Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Laboratory of Citizenship: Shifting Conceptions of Citizenship in Yugoslavia and Its Successor States
A Laboratory of Citizenship: Shifting Conceptions of Citizenship in Yugoslavia and Its Successor States
Igor Štiks
University
University of Edinburgh, School of Law
The Europeanisation of Citizenship in the Successor States of the Former Yugoslavia
(CITSEE)
A Laboratory of Citizenship:
Shifting Conceptions of Citizenship in Yugoslavia and its Successor States
Igor Štiks
The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in Scotland, with registration number SC005336.
© 2010 Igor Štiks
This text may be downloaded only for personal research purposes.
Additional reproduction for other purposes, whether in hard copies or electronically,
requires the consent of the authors.
For information about the Project please visit the project website at
http://law.ed.ac.uk/citsee
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 1
! "
" # $ ## "
##% & !
' "
( !
) # $* #+ , *
* ) #+- " * #.% ,
" "
) , ) #.% ##%,
" ) ##%* ## ,
! / &
& "
! / ' " * 0
1 " ! 2 0
3 ! 4 " / 5 / 4
/ ) # +* ## ,6
" " !
) "" 7%%- & 8 /
1 3' " 7%%.
& :
"
! ? &
< 4 * /
: ?
E E "
? ##7 ##- &
5 *
"" " ##7
" : &
!
" " ##% &
" " "
E " E " "
! /
" " *
" 4 /&
" * " * E "
E ?
* " " 4 /&
&
1 " (
/ "
" & "
" ) *, &
" " &
* *
" = " "
"" &
!
' "
(
! ) # $* #+ , *
* ) #+- " *
#.% , "
" ) , ) #.% ##%,
" ) ##%* ## ,
! / & 7%%% ?
!
& 3 '
& "
! /
' " * 0
& ' " "
"
" " " &
!" # $ %
!&!'(!&)!
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 4
! A 2 2
" &
& "" " "
G " "
" &
" " *
" & : " </8 /
" ? " % !
& ! D "
" 4 / " (
D " 1 &
; * 8 5
4 " / ) & ' , " " 8 *
5 '
)H I #FF( * 7,&
"
" " *
" " " * & & "
* &7
E 5 " *3 "
" E " !
&A #7$ D " 1
! &
& " =
! # $ #7$ ) I J 0 K I #.-(
%-* 9%,& 8 !
) < " # $, D "
D " : D " 1
; &
4 " & ' D "/ " /&
( & ' E " 4 " / E
" "
" )H I #FF( -,& ( & '
" " #+-
" ! &
" !
! &! " " & 4 /
" "
7 A B "< " =
" &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 5
"
! & ! * '
" "
" '
&5 ' "
) , " " "
"
" " " " " "
"
&A *
* ' 4 /
&
" ! *
" &3
2 2 "
!
! 4 "" /
) # * )
" " ,&
" ! & 1 =
"* 1 #9#
! )<? I 7%%9( -9,& > !
" & "
! " 8' 4 /
! ' &
" ' " ""
" * " & 8 4 /
! "" * "
*
" & &
*" # + (
% !&),(!&&-
! " " =
! : ' & 1 "
! 4 "
" / 4 "" /& ! 4 "/
" D ? = #F 4
N N N *" ""
/) B " ## ( .9,& 3 "
" ) , !
" " " ; &
"
" " ! & :
"
&
! / "
# # & 1 "
" ! "
" " "
#.F #F ! #F+& :
"
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 7
" &
"
" &
! " "
! " *
" = &8
" " ?
"
" ! & " !
) , "
) #+- " " #.F* #F ,
) " #.F #F+,&
! "
& 8 & 7+#
1 AB ! ) #F+, 4
AB!/ 4 " / AB!&
" 4
" /&
A
" &
= "
* &< " !
" =
" " "
& > ' = " 6 "
" ); ? I ##$, =
"
& !
" "
" " " "
" "
&
! & 8 " " ! /
' * "
= &4 /!
"
" ? =
" &
." # $ / %0
1 1 2
." !"
8 ! #+-
* "
##% ! / & " "
" = E " + , +
- .+ . -E
" ! /
&1 "
&
" ! "
#$%& 0 #$%
" &
1 "" ! H ##% "
!
" ##% "
* & < " " !
&
" " " * * "
" " ? '
& ) ,
" " "
" = ! &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 10
* " )
, ' !
" ! & *
" "
" " &
"
& " 4 /
* *
& +
;
" ""
"" ) R,& 1
" " " ! E
E " )
: 0 ,& 8 " * ""
" ! " 4 *
" /) ###( 7 +,&
" " / C
&
= 8 D
: L ? : " U &
*
) 7% %,
* "
" ? * &< "
* & " ?
" ? "
*
" ? C" " & A "
? * '
" " " "
" ? "
&
" " ! M
" ' M
&0
" " "
" " "
) 7%%.,& "
&
" " "
" 4 "/ )5 ##7,
"
&
1 "
& A
! / " ! /
" " " ?
) ,& 3
"
* "
" ! "
" " & ' " "
& =
" = "
&
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 12
"
! / ) 1
0 AB ! : , (
' * ' &
,
8 !
& 8 "
/
" &;
=
" < " ?
& "
" & "
" " &5 =
" "
" " ' &
"
" E !
" E
" & E
"
" )B I ##$,& " *
) " 0 ##7, D ) 7%%$,&
5 " " " "
" & '
" B
* )0 ##7
7%%#,&
,
8" " M"
4 / & &
M ? &8 '
1 ## ) B
7%%#,& A = 1
1 " * ( 1
1 6
4 / " 0 *5 E "
= E 6 " " 1
) * 2 2 " * #+-
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 13
1 ,&
1 = "" /
1 & " "
" " " E < E
&! B " 1 1
: " /
41 /& 8 & .
1 1 "
0 *5 & 8 " " & - "
1 ## $%% %%% "
0 *5 ) " " *1
" " 1
* ,&- >
= E
0 *5 E "
&.
0 *5 " *
= ##9 " " ##7
&
AB! 0 *5 .8 ##7
E E
" 0 *5
* " & 5 " " " 4
/ & " " "
:
" " " &
;
""
' ! &
" "
& 3 !
" &
A " =
= "
& :
< , & ?
" 4 / " " M "
" & & &
'" "
" " " ! / * =
AB!
H ##7 ): Y*; ##$( 77 *77.6 : 7%%#,& H ### 8
1 AB! F %%% "
& 5
+ %%% " 9
8 7%%9 1 1
" "" " &
* 1 " ) *
1 " ,
1 " "
D ? & " "
* 1 / ## ' *
& * ' ) * '
, " 1 " '
1 "
2 D ? ##- )
1 H ##$,& " ? 1 "
" "
1 1 & S" "
1 & "
& 1 E " "
1 0 * 1 E
1 ) ,
* " ) 1 " 7%%.( 7#*
9 ,& 5 S" / = 7%%%
1 / " " 1 "
&
!B : "
##7 " ! :
" &
" " " :
& "
( 8 "
: ! "
8 " & 8 "
1 " *
' " 8 &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 17
#< ;
* ' " ' ) / ,E
" / * C ? *
E 1 0
0 1 / ##9 ##+& 8
8 ##%E " S" /
1 E "T < "
* ""
: "
1 & 3 " "
D ?
! / !
: ##& "
D ? "1 & "
" "" ## "
" / A 8 " )H>8,&
" 0 E
0 : " 1 E4
" / " ## & ##7
" 0 & " 0
" G ? 1
## =
0 &8 1 0 ## ##7
0 / &5 ##9
##+ 1 2 5 1 0 E
" " T E
" 0 & ? 0 "
* 1 B 5 *0
"
1 &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 18
$% $% & !
3 " "
" ! " 4 / ); ? I ##$( F9,&
>
'& " ? "
& 8 "
"
E '
= E " ? &
=
" &
" 4 /
" " " )
4 / , " &
1 " "
" " &
" &
% 2 8 : " :
## " "
: & 7%% 8 "
* ' &0 " E E
* ' " " &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 19
& "
= "
" "
? "" ' &
1
= "
" E
? " = E
' &
" " !
' '
? &8 "
" "
) ,
& "
" " "
& ##%
3 : 2 / 2
> 8" 8 (4
8 : * / ) #$9( -$,&
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 20
" = >
/ " " &
)" ' ( 1 + /
2
! / "D
###& " ' * "
* : 7%% & 8
A ? S" ### : K I[ "
7%%% T 7%%%
7%%9 " 4 / 2 0 "
& "
4 / "
" /
" " & 7%%% "
" *
" E " " E
! / & " " "
)
: 7%%., ) D " 7%%$,
" & " " "
" ##% &
" * ! 1
0 *5
" & 8
" " 4 / &
7%%% 1 '
? &3 " "
" &
8 ' "
"
" " & "
" " " *
1 "" )B
7%%#,&
3 "
" * ! *
: " : D & 0
3 A " 8 " 8 7%% :
8 "" " " :
8 &8 " " 1 )
7%% , = 1 ) 7%%+, " & :
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 21
* 4 " /V " W) #
% " # ? 7%% ,& 8
" ? 8
8 " & A 7%%+ ; "
= " &
7%%+ > 8 "
1 ) #F.* #$9, AB!
& " 7%%+ =
" " &
"
" ! =
) \,& " *
" 1
& 8 : /
" & 1 4
/ )@ % " " ' 7%%.,&
* E " 1 E
" " 7%%F&
" " " AB!
= = "
4 /& 7%%F
" : =
&
" ": /
" &8 7%%9
97 & :
: &
### :
" &
AB !
& 8 7%%. :
1 # 3 7%%F&
: 4 " / )@ A
7%%F,& 8 " : "
: 7%%$& 1
: 4
B : /
V " W&
: " E E = :
? " &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 22
: "
" "
E ' " / E
" & :
& : "
" ? :
"
: / E "
7%%.E &
4> / D A 7%%$
1 " - H 7%%$
8 D / 4 /&
D 4 / 4 "
/ ) # % " #
B 7%%$,& 3 " D " &
' D AB !
4 / D H ##$& 5 ' " *
' "" &D D
4 / *" ? / &
' / ? /
" ! / &
" " "
=
" " " &
*" " "
1 > '
" 0
D : & "
*"
& 0 1
"
&5 "
"
= & > 7%%%
"
" ?
&
" (
! / '
" "
&:
1 :
" D & 0 * "
""
= &5 *
) 1
, 0 : &
D / D )
" "
8 , D
" D D & 3
4 / ! &
3 1 4 3 156 1
# 6
1 " *!
R " " "
" ! & E
" " " E
" " ! "
? ! &
E "
" " E
" &5 " (
" " "
" " "
&
3 "
" ! & 8
" " &
'
" " "
& "
E "
' " "
E"
" " !
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 24
0 &
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/02 25
B 0 ` 0 ; 2 +9#*+-$&
& 8" "( 8" " ; &
1
& ###& < " < : (
0 1 "" A &I : - )7,( 7%-*79-&
I G & ##$& > ! 1 (;
; ; & ! +% + 9 ) *7,( 7+9*7-#&
@ A V1 : W& 7%%F& 8
(CC & & & C ' & R" X9J X7