Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Feminism in The Art of Virginia Woolf PDF
Feminism in The Art of Virginia Woolf PDF
This document is brought to you for free and open access by Lehigh
Preserve. It has been accepted for inclusion by an authorized administrator
of Lehigh Preserve. For more information, please contact
preserve@lehigh.edu.
.,._.. ,.. I
p ~ - -..- - - ~ - .... ___ ~-- -··-~---.~--~···--,.···-·~·-·-.-....... _ _ , . , .•. ,• • • . • " -.• . - , ~ , - .... ~ - ... - . . . ~ ......... - ....
.... ,.••
l .
...
..p.1
by
Patricia L. Richards
A Thesis
of Lehigh University
..:·
Lehigh University
1973
•'1c.,
' ,.,...,
Certificate of Approval
(date)
..::
Professor in <;;harge
Chairman of Department
••
11
....
', r ,.,._
--,·· .
Acknowledgment ;~-·- -·
',.
.;-.r" ...
r ..
. .. ~-
...
•••
111
.
·, ..,.
-~
.
-
,- ~---·
..,:
I
,,
Contents
Page
.Abs tr·a ct .. . . •.. . . • ., . .. .•. • .·.. . . -~-~.'lt, •. ..•. .• • !.: • '.•: •. • •. • .. .• • • • .. .• • •. f • • .•.•: •. ~ l
Chapter
I. Intro·ductic5:n .
• •
. '
• • • •
'
• • ·,• .•
:
'
.
:,e
..· t·· . .
•. ·.•.• ' • •
.
•. • • • • •
. ·.· .
• ' • ... •
..
,•. '. • • •. • • ' •. 3
'
'
I
IV. Veils of Anonymity: Creation of Images that. I1·
I,I
Con.c·.~,al Woman in the Present ......•. ,,;•.. .-.••... :....
Vita
'.
•
lV
,,., ···,
Abstract
Myths of the past are studied as they are ~sc·ussed irt the non-
woman
'
are present which portray woman as being either extremely
show that Ms. Woolf moved beyond this dualism and developed
·.~
• • • ' ' • ,.i,' •• ~~ . . . . . . . '~1.' t:,·;·:.---: - ... '
. ·.'
.'!
J .
presence who has been concealed and forced into a state of ano-
same veils indicating that there are strong parallels between Ms.
Virginia Woolf asked early in this century and which women are
lowing Virginia Woolf, the women of today are seeking answers to- -
this question. They seek new female images., especially new self-
images, which will allow them to move beyond the sex-role stereo-
types that have botllld them in the past. More urgently, however,
they need strong and secure self-image s that will free them from
the guilt they have been _conditione d to feel if they choose not to re ..
finally be free and strong enough to find her own answer to Virginia
,-;..-.
Woolf 1 s concise but infintely complex question. (
.2
. ,~-• ,•. ~,~',• , , ,.,.•t..,·•~,,---.,·-~:;-. _ _ ~--~,,"\ ·~,,·. > • ..,;, ,• "~II",.,-':'~, ,1,~•i>f.o,~r"<"• •• r. • '"'°'' r~ • '' • •
.,
Virgi nia Woolf , a woma n whose art so often dealt with wome n,
expre ssed her views on the oppre ssion of wome n with force in her
nonfi ction. Her essay s., biogr aphie s, and books conve y her deep
conce rn about the cultu rally impo sed disab ility of her sex. In-
volve ment with quest ions regar ding the positi on of wome n did not
end with her nonfi ction, howe ver. Her novel s are domin ated by
wome n who are conce rned in one way or anoth er with the probl em
rent them es of her fictio n are relate d to her own perso nal confl icts :-r
a_s_ a, woma n and artist . Paral lels can be drawn betwe en many of
these them es and majo r issue s of the femin ist move ment. In this
paper I will attem pt to analy ze the art of Virgi nia Wool f and to re-
late it to the quest ions about wome n which are being raise d and.
Virgi nia Wool f looke d back in retro spect in analy zing the prob-
lems of wome n. In doing so she seems -to--h ave antici pated the
prese nt resur gence of the femin ist move ment. Her art utiliz ed
this comb inatio n of antici pation and retro spect in the devel opme nt of
I .
•
.::, .; _.,:..
.. 1.,
ment when anticipation flows into retrospect. 1 The problem of
this paper will be that of pointing out some ideas that may be ex-
-\.l..
"f.
I,
I
: ~ .
,4.
~-=- ...
...----·.- -
women in fiction was based upon two papers read to the Arts So-
..\
''
o.f the ideas mentio ned in this essay relate to specific concep ts '•
·which have been explore d and researc hed more comple tely in the
/
literatu re of the presen t-day women 's liberati on movem ent. Ms.
Woolf seems to have underst ood what has only recentl y been ques-
tioned in depth.
One such conce·p t that trouble d Ms. Woolf conside rably is the
discrep ancy so readily appare nt when one compa res the image of
'
women as portray ed (largel y by men) in fiction with the contras ting
She domina tes the lives of kings and conque rors in fie-
s
tion; in fact she was the slave of any boy whose par-
ents forced a ring upon her finger.. Some of the most
inspired words, some of the most profound thoughts in
literature fall from her lips; in real life she could
hardly read, could scarcely spell, and was the prop-
erty of her husband.
These studies deal with the contrast between the images ··as pre-
senteg and the reality of the lives of actual women. I wish to"spend
. priate here for two reasons. First of all, these women, with Vir- -..- --r-f.. .
legend regarding images of woman. They too point out what Ms.
. 6
: •:,; ... ··-
,•
I
V , _ . . . ,, ...
novelso
Cecelia Wallac e has written about her histori cal investi gation
finding s are worthy of comme nt. She finds that during the period of
good or evil was prevale nt. She studies the cult of the Mother -
istic in nature. There was a good aspect (fertile soil was provide d)
.
and an evil one (inferti lity, volcano es, and earthqu akes). Sacri-
·-· fices·-h ad to be made-- someti mes of h·uinan victim s--to appeas e this
Ms. Wallac e also,·po ints out -the connec tion of woman with the
·cults of the dead. The ancient s recogn ized the close relation ship
betwee n the good and evil aspects of woman . Woman , as the source
. of life, was ultimat ely the one who began the ·proces s that ended iri
death. Hence, the rites of the dead were turned over to women .
This associa tion of feminin ity with the power of life and death is
an extrem ely import ant one in myth and legend. It is at least par ...
tially respon sible for many attitude s concern ing women which pre-
in religio us myth and legend are conduc ted by Kate Millett and
:1'
•.,: ." .
.)
·~· '
., ... ,1• .... ,,, ;'~""~ . ,_ _ r,,, ,, . ltiA !119Mllt. Ida c!M¥1 Ill.II
",•
,-,l',1. '
Simon e de Beaw .oir. Each write r discu sses both the good and evil
aspec ts of the femin ine dicho tomy. I have decid ed to includ e here a
summ ary of their resea rch regar ding sever al myths which are
:and the begin nings of evil- -the tale of Pand ora and the Biblic al
story of Adam and Eve. She expla ins each of these legen ds as being
basic ally storie s of the origin s of sexua l know ledge and activi ty in
human ity.- In each of these myth s a fathe r figure punis hes his chil-
Alter nate versi ons of the myth of Pand ora point up the dicho t-
Qmy in the image of the woma n as be~ng eithe r good or evil. In both
storie s Pand ora, the first woma n, was endow ed with- all the gifts of
the gods. Her name mean s all-gi fted. She was creat ed by Jupit er
and sent to Prom etheu s and his broth er Epim etheu s and becam e the
wife of the latter . In the first versi on of the story she was sent as
a punis hmen t to the ·Titan s and man becau se the Titan s had stolen
fire from heave n and man had accep ted it. The secon d story ex-
plain s that Jupit er sent Pand ora to the Titan s and mank. ind as a
bless ing. In eithe r case Pand ora is respo nsibl e for the comin g of
evil into the world . ~n the first versi on Pand ora opene d a box in the
··hou se of Epim .etheu s which had .conta ined all kinds of evils. Her
curios it_y overc ame. her and she looke d insid e. All the evils escap ed
8
'·
.
:
,._ JI ' ~,
, I
and scattered. She replaced the lid but nearly everything had es-
.l.
opened the lid carelessly and all the blessings were lost except
~
!
I
\
sexual activity are seen as the real evils, and the punishment that
and activity. 5
..
it too cites the female as the principal cause of suffering and evil.
Kate Millett stresses the enormous power this myth still holds for
"":•' .
sciousness is the Eden legend and how utterly its patterns are
planted in our habits of thought (p. 52). She interprets the myth as
is blamed for being tempted to eat of the fruit of the tree of knowl-
I'
edge of good and evil. The sexual implications of the story are
..J
pointed out: the Hebrew verb for ''eat'' can also mean intercourse,
. -
. ..
(I
·'!
.......
,_.,
.·_ ··:' .;··,'
·. •-\.. ··J •.,· ..
.
1' •• ~ \ , • . -••• -, ~--·1 ,~ • ••
and the serp ent is real ly a phal lic sym bol. Tem pted by the phal lic
snak e, Eve is give n ·prim ary blam e for Ada m's part icipa tion in sex.
Both are puni shed as in the Pand ora myth . The real crim e of Adam
Simo ne de Beau voir also does a very com preh ensi ve stud y of
the dual istic natu re of wom an as trac ed thro ugh the myth s and
lege nds of antiq uity. She show s how throu ghou t histo ry wom an has
alwa ys been rega rded as the othe r: thus she was neve r real ly al-
lowe d to be hum an. "Con dem ned to play the part of the othe r,
wom an was also cond emn ed to hold only unce rtain pow er: slav e or
idol, it was neve r she who chos e her lot. tt 6 Simo ne de Beau voir
ques tions the dual ism that is part of this othe rnes s. She says :
But if wom an is depi cted as the Pray ing Man tis, the
man drak e, the Dem on, then it is mos t confu sin·g to
find in wom an also the Mus e, the Godd ess Mot her,
Beat rice.
As grou p sym bols and soci al ty·pe s are gene rally de-
fined by mea ns of anto nym s in pair s, amb ivale nce
•
will seem to be an intri nsic qual ity of the Eter nal
Fem inine . The sain tly moth er has for corr elati ve the
crue l step moth er, the ange lic youn g girl has the per-
vers e virg in; thus it will be said som etim es that . ,... , '
Mot her equa ls Life , som etim es that Mot her equa ls
dedi cate d to the devi l (pp. 238- 239)
. If wom an in the guis e of Pand ora or Eve was resp onsi ble for
~•. ·-~,I.•·•.-.,.• , - .
-, -··
brin ging evil into the worl d, wom an was also the ·sou rce of man 's
10
.
'
salvation in the person of the Virgin Mary. The virginity cult that
because Mary willingly _acc-epts her subservient role with the words,
:f,1 :am the servant of the: Lord" (p. 160).'. Thus, part of the awe-
. II
11·
_
.................: ,... ~
' l • ' ,~ •• • ,. • ·- • J ' "'
.....
._.
·/'
novel The Waves in the J)er~on of Susan~ Susan is on.e of the six 0
~- friends whose lives are traced through early childhood to late adult-
hood. Even as a young woman she identifies with nature-- ''I am not
a woman, but the light that falls on this gate, on this ground. I am
I
.-·
the seasons, I think sometimes , January, May, November ; the mud,
the mist, the dawn. irl · When she is slightly older the same wish to
bearing crops in rotation; in the summer heat will dance over me;
in the winter I shall be cracked with the cold. But heat and cold
12
0 .,
• 0
·~••'I,, ........._
, • ' · , · - ~, J \ - ' • ' • • •
piness. Yet more will come, more children; more cradles, more
baskets in the kitchen and hams ripening; and onions glistening; and
gale; now brushing the wet grass, now whirled up" (p. 295). As a
more mature woman she can look back on her life and say that "l
daughters, once nettled over like fruit in their cots, break the ·
meshes and walk with me, taller than I am, casting shadows on the
Daphne: ''• . • she being part, she was positive, of the trees at
home. • . being laid out like a mist between the people she knew
best, who lifted her on their branches as she had seen the trees lift
the mist, but it spread ever so far, her life, herself. 11 2 To Lucy
··..:.i
it in the umbrella standtt (pp. 43-44). When Richard thinks of her
he associates her with f~owers and wishes "- -to come in holding
13
. ....,;' :· '\· .. ··
·
I •, ,,,, 0
/"
~· .' • - • • I
.... · ,...
• t "t'-'' .'.'
···- ~«.)r'
·.1..;
~·i.--· .•
.
taste in gold; any number of flowers, roses, orchids, to celebrate
about her.. " (p. 174). Later she is described as a kind of sea
nymph. 11
She wore ear~rings, and a.silver-g reen mermaid 1 s dress.
.-•
Lolloping on the waves and braiding her tresses she seemed, having
flowered fruit tree laid with leaves and dancing boughs. 113
And later
''she grew still like a tree which has been tossing and quivering and
'
now, when the breeze falls, settles, leaf by leaf, into quiet" (p.
~ 77). She is a Greek Goddess to Mr. Bankes, who "saw her at the
.:-· - r ., .
phodel to compose that face'' (p. 177). Mr. Tansley sees her as a
goddess of nature "with stars in her eyes and veils in her hair, with
and taking to her breast buds that had broken and lambs that had
•,
_fallen; with the stars in her eyes and the wind in her hair 11 (p. ZS).
,, ~-
14
,•'•
c\'l"
al ti
.., ,, , ,• ,\•.,.~ 1, .. ,.,,r~•" •,-,, -; ,.,,~•~ ,J.><•'•-'~J,~•1•11,,..•;~.n,,-,•.,.••'~';~,."C>,,!f.-,,J..., .~'•"'"'·'.i,, .',11·1•• ••1",.va.~,-.,..-;-r,,,•t,1,-;r••-;--.,,.••, 1 .... ~._.,,.~1;,••\,-1.'>•l''°"" '"r•" ' , . , , , . , ,•• ~ , ' r' •t , •·•
lighthouse: "she praised herself in praising the light 11 (p. 97). She
.ct>me sight to travelers in the flux. People who are lost look to her
£or direction. It is significant that all these ideas can also be re-
looking at the same time animated and alive as if all her energies
were being fused into force, burning and illuminating. • • this deli-
woman of the age of chivalry, the lady. of the fountain in the Mabino-
•
geon who provides water and food to Owain. S·he is described by a
. .._...:...,.
maiden as being "the fairest, and the most chaste, and the most
--
liberal, and the most noble of women. She is my mistress, and she
15
'.
is called the Countess of the Fountain. 115
The descriptio n might
have been uttered by Lily Briscoe about Mrs. Ramsay and the Vir-
..
gin Mary in the fountain imagery. Litanies from ~he Middle Ages
address the Virgin Mary: ''Most high Virgin, thou art the fertile
Dew, the -Fountain of Joy, the Channel of pity, the Well of living
characteri zations, one might be led to make the as sum·ption that she
-~::r
is as guilty as the male writers she criticizes in A Room of One•s
Own. She does use the classic mythic devices to some extent in her
acterizatio ns· so that the women she creates are not simply ideals in
the guise of Daphne or the Virgin Mary. Her women are far too
complex for this type of rendition. She forces them to jump from
16 ' ' ~ .....,. ~-. -..·.. ..
·.•-::-
. ,i;;.
the pedestals on which men, as writers and as characters in her
novels, have placed them. They shatter the ideals. They assert
their humanity.
'~· '
with the vision of a very real woman-'wh en Susan says that she
"feels Jenny 1'·s laughter curl its tongues of fire round me and light
which I at once hide under the tablecloth 11 (p. 259). This same de- .•
. ..
diminish your hostility, your green eyes fixed on mine, and yo·ur
shabby dress, your rough hands, and all the other emblems of your
happiness., and fruit growing, and children scattering the house with.,
oars, guns, skulls, books won for prizes and other trophies. I am
17
" :: '
·.,.·:-
under her jealous eyes at one long table her own children, always
of motherhood:
limitations. She feels a frustration because she has not been able
(p. 308). She says that she can 1 'feel the waves of life tossed,
like a young bird, unsatisfied, for something that has esca·ped me"
(p. 338).
·,
qualities reminiscent of a sea nymph, she isn't really one for she is
18
' .•'
;.,; :· .
,· :;·,.,·, ', ·.~..
' .' }, . ~
,
.,\, -' ' ..
', . ,
growing older: "But age had brushed her; even as a mermaid might
behold in her glass the setting sun on some very clear evening over
prudery, her woodenness were· all warmed through now" (p. 264)0
ting down. I shan't tell her anything about it., he thought. for she ls
grown older" (p. 60). Clarissa is also very aware of ''feeling her-.,~-~'
.•'~ '.·;
self suddenly shrivelled, aged, breastless, the grinding, blowing,
flowering of the day., out of doors, out of the window., out of her
body and brain which now failed" (p. 45 ). At times Clarissa may
ridiculous little face, beaked like a birid 1 s" (p. 14). Clarissa wish-
"She would have been, like Lady Bexborough, slow and stately;
prudishness and feels that she has failed Richard: ''she could not
.. . .
I. ' "
.•. ,, ·o--·--··· i,,~·· r - ', . _)
•
.
throu gh some contr actio n of this cold spirit , she had failed him''
{p. 46).
The huma n aspec ts of Clari ssa Dallo way exten d beyon d mann er
and physi cal appea rance . Her great est fault seem s to lie in her so-
cial aspir ation s. We are shown the rathe r unple asant qualit ies
which accom pany the maint enanc e of a socia l positi on. Peter ob-
serve s that Clari ssa Dallo way "fritt ered her time away., lunch ing.,
dining ., giving these inces sant partie s of hers., talkin g nonse nse,
sayin g thing s she didn 1t mean , blunti ng the edge of her mind., losing
' . ~
., her discr imina tion'' (pp. 118-1 19). He also critic izes Clari ssa•s
socia l strivi ng: "The obvio us thing to say of her was that she was
world ly; cared too much for rank and socie ty and gettin g on in the
world " {p. 115). Sally , in spite of her friend ship with Clari ssa, is
aware of her socia l arrog ance and feels that "Clar issa was at heart
a. snob- -one had to admi t it., a snob' ' (p. 289). Even Clari ssa her- ..•
self is aware of her motiv ations and her prete nse in socia l situa-
tions: "half the time she did things not simpl y, not for thems elves; _
but to make peopl e think this or that; perfe ct idioc y she knew 1? (pp.
13-14 ). Clari ssa know s that ' 1She had schem ed; she had pilfer ed.
She was never wholl y admi rable . She had wante d succe ss'' (p. 282).
Mrs. Rams ay is also allow ed her huma nity despi te the fact that
....
she seem s at times to be Moth er-Go ddess ., Natur e Deity , and the
20
! ....
-.,.&,: ••••
.. • ·-:, ·,,..t'
·.. ·- ......
beauty in the midst of life constan tly moving , alterin g. Mr. Bankes
11 When she looked in the glass and saw her hair grey, her cheek
sunk, at fifty, she thought , possibl y she might have manage d things
better- -her husban d; money; his books" (p. 14). The proces s of
growin g older bothers her to some extent: "But indeed she was not
jealous , only, now and then, when she made herself look in the glass
a little resentf ul that she had grown old, perhap s, by her own
Like Clariss a Dallow ay, Mrs. Ramsa y finds fault with her own
.I
motiva tions "all this desire of hers to give, ~to help, was vanity.
For her own self-sa tisfacti on was it that she wished to help, to
give, that people might say of her, '0 Mrs. Ramsa y! dear Mrs.
Ramsa y. • • Mrs. Ramsa y, of course r and need her and send for
Zl
Like Susan, Mrs. Ramsa y is· not comple tely fulfille d in her
role as wife and mother . She wishes occasio nally to have had time
here- -those two things she would have liked to do, herself . But
how? With all these childre n? When they were older, then perhap s
she would have time; when they were all at school" (p. 89). She
looks back over her achieve ments and asks herself , 11 But what have
comple tely good nor comple tely evil, extrem ely beautif ul nor~~x-
..
tremel y ugly. They cannot be fully cast in either the role of the
comple xity of reality and res·pec ts her charac ters as real women .
,. ..
:22
• • . ·V
I
...
legend, the actual woman of flesh and blood was, for the most part,
presence throughout the ages who has been denied the apport~ity of
-
Women are studied both as writers of a~d characters in fiction.
"
In an essay on this topic Ms. Woolf speaks of the lives of women as
fact that the roles that have traditionally been assigned to women
have kept them away from the probing eyes of the world. Woman's
23
. ~-.
•-"' .
work has been such that she seldo m feels the satisf action of havin g
produ ced or creat ed some thing lastin g. Her tasks have been repe-
titiou s and large ly uncre ative maint enanc e work s which , thoug h
neces sary, resul t in little that is tangi ble. Until wome n are free to
play a wider role in the world , Ms. Wool f feels that their lives will
rema in hidde n and myste rious . Of woma n she says that 11 Her life
has an anony mous chara cter which is baffli ng and puzzl ing in the ex-
treme " (p. 146) She feels that as wome n enter the profe ssion s,
they will gain, throu gh exper ience and expos ure, a broad er frame
of refere nce which will in turn enhan ce all creat ive expre ssion and
achie veme nt, espec ially that of the femal e write r. Only then will- "
litera ture becom e for wome n a real art worth y of exten sive study .
As wome n's lives are broug ht into the main strea m, they will. be
subje cted to more thoro· ugh analy sis •. Thus, the image s of wome n
as fictio nal chara cters will lose some thing of the anony mous qualit y
anoth er prese ntly unkno wn dimen sion of woma n: Her poten tial as a
real perso n.
Later femin ist write rs are also very much conce rned about the
..
.,
Dr. Mary Daly discu sses the femin ine stereo types that still aboun d
in Catho lic litera tureo She feels that genui ne perso nhood is often
denie d wome n within Catho licism becau se the stereo type of the
24
·'." ..,
.;··,' .
',·•
''eternal feminine" persists. The authentic woman is relegated to
the area of anonymity - -her ·personal qualities are cast aside and she
tery is a myth that men utilize to cover their own ignorance. In es-
sides since neither can fully comprehen d the experience s of the op-
posite sex: 11 • • •
the categories in which men think of the world are
·25
•: I ;~
··'
.,
over it, feeling as a strange r to her own body at times. Like Vir-
woman is until she is free to act since "an existen t 1is' nothing ...,.: ·\.
--
.,. ..•
other than what he does; the possibl e does not extend beyond the
real., essenc e does not preced e existen ce: in pure subject ivity, the
Ms. de Beauvo ir feels that the time has come for both sexes to
careful ly pull away the veils concea ling the feminin e myster y.
Myster ies can be harmfu l becaus e they so often distort and destroy :
~· . ·:_,
near to look at it. 116 Since human relation ships must be founded on
Woolf that we begin to s'eek the realitie s that lie ·beyond the mirage .
-cusses woman as myster y. Like Virgini a.Wool f, she feels that the
26
~
...' -:---·. ,\T ; • •
.
.':"
...
"1"' .•-··; '
what is real in woman. She says that woman has always repre-
sented 11 the secret side of life" ·and emphasize s the fact that
-·t....:, .
27
•:.~ ·-: <)
·_:;:.
,,,1:'t,
141. '.
--
···-"'-.. __........ __ ,....._.
... ide~~- about the anonymity of women. Ms. Woolf indicates that the
House has resorted to all the games of flattery and deception that
been open to them in the past: getting a man to marry them. Ms.
the House, cannot be dealt with freely and openly by wo1n:en; they
tell lies if they are to succeed. 111 O Ms. Woolf struggles with and
destroys the phantom, knowing that "killing the Angel in the House
was part of the occupation of a woman writer" (p. 286). She then
woman? 'I assure you, I do not know. I do not believe that any-
r,body can know until she has e~ressed herself in all the arts and !
~ ........' I
'
.I .
. , '
., . j , : ' .r I
0
0
,.:
.,.. '.,' l •' •• , ,c - •• : - - ~ - -
busy men, the soldiers., the lawyers., the ambassadors, the cabi-
. :~ . ....
:J,.,-.
net ministers who wanted recreation after their day 1's work. Con-
sciously she .~ust accept their views, and fall in with their decrees
because it was only so that she could wheedle them into giving her
Here it is stated that women have served "as looking gla.sses pos-
man at twice its natural size'' (p. 35). Ms. Woolf stresses how
are essential to all violent and heroic action. That is why Napoleon
•
women., for if they were not inferior, they would cease to enlarge"
begins to tell the truth., the figure in the looking-glass shrinks; his
·... '"
,- I .L ' ~ •• ,, '·: ••
Of the later feminist writers, Germaine Greer devotes some
through the ages. Ms. Greer discusses the work of Otto Wein-
inger (Sex and Character , (London, 1906, p. 236.) and his obs er-
larger context of woman 1s lack of ego and very real namlessne ss.
observes that he could not have realized in his time that the very
been charged with deviousne ss and duplicity since the dawn of civi- ·
..,
,... ~,
30
........ ,,
• ,, ' 1 -··.-,
_ _ ....
, - ......... ------~..-...- d-•··- .. ··~·- ··--··---·-····-· ~"-· ' '-·· -"-,• ...--,,.---........._,. . . . _... _ _ _ __
,., ..
lization so they have never been able to pretend that their masks
were anything but masks. 11 1'3 Like Virginia Woolf, Ms. Greer feels
-
that women must strive to seek what is genuine in themselves even
though this may involve having to "explor~ the dark ~ithout any
guide. " 14
ln this book Ms. Woolf suggests that perhaps many of the poems and
She point§ out that Edward Fitzgerald also considered this as prob-
able since he felt that many of the old anonymous ballads and folk
(p. 52). Writers Currer Bell,· George Eliot, and George Sand are
name of a man'' (p. 52). · Ms. Woolf sees this as being completely
novel has this correspondence to real life, its values are to some
extent those of real life. But it is obvious that the values of women
differ very often from the values which have been made by the other
31
.j
:II!,.
sex; naturally, this is so. Yet it is the masculine values that pre-
with the names of men can be extended to apply to women who are
women have veiled themselves by taking the names of the men they
showed her concern about these women also in writing with com-
passion about their lives. She raises questions in these works not
only abo'.ut the tradition of wives assuming their husbands names but
that the taking of another's name held many implications about the '
I:
'
knew that these injustices were built into the social structure and
marriage, her own legal identity vanished and her husband "was
lord and master, so far at least as law and custom could make him' 1
··r .,
(p. 44). A woman "was the slave of any boy whose parents forced a
ring upon her finger" (p. 45) and in reality "was the property of her
· 32
·L. . -
'.
:\
'L,-
·- "",I ' • '' .!r• ' ' -
chal system and scrutinizes many of the customs which form the
basis for existing laws. Like Ms. Woolf, she discusses the tradi-
the father nearly total ownership over wife or wives and children,
cept of ownership one of these being the wife's assuming her hus-
the husbands domicile, and the general legal assumption that mar-
........., ..
3.3
'
.;,.~'
4
Germaine Greer also considers the position of the woman in
the married state where the loss of selfhood accompanies the loss
Others have also linked the loss of one 1 s name with the loss
Diane B. Schulder, a lawyer and teacher, has studied the legal op-
that when a woman becomes anonymous through loss of her name, " '
knowledges the fact that laws are slowly beginning to change, . but
.
knows also that "Changes in the law cannot take place without
34 7
,; '• .
- , .. ,,,..,... ,,···
Even after considering only a few.· of the modern feminist
up one's name in marriage and to? often at the same time one's
-·-··-· ........... .
·use of the veil image to symbolize many qualities - -the mystery of
posed ideal of chastity that the image of the veil comes most
··,.5···,
3
·-·•..'.· ·:
·'
. /. .
•.,
that dictate d anonym ity to women even so late as the ninetee nth
century " (p. 52). The idea of chastit y exerts a profoun d and im-
measur able influen ce on the female --"it has even now, a religio us
import ance in a woman 's life, and has so wrappe d itself round
with nerves and instinc ts that to:_ ~~t: it free and bring it to. the
Forma l Schooli ng
stresse s the damage that has been done to the develop ment of
36
her from studying medicine; from painting from the nude; from
down Bond Streef alone'' (p. 168). Chastity, along with other
facts of their lives, denied women education and thus of the means
·- - ,··-··
37 ··1,
-~-
.::·
··,
' I ' •
) I L
·,'
,..
Caro line Birc;l :writ es of an "inv isibl e bar" whic h kefp s wom en
down . In .elem enta ry and seco ndar y scho ols, at leas t on the sur-
:fa:ce,- girls ~t:1.d: boys have equa l educ ation al oppo rtuni ty. Soci ety
very subt ly ·begi ns to.. insti ll its valu es when a girl reac hes high
scho ol ... The girl the_n learn s that her biolo gica l func tions are far
mo're · impo rtan t in soci ety's eyes than her intel lectu al purs uits.
The mes sage com es thro ugh loud ly and clea rly that "the real busi- -
ness of. life is attra cting a desi rabl e husb and. 1120
colle ge educ ation -, they are often expe cted to mee t stric ter and -
·mor e exac ting stan dard s for adm issio n than are their male coun -
terp arts . 21 She feels that wom en's sexu al and biolo gica l role s
l
t
are -µsed as .excu ses by thos e in auth ority to keep wom en in a sec- I,
I
I'
1,
..
·- I
onda ry strat um. Sh~ says th~t "Wo men who seek fulfi llme nt in
adva nced intel lectu al achi evem ent are held back or exclu d-ed by
ever y mea ns from ridic ule to the quot a syst em. n22 She repe ats
soci ety's mes sage to wom en: "For the sake of peac e, dem ocra cy,
-and a bette r ~orl d, wom en are expe cted to give up aly-t houg hts of
a care er or even hold ing down a job and inste ad to beco me man 's
Ms. Robi ns is awa re that lega l chan ges and gove rnme ntal
injun ction s are chan ging the pres ent cond ition s at leas t on the ·t~? 1
~,
.r
. ,.,~jj"...·a-..
......
•\ .
,,__ :~· .. ;,,. .~:!--~,
because they also de~elop and expand ideas about limitation s be-
says that ·11 c·onsciousl y or unconsciou sly the girl equates intellectua l
tions she worries not only about failure, but also about success.
about the female role. Men in our society do not experienc e this
kind of ambivalen ce, because they are not only permitted but
actively encourage d to do well. 1124 Ms. Horner notes that "In re-
39
II. I•,
\·
barrier remains. The motive to avoid success has an all-too-
Religious Teaching
the society in which she lived. Her feeling was that religious -,. -••----r,.
teaching had had a very profound effect on social customs and laws
.n
One such teach_ing, which says that a woman should be veiled when
. ' she prays, shows the connection between the. ideas of chastity and
The veil is also a means of keeping the woman out of the public
eye. The symbol of the~ veil makes lucid the link between
mission. She sees through his prejudices and points out his lack
40
of logic. She is aware, though, that however illogical the reasoning
the lives of women were and are still very real and p_owerful: ''But
·:the problem of stereotype .s, one of these being the •ieternal femi-
nine" image which was mentioned w.ithi:n the earlier cont·ext also.
Dr. Daly feels that this particular image continued to recur in re-
ligious writ~~g:s .even in the present day. She feels that this stereo-
tic person, who will be unique, self~critic al, self-creati ng, active,
26
·and searching .'' In her o·pinion writers in the religious field con-
tinue to reinforce this image because their works ''oppose the idea
the grounds that they then become 'defeminiz e,d 1-; 112 ?
,-~- '.;
..........
_...._ 41
\'' t . J ·,
.,
-~,. . :.r..,
. "''""'•'• .
.... L ..
feminine mind should be as untainted with worldly knowledge as
chaste. She has been defiled because of the acquisitio·n: -of knowl-
edge.
thinking ·enc·ompasses the idea that to the male "the virgin would
body and in mind. She has been taught to follow St. Paul I s ad-
·i
monitions, she has been offered stereotyped images of feminin-
ity, and she has been given models to imitate- -Biblical characters, .......... ~-~·· .. _ .. ~,
,...;,
42
:f
\. ,•
. mind and too often in her own, by "invisible bars" that are related
to her sexual nature. This logically leads into the next topic to
"Professio ns for Women" men are blamed at least in part for this
43
....
. . .
'\/ • I
men have been largely responsibl e for imposing restriction s in
~ ....~.
-.~·: ..............._,__
a modicum of freedom by means of the double standard of moral-
Like Virginia Woolf, she feels that this is largely the result of
patterns that are encou:tage d in boys and girls to find that modesty
is stressed far more in young girls than in boys. She notes that
..' . '
~ 1_.' ·. , . ., '::. '
,·
Virgini a Woolf and these later writers agree that woman 's
.......... . ·--- ·-···
for Women Ms. Woolf writes that she sees a relation ship betwee n
this early trainin g and woman 's later relucta nce to enter the pro-
. -. ., .. ~
sions more difficul t for women even when all barrier s are remove d
"femin ine" if she compli es. Her educati on has prepar ed her to
play the role she has gained applau se for over the centuri es: that
of the mysteri o·us being who moves behind masks and veils-- that of
she loves. Woman 's educati on has been respon sible for trainin g
..
-r---
,, . i ·.
,•
her in flattery and falsehood toward men and has prevented her
from looking honestly at herself. She has been defined and has
believed the definitions that men have formulated. She has also
been deceived and in her deception she has denied and therefore
would agree that the time has come for honesty, self-acceptance,
:~ 'I
--;• :
·r
' .
- -,
'·.-·
.•
' .
. ,. ' . -
I". . -·'"
'
;
..
,'
.
I
' . '
~
',
.46
' ' .
. ' -
, I ,' ,
:; -
,' .. ·
• ',, I :',:,, "• '
, • - - · ~.,,,', ·,' ' - ,, .. ,,. -/ •l• - , l • L~ I , • , ~ • • ', , • , • , 1 ,
·.
·;,.:....
The many -face ted conce pt of anony mity was a centr al conce rn
of Virgi nia Wool f's in her non-f iction . These works expre ss her
belie f that the anony mity of wome n has been perpe tuate d becau se
of wides pread custom s. and. pract ices which fwicti on to keep wome n
are evide nt in Virgi nia Wool f's fictio n as well. Her centr al femal e
chara cters have all been confr onted with at least some of the veils
•.···
of their own anony mity. They begin to realiz ·e that anony mity not
only .enco mpas ses them but also has been br~nd ed dee·p within
their souls .
In "Prof essio ns for Wom en 11 Virgi nia Wool f creat ed the Ange l
•
in the Hous e to show how.d efinit ions of femin inity and woma nline ss
often becom e self-f ulfill ing proph ecies . She asser ts that wome n
~·:--
'.'
f·
')·.
'\•
,'
have not been free to define them selve s, but have been define d by
,~:
.I
- · ' .,._ • , • ; , • • , ~ •, , , - ••'-'r " • ,.,,., r p~, ,, "'• ~ . ~ . ,, ,, e. , , _., ., ·~, 1,, , 1• - ,- • ~ -. , - , _
men in such a way that men's own purposes have been served.
The basic problem is that men's definitions have all too often ap-
.~ome link between the real woman before them and some elusive
.and ..dist.·ant being from the.past. Woman, tied in with the shadowy
i' I:
past,. was linked with and to s9._me ex~ent defined by mystery.
Woman was "the other," and man, not she, determined what that
In Mrs.
.
Dalloway Peter
.
Walsh conjures up a definition of wo-
.•. and advancing down the path with his eyes upon sky
and branches he rapidly endows them with·womanhood;
!
48
.\
Qi
0
·selfish giving. These qualities are beautiful and desirable, but
who she is and what she ought to be. She becomes so caught up
will left with which to find what is real. This is expressed in re-
~i . I
49
' .' -.. . . . .. - ,, - - ~~ ,' ' - ,--··
' .
:But Elizabeth has been well trained in the art of what others
I
have considered to be "feminine. 11 She has accepted other's defi-
Her own will has been weakened so that 11 She had no preferences.
Of course, she would not push her way. She inclined to be passive"
(p. 204). And so., lacking assertion,, her real self remains a
•
mystery and she will follow the patterns others have cut out for
her.
Andrew does the same thing later in the book to Minta. She
.~· '.:,..., ..
has lost her brooch that had been given her by her grandmother
from the particular "she had no control over her emotions" (p. 117)
who at dinner has decided that "He was not going to be condescended
to by these· silly women'' .(p. 129). He also cannot simply say this :.-~,;..-
- .-
.
....
' .., .....,_
-~-
-
so .' i
\.
I, .
" ..... , ..~ -• ·~ ..,,_....,.J,......., .....,._.,.,."".._"~~•-.~~.,,.w,f'·,;,,__,,_,,.....4r1, 1 ..,_,_ ... , _ 1.,,.,,•. ,.,._ ..,>"1,~-·,,.._..,_,.,.,_,,,....,.,....,,v,...,,.,..'-tf,:,.,.._· ._.,,,.~-,....·.-•. ~, -.•.... ,......-.., • ..._...,,,.,. _ ._.,_ ... ....__,_,,,.,_,_,,
_,,..,.,..,..,.,,_,,.._,,,., •...,...-, . . ,, 11o'l'.-~ 1
. , ..•. ,.·j··-·- . ... .. . _ ..... ~·-"'''" ,,,,.,_,-_-,,., """~~....~-... 1-c;..,o1>w..._,,._.,"""", ...1,_')l,IJ!l,:O, .\~.,.l".:"'.;)!<;;li•~.,,'<....'i..,.'1."\":'-",r•:\.!")rNffil 'a!':'fl.i'f."Ji.rf:'-'.'~'T~~ ~lff"r,'i~ ',
. .
\ '
i .
apply his judge ments to all wome n: "They did nothin g but talk,
talk, talk, eat, eat, eat. It was the wome n's fault. Wom en made
civili zation i_rnp_ ossible witli:··a.11- their 'charr n, 1 all their sillin ess''
(p. 12 9).
:Mr. Rams ay, at anoth er time:.~ is annoy ed that. ·hts daugh ter
.Cam does not know the point:s: o·f<th_e· comp ass: "·Be thoug ht, wome n
"'
are alway s like that; the vague ne·ss of· the-i.r mind s :t~ hopel ess; it
was a thing he . had never been able to: µnder stand ; but so it was.
It had been so with her- -his wi.fe.. T·hey could not keep anyth ing
clear ly fixed in their minds.-.. B.-ut he: :had bee~ wrong to be angry
w1th her; more over, did h~ n:.<;>t ::r.ath,e·r like this vague ness in
...
wome n? It was part ?f ·their extr·ao r·d-in· ary charm " (pp. 249-25 0).-·
\
I,.
·• Mr. Rams ay not only critici z.e:s· .C;a.m, . b11t he gener alize s abo.ut
what he consi qers to be her v~g).1epe·s:s· .:Qf m.ind . Final ly, thoug h,
the truth emer ges and he is able to admit that there is actua lly
some thing about this charm ing vague ness that he likes. Is Virgi nia
Wool f trying to· c·:·onvey the idea that this make s him feel super ior
really is" (p. 36)? Is she trying also to imply that wome n need
to pleas e men becau se of their socia l positi on and there fore show
this vague ness? Is this why the cycle perpe tuate s itself ? Wom en
are told that to be real wome n they must be charm ing and vague
51
.,
------r-
-\ ' .
•
a.nd ,so,- taught to be passive from earliest· childhood, they comply?
the novels what she has told us about in the nonfiction. Men have I
I
l i,,
! .'
determined what women are to be, have condemned them for it,
·They are threatened by· women and fear their reality and so distort
human relations. Mr. Ramsay cannot bear to think· that his wife
'
mi:g-ht
·
indeed ·b·e. intelligent so must reassure .. ·hfm..$·:elf that she is
.... ,
r.
not: "And he wor.idered what. ~.he was reading_, and exaggerated her
women can't write ... 111 ) and seems to plead with us to ask our-
=52
Even in· The Waves Ms. Woolf presents us with an example of
to define her femininity and does not allow her to speak for her-
self. This is the fault of all the male characters that I hav·e
•··
imperative that they do so. Until this is changed, the true na-
ture of woman remains a mystery not only to the man who fears
who fears what she may find or fail to find beneath the veils
concealing reality.
.
5 ··.3.•
' .=
----"•<>-·c-•••-~-~-• 4-- , •··----·---·-·-·•- ,4 ... _..,.•. __ ........__,. --- ,,.,-,..,__.., ~--- .. L • -•••---- r_n.,H -·-L .... , I I, .. _ _ . ---.-- ......, ..... ~ ~-<lc-
Woman must b:ea·r some of t"he blame for complyin·g so easily and
Ms. Woolf doe·s not exonerate woman so easily, but stresses th·e
fact that woman often. preferred to assume the roles others created
..
J
·he.r,se.lf :daily.. . ·.
If there wa-s chicken, she took the leg; if there
was a. draug·ht she sat in it~:~:in short she was .so :c·on·stituted th~t
she never had a min;d o-~ a wish of her own, but preferred to
f
Why has sh·e not had the courage to look into the mystery of her-
her essay states that she personally had to kill the phantom 11 in
self defence. Had I not killed her she would have killed men
54
i.
- ! :"""·,•-
. :fict itiou s natu re was of grea t assi stan ce to her . It is far har der
~o kill a pha ntom than a real ity" (p. 286) . Ms. Woo lf also tell s
·Q.-~ -tha t '•the stru ggle was sev ere" (p. ·2s6) and the tim e and ene rgy
. r
spe· nt hav ing to kill mig ht bett er hav e bee n spe nt in othe r way s.
The ·ma jor pro blem , how eve r, aro se ~te r she suc cee ded in
m~: rd~r ing the Ang el. The n she had to set abo ut the bus ines s of
:de:f iping wha t a wom an is. Eve n Vir gini a Woo lf cann ot do thi.~
.but draw s bac k ·--sa·yi:n:g·:.,: :t:'I assu re you , I do not know . I do not· be-
liev e· that you know.. I clo not beli eve that ·any body can kno w un.t il
·'
:ahe has expr es'-s :ed iher self in- all the arts and pro fess ions ope n to
._
hum an skill i·, {p~ 286 ). She add ress es thes e thou ghts in her essa y
to you ng wom en of the Wo man 's Ser vice Lea gue who she hop ed
·wou ld eve ntua lly help to pro vide the wor ld with at leas t a part i~l
d~fi nitio n of wom anho ,6<f . Virg inia Woo lf add ress es them hum bly
and "ou t of resp ect• ' -~br them kno win g that she, a suc cess ful fe-
It is with ,tlii s sam e attit ude of resp ect, hum ility , and com -
pas sion that Ms. Woo lf app roac hes her own fem ale cha ract ers
fJ
in fict ion. Eve n hav ing slai n the Ang el her self , she doe s not ex-
I
I
·pec t that all wom en can do so. Gra tefu l for and awa re of her own
priv ileg es and gift s, Virg inia Woo lf kno ws that othe r wom en are
suff oca ted eve n mor e by the ove rwh elm ing pres enc e of the
i
'!· '·
i'
:
•
myster ious Angel who hovers over them and within them. It is
with deep compas sion and little blame that Ms. Woolf creates the
center of it. Virgini a Woolf had person ally and artistic ally ex-
perienc ed their fear and, knowin g the· pain of self-an alysis, does
not condem n her charac ters for turning away. She seems, on the
there is a ·myster y beyond them and within them and helps them
I·
r·
her own mind now, what did it mean to her, this thing she called '
life? 11 (p. 184) She lives in this world of fragme nts and super-
_ficialit ies where pe·ople 's opinion s are very influen tial. But she
she knows that this world of social gatheri ngs is unreal and unful-
···~·
..J.
: ',... t~.,.
•1 • , ' 111., > I 1, ( "'i, d " ;"',<'\:·,--, _, '-") • •
. 1--.--..- ~.
····"···-···- ..... ~ . . . . . - - · - - - - ~ ~ G l l l l f f t m i . . m 1 ~....- .......
-.
. ' . '., ' ·, '
~ M ; l l.....~1.41•1ttl><'!t•o!',.f!,.CW '<i~~.~ ..... ,.,,,·
that she puts forth. She draws back, howeve r, from probing
~
deeply to -find it. She seems to fear the unknow n that lies there
_knew tha.t· ''it was possibl e to say things you couldn 't say anyhow
I
II
e.l~·e., "things that needed an effort; possibl e to go much deeper . I
I
I
·Bu.t. n-ot for her; not yet anyhow " (pp. 25.:6_-,.260) ..
She spends her time with her f~mily and seldoin: has a chance
a_mon-.g all the practic al and social concer ns to be alone with her-
, .
:s-_e1f--. There are a few momen ts, howeve r, when this is possibl e .
.)
In one of these she reflect s that "All the being and the doing, ex-
pansive , glitteri ng, vocal, evapor ated; and one shrunk , with a
the demand s of others upon her are so great that "she often felt I
I
,I
57
•
I
i
l\
she was nothing but a sponge sopped full of human emotions" (p. 51).
she has little strength left to try to investigate that "wedge-sh aped
protect, there was scarcely a shell of herself left for her to know
herself by; all was so lavished and spent" (p. 60). She feels her-
.'.he:i: ow:n ~a.s.ence and not really_. in. connection with others: "She
eve.:rythin·g·_,· :a.s, :she.1.i~lp_ed: th~. ~.Qµp, -as if there was an .e·ddy there--
aµcf., 'QP~- :c·9.u;Jc:l b·e ·itt it,, .o-r o:r1e: ·could be out of it, and she was out of
..
sees the ability to -]le in touch with life at the core of Mrs. Ramsay's
soul? 11 • • • she imagined how in the chamber of the mind and heart of
the woman who was physically , touching her, were stood, like the
which if one could spell them ~C)ut, would teach one everything , but
5.8
l.
·.)·
r
J
' ·- .•. \I '
\. ,,
they would never be offered openly, never made public. What art
r)
II ':':.
:
i,'. :~:
into those secret' chambe·rs: ?'' (p_. 79). ''And yet, she knew knowl-
·edge and wisdom were stored up in Mrs. Ramsay's heart" (p. 79).
her own darkness a·sking herself, •i13ut- -who am I, who lean on this
children. !
:rriands.·.. Ye.t :she·. toc:>c ·e·:hares with Mrs. Ramsay the feeling of being
:an: -o.ut-s..id-.er:-. :riI ·b.egin to draw a figure and the world is looped in
it, .a:nd' I my.self ·?-rri. outside the loop; which I now join--so-- and
seal up, .~n.d :make entire. The world is entire, and I am outside
of··tt, crying, 'Oh, save me, from being blown forever outside
.ir
the loop of time!'" {p. 189).
herself simply because she spends herself caring for her family.
5·.9.
~i
/« I
i!f.
J _, ._.
l
I
I
....... _
'
and Jinny change bodies and faces), flutter unattached, without
~
(p. 259). Rhoda, like ·Mrs. Ramsay and Clarissa Dalloway, fears
learning of the realily ·:cif herself yet strikes out as she feels her-
I_ rnu·~t ·pu-sh my foot·. stealthily lest I should fall off :fhe edge of th.e.,
w:o·r.ld in.t.o nothingn·ess. I have to bang m;y hand ag.ainst some hard
that the mystery of woman remains unsolved and will until women
are free. In her fiction as in her nonfiction Ms. Woolf shows that
I
men continue to define woman and that woman fears defining her-
. f_l-
/,
'
decepti veness attribu ted to woman was actuall y not part of her
nature, but was instead a necess ary quality that her positio n in
her fiction Ms.- Woolf creates female charac ters who live within
of. hostes s. This role ·has been so deeply imbedd ed within her
~-n_d·s a:nd the real woman begins. The veneer never cracks, how-
human tragedi es occur, Clariss a acts -on the belief that "all the
..
"saying things she didn't mean" (p. 118) becaus e this is require d
6i
her wo rst- -ef fus ive , i.ns inc ere " (p. 254 ). Pet er is per son ally
offe nde d by Cla riss a in one ins tan ce in par ticu lar wh en "Cl ari ssa
cam e up wit h her per fec t ma nne rs, like a rea l hos tes s, ant! wan ted
to .int rod uce him to .so me one --sp oke as if the y had nev er me t be-
Pet er is dis tres sed · wit h the arti fici alit y of soc iety in
I
g·en era l but foc use s his dis tre ss upo n Cla riss a. She aro use s con -
. -·
fli.c ting rea ctio ns in Pet er· bec aus e of her pro jec tion of her sel f.
The re is an attr act ive nes s in the soc ial ima ge tha t she pre sen ts
-. and he is torn bet wee n the adm irat ion and attr act ion he fee ls for
h,er and his dis gus t wit h her for the ins tnc erit y of tha t soc ial
It is not onl_y .in: her rol e of hos tes s tha t this is so, how eve r.
·a.e.. ff11d:.s it also in her rol e as a mo the r and spe aks of oth er wom en
~.~·. wel l as of Cla riss a in com me ntin g tha t she is "try ing to ma ke
~)Ut, like mo st mo the rs, tha t thin gs are wh at the y're not ...
She
tru sts to her cha rm too mu ch he tho ugh t. She ove rdo es it" (p. 84) .
He fee ls tha t her per son al wo rld has bee n inv ade d by her pre ten se
so tha t eve n as a mo the r she pla ys a rol e tha t is dec ept ive . It ·
is not onl y Cla riss a, how eve r, but 11 mo st mo the rs" who atte mp t
.•'
to put up fals e app ear anc es. His cri tici sm is of wo me n in gen era l
who util ize dec ept ion not onl y soc iall y, but als o in the ir per son al
relati onshi ps.
Clari ssa, the perfe ct, well- mann ered lady, has been taugh t
to make a distin ction betwe en the perso nal world and the world
•'
of socie ty (altho ugh an eleme nt of prete nse enter s each)- . She has
learn ed that one does not behav e distas tefull y by allow ing the per-
sonal to interf ere with the public --the. y are distin ct. Peter canno t
make this distin ction himse lf and has there fore never been able to
succe ed in a socia l conte xt. He canno t live with such a dicho tomy.
himse lf and is .distr essed becau se Clari ssa can and does fluctu ate
betwe en the. 'two world s. He f.e·e·ts.. that this fluctu aticfh. has
. . . : •' ' .- ~ . . '. affec ted -
her self-i n'tegr ity to the p:<;>i µt:whe re·mos t of her 'life is· a pre-
In devel oping the chara cter of Clari ssa Dallow.ay:;, Virgi nia I!-
\
Wool f strive s t·o, .show that there is a ·deep er .dime nsion within
Clari ssa that is bey·on d her role as hoste ss. Clari ssa is portr ayed
in reflec tive mome nts when it is clear that she is painf ully aware
of her own artifi cialit y. She know s that she is proje cting a false
image and, espec ially as she gr~w s older , feels a gnawi ng dis-
.1:: ·---
satisf actio n with herse lf: ''--ye s, but after all it was what other
peopl e felt, that; for, thdug h she loved it and felt it tingle and
.- sting, still these semb lance s, these trium phs ... had a hollo wness ;
at armrs lengt h they were, not in the hea·rt ; and it might be that
:63:
['' ',
!'
f
ft
t JI
she was growing old llut·: they satisfied her no longer as they used ... "'
(p. 265).
the pattern of life that has been laid out for a woman of her social
c.las·s. There is with her though a dull throbbing ache that she
•·
minds _her that there -are levels to life that she longs to explore
but -c·annt>t. She knows that "A thing there was that mattered; a
thing
.,
wreathed about with chatter, defaced, obscured in her own
.life, let dr·op every day in corruption, lies, chatter'' (p. 280).
:-L"ily Briscoe. Il i.s clear that within both of these women there is
)'
64
. ',,
:·f
,,
6:,,
Lily , how ever , is youn ger and ques tions deep ly even to the poin t
of plac ing hers elf in oppo sitio n to Mrs . Ram say on occa sion .
0
Beca use Lily is mor e inde pend ent and self- suff icien t than Mrs .
Ram say, she is less emo tiona lly and phys icall y thre aten ed by the
ques tions raise d. She has far less to lose if she finds answ ers
and appl ies them to her life. Virg inia Woo lf seem s to be indi-
( ·-·
catin g that this ques tioni ng proc ess is nece ssar y and that findi ng
answ ers and solu tions will take seve ral gene ratio ns. Wom en will
have to grow stron g and beco me depe nden t only on them selv es
befo re their self- dece ption or the dece ption they prac tice. with in
hum an relat ions hips can be total ly obli terat ed. The mes sage
·~eem s to b~ a hope ful one, thoug ·h, that even tuall y wom en will be
i1.
free to be com plete ly true to them selv es and to othe rs.
Mrs . Ram say first beco mes awa re of her own insin cerit y
earl y in the nove l when she sits quie tly think ing and says , "We are
in the hand s of the Lord '' (p. 97). Sudd enly , hear ing hers elf, she
real izes what she is real ly doin g. "But insta ntly she was anno yed
with hers elf for sayin g that. Who had said it? Not she; she had
been trap ped into sayi ng some thing she did not mea n" (p. 97). ·She .
is imm edia tely awa re not only that she is bein g insin cere but also
that she is not entir ely resp onsi ble sinc e she is, to some exte nt
··-.·
at leas t, trapp ed. She is not enti rely abso lving hers elf of blam e,
65:
howeve r, but feels instead displea sed with her behavi or: "The
(p. 98).
clear that it is in the area of her relation ship with her husb·an d
~:
that most conflic ts arise. It is there that she £.eels most unable
to be really, honest: She fears what shatter ing effects truth would
But then again, it was the other thing too- -not being
abl~ t·o tell him the truth, being afraid, for instanc e,
ibout the greenh ouse roof and the expens e it would be,
fifty pounds perhap s, to mend it; and then about his
books, to be afraid that he might guess, what she a
little suspect ed, that his last book was not quite his
best book (she gathere d that from William Bankes );
and then to hiq.e .small daily things, and the childre n
seeing it, and the burden it laid on them- -all this
diminis hed the entire joy, the pure joy, of the two
·notes soundin g togethe r, and let the sound die on her
'ea·r now with a dismal flatnes s. (p. 62)
Her relation ship with her husban d is made far less joyous be-
cause she feels compel led to compro mise with lies and flattery .
Yet her lies and flattery result becaus e of her fear of his inabilit y
to face the truth. She rumina tes upon feeling forced to compro mise
her integrit y and is filled with pain over the conflic t within herself
and over the fact that she feels helples s to r~solve it:
'6·.6.
•\
. e ' , , ~ , ----...~-r, ~ ,, , ·"•~i,,.-:':',-".""" ~ ,--. .', ""
f ,
I•
he r·s elf...•
. . . .
.th¢· rno ld. Ma ny pr es su res inf lue nc e he r an d the tra dit ion is so
.. '
f
....
···- ---
I
!
Ramsay's wishes but really does not give up her questioning of-· 0
•
what could be if honesty were only -allowed to form the basis .of
human relationships.
·t·ansJey are seated at the table talking about the fishing industry.
·himself in the conversation.. .Lil,y senses his discomfort and knows '
I
I.
I
that as a woman she is expe.c.ted .f:o come to his aid. Lily 1 s ques~
6-8
:M·:r:s. Rams ay despe rately tries to draw Mr. Tansl ey into the
-~onv ersati on and is distre ssed that Lily has not done her woma nly
duty and been nice to the man. Final ly Lily comp lies:
Will you take me, Mr. Tansl ey? said Lily, quick ly,
kindly , for, of cours e, if Mrs. Rams ay said to her,
as in effect she did, ''I am drown ing, my dear, in seas
of fire. Unles s you apply some balm to the angui sh of
this hour and say some thing nice to that young man
there , life will run upon the rocks - -inde ed I hear the
gratin g and the growl ing at this minut e. My nerve s
are taut as fiddle string s. Anoth er touch ·and they· ~-···-- - ,_
Lily sense s that huma n re lation- s:hips .coq.lc;l . 'b-e·_,.-:!:~-r .l~ss flawe d
.
.if.: wome n were not expec ·ted to alway s: ·be nlc~ .Jn order to spare
-an.d: enlar ge the egos .of .men. She wishe s that she were not bound
:by socia l custo ms and know s that a very dear price is exact ed
,. • l
And so the deception continues, and the flaws in human
tions begins with Lily, and Virginia Woolf seems through her to
inject a ray of hope that one day she will have the courage to carry
out her experimen t. Ms. Woolf is not so hopeful that she conveys
the idea that this will be easy ·or -even a.:c·complis hed within the next
Lily, has already been trained to be nice al1d Ms·. Woolf shows
us that her lesson has been well learned. Minta is fearful of Mr.
on perfectly, a'nd made herself out even more ignorant than she
was, becaus.e he liked telling her she was a fool" (p. 148).
Virginia Woolf -seems to say that unless the questions of the Lily
,\.
..
sented mainly through the thoughts and actions of the character
Rhoda. At one point she is thinking back over her life, and she
speaks of her dread of life and of.her hatred for human beings.
She feels that life and other people have stained and corrupted her
'70
. :J
- - she feels that she has been . com pelle d to lose her se If-in tegri ty:
R_hoda., ·mor e ·than :Clar iss.a Dall oway , Mrs . Ram say, ·o:r: ·Lily
::h-a.s felt rage at what life and peop le have forc ed upon her. She
:has pass ed the poin t wher -e each of the earl ier wom en left off-- she
is past the thou ght stag e and has been affec ted on a deep er emo tiona l
..
, ....•
'
leve l by rage . Still , even whil e adm ittin g ·ang er, she has cont aine d
her rage and bas pret ende d. Her pret ense has been dire cted not
only at othe rs but also at hers elf. She has used pret ense as a de-
fens e mec hani sm in orde r to shie ld hers elf from reali ty: "So
......
terr ible was life that I held up shad e afte r sh~d e. Look at life
l . . .
.thro ugh this, look at life throu gh that; let ther e be rose leav es,
let ther e be vine leav es- -I cove red the who le stre et, Oxfo rd Stre et,
Picc adill y Circ us, with the blaz e and ripp le of my mind , with
:,.
··,,,_
71
'o
~. , , - • .•• , , , - ,, _. .,.,...,. ,"s,jl_...•,-l,. I , ,,,.--.-....• .-. ,~ µ"t" .Wfit"'""'...., ~ 1 1"! . • . , -,, ,-,..,:Ji'-- i .. f!-""-±'>J>•"':.l~"'. ~ -,.~41' ' --:,i-, ~ .-~-= - . .. .- -:'.".... ·t .,,;. " ' ~ .... ~" • • .• •• • • ' <
. .
Rhoda's defensiveness is a reaction to the terror that she
feels when confronted with society and its falseness, with people
who are "throwing faint smiles to mask their cruelty" (p. 247).
and honesty and she feels that she is "thrust back to stand burning
in this clumsy, this ill-fitting body, to. receive the shafts of his
indifference, and his scorn" (p. 248). She cannot even believe in
her deception. She even knows that she pretends because she mu-st
knives, making me stammer, making me lie ..• " (p. 249). She
~-
is also aware that the fault is also her own because, a·s · she says,
72
........ ""*"' ... ··"""-··"·'-- .
.. ._....
still scorched by the hot breath, afraid of the door opening and the
leap of the tiger, to make even one sentence. What I say is per-
.
petually contraq.icted" (p. 249). She cannot assert herself because
she does not believe in herself- - she has no sense of the solid
who has not had a separate identity; who has not defined herself;
i '
l
lI
still scorched by the hot breath, afraid of the door opening and the
leap of the tiger, to make even one sentence. What I say is per-
I
i
j.'.
petually contraqict ed" (p. 249). She cannot assert herself because ..I,.
i
she does not believe in herself- -she~ has no sense of the solid
who has not had a separate identity; who has not defined herself;
argued that rather than namelessn ess, the woman actually takes
7·3: ·
,
......, ...........-
• ~' • I • • '
.........-......
" -' I. ;u ' • ' .., '
these traditio ns. Many of the ideas put forth in the nonfict ion are
woven throug h the fiction as her female charac ters reflect on their
I
own anonym ity within the marrie d state.
I
Clariss a Dallow ay feels that she has lost her name and with it
charac ters about the institut ion of marria ge itself. As young wo-
men, for instanc e, Clariss a and Sally realize that the bond betwee n
someth ing that "was protect ive, on her side; sprang from a sense
bound to part them'' (p. 50). Of course marria ge was the thing
for one brief instant , does so in order to make some observ ations
74
•
- -~-·,,.,.
,, '
r
,,
who had been an independent spirit is now stifled so that her own
she had caught salmon freely: now, quick to minister to the crav-
ing which lit her husband-1 s eye ·so oilily for dominion, for power,
• ••II (p. 152). Her very will has been submerged to that of her
I
!.
i
!
. ' '. .
I'
.,.
h.usba :nd:. .fiFift een years ago she had gone under . It was nothin g
~ou ·could put your finge r on; there had been no scene , no scrap ;
only the slow sinkin g, water -logg ed, of her will into his. Swee t
was her smile , swift her subm ission ... 11 (p. 152).
Peter Walsh make s sever al obser vatio ns conce rning marri age
espec ially when he loo. ks close ly at the marri age of Clari ssa and
Richa rd. He becom es irrita ted when he realiz es that all the tiw:~
he 1·s been in India, Clari ssa has been mend ing dress es, giving
parti es, and allow ing her life to revol ve a.ro.µ,nci :h:~r conse rvativ e
husba nd. Peter feels that "ther e's nothin g. in the. world so bad for
:s·ome wome n as ma:r··r.ia.g:-e•-:·" (p. 61). Peter · s·ees that Clari ssa's
entire life has ·:peen used up in ser·vi ce of one type or anoth er to
or for Richa .rd. Peter knows that "Thes e partie s for exam ple i
I·
I'
i
i
were all for him, or for her idea of him (to do Richa rd justic e he
would have been hap·p ier farmi ng in Norfo lk)" p. 116). Peter re-
alizes that the state of affair s is not totall y Richa rd's fault. He
knows that all "that interm inabl e traffi c that wome n of her sort
keep up'' (p. 117) was really done "genu inely, from a natur al in- I
!;
stinct " (p. 117). Peter simpl y comm ents on the fact that her per-
'!.·
i
sonal ity must be subm erged , her abilit ies must b.~· suppr essed : I
"With twice his wits, she had to see thing s throu gh his eyes- -one
of the .trage dies o~f marri ed life. With a mind of her own, she must
......... :.....: -
7.6
·-
.,,
.
,, . '
..
·,.~
. ., .;. .. . . . . . . . . ,. ; , ~ , ;. :. ~ .- '" ·. !.·
t
I
I
I
marry to fulfill herself. Like Peter Walsh she recognizes the •
in marriage.
insistence that they all must marry" (p. 77) and that "an unmar-
f1
ried wom~n .lias missed the best of life" (p. 77}.. Of. Lily it is
own exemption from the universal law; plead for it; she liked to
be alone; she liked to be herself; she was riot made for that ... "
·(p. 77). Later she repeats her desire to avoid being swallowed up
of the salt cellar on the pattern, she need not marry, thank
Heaven: she need not undergo that degradatio n. She was saved
has not tu~ned out as Mrs. Ramsay would have liked since she has
/
indeed ne·ver married. She· says that if one could communic ate
with Mrs. Ramsay "one would have to say to her, It has all gone
11 "·.• ~ ••
against your wishes. They're happy like that; I 1m happy like this.
77
.I
, I
. . . -., . ' ,· ,,
only esca ped by the skin of her teeth thou gh, she thou ght. She
,. ' ~. t
.J
had been look ing at the table -clot h, and it had flash ed upon her
that she woul d mov e the tree to the midd le, and need neve r mar ry
anyb ody, and she had felt an enor mou s exul tatio n" (p. 262) .
Lily pond ers the diffe renc e betw een wha t peop le say a.,bout,
mar riag e and what they actu ally feel. She know s that "if yo·u
aske d nine peop le out of ten they woul d say they want ed noth ing
but this - - love ; whil e the wom en, judg ing from her own expe rienc e,
woul d all the time be feeli ng, This is not wha t we want ; ther e is
:noth ing mor e tedio us, puer ile, and inhu man e than this; yet it is
~t·so beau tiful and 'nece ssary '' (p. 155 ). The re is a larg e disc rep-
·a_ncy betw een what is sa1d. ~nd what is actu ally felt. Even Mrs .
,·
Ram say, who urge s peop le to mar ry and impl ies that unm arrie d
wom en cann ot :poss ibly be fully happ y, does feel conf lict with in
hers elf conc ,erni ng mar riag e. Mrs . Ram say expr esse s her self-
awa rene ss that nshe was driv en on, too quic kly she knew , almo st _ _
as if it were an esca pe for her too, to say that peop le mus t mar ry;
The conf lictin g feeli ngs are espe ciall y reve aled when she
assu mes that the attra ction betw een Paul and Mint a will resu lt in
a unio n betw een the youn g peop le. She know s deep insid e that
i
; . .- .
~
78 .--' --·· ·.
_;
,-~·t"'i:'t..,•·y.,A ·,,,, 1 t, ...1~.,,,.(, • ,•.,1",';- 0:L cl'',, .. · . , , , v.~
illusion and wants to celebrate even though she feels "a curious
for what could be more serious than the love of man for woman,
the seeds of death; at the same time these lovers, these people
"'·
entering into "illusion glittering eyed, must be danced round with
ence for her husJ;>and than it is for herself. She admit·s, if only in
her thoughts, that he is really happier than .she· Js: .,'='F·:Qr it wa·s
odd; and she believed it to be :t.rue; that with all his gloom and
had ..always his work to fall back on .. i:r (p. 91) Mrs. Ramsay idol-
izes her husban~, however, and. t:r;µly ,b·elieves' that this work of
'
,.
~1
his is truly a greater contributio n tp the world than her ·own. She
her, when they must know that of the two he was infinitely the more
1
important, and what she gave the world, in compariso n with what
I
1
Whil e re·co gniz ing to som e exten t: at leas t her own subj ugat ion,
she still woul d choo se that posi tion rath er than dimi nish her hus-
band 's ego to the sligh t~st degr ee. Still , in a scen e with her
daug hters , it is evid ent that witti ngly or· not she has tran smit ted
her feeli hgs ·of conf lict to th~ next gene ratio n to such a degr ee that
it is· clea r that they will chO'C)Se diffe rent lifes tyles for them selv es:
But for her own part she woul d neve r for a sing le
seco nd regr et her deci sion , evad e diffi culti es, or
slur over dutie s. She was now form idab le to beho ld,
and it was only in silen ce, look ing up from thei r
·plat es, afte r she had spok en so·: seve rely abou t Cha rles
. Tans ley, that her daug hters Prue , Nanc y, Ros e--
coul d spor t with infid el idea s whic h they had brew ed
for them selv es of a life diffe rent from hers ; in Pari s,
perh aps; a wild er life; not alwa ys takin g care of
som e man or othe r; for ther e was in all their mind s
a mute ques tioni ng of defe renc e and chiv alry, of the
Bank of Engl and. and the India n Emp ire, of ring ed
.fing ers and lace , thou gh to them all ther e was som e-
thing in this of the esse nce of b~au ty, whic h calle d
out the man lines s in their girli sh hear ts, and mad e
them , as the_y sat at the table bene ath their moth er I s
eyes , hono ur her stran ge seve rity, her extr eme
cour tesy . . . (p. 14)
Her daug hters are not going to subm it their wills to any man 's.
They have ·seen their moth er play ing the trad ition al role of wife
supp ortin g a man 's ego. Tim e and time agai n they have witn esse d
soci al situa tions such as the one with Cha rles Tans ley in whic h
thei r moth er assu mes the seco ndar y role: ''It flatt ered him;
snub bed as he had been , -rt·~ sooth ed him that Mrs . Ram say shou ld I
I
j
80 ./
'· ' ,. . . . p
tell him this... Insinuating, too, as she did the greatness of man 1s
intellect, even in its decay, the subjection of all wives ... to their
husband's labours, she made him feel better pleased with himself
I ,
I .
than he had done yet" (p. 20). I-'
has been enjoying his mother's attention and knows that his father
wants her compassion. He sees that 11 the fatal sterility of the male
(p. 59). James is angry, but his anger is not over the fact that he
his annoyanc~ stems from the fact that his father has interrupted
I
his father, has a very definite belief that woman is primarily in-
role. She has lived p.er life ·and sought her identity primarily
strength has been "drunk and quenched" (p. 59) by all who have
,,. . . ....
:i_
81
...
,,'l., .-,
'I,,·
"dem and ing sym path y" (p. 59). Yet it is clea r that pers ona l
con flict s did aris e with in, her at tim es as she beg an to feel the
nee d to be sep arat e from her fam ily and thei r dem and s: "· .. it
was a reli ef whe n they wen t to bed. For now she nee d not thin k
abo ut anyb ody . She cou ld be her self , by her self . And that was
wha t now she ofte n felt the nee d of- -to thin k; wel l, not even to
thin k. To be sile nt; to be alon e" (pp. 95-9 6). Mrs . Ram say
has lear ned that her iden tity is real ly bey ond her role as wife
and mot her, and that it has to do with this priv ate wor ld of the
self . She· is awa re also that she has to ~om e exte nt bee n prev ente d
- from exp erie ncin g som e segm ents of life:_ 11 She took a look at
life , for she had a clea r sen se of it ther e, som ethi ng real , some..;,
thin g priv ate, whi ch she sha red neit her with her chil dren nor
with her husb ai1:d . A sor t of tran sact ion wen t on betw een them , in
whi ch she was on one side , and life was on ano ther " (pp. 91-9 2).
Mrs . Ram say 's dau ghte rs hav e reac ted not only to her pas sive
assu mpt ion of the trad itio nal sup mis sive role , but also to her per -
son al con flic ts whi ch hav e, of cou rse, bee n sile ntly com mun icat ed
to them eve n if unin tent iona lly. The y hav e witn esse d her con stan t
sup pres sion of her own nee ds in mee ting the dem and s of her hus -
ban d and fam ily. The y are also awa re that her den ial of self has
prev ente d her from exp erie ncin g all of life. She has prod uce d
!.
i
i. :s-2
daugh ters who are hopef ully going to rebel again st her lifest yle
(p. 14) and' creat ing "a life di~.f~ rent from hers" (p. 14). They. I
' .
will rebel , howe ver, not in anger but with a deep admi ration for
her as they "hono ur her stran ge sever ity, her extre me court esy .•. \i
(p. 14).
The idea of losing one's ident ity and· o:f being confin ed i._n
marr iage is expre ssed in The Wave s by both Jenny and Susan .
Jenny knows that she could not possi bly subm erge her identi ty and
give up her freed om for anoth er and choos es to live alone rathe r
than to do so: "But I shall not let myse lf be attach ed to one per-
quive r, like the. leaf in the hedge:,· :as I sit dangl ing my feet, on
the edge of the bed, with a new day to break open' ' (p. 212).
Susan , on the other hand, has chose n to follow the tradit ional
patte rn of marry ing and devot ing her life to her husba nd and
0
child ren. She is conte nt with her life for the most part, but she .,
does feel the restri ction s that are place d on her in the marr ied
state and expre sses her feelin gs about them. She descr ibes her
life in terms of confi neme nt sayin g that sh~ .i-s ''fenc ed in, plant ed
here like one of my own trees " (p. 308). Refle ctivel y, she ob-
serve s, "Life · stand s round me like glass round the impri soned
I
!
I
:_8:3
:f ...
'
reed" (p. 309) and,f eels "the waves of my life tosse d, broke n,
least has given up a part of life and she contr asts her prese nt
life with the life she reme mber s befor e her marr iage:
I pad about the house all day long in apron and slipp ers, .. ,,
like my moth er who died of cance r. Whet her it is
summ er, whe't her it is winte r, I no longe r know by the
moor grass , and the heath flowe r; only by the steam
on the windo w-pan e or the frost on the-w indow -pane .
When the lark peels high his ring of sound and it
falls throu gh the air like an apple parin g, I stoop ; I
feed my baby. I, who used to walk throu gh beech
woods noting the jay's feath er turnin g blue as it falls,
past the sheph erd and the tramp , who stare d at the wo-
man squat ted besid e a tilted cart in a ditch, go from
room to room with a duste r." (pp. 294-2 95)
The woma n who used to exper ienc·e natur e first hancl is now I
I
I
1-
separ ated from it by windo w-pan es and oblig ations . She know s
that she is missi ng what is happe ning beyon d her home . From
her windo wed priso n she looks at a rook' s nest and knows that "His
-,·
eyes will see when mine are shut, •.. 11 shall go mixed with them
Thoug h happy , Susan does feel her confi neme nt and revea ls
her mixed feelin gs about the life she has chose n when she says,
' '
11 1 am glutte d with natur al happi ness; and wish some times that the
84
'-
.. '.
-
,
fullness would pass from me and the weight of the sleeping house
.,
lives in th..~ married state, they reveal their feelings about the
these ideas. Her novels abound with descrip tions, charac teriza-
tions, and dialogu e that convey the attitude s -arid assump tions about
women that Ms. Woolf so explici tly discuss ed in her nonfic.t ion:
"
thetr chastity , their anonym ity., and the learnin g proces s that has
::she realize s that her own: educati on has been inferio r. She
pond.er s to herself --~·t o.n:·e point: ''How she: had got through lif~ Q~
••
the few twigs of knowle dge Fraule in Daniels gave them she could
not think" (p. 11):. Clariss a thinks about her life and gives her
gatheri ngs grow out of her feeling that she has not been trained to
do anythin g else of import ance. She sees her dinners and parties
fa
.,~
...
':,
Anyhow , it was her gift. Nothing else had she of the slighte st ri,_·_·
importa nce; could not think, wr!te, even play the piano. She _mud- · ·. ----1: ~-.
I
"'''"""''"' '., ''"'''""'''"'""--°t-
dled Armen ians and Turks; loved succes s; hated discom fort;
must be liked; talked oceans of nonsen se: and to this day, ask [
I
I
Ii
!.
--~
~--.·.·
her what the Equato r was, :and· she did .not know" (p. 185).
ning, tearing up, beginni ng again, she used to feel the futility of
her own woman hood as she felt it on no other occasio n. . " (p. 1.65:}.
In her distres s she turns to· Hugh Whitbr ead, a man "who posses: sed
·---,ho .01te' c.ould: doubt it--the art of writing letters to the Times"
(p. 165). H··er feeling s about being forced to turn to a man are
describ ed: i'iLady Bruton often suspend ~d judgem ent upon men in
stood to the laws of the univers e; knew how to put things; knew
what was said; so that if Richar d advised her, and Hugh wrote for
her, she was sure of being someho w right'' (pp. 165-16 6).
In each instanc e the woman feels the inferio ~ity of her own
being very limited . Each woman choose s her own form of anonym -
Millice nt Bruton can only feel "someh ow right" if she has the ad-
··,.· .••v.,.
vice of Richar d and the words of Hugh.
who has borne a daught er, there are many descrip tive passag es ·
..... ,, ... ,
in the nov el whi ch ma ke her : .s:ound vir gin al. Upo n ent erin g her
hom e and ass um ing he_r_ dail y: task s onc e °-1-0re her fee ling s are
des crib ed: "Sh e felt like .a nun wh,o· has left the wo rld and fee ls
fold rou nd her the fam ilia :r vei ls and the res pon se to old dev otio ns"
{P·= 42) . Wh en she was firs t vis ited by Pet er Wa lsh and hea rs the
-knob of tq.¢ doo r turn ing her firs t res pon se was tha t 11 She ma de to
hi-de l:te::-r ,dre ss, like a vir.gi~n pro tect in;g cha stit y, res pec tin. g
·pri vac y11 (p. 59) . Cla ris· sa is de· scri bed as a rat her inno c·er tt wo·:.
rna.n._ of mid dle a-g·e· who ·"-_knew n·othing abo ut sex --n oth ing abo ut
l-I_e~ cha stit y,: :he r vir gin al qua lity is rea lly the res ult of: a
frig idit y tha t is esp eci ally evid ent: to· Pet er Wa lsh, who com me nts
~'bo ut .:it: 11 The re was alw ays som eth ing col d in Cla riss a, he
·tho ugh t. She haq.: alw ays , eve n as a gir l, a sor t of tim. _idi ty, whi ch
"in mid dle age bec om es con ven tion alit y ... 11 (p. 73) . ''Bu t she is
.too col d, he tho ugh t" (p. 64) . He say s tha t "sh e was uny ield ing ~
She was like iron , like flin t, rigi d up the bac kbo ne" {p. 97) . ·-~-
Pet er is d1s tres sed by this qua lity in her : "Th at was the dev ilis h
par t of her --th is col dne ss, this wo ode nne ss, som eth ing ver y pro -
fou nd in her whi ch he had felt___ agai:q._ this mo rnin g talk ing to her ; an..
imp ene trab ilit y. Yet Hea ven kno ws he lov ed her " (p. 91) . Cla riss a,
tho ugh ma rrie d, is see n as the virg in. pro tec ting cha stit y, gua rdin g ; •·
against involveme nt. Peter generalize s and applies this quality
ting his pocket-kni fe, don't know what passion is. They don't know
Richard. At one point she goes to he* room "Like a nun with-
.an em-ptiness about the heart of life; an attic room" (p. 45). On
her bed "The sheets were clean, tight stretched in a broad white
band from side to side Narrower and narrower would her bed
be" (pp. 45-46). She reads here in her bed alone, for ''Richard
insisted, after her illness, that she must sleep undisturbe d. And
knew it. So the room was an attic; the bed narrow ... 11 (p. 46).
·',11"
.)
a . W -· PS I •
I
I
r
r
i
I
·pf this cold spirit, she had failed him. And then at Constantinople,
and again and again. She could see what she lacked. It was not
' ated; something warm which broke up surfaces and rippled the
process. Mrs. Ramsay feels her own lack of training when she
she keeps a record of finances and employment "in the hope that
thus she would cease to be a private woman whose charity was half
and become what with her untrained mind she greatly admired, ·an
however, her education is such that she has no choice but to remain
a private woman.
··90:
...:.: '
_· .._ ;._ ~ .
Ramsay did not qu.ite. :catch the meaning, only the words, here and
·s:he ~qu.lcl not follow the ugly academic jargol;l., that rattled itself
·0 ·ff··. · ·1·b·
.· · :.g:
•· S:O :J. · ..·1·y.·· . . '' (p 22)
Silently, Mrs. Ramsay lur·ks behind her own beauty.- ·she 1.·s.
aware .. Even so, she fears putting forth her thoughts in speech
.. (' ··~
9.1
4~. ; •• r,·.
~ ""*,:_.,. 1J • ~! 1 •; • ,.-~~-- - -, ', • • ' I ! - O I ~ - t ' ' \ ' , 1
~sked him what his father 1 s books were about SubJect and object
1
and the nature of reality, 1 Andrew had said. And when she said
Heavens, she had no ·notion what that rrt.eant'·1 {p. 38). Feeling
dis satisfactio n with her own life, Lily £e.els inadequate : f 1And it
was then too, in that chill and windy way, as she began to paint,
that ·there forced themselve s upon her· .qther things, her own in-
.a:dequacy, her insignifica nce ... " (p. ~.Z} •.. L1ly doubts and fears
her sex, she did not know which) before she exchanged the fluidity·
of life for the concentrat ion of painting she had a few moments of
tection to all the blasts of dou~t" (p. 236) .. Lily does, however,
battle her own fears in much the same way that Ms. Woolf herself
battled the Angel of the House. Lily, like V.lrginia Woolf, pursues
her vision to the finish, but will also have to pay dearly for chaos -
a thr ead of som eth ing ; som eth ing of her own whi ch Mr s. Ram say
like d ver y mu ch ind eed , but no ma n wou ld, she fea red " (p. 157 ).
I·
I'.
'.
Lil y's ass ert ion of self , her art isti c exp res sio n, her use of \
·'ta,J.ents and abi liti es, her on- goi ng edu cat ion of self flie s in the
fac- e of.: the trad itio nal opt ion s ope n to a wo ma n. In cho osin g not
to· ,r·e mai n ano nym ous , she cha llen ges and thr eat ens the me n aro und
'her .and is for ced into the airt .igh t S'fe j:eo type of the ind epe nde nt
shi ps wit h me n. '.Not onl y do me n t'Jie -ms elve s shu n her bec aus e· s:he
is a thr eat to the..m, .but- :also·. Lil y her sel f has gra ve dou bts and
·fea r.s abo ut her own a·rt isti c abi lity and ade:qu~,c:y as a wom an.
:$:he wis hes tha t she cou ld for m att.a_c:htrients and trie s to ma ke ex-
cus es for her sel f alth oug h th.ey· ar.e nev er suf fici ent : "Oh , but ,
Lil y wou ld say , the re was her fath er; her hom e; eve n, had she
dar ed to say it, her pai ntin g. But all this see me d so litt le, so
vir gin al, aga ins t the _oth er" (p. 77) . •
"
Lil y is afr aid to act and res pon ds to me n by wit hdr awi ng in
sel f-d efe nse . Sile ntly clin gin g to her pai ntb rus h, she is not abl e
to giv e. Lil y fee ls the nee d to rem ain unt ouc hed --to hol d ont o
.
cha stit y in a sen se. She cho ose s this rat her tha n to cha nce di-
luti ng her art isti c vis ion , and yet she fee ls ina deq uat e as a wom an
,':"'-::.
I
.. .I
.'
.. ,,..;,
woman does give to a man. She remem bers the relation ship be-
tween Mr. and Mrs. Ramsay : "That man, she thought , her anger
"':,•
rising in her, never gave; that man took. She·, on the other hand,
giving she had died- -and had left all this 1f (P··: ··223). Lily wishes that.
someho w she could be like other women if .only tt,. 'i..:rnitate them:
"Surely , she could imitate from recolle ction t~e glow, the rhapsod y,
the self-su rrende r, she had seen on so mariy women 1 s faces ... 11
-·(p. 224). Her very woman hood i_:s on trial. She feels "that any
·other woman in the whole world would have done someth ing, said
Lily sees Mr. Ramsa y's insatia ble need for sympat hy as
nothing less than a "deman d that she should surren der herself
adequa cy as a woman " "A woman , she had provok ed this horror ;
a woman , she ·should have known how to deal with it. It was
94
..,
.f,
r.i. ...... - ••
immen sely to her discred it, sexuall y to stand there dumb'' (p. 228) .
..
In spite of doubts and guilt feeling s Lily does choose to preserv e
herself . She keeps herself from being cata.ght up in this emotio nal
--
turmoi l in order to give herself fully to the pursuit of her artistic
a.:n.d spread itself in pools a.t ·her feet, and all she did, misera ble
sinner that she was, was to draw her skirts a little closer round
her -ankles, lest she should get wet. In comple te silence she stoqd
t.h·er:e·, ·graspin g he:r paint brushn (p. 228). She has made her de-
cl~ion. 111 s-pite ·of :guilt, b.ut the feeling s of guilt do· not ·end here.
.
,: .
.Later, "she felt a sudden emptin ess; a frustra tion. Her feeling
had come tcio late; there it was ready; but he no longer needed it"
(p. 231).
Relatio nships with the opposit e sex and feeling s about one's
own sexual wholen ess are very much influen ced by Lily 1 s decisio n
able to turn to her artistic pursui ts. Even when she is able to
and an artist. The voices of genera tions of men fill her ears
with more doubts about develop ing her abilitie s than she already
.... ' -
" ' . '_; ______ -- . c-----
~
that "Women can't write, women can't paint" (p. 130) is really
not just the personal opinion of one man. He really is the voice of
Lily .doesn 1t believe what he says., but his voice haunts her and
trying to ignore it draws even more energy from her. She asks
herself "Then why did she mirid what he said? Women can't write,
.•-
women can't paint--what did that :matter coming from him, since
clearly it was not true to him but- for some reason helpful to him,
and that was why he -said it? Why- did her whole being bow, like
. corn under a wind, and e·rect its·elf again from this abasement only
,, man could direct at once to his art must :b·-e :d1verted and lessened
··=~~ .
...
House and the voices of men who have created the phantom. She
96
·'i-·
.It. is as if the wom an who crea tes any thin g othe r than hum .an
... . ~
arti st bec aus e she so cho ose s. Lily 's batt le to pain t is real ly Ms.
Wo olf's own batt le aga inst the Ang el. Lik e Vir gini a Woo lf, Lily
doe s suc cee d in killi ng the Ang el and in dire ctin g her ene rgie s
fina lly to her form of self -exp ress ion: 11 She took up onc e mor e her
.old pain ting po.s i:tio n with the dim eye s and the abs ent- min ded
man ner, subq uing all her imp ress ions as a wom an to som ethi ng
muc h mor e gen eral ; bec omi ng onc e mor e und er the pow er of that
visi on whi ch she had seen clea rly onc e and mus t now grop e for
amo ng hed ges :an·d hou ses and mot hers and chil dre n--h er pict ure ''
(.p. 8:2,). Wit h Virg inia Woo lf her self Lily can ulti mat ely say
:i 1 layi ng· .down her bru sh in extr eme fati gue , I hav e had my visi on"
·.. 310 ).
(p.
.
The re is eve n at 01te poin t the :pro mis e that Lily can beg in to
enjo y a real rela tion ship with a man that exis ts outs ide the tra-
diti ona l sexu al ster eoty pes . It is only a pro mis e but at leas t it
offe rs her hop e that "On e cou ld talk of pain ting then seri ous ly to
a man . Inde ed, his frie nds hip had bee n one of the plea sure s of her
Wil liam Ban kes and Lily both hav e thei r sep arat e live s, but
are able to sha re on man y leve ls eve n thou gh "Ma ny thin gs wer e
97 ,,
- ,,
.• '
left unsaid" (p. Z63). There is a degree of hope, then, that full
promise ·is that both woman and man may develop and use their
talents and skills, may re.late. to one another without binding the
'fo.r all individuals of ,eithe:r s·ex may at long last i1o·t- be the onl.Y
(lption •.
ity, ahd the educationa l p,r·oc~s.:~ tha.t. :has been utilized to preserve
both, yet there. ar.e a .few ev·e.:n. in this later novel indic·at_ing that
Virgini.a Woolf :r:etained her :c:on.c.:·ern for these topics even in her
.:susa·n relates. that· h·er ·only· education for life has been related
to human emotioIL, .she insists that she does not feel inadequate
and yet she is very jealous and bitter that others, particular ly the
other women she has known, have fared better than she has. She
speaks of her capacity to love and explains how even that has been
affected by her lack ·of understand ing: ''I love with such ferocity
that slips in and out among the leaves on the tree-tops. I do not
understand phrases" (p. 267). She knows that her comprehen sion
• 98
,. . .Y.~
,: ..· - ~. .,.- ... -··,~- ·. ·; ·~
I ,; ', :,, ; ,,
' .. .1
•)(
is limited to -the emotio nal and physic al level: ''The only sayings I
. .
W1ders tand are cries of love, hate, rage and pain" (p. 266) •
sexual trainin g for chastity .and frigidit y that so often accomp anies
the conditi oning for feminin e anonym ity. Jinny also is capable of
and accepti ng of her body and passion s and is in control of her own
Jinny is affecte d by the woman 's reactio n and her body respon ds
.
negativ ely- - she is forced to deny her body: ''And I lie back; I give
myself up to raptur e... But behold, looking up, I meet the eyes
.,/ ... ·
her face, imperti nently. , like a paraso l. · I open my body, I shut my
Even though s:us·an a:nd Jinny ha·ve someho w escape d for the
deeply affecte d by her trainin g for chastit y and anonym ity. She
says at one point ''I left Louis; I feared embrac es" (p. 318).
t •
·wool£ as well as in the nonfict ion: The educati onal proces s (both
formal and inform al) has been respon sible for trainin g women to
know their place and has limited them in the develop ment of
·.99 .....
-~
healthy self-co ncepts. Instead it has given them inadequ ate tools
... with which to achieve in the real world and has taught them to deny
wives and lovers they are more often than not frigid. It is her
trainin g or its lack that is mainly respon sible for keeping woman
from self-ac ceptan ce and self-as sertion in all areas person al and
in most cases she becom es at least symbol ically if not in fact that
"anony mous presen ce through out the ages who has been denied the
opportu nity of explori ng the fullnes s of her humani ty' 1 (p. 70).
·ni.z:e: ::and comme nt ·upon the various vefJ:$ of anonym ity that hinder
and concea l their humani ty. They be:g{p. in fiction the proces s of
peeling away the -veils in order to find that evasive core which is
the self. The proces s that Virgini a Woolf's charac ters engage in
is essenti ally the same proces s of self-an alysis that modern woman
Woolf, she envisio ns a time when women will no longer veil them-
...
-~ 100
. ,.
~:
.•
Cha pter VI: Con clus ion: In Sea rch. of a Self -Im age
•
The fem inin e exp erie nce· was an esse ntia l con cern of Virg inia
Wo olf's art. The que stio ns rais ed in the non ficti on, the cha ract er
dev elop men t in her nov els, and he.r very life as an arti st and
wom an are acco ·unt s of stru ggle s in sea rch of com plet e self hoo d
Vir gini a Woo lf was a stuc lent :qf· th'~-- ::r-~st who poin ted out in her
non ficti on the dua listi c ima g_ es ·-a.:r:;tdi ·v-eils of ano nym ity that hav e
:.a,e istric ted fem inin e devel.o_pm.ept ~nd. con ceal ed the true natu re of
wom en thro ugh out hist ot:y . fler wor k is a link betw een the earl y
suff ragi st cau se and· the pr-e s-en t libe rati on mov eme nt. She seem s
' to hav e anti cipa ted the wid
e-ra ngin g que stio ns that are cur ren tly
bein g rais ed by wom en in m~n y· p:ar ts of the wor ld abo ut thei r own
con ditio n.
In her nov els Ms. Woo lf reb elle d aga inst the esta blis hed
ima ges and crea ted fem ale cha rac ters who wer e com plex _and in-
tlrig uing indi vidu als who did not fit t~e man -ma de patt ern s of the
""·•
pas t. She dev elop ed fict iona l wom en who beg an to tug at the veil s
and to ass ert them selv es in all thei r com plex ity and amb igui ty as
. ····· l---
I
I
l.·
101
.,
'
'/
huma n being s about to begin the proce ss of attain ing whole ness.
In, her own life Virgi nia Woolf never comp letely resolv ed the
confl icts she felt about attem pting to define and balan ce the roles
of woma n and artist . ,She did, as she descr ibed in Profe ssion s for i
-'.I
Wom en, succe ed in killin g her own Ange l in the, Hous e, and, by so
doing , encou raged all wome n to follow her exam ple. She asked upon
the death of this phant om, "- -what rema ins?" and answ ered "A
woma n" only to be haunt ed by the more diffic ult quest ion, "Wha t
is a woma n?'' -H,er only ans~ er durin g her own lifetim e could be,
"I assur e you,,, I ·do, _not know . I do not believ e that anybo dy can ,
know, tu1til sh·e has expre ssed herse lf in all the arts and profe ssion s
arts and in the profe ssion s. Many of these wome n have found that
~· the real challe nge Virgi nia Woolf held out to them is not that of
expre ssing thems elves in artist ic and profe ssion al fields or even
that of killin g their own Ange l in the Hous e. The real hurdl e
/
they stumb le upon is that of havin g to find an adequ ate self-i mage . '
The old image s and veils that Ms. Wool f descr ibed are finall y be- i
'
•
ginnin g to crum ble, -but now wome n are faced with the probl em of
filling the void. In attem pting to accom plish this, they are feelin g
some of the deep confl icts that Virgi nia Wool f felt as she strug gled
. ,.
·..... <f!o
102
:,~ ·.
- ·... ~~'t . ;..: .
. ,. . "•
,: '
...... 't
to work out her ·peit:sonal life as woman and as artist. Only now are
-·,·
':
. '-
• ·I""'
:·:f :. - r
j
I.
I
103
.... {.
:,
...,.:
_.,.._
. L.:
·cha_ptE:tr II:-· Dualist ic: lma·ges ·of Woman in Myths of the Past
5. Millett , p. 52.
i -
104
-·. ...
,,
..•
.
Chapter III: Moving Beyond Dualistic Images of the Past:
The Novels of Virginia Woolf
5. Bulfinch, p. 450.
I! -
3. de Beauvoir, p. 241 .
105
',', .
. ·i' . .;1;
' ~. '• 11
,·.. : '•
·'.!•, ·.
,:."; : ;•
15. Millett , p. 33
19. Diane B. Schuld er, "Does the Law Oppres s Women ?",,.
Sisterh ood is Powerf ul, ed. Robin Morga n (New York: Vintag e
Books, 1970), p. 150.
"
20. Carolin e Bird, "The Invisib le Bar, '' Born Female (New
York: Pocket Books, 1-968), p. 41.
.,
106
:-
23. Robins, p. 59.
No Footnotes
No Footnotes
Ii
i
I
.:.
.
. -·-- -- .
....- · -
,.
:107
·.. ,.;.;
.: Appendix I
''!),
108
. I
••• ' .. ,1 .
'';.·' '·,·
·, 1'' I
......
~
1
r
r
!'
'
·./
Bibliography
Works Cited
- .....
110
--·- -·----~---
,
Bell, Quentin.......-Vir·gin ia Woolf: A Biograp l)y. New York:
Harcou rt, Brace, Jovano vich, 1972. I•
'
r
Corrig an, Sylvia Robins on. "Art and Marria ge. 11 Aphra, 2
(Winte r 1970), 5-14.
·---:7
._Ellis, Julie. Revolt of the ~~cond Sex. New York: Lance·r ·
,"
J- Books, 1·910.
Figes, Eva. Patriar chal Attitud es. Greenw ich, Connec ticut:
Fawcet t Publica tions, 1970.
Firesto ne, Shulam ith. The Dialect ic of Sex: The Case for
Femin ist Revolu tion. New York: Bantam Books, 1970.
Karl, Freder ick and Magala ner, Marvin . A Reader 's Guide
to Great Twenti eth Century English Novels . New York:
Farrar , Straus, and Giroux , 1959.
111
' ,-; .•
. ·' .
\
:Mill, John Stuar t. On the Subje ction of Wom en. Green wich,
Conn ecticu t: Fawc ett Publi catio ns, 1971.
'--
Sc hn e i r, Miria m, ed. Femi nism: The Essen tial Histo rical
Writi ngs. New York: Rand om Hous e, 1972.
Stam bler, Sooki e, ed. Wom en's Liber ation : Bluep rint for the
Futur e. New York: Char ter Comm unica tions, 1970.
Tann er, Lesli e B., ed. Voice s from Wom en's Liber ation .
New York: The New Amer ican Libra ry, 1970/
Ware , Celle stine. Wom an Powe r: The Move ment for Wom en 1 s
:.,.
,
Liber ation . New York: Towe r Publi catio ns, 1·910.
Wass erma n, Barb ara .Alson , ed. The Bold New Wom en.
Green wich, Conne cticut :. Fawc ett Publi cation s, 1966.
Wo.c>.lf, Virg~ nia. A Write r's Diary . New York: Harco urt·
• Brace , 1954 .
"'.;····.
~· ..
112
·~ I
..
.. , ·\ ':,. :.
:\ .
' .
Patricia L. :E;i<;hards was born in Reading, Pennsylvania o;r:1
Ms: Richards has also studied dance for mo.st of her life.
··''·
,..,;,,~ .
,.r··
... 113