Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reynaud 2008
Reynaud 2008
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 38, 155–160 155
156 P. Reynaud et al.
Abelia sp. 2
Acacia sp. 1
Arbutus unedo 1
Buddleja sp. 3
Nerium sp. 9
Osmanthus fragrans 99
Rosa sp. 1*
Total 116
*Specimen captured indoors. Fig. 1 Numbers of Thrips hawaiiensis captured weekly in France in 2006.
captured outdoors until the beginning of January 2007. Figure 1 and by the French authorities at Roissy airport (1998 and 2000)
gives the temporal distribution of the 116 specimens identified and Nice airport (2002) on imports from Thailand (on
between week 31 (July 2006) and week 1 (January 2007). The Azadirachta sp. and Melia sp.) and Sri-Lanka (on Musa sp.). In
sex-ratio (ratio of male to female) of this population was 0.84. Japan (Mizobuchi et al., 1991), T. hawaiiensis is one of the
predominant thrips species found in the vicinity of 4 seaports
(Kobe, Himeji, Uno and Hirao). Figure 2 presents the geographical
Distribution
distribution published by the Commonwealth Institute of
T. hawaiiensis is a polyphagous flower-dwelling thrips, widely Entomology (CIE) in 1983, updated to include descriptions
distributed and common in tropical Asia and the Pacific region. published since this date (indicated by a star). The current
It shows undeniable invasive capacities as it is now found – known geographical distribution of T. hawaiiensis is as follows:
although still localised – in Africa, as well as in North and Asia: Bangladesh (CIE, 1983), Burma (CIE, 1983), China [(CIE,
Central America. Until now, T. hawaiiensis had never been 1983), Yuanjiang (Yang, 2000), Guangzhou (Zeng & Lin, 1998),
reported as established in Europe although a unique specimen Hong-Kong (CIE, 1983)], India (CIE, 1983), Indonesia (CIE,
was reported in England by Bagnall (1927), which was 1983), Iran (Manzari & Golmohammadzadeh-Khiaban, 2000),
captured in the natural environment in 1919 near Horden Japan (CIE, 1983), South Korea (CIE, 1983), Laos (CIE, 1983),
(County Durham) on a Compositae. However this record Malaysia (CIE, 1983), Pakistan (CIE, 1983), Philippines Islands
remains doubtful (Collins pers. comm., 2007) and at that time, (CIE, 1983), Singapore (CIE, 1983), Sri Lanka (CIE, 1983), Taiwan
T. hawaiiensis was not included in the British list of (CIE, 1983), Thailand (CIE, 1983), Vietnam (Nakahara, 1994).
Thysanoptera. Interceptions have frequently been made by Africa: Angola (CIE, 1983), Mozambique (CIE, 1983), Nigeria
quarantine services: in the UK (2006) on Musa sp. coming from (CIE, 1983), Sierra-Leone (CIE, 1983), Uganda (CIE, 1983),
India (http://www.defra.gov.uk/planth/interc/intercold.htm) Reunion Island (Bournier, 2000).
Fig. 2 Distribution of Thrips hawaiiensis according to Commonwealth Institute of Entomology Map no. °431 (1983); later records are indicated by a star.
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 38, 155–160
Thrips hawaiiensis now established in Europe 157
Australasia and Pacific islands: Australia (CIE, 1983) main vein of the forewing and by the irregular teeth on the
[Queensland, New South Wales (Mound & Masumoto, 2005)], posteromarginal comb on tergite VIII.
Fiji (CIE, 1983), Guam (Nakahara, 1994), Hawaii (CIE, 1983),
Midway Islands (Jacot-Guillarmod, 1975), Norfolk Island
Economic importance
(CIE, 1983), New Guinea (CIE, 1983), Samoa (CIE, 1983),
Campbell Island (Mound & Walker, 1982). T. hawaiiensis, is a strict flower-dwelling species which can
North America: USA [Florida (CIE, 1983), Georgia attack various crops such as tobacco (Kurozawa et al., 1964), rose
(CIE, 1983), South Carolina (Sakimura, 1986), California (Woo & Paik, 1971; Wang, 1982), gladiolus (Chen & Lo, 1987),
(Nakahara, 1994), Texas (Nakahara, 1994) and Washington DC Brassica oleracea (Chandra & Lal, 1973), coffee (Ketavan, 1978),
(Nakahara, 1994)]. tea (Chen, 1979), mango (Lee & Wen, 1982), citrus (Srivastava &
Central America and the Caribbean: Jamaica (Sakimura, Bhullar, 1980; Chiu et al., 1991), apple and pear (Palmer & Wetton,
1986), Mexico (Nakahara, 1994). 1987) and banana (Tsai et al., 1992; Jhala et al., 2004). Chen
& Chang (1987) regards T. hawaiiensis as one of the main thrips
devastating vegetables in Taiwan. Adults are very polyphagous
Taxonomy
and can feed on numerous host plants. Takahashi (1936) and
Morgan described this species from Hawaii under the name Wang (2002) give further information about host plants.
Euthrips hawaiiensis in 1913. Its great morphological T. hawaiiensis is also considered to be a useful pollinating
variability has resulted in many authors subsequently agent on oil palm (Elaeis sp.) (Syed, 1979; Tay, 1981), Cosmos
redescribing it under various names: the nominal species has 18 bipinnatus (Varatharajan et al., 1982) and Lantana camara
recognised junior synonyms. (Mathur & Ram, 1986).
The genus Thrips is large with about 280 described species However, lists of host plants should be treated with caution
worldwide (Mound, 2001). Palmer (1992) separated the Thrips because T. hawaiiensis has often been confused with T. florum.
species of the Oriental and Pacific regions into five groups. These 2 species are morphologically very similar and at
Thrips hawaiiensis was assigned to group V, characterised by one time (between 1966 and 1985) they were synonymized.
Palmer as having abdominal sternites III-VII with discal setae, T. hawaiiensis causes direct damage by puncturing flowers and
pleurotergites without discal setae and metanotum usually fruits, inducing spot lesions, scarring, necrosis or malforma-
striate or with some median reticulations. However, this tions depending on the intensity of the attack. It also feeds
allocation of the species into five groups, convenient from on pollen and host plant fertility problems can be noted.
an identification point of view, does not necessarily reflect T. hawaiiensis is not a virus vector.
phylogenetic relationships within the genus Thrips (Mound,
2005). T. hawaiiensis belongs to a complex of four species
Biology
that also includes T. florum (South Asia, Pacific, Australia,
North America), T. andrewsi (Northern India and China) and There are few publications about the life history of T. hawaiiensis,
T. exilicornis (Africa). The geographical coexistence of the two mainly from Asian authors. Murai (2001), however, has
invasive species, T. florum and T. hawaiiensis, renders their explored in detail the relationship between temperature, and
identification particularly difficult in certain regions. Bhatti thrips development and reproduction. Under laboratory
(1999) fully discusses this subject. conditions, with thrips reared on pollen of Camelia sinensis at
Under the stereomicroscope, the specimens collected in constant temperature, the developmental period from egg hatch
France corresponded to the bicoloured form with a yellow to to adult emergence was 38.9 days at 10°C (but then the adults
dark orange head and prothorax, yellow legs, and distinctly failed to oviposit), 19.4 days at 15°C, 16 days at 20°C, 10.3
brown abdomen. Forewings were grayish with the basal quarter days at 25°C and 8 days at 30°C.
paler. The antennae were 8-segmented, brown except segment According to Murai (2001), the lower threshold temperature
III, the apex of segment II and the base of segment IV and V of development from egg to adult oviposition, calculated by
which are yellow. According to Bhatti (1999), the nominal form linear regression, was 10.4°C and the thermal constant was
is dark brown. This form was not encountered in France. 153.8 degree-days. T. hawaiiensis is a plurivoltine species.
Under the optical microscope, females of T. hawaiiensis can In Western Japan, the number of generations completing
be separated from the 43 other species of Thrips occurring in development varied annually between 11 and 18. Longevity
France by the possession of the following characters: several and fecundity were functions of the temperature. Developmental
discal setae on sternite VII, pleurotergites without discal setae, time decreased with temperature (18 days at 25°C but 92 days
metanotum with a pair of campaniform sensilla and with S1 at 15°C). Maximum longevity was reached at 15°C (121 days)
setae long (more than half the length of the sclerite) and close and maximum fecundity at 20°C (536 eggs). Daily egg produc-
to the anterior margin. The T. hawaiiensis collected in France tion was fairly constant during the lifetime of the female with,
have 8-segmented antennae but a form with 7 segments exists for example, 6–8 eggs per day at 20°C. The sex-ratio was 0.74.
in certain countries. Thrips angusticeps Uzel, 1895, is the most T. hawaiiensis appears to tolerate low temperatures and
similar common and polyphagous species found in France but to show a greater potential voltinism than other pest thrips
this is distinguished by the presence of 5 – 6 distal setae on the (Frankliniella intonsa, Thrips palmi, Thrips tabaci, Frankliniella
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 38, 155–160
158 P. Reynaud et al.
Table 2 Biological parameters used by climex, partly deduced from Murai of T. hawaiiensis in Europe. The increasing number of new
(2001) and adjusted to take into account the currently known distribution of outbreaks being detected, in particular in North America,
Thrips hawaiiensis supports this hypothesis. The discovery of a population in the
South of France confirms the existence of such a pathway, even
Growing Index (GI) Stress Index
if it has not been precisely identified.
Temperature Index Cold Stress
Lower temperature: 10.4°C Temperature threshold: 1°C Probability of establishment
Lower optimum temperature: 15°C Temperature rate: −0.005 For a successful establishment, two criteria have to be met: the
Upper optimum temperature: 25°C
presence of at least one host-plant and a suitable climate to
Upper temperature threshold: 34°C Dry Stress
Degree-days for total development: 153.8 Dry stress threshold: 0.2
allow the species to complete at least one generation. The
Dry stress rate: −0.005 polyphagy of T. hawaiiensis guarantees it an easy access to
Wet Stress food resources in France and Europe, both outdoors and under
Wet stress threshold: 2.5 glass. But Europe might be a marginal climatic zone because
Wet stress rate: 0.002 this thrips is known to be of tropical origin, so climatic
parameters need to be studied more precisely. The potential
geographical distribution of T. hawaiiensis was assessed
occidentalis, Scirtothrips dorsalis, Thrips imaginis). Murai with the climex software based on biological parameters
(2001) concluded that there was considerable potential for (Table 2) partly deduced from Murai (2001) and adjusted to
T. hawaiiensis to become a major pest. Nevertheless, T. take into account the currently known distribution of this insect.
hawaiiensis has not become a major pest in Japan, possibly due The results (Figure 3) suggested that conditions suitable for
to its overwhelming preference for flowers rather than other establishment of T. hawaiiensis exist across the whole
parts of plants and an apparent lack of insecticide resistance. Mediterranean area (from Israel to Spain, and North Africa) and
It is also noted that there may be interspecific variation with along the Atlantic coast of both France and Spain. In Northern
respect to temperature tolerance. Europe, conditions are less favourable but establishment cannot
be completely excluded. The number of generations that could
complete their development annually will vary from 10 to 15
Phytosanitary risk
(up to 20 on a local basis) according to the different regional
A pest risk assessment classically includes 2 steps: firstly, conditions.
an assessment of the risk of introduction (i.e. entry and
establishment) and, secondly, an assessment of the economic
Evaluation of the potential economic and environmental
and environmental damage.
damage
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 38, 155–160
Thrips hawaiiensis now established in Europe 159
Table 3 Economic indicators for crops potentially threatened by Thrips paléarctique (sud de la France). Des éléments portant sur la
hawaiiensis in France répartition géographique actuelle, l’identification, la biologie
et le risque d’établissement en Europe de cette espèce
Production Surfaces Number of farms Production value
potentiellement invasive sont fournis.
Ornamentals 21 000 ha 11 000 $1.0 billion
Vegetable crops 277 400 ha 36 100 $3.1 billion
Tobacco 8 153 ha 3 662 $98 million
Orchards 188 759 ha 20 691 $2.5 billion
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 38, 155–160
160 P. Reynaud et al.
Lee HS & Wen HC (1982) [Seasonal occurrence of and injury caused by the shop on biological, integrated and rational control: status and perspectives
thrips and their control on mangoes]. Plant Protection Bulletin (Taichung) with regard to regional and European experiences, Lille, France, 21–23
24, 179–187 (in Chinese). January 1998, 17–18.
Manzari S & Golmohammadzadeh-Khiaban N (2000) Thrips hawaiiensis Reynaud P, Bertaux F & Martinez M (2001) Premier signalement en Europe
(Morgan, 1913), a new species for the thrips fauna of Iran. Journal of de Neohydatothrips samayunkur (Kudo) (Thysanoptera, Thripidae).
Entomological Society of Iran 19, 107–108. Nouvelle Revue d’Entomologie 18, 91–93.
Mathur G & Ram HYM (1986) Floral biology and pollination of Lantana Sakimura, K (1986) Thrips in and around the coconut plantations in Jamaica,
camara. Phytomorphology 36, 79–100. with a few taxonomic notes (Thysanoptera). Florida Entomologist 69,
Mizobuchi M, Fujiwara Y, Kobayashi K, Ikawa Y, Maruyama S & Ogino T 348–363.
(1991) Notes on thrips (Thysanoptera) collected in and around ports of Srivastava S & Bhullar JS (1980) Thrips – a new record as a pest of citrus
Kobe, Himeji, Uno and Hirao. Research Bulletin of the Plant Protection blossoms in Himachal Pradesh. Current Science 49, 747.
Service Japan 27, 115–126. Streito JC & Martinez M (2005) Nouveaux ravageurs, 41 espèces depuis
Mound LA (2001) So many thrips-so few tospoviruses. In Thrips, Plants, 2000. Phytoma – La défense des Végétaux 586, 16–20.
Tospoviruses: the Millennial Review Proceedings of the 7th International Sutherst RW, Maywald GF & Kriticos D (2007) CLIMEX version 3 User’s
Symposium on Thysanoptera 15–18. Guide. CSIRO Publishing, Melbourne, 1–131.
Mound LA (2005) The Thrips orientalis group from South-east Asia and Syed RA (1979) Studies on oil palm pollination by insects. Bulletin of
Australia: some species identities and relationships (Thysanoptera, Entomological Research 69, 213–224.
Thripidae). Australian Journal of Entomology 44, 420–424. Takahashi R (1936) Thysanoptera of Formosa. The Philippine Journal of
Mound LA & Masumoto M (2005) The genus Thrips (Thysanoptera, Science 60(4), 427–459.
Thripidae) in Australia, New Caledonia and New Zealand. Zootaxa 1020, Tay KC (1981) Observations on insects visiting oil palm inflorescences. The
1–64. Planter 57, 82–91.
Mound LA & Walker AK (1982) Terebrantia (Insecta: Thysanoptera). Tsai YP, Hwang MT & Chen HP (1992) [Occurrence and damage of Thrips
Fauna of New Zealand 1, 1–115. hawaiiensis in banana orchards]. Chinese Journal of Entomology 12,
Murai T (2001) Development and reproductive capacity of Thrips hawaiiensis 231–237 (in Chinese).
(Thysanoptera: Thripidae) and its potential as a major pest. Bulletin of Varatharajan R, Gopinathan K & Ananthakrishnan TN (1982) Comparative
Entomological Research 91, 193–198. efficiency of thrips in relation to other foraging insects in the pollina-
Nakahara S (1994) The genus Thrips Linnaeus (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) tion of Cosmos bipinnatus Cav (Compositae). Proceedings of the
of the New World. Technical Bulletin. United States Department of Indian National Science Academy, B (Biological Sciences) 48(6), 735–
Agriculture 1822, 1–183. 739.
New M, Hulme M & Jones PD (1999) Representing twentieth century Wang C (2002) [Thrips of Taiwan: Biology and Taxonomy]. Taiwan
space-time climate variability Part 1: development of a 1961–90 mean Agricultural Research Institute 99, 1–328 (in Chinese).
monthly terrestrial climatology. Journal of Climate 12, 829–856. Wang CL (1982) [Insect pests and their injury on rose]. Journal of Agricultural
Palmer JM (1992) Thrips (Thysanoptera) from Pakistan to the Pacific: a Research of China 31, 97–101 (in Chinese).
review. Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History), Entomology Woo KS & Paik WH (1971) [Studies on the thrips (Thysanoptera) unrecorded
Series 61, 1–76. in Korea (I)]. Korean Journal of Plant Protection 10, 69–73 (in Korean).
Palmer JM & Wetton MN (1987) A morphometric analysis of the Thrips Yang Y (2000) [Harm Characteristics and the Control of Thrips in Mangifera
hawaiiensis (Morgan) species-group (Thysanoptera: Thripidae). Bulletin indica in Yuanjiang]. Yunnan Forestry Science and Technology 3, 57–60
of Entomological Research 77, 397–406. (in Chinese).
Pijnakker J (2003) Echinothrips americanus, un ravageur sous-estimé. Zeng XN & Lin JT (1998) [Damage of Thrips hawaiiensis (Morgan) to
PHM-Revue-Horticole 449, 25–27. banana and its control]. Plant Protection 24(6), 15–17 (in Chinese).
Reynaud P (1998) Les Thysanoptères des cultures légumières et ornementales: Zur-Strassen R (2003) Die terebranten Thysanopteren Europas und des
2 années d’inventaire et un invité surprise! In First transnational work- Mittelmeer-Gebietes. Die Tierwelt Deutschlands 74, 1–277.
© 2008 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2008 OEPP/EPPO, Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 38, 155–160