Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Parivarthan
Parivarthan
NOSPLAN ANNUAL
MAGAZINE 2019
3
NOSPlan Annual Magazine is an annual
publication by NOSPlan- Organisation of
Students of Planning, a student organisation
registered under Societies Registration Act of
XXI, 1860. Magazine showcases works of
the student members along with faculties and
guests.
Title
PARIVARTAN
NOSPLAN ANNUAL MAGAZINE 2019
Released on
October 2020
Janhvi
Graphic Designer, NOSPlan “PARIVARTAN” meaning “change“, directs about the changes we have
created in the process of developing cities for enhancing our quality of
NOSPlan Magazine Team of year 2020 life. This change affects our life, society and eventually our earth.
Cover Page By The logo symbolizes change from Agrarian Society to Industrialization
Chinmoy Borah, to Globalization and next towards Sustainable Future. The leaf outline
School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal symbolizes the dire need for changing our perspective towards
Sustainable Planning and Development.
Disclaimer
The opinions, beliefs and viewpoints
expressed by the various authors in this
magazine do not necessarily reflect the
opinions, beliefs and viewpoints of NOSPlan
– Organisation of Students of Planning.The
author of each article in this magazine owns
his or her own words.
Registered Office
NOSPlan Secretariat
Department of Physical Planning
School of Planning and Architecture
4, Block B, Indraprastha Estate
New Delhi-110002
www.nosplan.com
4 5
MEMBER COLLEGES
6 7
MAGAZINE TEAM
Chaitanya Lodha
Editor-in-Chief
Janhvi
Graphic Designer,
SPA D
Raj Choudhary
Amity Noida
Sahil Raj Harbansh
MANIT
Manogna Gauthami
JNAFAU
10
Faculty Articles
62
Poetry
TA B L E
OF
Arun Shankar Trisha Udumudi Anirudh G Mounika Nagireddy Anoushka Das Dhruv Vagadiya
CONTENTS
GEC Thrissur SPA D SPA V SVNIT Nirma University MSU B
24
Sudent Articles
74
Convention 2019
8 9
or not to write, new questions emerged. profession? I don’t think so, because
For instance, is it necessary for you at any point of time I have tried to
to have an aim and purpose at the follow my passion, whether it was
beginning of your career to assess while I worked in the corporate
whether you meet success? Would each sector or engaged myself at the
one of you have an aim and purpose community levels without paychecks
at the end of your graduation; if yes, to boast of.
should it be for what it is to be at the I have also not hesitated in dropping
end of 10 years, 20 years… or is it just out of jobs in as short period as a
Dr. Chidambara fine to have an immediate short-term month when it didn’t meet with my
Associate Professor
goal? Is it also possible that setting up expectations. The most important
Department of Transport Planning
SPA, Delhi a goal so early might make you turn thing I feel is to be convinced
a blind eye to other greater or more of what you are pursuing at that
meaningful opportunities that cross your moment, to align your professional
path? Did I do the right thing going interest with your life goals and
straightaway to pursue a masters course choices. So I am not going to
When I received a mail requesting in Transport Planning from the same preach you here whether or not you
I could not hold back the teacher in
to share my success story as an institute when during my time I recall should do a Masters course after an
me. While I debated on whether to
alumnus of this Institute, I must admit there was a deluge of students crossing undergraduate course immediately,
accept or reject the invite I thought
I was a bit amused, a bit confused, overseas to pursue a Masters’ degree whether you should pursue higher
of consulting my favorite dictionary
as the term ‘success’ hung in air in various fields or in management? I studies in your country or elsewhere,
which defined the word rather
appearing to weigh down rather recall of my conviction at that point of whether to look for a job in Planning
pompously, as ‘the accomplishment
heavily. I wondered what exactly time to stay in my country and discover or to ditch the profession, whether to
of an aim or purpose’ with all
might success mean to you, did it my opportunities here (conviction of join the consultancy sector, the non-
synonyms of the word relating to a
mean the same to all you young youth has no parallel), while if someone profit sector, become entrepreneurs
‘favorable’ outcome. Not ready to
minds alike, did it mean differently were to ask me of the reasons now, I or come and join me as a colleague.
give up, I looked further down before
from what it meant to me, and may not be that sure. I also remember The key is to follow your instincts
I hit the archaic English definition
coming to the latter thought was in my early career days when my father and your passion and not be
which threw in a more interesting
I even sure of what it meant to me once dared suggest that I consider a hesitant to change course if your
and inclusive (thankfully for the likes
and if not, could I take it for granted profession in teaching (himself being a conviction wears out or you seek
of me!) definition considering both
that you are so sure of it as well. Professor) it was met with considerable different challenges. Sometimes a
‘the good and the bad outcome’,
Success with respect to a profession ridicule and a curt retort, “What?! No change of course may not be even
and it brought me give up, I looked
can have several connotations: it way!” Today perhaps if one would sufficient; you may be seeking a
further down before I hit the archaic
can be the paycheck you carry advise me to leave this profession different medium altogether. At
English definition which threw in
home, position, power, fame, job (since it pays such a pittance; some of those junctures perhaps the ending
a more interesting and inclusive
satisfaction, an opportunity to live you may be earning the same as I do verses of Morrison’s beautiful poetry
(thankfully for the likes of me!)
your dream… or a combination of in a couple of years) it is possible that “we must try to find out new answers
definition considering both ‘the
these and many other things unlisted it might meet with a similar response, instead of a way” may be most
good and the bad outcome’, and it
here (words restriction!). As often in though a more polite one. appropriate. I hope you all keep
brought me immense relief towards
my lectures when I start with a term, So if I am so sure of what I am pursuing looking for new answers, but for
the execution of the task I have been
the dictionary meaning of the term today, do I have regrets over the career that questioning is always a must.
entrusted with!
precedes the rest and in this case too Having settled the debate of whether course I followed before I joined this
10 11
are environmentally more
W H AT D O vulnerable. Thus the three
factors of evolution, economic
W E N E E D TO growth and environmental
vulnerability create a need
CHANGE? to learn, adapt, plan and
manage these Metropolitan
areas.
S. Brintha Lakshmi Smart City planning and
B.Arch (MSU), MUEM (Netherlands), PhD (IIT Madras) approach may look skewed
Head, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Technology and Engineering in absence of provisions for
The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda regional influences. Cities
cannot expand, improve and
remain livable in absence of
a regular funding mechanism
The theme for NOSPlan 2019 is ‘Parivartan’. ‘Parivartan’ means change. The question then that and land management.
comes to my mind is ‘What do we need to change?’ An impromptu answer is, as Planners we Constitutional amendment
need to change the glaring, shoddy state of our built environment. This is discussed, and solutions to create regular budget
are attempted everyday in some way or the other. Ordinary citizens are grumbling; planners for urban development may
are trying to grapple with the chaos and create infrastructure, development plans, bye laws to support the Metropolitan
list a few actions; city fathers are working at addressing complaints, and proposing projects; areas and Megaregions.
newspapers are reporting all developments, research and, state of the built environment; and The changing aspects of
researchers are engaging with the built environment to get a deeper understanding of the chaos increasing urban areas having
and putting forth publications. Despite all these efforts and investing large amount of funds to
improve conditions in urban and rural settlements, most of the built environment in India continues
I N D I A N C I T I ES E X PA N D I N G regional influence need a
strong financing mechanism
to be chaotic, polluted and, inconvenient. F ROM M ET RO PO L IS TO to sustain a constructive and
This is worrying. As budding planners this situation should be of concern to all of you too. Our MEGAREGIONS qualitative growth.
Parivartan in planning of
built environment, both rural and urban, need to be improved for ease and healthy living. This Utpal Sharma urban areas from Metropolitan
Top: Sherwyn Zeniyadh
could be seriously addressed broadly in two ways: Director TKMCE, Kollam areas to Megaregion merging
1. Short term immediate action to work systematically to reduce the chaos. Institute of Architecture and Planning
transecting and physiographic
2. Strategic decisions to preserve natural heritage so that decisions made today are in the Nirma University
spaces is the next stage of
interest of the future too. development. This change
Planning is not about solving problems of today only but also about creating for the future. India has been growing at Capital Region, Kolkata will have an influence on
a phenomenal rate and its and Mumbai are examples the overall understanding of
cities are changing in form, of increasing influence of urban form and structure. This
behaviour and function. Metropolitan region on the gradual change challenges
From being mere settlements economy and social dynamics. our preparedness to handle
housing large population to Bangalore, Pune, Hyderabad size, complexity, inter and intra
playing an important role in and Ahmedabad are also relation in a regional setting
regional setting, Indian cities developing their Metropolitan and brings with it issues that
have grown to become nodal areas. may need a unique approach
centres for their surrounding Though it is desirable to have to address in each region.
areas. They have started smaller towns but evolution There is an urgency to have
influencing and playing an of Metropolitan areas is huge funds for developing
important role in economic increasing in India and Asia. infrastructure. Funds with
and social growth of regions Growth of Metropolitan the State governments and
around them. areas is proportional to rapid Urban Local Bodies are not
Historically, Regional Plan economic growth of the country sufficient. Governance beyond
of Greater London provides and this growth is happening physical, administrative and
a glimpse into the changing in Metropolitan areas political boundaries along
dynamics and shift of focus only. An emerging area of with innovation in Smart City
from Central Business District concern here is environmental approach may hold the key
to influence areas around. vulnerability. These areas for a successful and buoyant
Closer home, National with augmenting population Megaregion.
12 Anupriya Aggarwal 13
SPA Delhi
‘ SYST E MS T H I N KI N G ’ I N
PLANNING PROGRAMME
B RI E F TO AC H I EV E T RU E
‘ PA R I VA R TA N ’
Dr. Aparna
Assistant Professor
Institute of Architecture and Planning, Nirma University
14 15
I S T H E “ C R Z PA R I VA R TA N ” F O R “Change makes good
PROFIT OR ENVIRONMENT? living possible and treat
as experiencing new
habits”
Prithvijith V S Nair
Asst. Prof.
Government Engineering College, Thrissur islands have limited carrying
capacity. We are aware of all
this due to over-development
& exploitation seen at Bali,
Coastal Regulation Zone opening up the coastline of Maldives etc.
(CRZ) is a buffer or the country for construction The new CRZ notification failed
transitional zone between and tourism activities. No to acknowledge the problems
the marine & the territorial Development Zones (NDZ) of global warming and sea-
zones which includes sensitive could get significantly reduced level rise. Climate change is
ecosystem like the wetland, with this new notification. This resulting in a drastic switch
mudflat seagrass, seaweed paves way for a construction to the environmental status.
ecosystems, mangrove and salt boom along the coastline. environment? Top: Anupriya Aggarwal The human development in
marshes. The Union Ministry The tourism sector is to benefit Island has a unique ecosystem
SPA Delhi islands are under the threat of
of Environment and Forest from the relaxation of the consisting of lagoon, land, climate change. As sea levels
released the CRZ, in 2019 NDZ but will it be good for and flora-fauna. India has climate and diseases. continuing to rise, island
two main islands Andaman In case of islands, the change inhabitants and their cultures
& Nicobar and Lakshadweep in CRZ will affect in numerous are in great danger. There
Islands. Many islanders in ways. A coral reef of an island are small and less populated
these islands are endowed is an underwater ecosystem islands that are economically
with unique cultures and characterized by reef- vulnerable to protect the
receive much of their building corals. These corals Islands. People from these
economic, environmental and would damage due to the islands don’t have the
cultural well-being from the development along the coastal resources to bring a change
valuable natural resources in side and human activity like to the island. If this continues,
their immediate environment. mining or digging, pollution, then within few years many
These islands harbour diverse etc. If NDZ is reduced or islands in Lakshadweep
ecosystems which provides removed in these islands then will be submerged similar
food, fresh water, herbs, the developments along the to that of Maldives. What
fuel, wood, tools, and other coastal areas will result in significance does CRZ have,
essential raw materials, in coral bleaching which initially if it can’t address what need
addition to aesthetic, spiritual, will lead to disintegration of to be done and why?
educational and recreational soil and cause soil erosion, So, according to the title, the
values, that aid island also making the island more Parivartan here is to fill pocket
livelihood, economies, and prone to the disasters. CRZ of some people through
cultures. Island ecosystems focuses more on gaining profit or is it to protect the
contribute to the protection profit from tourism sector. This environment and ecosystem?
of ecosystem functions: they could cause over-development As planners which side will u
give defence against natural and exploitation of limited choose?
disasters, support nutrient resource in the island. All this
Right: Nidish Pithawa
Maharaja Sayajirao University cycling, soil and sand will affect the ecosystem and
of Vadodara formation; and regulation of ecology of the island since
16 17
STAT U S O F U R B A N WAT E R
S U P P LY A N D M U N I C I PA L S O L I D
Govind M.P Top: Sreehari S
Assistant Professor, Department of Environmental Planning TKMCE, Kollam
School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal
India, just like many other the water bodies and through and annual operation &
developing nations, is legislations such as Indian maintenance expenses make
struggling to manage the Easements Act, 1882, made it un-viable for the agencies
water supply demands and it lawful to extract ground to embark on expansion of
municipal waste menace water from the land owned the service coverage. Realistic
generating from rapidly by an individual. This had an pricing of the water supply is
growing urban areas. Here, implication on the aquifers the way forward for achieving
I wish to broadly list, some shared by multiple users. In the both financial viability and
of the transformations related post-independent India, urban water conservation. It has
with both. water supply is predominantly been found that non-pricing
Urban Water Supply in the hands of agencies approaches for achieving
Water supply had been which are Government or water conservation such as
considered as a free parastatal in nature. However, awareness creation, voluntary
commodity and was never privatisation of urban water efforts such as low-flush
considered as an economic supply is also present at a toilets etc. were in-effective etc. is a transformation from Subsidising the connection have following stages: waste
good in the older days. limited scale. in comparison with pricing the conventional pricing cost which is incurred in segregation and storage,
Before the reign of British, Due to fast spreading urban approaches such as tariffs, approaches such as flat laying the service line from segregated collection,
we used to have community areas, providing water supply taxes etc. Even within the pricing and un-metered the distribution system to the segregated processing,
ownership of water bodies systems to all the nook and pricing approaches there are connections and non-pricing user’s end is the way out. disposal of rejects from
and the abstraction rights corner is a daunting task for two types: conventional and approaches. Going back to the older processing in sanitary
were decided by the village any agency shouldering this realistic. Hence, adoption of There are many issues system of community-based landfills. In Indian urban
councils. This completely responsibility. Because of realistic pricing approaches pertaining to water supply management of water supply areas, in order to achieve
changed during British the cost implications and the such as metered pricing, systems in urban areas is the option having long-term these, lot of efforts are yet to
reign. Here, the provincial non-recovery of the already increasing block tariff structure of India: Un-accounted sustainability. In this form of be taken.
governments took control of invested capital expenses for water (UFW), low- decentralised system, people As per the MSW (M&H) rules,
cost recovery, un-metered have to manage the operation sanitary land-filling involves
connections, in-equitable and maintenance of the system. filling a constructed trench
coverage, fast depleting In order to have a sense of with the inert component of
water sources. Poorer ownership, the community municipal solid waste in a
segments of the society do members would have to bear safe manner which typically
not have any access to the certain portion of the capital involve geo-membranes
system due to very high cost for implementation of the made of High-Density
connection charges. Basic distribution system. Example Polyethylene (HDPE) to act
water requirement for an for one such system is the as impervious liner. Inert
individual to survive is known mini-water supply project in category of municipal solid
as the ‘lifeline supply,’ which Calicut district in Kerala. waste consists of matters
should be provided at a very such as street sweepings,
low rate to the economically Municipal Solid Waste dry leaves and any other
weaker segments of the As per the Municipal Solid waste which do not come
Right:
population. But for this to Waste (MSW) Management within the categories of bio-
happen, these segments must & Handling Rules, municipal degradable and recyclable.
be brought within the service solid waste management
coverage.
18 19
must In Indian urban areas, must be intelligently chosen.
the final disposal sites are E.g.: In case of Ladakh, in-
nothing but huge depressions vessel technology is the most
or just vacant land parcels feasible one because of
without any scientific the vast diurnal variation of
designing involved. In reality, temperature there. Compost
all types of waste reach is considered as a ‘wealth’
the designated dump sites and is deemed as means to
without having any measures recover cost incurred in setting
to disallow percolation of up of the waste management
leachate generated from the system.
biodegradation of the organic In Indian urban areas, non-
waste. This is one of the major segregated storage and the
environmental threats resulting subsequent non-segregated
from un-scientific method of handling must end to bring
waste disposal followed in about transformation in the
Indian urban areas. waste management system.
Due to the fast growth of Clean India Mission is a right
urban areas which has led to step towards making people
its sprawl in turn has made it aware about the importance
operationally difficult for the of waste segregation at
municipal agencies to manage source and recycling/ reuse.
the municipal solid waste from Considering waste as wealth
collection till final disposal. In and the golden principle
order to make the operation of 4Rs (Recycling, Reuse,
of the waste handling system Recovery, Reduce) are the
financially feasible, authorities right approaches for tackling
have resorted to setting up the ever-increasing menace
of transfer stations. At these of municipal solid waste.
Clockwise from top: stations, municipal solid waste Bioremediation of the dumped
1. Meera Aswathy N get transferred from number of waste sites and mining of
TKMCE, Kollam
2. Anupriya small vehicles to single large reusable components from
Aggarwal vehicle and head for the them are transformations from
SPA Delhi
3. Sherwyn Zeniyadh
processing sites such as those the conventional approach of
TKMCE, Kollam for treating bio-degradable abandoning the final disposal
component of waste sites once the capacities
(composting, bio-methanation) are exhausted. Other
and for recyclable component transformations in this sector
of waste (Waste to Energy are also happening such
(WTE) or recycling facilities). as centres for segregation
Composting is one of the waste of mixed waste and for
processing options available processing e-waste, etc.
and adopted to some extent in
Indian urban areas. Only the
bio-degradable component of
municipal solid waste is usable
in this process. Typically, for
the complete conversion from
waste to compost, it takes
about four weeks. Depending
on the ambient temperature
and other climatological
aspects such as humidity,
the method of composting
20 21
CHANGE
H A B ITS TO
B U I L D L I VA B L E
H A B I TAT
22 23
CROSSING THE NET WORKS AND
D OT TI N G T H E I R EVO LU TI O N
Kaveri Gaikwad
SY student
College of Engineering, Pune
24 25
Right: Fig 1. Temporal
comparison of LULC of
Vadodara
C H A N G I N G U R B A N S P R AW L
O F C I T I ES : A G E O S PAT I A L Below: Fig 2.
Temporal change in
urban and barren
land covers for
Vadodara city
Ankit Khatoliya
Arzoo Kumari
Prabhjyot Singh
Pratyush Kumar
School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi
Left: Fig 3.
Temporal Change
in Population and
Area of Vadodara
26 27
CONCEPTUAL CONSTRUCTION
Left: Rushi
SPA Vijaywada
28 29
T R A N S F O R M AT I O N O F
“Each city has an
GURGAON energetic quality, all
Sakshi Gilhotra
of its own- a way of
M.Plan, 2nd year,
SSAA
speaking, an individual
offering and its own
darkness and light”
the changes in society and accommodating an altogether The rapid transit exhibits fast
culture. The city we see different development and movement but also reflects
today has been shaped by different population. the lack of walkability that
different energies, different Traditional Indian cities could bring more people on
people from the country as focused on giving emphasis the street and reduce this
well as from abroad through to public life, to social feeling of alienation.
their different cultures and interactions and culture. Thus transformation of
Right: Cyber hub, ethics. The city throughout its But Gurgaon as of today Gurgaon suggests uneven
Gurgaon
transformation has struggled represents a city that is too fast changes, lack of integrity of
to adopt the new spaces, new and rapid, competing with the spaces and a story of lost
patrons, new art forms and whole world entirely following traditions, but this is also the
ever changing skyline. the globalization trend. city that holds the future of IT
Gurgaon today showcases Gurgaon offers perfection sector of India and promises
the urge towards being and dynamism, but at the growth of our Indian
The transformation of discernible area that grew in recognized as India’s model of same time it looks too foreign economy and technology.
Gurgaon- a city that emerged the millennial era and rose globalization and capitalism. and misses out on the quality
from dusty barren lands to a to new heights. Offering a The city is ever dynamic and of public realm that makes
millennial city is a great story high tech lifestyle and an full of energies, totally different people feel belongingness
in itself. One can witness imposing cityscape through its from the other cities of India towards a place. On one hand
the spectacular and rapid high rise buildings, corporate where the traditions and are the visible tremendous
urbanization of this city, where precincts, rapid transit and a ethics dominate our urban opportunities and on the
the totally agrarian land dominant skyline comprising realm. Cyber city is a great other hand is a strong feeling
transformed into a privatized of glass facades, the city is contrast to our Indian cities, of alienation with no sense of
urban property through a the representative of India’s belonging. The transformation
series of events, the wholesale global accommodation of IT has clearly missed out on
acquisition of agricultural sector and privatized urban providing open spaces
land, uneven integration growth. Showcased as the creating a mess of built fabric
of the acquired land into ambassador of the IT fabric, of that rarely invokes public and
real estate urban property the largest IT hub in the NCR, social interaction.
and thereafter a capitalized it represents the powerhouse
development. The city evolved of our nation with its high
from a agrarian set up to a technosetup.
site of global accumulation The story of Gurgaon’s
where the dominance of transformation not only
privatized urban development speaks about the changes in
is clearlyfelt. land use or global privatized
The cyber hub Gurgaon, a development, but also of
30 31
COPENHAGEN:
A J U X TA P O S I T I O N O F
R ES I L I E N C E A N D L I VA B I L I T Y
Kiran Kumar. S,
Government Engineering College, Thrissur
The past 30 years have seen and strong segregation. The in parts of the park and is Top: Snigdha Dev
Roy
Copenhagen transform itself city was remarkably able directed to the city’s water SPA Delhi
from an ageing, indebted to turn things around with system, and is also utilized
Right: Saranya
city with declining industries unemployment being rate in the summer to water the GEC, Thrissur
and inhabitants, to one of being 4.4% in 2017. plants in the garden.
the happiest and best cities in The primary purpose of the city The city is also striving to be
the world to live in according is to make the city more livable, the first carbon-neutral city Regarding preventive actions,
to various international so all aspects of its citizen by 2025 and has allocated Copenhagen made the
rankings. Copenhagen has are taken into consideration, a fund of $425 towards headlines by launching
placed its trust for resilience under an inclusive strategy. this. Energy, both electricity clinics to treat stress, anxiety
on a dynamic economy and This primarily focuses on jobs generation and heating, is and depression in 2014,
a green and inclusive urban and affordable houses but a major component when spending around €800,000.
environment for its citizen. also a green environment and considering carbon-neutral In Copenhagen, above 40%
Forging ahead with the goal citizens’ health and lifestyles. cities, and the thrust is towards of all commutes are made by
of making cities more livable, With the climate change wind turbines and biomass. bike.
the city has launched various increasing by the day, the city In Copenhagen, the meaning Despite its strong momentum,
revitalization of several will find itself battling increased of livable cities goes beyond the city faces challenges are
declining neighborhood over rainfall, with the infrastructure affordable housing, clean the housing market and the
the decade with the ambitious incapacitated severely. air, jobs and transportation growing social needs of its
aim of meeting economic, The amount of flooding is infrastructure. The city also population.
social, and environmental suspected to increase. In considers the provisions of Copenhagen has based
goals, which offers each of its 2011, a particularly heavy its resilience on a dynamic
public gathering spots where Health is also a key determinant economy and a green and
citizens a homogenous and rainfall caused over $1 billion
people can meet, gather, in any happiness index and a inclusive urban environment
social fabric. in damage and a hundred
play, and engage, a crucial strong emphasis on the city of for its inhabitants. The
In 1980’s the city was year’s rainfalls has happened
component of this progression. Copenhagen. The intervention two building blocks of this
suffering from a decline of twice in the past five years.
This has the purpose of building of the city on health is twofold strategy are green “future-
its port and industries with The city has a preference for
and maintaining the social and a strong emphasis on proof” infrastructure and an
unemployment reaching about green and forward-looking
fabric that is so fundamental the city of Copenhagen. inclusive social fabric. This
17.5% and an annual deficit infrastructure. An example
to resilient societies. The Denmark has (1) a notoriously has materialized through
of $750 Million. The city of this is the integration in
swimming pool at the harbor generous social welfare system comprehensive urban
was trapped in an endless neighborhoods of green
of Copenhagen, which is the with preventive actions and planning.
cycle of deindustrialization, spaces that can retain water
result of the climate prevention (2) the city of Copenhagen
unemployment, high welfare when rainfalls cause risks of
costs, suburbanization, an flooding. Also, during heavy
outdated housing market, rains, the rainwater is retained
32 33
THERE
IS MORE
S U STA I N A B L E TO T H E of the ULB, opposition is edge out the losses and the
usually strong when there’s plan guarantees successful
MOBILITY GREENS climate change is at stake.
Another point of contention
implementation in the end.
However, more stringent
Aakriti
THAN is that green covers in
urban areas help reduce the
and detailed procedures
must be enforced in order
W H AT
Top: Munjal Mehta, ANU
School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi urban heat effect. Plus, it’s to grant permissions. Just so
a bonus when citizens are you know, Earth was formed
MEETS
more aware of their nature. billions of years ago and
Cities are engine of innovation motor vehicles. Urban Mobility City logistics involves local Now, coming to the latter if we compare the time of
and economic growth. Plans that are currently being government intervention in a point of view, infrastructure mankind’s evolution, you’ll be
Employment opportunities and
social services attract people
adopted have expanded the
scope of traditional planning
realm in which it is relatively
inexperienced—and therefore
THE EYE is believed to help reduce
pollution by encouraging
surprised to know, it’s only
been 3seconds! And we’re
from rural areas and other processes by focusing on requires collaboration and public transportation. These already witnessing the effects
regions. To accommodate overarching policy goals as partnership with the private projects have many assets; of climate change. So much
growing demand for well as the mobility needs sector.In fact, innovation replanting and relocating for the ‘fun’ fact. The question
residential and commercial of all population groups. Aditya Deshmukh
itself may prove to be the considerable amount of plants that now remains is; Must
TY student
space, urban boundaries Comprehensive and inclusive most promising path to and trees being one of them. we go forward with projects
College of Engineering, Pune
are extending in an often mobility planning has proven sustainability. New ideas are This project hopes to aid concerning development and
uncoordinated manner, to be an effective way for continually being tested; many people in reducing personal conservation of environment,
especially in rapidly growing identifying the right priorities fail, but the best ideas thrive vehicles encouraging public but at the cost of nature? Or
cities in developing countries. and measures for achieving a Recently in October 2019,
and are adapted elsewhere. strenuous opinions were transport. It also connects the must we change our idea of ‘
Cities with an effective system safe, efficient and accessible The lesson of these efforts is inaccessible sites spreading development’? A famous movie
for managing land use can urban transport system which reported about felling trees
that the key to sustainability in Mumbai. The reason? the motto of inclusivity. So, quote that has stuck with me
ensure that this development is serving the needs of the will be leadership from activists what’s all the face off about? is “We resign ourselves to the
happens in close proximity to population and the economy. Creation of an underground
and policy professionals who metro shed. Metro sheds are You might as well ask. oh-so-sad future, just because
high quality walking, cycling It is a way to identify financing have the optimism and vision Although development is done that horrendous future doesn’t
and public transport facilities. options and support the basically a depot for metro
to innovate, and the courage rails. Now, consider this for protecting the environment ask anything of us today…” Is
Mixed use and compact urban optimal use of public funds. to learn from occasional and abating pollution, this who we truly are?
development can considerably It is imperative to understand situation as a mere observant.
failures.Because in order There were two parties: ironically it encourages the I believe that we may be speck
reduce the demand for that having policies for to experience a change initial steps of degradation. of dusts in the wide universe,
travel by private motorized mere provision of supporting one fighting with motto of
ultimately, transformation and conserving the environment Clashes occur when there is a but we did accomplish a lot
modes. Too often, transport infrastructure cannot even innovation are two sides of grey area that is left unnoticed for 3 seconds! My perspective
infrastructure fails to keep up suffice the present dynamics, by opposing the cutting of
a same coin, the coin of tress, while the other party and unresolved. Being an stands to seek and understand
with the mobility needs of the let alone the future concerns. sustainable mobility! aspiring planner and learning the grey area we left out, just
growing population. The use of Furthermore, the transformation is in favour of infrastructure
development which will about various concepts of because it was too tedious
private vehicles and informal of public transit agencies from the realm, I understand why to process. I seek to discover
paratransit increases the gap organizations that operate eventually reduce pollution.
From the former point of view, infrastructural development is the hidden third door that
in demand that is not met by vehicles into customer-oriented necessary and the impact it addresses both the point
other modes. Cities around the ‘mobility managers’ requires a chopping trees in urban areas
is like purposely digging your has on the economic sector. of views. Maybe, a bit of
world are searching for better shift in organizational culture. The assets of projects do ‘Parivartan’, is what we all just
alternatives to provide greater The use of livability and own grave hoping you’ll never
have to lie in it. Although here, might need.
accessibility and mitigate the social welfare as organizing
negative impacts caused by principles act as radical permission was granted to cut
the dependence on personal challenges to organizations. trees by the Tree Authorities
34 35
S U P E R B LO C KS : TA K I N G
STREETS BACK FROM CARS
Upasana Patgiri
SPA Bhopal
As a first year student of traffic. So much so, that we by the Barcelona City Council
Planning, one thing that I have people ourselves, all the in collaboration with the
learnt is that in today’s world pedestrians, vendors, bikers, Urban Ecology Agency of
sustainable development and etc. have been pushed to Barcelona that aims to foster
creativity are the two most the sidewalks and narrow sustainable mobility, the
important concepts in Urban lanes. The only open spaces intensive use of public spaces,
Planning. All the different remaining are the few parks biodiversity, social cohesion
ways and patterns that a city and playgrounds which also involving the participation of
or town could be laid down are dwindling day by day. the general public, a reduced
in (linear, radial, grid iron Are cities really just meant for ecological footprint and, in
and so on) have been already that? Just to commute and not short, which enhances the
given and put to use centuries to communicate? Are they not human dimension of the city.
back and now is the time to for people anymore? And if A superblock is defined by a
bring about changes in them yes, then how do we reclaim grid of nine blocks where the
in a way which is innovative them? main mobility happens on the
as well as sustainable to Barcelona in Spain seems roads around the outside of garages and parking spaces He and his team designed Top: Image source
Ajuntament de
create settlements of the future to have found out a very the Superblock, and the roads but keeps the Superblock clear an orthogonal network of Barcelona
which help us in achieving innovative solution to this - within the Superblock are for of through traffic. The aim is to bus routes that it is being
the sustainable development ‘Superblocks’ or Superilles (in local transit only. The one-way improve the quality of life and implemented today. Based
goals. Catalan), it is a concept that system inside the Superblock conditions for local residents, on this orthogonal design,
Cities, a very significant I came across in a YouTube makes it impossible to cut by rationally managing using the main streets of
creation of mankind, are video by the channel called through to the other side. That natural resources and public Barcelona to move the buses
today ruled by cars and Vox. It is a project designed gives neighbors access to their spaces. In Barcelona, Five in a grid format, some city
areas have been identified blocks appeared clear of
for this experiment. They are bus traffic. This gave Rueda
in Les Corts, Hostafrancs, the idea of the Superblocks.
Right: Yamini
SPA Vijaywada Eixample, Poblenou and in the
area around Glòries. Local residents of Barcelona
The main person behind this when interviewed about
concept is Salvador Rueda, the their experience of living in
director of the Urban Ecology a superblock neighborhood,
Agency. In an interview with said that they were really
cities of the future, Rueda happy and wanted the
said the idea of Superblocks entire city to be like that. It
came to him in 2002 when gave them an opportunity to
he was designing the new bus reclaim and rediscover their
network for the city. area and get to know their
neighbors better.
36 37
Evidence suggests that life on The industrialization has led The recent government
earth has existed for at least to global warming & this policies like mining in
3.5 billion years. From the triggered climate change Indian forests, the easing
Stone Age to the 21st century, which resulted in the melting of government regulations
we have witnessed many of icecaps & forest fires etc. on environmental clearance
advancements. In this process, There was a rise of 0.3oC to in the name of single
we have internalized a much- 1.7oC surface temperature in window clearance and most
skewed notion of so-called the 21st century and this may recently the absolute lack
“development”. go up to 4.8oC depending on of seriousness in tackling
Development is referred to the rate of future greenhouse air pollution in Delhi, etc.
as increasing Gross National emissions according to the point to a very grim future
A LO N G I N G FO R Product or Per Capita Income
which is equated with growth.
fifth assessment report of
the Intergovernmental Panel
unless there is a radical shift
in attitudes of the political
E N V I R O N M E N TA L J U ST I C E Rapidly growing developing
countries are following the
on Climate Change (IPCC).
Additionally, the report
leadership.
In the absence of any action,
policies of the 19th Century also estimates that nearly every single aspect of nature
industrial revolution which 36 million Indians may be that we cherish and value
failed to take into account affected by flooding due to will be commodified for
B.Krishna Samarth the ‘Environmental Debt’ that sea-level rise by 2050 and private gains and we may
Jawaharlal Nehru Architecture and fine Arts resulted from the so-called 200 million lives on land with have to pay to even catch a
University development and destruction being completely submerged glimpse of a tree.
caused to the ecosystem. by 2100.
Decades of neglect and
ignorance combined with a
denial of the human impact
on climate have resulted in an
exacerbated rate of species
extinction which by some
estimates is 1000 to 10000
times higher than the natural
rate of extinction. Since the
onset of agriculture (12,000
years ago) the number of trees
worldwide has dropped by
46% according to one research
published in 2018.
Chaitanya Lodha
SPAB
40
41
D O S H E L L S S AY Thus, threatening the existence of
creatures which absorb the carbon
every little creature is important for
the sustenance of the human race
SOMETHING
dioxide emissions. Thereby rise and the ecosystems to survive.
in the level of greenhouse gases We need to understand the loops
resulting in the ultimatum global and cycles that earth needs,
ABOUT THE warming, the loop.
Why do planners need to know
to live. Every detailed study is
important at this hour. We do
CHANGE IN this?
Planners learn and study about
have very little time to protect
our systems of life. We do need
ENVIRONMENT the cities through the development,
economy, the people and their
to understand addressing the
issues, of maintaining the marine
42 43
MINDFUL OBLIVION A basic rainwater harvesting
structure could consist of the
“Yesterday I was clever,
Mission, interestingly, around so I wanted to change the
Zorba 45 of 60 borewells were closed world. Today I am wise, so I
School of Planning and Architecture in less than 24 hours. Deputy
Vijayawada commissioners of the state am changing myself.”
campaigned to create awareness – Rumi
among farmers, FIR was lodged
in case of not plugging borewells. young volunteers.
India is the home to nearly 16% of the The solution for this could be the A basic rainwater harvesting
world population and depends only exact antipode of the existing structure could consist of the
on 4% of fresh water available. The case. The same borewell that is revamped borewell, a
pervasive availability of ground water used to extract water could be filtration well and a pond.
is one of the causes for agriculture to be transformed in to an apparatus A Feeder pond of 8 ft is
the main economic sector. Current water that allows rainwater to constructed near the site to
availability can fulfil 62% of irrigation, percolate and recharge ground capture water. A trench is
85% of rural water supply and 45% water table. dug around the borewell and
of urban water supply requirement. filled with filtration layers
Over exploitation, contamination and This could be a feasible key which is course of rubble and
improper water management are to revive defunct borewell in sand alternatively. The PVC
propagating the increasing ground areas that completely depends pipe is given slits for water to
water crisis in drilling a magnanimous on rainwater as their primary seep through. Another well is
number of 27 million borewells for closure of all abandoned borewells. irrigation source which also dug near, to slow down the
across the country. Due to unnatural Reward of 5,000 rupees was announced helps in sealing death traps. percolation of rainwater for
monsoon pattern farmers are preferring for identifying abandoned borewell under Though the solution is site filtration. During monsoons
monocropping to multiple cropping Tandarust specific, the underlying idea water is captured in the pond
creating more water hunger farmers. is to capture as much as it made to stagnate, for particles
In pursuit of finding this cache, farmers This could be a feasible key to revive could. Many NGO across to settle and percolates
drill deep the ground to almost 300m, defunct borewell in areas that completely the country are successfully through well for filtration and
only to meet their demand that serves depends on rainwater as their primary practicing this approach. For then to the recharge pit.
for just 4 months of the harvest period. irrigation source which also helps in sealing example, Sankalpa Rural The Revival of borewell is
Farmers drill bore well every year as death traps. Though the solution is site Development Society an NG a solution that is one of its
the old one has dried, resulting in specific, the underlying idea is to capture in karnataka has come up with kind, as there are many more
escalated debts that cannot be repaid as much as it could. Many NGO across a workable model and has approaches. This article is an
for a lifetime and finally end up their the country are successfully practicing accomplished in reviving 1130 attempt to conjoin the gaps
life to at least earn back money from this approach. For example, Sankalpa abandoned borewells. Lauding and hitches related to current
insurance. The hidden beneficiaries are Rural Development Society an NG in this attempt the National water management issues.
borewell contractors who get plenty of karnataka has come up with a workable Bank for Agriculture and Rural Thirst for water is a meagre
orders especially from poor farmers. model and has accomplished in reviving Development (NBARD) in 2012, approach but the vigilance
The cost of drilling bore well in the 1130 abandoned borewells. Lauding this acknowledged it to be one of of one’s mind to act should
current market price is approx. 45Rs. / attempt the National Bank for Agriculture the ‘Top five rural innovations be the first step to change.
ft. up to 200ft. above which the charge and Rural Development (NBARD) in of the Year’. Kadaimadai Area PARIVARTHAN without
increases to 4,500 Rs. per hour, for 2012, acknowledged it to be one of the Integrated Farmer’s Association WITHIN is vice and immoral.
labour alone. ‘Top five rural innovations of the Year’. is another organisation in
These open borewells have resulted in Kadaimadai Area Integrated Farmer’s Tanjavur and Pudukottai districts
unprecedented causalities like children Association is another organisation in of Tamil Nadu involved in
getting trapped in borewells. Ensuing Tanjavur and Pudukottai districts of Tamil conversion with the help of
the death of two-year-old Fathehveer Nadu involved in conversion with the help
Singh, Punjab Chief Minister Capt. of young volunteers.
Amarinder Singh ordered the State’s AKSHAY
Water and Sanitation Department SCHOOL OF PLANNING
ANDARCHITECTURE, BHOPAL
SOCIO ECONOMIC
infrastructure, etc. It is also
noted that the enrolment rate
cannot be raised unless the
D E V E LO PM E N T basic requirements of the
common people are met. True
IN INDIA development therefore requires
government action to improve
basic education, safe drinking
water services, and health
care, and remove barriers to
Shravani Sonar social minorities, especially
Amity University, Noida
women. As a prerequisite for
growth and thus establishes overall development, the role
the sensitive measures of of social development such as
Technology is a multidimentional developmental diversity. literacy (and particularly of
process. Some of its main Instead of analyzing the female literacy) in promoting
dimensions include: level variance of a specific factor basic skills emerges. While
of economic development, across states, a composite economic growth in the
level of education, level of index based on multiple context of expanding gross
health services, degree of variables was developed using national product and other
modernization, status of main component analysis and related variables is one of
women, level of food, quality states were grouped according the most fundamental inputs
of housing, goods and to indices derived from four to the overall development
services delivery, and access widely accepted components: cycle, the fundamental goal
to communication. In India, (a) economic growth and of development should be to
the improvement between economic condition or, in expand human capacity that
major states in socio-economic other words, level of economic has long been overlooked in
growth is not standardized. This development; (b) common India.
research explores the current minimum requirements;
heterogeneity of inter-state
Snigdha Dev Roy
SPA Delhi 47
DOES INDIAN SET TLEMENT
“Is it ideal to continue
PLANNING NEED A NEW with the narrow
R AT I O N A L P L A N N I N G meandering lanes of the
old city core when the
Adwait S. Limaye
SPA Bhopal societies are demanding
a change in the
lifestyle? Is the planned
A historical city has an
organically developed ‘old
planning. The
framework is a ‘grown
ordering principles are pre-conceived
and the reality is made to
Top: Raj Chaudhary
Amity University, Noida lifestyle helping de-
city core’ characterized by order’. The term ‘order’ match the drawings as close
considering the advantages
clutter one’s thoughts
dense grain fabric and a here, connotes hierarchy of as possible. Such plans thus
‘planned new city periphery’ spaces, degree of contextual exemplify the ‘made order’ or of the ‘old city core’ planning thus giving more room
characterized by medium to interpretation and multi- ‘forced order’. While drafting principles which responds
sparse grain fabric. Upon usability of a space. These the plans, in its truest sense, to the behavioral and other for creativity? ”
drawing a comparison plans intrinsically respond to the intangible aspects are social aspects of the urban
between these two types, it various aspects of sustainable often devalued. The planning communities. And, it would
can be found out that besides planning principles, the process envisages to nudge base its ordering principles
physical distinction, there are spatial organisation, structural growth of the city which is on the ‘planned new city
various other distinctions on forms, spatial hierarchy etc. sustainable and dynamic. In periphery’ planning principles
the basis of climatological, The spaces derived based the process, the quantitative enabling ease of provisioning
sociological and many other on the functional needs are analysis draws more assertion of infrastructure.
aspects. transformative in nature. as compared to qualitative. Upon pondering over the
The old city core is historically The planned new city The spaces which are topic, one may think - Is the
developed by the dwellers periphery is implementation unintentionally carved out in chaos in the core really mere
based on their notions and of the drafted drawings by between the built spaces are a chaos or rather a challenge?
understanding of a settlement the planners. The ordering described as ‘formless voids’ Is the orderly development in
by some critics. These spaces the planned new city really
are a derivative of the built the order that the urban
imposing its dominance on societies ever yearned for?
the urban form. On the contrary, it is ideal
However, there are to continue with the narrow
advantages and limitations of meandering lanes of the old
both the planning systems. A city core when the societies
critical research of these can are demanding a change in
help identify the pros and the lifestyle? Is the planned
develop a responsive planning lifestyle helping de-clutter
system for the future cities of one’s thoughts thus giving
India. This would be with a more room for creativity?
vision of holistic development Or do we simply satisfy
of urban communities. ourselves by accepting that
Right: Divakshi Bharadwaj The resultant would derive ‘Cities are like personalities –
Amity University, Noida
its spatial organization They change!’?
48 49
KUDUMBASHREE I M P O R TA N C E marketing and control over more distant
50 51
apt solutions to the problems in considering the environmental
our cities. psychological factors in mind.
Environmental psychology is Even if we do so,
a diagnostic study that helps we are not evaluating it.
us understand the problems We as planners have become so
and what is good about that much focused on the economic
place. Urban planning on aspects than any other domains
the other hand provides a that planning is willing to
prescriptive treatment for what consider.( Domains such
is to be treated and what is social, environmental, ecology, With many of the things like
to be kept intact. The nexus environmental psychology new urbanism, traditional
of environmental psychology etc. . are very seldom looked neighborhoods coming in
and urban planning focuses into) Sometimes I wonder that style, I can’t wait for the day
on three things at once: aren’t we supposed to work till people’s perception and
public participation, methods beyond institutions of economic preferences become a trend.
of environmental psychology providers. Moreover, we make
and planning related decision plan in two dimensions. But
making. people experience our plans in
Currently, all the data layers three dimensions. All the people
that planners need to acquire experience our plans in different
do not contain the data for manner. This experiential quality
environmental psychological is experienced differently by
factors. Planners acquire natural differential people.
systems layers that includes We know more about the “People are
contours, vegetation cover, habitat of animals than we demi-experts. Let them
drainage systems; cultural or know about the habitat of our
Top: kanishka singh, MANIT
human systems that includes own- the cities. Planners with plan their own cities!”
land ownerships, land uses, people’s cognition and power
A MINDFUL PLANNING: streets, users etc. However,
planners do not consider the
can make parivartan to suit
our never-ending needs and
CHANGING CITIES experiential quality that arises
from the farrago of the natural
preferences of our environment.
Chintan Rathod, Alumnus
systems and cultural systems. Anon
MSUB COEP
We do not plan our cities
52 53
‘POST DISASTER and commercial developments.
There has also been a decline
natural flow of the “Chengal
Thodu”. It has been redirected
Environment
assessment, during
impact
land
SCENARIO’: REDEFINING in the agriculture in the past 8 it along the periphery use conversions has to be
years from 39.27% to 39.02 % altering the natural terrain made a part and parcel of
any development project.
D E V E LO PM E N T PR I O R ITI ES O F
which is around 796 Ha of land. and path of the water body,
2) Improper Water management making it regularly flooded Suitability and vulnerability
and Terrain Manipulation: 3) Incomplete system of analysis of any geographical
A N G A M A LY M U N I C I PA L I T Y Manjaly Thodu and Mullassery
thodu are the only major water
drainage: In the central area
of the town, wastewater from
area has to be done to ensure
the prevention and mitigation
bodies of Angamaly. However the market, hotels etc. are let from any future disasters. A
Manjaly has been obstructed into the roadside drains which control over the conversions
for the past 55 years by finally drains in to the Manjaly and terrain manipulation
Soosanna Jaxon, large water hyacinths and silt thodu and the Vengoorthodu. of environmentally sensitive
Alumnus, areas, even for smaller
G.E.C, Thrissur
accumulation from up streams Land conversions without
as thick as 3ft. The traffic and proper environmental impactA scale projects, has to be
transportation occupies 7.5 % change in our development made through properly
of the total area. It comprises approach is most essential at regulated rules. Rebuilding
Angamaly is one of the 13 municipalities mainly of major roads NH 544 the current scenario, which the municipality requisites for
of Ernakulum district, located towards and MC road passing through can make Angamaly develop sustainable development that
the northern suburb region of the state the heart of the city along with in a much sustainable manner. emphasise on conservation of
of Kerala. The municipality stretches theT3 terminal and ATC tower proper environmental impactA these eco-sensitive and fragile
over an area of 20.40 sq. km and has of the airport. The construction change in our development areas. Development strategies
a population of 33,645 as per 2011 of the T3 terminal has resulted approach is most essential at in master plans must focus on
census. The municipality is a gateway in the conversion of 103 acres the current scenario, which the concept of resilience and
to the Cochin city and draws in through of agricultural land, which has can make Angamaly develop sustainability rather than mere
traffic from the northern and southern part neglected the environmental in a much sustainable manner. economic growth.
of the state. It is also a fast developing aspect and has also altered the
economy with a large number of floating
population dependency on the town.
With the presence of one of the busiest Top: Snigdha Dev Roy, SPAD
54 55
PA R I VA R TA N I N in the suburban areas. The concept
of Network Based Compact Cities
T R A N S P O R TAT I O N Enhances the Utilisation of Public
Transport as all the services, commercial
& MOBILITY areas and recreational spaces are
provided in close proximity to public
THROUGH transport nodes.
Mode Shift – Interventions like Transit
56 57
scheme (From 33% pink ticket sale on Luxemburg, Estonia, Parris, Hong
the first day to 44% on 21st day, as Kong, and Berlin had already
FREE BUS RIDES FOR WOMEN: per DTC). This not only allows women implemented such free rides for
to explore new job opportunities but different groups of its citizens, which
A BROKEN WINDOW also attempts to reclaim public spaces.
A woman now feels safer as there are
had both direct and indirect benefits
for its society. The only thing the Delhi
FA L L AC Y ? more women on the street. Experts
argued that with the same money,
government is lacking is a proper
financial plan. The government
the government could have instead should look at alternative sources of
P.Karun Achintya, Alumni, invested in purchasing CCTV cameras financing from its direct and indirect
School of Planning and architecture or deployed more policemen. Though beneficiaries.
Vijaywada more CCTV cameras and police could For example, this scheme has a direct
(2015-2019) create a fear among the thieves it impact on easing private vehicular
doesn’t guarantee that the number mobility on the road, and this benefit
of crimes would decrease, the CCTV can be charged on private vehicle
cameras can only watch the incident users. France, for example, supports
and can never prevent it. its 40% of public transport funding
As per the Delhi Economic Survey from indirect benefits, 30% from its
The Delhi government had to travel by safer route. And a study 2018-19 report, the DTC was already direct users and just 30% is publicly
announced that women can travel for conducted by Sustainable Urban on a working loss of Rs 1750.37 crore funded.
free in Delhi Transport Corporation Transport Project (SUTP), highlights in 2018-19 period, experts opine that, Cities like London and Stockholm
(DTC) and cluster buses from that women forego opportunities to the free bus ride scheme could also funds Public transport in their cities
October 29th . This announcement work outside their neighborhoods, mount an additional pressure of 300 through congestion pricing in Central
had welcomed positive debates on considering the travel costs and crore/ year. Business Districts (CBD), parking
safety and mobility issues in our safety issues. As stated earlier, though the scheme charges and other developmental
Indian cities. Critics argue about has many social and economic charges along with the high-frequency
the financial unviability and lack of The women workforce participation benefits as it can increase the number public transit routes and around bus
a proper plan, but supporters claim
GAUTAM AGARWAL
rate in Delhi is 11%, which is the of women workers, improve financial stops.
SPAD
that this could improve the safety least among all Indian Cities, despite independence among women and If these financial models are
and could liberate women. As too its huge economic activities and its increases safety, but If the scheme is considered, the impact won’t just
much skepticism about the scheme contribution to India’s GDP. With this not thoroughly assessed for financial benefit the females but also the entire
continues, it is very important to huge gendered bias, this scheme sustainability, this scheme would soon city, as it can also increase and stress
assess whether this has any positive has a huge potential to liberate end and would be reasoned just as on the need for more busses with
impacts to the society or not. women from their homes. There was another ‘broken window fallacy’. high frequencies (just because more
Article 13 of the UN Universal a measured 10% increase in women Looking at the world’s best practices, people are using it). And as theorists
Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) users within the first 21 days of rolling such a freebie for public transport is not speak, more frequency would also
underpins freedom of movement. out of the scheme (From 33% pink new. mean the more modal shift towards
But most of the Indian cities fail to ticket sale on the first day to 44% on public transport and that also means
guarantee this, owing to reasons 21st day, as per DTC) fewer private vehicles on roads and
of ‘Transport Poverty’ and ‘Gender less pollution and finally the change
Issues’. A 2017, study conducted by that the city wants to see.
world bank economist Girija Borker
on 4,000 Delhi’s college students
highlights that female students chose
a lower quality college, which
involved long distance and expensive
travel compared to men, just in order
58 59
Ministry of Women and Child required amenities are not being
STAT U S A N GA N WA D I S E R V I C ES Development (MoWCD),
Melinda Gates Foundation has
with made available such as the basic
infrastructure required to run the
U N D E R I C D S : WAY A H E A D distributed smartphones at 62,000
Anganwadi Centres in 6 states from
Anganwadi, that is, ORS (Oral
Rehydration Solution), medicines,
June 2017 to track services being food items etc. due to lack of funds
offered there. These services include from the government. After not
making nutrition-related interventions providing the basic amenities to the
by giving daily reports on how Anganwadi’s, the Delhi Government
Prashant Aswani many children were provided food, announced to distribute smartphones
M.Plan (Urban & Regional) weighed. The Anganwadi worker to the workers, which infuriated
UPES, Deahradun, Batch 2015-17
performs the following tasks- Manisha, a 34-year-old Anganwadi
•Preparing Job Chart Helper who had not received her
•Surveying houses in the monthly honorarium of Rs. 4839 and
neighbourhood reprehended the administration for
•Marking the attendance of children being ineffective and not being able
•Sending pictures of hot cooked to provide the basic infrastructure and
meals served at the centre. amenities of the Anganwadi.
Status Anganwadi Services Under ICDS: Way Ahead Workers scan bar code on the take-
home ration to maintain ration
Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) is an
administrative programme in India which provides quota. Alerts are sent via SMS if the
sustenance, primary education, primary healthcare, child is underweight. Smartphones
immunization, health check-up and referral services to also prevent falsification of data and
children under 6 years of age and their mothers. During the reduce the workload of maintaining
2018–19 fiscal year, the Central Government designated 11 registers manually. The alert
₹16,335 crores to the programme. The widespread is sent to the parents, Anganwadi
network of ICDS has a significant role in combating
malnutrition especially for children of weaker groups. supervisor and Child Development
Objectives of the scheme- Project Officer.
•Immunization Delhi Government will provide mobile
•Supplementary nutrition phones to Anganwadi workers for
•Health check-up real-time monitoring of the centres
•Referral services and enabling Aadhaar based
•Pre-school education(Non-Formal)
•Nutrition and Health information registrations of the employees. This
initiative comes under the Central
Case Study- Government’s POSHAN Abhiyan
Mobiles have been distributed under World Bank Scheme.
sponsored International Society for Neuro-imaging in The mobiles will have installed
Psychiatry (ISNIP) project for eradication of malnutrition. applications for recording
200 workers will be provided with the smartphone in Phase
1 will increase the efficiency of Anganwadi Workers. attendance, opening and closing
The Smartphones and Tablets have been procured under time of the Anganwadi Centre,
“Poshan Abhiyan”, a program launched to reduce the enabling Real-Time monitoring of
level of stunting, undernutrition, Anaemia and low birth the centres, sharing Centre, sharing
weight in children. daily photographs of the children
An application has been made available which can work being served food in the Anganwadi
offline partially so that the Anganwadi Centre could note
information about child nutrition in the application even Centre, registering the time of
from remote parts of the country where the internet is serving food and carry out name-
neither accessible nor available. based, Aadhaar Linked registration
of all members employed in the
Anganwadi Centre.
Current Scenario-
Ahana Chatterjee The present condition of the
Saranya
SPAD Anganwadi Centres is ailing. The GEC Thrissur
60 61
THE WORLD, A PL ANNER AND ME
Look outside for moment…
and appreciate the green.
Its alright to have zero visibility in winter, adds to the hysterical affair
But who can be responsible for the deaths happening…?
All of which burns me straight into my deepest lair
I can’t take this anymore, how long must I suffer?
This is when the doctor said, ‘It’s alright. You’re going to be fine.’
She removes all the clutter and brings in inclusion
Clears the junction, without much confusion
She seems to be knowing what she does
But does falter sometimes;
And when she does, she brings in another layer
A layer of reconciliation and of trust
Both pictures:
Anmol Chaudhary,
66 School of Planning and Architecture, New 67
Delhi
CHANGE
It’s 21st century thing nowadays,
It keeps on fluctuating with time,
People are thinking of this day,
It’s reflecting today’s busy life,
Ideology is getting flawless in ways,
Knowledge is getting wide,
A negativity will teach you many ways,
A positivity will lead your future,
Make change as per your styles!!
-Rajvi Shah
Anant National University
FROM…..
Right and bottom: TO … . .
Janhvi, School of Planning and
Architecture, New Delhi
From cool breeze,
To pollution freeze.
A CITY OF From well water,
To mineral matter.
DREAMS From green fields,
To concrete jungles.
From mud roads,
A man with dreams, To traffic nodes.
Whose thoughts flow like a streams, From walking miles,
Walks through the streets, To lazy lifestyles.
With beautiful ideas rendered on sheets. From mathaji-pithaji,
To mom-dad.
Collects and analyses information, From real relations,
Which leads to transformation, To selfish attractions.
Sort outs the things, Relationships changed to agreements,
Writes out and sings. Orthodox changed to heterodox,
We changed to me,
Plotted on sheets, And…. Village changed to city.
Presence and meets,
With attractive plan in route, S. Pavani,
And prevents the pollute. SPA, Vijayawada.
A city of dreams,
Radiating like sun beams,
With economical trade,
And eco-friendly grade.
-Siddhu
JNAFAU
SPAB
Left:
Janhvi, School of Planning and
70 Architecture, New Delhi 71
ऐ बड़े शहर कैसे बयां
करूं तुझे,
तू वो है जिसे बचपन से चाहा है मैंने,
तू वो है जिसे जाने कितनी जद्दोज़ेहद के बाद पाया है मैंने,
Shalini Keshri
SVNIT, Surat
All pictures:
Janhvi, School of Planning and
Architecture, New Delhi
72 73
A N O D E TO M Y TREASURES PIPED DREAMS
OUTSIDE THE
CITY Series of fervent midnights, juggling between
All pictures:
Janhvi, School of Planning and
Architecture, New Delhi
74 75
Annual NOSPlan Host: UPES, Dehradun
Convention Left: Inaugration of the convention
Bottom: Audience at the inaugration
2019
Held on 26th, 27th and 28th
December, 2019
NOSPLAN‘s Annual Convention 2019 was held
at UPES, Dehradun. This convention included
formal and informal events. Over 30 colleges
participated.
Dean, UPES
The focus of the convention is to discuss the core issues in planning profession, practice and academics
Top: UPES at dusk
as well, to exchange and promote best practices and innovative ideas. This platform promotes the Dr. Siddiqui did his post graduation
overall growth of all involved in this profession. This event is a huge interactionfor the students as well as in Environmental Science and Students involved
Doctorate in Environmental Impact
professionsals in the country. Assessment. He started his carrier
as Assistant Professor in Institute of
Environment & Management.
Assistant Prof.
Unit Council
76 77
Formal Events 2. Donatello
Right, Bottom: Preparation for
Donatello (model-making)
These events include Profession related activities that test planning skills of the students. These
events include 2400 minutes for design proposals, Donatello for model-making, Showcase Pin-up
for overall work of a college, Big 3 (a quiz) and Current Practices.
1. 2400 Minutes
Competition Brief : Make a Model with the skills of Resource Management, Creativity and Thinking
out of the Box. You have to make a logical, symbolic, themed model with the
stationary you have to buy via bidding process. Equal amount of money will be
distributed among teams and a time of 15 mins. will be given to all the teams to
see and plan for the purchase of items which are on sale. Basis stationary will
also be available for sale, it’s the participant’s choice if they want to buy it or
not.
Winners
Competition Brief : The participants will be taken on a field visit to KOTI village within the contextual
area of Bidholi, Dehradun. KOTI is the first ever smart village developed and
sustained by UPES.
The participants will have to assess the scenario in order to analyze and
produce strategies,proposals accordingly. This event includes a design-based
assignment which has to be completed within the given time frame.
Winners
Left, Top:
1st College of Engineering, Pune (COEP) Preparation for
2nd Jawaharlal Nehru Architecture and Fine Arts University (JNAFAU), Hyderabad Donatello (model-
making)
3rd Shri Gijubhai Chhaganbhai Patel Institute of Arch., Interior Des. & Fine Arts
(GCPIA) ,Surat
78 79
3. Showcase Pin-up 4. The Big 3
Competition Brief : Colleges will be required to present previous works done in studios,
Competition Brief : This 3 round event will consist of a quiz, a spin off and a formal panel
projects, etc. Each college will be provided with a panel, wherein they are
discussion on given topic.
expected to display their work, with an aim of making the presentation more
attractive. The work may consist of sheets, drawings, reports, etc. Models
will not be included. Winners
Left: Students
Left: Student preseting receiving 2nd
for Show-case pin-up position for Big 3
Bottom: Students
preparaing for
Showcase Pin-up
5. Current Practices
Right: Competition Entry Competition Brief : Participants are expected to critically analyse a case study.
for Showcase Pin-up
And prepare a good practice model of potential analysis, and solutions. Focus to
be given on the rationale of topic selection, feasibility and practical applicability
in the current scenario. Emphasis must be given to following points: Why the
particular case study is selected, what were the parameters chosen for analysing,
the ways and extent up to which it went transformation. The study should also
include current status of context, conclusion of context and justification for it being
a ‘good practice’.
Winners
80 81
2. Nukkad Natak
Informal Events
Competition Brief : A team from every participating college will prepare a 10 minutes performance
with a soul perspective of spreading awareness. The act can be bilingual
These events consist of extra-curricular activities to provide a platform for talented students. i.e. Hindi and English, the participants are expected to prepare the costumes
A number of activties were included in these events such as Box Cricket for Sports, Nukkad Natak accordingly beforehand.
for drama, Sab Nacho for dance,Wall Painting, Fashion Show, Virtual Gaming and Photography.
1. Box Cricket
Competition Brief : The event will be a knockout cricket competition. The team that survives till end
wins. It will be a six over match. If there happens to be a tie, then a super over Winners
Top: Students performing
will be conducted. Nukkad-Natak
1st Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology
Winners (MANIT), Bhopal
2nd School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi
1 st School of Planning and Architecture, Vijaywada 3rd College of Engineering, Pune (COEP)
2nd School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi
3rd School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal
82 83
3. Sab Nacho 4. Wall painting/grafitti
Competition Brief : Groove to the beats Theme - Pick any of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals Competition Brief : A team from every participating college will prepare a 10 minutes performance
(blueprint to achieve a better and more sustainable future for all) and prepare with a soul perspective of spreading awareness. The act can be bilingual
your performance in accordance to that. i.e. Hindi and English, the participants are expected to prepare the costumes
accordingly beforehand.
Winners
1st Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology (MANIT), Bhopal
2nd School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi
3rd College of Engineering, Pune (COEP)
Winners
1st College of Engineering, Pune
(COEP)
2 School of Planning and Architecture,
nd
Bhopal
3 Sardar Vallabhbhai National
rd
All pictures:
Students
participating in
Wall painting
84 85
7. Fashion Show
Competition Brief : Theme: Cultural Literacy
The theme depicts understanding other cultures and “focusing on what we share”
as a culture, as a society altogether rather than focusing on what divides us.
Participating team from each college will be given time for preparation prior to
the event. The teams are required to deliver the theme to the audience, through
their walking, dressing (clothes, ornaments, makeup, etc.) No materials will be
provided by the host college for preparation purpose.
Winners
5. Say Cheese!
Winners All pictures: Students
participating in Fashion
1st School of Planning and Show
Architecture, Vijaywada
2nd College of Engineering, Pune
(COEP)
3rd Maulana Azad National
Institute of Technology
(MANIT), Bhopal
Top: Entries for Photography
event
Winners
1st School of Planning and Architecture,
2nd Vijaywada
3rd College of Engineering, Pune (COEP)
School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi
Top: Students participating
in Virtual Gaming
86 87
2nd Position - College of Engineering, Pune (COEP)
School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi secured first position in NOSPLAN, 2019
Came first in three events, second in two events and third in two events, total: 7.
School of Planning and Architecture, Vijaywada secured third position in NOSPLAN, 2019
Came first in four events, second in one event and third in one event, total: 7.
88 89
NOSPlan - Organisation of Students of Planning
Department of Physical Planning, School of Planning and Architecture
4, Block B, Indraprastha Estate, New Delhi - 110002
90
editor@nosplan.com, www.nosplan.com