Professional Documents
Culture Documents
From Soil To Skin
From Soil To Skin
TO:SKIN
a meditiation on
belgonging and identity
FROM SOIL TO SKIN
a meditiation on belonging and idenity
Samira Saidi
when did you forget how to fly?
ABSTRACT 9
PROLOGUE 15
MY SKIN IS TIRED 27
THE FANTASY OF BLACKNESS
LA BÊTE NOIRE
UNCONDITIONAL BELONGING 55
SEASONS OF BECOMING 67
REMAIN WATER 77
EPILOGUE 83
Or you see. Or you keep. Or you speak. Or you write. Or you James Baldwin ABSTRACT
fight, so that one day everyone will be able to walk the earth as
though they, have “a right to be here.”
About belonging and the small fragments that make you feel
like you have arrived.
9
11
13
PROLOGUE
15
The question of: what does it mean being a person of colour? A
Woman? A Muslim? A daughter of an immigrant? A middle class
brown girl in a rich white country?
You are being taught that your identity is in contrast with ev-
erything that has been told to you. Not only have I never been
enough; I was never the right thing at all. Few people under-
stand, my experience has never been the experience of a white
My mother
woman. Especially in Austria, I have lived the experience of a
could never
black person. I have been put into the corner of a single exis-
understand
tence, a confined category. A place I was pushed into but never
that I am fighting
wanted to settle in.
to exist.
because
My truth about identity has always been built on unstable
she believed
ground. I have made my decisions based on hopes to find ac-
in
knowledgement rather than on how I perceive myself. Figuring
love.
out who I really was has only become a topic in my life once I
My father
left Austria and moved to the Netherlands. A place that seemed
could never
like heaven on earth to me. A place where my skin colour was
understand
celebrated. Where I found people that not only look like me but
that I am fighting
also were also mixed like me. That shared the same struggles.
to exist
The same worries. And the same hopes for the future. Yet, even
because
paradise shows its flaws after living in it for some time.
he believed
that I was
Ever since then, self-reflection has become a significant part of
the best of
my life. I have carefully analysed my behaviour, my respons-
both worlds
es, the way I walk, the way I talk. Even the way my skin turns
I
darker when I am exposed to the sun. I have pulled my skin
could never
back and tried to see what lays underneath all of this. Under-
understand
neath my own insecurities but also underneath the insecurities I
why I had to fight
spark in others.
in the first place.
I asked myself what would happen if I took my race away. What
is left of me? What am I without my physical appearance? My
troubled skin, my curly hair, my dark brown eyes, and my ample
figure? It is difficult to put something aside that seems terribly
superficial, in a world that functions primarily on that very con-
struct. A world that found its purpose in its man made systems.
17
During my late teenage years, I fell in love with my other half.
With the half that I had been desperately trying to hide and
push behind all the things I thought a woman in central Europe
should be. My blackness, my African heritage, the Ghanaian
traditions I grew up with. I started straightening my hair, dyed
it blond, and wore the clothes I saw the white kids wear. Every
aspect of my controversial being that didn’t seem to fit in West-
ern social norms, I worked so hard to erase.
19
the way I look
is the way
europe
looks like.
the way I look
is the way
africa looks like
too
21
23
25
MY SKIN IS TIRED
A painful journey that starts with the mind not being able to
comprehend the body’s powers, yet. Switching between living
in its shadow and putting yourself into your own skin. Howev-
er, never finding the comfort to stay. To reclaim. To respect. To
consider it your beloved home. Instead manifesting this radical-
ly empty presence in its bones. Internalising emotions of disre-
spect and paralyzing fear from the outside world. Cleansing its
precious skin with the unfiltered hatred that has been projected
onto it.
27
My skin still gets tired. My hair at times loses its magic, and my
smile often fades. When there is yet another person who ques-
tions my belonging, my origin, or my comfort.
29
Making people aware of their lack of knowledge, of what it
means to be forcefully displaced, shut down, and marginalised.
Walking the thin line between black and white, between - finding comfort in people who look like us.
belonging and alienation. People born in mixed families often
do not find their belonging in their families, since their parents
might visually represent another race. However, rightly find-
ing crucial significance in being able to communicate with one
another without extensive explanations that can still lead to
empathy and recognition of different patterns of existence.
31
The privilege to experience belonging with people that look like
your reflection is undervalued. Having the possibility to drown
in an ocean of people that have the same complexion, similar
features, and perhaps even comparable upbringings can form a
profound sense of belonging and safety that potentially impact
your future in beneficial ways.
When you are left starving for recognition from your own kind
and are deprived from loving and caring notions of people you
want to associate with. Loneliness has found its source in its
longing.
33
35
37
THE FANTASY OF BLACKNESS
The most dangerous place for people of colour to exist in, is the
imagination of a white person.
39
Although women of colour are perceived from a single It is the perspective of blackness that is accompanied by the
perspective through the lense of the erotic, they are contrarily vivid culture, pride, and unity of people of colour that makes it
discussed as the least feminine race. Often seen as aggressive, desirable for others to be part of a community with this mag-
angry, or too tough. Beyond the stereotyping, fetishising, and nitude. Yet, there is a certain goal of leaving nothing to the
shameful discussions around the erotic, the erotic is a nurtur- imagination. The imagination that is often fuelled by negative
er of the deepest knowledge of the Dasein. Being corrupted or stereotypes. The question: what might happen if… ? needs to
distorted in someone’s erotic equals the deconstruction of their transform into the acknowledgment how these ‘ fantasies’ are
various powers and encourages a culture of the oppressed. inevitably affecting every one of us living in the fantasy of
Whiteness and Blackness.
Despite the sexual fantasy of races, these imaginations also
show their powers in the appropriation of cultures and their ex-
istence far beyond objectivity. Systems of appropriation that are
being supported by mass media not only share a flawed inter-
pretation of what it means to be a person of colour but addition-
ally promote the act of ‘othering’.
41
43
45
47
LA BETE NOIR
THE BLACK BEAST
How much does fear interfere with our world, when behaviour
is getting altered towards people of different ethnic back-
grounds?
49
The terminology and idea of the ‘Black Beast’ and its translation
into ‘ being someone’s thorn in their eye’ make the experience of
people of colour more tangible. Being confronted with this gaze,
which is charged with the fear of danger and pain, one starts
to dismantle oneself and question any type of self-worth. When
the gaze touches your body and disassembles every inch, fear
turns into a cloud hovering over your being, slowly discharging
its energy into the crown of your head, leaving both parties
with groundless fear and concern. Yet, simultaneously urging
the radical act of demanding liberation from the white imagina-
tion.
Not only associations with the colour black but also dominant
thoughts that have been seeded into our brains about the other
and the unknown are actively shifting social behavior.
Instead of acknowledging that the colour black holds its power
in combining all the colours of the spectrum in its mysterious
and beautiful depth, negative narratives thrive from silencing
other points of views. Especially sayings that support discrimi-
natory attitudes and interactions quickly dismantle alternative
narratives.
51
53
UNCONDITIONAL BELONGING
Lorde, Audre; Poetry The white fathers told us : I think, therefore I am. The Black mother
Is Not A Luxury; within each of us - the poet - whispers in our dreams: I feel, therefore
pp.10
I can be free.
55
Establishing the concept of freedom into notions of belonging, Immigration, as either a voluntary or forced displacement of
one might not immediately see the intersections of mentality the body, instantly becomes an exploration of relative strength
and physicality, freedom to and freedom of, and rejection and once when discussing topics such as integration and division.
acceptance. Yet, those juxtaposing understandings all find their Experiencing individual backgrounds such as tradition, reli-
one common denominator in the realm of migration. gion, language, culture, identity, and home, as an extension of
someone’s body can shift these questions of social and economic
Constructing narratives that find their foundations in new integration into a new light.
perspectives, different lenses, and neglected voices in order to
visualise discriminating structures in the Western Globe. Human beings walking the planet with their individual exten-
Systems carefully designed to marginalise people in the quick- sion that has been growing with them since the day they were
est way possible. Through economic and social reforms of values born, suddenly need to shift and adapt to new spaces, people,
and beliefs, people of different ethnical backgrounds are fight- languages, cultures, and traditions. Adapting to new circum-
ing a battle in their everyday lives, in hopes of winning the war. stances can alter and simultaneously broaden one’s extension,
A prolonged war that is setting against key dynamics whilst yet raises questions if forceful integration into a new society
examining underlying politics of a historical narrative that with different values eliminates previously gained understand-
ultimately can expose the absence and negation of values to- ing of oneself and the extension that was fostered in their place
wards people of colour in the West. Meanwhile, accepting the of upbringing. Considering this extension as part of their ex-
fact that in this contemporary world, safety and protection has istence, holding moral and ethical values, those modifications
turned into the currency of integration and citizenship. might feel as if one loses themselves. Even forms of communi-
cation, which is one of the profound mechanisms of survival,
will alter with this change and can lead to miscommunication
between one another. Especially when one is denying the exis-
tence of different truths and different worlds of reality.
Europe is the land of the sons Waheed, Nayyirah; you broke the ocean in
my mother is Austrian because her father is Salt.; pp.5 half to be here.
I am not European because the sons own the land only to meet nothing that wants you.
-immigrant
57
Nowadays, in a world filled with neo nomads, a new type and Acknowledging that we have every right to experience a feeling
understanding of belonging has been established in upcoming of belonging, the longing for protected spaces, in which people
generations. Rather than finding a sense of home in one’s face each other on eye level and equally prioritise physical safe-
surroundings, the search of home is redirected to oneself and ty and mental safety, is awakened. So the only thing one hears
the body. Homelessness within the body however can not solely is not the absence of responses but rather the echoing of similar
relate to a mental state that has manifested itself in our being moral values.
but also finds itself in the physicality of its Dasein. Breaking
these sentiments down, we have to recognize its source and ask Lorde, Audre; ‘ There are myths of self-protection that hold us separate from
what will happen when belonging goes beyond the surrounding Your Silence Will Not each other and breed harshness and cruelty where we most
Protect You; pp. 160
and meets the thought in the body. This encounter might be need softness and understanding. ‘
capable of enabling liberation and breaking down the temporary
comfort of belonging through a distance whilst expanding Changing the language is transforming the protagonist of our
emotional responses toward experiencing the body as a shelter. worlds. Even in non-western countries the protagonist is still
European. Holding strings with more and more attachments
that create a circle of domination and dependency. As long as
there is no change in the roots of these issues, people of colour
can never achieve physical or mental freedom. It is a never
ending game in which new rules are forced onto people every
step of the way. Intentional rules to misguide the ‘other’ into
believing that belonging can not be found outside of predefined
notions.
there are a hand full of
people
who welcome others,
in their homes
share
their thoughts,
even their worries
I wish for my hand to get so full.
it gets hard to hold up.
yet with the support I can raise my hands
far above my head and show with pride
all the people that
are welcome
59
61
63
65
SEASONS OF BECOMING
It is not an
identity crisis
if you are out there
trying
to find
yourself.
67
Through stages of self-development, the internalizing of the Unfortunately, the stories of people of colour are often valued
values of parents and close friends has the greatest impact in as less impactful or important. This can be due to the fact that
forming the self, nevertheless acknowledging the undeniable non Western history has been forcefully destroyed and disman-
influence of the intuitive matching of one’s identity to social tled since times of slavery, perceiving every human not repre-
roles and their expectations. The danger of existing in accor- senting the white race as less than and not worthy of their own
dance with one’s surroundings is the deceit of misrepresenting stories of becoming. The representation of the other forms the
oneself. The altering of one’s identity requires cognitive self. These devaluating reactions and systematic stigmatisation
resources that can lead to a mind filled with self-doubt, altered towards others shows not only the insecurity and fear towards
self-consciousness, and the uncertainty of the self. success stories of the ‘other’ but are also used to crumble us in
the air, in order to fall like dust on unfruitful ground.
A lack of coherent sense of identity, however, does not necessar-
ily connect to the self but social myths such as bodily appear- Growing futures so strong and vivid that one does not have to
ance, behaviour, and personal preferences that are pressuring look to ‘otherness’ for shelter. Deconstructing ourselves, to find
one into losing oneself and adopting a sense of the ‘other’. the essence beyond national and cultural identity, the abstract
which makes us unique. Finding new connections in the rich-
“The Modern concept of identity places a supreme value on Fukuyama, Francis; ness of our heritage and the blessings of our ancestors, in order
authenticity, on the validation of that inner being that is not Identity, Contemporary to reveal our self.
Iditentity Politics and
being allowed to express itself.” Throughout the journey of the Struggle for Recog-
becoming oneself, we are challenged to show empathy not only nition; pp. 25 Mental health plays a crucial role in the development of some-
to each other but also to ourselves. Embracing different stories one’s identity. Finding yourself struggling with your own mental
of becoming and letting go of manifestations within, that lead health throughout periods, in which placing your voice into your
us to believe that there is only one right way of pursuing a sense existence seems impossible and positive thoughts cannot create
of arriving in our bodies and lives, is claiming power over who a sense of comfort, often coexists with notions of shame and a
we choose to be. lack of confidence. These emotions hovering over the process of
becoming oneself can cause isolation and confusion and simul-
taneously create walls throughout conversations with others.
Being vulnerable about the difficulties of becoming shows
“ What does that mean for Black women? It means we must establish Lorde, Audre; Your
others that this very evolution of the self can be a painful and
authority over our own definition, provide an attentive concern and Silence Will Not Pro- uncomfortable process, yet underlines the importance to under-
expectations of growth which is the beginning of that acceptance we tect You; pp.166 stand that the practice of love ( to others and ourselves ) needs
came to expect only from our mothers. It means that I affirm my own patience.
worth by committing myself to my own survival, in my own self and
in the self of other Black women. On the other hand, it means that as I Mental health difficulties find their source in the lack of a sense
learn my worth and genuine possibility, I refuse to settle for anything of belonging and identity and result in distorted views of one-
less than a rigorous pursuit of the possible of myself, at the same time self. People of colour found grace in their oppression, yet the
making a distinction between what is possible and what the outside importance in the relation between identity, belonging, and
world drives me to do in order to prove I am human. It means being their well-being came into understanding. Growing up with
able to recognise my successes, and to be tender with myself, even pain that is not given attention. Healing that has not yet begun.
when i fail. “
69
The moment this pain is voiced, one not only conquers fears of
rejection and abandonment, but also allows themselves to heal,
and dream about the person they want to become.
“We must love ourselves even if - and perhaps especially if - Wilkerson, Isabel;
others don’t” “Where Do We Go
From Here?” The
Fire This Time;
pp.61
71
73
75
REMAIN WATER
77
at my calmest you can see your reflection in me
and if you hear the storm approaching
so tell your story to the ocean
you will feel my waves crashing
it is the only entity that knows how to listen
I hope
without judgment.
it will not drown you
but you will swim through it
remain water in all of its forms
to see the fire burning on the other side
water that nourishes the soil
to grow the flowers
the fire I kept between my palms
we grace our homes with
until it scared my skin
let us all be soft fierce and water
I screamed the pain into the ocean
to harvest a good heart.
and my voice echoed within me.
until it forced the rain
it is difficult to remember.
to pour
to remember to remain water in fire.
in me to nourish my soil
to heal the scars.
79
81
EPILOGUE
83
Tell the story of your body to the ones who have learned how
to listen. Since the ones that have taught themselves how to be
quiet, when others are speaking, are the ones who have placed
their ego aside and welcome others into their existence.
take the courage
the moon
As a woman of colour I myself have been drowning in the chaos
carries.
of finding my identity and my belonging. The urge to be seen
the courage
as fully human who is allowed to feel. To laugh loudly and cry
to shine
in dark times even louder. I quest the freedom to show my emotions and make
and make others my heart the most beautiful thing about me. Without being
point at you called the angry black woman or being shut down for being too
and say sensitive to talk to. To allow also people of colour, to perceive
‘Look at her, vulnerability as strength. Talking to ourselves like we would
she is the moon.’ talk about flowers in order to restore our aura and bring no-
tions of healing back into our state of being. Acknowledging the
importance in finding love in what sees you and appreciate the
body with the understanding that it is in fact, a borrowed home.
85
I am showing gratetude to
everyone that helped me turn
into water. This support will
never go unnoticed.
From Soil To Skin explores notions of belonging and identity.
The work exists in the realm between ficiton and nonfiction and
finds its purpose in the discussion of the internsectionality through
the Dasein.