MUMBAI METRO RAIL CORPORATION
DESIGN/DOCUMENT REVIEW SHEET
Definitions
Status - P: Pending, C: Closed
Document Reference
No.
Ref.
1 JKC-GCC-MEP-SVN-180002-A4
Date: 18/11/2020
LDC comments DDC Comments Status Closure Date
Rev. Page No.
Noted.
Type 2 coordination is always done with local starter that too on
starter enclosed in one panel(unit). UGC05 breaker is at
500 A TPN MCCB are considered for TVS Panels.
remote(over 150m)/out of sight for TVE SWC, as per design
The same shall be checked as per TYPE 2
A4 requirement local circuit breaker in starter is inevitable. Type 2 P 10/11/2020
Coordination of Motor Load and as per
coordination with TVE motor is therefore not in scope of UGC 05.
Discrimation studies
Inputs for discrimination study will be obtained from TVE
requirements prior to obtaining the Closure certificate.
Noted &Closed C 13/11/2020
Noted Input for discrimination studies will be Conducted after
Kindly arrange Discrimination studies for the obtaining inputs (Load) from SWC. Thereafter consolidated P 10/11/2020
complete Electrical Schemetics Discrimination study will be performed and will be shared prior to
the closure certificate.
Noted &Closed C 13/11/2020
Noted. Please find the attached Type -2 Co-ordination chart
Star Delta starters are considered for Fire Panels. provided in the report in which 160A MCCCB has been
Kindly check the starting current of the motor recommended for Star Delta Starter. This is not final make, It is
P 10/11/2020
with Star Delta and design accordingly. 160 A will assured on finalisation of vendor the type 2 coordination shall
not suffice for 75 KW motor with sta delta started again be applied as per name plate rating of pump motor and
starter gear of approved vendor make.
Noted &Closed C 13/11/2020
 In Load calculation term defined as ECS panels,
TVS panels but in Mode Operation,
Noted & Revised calculation submitted.
Nomenclature are different as VAC panels. Kindly
use the same terminology at all places
Noted &Closed
As per Architect Drawings, False ceiling at Public layout of all services above the false ceiling height are likely to
ares is 3.5 Meter but Dialux calcualtion mounting reduce. the lighting calculations shall be revisited after finalization
height are considered as 3 Meter.
Noted &Closed
1. Cable Sizing, Short ckt, Earth strip, capacitor
Calculation.
a. Cable Sizing Calc-ASS1 and ASS2 :
%VD Main to be corrected and Voltage drop
calculations shall be corrected.
2 JKC-GCC-MEP-SVN-180002 A5 b. Design Methodology-VD :
Short circuit current at receiving end and sending
end shall be corrected.
2. Bus Duct Sizing
a. Fault Current at sec side of Transformer
formula shall be rechecked.
1.a Pending. Kindly check the VD at UPS Panel.
UDB will always be functional at normal supply as
well. Also provide the VD upto last circuit in UDB
which is always higher as circuit runs upto 100
meter.
1.b and 2.a Noted & Closed
P 10/11/2020
C 13/11/2020
The false ceilling drawing are 3.5 mtr. We have issues related to
P 10/11/2020
of false ceiling level.
C 13/11/2020
1. Cable Sizing, Short ckt, Earth strip, capacitor Calculation.
a. Cable Sizing Calc-ASS1 and ASS2 :
Main voltage drop is the voltage drop from terminal transformer
to MDB=0.18%. This is provided in Bus Duct Voltage Drop
calculation We have checked and find no error. Hence no change.
b. Design Methodology-VD :
In design methodology of short circuit the formula indicated in P 10/11/2020
the methodology have been corrected, how so ever formula used
in the spreadsheet is correct, therefore values in spreadsheet are
unchanged.
2. Bus Duct Sizing
For current from transformer from secondary refer "SVN-Fault
Level Calculation at MDB-1" This reference is now indicated in
Bus Duct Sizing
1. This is the online UPS so UDB will always feed from UPS & will
be functional at normal supply as well. UPDB voltage drop has 18/11/2020
been revised in the calculation.

3 JKC-GCC-MEP-SVN-180002
1. Cable Sizing, Short ckt, Earth strip, capacitor
Calculation.
a. Cable Sizing Calc-ASS1 and ASS2 :
i) Kindly provide backup data for Diversity factors
for Lifts & Escalators. Factor for ECS-04&5 is 1
and rest escalators is 0.8. 1. Cable Sizing, Short ckt, Earth strip, capacitor Calculation.
Factor for Lift 5 &3 is 0.8 and rest lifts is 1. a. Cable Sizing Calc-ASS1 and ASS2 :
Kindly justify the same. i) Diversity Factor for All eascalators will be is 0.8 & Diversity
c. ASS-2 Switch. Sizing : Factor for all Lift will be 1 also revised in the calculation. refer the
A6 P 18/11/2020
i) Status of UPS-3B(S&T) & PSD(Standby) is "S" attachment for backup.
but its Diversity/MD factor is 1. Kindly justify and
provide the backup for the same. c. ASS-2 Switch. Sizing :
i) Noted & Corrected in the calculation.

Contract No.: UGC 05

Document No.: JKC-GCC-MEP-SVN-180002
Rev. No. A6
Document Name: CRD Drawing Submission of the Design Calculations Electrical System - Vidyanagari Station
Date of Receiving: 18.11.2020
Discipline: MEP

Checked by Reviewed by Verified by