Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ontel v. Does - Complaint
Ontel v. Does - Complaint
v. Hon.
Defendants.
VERIFIED COMPLAINT
(“Ontel”), by and through its attorneys, DICKINSON WRIGHT PLLC, and for
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
INTRODUCTION
evaporative air coolers sold under the Arctic Air trademark. Exhibit A.
Defendants copied Ontel’s product design and Ontel’s copyrights and are
that they are clear counterfeit versions of Ontel’s Arctic Air Products, often
are entering into legitimate transactions with Ontel and/or for the purchase
are inferior and do not function as advertised. The harm to Ontel and to the
2
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
general public will continue unless Defendants’ conduct is enjoined by this
Court.
Ontel’s Arctic Air products are sold throughout the United States, and
internationally.
Northern Ireland. Upon information and belief, Hyper Z Tech Ltd is owned,
including hypertechz.com.
Hong Kong. Hyper SLS Ltd is an owner and/or operator of one or more of
3
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
coolz.com, buyudrone.com, getwondabra.com, gadgetmall247.com, free-
Northern Ireland. Tech X Deal Ltd is an owner and/or operator of one or more
4
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
8. Defendant G Com PTE Ltd is a private company registered in
process because they purposefully direct their activities toward the United
States. Defendants advertise their products in the United States, sell their
11. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over Ontel’s claims,
which arise out of Defendants’ violation of the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C.§ 101,
et seq., the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125, and the Patent Act, 35 U.S.C. §
1, et seq. This Court also has supplemental jurisdiction over Ontel’s state
the United States may be sued in any judicial district. 28 U.S.C. § 1391(c)(3).
Further, through the use of websites, including those set forth on Schedule
5
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
A, Defendants advertise, market, sell, or have sold infringing product within
breaking household items. Ontel’s products are sold in nearly every major
14. Among the products sold by Ontel are the Arctic Air and Arctic Air
Ultra (collectively “Arctic Air Products”). The Arctic Air Products are personal
15. The Arctic Air Products were launched in 2018 and since that
time they have become one of Ontel’s best-selling products in the United
16. The success of the Arctic Air Products began with the launch of
the Arctic Air evaporative cooler. Further research and development refined
the original Arctic Air product, and Ontel launched the Arctic Air Ultra. Both
6
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
17. Ontel’s products are available for purchase at many large retail
stores, including WalMart and Target and are also available for purchase
the United States to represent genuine, high quality goods and Ontel owns
the goodwill associated with its intellectual property rights and has invested
7
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
B. ONTEL’S COPYRIGHTS.
for the packaging associated with the Arctic Air Products as well as the
20. Arctic Air’s packaging was registered with the U.S. Copyright
Exhibit B.
21. The Arctic Air Ultra was also registered with the U.S. Copyright
8
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Exhibit C.
676 on January 2, 2018 for the commercial associated with the Arctic Air
23. The Arctic Air Packaging, Arctic Air Ultra Packaging, and Arctic
9
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
C. ONTEL’S TRADEMARKS
registered with the United States Patent and Trademark Office as follows
U.S. IC 011.
Registration Personal
Number portable
5814181 humidifier
and air
Date: purifier in the
07/23/2019 nature of a
cooling
device
interstate commerce under its marks and Ontel enjoys the benefit of
10
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
27. The Arctic Air Products bearing these marks are well known and
D. ONTEL’S PATENTS.
28. Ontel owns U.S. Patent No. D848,593 (the “Artic Air Design
Patent”).
29. The Arctic Air Design Patent was filed on December 26, 2017
30. The Arctic Air Design Patent protects the ornamental design for
excerpted below:
11
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
31. Ontel also owns U.S. Patent No. D852,340 (the “Arctic Air Ultra
32. The Arctic Air Ultra Design Patent was filed on December 21,
33. The Arctic Air Ultra Design Patent protects the ornamental design
for a personal air cooler as described and depicted in the patent and as
excerpted below:
34. The Arctic Air Design Patent and Arctic Air Ultra Design Patent
35. Ontel also has other patent applications pending for its Arctic Air
products.
12
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
36. Ontel’s Copyrights, Ontel’s Marks and Ontel’s Patents are
E. INFRINGING SITES.
“Infringing Sites”).
38. The Infringing Sites that are currently known to Ontel include the
Property Rights.
41. The Infringing Sites that market, sell, or purport to sell a knockoff
version of the Arctic Air call the product “Polaire”, “CoolAir”, and/or “Ice Cube”
42. The Infringing Sites that market, sell, or purport to sell a knockoff
version of the Arctic Air Ultra call the product “CoolZ AIR” or, more commonly,
“Fresh-R”.
13
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
43. Attached as Exhibit A are PDF screenshots of each of the
44. Upon information and belief, one or more of the Infringing Sites
Infringing Sites, have taken active steps to conceal their true identities in
are required to maintain WHOIS data, which must include the name,
address, email, phone number, and administrative contact for the registrant
of the site. For at least 45 of the 46 Infringing Sites, Defendants utilized the
1 See Exhibit A, homepage for get-polaire.com and Terms of Use for techmsx.com showing PayPal logo;
see also Exhibit A Terms of Use for BuySmartProduct.com, iApplexa.com, iGadget24.com,
hypertechz.com, techsxpro.com, novads.co, techxsv.com, hyperstech.com, buy-coolz.com,
techdailyx.com, applexa24.com, g63com.com, buyudrone.com, getwondabra.com, gadgetmall247.com,
free-the-internet.com, bestxtech.org, urgoodeal.com, smartgadgetpro.com, i-want-internet.com, internet-
for-everyone.com, flightxshop.com, buyvisionpro.com, buysealpro.com, boost-my-internet.com, give-me-
internet.com, give-me-fast-internet.com, amazingxtech.com, techxdeal.com, techxdeal.org,
xtechgadget.com, buy-cleant.com, popularhitech.com, niwiminipods.com, tryecoheats.com,
matrixeshop.com, techmsx.com, stating that “[p]ayment for all orders must be made by Credit, Debit card
or PayPal payment method on the checkout page.”
14
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
and contact information by becoming the registrant, and then licensing the
queried to try to determine the identity of the website owner, the search yields
generic contact information for WhoisGuard. See Exhibit H, WHOIS data for
46. Upon information and belief, all of the Infringing Sites are part of
48. Evidence that the Infringing Sites are part of the same enterprise
includes:
15
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
original.com markets the infringing product but links directly to
techmsx.com to purchase). See Exhibits A and I;
iGadget24.com:
TechXDeal.com:
Give-me-internet.com:
Tryecoheats.com:
16
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Buy-cleant.com:
Hyperstech.com:
17
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Infringing Site CoolAir Ice Cube Fresh-R
Hyperstech.com
Buysmartproduct.com
iGadget24.com
Buy-cleant.com
18
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Tryecoheats.com
49. In light of the foregoing, it is clear that each of the Infringing Sites
enterprise and is directly liable for its/his/her own infringement, and indirectly
counterfeit copy of Ontel’s Arctic Air Product to the consumer, often with
19
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
multiple consumers contacting Ontel concerning products purchased from
the Infringing Sites. Even where Ontel’s contact information is not included
in full herein.
20
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
commercial to sell the inferior Infringing Products, including as depicted
below:
21
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Still image taken from copyrighted Arctic Air Commercial
Ontel’s Arctic Air Packaging by copying and using significant portions of the
22
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
packaging in connection with the advertising, marketing and sale of its
infringing products:
23
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
57. Defendants’ improper copying and use of Ontel’s Copyrights was
in full herein.
24
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
63. Defendants used and are continuing to infringe upon Ontel’s
the mistaken belief that Defendants’ products represent genuine Ontel Arctic
Ontel.
Marks and apply such reproduction, copy and colorable imitation to products
65. By way of example, one consumer, B.N., sent Ontel proof of her
purchase from “Polaire” (the name and e-mail address of B.N. have been
25
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
66. The Polaire name and logo are the same name and logo that
appear on www.get-polaire.com:
26
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
67. The image below depicts the product B.N. received - a
counterfeit that directly copies Ontel’s Marks in their entirety without approval
or authorization by Ontel:
mistake, or to deceive.
counterfeiting.
27
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
72. As a result of Defendant’s unlawful conduct, Ontel has been
73. Ontel is entitled to its actual damages (or in the alternative for
28
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
78. Defendants’ actions were taken with knowledge and with the
websites.
79. Defendants acted with knowledge and with the intent that their
actions would confuse third parties into believing they were purchasing
Defendants, Ontel has incurred losses to its business and to the value of its
marks, lost sales, loss of goodwill, and other losses for which Ontel is entitled
attorneys’ fees.
in full herein.
29
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
84. Defendants are directly infringing or inducing infringement of
on the Arctic Air Design Patent. Defendants’ “Fresh-R” and “CoolZ AIR”
marketing, advertising, offering for sale, and selling the Polaire, CoolAir, Ice
Cube, CoolZ AIR, and Fresh-R with knowledge and with the intent that third
Patent include:
30
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Arctic Air Design
hyperstech.com techmsx.com
Patent
31
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Arctic Air Ultra Design
Patent Tryecoheats.com Fresh-r.shop
as described herein.
attorney fees, and Defendants’ profits (for which Ontel demands an equitable
accounting).
32
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
93. Ontel further seeks a declaration by the Court that it is entitled to
§ 284.
in full herein.
competition.
Ontel.
99. Defendant acted with the intent to engage in common law unfair
33
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
100. As a result of Defendants’ illegal conduct, Ontel has been
attorneys’ fees.
herein.
the violation of any right of the registrant of a mark registered in the Patent
violation of any right secured by patent, on such terms as the court deems
reasonable.”
34
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
107. Ontel is likely to succeed on the merits of the claims raised in this
from continuing to violate Ontel’s rights will mitigate the irreparable harm
Ontel products;
35
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
sale, attempted sale, or importation of the “Polaire”,
infringing products;
§ 504.
U.SC. § 1117(c);
U.S.C. § 1125(a);
35 U.S.C. § 284;
g) Award Ontel the costs associated with bringing this action; and
36
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Respectfully submitted,
/s/Christopher J. Ryan
DICKINSON WRIGHT PLLC
John S. Artz (P48578)
Christopher J. Ryan (P74053)
350 S. Main Street, Ste 300
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
(734) 623-1907
cryan@dickinsonwright.com
JURY DEMAND
Plaintiff ONTEL PRODUCTS CORPORATION hereby demands a trial
37
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
Respectfully submitted,
/s/Christopher J. Ryan
DICKINSON WRIGHT PLLC
John S. Artz (P48578)
Christopher J. Ryan (P74053)
350 S. Main Street, Ste 300
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
(734) 623-1907
cryan@dickinsonwright.com
38
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
SCHEDULE A
39
4830-7550-6897 v6 [64944-1641]
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
Plaintiff,
Case No.
v.
Hon.
Defendants.
VERIFICATION
4817-7067-3106 v1 [64944-1641]
I have reviewed Plaintiff’s Verified Complaint and Plaintiff’s Ex Parte
The facts alleged in the foregoing documents are true to the best of my
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States
of America that the foregoing is true and correct.
_______________________________
CAROLINE KINSEY
2
4817-7067-3106 v1 [64944-1641]