Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease: Felix L Otsch, Jenny Schnyder, Abraham Goorhuis, Martin P. Grobusch Prof
Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease: Felix L Otsch, Jenny Schnyder, Abraham Goorhuis, Martin P. Grobusch Prof
Review
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Background: The recent West African Ebola virus disease (EVD) outbreak had catastrophic impact on
Received 17 March 2017 populations, health care systems and economies of the affected countries. Somatic symptoms have been
Received in revised form reported to persist long beyond the acute infection. This review was conducted to provide an overview
28 April 2017
on neuro- and socio-psychological long-term sequelae of EVD survivors.
Accepted 2 May 2017
Available online 4 May 2017
Methods: Utilizing Pubmed and PsycInfo databases, a systematic review prepared according to PRISMA
guidelines. Only studies reporting quantitative data on neuropsychological sequelae three weeks or later
after discharge from the Ebola-treating unit were included. Pooled proportions of common outcomes
Keywords:
Ebola virus disease
were calculated.
Viral haemorrhagic fever Results: In total, 224 papers were identified, of which 10 were included. Depression, insomnia, fatigue,
Neuro-psychological sequelae anxiety and post-traumatic stress were common sequelae in EVD survivors. However, data from high-
Socio-psychological sequelae quality studies were scarce.
Systematic review Conclusions: EVD survivors have been thought to commonly face neuropsychological long-term
sequelae. Methodological drawbacks and heterogeneity of current studies limit conclusions of the
impact and magnitude of such sequelae. We advocate the preparation of a prospective, controlled cohort
study protocol in preparation for a future outbreak.
© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND
license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
1. Introduction Ebola treating unit (ETU). The aim of this review was to provide a
concise overview of published data on neuro- and socio-
The recent Ebola outbreak in West Africa, mainly affecting psychological sequelae and to summarize the data on frequencies
Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone, has had catastrophic impact on and proportions of such complications in Ebola survivors.
the affected patients, health care systems and countries, but has
also led to the development of vaccines [1,2]; allowed the evalua-
tion of interventions [3,4]; and provided new insights into Ebola 2. Methods
virus disease (EVD) and its consequences [5]. Now, in the aftermath
of the epidemic, there are over 10,000 survivors according to the A systematic literature search in line with PRISMA guidelines
WHO [6]. The long recovery period of EVD was already noted was performed in PubMed and PsycINFO using “Ebola” AND
during the outbreak in Sudan in 1976 [7], and prolonged psycho- (“sequelae” OR “convalescent” OR “survivors”) as search terms.
logical problems were acknowledged after the Uganda outbreak in Studies indexed up to January 30th, 2017 were included. No other
2001 [8]. As recently reviewed by Vetter and colleagues, EVD sur- restrictions on publication date or language were applied. After
vivors frequently struggle with long-term sequelae such as rheu- exclusion of double entries, two researchers (JS, FL) independently
matologic, ocular or neurological disorders [5]. However, patients assessed all publications. Studies were included if neuro- and socio-
do not only suffer from somatic complaints but also from neuro- psychological sequelae or stigmatization of survivors of a
psychological sequelae and stigmatization after discharge from the confirmed or probable Ebola virus disease were reported quanti-
tatively 3 weeks (or more) after discharge. Reference lists of
included studies were also reviewed for potentially relevant articles
* Corresponding author. that were missed in the database search. Data was extracted by one
E-mail address: m.p.grobusch@amc.uva.nl (M.P. Grobusch). author and double-checked by another in a self-designed data
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmaid.2017.05.001
1477-8939/© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
€tsch et al. / Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease 18 (2017) 18e23
F. Lo 19
extraction form. Authors were contacted if important information cross-sectional study from Sierra Leone, Nanyonga et al. assessed
was missing. Data was extracted for all neuro-psychological and long-term sequelae four months or later after resolution of the
psychosocial sequelae presented in the included studies Simple acute disease in a convenience sample of 81 survivors. Depression
pooled analysis was performed for the outcomes ‘depression’, was recorded in 30/81 (37%) survivors. However, no details on the
‘insomnia’ and ‘fatigue’. No other summary measure was used. Bias methods of data collection and tools used for assessment were
evaluation of individual studies was performed using the original provided in this report [11].
Newcastle Ottawa scale for cohort studies and a modified version In a case series of American survivors, ‘depression or anxiety’
for cross-sectional studies (Supplementary Materials 1,2; was reported in 4/8 (50%) of patients. Symptoms started 0e12
Supplementary Tables 1e3). No bias evaluation was performed for weeks after discharge and lasted 4 weeks. A semi-structured
case-series, short reports without a method section and qualitative questionnaire by phone or face-to-face was used to evaluate pa-
studies reporting quantitative data only as secondary outcome. No tients [12]. A summary of frequency of depression across these four
bias evaluation was performed for bias across studies. The review studies is presented in Fig. 2.
protocol was registered with the University of Amsterdam. Mohammed et al. assessed psychological distress in Ebola sur-
vivors using the General Health Questionnaire. Four survivors were
included and two (50%) reported that they had been feeling un-
3. Results
happy or depressed [14]. In a study with survivors from Sierra
Leone, an attempt to assess long-term sequelae was made by
The search yielded 224 articles in total, of which 10 studies were
reviewing medical charts. Mental health counselling and depres-
included in this review. A flow chart depicting the study selection
sion was recorded in 2 out of 115 survivors. However, the authors
process is presented in Fig. 1. Eight studies stem from the recent
state that this was not recorded consistently in the medical charts
outbreak in West Africa; one study from the 1995 outbreak in
and that the numbers probably underestimate problem [15].
Kikwit, Democratic Republic of Congo, and one from the 2007
Another common symptom was insomnia, which was reported
outbreak in Bundibugyo, Uganda. All studies were published in
in seven studies [10e16]. In a retrospective cohort study with
English.
survivors of the outbreak in Bundibugyo, Uganda, and a control
Four studies providing information on the interval between
group, symptoms were assessed using a standardized question-
discharge and assessment reported data on depression in EVD
naire; 28/49 (57%) individuals reported difficulties sleeping.
survivors [9e12]. The largest of these studies by Etard et al. used
Sleeping difficulties were significantly more frequent in survivors
previously evaluated questionnaires and scales and found 124 out
compared to the controls (RR 1.9, 95%CI 1.3e2.8; p < 0.001) 29
of 713 participants (17%) to suffer from symptoms that may be
months after the outbreak [13]. In the recent outbreak, insomnia
indicative for depression at study inclusion. The median delay be-
was recorded in 55/115 (48%) survivors in Sierra Leone at one point
tween study inclusion and discharge from the Ebola-treating unit
during the follow-up. The data were extracted retrospectively from
was 350 days (IQR 223e491). Follow-up in this prospective study is
medical charts and records [15]. In a similar study by Tiffany et al.
ongoing, and has not been published to date [9]. Only one study
based on routine data from a survivor clinic 20/104 (19%) of sur-
compared depression in Ebola survivors with a seronegative con-
vivors presenting 30 days or later after discharge from the ETU to a
trol group. The authors found a depressed mood in 12/49 (24%)
survivor clinical reported insomnia [16].
survivors compared to 23/157 (15%) in the control group (RR 1.9;
Qureshi et al. reported insomnia in 13/104 (13%) and difficulty
95% CI 1.0e3.6; p ¼ 0.058) 29 months after the outbreak. The au-
sleeping in 20/105 (19%) survivors in a cross sectional study using a
thors also performed a sensitivity analysis including probable cases,
self-designed questionnaire [10]. Nanyonga et al. found 34/81 (42%)
whereupon the results achieved statistical significance. Data were
survivors suffering from sleeplessness, although it is not described
collected retrospectively [13].
how the symptoms were assessed [11]. Out of the eight American
In a cross-sectional study by Qureshi et al., 34/104 (33%) patients
survivors who were interviewed after convalescence, 4 (50%) re-
described a difference in mood; in one patient (1.0%), self-perceived
ported insomnia. In one additional patient, it had already resolved
depression was documented [10]. The median time between
at the time of assessment [12]. Furthermore, 3/4 (75%) survivors in
discharge and assessment was 103.5 days (SD 47.9). In another
Nigeria reportedly had lost much sleep over worry [14] (see Fig. 3).
In a prospective cohort study from Kikwit, Democratic Republic
of the Congo, extreme fatigue was recorded 10 times in 123 con-
tacts (8%) with 29 survivors throughout a 6-month follow-up
Fig. 2. Frequency of depression per individual study, and pooled analysis of data. For
Fig. 1. Flowchart depicting the study selection process. interval between discharge and assessment see Table 1.
20 €tsch et al. / Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease 18 (2017) 18e23
F. Lo
4. Discussion
Study Design Control Outbreak N of Time of assessment Methods Depression Insomnia Fatigue Others
group survivors/ after discharge
controls
Clark et al., Retrospective Yes Bundibugyo 49/157 approx. 29 months Standardized questionnaire 12/49 (24%); 28/49 (57%); RR 1.9 (1.3 28/49 (57%); RR -Limited due to difficulty
2015 [13] cohort study ’07-‘08 RR1.9 (1.0e3.6; e2.8; p ¼ 0.001) 1.9 (1.3e2.8; remembering or confusion 7/49
p ¼ 0.058) p ¼ 0.001) (14%); RR 5.8 (1.5e22.4; p ¼ 0.010)
Epstein Case series No West- 8 median 5 months Semi-structured questionnaire 4/8 (50%)a 4/8 (50%) þ resolved in 6/8 (75%) -peripheral paraesthesia or
et al., African ‘13- (range: 4e7) one additional patient dysaesthesia 3/8 (38%)
2015 [12] ‘15
Mohammed Retrospective No West- 115 median 261 days Review of medical charts 5/115 (4%)b 55/115 (48%) 28/115 (24%)c -Anxiety 17/115 (15%)
H. et al., cohort study African ’13- (range 4e504) -Dizziness 44/115 (38%)
2017 [15] ‘15
Mohammed Cross- Yes, but no West- 4/113 2-4 weeks -General Health Questionnaire 2/4 (50%) 3/4 (75%) Not reported -Inability to concentrate 4/4 (100%)
A. et al., sectional statistical African ‘13- 12-item version; -Oslo 3-item -Felt constantly under strain 1/4
2015 [14] study analyses ‘15 Social Support Scale (25%)
-Not been able to enjoy normal day to
F. Lo
day activities 1/4 (25%)
21
22 €tsch et al. / Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease 18 (2017) 18e23
F. Lo
5. Conclusions
145 (27%)
survivors and is the largest study by far [9]. Following the partici-
Others
pants over a long period of time will provide new insights in the
dynamics of post-Ebola sequelae. Unfortunately, the opportunity
was missed to include a control group, which is necessary to
Not reported
10/123
Not reported
4.3% with depression reported, but authors state that this was not reported consequently due to methodology.
Funding
Questionnaires
survivor clinic
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding
Time of assessment Methods
Median 28 days
(IQR 223e491)f
survivors/ after discharge
Contributions
104
802
African ‘13-
African ‘13-
Outbreak
West-
West-
West-
‘15
‘15
dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmaid.2017.05.001.
Control
group
Yes
No
No
No
References
1999 [17] cohort study
cohort study
Prospective
[1] Agnandji ST, Huttner A, Zinser ME, Njuguna P, Dahlke C, Fernandes JF, et al.
Phase 1 trials of rVSV ebola vaccine in Africa and europe. N Engl J Med
Design
2016;374:1647e60. http://dx.doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1502924.
Table 1 (continued )
[2] Henao-Restrepo AM, Camacho A, Longini IM, Watson CH, Edmunds WJ,
Egger M, et al. Efficacy and effectiveness of an rVSV-vectored vaccine in
Etard et al.,
2017 [9]
preventing Ebola virus disease: final results from the Guinea ring vaccination,
open-label, cluster-randomised trial (Ebola Ça Suffit!). Lancet Lond Engl 2016.
Study
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(16)32621-6.
[3] Moekotte AL, Huson MaM, van der Ende AJ, Agnandji ST, Huizenga E,
a
e
b
f
c
d
disease. Expert Opin Investig Drugs 2016:1e11. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/ Sequelae and other conditions in ebola virus disease survivors, Sierra Leone.
13543784.2016.1240785. Emerg Infect Dis 2015;2017(23):66e73. http://dx.doi.org/10.3201/
[4] Grobusch M, Visser BJ, Boersma J, Huson MA, Janssen S, Greve P, et al. Ebola eid2301.160631.
virus disease: basics the medical specialist should know. Neth J Crit Care [16] Tiffany A, Vetter P, Mattia J, Dayer J-A, Bartsch M, Kasztura M, et al. Ebola virus
2015;22:6e14. disease complications as experienced by survivors in Sierra Leone. Clin Infect
[5] Vetter P, Kaiser L, Schibler M, Ciglenecki I, Bausch DG. Sequelae of Ebola virus Dis Off Publ Infect Dis Soc Am 2016;62:1360e6. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cid/
disease: the emergency within the emergency. Lancet Infect Dis 2016;16: ciw158.
e82e91. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1473-3099(16)00077-3. [17] Rowe AK, Bertolli J, Khan AS, Mukunu R, Muyembe-Tamfum JJ, Bressler D,
[6] World Health Organization. Ebola virus disease. Situat Rep 2016:1e2. et al. Clinical, virologic, and immunologic follow-up of convalescent Ebola
[7] Ebola haemorrhagic fever in Sudan. Bull World Health Organ 1976;1978(56): hemorrhagic fever patients and their household contacts, Kikwit, Democratic
247e70. Republic of the Congo. Commission de Lutte contre les Epide mies a Kikwit.
[8] Wendo C. Caring for the survivors of Uganda's Ebola epidemic one year on. J Infect Dis 1999;179(Suppl 1):S28e35. http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/514318.
Lancet 2001;358:1350. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(01)06467-4. [18] Hugo M, Declerck H, Fitzpatrick G, Severy N, Gbabai OB-M, Decroo T, et al.
[9] Etard J-F, Sow MS, Leroy S, Toure A, Taverne B, Keita AK, et al. Multidisci- Post-traumatic stress reactions in Ebola virus disease survivors in Sierra
plinary assessment of post-Ebola sequelae in Guinea (Postebogui): an obser- Leone. Emerg Med Open Access 2015:2015.
vational cohort study. Lancet Infect Dis 2017:0. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/ [19] Gidado S, Oladimeji AM, Roberts AA, Nguku P, Nwangwu IG, Waziri NE, et al.
S1473-3099(16)30516-3. Public knowledge, perception and source of information on ebola virus dis-
[10] Qureshi AI, Chughtai M, Loua TO, Pe Kolie J, Camara HFS, Ishfaq MF, et al. easeelagos, Nigeria; september, 2014. PLoS Curr Outbreaks 2015 Apr 8;7. http://
Study of ebola virus disease survivors in Guinea. Clin Infect Dis Off Publ Infect dx.doi.org/10.1371/currents.outbreaks.0b805cac244d700a47d6a3713ef2d6db.
Dis Soc Am 2015;61:1035e42. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cid/civ453. pii: ecurrents.outbreaks.0b805cac244d700a47d6a3713ef2d6db, pubmed-id:
[11] Nanyonga M, Saidu J, Ramsay A, Shindo N, Bausch DG. Sequelae of ebola virus 25914860.
disease, kenema district, Sierra Leone. Clin Infect Dis 2015. http://dx.doi.org/ [20] Hewlett BS, Amola RP. Cultural contexts of Ebola in northern Uganda. Emerg
10.1093/cid/civ795. :civ795. Infect Dis 2003;9:1242e8. http://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid0910.020493.
[12] Epstein L, Wong KK, Kallen AJ, Uyeki TM. Post-Ebola signs and symptoms in [21] Rabelo I, Lee V, Fallah MP, Massaquoi M, Evlampidou I, Crestani R, et al.
U.S. Survivors. N Engl J Med 2015;373:2484e6. http://dx.doi.org/10.1056/ Psychological distress among ebola survivors discharged from an ebola
NEJMc1506576. treatment unit in monrovia, Liberia - a qualitative study. Front Public Health
[13] Clark DV, Kibuuka H, Millard M, Wakabi S, Lukwago L, Taylor A, et al. Long- 2016;4:142. http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2016.00142.
term sequelae after Ebola virus disease in Bundibugyo, Uganda: a retrospec- [22] Sow S, Desclaux A, Taverne B. Groupe d’e tude PostEboGui. [Ebola in Guinea:
tive cohort study. Lancet Infect Dis 2015;15:905e12. http://dx.doi.org/ experience of stigma among health professional survivors]. Bull Soc Pathol
10.1016/S1473-3099(15)70152-0. Exot 1990;2016(109):309e13. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s13149-016-0510-5.
[14] Mohammed A, Sheikh TL, Gidado S, Poggensee G, Nguku P, Olayinka A, et al. [23] Lee-Kwan L-K, DeLuca N, Adams M, Dalling M, Drevlow E, Gassama G, et al.
An evaluation of psychological distress and social support of survivors and Support services for survivors of ebola virus disease - Sierra Leone. MMWR
contacts of Ebola virus disease infection and their relatives in Lagos, Nigeria: a Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2014;2014(63):1205e6.
cross sectional studye2014. BMC Public Health 2015;15:824. http:// [24] Arwady MA, Garcia EL, Wollor B, Mabande LG, Reaves EJ, Montgomery JM,
dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12889-015-2167-6. et al. Reintegration of ebola survivors into their communities - firestone
[15] Mohammed H, Vandy AO, Stretch R, Otieno D, Prajapati M, Calderon M, et al. District, Liberia. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2014;2014(63):1207e9.