Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7398 14700 1 SM PDF
7398 14700 1 SM PDF
Hendra Heriansyah
Syiah Kuala University, Aceh
hendra_hrsyh@yahoo.com
Abstract
This paper discusses the difficulties and causes perceived by English
Department students of Syiah Kuala University in learning speaking and the
efforts made by them to overcome their difficulties. From both observation and
interview, this study reveals that all students encountered various difficulties in
English speaking ability. The prevalent problem faced by the students was ‘lack
of vocabulary’, while ‘being afraid of making mistakes’ was the prime cause of
problem which hindered them to speak. The students had striven to cope with
their problems in learning speaking, but their attempts had not been yet ample
and successful.
37
Lingua Didaktika Volume 6 No 1, Desember 2012
38 ISSN: 1979-0457
Speaking Problems - Hendra Heriansyah
Contractions, elisions, reduced vowels, etc; speaking the target language. The fourth is
all form special problems in teaching Low or Uneven Participation. Only one
spoken English. Students who do not learn participant can talk at a time if he or she is
colloquial contractions can sometimes to be heard, and in a large this means that
develop a stilted, bookish quality of each one will have only very little talking
speaking that in turn stigmatizes them. (3) time. This problem is compounded by the
Performance variables. One of the tendency of some learners to dominate,
advantages of spoken language is that the while others speak very little or not at all.
process of thinking as you speak allows From the explanation above, we can
you to manifest a certain number of draw a conclusion that students face
performance hesitations, pauses, back- difficulties in speaking that are related to
tracking, and corrections. Learners can such non linguistic problems as worry, fear,
actually be taught how to pause and shyness, no motivation, and low
hesitate. For example, in English our participation in class, etc. The purpose of
“thinking time” is not silent, we insert this study was to delineate the difficulties,
certain “fillers” such as uh, um, well, you the causes of difficulties, and efforts to
know, I mean, like, etc. One of the most overcome the difficulties in speaking by the
salient differences between native and students of English Department of Faculty
nonnative speakers of a language is in their of Teacher Training and Education of
hesitation phenomena. (4) Colloquial Syiah Kuala University.
language. Students should be reasonably
well acquainted with the words, idioms, B. Methodology
and phrases of colloquial language and get This study was conducted at the
practice in producing these forms. English Department of the Faculty of
Meanwhile, Ur (1996) eludes four Teacher Training and Education at Syiah
factors that make speaking difficult for Kuala University. The subjects of this study
second or foreign language students. The were all the third semester students at the
first is Inhibition. Unlike reading, writing English Department who got the lowest
and listening activities, speaking requires passing grades in speaking class. Many
some degree of real-time exposure to an students in these groups had low
audience. Learners are often inhibited performance in Speaking Class. They were
trying to say things in a foreign language in taking Speaking III. The focus of the study
the classroom, worried about making was on 10 students, selected from 25
mistakes, fearful of criticism or losing face, students. The selection was done by using
or simply shy of the attention that speech the students who got grade C (the lowest
attracts. The second is nothing to Say. Even passing grade) in Speaking II, and also
if they are not inhibited, we often hear based on information about the low
learners complain that they cannot think of performance students according to the
anything to say, they have no motive to lecturer. The lecturer said that the students
express themselves beyond the guilty were considered as low performers with
feeling that they should be speaking. The some indicators: (a) being afraid of
Third is Mother-Tongue Use. In classes speaking, (b) lack of vocabulary, and (c)
where all or a number of the learners share not being good at grammar. There were ten
the same mother tongue, they may tend to weak students in this class. The writer
use it; because it is easier and unnatural to chose the 10 students as they were who had
speak to one another in a foreign language, low performance in Speaking class. It was
and because they feel less ‘exposed’ if they also based on the preliminary research done
are speaking their mother tongue. If they by the researcher when he taught them in
are talking in small groups it can be quite Speaking II. To collect the data this study
difficult to get some classes particularly the used interview and observation as the main
less disciplined or motivated ones to keep instrument, conducted by the researcher
39
Lingua Didaktika Volume 6 No 1, Desember 2012
himself. An interview was carried out to avoid the impression of too formal
get the main data. The researcher inter- interview to the respondents.
viewed ten out of the 25 students. Each
student was asked with 3 questions, namely C. Finding and Discussions
(1) What difficulties did you face or feel in 1. Kinds of Student’s Difficulties in
speaking? (2) What were the causes of Speaking
difficulties? (3) What efforts did you make From ten respondents that were
to overcome the difficulties? In addition, interviewed, it was found that there were
the researcher also observed the speaking twelve kinds of difficulties that were faced
class. The observation was intended to by the students in speaking. The most
crosscheck the problems faced by the problems felt by the respondents were: lack
students in speaking in class. The of vocabulary, not confident to speak, not
observation was conducted using an used to talking in class, and difficult to
observation guide. express words or sentences.
The procedure of data analysis is as The difficulties faced or felt by the
follows. After interviewing, the data were students in speaking can be divided into
collected and translated into English. The two kinds of problems namely linguistic
data were grouped into problems, causes, problems and non-linguistic problems.
and solutions. Then, the data were analyzed There were three difficulties related to
based on the student’s difficulties in linguistic problems. They were ‘lack of
speaking, the causes of difficulty, the vocabulary’, ‘lack of grammar knowledge’,
student’s efforts in improving speaking in and ‘poor pronunciation.’ While, the 9
order to find the relationship of the difficulties dealt with non-linguistic prob-
problems, causes, and efforts to solve the lems were, ‘not being brave to speak’, ‘not
problems. being confident to speak’, ‘being afraid of
Two procedures were used to validate speaking’, ‘being afraid of making errors’,
the data in this study. The first was the ‘being afraid of being mocked by friends’,
involvement of the researcher in the ‘being nervous to speak’, ‘not used to
research including preparation of the study, talking in class’, ‘difficult to express words
data collection, data analysis, and data or sentences’, and ‘confused how to use
interpretation. The second was triangu- appropriate words.’
lation. In this case, the researcher compared 2. Kinds of Causes of Difficulty in
the data taken from interview with direct Speaking
observation. It was found that there were 9 causes of
A triangulation was done to verify the difficulty faced by the students with
data or information that the writer obtained linguistic problems. They were ‘lack of
from the respondents by looking at the vocabulary’, ‘seldom memorizing voca-
source of data repeatedly to get the same bulary, ‘words having more than one
conclusion. In terms of this, Hopkins meaning’, ‘being confused about how to
(1993) contends that technique of use appropriate words’, ‘lack of grammar
triangulation can increase the validity of a knowledge’, ‘seldom reading grammar
category in verifying data. books’, ‘poor pronunciation.’
To support the data to be more valid, 13 causes of difficulty related to non-
the writer clarified every student’s answer linguistic problems. They were ‘being
by asking them again each question that the afraid of making errors’, ‘being nervous to
writer asked to them, and to get reliable speak’, ‘not being confident to speak’,
data, the writer wrote the result of ‘often forgetting’, ‘dislike learning
interview as immediate as possible, not grammar’, ‘afraid of being mocked by
more than one day after the interview. The friends’, ‘not being used to talking in
researcher did not use tape recorder to class’, ‘better performance or ability in
speaking by other students’, ‘the use of
40 ISSN: 1979-0457
Speaking Problems - Hendra Heriansyah
Indonesian by other students’, ‘no friends (19) reading English books, (20) looking
at campus or home to practice English’, for difficult words by reading book then
‘difficult to understand the 12 tenses’, memorize them, (21) taking English course,
‘seldom hearing English from their teachers and (22) practice English at home.
at SMU’, and ‘ideas or opinions not All the above students’ efforts to
accepted by friends.’ overcome their difficulties in speaking
From the causes of the difficulty that matched with the characteristics of
were faced by the students in speaking, the successful language learners according to
writer found that one cause had some Rubin and Thompson. It was intended to
difficulties. It was given in detail the find justification for the students’ efforts to
difficulties of each cause. solve their problems.
There were 5 difficulties (‘not being Rubin and Thompson (1982, cited in
brave to speak’, ‘not being confident to Brown, 2001) note that there are 14
speak’, ‘not used to talking in class’, ‘being characteristics of successful language
afraid of speaking’, and ‘difficult to express learners in learning a second or foreign
words or sentences’) which had one cause: language. The 14 characteristics of
being afraid of making errors. Two successful language learners that are
difficulties (‘not being brave to speak’ and proposed by Rubin and Thompson, are all
‘nervous to speak’) came from one cause: unique characteristics of successful
not confident to speak. Two difficulties language learners. From 22 kinds of the
(‘being afraid of making errors’ and ‘not efforts that were used by the students to
being confident to speak’) had one cause: solve their problems, they only used 3 out
lack of grammar knowledge. Two diffi- of the 14 characteristics namely ‘they make
culties (‘not being confident to speak’ and their own opportunity for practice in using
‘difficulty expressing words or sentences’) language inside and outside the classroom’,
came from one cause : lack of vocabulary. ‘they learn certain production strategies to
From the number of causes of difficulty fill in gaps in their own competence’, and
above, we can conclude that most students ‘they are creative, developing a ‘feel’ for
stated that ‘being afraid of making errors’ the language by experimenting with
was their main problem. grammar and words’. Based on the result of
3. Kinds of Student’s Efforts in Speaking interviews many students said that their
Pertaining to the students’ efforts to efforts did not meet their expectations
cope with their difficulties in learning maximally. Perhaps, it might be due to the
speaking, it was ascertained that there were efforts that they had made from no. 6 to no.
22 attempts that they had done for these. 22 were deemed as common efforts. In
They were (1) practice English with addition, the students also did not have a
friends, (2) try to be braver in speaking, (3) variety of strategies and creativities to
making sentences from difficult words, (4) solve their problems. This may had caused
making English club, (5) sitting with their unsuccessful adequate efforts.
friends who give support to speak, (6) From the result of interviews with
looking up the dictionary for words, (7) speaking lecturers about the difficulties that
doing exercises on grammar book, (8) speaking students had, it was found that the
memorizing vocabulary, (9) reading difficulties faced by the students in
English grammar books, (10) reading speaking were ‘difficulty speaking’, ‘lack
English in order to get new ideas, (11) of vocabulary’, ‘lack of grammar know-
reading conversation books, (12) practice ledge’, ‘afraid of making errors’ and ‘less
English by themselves, (13) listening to the active in speaking.’
radio, (14) listening English conversation Four difficulties that Taiqin found were
cassettes, (15) listening to music, (16) ‘being afraid of making errors’, ‘losing
watching TV, (17) asking friends if any confident to speak’, ‘feeling uncomfortable
difficult words, (18) studying 12 tenses, to make mistakes’ and ‘not having ideas
41
Lingua Didaktika Volume 6 No 1, Desember 2012
about what to say.’ In this study the and they are forced to use English with the
researcher found two problems addressed lecturers at all the times.
in Taiqin’s finding, they were ‘being afraid After all the solutions that were applied
of making errors’ and ‘not being confident by the students, the researcher asked the
to speak or lose confident to speak. students whether the solutions that they had
From this study the researcher also used had been successful or not, and the
ascertained that there was an inter- students said that some solutions that had
relationship between problems and the been successful for increasing their ability
causes. In this case, problems could be the to speak and overcome their difficulties,
causes, and the causes could be the but there were also solutions that had not
problem. Some examples are as follows. been successful in coping with their
(1) ‘Not being brave to speak’ was caused problems.
by ‘being afraid of making errors’ and Some important suggestions are pro-
‘being afraid of making errors’ was caused posed. They are addressed to the following
by ‘not being brave to speak.’ (2) ‘Not people. Firstly, for the lecturers of language
being confident to speak’ was caused by skills, speaking skills do not stand alone
‘being afraid of making errors’ and ‘being but they are supported by the mastery of
afraid of making errors’ was caused by ‘not vocabulary, grammar, and pronunciation;
being confident to speak.’ (3) ‘Being afraid accordingly, the lecturers of these subjects
of speaking was caused by ‘being afraid of need to increase student’s mastery. The
making errors.’ ‘Being afraid of making input students for the English Department
errors’ was caused by ‘being afraid of may not have had high and sufficient
speaking.’ (4) ‘Nervous to speak’ was English ability when they entered Syiah
caused by ‘not being confident to speak.’ Kuala University. The lecturers should pay
‘Not being confident to speak’ was caused attention to the weak students such as those
by ‘nervous to speak.’ (5) ‘Not used to in this study. Remedial measures have to be
talking in class’ was caused by ‘being done if necessary so that the weak students
afraid of making errors.’ ‘Being afraid of are not left behind other students who,
making errors’ was caused by ‘not used to according to these students, had better
talking in class.’ The data above showed speaking performance.
that between problems and causes there Concerning the lack of vocabulary, as
was a cause-effect cycle. felt by the respondents, the suggestions
Regarding students’ efforts related to proposed by Brown (2001) can be
the difficulties in learning speaking the considered, namely the lecturers allocate
researcher classified the kinds of solutions specific class time to vocabulary learning,
that the students made to cope with their help students to learn vocabulary in
problems, from the 22 attempts the students context, play down the role of bilingual
only used three of Rubin and Thompson’s dictionary, encourage developing strategies
ideas about the characteristics of a for determining the meaning of words, and
successful language learner in learning a engage in “unplanned activities.”
second or foreign language. The second, lecturers of speaking the
In relation to this matter, the lecturers linguistic problems can be dealt with by the
of the Speaking class have also attempted lecturers of language element subjects
to solve the students’ problems by (vocabulary, grammar, and pronunciation).
encouraging the students to speak English, Speaking lecturers need to pay attention to
giving them a great deal of chances to non- linguistic problems. The most
speak, using English in class, asking them common non-linguistic problem faced by
to make English speaking environment, most students was “fear”. The lecturers
using English with the lecturers such as should make them brave to speak.
when the students want to meet him/her, Speaking lecturers should not criticize
any mistakes made by students in
42 ISSN: 1979-0457
Speaking Problems - Hendra Heriansyah
43
Lingua Didaktika Volume 6 No 1, Desember 2012
44 ISSN: 1979-0457