Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unilateral Nerve Injury
Unilateral Nerve Injury
There are no known anatomical connections between neurons that innervate homologous right and left body parts.
Nevertheless, some patients develop bilateral abnormalities after unilateral injury, a phenomenon often unrecognized and
not yet characterized. Therefore, we examined in rats the effects of ligating and cutting one tibial nerve on sensory
function and on density of innervation in hind paws contralaterally as well as ipsilaterally to the injury, at times between
1 day and 5 months after surgery. Punches removed from tibial- or sural-innervated plantar paw skin were immunola-
beled to quantitate epidermal nerve endings. Naive and sham-operated rats provided controls. Axotomized rats had
near-total loss of PGP9.5ⴙ innervation within ipsilateral tibial-innervated skin at all time-points. Adjacent ipsilateral
sural-innervated skin had persistent hyperalgesia without denervation, and robust axonal sprouting at 5 months after
surgery. Contralesional hind paws lost 54% of innervation in tibial-innervated epidermis starting 1 week after surgery
and persisting throughout. Contralesional sural-innervated skin had neither neurite loss nor sprouting. These results
imply that unilateral nerve injury can cause profound, long lasting, nerve–branch–specific loss of distal innervation
contralaterally as well as ipsilaterally. They discredit the practice of using tissues contralateral to an injury to provide
normative controls and suggest the possibility of rapid, transmedian postinjury signals between homologous mirror-
image neurons.
Ann Neurol 2004;55:639 – 644
Neuroanatomy textbooks show no connections be- strated that patients with postherpetic neuralgia (PHN)
tween neurons that innervate homologous areas of the after unilateral shingles have lost most innervation in
left and right sides of the body, and injuries usually are previously affected skin.3 On average, they have also
not thought to directly affect the opposite side. Despite lost half of the innervation in clinically asymptomatic
this, several studies suggest that unilateral injury affects mirror-image contralateral skin.3 These findings, now
contralateral (contralesional) tissues as well as those ip- confirmed,4 were attributed by many to undetected
silateral (ipsilesional) to the injury. Usually, contrale- spread of Varicella zoster virus into the spinal cord.
sional effects are restricted to specific areas, most com- However, because we, and others, have found contrale-
monly those that are mirror-image to tissues innervated sional effects after one-sided experimental nerve inju-
by injured nerves. This pattern demonstrates that the ries where there is no infection,5–7 we considered the
signals initiating contralesional effects are not systemic alternative: that contralateral loss of distal neurites is
and suggests neural mediation. initiated by ipsilateral axonal injury alone.
Early reports of patients with contralesional effects Animal studies have provided indirect support.6
come from S. Weir Mitchell, whose 1872 masterpiece, Contralesional changes in animals include changes
Injuries of Nerves and Their Consequences, presents ex- within sensory ganglia8 and spinal cord, some develop-
aminations of Civil War soldiers with meticulously ing just minutes after paw injury.9 Distal contralesional
characterized nerve and plexus injuries. Several with changes include reduced extravasation of intravascular
single-limb wounds developed bilateral- or contralateral- proteins (a C-fiber axon reflex)10 and formation of ad-
only pain or sensory loss (pp. 137, 146).1 Modern ditional neuromuscular junctions in muscles mirror-
studies confirm contralateral changes in some patients, image to those denervated by unilateral axotomy.11 Re-
including limb edema, loss of strength, and changes in ports of bilateral hind paw hyperalgesia after unilateral
bone metabolism, suggesting effects beyond mere al- injury demonstrate that contralesional changes affect
tered use.2 Examination of skin biopsies PGP9.5- behavior.12,13 Systemic lidocaine has different effects
immunolabeled to show nerve endings has demon- against the hyperalgesia that develops in the paws ipsi-
From the Nerve Injury Unit, Departments of Anesthesiology, Neu- Address correspondence to Dr Oaklander, Massachusetts General
rology, and Neuropathology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Har- Hospital, 55 Fruit Street, Clinics 3, Boston, MA 02114.
vard Medical School, Boston, MA. E-mail: aoaklander@partners.org
Received Aug 14, 2003, and in revised form Oct 28 and Nov 11,
2003 and Jan 3, 2004. Accepted for publication Jan 3, 2003.
Published online Apr 12, 2004, in Wiley InterScience
(www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/ana.20048
Results
Behavioral Testing
The results of behavioral testing of the lesioned rats
duplicate those previously published.19 Profound, long-
lasting mechanical allodynia and hyperalgesia, as well
as cold hyperalgesia, were present in all rats in the ip-
silateral sural-innervated territory only (Fig 2). Results
from sham-operated rats did not differ from those
from naive rats.
punches from the left (847 ⫾ 47) or right (952 ⫾ 28) as controls against which to compare data from rats
paw ( p ⱕ 0.36); therefore, data from left paws of naive that underwent axotomy 1, 3, or 7 days before death.
rats were used as controls. Sham operation in 12 rats
killed 3 weeks after surgery did not reduce the density Neurite Densities in Skin from the Paw Ipsilateral to
of innervation from that present in same-age naive rats Nerve Injury (Ipsilesional Paw)
( p ⱖ 0.98), so naive rats provided control values. Neu- Neurite densities from rats that had undergone axo-
rite densities at the tibial and sural biopsy sites differed tomy were compared with data from same-age naive
at the 5-month time point only ( p ⱕ 0.03), so data rats (see Fig 4) to determine the percentages given be-
from tibial- and sural-innervated skin punches from low. At 1 and 3 days only, postoperative edema in the
naive rats were analyzed independently to provide sep- ipsilesional paw artifactually lowered densities in sural
arate controls for tibial- and sural-innervated samples. (and presumably in tibial) territories by half, so these
ANOVA and post hoc analysis showed no significant data were discarded. However, the near-total neurite
time effect ( p ⱕ 0.41); therefore, data from naive rats loss in ipsilateral tibial-innervated punches was far
used for the 7-day postoperative time point were used greater: 97% loss at 1 day ( p ⱕ 0.03) and 99.8% loss
Fig 3. Fluorescein isothiocyanate–conjugated PGP9.5⫹ epidermal and dermal innervation in tibial-innervated plantar paw skin at
3 weeks after surgery. Near-total loss of PGP9.5⫹ neurites is evident ipsilaterally, and loss of half of neurites is visible in contrale-
sional uninjured mirror-image skin. SNI ⫽ spared nerve injury.