Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

2020 TEXAS

HOMESCHOOL
REPORT

A glimpse of homeschooling in the


U.S., Texas, and your local area

TEXAS
HOMESCHOOL
COALITION
O V E R V I E W

This report explores helpful information about growth in homeschooling


in the United States, Texas, and various counties and political districts
across Texas.

In the 2018-2019 school year, 22,967 students between grades 7-12


withdrew from public schools in Texas to homeschool. Since 1998, a
total of 379,815 students between grades 7-12 have withdrawn from
public schools in Texas to homeschool. This number has increased at an
average of 6.5% per year. Texas public school enrollment rose 1.57%
over the same period.

Notably, these numbers track only homeschool withdrawals from public


school between grades 7-12 and do not account for the large number
of students who began homeschooling without first entering the public
school system. As a result, these numbers are helpful as a partial picture
of homeschool growth in Texas, but do not provide a comprehensive
view of homeschooling growth in Texas.

There are an estimated 2.5 million homeschool students in the United


States, which has grown between 2-8% per year and is the fastest-
growing form of education in America.

The report also highlights helpful findings related to demographic


trends, academic success, and opinion information among homeschool
students and families.

The report concludes with a helpful fact sheet providing high-level


insights into homeschooling nationwide.

NOTE: You can view Texas homeschool withdrawal information online


by using our interactive map at THSC.org/map. This tool allows you
to view withdrawal information broken down by year, county, grade,
political district, school district, county, and region of Texas.
HOMESCHOOLING
IN TEXAS

A Note on Covid-19 Homeschool Growth:

The Coronavirus has resulted in a tremendous uptick The Texas Home School Coalition maintains an online
in families choosing to homeschool nationwide. While tool at THSC.org where families can automatically
currently available data makes this trend clear, this generate a letter of withdrawal that can be used to
report focuses primarily on the hard numbers available withdraw their student from public school in Texas.
for homeschool growth in Texas from the Texas This tool is a voluntary resource and is not used
Education Agency (TEA). by all families who withdraw from public school to
homeschool in Texas.
Data from the TEA showing withdrawals to homeschool
for the fall semester of 2020 is not yet available. As soon The number of families using this tool to withdraw from
as it becomes available, it will be available for viewing public school in Texas has skyrocketed. Compared to
through THSC’s online tool here: THSC.org/map. 2019, usage of this withdrawal tool was up 1700% in
July of 2020, 400% in August, and 400% in September.
Early numbers indicate that the growth in
homeschooling nationwide and in Texas is substantial. While hard numbers showing the growth of homeschool
A recent survey from Real Clear Opinions found that withdrawals in Texas are not yet available for the
40% of registered voters were more likely to enroll their fall of 2020, all available indicators point towards
children in a homeschool or a virtual school after the record breaking growth. Once available, homeschool
coronavirus.1 withdrawal information for the fall of 2020 will be
viewable online here: THSC.org/map.
A survey from Gallup found that the number of families 1
https://www.federationforchildren.org/national-poll-40-of-families-more-likely-to-
reporting their child would be homeschooled this year homeschool-after-lockdowns-end/
had doubled from 5% in 2019 to 10% in 2020.2 2
https://news.gallup.com/poll/317852/parents-satisfaction-child-education-slips.aspx

PAGE 1
HISTORICAL DATA ON HOMESCHOOL GROWTH

1. Statewide enrollment trends


The number of students withdrawing from public school to homeschool has averaged an annual growth rate of 6.5%
since 1997. The 2017-2018 school year saw a record high number of students withdrawing to homeschool.

In the following year (2018-2019 school year), the number of students withdrawing from public charter schools
declined, while the number of students withdrawing from traditional ISDs increased slightly. This resulted in a net
decrease in the number of students withdrawing to homeschool compared to the high in the 2017-2018 school
year, but still represented an increase over the 2016-2017 school year.

a. Homeschool growth in Texas compared to public school growth

Statewide Homeschool Withdrawals by Year

30000

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0
8

9
99

99

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

01

01

01

01

01

01

01

01

01

01
–1

–1

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2
97

98

99

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18
19

19

19

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20
Statewide Public School Enrollment by Year

6000000

5000000

4000000

3000000

2000000

1000000

0
8

9
99

99

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

00

01

01

01

01

01

01

01

01

01

01
–1

–1

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2

–2
97

98

99

00

01

02

03

04

05

06

07

08

09

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18
19

19

19

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

PAGE 2
Enrollment/Withdrawal Percentage Increase since ‘97

300%

227.91%

200%

100%

40.85%

0%
Public Homeschool

b.Top 7 counties for homeschool withdrawals in Texas

Top Counties for Homeschool Withdrawals

3500

3000

2500

2000

2500

1000

500

0
9

3
0

7
4
1

1
8

8
5

5
2

2
9

9
6

6
3
0

7
4

8
99

00
00

00
00
00

01
99

00
00

01
00

01
00

01
00

01
01
01

01
01

01
–1

–2
–2

–2
–2
–2

–2
–1

–2
–2

–2
–2

–2
–2

–2
–2

–2
–2
–2

–2
–2

–2
98

02
99

06
03
00

10
97

07
04

14
01

11
08

18
05

15
12
09

16
13

17
19

20
19

20
20
20

20
19

20
20

20
20

20
20

20
20

20
20
20

20
20

20

HARRIS COUNTY BEXAR COUNTY DALLAS COUNTY TARRANT COUNTY


MONTGOMERY COUNTY DENTON COUNTY TRAVIS COUNTY

PAGE 3
19

0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
97

0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
19
97 –1
–1 99

PAGE 4
99 8
8 19
19 98
98 –1
–1 99
99 9
9 19
19 99
99 –2
–2 00
00 0
0 20
20 00
00 –2
–2 00
00 1
1 20
20 01
01 –2
–2 00
00 2
2 20
20 02
Rural vs Urban Homeschooling

02 –2
–2 00
00 3
3 20
20
c. Rural vs Urban homeschooling

03
03 –2
–2 00
00 4
4
20 20
04 04
–2 –2
00
00
5 5
20 20
05 05
–2 –2

ISD
00 00
6 6
20 20
06 06
–2 –2

Statewide Homeschool Withdrawals ISD vs Charter


00 00
7 7
20 20
07 07
–2 –2
00 00
8 8
20 20

d. Homeschool withdrawals from ISDs vs charter schools


08 08
–2 –2
00 00
9 9

Rural Urban
20 20
09 09
–2 –2
01 01
0 0

CHARTER
20 20
10 10
–2 –2
01 01
1 1
20 20
11 11
–2 –2
01 01
2 2
20 20
12 12
–2 –2
01 01
3 3
20 20
13 13
–2 –2
01 01
4 4
20 20
14 14
–2 –2
01 01
5 5
20 20
15 15
–2 –2
01 01
6 6
20 20
16 16
–2 –2
01 01
7 7
20 20
17 17
–2 –2
01 01
8 8
20 20
18 18
–2 –2
01
9 01
9
2. Why do families choose to homeschool in Texas?

In a 2017 survey conducted by Ragnar Research, homeschool parents in Texas were asked,
“Which of the following best describes the reason that you chose to homeschool your children?”

Parents gave the following responses:

• You prefer to teach religious/Christian/moral based curriculum instruction: 33%

• You are dissatisfied with the academics: 28%

• This child has other special needs that you feel the school can’t or won’t meet: 10%

• You are concerned about school safety/drugs/gangs: 8%

• You are concerned about peer pressure from other students: 6%

• This child has a physical/ mental health handicap: 4%

• This child has a temporary illness that prevents him/her from going to school: 2%

• Other: 6%

• Don’t Know: 4%

On the National Home Education Survey conducted in 2016 by the Department of Education, parents
across the United States cited the “most important” reason that they chose to homeschool as:

• A concern about environment of other schools: 34%

• A dissatisfaction with academic instruction at other schools: 17%

• A desire to provide religious instruction: 16%

• A desire to provide a non-traditional approach to child’s education: 6%

• Child has other special needs: 6%

• Child has a physical or mental health problem: 6%

• A desire to provide moral instruction: 5%

• Child has a temporary illness: % N/A. Inadequate sample

• Other reasons: 11%

PAGE 5
While studying the differences different styles of instruction for Online Classes:
between Texas data and each student in the family, try new Thirty-three percent of families
national data related to parental methods or tweak old ones each report that at least one of their
motivations for homeschooling year, and use different solutions students uses online classes for
is helpful, direct comparisons for different subjects. all or part of the student’s school
between Texas data and national work. A wide variety of online
data are difficult because the Here are a few common styles class providers makes this an easy
categories available for parents to of instruction that homeschool option for many families.
choose between these two surveys families use in Texas.
were different. Dual Credit:
Homeschool Co-op: Many homeschool families in
Even so, it is clear that A homeschool co-op is formed Texas utilize dual credit from
dissatisfaction with other schools when a group of parents band their local community college
regarding their academic together to help each other teach as a central element of their
instruction and environment and each student. Parents usually students’ high school education. A
a desire to provide moral or agree to specific responsibilities growing trend in the homeschool
religious instruction are highly related to teaching certain subjects community is for students to utilize
motivating factors for parents or taking on administrative tasks. dual credit to obtain an associates
choosing to homeschool. degree by the time they graduate
Students then attend co-op classes high school.
3. Common methods on a regular basis, often a few
of homeschooling days a week or a few days every Homeschool “Pods”:
other week, and complete their Similar to a homeschool co-
in Texas
remaining school work from op, “pods” are small groups of
home. Thirty-four percent of Texas parents who band together to help
The only near-universal trait of
homeschool families from a 2019 teach each other’s children, often
homeschooling programs in Texas
survey reported that they had at meeting on a weekly or bi-weekly
is variety. According to an non-
least one student who attended a basis at each other’s houses and
scientific THSC survey, eighty
homeschool co-op. alternating responsibilities to help
percent of Texas homeschool
families report that they mix and accommodate the needs of each
match curricula from different family.
providers. Families often use

PAGE 6
4. Texas homeschool opinions and challenges

In 2019, THSC conducted a wide ranging, that they support giving homeschool families access
non-scientific survey of homeschool families to extracurricular activities through the University
Interscholastic League (UIL) at their local public school.
in Texas to gather information on homeschool
family demographics, preferences, and Support for homeschool student access to UIL was high
habits. across the political spectrum. Families who identified as
liberal were more likely to support it (84%), but support
When asked what type of educational resource the among conservative homeschool families was also very
family most wished they had better access to, by a wide high (75%).
margin families chose “discounts on curriculum and
materials.” When asked what issues should be prioritized by the
Texas legislature, by a wide margin, education was the
Sixty-three percent of families reported that they issue that homeschool parents believed was the “most
had been homeschooling for less than five years, important” issue that the legislature should prioritize:
underscoring the large number of new families that
are moving into homeschooling. Twenty-six percent of • Education: 23%
families surveyed stated that they were homeschooling • Healthcare/Obamacare: 9%
a special needs child. • State government corruption/mismanagement/
reform: 7%
When asked what type of homeschooling support/ • Jobs/economy: 7%
opportunity families most wished they had better access • Immigration/border security: 7%
to, easier access to extracurricular activities was chosen • Taxes/fees: 6%
by nearly half of families and was the most common • Social issues/Abortion/Gay Marriage: 6%
type of opportunity selected. Low-income and rural • Government spending: 5%
families were more likely to choose this option than their • Social Security/Medicare/Medicaid: 4%
urban or high-income counterparts. • Crime/police/law enforcement: 3%
• Transportation/roads/highways/interstate: 2%
In a 2017 scientific survey of homeschool parents • Other: 13%
conducted by Ragnar Research, 77% of families stated • Don’t Know: 10%

PAGE 7
2020 GENERAL HOMESCHOOL FACT SHEET

Homeschool Growth (McQuiggan and Megra p. spent on structured learning,


1811). or the age at which formal
Nationwide
• Homeschooling families spend instruction began. None of these
• Homeschooling is growing factors causes any significant
approximately $600 per student
between 2-8% per year. It is the variance in the student’s
per year on education. Public
fastest-growing form of education academic test scores (Ray, p.
school students average more
in the U.S. (public school growth 2718).
than $11,000 per year (Ray12).
has been 1% over the last 10
• The degree of state regulation
years) (Bustamante3, Ray4).
Reasons to Homeschool on homeschooling causes no
• There are approximately 2.5 statistical difference in the
• When citing the most important
million homeschool students in the academic performance of the
reason that they chose to
United States (Ray5). students (Ray, p. 2719).
homeschool:
• Homeschooling saves taxpayers
• 34% cited concern with the school Social, Emotional, and
approximately $27 billion per
environment, such as safety,
year (Ray6).
drugs, or negative peer pressure
Psychological Development
• A recent survey showed that 40% (McQuiggan and Megra p.1913). and Performance as Adults
of registered voters were more
• 17% cited dissatisfaction with • Homeschool students outperform
likely to enroll their children in a
academic instruction at other their peers by a statistically
homeschool or a virtual school
schools (McQuiggan and Megra significant margin on social and
after the coronavirus (Schultz7).
p.1914). emotional development issues,
• A recent survey from Gallup measured by peer interaction,
• 21% cited a desire to provide
found that the number of families self-concept, leadership skills,
moral or religious instruction
reporting their child would be family cohesion, participation
(McQuiggan and Megra p.1915).
homeschooled this year had in community service, and self-
doubled from 5% in 2019 to • Among black homeschoolers, esteem (Ray20, Ray, p. 1021).
10% in 2020 (Brenan8). racism in the schools was the
• Homeschool students are
second most-common reason
more politically tolerant by a
Homeschool Demographics cited for why the family chose to
statistically significant margin
homeschool (Mazama and Lundy
• Approximately 41% of (Ray, p. 1222).
p. 1116).
homeschool families are
• Homeschool graduates are more
minorities. Twenty-six percent are
Hispanic and 8% are black. The
Academic Performance likely to participate in community
service, more likely to attend
black community appears to be • Homeschool students rank 15-
community meetings, and more
the fastest-growing segment of 30 percentile points above their
likely to vote (Ray23).
homeschooling (McQuiggan and public school peers on national
Megra p. 189). achievement tests (Ray, p. 2717).
Other Facts
• Approximately 21% of • Homeschool students significantly
• Homeschool students are 40%
homeschool students live in outperform their public school
less likely to die of abuse and
households below the poverty line peers academically regardless
neglect and are less likely to
(McQuiggan and Megra p. 1810). of gender, amount of money
experience sexual abuse when
spent on education, whether the
• Approximately 45% of compared to students in the
parent had ever been a certified
homeschool students live in general public (Ray24).
teacher, number of children living
homes where parents have a
at home, degree of structure in
bachelor’s degree or higher
homeschooling, amount of time

PAGE 8
Summary: A sizable group of homeschool extracurricular activities through UIL at
families in Texas report that they their local public school.
Homeschooling in Texas is growing at
homeschool a special needs child,
an incredible rate compared to other
although most do not cite this as the Homeschool withdrawals in
forms of education. Families who
“most important” reason that they
choose to homeschool are motivated your local area
chose to homeschool.
by a wide range of factors, but when You can view Texas homeschool
asked for the “most important” factor, withdrawal information online by
Homeschool parents, particularly
families cite dissatisfaction with using our interactive map at THSC.
rural and low-income parents, cite
academics and/or the environment org/map. This tool allows you to view
better access to extracurricular
at schools, or a desire to provide withdrawal information broken down
activities as the type of opportunity
moral and religious instruction to their by year, county, grade, political
that they most need better access to
students. district, school district, county, and
and 77% of families support allowing
homeschool students to participate in region of Texas.

Methodology small, masked numbers were estimated by Household Education Surveys Program of nheri.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/
this method. Statewide totals for each year 2016.” Nces.Ed.Gov, U.S. Department Ray-2010-Academic-Achievement-and-
This report was constructed using a variety and other large withdrawal numbers are of Education, Sept. 2017, nces.ed.gov/ Demographic-Traits-of-Homeschool-Students.
of sources. Each source is cited in the report reported raw from the TEA. pubs2017/2017102.pdf. pdf.
alongside the fact that is used from that
source. Footnotes: 10 Id. 18 Id.
Data showing the number of withdrawals 3 Bustamante, Jaleesa. “K-12 School 11 Id. 19 Id.
from Texas public schools to homeschool Enrollment & Student Population Statistics.” 12 Ray, Dr. Brian D. “Homeschooling: 20 Ray, Dr. Brian D. “Homeschooling:
was obtained from the Texas Education EducationData.Org, 6 Sept. 2019, The Research.” National Home Education The Research.” National Home Education
Agency (TEA). School districts in Texas educationdata.org/k12-enrollment-statistics. Research Institute, 23 Mar. 2020, www. Research Institute, 23 Mar. 2020, www.
are only required to record homeschool 4 Ray, Dr. Brian D. “Homeschooling: The nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling. nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling.
withdrawals between grades 7-12. All TEA Research.” National Home Education
data is restricted to these grade levels. 13 McQuiggan, Meghan, and Mahi 21 Brian D. Ray (2017) A systematic
Research Institute, 23 Mar. 2020, www. Megra. “Parent and Family Involvement review of the empirical research on
The data records homeschool withdrawals nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling. in Education: Results from the National selected aspects of homeschooling
from all Texas public schools, including 5 Id. Household Education Surveys Program of as a school choice, Journal of School
charter schools, since the 1997-1998 2016.” Nces.Ed.Gov, U.S. Department Choice, 11:4, 604-621, DOI:
school year. TEA data also does not 6 Id.
of Education, Sept. 2017, nces.ed.gov/ 10.1080/15582159.2017.1395638
account for growth in homeschooling from 7 Schultz, Tommy. “National Poll: 40% of pubs2017/2017102.pdf.
the substantial number of families who Families More Likely to Homeschool After 22 Id.
choose to homeschool but have never been Lockdowns End.” American Federation 14 Id. 23 Ray, Dr. Brian D. “Homeschooling:
enrolled in the public school system. for Children, 14 May 2020, www. 15 Id. The Research.” National Home Education
Texas law prevents the disclosure of federationforchildren.org/national-poll-40- 16 Mazama, Ama, and Garvey Lundy. Research Institute, 23 Mar. 2020, www.
particularly small withdrawal numbers. of-families-more-likely-to-homeschool-after- “African American Homeschooling nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling.
Therefore, these numbers were masked in lockdowns-end. as Racial Protectionism.” Journal of 24 “Child Abuse of Public School, Private
the TEA data. Although larger withdrawal 8 Brenan, Megan. “K-12 Parents’ Black Studies, vol. 43, no. 7, 2012, School, and Homeschool Students:
totals are raw (such as total withdrawals Satisfaction With Child’s Education Slips.” pp. 723–748. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/ Evidence, Philosophy, and Reason.”
per year statewide or withdrawals per year Gallup.Com, Gallup, 25 Aug. 2020, stable/23414694. Accessed 9 Oct. 2020. National Home Education Research
from larger school districts), as reported news.gallup.com/poll/317852/parents- Institute, 23 Jan. 2018, www.nheri.
17 Ray, Dr. Brian D. “Academic
by the TEA, smaller, masked withdrawal satisfaction-child-education-slips.aspx. org/child-abuse-of-public-school-private-
Achievement and Demographic Traits
numbers are estimates which have been school-and-homeschool-students-evidence-
9 McQuiggan, Meghan, and Mahi of Homeschool Students: A Nationwide
weighted based on known averages for philosophy-and-reason.
Megra. “Parent and Family Involvement Study.” Academicleadership.Org,
particular grade levels and years. Only
in Education: Results from the National Academic Leadership, 3 Feb. 2010, www.
PAGE 9
PAGE 10

You might also like