlackRock’s contract. Kuroda’s predecessor a decade ably large size of its holdings.
B12 | Friday, November 27, 2020 * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
The decline of oil-and-gas su- U.S. peer NextEra, which trades for velop a large pipeline of renewable Harder-to-transport power is a the company bought PNM Re-
permajors over the past two years much higher earnings multiples, but projects around the world: Enel has much more local product, with sources, which supplies power in
has been matched by the rise of pre- with an international rather than 141 gigawatts worth, while Iberdrola prices often regulated or fixed by New Mexico and Texas, making it
viously obscure utility companies. In domestic footprint. has 70 gigawatts. They continue to long-term contracts. That predict- one of the largest players in the U.S.
Europe, Enel and Iberdrola have All three are gearing up for dra- bid for new opportunities. ability helps utilities to use leverage There are risks. Green power de-
emerged as green energy giants, in matic growth in clean-power de- to boost returns, while oil compa- mand is expected to rocket but re-
part by taking leaves out of the big- mand. Renewables can now be cost- nies need lower debt levels to turns could be pressured as many
oil playbook. competitive with fossil fuels, and weather commodity-price cycles. companies, including the likes of BP
Like Shell and BP before them, governments are accelerating plans
The companies hold Based in Rome, Enel operates pri- and Shell, crowd into the space. The
the companies have built global to cut carbon emissions. permissions to develop a marily in Europe, the U.S. and Latin payback on these multidecade proj-
portfolios to meet growing energy Enel and Iberdrola share traits America. Its plan to triple its renew- ects could eventually be squeezed
demand, only with wind and sun with oil supermajors. They are verti-
large pipeline of projects able capacity is part of a €160 bil- by higher interest rates, lower long-
rather than fossil fuels. The strategy cally integrated: They secure gov- around the world. lion, equivalent to $190.30 billion, term power prices (when fixed-price
has already made them the world’s ernment rights to many wind and investment package in solar and on- contracts expire) or regulatory
two largest renewable energy pro- solar sites; develop those projects; shore wind farms, power infrastruc- changes. Ironically, climate change
ducers by capacity, but they want to and then manage power plants and ture, storage and hydrogen. It also could shift patterns of wind or sun-
get even bigger. distribution networks. Their big, in- There are some important differ- has 10 coal-fired power plants that shine, affecting plants’ efficiency.
Enel said Tuesday that it will ternational operations provide the ences, too. Oil projects are typically it intends to unload by 2027. Still, renewables are set to be a
nearly triple its capacity to 120 scale for cost efficiencies, as well as high-risk, high-return investments, Spanish rival Iberdrola plans to major energy source and Enel and
gigawatts by 2030. Earlier this local know-how and relationships. while new power plants are a surer spend €75 billion by 2025 to double Iberdrola, as the current leaders,
month, Iberdrola laid plans to dou- Oil producers maintain a bank of thing and generate correspondingly its capacity. It builds solar and wind warrant more attention. These are a
ble its capacity to 60 gigawatts by drilling rights. Similarly, Enel and lower profits. Crude is a global com- farms, both on and offshore, mostly far cry from your grandmother’s
2025. The companies are similar to Iberdrola hold permissions to de- modity and prices are volatile. in the U.S. and Europe. Last month, utility stocks. —Rochelle Toplensky
Late Wednesday, Europe’s larg- March selloff. The new debt will
est listed-property company by as- come on top of net borrowings
sets said it had issued bonds equivalent to 12 times the earnings
worth €2 billion, equivalent to before interest, taxes, depreciation
$2.4 billion: one with a six-year and amortization Unibail generated
HOMES | MARKETS | PEOPLE | REDOS | SALES THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Friday, November 27, 2020 | M1
$1.76
MILLION
2015 Purchase
Price
VANESSA BERBERIAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (2); SHRIMPLIN FAMILY (“BEFORE”)
$226,300
Cost for addition to
back of home
$740,000
Total cost of renovation
2,507
SQUARE FEET
Total size of home after
301-square-foot addition
BEFORE
BY RUTH BLOOMFIELD
B
ehind a very traditional facade,
Rob and Cath Shrimplin’s house
is hiding a contemporary sur-
prise.
The rear Confronted with a 1930s
facade of the home with a whole litany of problems to
Shrimplin overcome, the couple embarked on a radical
home, top, with remodel which involved taking a big bite
addition and out of the back of the property and replac-
central window. ing it with a wide column of glass.
The Shrimplin The project began five years ago, and was
family in their triggered by a change in the couple’s work-
addition, from ing lives. They had been living in a four-bed-
left to right, room terraced house in Wimbledon, the
Jessica, 11, neighborhood in southwest London which is
Scarlett, 8, home to the famous tennis tournament.
Luke, 6, Cath When they bought that house, both had been
and Rob. working in the West End; Mr. Shrimplin, 43,
as a planning consultant, and Mrs. Shrimp-
lin, 41, as a finance director. Then new jobs
brought relocations. By coincidence, both
found themselves working in offices in the
“home county” of Surrey, on the southwest
Please turn to page M4
MANSION
SANTA
BARBARA, CALIF.
$8.95
MILLION
Six bed, five bath,
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP: CARSTEN SCHERTZER; JAKE DONAHUE/PORTLAND PICTURE; CHRIS MEECH; BEN MOSS/THE JILLS ZEDER GROUP; GABE BALAZS
three ½ bath,
8,306 sq. ft.
COMPARISON SHOPPING
Go Play Outside
Gardens and extensive landscaping have become hot home features during the pandemic
AKRON, OHIO // $2.95 MILLION BY CHRISTINA POLETTO in the 100 largest metro areas dis- VANCOUVER, WASH. // $2.995 MILLION
C
playing outdoor-related keywords
ovid-19 and long such as garden, courtyard, deck,
stretches at home greenhouse and backyard sold
have turned owners’ 27%, or 12 days, faster than simi-
attention to creating lar homes lacking those keywords.
expansive, landscaped (News Corp, owner of The Wall
outdoor spaces. Keith Williams, Street Journal, operates Real-
co-owner of Nievera Williams, a tor.com under license from the
landscape architecture firm in National Association of Realtors.)
Palm Beach, Fla., says his business Landscaping and gardens are
has been very busy. “Clients are investments that require year-
focusing more on their gardens round attention, says Mario Nie-
Seven bed, six bath, two ½ bath, 13,927 sq. ft. and how they use their exterior vera, co-owner of Nievera Wil- Six bed, five bath, two ½ bath, 8,837 sq. ft.
spaces, and just want a better and liams. “Many people who live
more functional experience alto- within apartments in large cities
CORAL GABLES, FLA. // $5.495 MILLION gether,” he says. are surprised to learn that you GREENWICH, CONN. // $8.21 MILLION
One priority for clients, says have to maintain and upkeep the
Mr. Williams, is creating a space landscaping,” says Mr. Nievera.
for items like pools, fountains and Christian Douglas, a landscape
tennis courts. “Most of our clients designer based in San Rafael, Ca-
have more than one home and are lif., suggests hiring the home’s ex-
moving to one location and com- isting garden team or hiring a
bining all of their favorite ele- competent crew with a skilled su-
ments,” he says. pervisor. “The design and installa-
Properties with gardens and tion is the easy part,” says Mr.
outdoor gathering spaces are of Douglas. The critical piece, he
particular interest to buyers. Ac- says, is deciding “who is going to
cording to an October analysis by nurture and take ownership once
Six bed, eight bath, one ½ bath, 9,807 sq. ft. Realtor.com, single-family homes it’s all done.” Five bed, six bath, one ½ bath, 8,435 sq. ft.
PRIVATE PROPERTIES
Property listed and offered for sale by Kerry Mormann, of Kerry Mormann & Associates
(CABRE# ), with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices California Properties
(DRE#
BHH Affiliates LLC. BHH Affiliates LLC and BHHSCP do not guarantee accuracy of all data
including measurements, conditions, and features of property. Information is obtained from
various sources and will not be verified by broker or MLS. Buyer is advised to independently
verify the accuracy of that information.
772 388 8400 WINDSORFLORIDA.COM
M4 | Friday, November 27, 2020 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MANSION
Cost of reconfiguring
first and second floors
$112,500
Cost of steel
panels for stairs
$9,265
R E M OT E B I D D I N G AVA I L A B L E
MANSION
Cost of redecoration
and hardwood flooring
$63,530
Throughout the house, the old- rear wall was qualms about their home’s change
fashioned décor was stripped demolished of pace. The addition is used as a
away and replaced with more con- and the house Cost to update very nontraditional looking play-
temporary alternatives. The walls extended out bathrooms room, which is heated by a wood-
are mostly white. Geometric into the back- $5,290 burning stove.
black, blue, and white tiles were yard, adding The project began in November
laid in the hallway, and the bed- 301 square feet 2016, and the family was able to
room carpets are a neutral oat- and creating a move back into the house in Feb-
meal. In the kitchen, the timber new room be- ruary 2018. The builders contin-
cabinets are painted in deep blue hind the exist- ued working around them until
and pale gray. The off-white com- ing living room May of that year. And although it
posite stone work tops are illumi- and entrance took longer than Mr. and Mrs.
nated by lights strung onto a cop- hall. Viewed Shrimplin had hoped, their project
per pipe, industrial style. The from the yard was delivered close to their bud-
original teak parquet flooring— this double- get, at a total cost of $740,000.
which Mrs. Shrimplin was over- height addition The couple were thankful to be
joyed to find hidden under the appears to settled in a large, comfortable fam-
carpets in the living and dining slice the old ily house with a backyard during
rooms—has been restored to its house in two Britain’s spring lockdown when the
original glory. with a wall of three children were being home-
The couple decided to reduce glass. French schooled and they were both si-
the number of bedrooms too, doors lead out- multaneously working from home.
combining two small adjacent doors, with “It was undoubtedly stressful,”
rooms into a single, spacious windows above said Mrs. Shrimplin. “But it was
guest room. Another bedroom has reaching to the loft. steel wall panels, is a world away into it,” said Mr. Shrimplin. “But relatively short-lived and the
been repurposed as an upstairs This glass segment brings light from the cottage-style front fa- because you don’t see it from the sense of achievement that we get
study, bringing the total bed- into the rest of the house, solving cade of the house, or the cozy liv- front of the house, or as you first from the house now is amazing.
rooms down to five. its final problem. The back room, ing room with its open fireplace walk in, I don’t think it is too in There are moments when I walk
The back of the house has seen with its poured concrete floors, and comfortable sofas. your face. You come to it slowly.” downstairs thinking, ‘Just look
the biggest metamorphosis. The bare brickwork, and geometric “It surprises you as you walk The children certainly have no what we have done.’ ”
IRVINE MANAGEMENT COMPANY, A LICENSED REAL ESTATE BROKER DRE LIC. #02041810
M6 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MANSION
HOUSE CALL | ALEX WINTER
An Excellent
FROM TOP: PHILIP CHEUNG; CAL SCHENKEL/ MAGNOLIA PICTURES; ALEX WINTER (FAMILY PHOTO)
And Bogus
Childhood
The ‘Bill & Ted’ actor and ‘Zappa’ director studied
tap, performed on Broadway at 13—and coped
T
he lights went down, timidated. I had been acting since
the curtain went up age 5.
and out I went. I was My mother, Gregg Mayer, was a
13 and appearing in New Yorker who studied with
the late-’70s revival of Martha Graham and started a
“The King and I” as Anna’s son, modern-dance company in London
Louis. in the mid-’60s. That’s where she
I was on Broadway at the Uris met my father, Ross, an Australian
Theatre, and Yul Brynner had re- dancer in her company.
turned to play the King. The When I was 5, we moved from Alex Winter at his became my manager King and I,” resulting in post-
stakes were high, but I wasn’t in- London to St. Louis so my mother South Pasadena, and got me an audi- traumatic stress disorder that
could teach at Washington Univer- Calif., home, above, tion for “The King surfaced when I was in my 20s.
sity. My father later started the and with his mother, and I.” When the After film school at NYU, I
ALEX’S ADVENTURE Mid America Dance Co. Gregg Mayer, in run ended in De- moved to Hollywood and ap-
Our home near campus was a London in 1969, right. cember ’78, I went peared in “The Lost Boys” and
Why a documentary on Frank beautiful Tidewater with broad on the road with “Rosalie Goes Shopping.” Then
Zappa? He was one of porches. The house was always the show. In 1979, I came “Bill & Ted’s Excellent Ad-
America’s greatest avant-garde filled with dancers touring or at- different lives from was cast as John venture” in 1989.
composers. tending college. the time I was born. Darling in Broad- That film was both a turning
I started taking modern dance Even though I sensed way’s “Peter Pan.” point and a dark period for me,
and ballet in London when I was the split coming, the Being a profes- since I was coping with PTSD.
4. In St. Louis, I moved on to tap divorce was hard. sional actor that Working on the set helped, since
for 10 years. It helped me with Over the next few young came with a the film was light and fun.
syncopation and thinking fast on years, I appeared in lot of pressure for Today, I live in South Pasadena,
my feet. national TV ads and me. I had to balance Calif., with my wife, Ramsey, who
Because my parents both performed in re- school, friends, per- is president of animation at Nick-
worked, I was a latchkey kid. gional theater. My time in London forming, memorization, rejection, elodeon, and our sons. It was built
Washington U. became my after- came in handy. I landed parts that not missing a line and so on. I in the 1920s and is similar to the
Biggest hurdle? Zappa’s wife, school sitter. Mom was well needed an English accent. This in- compartmentalized my life to get one I grew up in St. Louis.
Gail, gave us access to his vast known on campus, so I spent cluded my first professional stage it all done at a high level. None of our three boys is an
archives. Sorting through what much of my time wandering into role at 10 in a St. Louis Opera To help ease the stress, Mom actor. Our oldest is a painter
to use was a challenge. film and theater classes. production of “Oliver!” and I moved to Montclair, N.J. She studying at art school. Our middle
Drama instructors threw me on When I was 12, my mother was an arts administrator at Wil- one is a jazz trumpeter in high
Any Bill & Ted experiences stage whenever a production moved us to New York. Stephen liam Paterson College. school. And our youngest is just a
growing up? None at all. needed a little kid. I loved make- remained in St. Louis to finish Each day, I took the commuter kid. Thank God.
believe more than anything else. high school and then went to col- bus alone to New York and walked —As told to Marc Myers
What was your Bill reference? My mother and I were close lege in Missouri. to “Peter Pan” at the Lunt-Fon-
I drew from myself at age 9 and spent an enormous amount of I didn’t want to leave my tanne Theatre. When the show Alex Winter, 55, is an actor best
and my best friend, Matt. time together. My brother, Ste- friends. But when we arrived in was over at 11 p.m., I caught the known for portraying Bill in the
phen, who was 4½ years older, Long Island City, Queens, and I bus home. three “Bill & Ted” comedy films.
Next documentary? I’m explor- got a lot of her time, too. climbed out of our car, I couldn’t On top of all of my school and He directed “Fever” and the docu-
ing two. One is political and the When I was 8, my parents di- believe the buildings. acting work was another weight. I mentaries “Showbiz Kids” and
other is music-related. vorced. They had been leading very Weeks later, Niederlitz & Steele was sexually abused during “The “Zappa,” out today.
ADVERTISEMENT
&
&
+
,-
. + + /
. 0/ 1
!"#
' ( (
$& &
#
#
)
( * (
(
%
&
&
&
'
ADVERTISEMENT
Distinctive Properties
To advertise: email sales.realestate@wsj.com or WSJ.com/classifieds
VIRGINIA
!" #
! "
# $
% &'!()') )*)*# + ,
-.
/# "
0* "
1" 2
'3!
1"
( 4323
= " ( + 8
=> 4+$5,9
54 >+ >$>
( <,
,$ 29+5=5:92>+32>
$3 9 ?
"@"13" ? 0A03B.'3'.CA
FLORIDA AUCTIONS
!
!
"
# $!
%!
CALIFORNIA PENNSYLVANIA
! "#$
++ , -
! "
" # $
%
.!" *#/"/ .* !"
&
!" #
$
% & '
#$!% !-
0!"/ #$!% $ %&
('
)
*+,'-.'+,-/ 0&1 *+,'2.'+*+* 031 # $ %&
&
' !"
' ( ( ) ( * *
(800) 366-3975
sales.realestate@wsj.com
For more information visit:
wsj.com/classifieds
"
%
& #
%
#
© 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
M8 | Friday, November 27, 2020 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
PRIVATE PROPERTIES
Ad-Worthy
Ranch Sells
ADVERTISEMENT
Distinctive Properties
To advertise: email sales.realestate@wsj.com or WSJ.com/classifieds
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
DISTINCTIVE PROPERTIES
PENNSYLVANIA
DALLAS
UNDER CONTRACT / 1120 Easton Road
Listed for $775,000
DALLAS
SOLD / 6146 Park Lane / Listed for $2,500,000
* "
PENNY COOK / 214-384-2847 / ptcook@briggsfreeman.com JUSTIN FARMER / 214-538-5100 / jfarmer@briggsfreeman.com VICKI FOSTER / 214-642-8966 / vfoster@briggsfreeman.com
!"" #" $
% #
$& ' (
" ) "
M10 | Friday, November 27, 2020 NY / NE THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MANSION
FROM TOP: YING YI CHUA FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (3); JASON LEE (MAP); CITY DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED (3, INTERIORS (2); EXTERIOR RENDERING)
surgeon of his apartment’s most desirable homes have
sprawling views. traded for more than $100
Dr. Quek was initially million. Because Singapore
worried about the cost of fi- is densely populated, the
nancing his new home dur- government pursues a policy
ing the lockdown, when his The dining room of a penthouse on the 60th floor of Wallich Residence, which has a view of the Marina Bay area. of gradual price appreciation
income momentarily took a through measures such as
hit, but said he doesn’t re- stamp duties and a cap on
gret the timing of the pur- debt to 60% of a buyer’s
Purchase price: $2.5 million
chase. “It felt like I had the gross monthly income.
whole building to myself,” “As a result, there’s not
he says about the lockdown. much speculation in the
“That’s the price of vanity.” market,” says Lee Mei Ling,
Rules for foreign owner- executive vice president at
ship, made more compli- City Developments, which
cated by the pandemic, add built Boulevard 88 and
to the divisions in the mar- South Beach Residences.
ket. Foreigners typically “That is why we are not
have been the buyers of the seeing a knee-jerk reaction
higher-price apartments be- at this point compared to
cause of government re- previous crises.”
strictions on ownership of Some have their eye on
the bungalows on large 2023, when 3,514 new units
land plots that are the pre- are expected to be com-
ferred properties of locals. Desmond Quek, a local eye surgeon, bought a three-bedroom, 50th-floor unit in December. pleted in downtown Singa-
And while Singapore has pore, up from 1,553 in 2021.
been selectively easing the British industrial-design Meanwhile, four pent- fall in love with a property, has encouraged some “Most people aren’t feel-
ban set in March on foreign billionaire James Dyson, houses at Boulevard 88, a they will go for a bigger hedge-fund and family of- ing the impact of oversup-
entries, potential buyers who last year paid a record condo development—popu- unit because they want the fice managers to relocate to ply because completion is
seem wary. Brokers say that $54 million for a 21,108- lar with Chinese buyers—at- best. It is very different this majority-Chinese city, in three years’ time,” says
Chinese clients have started square-foot penthouse at tached to an Edition-brand from the mass market.” while Chinese tech giant Christine Li, head of re-
reaching out again, but the Wallich Residence, which hotel and set to be com- There are signs that a Tencent and TikTok owner search at Cushman & Wake-
number of $5 million-plus occupies the top portion of pleted in 2022, were ac- new wave of wealthy buy- Bytedance have said they field Singapore. “But it is
deals this year has been rel- a 951-foot skyscraper with quired last year for between ers is about to enter Singa- would invest billions in set- always in the mind of some
atively small. 360-degree views of Singa- $20.5 million and $22.75 pore. Beijing’s political ting up regional hubs there. investors who have gone
“We have quite a number million. crackdown in Hong Kong Among those hoping to through that before.”
of people who are very in- In December, a 4,424-
terested but want to take a square-foot apartment at
look before making a deci- MALAYSIA South Beach Residences,
sion,” says Cheng Hsing part of a mixed-use de-
Yao, group managing velopment with 190 lux-
director of GuocoLand, ury units, offices and a 3,500 Beautiful Acres
a luxury developer five-star JW Marriott
SINGAPORE
that recently sold
about a half-dozen Singapore
hotel that overlooks a
Formula One racing
Where Social Distancing
multimillion-dollar
condos across Singa-
Strait
route, was sold for
$12.6 million.
is a Pleasure
pore in virtual transac- Despite the dearth of Your own private estate in nearby Rhode Island
tions alone. INDONESIA foreign buyers this year,
To understand the im- developers have avoided
pact of the loss of wealthy slashing prices, as buyers
Chinese, Indonesian and with deep pockets scoop up
American buyers, look to pore, Malaysia and the In- the relatively small number
Singapore’s skyline. Over donesian islands. (The of ultraluxury homes cur-
the past half-decade, it has building received special rently available, says Chris-
been transformed by devel- dispensation to exceed local tine Sun, head of research
opers catering to a wave of height restrictions.) Mr. Dy- at OrangeTee & Tie.
international buyers seek- son, who has another home “Luxury buyers don’t [re-
ing mixed-use towers that in Singapore, recently sold ally] have a budget con-
blend offices, hotel and res- the penthouse for $46 mil- straint,” says Mr. Cheng,
idences. lion to an Indonesia-born whose company developed
Those buyers include entrepreneur. Wallich Residence. “If they
Now Available
Introductory Pricing
Tiny Homes Starting at $549k
to Luxury Homes at $5m