Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Computer-Aided Concrete Mix Proportioning: Aci Journal Technical Paper
Computer-Aided Concrete Mix Proportioning: Aci Journal Technical Paper
The hetrogeneous nature of concrete and concrete materials creates Linear regression
numerous variables which influence the properties of fresh and hard-
If the relationship between the independent and de-
ened concrete. In the AC! 2Jl.l-77 method of mix proportioning, a
set of tables obtained from the observation of a large number of trial
pendent variables can be expressed as a straight line, it
mixtures are used. The relationship between the different variables in is called linear regression. This relationship is called
these tables are formulated into equations. Simple nonlinear regres- simple linear regression if it involves only one indepen-
sion and multiple nonlinear regression equations were used to derive dent variable x as shown
the relationships between the variables involved. The regression anal-
ysis was done by using the computer program Statistical Analysis
System (SAS). A computer program was writtten for proportioning
(1)
the different ingredients of concrete using the derived equations.
where e is the error between the observations and the
Keywords: age-strength relation; aggregates; compressive strength; computer regression line. The intercept bo and the slope b, are un-
programs: concretes; curing; mix proportioning; regression analysis; statistical
analysis; temperature; water-cement ratio.
known constants.
A regression model that involves more than one in-
The hetrogeneous nature of concrete and concrete dependent variable is called a multiple regression
materials creates numerous variables which influence model. The model
the properties of fresh and hardened concrete. The pri-
mary objective of mix proportioning is to select suit-
able proportions of the various ingredients of concrete
which will yield fresh concrete of desired placeability is called a multiple linear regression model with x,, x2 ,
. . . xk as k independent variables. The parameters b
and consistency, and hardened concrete having the
specified strength and durability. In addition, the de- b,, h2, . . . bk are called the regression coefficients and
sired quality of concrete is to be achieved at a reason- e is the error. The method of least squares is used 2 to
estimate the regression coefficients, that is, the sum of
able cost. In the ACI 211.1-77 method of mix propor-
the squares of the deviations between the observations
tioning, a set of tables obtained from observing a large
number of trial mixtures are used. The usual procedure and the regression line is a minimum.
is to interpolate the values in these tables for certain
Nonlinear regression
given material properties of aggregates, the required
It was found that occasionally the straight line
slump for fresh concrete, and the compressive strength
regression model is inappropriate, determined from the
for hardened concrete. The relationship between the
different variables in these tables are formulated into lack of fit between the given data and the regression
equations by using regression analysis. equation. Sometimes it is known from the underlying
theory that the relationship between the variables is
REGRESSION ANALYSIS nonlinear. There are two general types of curves, poly-
Regression analysis is a statistical technique for nomials and exponential or logarithmic, that can be
used as regression equation for nonlinear models . The
modeling and investigating the relationship between
two or more variables. In general, suppose that there is relationship
a single dependent variable or response y that is related
to k independent variables, say x,, x2 , • • • , xk. There-
Received Nov. 5, 1982, and reviewed under Institute publication policies.
lationship between these variables is called a regression, Copynght © 1983~ Amencan Concrete Institut_e. All rights reserved, including
equation. This is also called the regression of y on x,, the makmg of co~tes unless permiSSion JS obtamed from the copyright propri-
etors: Penment dtScusSton wtll be published in the May-June 1984 ACI JouR-
x2, . . . , xk. NAL tf recetved by Feb. I, 1984.
In the multiple nonlinear regression having two in- The relationship between the different variables given
dependent variables X 1 and x 2 , the function is repre- by Tables 2 and 3 and Fig. 1 and 2 are dervied by using
sented by Eq. (7). In these relations there are two independent
variables; therefore the multiple nonlinear regression
(7) expression given by Eq. (7) is used. The independent
variables are slump and maximum aggregate size in Ta-
where a, b, and c are the regression coefficients. Take ble 2, fineness modulus of sand and maximum aggre-
the natural logarithm to make it a multiple linear gate size in Table 1, compressive strength of concrete at
regression as follows 28 days and age of concrete in Fig. 1, and age of con-
crete and temperature of the moist curing room in Fig.
logy = log a + b log X 1 + c log X2 (8) 2. The various relations obtained are as follows:
1. For non-air-entrained concrete (Table 2)
which can be written as
284.60 (slump, inf 1
(lOa)
where y = logy, A = log a, XI = log XI, and x2 =
log X 2 • Eq. (9) is solved using multiple regression anal- 218.80 (slump, mm) 01
ysis to get the parameters A, b, and c. The regression water kg/m 3 (R 2 0.95)
coefficient a in Eq. (7) is found from Eq. (6). (max agg. size, mmY' 18
(lOb)
FORMULATION OF EQUATIONS
The regression analysis was done by using the com- For air-entrained concrete (Table 2)
puter program Statistical Analysis System. 3 The SAS
output gives the regression coefficients A, b, and c as 255.30 (slump, in.) 0 11
water lb/yd 3 (R 2 0.89)
defined in Eq. (5) and (9). The coefficient a can then be (max agg. size, in.) 0148
found from Eq. (6). The SAS output also lists a quan- (l1a)
Slump (70
in. mm in. mm)
1-2 30-50
350 (205) 335 (200) 315 (185) I 300 (180) 275 (160) 260 (155) 240 (145)
354' (209) 336 (201) 312 ~ 296 (177) 276 (163) 262 (156) 243 (147)
- - - - - -
385 (225) 365 (215) 340 (200) 1325 (195) 300 (175) 285 (170) 265 (160)
3-4 80-100 385 (227) 365 (218) 340 (200) 323 (192) 300 (177) 285 (170) 265 (160)
- - - --- - - -
6-7 150-180
410 (240) 385 (230) 360 (210) I 340 (205) 315 (185) 300 (180) 285 (170)
409 (241) 389 (231) 361 (213) 343 (204) 319 (188) 303 (180) 282 (170)
- - - -~- - - -
A1r-entramed concrete
305 (180) 295 (175) 1280 (165) 270 (160) 250 (145) 240 (140) 225 ( 135)
1-2 30-50 (145)
309
-
(184)
-
296 (178) 279 (166) 267
-
(161) 251
- ~ 241
-
227
-
(138)
340 (200) 325 (190) 1305 (180) 295 (175) 275 (160) 265 (155) 250 (150)
3-4 80-100 339
-
(201)
-
325 ~94) 306 (181) 293
- ~ 276
- ~ 264
-
(158) 249
-
(151)
365 (215) 345 (205) 1325 (190) 310 (185) 290 (170) 280 (165) 270 (160)
6-7 150-180 (169) (161)
363
-
(215)
-
348 (208)
---
327 (194) 314
-
(188) 295
- ~ 283
-
267
-
• Adapted from Recommended Practice for Selectmg Proportions for Normal and Heavywe1ght Concrete (ACI 21 I. 1-
77). For complete table see Reference I.
'Underlined quantities are calculated from regression analysis [Eq. (10) and (II)].
where f: compressive strength of concrete after !,. = 0.192 (f; )1°5 (t) 043 lblin. 2 (MPa) (R 2 = 0.87) (15)
28 days in lb/in. 2 (MPa)
wlc water-cement ratio 5. The relationship between the percentage compres-
3. Volume of coarse aggregate per unit volume of sive strength, age in days, and the temperature of cur-
concrete (Table 3) is ing as in Fig. 2 is given by
314 ACI JOURNAL I July-August 1983
o/ofc = 0.755 (t)0 ·557 (7) 0731 (R 2 = 0.98) (16) U)
I~
where compressive strength of concrete lb/
zO TEMPERATURES GIVEN
fc oco
Uc:\.1 ARE THE MEAN TEMP-
in. 2 (MPa) ERATURES OF MOIST
w/c water-cement ratio u..cr CURING ROOM
Oo
t age of concrete in days :z:U..
I-,....
f: compressive strength of concrete after (!){)