Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effects of Recycling On The Microstructure and The Mechanical Properties of Isotactic Polypropylene
Effects of Recycling On The Microstructure and The Mechanical Properties of Isotactic Polypropylene
Polypropylene (PP) was injection moulded several times to mimic the effect of recycling
procedures. The influence of the recycling was studied by following changes in chemical
structure, melt viscosity, crystallisation behaviour, and tensile and fracture properties. The
main effect of recycling is the lowering of the melt viscosity, which is attributed to
molecular weight decrease. Recycled PP exhibits greater crystallisation rate, higher
crystallinity and equilibrium melting temperature than those measured for virgin PP. Elastic
modulus and yield stress increase with the number of recycling steps. However, elongation
at break and fracture toughness decrease. C 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers
0022–2461
C 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers 2607
injection moulding cycles, and 0 represents the virgin The degree of crystallinity (X c ) of the isothermally
material (pellets). There are no results of mechanical crystallised samples were calculated using the follow-
and fracture tests for PP–R0 since the preparation of ing equation:
the specimens implies the injection moulding of the
pellets. X c = Hf /Hf0 (2)
Tensile test specimens (ASTM D-638-97, type I) where Hf is the heat of fusion, derived from the area
have been obtained as described above. For each between the measured curve and the base line in the re-
recycling step prismatic bars (ASTM D-647) with gion of the peak, and Hf0 is the enthalpy of fusion of a
12.7 mm × 6.35 mm × 127 mm dimensions were also completely crystalline isotactic PP, taken to be 207.1 J/g
injection moulded. These bars were cut to 12.7 mm × [13].
6.35 mm × 63.5 mm dimensions and notched to ob- The apparent crystallisation temperature (Tapp ) was
tain single-edge notched bend (SENB) specimens for calculated by taking the peak temperature of crystalli-
impact tests. Crack (a) to depth (W ) ratio between 0.3 sation exotherm. The PP sample was heated to 230◦ C
and 0.54 were used. A pre-crack was also introduced at a rate of 200◦ C/min and held for 5 minutes to ensure
by sliding a fresh razor blade over the tip of the notch. complete melting. It was then cooled to 50◦ C at a rate
The final value of the notch depth was measured after of 10◦ C/min.
fracture by using an optical microscope. The specimens
were annealed in a fan-assisted oven for 3 h at 145◦ C 2.3. Mechanical properties
(tensile specimen) and 150◦ C (fracture specimen). Tensile tests (ASTM D-638-97) were performed on an
Instron 4206 standard testing machine at a crosshead
2.2. Characterisation of the microstructure speed of 50 mm/min and at room temperature. Elastic
The Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) analysis was deformations were measured by an Instron strain gage
carried out in order to study any change in the chemical extensometer, model No. A1439-1007, having a gage
structure, using a Nicolet FTIR-460 spectrophotometer. length of 50 mm. A minimum of five specimens was
The measurements of Melt Flow Index (MFI) were tested for each material.
done with a CEAST 6540/010 equipment according to SENB specimens were tested on a CEAST instru-
the test conditions of ASTM D-1238-95: 230◦ C; load mented Charpy impact pendulum, equipped with a
2160 g. MFI is a measure of the fluidity of the mate- data acquisition unit. Impacting of the specimens oc-
rial and is strongly influenced by the weight-average curred under the following conditions: mass of the
molecular weight (Mw ). For this reason MFI can be striker = 2.182 kg, v = 0.57 m/s, room temperature,
used to obtain rapid information about the change of span 50.8 mm. The impact data were analysed accord-
the molecular characteristics of the PP due to repeated ing to the linear elastic fracture mechanics approach
recycling events. [14]. The fracture toughness (K IC ) was calculated by
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was carried means of the equation
out with a Perkin-Elmer DSC7 thermal analyser under
1/2
nitrogen atmosphere. Microtomed sections of tensile 3 Fmax · S a a
specimens were used as samples. According to ASTM K IC = · · ·Y (3)
2 B·W W W
D-3417-97 the samples typically weighed between 5.5
and 6 mg. where Fmax is the maximum load; S the span; B and
The Avrami analysis method was used to study the ki- W are the thickness and the width of the specimen,
netics of isothermal crystallisation [10]. DSC samples respectively; a is the initial crack length and Y (a/W ) a
were maintained as melt at 230◦ C for 5 minutes. At calibration factor depending on the specimen geometry.
this temperature self-seeded nuclei disappear because For the determination of the critical strain energy
the annealing temperature is higher than the equilibrium release rate (G IC ), the following equation was used
melting temperature (Tm0 ) of PP (the highest estimation
of Tm0 is 220◦ C [11]). An isothermal crystallisation tem- Uc
G IC = (4)
perature (Tc ) range from 124 to 134◦ C was chosen in BW φ
order to ensure that there is no possible crystallisation
where Uc is the fracture energy and φ is a calibration
occurring during the cooling from the melt to Tc . The
factor which depends on the length of crack and the
cooling rate was 45◦ C/min.
size of the sample.
After each isothermal crystallisation, DSC samples
Table I shows a summary of the experimental tech-
were heated from 50 to 200◦ C at a heating rate of
niques and samples preparation.
10◦ C/min with the aim of determining the melting peak
temperature (Tm ) and the degree of crystallinity (X c ).
3. Results and discussion
By plotting Tm against Tc , it is possible to obtain a lin-
3.1. Characterisation of the microstructure
ear plot, which, using the Hoffman-Weeks equation,
In general, during recycling the macromolecules are
allowed extrapolation to the point where Tm = Tc , i.e.,
submitted to high temperatures and intensive shearing
to the equilibrium melting temperature [12]:
which promote thermal, mechanical, oxidative or com-
Tm = Tm0 (1 − 1/γ ) + Tc /γ (1) binations of these degradation mechanisms. The pres-
ence of tertiary carbons in the chemical structure of PP
where γ is the proportionality factor between initial and induces a rapid oxidation [5]. Fig. 1 contains the FTIR
final laminar thickness. spectrum of the virgin (PP−R0) and ten times recycled
2608
T A B L E I Summary of the experimental techniques and sample preparation
Figure 3 Heating DSC curves for PP-R0 and PP-R10; PP-R10 curve is
shifted vertically.
Figure 6 Variation of the Avrami exponent (n) and kinetics constant (k) with the number of recycling events.
2610
Figure 8 Apparent crystallisation temperature (Tapp ) as a function of the
recycling cycle.
Figure 11 Elastic modulus (E) of the virgin and recycled PP as a func-
tion of the number of cycles.
Figure 10 Typical stress-strain tensile curve; elastic deformation (I), stress-whitening (II), necking (III), fibrillation (IV) and fracture (V).
2611
resulting in a more connected structure. At increasing
molecular weight, a higher elongation at break of fib-
rils is observed [24], increasing the energy required for
crack propagation, and consequently improving frac-
ture toughness. The concentration of the tie-molecules
can also be varied by the crystallisation temperature
[23, 24]. As the crystallisation temperature is lowered
the material becomes more and more compact, since the
degree of connection between lamellae and spherulites
increases. This is due to the fact that at lower Tc , the
nucleation and density rates, as well as the overall crys-
tallisation rate, increase. This effect trends to freeze
Figure 13 Elongation at break (εb ) plotted against the number of recy-
somewhat the melt configuration of the molecules, al-
cling cycles. lowing only for local lamellae formation. This pro-
vides in the fully crystallised sample a number of tie-
The yield strain is practically constant with recycling molecules between lamellae which is higher the lower is
(9%). The whitening of the necked region of the tensile Tc . Thus, it could be assumed that the tie-molecule den-
yielded PP specimens is associated with the presence sity decreases with recycling due to shorter molecules
of a large amount of micro-voids and a highly fibrillar and higher crystallisation temperatures.
morphology [20]. The lowering of the toughness with recycling may
The elongation at break (εb ) for virgin and recycled also be due to the increase in yield stress [25] (see
PP is seen in Fig. 13. εb is practically constant up to Fig.12). It has been reported that the fibrillated damage
four recycling steps, and decreases with recycling above zone ahead of the notch can be initiated more easily in
this point. This decreasing is related to the higher crys- a lower-yield-stress material [26], and that the amount
tallinity of the recycled PP [21] and to the reduction of dissipated energy is proportional to the extension of
of the molecular weight with repeated processing cy- this plastic zone, whose size depends on the yield stress
cles. Lower molecular weight inserts more chain ends of the material [27].
into the structure, resulting in fewer chains completely
integrated into the crystal to sustain stress during ten- 4. Conclusion
sile loading, causing failure at lower elongation. More- The effects of recycling on the structure and mechanical
over, shorter molecules have less entwining and less properties of isotactic polypropylene have been investi-
C-C linkages to stretch. gated. The absence of changes in the chemical structure
The break stress is practically constant (22.6 ± and the increase of the MFI suggest that chain scission,
1.6 MPa) up to ten recycling steps. As is shown in and not oxidation, is the dominant degradation mecha-
Fig. 14, K IC and G IC decrease with recycling. In this nism under the experimental conditions.
paper only the results for PP-R1, PP-R2, PP-R4 and The observed reduction of the molecular weight with
PP-R6 are reported in order to show the effect of recy- recycling increases the mobility and the ability to fold of
cling on the fracture parameters. Nevertheless, a more the chains, allowing the formation of thicker lamellae
exhaustive study is actually being carried out. and higher degree of crystallinity. The crystallisation
Tie-molecules act as local transmitters of stress rate also increases with recycling due to the shorter
among lamellae and are broken during deformation molecules and higher apparent degree of supercooling.
and fracture. The density of tie-molecules being in- The higher elastic modulus and yield stress of the
corporated in at least two crystalline lamellae (intras- recycled PP seems to be correlated with higher de-
pherulitic link) and also the number of those connect- gree of crystallinity, and the lower elongation at break
ing the spherulites (interspherulitic link) increase with with the decrease of the molecular weight. Fracture
molecular weight [22, 23]. Furthermore, an increment toughness also decreases for the recycled materials due
in the molecular weight enhances the probability of to the higher yield stress and the lower tie-molecule
chain entanglements in the amorphous phase [22, 23], density.
Figure 14 Effect of recycling on (a) fracture toughness (K IC ) and (b) strain energy release rate (G IC ).
2612
Acknowledgements 14. J . G . W I L L I A M S , “Fracture Mechanics of Polymers” (Ellis
The authors would like to thank Dr. O. Santana of Cen- Horwood, Chichester, 1987).
15. J . V A R G A , in “Polypropylene Structure, Blends and Composites,”
tre Català del Plàstic for his help with the fracture tests,
Vol. 1, edited by J. Karger-Kocsis (Chapman & Hall, London, 1995)
and to Mr. R. Rodrı́guez and Dr. A. M. Zaldua of Lea- Ch. 3.
Artibai for their assistance with FTIR analysis. 16. M . G A H L E I T N E R , J . W O L F S C H W E N G E R , C . B A C H N E R ,
K . B E R N R E I T N E R and W . N E I S S L , J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 61
References (1996) 649.
1. C . D . P A P A S P Y R I D E S and J . G . P O U L A K I S , in “The Poly- 17. A . S H A R P L E S , “Introduction to Polymer Crystallization” (Edwar
meric Materials Encyclopedia,” edited by J. C. Salomone (CRC Arnold, London, 1966).
Press, Inc, 1996) p. 7403. 18. A . G A L E S K I , in “Polypropylene Structure, Blends and Compos-
2. M . M A R R O N E and F . P . L A M A N T I A , Polymer Recycling 2 ites,” Vol. 1, edited by J. Karger-Kocsis (Chapman & Hall, London,
(1996) 9. 1995) Ch. 4.
3. J . G . P O U L A K I S and C . D . P A P A S P Y R I D E S , Resources, 19. N . B R O W N , in “Failure of Plastics,” edited by W . B R O S T O W
Conservation and Recycling 20 (1997) 31. and R . D . C O R N E L I U S S E N (Hanser, Munich, 1986) Ch. 6.
4. V . A . G O N Z Á L E Z G O N Z Á L E Z , G . N E I R A - V E L Á Z Q U E Z 20. Y . L I U , C . H . L . C O L I N , R . W . T R U S S and N . J . C A L O S ,
and J . L . A N G U L O S Á N C H E Z , Polym. Degrad. Stab. 60 Polymer 38 (1997) 2797.
(1998) 33. 21. R . G R E C O and F . C O P P O L A , Plast. Rubb. Process. Applic. 6
5. F . C A T A L I N A , Rev. Plas. Mod. 75 (1998), 391. (1986) 35.
6. B . E . T I G A N I S and R . A . S H A N K S , Y. LONG, J. Appl. Polym. 22. J . K A R G E R - K O C S I S , in “Polypropylene Structure, Blends
Sci. 59 (1996) 663. and Composites: Composites,” Vol. 3, edited by J. Karger-Kocsis
7. Q . Y I N G , Y . Z H A O and Y . L I U , Makromol. Chem. 192 (1991) (Chapman & Hall, London, 1995) Ch. 2.
1041. 23. A . O . I B H A D O N , J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 69 (1998) 2657.
8. M . M A R R O N E and F . P . L A M A N T I A , Polymer Recycling 2 24. R . G R E C O and G . R A G O S T A , J. Mater. Sci. 23 (1988) 4171.
(1996) 17. 25. M . S U G I M O T O , M . I S H I K A W A and K . H A T A D A , Polymer
9. H . H I N S K E N , S . M O S S , J . - R . P A U Q U E T and H . 36 (1995) 3675.
Z W E I F E L Polym. Degrad. Stab. 34 (1991), 279. 26. S . C . T J O N G , J . S . S H E N and R . K . Y . L I , ibid. 37 (1996)
10. Y . L O N G , R . A . S H A N K S and Z . H . S T A C H U R S K I , Prog. 2309.
Polym. Sci 20 (1995) 651. 27. J . J A N C A R , A . D I A N S E L M O , T . D I B E N E D E T T O and
11. J . V A R G A , J. Mater. Sci. 27 (1992) 2557. J . K U C E R A , ibid. 34 (1993) 1684.
12. M . P A T K A R and S . A . J A B A R I N , J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 47
(1993) 1749.
13. H . S . B U , S . Z . D . C H E N G and B . W U N D E R L I C H , Makro- Received 5 October 2000
mol. Chem. Rapid Commun. 9 (1988) 76. and accepted 12 January 2001
2613