Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Árbole, Mares y Ecofeminismo en La Poesía de Magda Portal
Árbole, Mares y Ecofeminismo en La Poesía de Magda Portal
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Erin S. Finzer
University of Arkansas
at Little Rock
The first Fiesta de la Planta took place on Christmas Day, 1921, in Vitarte, an in-
dustrial suburb of Lima, Peru. Home to a large textile mill, Vitarte at the turn of the
century was a community of organized workers who successfully won an eight-hour
workday in 1919. With a proletarian consciousness and new time on their hands, the
workers welcomed the opening of Peru's second Gonzalez Prada Popular Universi-
ty in January 1921, with the revolutionary Aprista leader Raúl Haya de la Torre as
the school's director. Popular universities, which represented the alliance between
intellectuals and the working classes, were founded throughout Latin America and
provided classes for the poor with no tuition charge. University student activist vol-
unteers, such as feminist poet Magda Portal (Peru, 1900-1989) in the later 1920s,
taught workers and peasants basic academic and life skills, as well as Marxist-in-
spired theory.
As a spirited celebration of the popular university movement, Vitarte's annual
Fiesta de la Planta - with planta referring both to industrial and botanical plants -
attracted some 5000 workers and their families from all over Peru to participate not
only in tree planting, but also sporting events, a large communal meal, cultural ac-
tivities and political rallying in support of worker alliances and organizing (Murillo
Garaycochea in Pérez Ruiz, n. pag.). This tree-planting festival came not only to
symbolize the cultivation of intellectual and worker solidarity in Peru, but also
served as an initial metaphor through which Portal lyrically transcribed her early in-
volvement in Peru's popular struggle. Using the tree as an ecocritical point of depar-
ture in her early voice, Portal's poetic subjectivity can be seen as inscribed with an
319
* Portal substituted th
commonly includes ort
the materiality and arb
Insofar as the verb trepar , or climbed up, is typically associated in Spanish with
trees, here skyscrapers stand in for trees as cruel, artificial substitutes of natural
abundance that has been replaced by urban development. It is no wonder, then, that
the poetic voice longs for a watery, unhuman space, "2000 kms. fuera de la / RE-
ALIDAD," as in Portars poetic, human reality represents misery and hunger in this
overdeveloped world ("Poema 18" 19).
Because Portal was an Aprista, it is not surprising to find in her environmental-
ly-themed poetry both the conservationist sentiments of the Fiesta de la Planta and a
primary concern with land ownership through Pan-Americanism. Less evident in
her poetry are the traces of feminism, but an unarticulated feminist ethos can be
read in the speaker's affirmative relationship with the sea and contiguous spaces.
Conspicuously free of nationalist tropes, her poetry significantly, albeit implicitly,
engages the international values of Pan-Americanism by pressing forever beyond
national and earthly borders. Her sea is superlatively transnational and fluid, allow-
ing for what critic Hester Blum calls literary oceanic studies' "reorientation of criti-
cal perception" (671). Blum writes, "If methodologies of the nation and the postna-
tion have been landlocked, [. . .] then an oceanic turn might allow us to derive new
forms of relatedness from the necessarily unbounded examples provided in the mar-
itime world" (671). Portal's sea imagines a new form of relatedness, or subjectivity,
for a female revolutionary navigating the realities of global capitalism, nationalism,
and patriarchy.
From the outset of the collection, the speaker announces that she does not feel at
home on the earth and needs the sea as a sort of primordial world, which Unruh in-
terprets as an "antidote to modernity's alienation" ( Performing Women 181). In the
first poem of the collection, "frente a la Vida," she states,
NO TENGO PROCEDENCIA
amo la Tierra
porque vengo del seno de la Tierra,
pero tengo los brazos
tendidos al Mar. (6-9)
When she is later landlocked in "Poema 14," she buys a train ticket: "ahora que está
lejos el mar / yo resuelvo el problema de mi angustia / con el boleto del pasaje" (11-
13). Unfortunately, this terrestrial voyage does not cure her suffering, as "cada
mañana llega con su equipaje de esperanza / que resulta vacío" (16-17). The speak-
The sea, boundless and alive, gives form to her imagining a reality beyond the con-
fines of her body, which she associates with death. In this way, the sea as image and
signifier introduces Portal's poetic "I" to an experience akin to what theorist Timothy
Morton has called the "ecological thought." The sea, like Morton's ecological
thought, "overflows the thought that thinks it" by thinking past itself and its thinker
and encompassing all existence in a radically interconnected totality (3). In this way,
Although the antecedent to the hands' possessor is ambiguous, the closest noun,
"mañana," again couples the motifs of time and space, as both morning and coast
function as the limits of mysterious seaspace, which in the night envelops the
speaker like the "vientre negro de fiera amaestrada" (15). Here again, the embodied
experience of sea travel described by the speaker captures the "mesh" qualities of
Morton's ecological thought (15). Blurring the boundaries between time and space
and among air, land, and sea, the speaker attempts to give poetic form to an infinite-
ly inviting space, a kind of heimlich sublime that allows one to unravel her subjec-
tivity in order to see it picked up by the universe.
In addition to its meditations on temporal and earthly liminality, "Pacific
Steam" reminds us that the speaker's cosmic experience of the sea does not exclude
a more materialist discourse. As critic Patricia Yaeger reminds us, "The sea is just
another site where human relations take shape and connect through low-cost hard-
ware and the freedom of an unregulated environment" (532). Even in Portal's day,
the sea was becoming increasingly polluted, mined for oil and other animal and
mineral resources, and cris-crossed with humans, raw materials, and consumer
goods. Portal's poetry does not mention sea trash, overfishing, oils spills, or toxic
waters, but, as Yaeger points out, when ecocriticsm - which she defines as "an envi-
ronment-based analysis that refuses to essentialize nature" - is set in the ocean, it
gives way to "echocriticism, a practice of anachronistic reading inviting stories,
novels, and other imaginative works about the sea to provide echo chambers, sites
of wild or sober echolalia, for the most pressing questions about the ocean's and
oceanic creatures' survival" (538). By examining Portal's sea motif as an echo
chamber, we uncover how her poetry implicitly engages the values of Aprismo. Al-
though her poetry is far from being propaganda, neither is it what Haya de la Torre
considered bourgeois lyrics because it consistently challenges traditional poetic
form and questions artificial limits that convention imposes on self-expression and
realization. Portal's speaker does undertake a sort of individual quest into the depths
In contrast to the incarcerated man of the past, it is implied that today's man is free
by virtue of the sea, "el único libre bajo el cielo" (7). Similarly, the speaker express-
es a primal need to go to the sea. Born of the earth, she returns to her origins, which
in turn liberate her:
amo la Tierra
porque vengo del seno de la Tierra
pero tengo los brazos
tendidos al Mar. (5)
Here Portal's primordial relationship with the earth genders as feminine a pre-mod-
ern, pre-industrial, ecology-centered cosmology, resonating strongly with the essen-
tialist chords of ecofeminism. Merchant writes,
In just this way, the last verse of the poem underlines that the speaker's yearning for
the sea is not only physical, but also somewhat erotic and spiritual with the mention
of "carne" and "dios."
Despite Portal and Mariátegui 's romanticized recipes for a new world order by
way of the sea or a pre-Columbian land ethic, the fact remains that both sea and
land exist as pre-conditions for accumulating material wealth. Even though these
writers tried to imbue these spaces aesthetically with meanings of freedom, equality,
and justice, their cartographies could not be purged of their histories of materialist
semiotics. Thus, just as Read arrives at the conclusion that Mariátegui's ultimate
blunder was not being able to see land - however idealized - as a modus for control
and domination, the echo-poetics of the ocean as literary metaphor reel Portal's pro-
NOTES
1 See Finzer.
2 He cites the work of historians Luis Alberto Sánchez, Felipe Cossio del Pomar
and Percy Murillo Garaycochea in order to demonstrate the profound reach of the Fiesta.
3 For example, Elvira García y García's La mujer peruana bears a frontispiece
from the executive committee of the Segunda Conferencia Pan Americana de Mujeres,
which was part of the Tercer Congreso Científico Pan Americano that took place in Lima in
November 1924 and which awarded the publication of the two- volume encylopedic tome.
4 These poems are "frente a la Vida," "Pacific Steam," "Poema 14", "Poema 18",
"Espumas", "Mar de alegría", "El mar distante" and "El viajero de todos los mares," which
is dedicated to Portal's lover, whose pseudonym "Serafín Delmar also seems to answer to
Portal's love for the sea.
WORKS CITED
Blum, Hester. "The Prospect of Oceanic Studies." PMLA 125.3 (May 2010
Brum de Parra del Riego, Blanca Luz. "Mi canto al árbol." Boletín de la
Populares Gonzales Prada , No. 1 (enero 1927): 9. Facsimile Edition. E
Amauta, 1994. 205.
Bustamante, Cecilia. "Magda Portal y el Perú." Wiracocha, 14 febrero 201
Castro Morales, M. And Jorge del Valle Matheu. "Saludo a las Universida
Boletín de las Universidades Populares Gonzales Prada , No. 1 (enero 1
le Edition. Empresa Editora Amauta, 1994. 199.
Chepstow-Lusty, Alex and Mark Winfield. "Inca Agroforestry: Lessons f
bio 29.6 (Sep 2000): 322-28.
Cohen, Shaul E. Planting Nature: Trees and the Manipulation of Environm
in America. Berkeley: U of California P, 2004.
Cushman, Gregory T. Guano and the Opening of the Pacific World : A
History. New York: Cambridge, 2013.
Denevan, William M. "The Pristine Myth: The Landscape of the Americ
of the Association of American Geographers 82.3 (Sept. 1992): 369-85.
Evernden, Neil. The Social Creation of Nature. Baltimore: Johns Hopkin
esta de la Planta." Claridad: Órgano de la Juventud Libre del Perú 1.4
15. Facisimile Edition. Lima: Empresa Editora Amauta, 1994. 117.
Finzer, Erin. "Grafting the Maya World Tree: Cosmic Conservation in R
Folgar 's Llamaradas (Guatemala, 1938)." Interdisciplinary Studies in L
Environment (2014): 1-23. doi: 10. 1093/isle/isu 1 29.
P, 2006.
Weaver, Kathleen. Peruvian Rebel: The World of Magda Portal, With a Selection of her Po-
ems. University Park, PN: The Pennsylvania State UP, 2009.
Williams, Raymond. Marxism and Literature. New York: Oxford UP, 1978.
Yaeger, Patricia. "Editor's Column: Sea Trash, Dark Pools, and the Tragedy of the Com-
mons." PMLA 125.3 (May 2010): 523-45.