Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Red Flag Report PDF
Red Flag Report PDF
2020
Foreword
Dear Readers,
This publication aims to create awareness about Fraud Risks & Red flags.
“Fraud” is a real risk impacting Indian organizations to a greater extent. The techniques deployed
by fraudsters are complex and usually masked in a complex web of falsehood, forgery and cheating.
Businesses especially smaller ones that are most vulnerable find it very difficult to unearth frauds
and material control breaches. Therefore, we believe that dissemination of Red Flag Indicators Report
and related information (primary goal of this publication) would assist Corporates in developing robust
defense control mechanisms.
In Q2 of FY 2020-21 we have witnessed a variety of large and small value frauds that are summarized
for your benefit in this publication. ICAI has recently issued Draft Standards on Forensic Accounting
& Investigation and my colleague partner Akif Cheulkar has summarized the same in this publication.
SEBI on 29th September 2020 has decided that listed entities shall be required to disclose the details
of Forensic Audit initiated by them and the details of final report submitted. Further, management of
listed entities would be required to disclose the comments of the management on such Forensic Audit
Report.
It is famously said that forewarned is forearmed keeping this in mind our publication team has
researched on newspaper and electronic media stories from leading portals about fraud and red
flags. Post research a crisp compilation of red flag stories has been made for readers highlighting
the nature of breach, quantum of impact and modus of the operator to the extent available in public
domain.
Huzeifa Unwala
Sr. Partner
JHS & Associates LLP
3. Guidance 07
3 BANKING FRAUDS 08
1. Bank Fraud by manager and three others 08
7. CBI Raids In Madhya Pradesh Over ₹ 938 Crore Fraud Case Involving Oil Firm 10
8. Bank fraud: ED slaps biggest ever FEMA notice of ₹ 7,220 Crore on Kolkata firm 11
9. CBI files ₹ 1,400 Crore Bank fraud case against dairy product manufacturing firm 11
10. Promoters of a financial services enterprise involved in ₹ 729 Crore bank fraud 11
11. Two senior Jammu and Kashmir officials suspended in ₹ 250 Crore bank fraud case 12
4 TAXATION FRAUDS 13
1. Chennai Man arrested for ₹ 107 Crore GST Fraud 13
4. I-T department conducts raids regarding ₹ 1,000 Crore money laundering case 13
6. Madhya Pradesh Cement Firm Director Arrested Over ₹ 17 Crore Tax Fraud 14
5 INSURANCE FRAUDS 16
1. Two men staged fake car robberies to claim insurance money 16
6 CORPORATE FRAUDS 17
1. CBI case against Indian limited company for siphoning off funds from Mumbai airport. 17
5. SEBI bans 102 entities from markets for fraudulent trading in an Engineering
Services Firm 18
6. SEBI orders impounding of over ₹ 1.38 Crore in insider trading case of a Jewellery
Concern. 19
7. A leading financial corporation used 2.6 Lakh fraud accounts in fake branch to
siphon funds 19
7 FINANCIAL FRAUDS 20
1. Two arrested for duping people posing as customs officers 20
8 CYBER FRAUDS 21
1. Alina Point-of-Sale Malware Spotted in On-going Campaign 21
10. 7 VPN services leaked data of over 20 million users, says report 25
9 HEALTHCARE FRAUDS 27
1. Fake Covid-19 Reports issued by lab in Amritsar 27
10 GENERAL FRAUDS 29
1. PM-Kisan norms eased for Covid, TN probes ₹ 110 crore fraud, 18 held 29
I. Issued by: The Digital Accounting and Assurance Board (DAAB) of The Institute of Chartered Accountants
of India (ICAI)
IV. Applicability: FAIS are a minimum set of requirements that apply to all members of the ICAI when
performing assignments in forensic accounting and investigation
(a) Preface:
The Forensic Accounting and Investigation Standards (referred to as “FAIS” or the “Standards”) at a
broad level seek to provide:
i. The Professionals with the minimum standards for undertaking Forensic Accounting and Investigation
(FAI) assignments;
ii. The Users of FAI services with an indication of the quality of service that can be expected from such
engagements;
iii. The Regulators and Governmental agencies with an appreciation of what can be expected from FAI
services; and
(b) Framework:
STANDARDS
iii. Standards on Forensic Accounting and Investigation GLOSSARY OF TERMS
GUIDANCE
iv. Guidance IMPLEMENTATION | TECHNICAL
(iv) Guidance:
These are a set of guidelines, which include Guidance Notes, Implementation Guides and Technical
Guides. These guidelines are important for implementation of the FAIS’s and provide clarification for
their applicability under circumstances. They also assist the professional is designing the forensic
accounting procedures and investigations activities to be conducted under various situations and
circumstances.
Source: https://www.icai.org/post/icai-ed-forensic-accounting-investigation-standards
On 29th September 2020, SEBI in its Board Meeting decided that in order to address the gaps in availability of
information on forensic audit, listed entities shall make the following disclosures to stock exchanges, without
any application of materiality: -
i. The fact of initiation of forensic audit (by whatever name called) along-with name of entity initiating the
forensic audit and reasons for the same, if available;
ii. Final forensic audit report (other than for forensic audit initiated by regulatory / enforcement agencies), on
receipt by the listed entity, along with comments of the management, if any.
Source: https://www.sebi.gov.in/media/press-releases/sep-2020/sebi-board-meeting_47739.html
3. BANKING FRAUDS
7. CBI Raids In Madhya Pradesh Over ₹ 938 Crore Fraud Case Involving Oil Firm
Sector: Banking
Nature: Misappropriation of funds
Modus: Loan obtained by means of inflated financials and diverted the proceeds
Details: A CBI team on Saturday raided multiple locations in Madhya Pradesh's Morena over a bank
fraud case of over ₹ 938 Crore, involving an oil firm. It was alleged that forensic audit findings indicated
that the financials of the company, while applying for loan, were inflated, and that the loan amount was
misappropriated through fraudulent diversion. In 2015, banks tried to recover their loss by auctioning
their assets under the SARFAESI Act but failed due to unsatisfactory response to the bidding process,
Source: NDTV
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/y2ogrdcz
9. CBI files ₹ 1400 Crore Bank fraud case against dairy product manufacturing
firm
Sector: Banking
Nature: Diversion of bank funds
Modus: The firm falsified books of accounts, created false assets, liabilities and transactions with related
parties and diverted the bank funds
Details: The dairy manufacturing company is accused of ₹ 1,400 Crore fraud for cheating a consortium
of banks. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) filed a fraud case after a complaint from one of the
Banks. The company is accused for diversion of bank funds, sham transactions with related parties,
fabricated documents/receipts, falsified books of accounts and creation of false assets and liabilities.
Source: Hindustan times
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/y6gq5883
10. Promoters of a financial services enterprise involved in ₹ 729 Crore bank fraud
Sector: Banking
Nature: Cheating, collusion and misappropriation of funds
Modus: With the help of two bank employees the promoters siphoned off the credit amount.
Details: The two promoters of a group of financial services enterprises committed a ₹ 729 Crore fraud
by colluding with two bank officials against a subsidiary of the same enterprise. The promoters made
the subsidiary make fixed deposits of ₹ 750 Crore and later it was found that the bank had credited the
proceeds in a current account in the subsidiary’s name and later debited the sum without any prior
intimation. It is alleged that the promoters used the amount to square off the loan taken by them.
Source: Business Line
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/y4v3lvxe
4. I-T department conducts raids regarding ₹ 1000 Crore money laundering case
Sector: Taxation
Nature: Operating a money laundering racket through bogus transactions.
Modus: Obtained bogus advances from shell entities for opening retail showrooms.
6. Madhya Pradesh Cement Firm Director Arrested Over ₹ 17 Crore Tax Fraud
Sector: Taxation
Nature: GST fraud
Modus: Clandestinely supplied cement without payment of GST
Details: The GST intelligence officials have detected over ₹ 17 Crore tax evasion by a major cement
manufacturer in Madhya Pradesh and arrested one of its directors. They also conducted multiple
searches at various premises belonging to the cement manufacturer in the states of MP and UP. More
than four lakh tons of excess limestone has been procured of what has been declared in the formal
records of the company and the cement and clinker manufactured have been supplied secretly without
payment of GST.
Source: NDTV
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/y44p4v3y
6. Corporate frauds
1. CBI case against Indian limited company for siphoning off funds from Mumbai
airport.
Sector: Corporate
Nature: Misappropriation of funds
Modus: Funds were siphoned off using fictitious work contracts and revenue was under-reported
Details: Mumbai International Airport (MIAL) has to pay 38.7% of its revenue as an annual fee to
Airports Authority of India (AAI) and use balance earnings for airport's maintenance. Upon investigation
it was found that, promoters of a group company in MIAL, their executives and unidentified officials of
AAI siphoned off the funds for personal benefits of their family and relatives using bogus work
contracts, inflating the company's expenses, and under-reporting revenue. This fraud caused a monetary
loss of up to ₹ 705 Crore.
Source: Money Control
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/yb964jon
5. SEBI bans 102 entities from markets for fraudulent trading in an Engineering
Services Firm
Sector: Corporate
Nature: Fraudulent and manipulative trading.
Modus: Creating artificial volume of trading through connected entities.
Details: SEBI has barred 102 entities for a period ranging from one year to seven years from the capital
markets for being involved in fraudulent and manipulative trading in the shares of an engineering
services firm which had almost no trading of shares. In 2011, two new promoters acquired 60% shares
and through their connected entities controlled supply of the shares. They also went for a preferential
6. SEBI orders impounding of over ₹ 1.38 Crore in insider trading case of a Jewellery
Concern.
Sector: Corporate
Nature: Insider Trading
Modus: Avoided losses by insider trading conducted by the Chairman and his two daughters.
Details: SEBI has ordered an impounding of ₹ 1.26 Crore, ₹ 9.62 Lakh and ₹ 2.09 Lakh from Chairman of
the Jewellery company and his two daughters respectively for avoiding unlawful notional losses by
selling their shares. They avoided losses on the basis of price sensitive information which was not
public yet which was regarding the company’s poor quarterly results of 2017. The Chairman sold over
30 Lakh shares while his two daughters who are also the vice-presidents of the company, sold their
entire shareholding.
Source: SEBI
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/y4k9fdlm
7. A leading financial corporation used 2.6 Lakh fraud accounts in fake branch
to siphon funds
Sector: Corporate
Nature: Fake Branch and customer accounts
Modus: A leading financial corporation used 2.6 Lakh fraud accounts in fake branch to siphon funds
Details: The ‘branch’ created fake accounts using names of account holders who had already repaid in
full and had no obligations against the corporation, to siphon out ₹ 11,750 Crore. The branch does not
physically exist and is just a facade and cover-up created for giving effect for sanctioning and disbursal
of loans. Based on the emails recovered, the branch accounts got direct fund transfers from the corporations'
treasury accounts
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/yxs34usb
8. Cyber frauds
1. PM-Kisan norms eased for Covid, TN probes ₹ 110 Crore fraud, 18 held
Sector: General
Nature: Siphoning of funds through illegal beneficiaries
Modus: The officials involved in the scam allegedly shared the login and password details of beneficiaries
with brokers
Details: Under the PM-Kisan or Pradhan Mantri-Kisan Samman Nidhi Scheme, ₹ 6,000 is paid annually
to a member of a landholding family, in three instalments. Many people who were added onto the list of
beneficiaries illegally were reportedly unaware of the fraud with most of the spike coming from a few
districts. The men posed as officials asking them for their details so that they could receive “Corona
cash” from the government. Through such means, ₹ 110 Crore-plus was siphoned off
Source: Indian Express
Web Link: https://tinyurl.com/y3w9tsxb
Huzeifa Unwala
Maharashtra Lead Partner
With respect to information available herein, JHS does not make any warranty, express or implied,
including the warranty of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose, or assume any liability
or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of such information. JHS has placed
reliance on the sources disclosed under specific media story item and has not made efforts to
vouch for their accuracy or completeness.
Reproduction, redistribution and transmission of any information contained herein are strictly
prohibited. JHS shall not be liable for any claims or losses of any nature, arising indirectly or directly
from the use of the data or material or otherwise howsoever arising.
Mazgaon Office
Ground Floor, Shop No. 11A, 345,
New Sai Niketan CHS Ltd.,
Dr. Mascarenhas Road, Mazgaon,
Mumbai, Maharashtra - 400 010