Dkfbslo: Lziff DFT (Efiff J Dxfgu/Kflnsf

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 40

;+:yfkslk+ M k'ik/Tg ;fu/, k"0f{sfhL tfd|fsf/, /Tgdfg l;+ t'nfw/, s'n wd{/Tg t'nfw/

bF &), NofM $, Yo+NofM @*! g];+= !!$) lbNnf÷u'+nf lj=;+= @)&& >fj0f

;Nnfxsf/ ;DkfbsLo
k|f= do\h' k|]dzflGt t'nfw/ lzIff; dft[efiff j dxfgu/kflnsf
yf}+ :jof ;Tof bF GXoj x] g]kfn efiffof Kou yfof 5un yf+ df=
;~rfns ;ldlt hut;'Gb/ dNn+ df+ efiff+ cfvn Aj+s]dfj . df+ efiff+ cfvn Ajg;f drft
efh' k'ik lrqsf/ ofsg ;j :o'p h'ofj jO wOu' jfn rfo]sf cHofju' ld Rofju' /f0ff
efh' ltns k|sfz sfn;+ g+ dUof;]+ ;fx;ofgf df+ efiff+ Aj+s] Hof GXofsfj lbn . cy] x] d]u'
efiff+ lzIff+ ofsg y'Os] kmOdv' wsf j}1flgs ægf]d rf]D:sLÆ -;g\ !(^)_
efh' gjLg lrqsf/
of wfk'lt sy+ df+ efiff+ lzlIft h'O;f d]u' efiff+ af}l4stf hs h'Ou' vj .
efh' k'ik/Tg t'nfw/
drfto\ GXok' z}zj -jfNo_ sfn+ lg;]+ k"0f{ h'O{ w'+sOu' h'of drf+ lg;]+ x]
df+ efiff+ lzIff ljOjn] drft ofsg ljsf; h'O{ . Yj vF; ljåfg æ;lk/ j
;Dkfbs tyf k|sfzs xf]km{Æof egfO sy+ eflifs ;fdYo{ j ;+k|]ifgof ;fdYo{of ;fk]Iftf; dg"to]s
do\h' ?lSdgL >]i7 ;+;f/ oft y'Os]u' j yju' ljrf/ JoQm ofo]u' Ifdtf ljsf; h'O . Yj
Ifdtf df+ efiff+ hs h'O{ . eflifs ;fdYo{ x|f; jOjn] Jojxf/ j ;Eotf;g+
sfo{sfl/0fL ;Dkfbs ljrng h'of jO{ . df+efiff+ lzIff w}u' gf/f+ cGt/f{li6«o sfg'gof df}lns xs
efh' k"0f{ tfd|fsf/
vj . o'g]:sf] j g]kfnof @)$& ;fnof lnkf ;ljwfg+ x/]s gful/s oft
df+ efiff+ lzIff sfo]u' xs ;'/lIft h'O wsf 3f]if0ff h'of Rj+u' b' . t/ Yj
do\h' k|]dlx/f t'nfw/
3f]if0ff Jojxf/] wfn;f nfu' dh'of Rj+u' b' . cfw'lgs lzIff lgltof k|efj+
Joj:yfks lk+ ljb]zL efiff ckf]ofj dft[e"ldof ef}uf]lns, k|fs[lts ;fwg ;|f]t cflb kfv]+
efh' s'Gbg k|;fb >]i7 ljd'v h'ofj cfofltt ljifoj:t' hs dv' x/]s knfv klts+ k/lge{/tf+
efh' ;'/]Gb| eQm >]i7 yju' hGde"ldof ef}uf]lns, k|fs[lts ;fwg ;|f]t gfk+ df}lns ;+:sf/ ;+:s[lt
cflb GXgf jgf Rj+u' b' . Yj x/]s ljifoof 1fg lg;]+ df+ efiff+ lzIff gLlt
sDKo'6/ 6fOk–n]cfp6 5onf, o+sn;f hs Jojxfl/s gfk+ ;}4flGts 1fg g+ sof o+s] k'm . dxfslj
l;l4bf; cdfTo efiff Djfgf Rjg;f hs hflQ g Djfgf RjlgO hfltof
cfgGb /fpt cl:tTj g+ bofj RjlgO . Yj x] l;4fGtoft cfTd;ft ofgf o]F, on, Vjk
ag]kf, w'lnv]n, kf]v/f cflb d]o/lk+, j8fof cWoIf j :yfgLo hgtf+ lklg+u'
yfs"÷d'b|s ;xeflutf+ yju' nfuf b'g] k'ms+ lzIf0f s'ly+;+ df+ efiff+ lzIff clgjfo{ ofgfj
l8«d js{; lkG6;{ Hof GXofs'u' On sy+ ;fGble{s h'u' Rj5fo] jxu' h'n . y'u' lzIff gLlt ;+
sf7df8f}F ef}uf]lns yfo\ jfo\, k|fs[lts >f]t, g;f Tj+;f, snf sf}zn, ;+:s[lt ;Dkbf,
:jf:Yo g}lts lzIff hflto ;+:sf/ ;+:s[lt gfk+ efiff+ j lnlkoft b'Yofsf
lksfs tMu' a'v+ b' . y's]+ g]jfn ;+:s[lt j ;+:sf/ gfk+ efiff oft lbuf] Djfsf
to]u' nFk' lwl; nfoL wofu' en;f sofu' h'n . cGt; sf=d=g=kf=of d]x/
yf}+sGx] k|sfzg k|f=ln= ljBf;'Gb/ zfSoh'+ ljz]if ;lqmotf GXoHofsf Rj+u' Yjknf Rj5fo] jxu' y'u'
hdn, sf7df8f}F df+ efiff cleofg lbuf] h'Okmo]dfn wsf cflzsf of;]+ le+t'gfu' h'n . á
;Dks{ sfof{noM !^% 8fFkm] dfu{ aa/dxn sf=d=g=kf= !!, kmf]gM %&)%!^$, df]afOnM (*$!*)&%%@
d"= %).– tsf Od]nM thaunkanhe@yahoo.com, shrestharukmani@yahoo.com
US$ 2.00÷ef=?= %).– ;k"m w's" ef]tflxlt o]F ltnsk|sfz Vjk–* Sjf5]F . kmf]g M ^^!@$!%
yf}+sGx] no\kf}
k'ik lrqsf/, lxl; ckm;]6 lkG6;{, hdn . df]= (*$!#&@))% 1
wn M

x:tfIf/
cflbjh| jh|frfo{ #
lrgfv+
Vjkef;+ uhn afa'sfhL ;'jfn …ljs]z lg/fzLÚ %
db'Dx df+ n'd+an] s'Gbg k|;fb >]i7 ^
k|1fof ldvf k'ik/Tg t'nfw/ &
sljtfof n'kfM laln sf]lnG; *
afv+
dltgf g/]z cdfTo (
Rjv+
g]jf hfltof hgtfof pTkL8tof
Oltxf; j u0ftGqof ;fGble{stf k|f]= dfl0fsnfn >]i7 !)
af]8]of P]ltxfl;s k:tf yfou'
hfqf 5' vM < Kf|]d s] lg8/ !%
d'lQmgfy ofqf–$ wL/h cdfTo !*
Oltxf;
g]jf ;dfho conf j YjFof e"ldsf ?sld0fL >]i7 @$
;dfnf]rgf
Affv+ 5u" la:s+u' SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' bLks /fh æVjkÆ #@
v“UjM Dxl;s] #(
a'v“ $)
x:tfIf/

cflbjh| jh|frfo{

efiff hjf cflb jh| jh|frfo{ g]=;+= !)@* kf]xn ] f !$ s'Gx' on gfujxfno a'Dx' vM . Yjosn+ g]kfn
efiff Jofs/0f, kof{ojfrL zAbsf]if gfk+ jf}4 wd{ ;DaGwL u|Gyt RjofljHofu' b' . Yjos g]=;+= !!)* ;+
lbj+ut h'of ljHoft .

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 3
g]kfn ;/sf/
;~rf/ tyf ;"rgf k|ljlw dGqfno
;"rgf tyf k|;f/0f ljefu

4 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
lrgfv+

Vjkef;+ uhn
afa'sfhL ;'jfn …ljs]z lg/fzLÚ

GXofSj ;+s6 jn wM;f+, Vjla+ Kofªfu' d? .


xln–dg" bSj+ Uof;f+, emLk'ª Uofªfu' d? ..!..

bfh'lshf, ttfs]x]F yM x] v, sk'{ª dv' ;'+ g


dltgf ofª Djfo]u' emL, ;'g+ ;'tf+ :ofªfu' d? ..@..

yMs] bMu' Oª go]u', ;';'sM go]u' afgL dof]


u'Gx'ts Bf+nfo] dM;f+, VjM emL;+ Hofªfu' d? ..#..

emLu' :jfledfg emLu' OHht, DjfsM to]dflg


;'tf+ Vjo]sM le+ h'Odv', zq'ofs] 5'+ Tofªfu' d? ..$..

kmOdv' a's] …ljs]zÚoftf, db' emL :jof] aMnfk'+


yMu' nfFo\ x] ªfo]k'+ emL, ;'of+ la?4 GXofªfu' d? ..%..
á á
!!$) lrNnfufM bzdL -^ r}q @)&^_
rfFu'gf/fo0f gkf–@, emf}v]n, eStk'/

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 5
lrgfv+

db'Dx df+ n'd+an]


s'Gbg k|;fb >]i7

u'nf b+s+ b'Mvl;of yf}+ Û dGt .


lhtM Kjfyo\ 3fgf d]lk+ bfh' lshf lk;+ y]+
lemnf bo\j+ lh+ b'Mv ljofu' g+ db'
Yj ;+;f/o\ xMDx lh+ xfo\sfu' g+ db'
lhld df+ lh+ SjfSjf Tofgfu' g+ db'
yf}+ Û dGt . co\g,
yDx+ b'Mv l;O kmSj l;of uo\uo\
lhtM ;'vof nF Sogf ys"Dx j lh+ d:o'
lhld df+ lhld df+
yf}+ Û dGt . yf}+ Û dGt .
lhtM b'Mv h'Oan] VjODx d]lk;+ y]+
lhu' ;'vo\ lGxlnDx Wojf dfnwsf
SjfSs d'no\tof b'? Ta+sf xfo\sfu' g+ dv'
lhtM Ajn+s"Dx d]lk;+ y]+
lhld df+ c+z dfnwsf
yf}+ Û dGt . Njfk' ofgfu' g+ dv'
;'oft+ 5'+ dwf;] Njr+ sMu' g+ dv'
;'ofu'+ gf+ dsf;] Dx't' d;fMu' g+ dv'
lhtM 5sM x] d;Mt';] uy]uy]
cfsf emfsf+ lh+ larfM ofo\ x] dk'mt
lhld df+ lhld df+
yf}+ Û dGt . yf}+ Û dGt .
dGt=== Û btn] s'rfM
dGt=== ÛÛ dbo\j larfM
b x] dGt=== ÛÛÛ lhtM cgfyofgf
lhld df+ lhld df+
6 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
yf}+ ugjg y]+
;'oft wfo\ lh+
ug jg] lh
Vjo\g+ dk'mt lh
lGxn]u'nf vF x] dv't
5' ofo\u' lh+ <
lhlddf+ k'ik/Tg t'nfw/
yf}+ Û dGt .
;gf jgfRjgf lh
df+of No' No"
k|1fof ldvf
cw{hno\ tof nM Tj+sf Rjgf On of lkg] z"Goo\
lh+ df+oft u'ln lxnfM lh h'of
lbko\ Ujt'Osf ofsMa'sM hs h'n
le tofRjgf lh+ n'Os] dk'mt ;'v .
yMu' x] Nxft+
yMoft a'Os'Dx df+oft UjMu" h'lg lagfjg,
uGofu' lj8Dagf Yj < UjMu" nf]s lxn]w'g,
v/fgL h"u' :jofRjgf 5'+ x] d:o" lh+ ;To
n'Os] dk'mt ;'v .
yMu' x] ldvf+
g'uM dl5+sf VjofRjgf lGx of hno\ rf of Vo'Fno\
lh yf}+ nf]sof lkg] nf]so\
GXofSj x] Vj;f+ dfM h'of lxSs bgf
df+ n'd+sf GXofSj x] xfM;f+ n'Os] dk'mt ;'v .
lnxfF jO dv't ujn]+ d]yfo\ ug n'O ;f
5fo\ wfM;f Vo'Fno\ gu'y]+ yLu'
dGt yf}+ yMu' g'uMr' b'g] b'
lh yMDx df+ . k|1fof ldvf rfn .
g]=;+= !!#( u'Fnf ufM, ;fkf?
lj=;+= @)&^ >fj0f #! ut] yMu' hnf vM yM x] t'+
hM lt nf]so\ vo]u',
Dx, jr+ j lrQ+
lgjf{0fof jfM rfn .

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 7
lrgfv+

sljtfof n'kfM
laln sf]lnG;

lh+ Oldt wof Introduction to poetry

5k' sljtf sof I ask them to take a poem

/+lug :nfO8y]+ and hold it up to the light

hM :jsfM Hjgf lt . like a color slide

of plsof xfKjno\ Gxfo\k+ Tonf lt . or press an ear against its hive.

lh+ wof, sljtfo\ 5'Frf -!_ TjtfM


I say drop a mouse into a poem
j+ sljtfo\ SjjfnLu' j}u' kxM lrjf sf
and watch him probe his way out,
of sljtfof Sjyfo\ b'ltgfM
or walk inside the poem's room
dtof l:jrof nflu c+uM tfo]ls .
and feel the walls for a light switch.
lh d+ b'M Oldt
Gxl;a'FO Rjldof gfdo\ NxfM Ajo]sfM I want them to waterski
sljtfof b]aM -@_ pv]y'v] across the surface of a poem
nvo\ :sL lDxts] . waving at the author's name on the shore.

t/ Old kmSj ofo] d+ b'M But all they want to do


sljtfoft d]ro\ lvkt+ lrOu', is tie the poem to a chair with rope
cn] j+ ofOu' sfo]ngfdfof nflu and torture a confession out of it.
;f:gf laOu' .
They begin beating it with a hose
Old;+ joft kfOk+ -@_ bfo]t GXolrnL to find out what it really means.
wfTy]+ psL b'vF 5' n'Os]t . - Billy Collins

laNnL sf]lnG;sy+ Dx:o"Dx ljlnod h]D; sf]lnG; -a"u' bF dfr{ @@, !($! dfgxf6\tg, Go"of]s,{ cd]l/sf_ cd]l/sfof
HjM db'Dx slj . ;g\ @))! lg;]+ @))# ts cd]l/sfof Poet Laureate sy+ xgf tMDx . j]sMof ;k"m, ;o\ln+u cnf]g
c/fp08 lb ?d Go" P08 ;]nS] 6]8 kf]Od -@))!_, lkslgs, nfOl6+u -!((*_, cf6{ ckm b|fl] g+u -!((%_ j d]u' sljtf
;k"mt . j]sn+ Go"of]so{ f n]xdfg sn]h j l;l6 o'lgel;{6L %) bF ts c+uh
]| L :ogf bL .

8 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
afv+

dltgf
g/]z cdfTo

lgDx dltgfldto by'O dltgf+ wfn, ofO ;hfo lh+ kmo dfnL Û dltgf lh h'ofg+ dltgf
æ ha ha l5ld oMToMt h'O l5lk+ lh ln;]+ l5D;+ ofO lhu' cl:tTj lhs] db' =====Æ
;lts j} cn] lhtM l5ld; r'Kkf g}, sltSs dltgf+ dltgfdL tot yMu' g'uM v+ sgft'+
3ok'of lkQ'lkof :kz{ ofO, cn] dltgfof Kofv+ Rjlg
Nx'O====== lhNn h'of Rj+lk+ dltgfld lgDx jf:ofxf+
don ls jfToMˆjfToM dbos jfG5\jl} a, lh lGxnf lgDx+ lgDx]l;u' VjfM :jof lgDx]l;g+ lgkf
ln;]+ tfkfgf jgfla, ldvfof w" h'of la, uNtL l5ld;+ NxfM sl;Ss Hjgf Rjg Û

] i f Og f k
f k , lj z
Ogfkg]kfn , Og
;Djt !!$) Gx"bFof n;tfo\ lkb+u' ljz]if ljz]iffª\s y]+
yf}sGx] no\kf}of #)) Nof g+ lkygLu'nL xg]jlk+ snfsf/to\u' UjxfnL+
Rj;'gfk :jfk'b'u' sy+of lskft tof cf6{ k]k/o\ ljz]if ljz]iffª\s lkyg]u'
Uj;f UjofRjgfu'ln+ xg]jlk+ Rjld lk;+ jOu' g];+ !!$! l;Nnf uf -@)&&
;fn kmfNu'g_ tsof b'g] Uo;'Uo+u' Rj;'t ljoflbOt Ogfk ofgfu' h'n . tlhs
lkbgLu' yf}sGx] no\kf} Gxfkfy] g]kfn ufn+ lkgo\ yL yL hLNnfo\ j ljb]z
tsg+ GogLu'ln+ xg]jlk+ lj1fkg bftf+ lj1fkg ljoflbof UjxfnL ofgflb w}u'
tx|f]u' en;f sof . cy] rGbf bftf to\;+ g+ k'm–rfsy+ rGbf ljoflbof yf}sGx]
no\kf}oft wL;Lnfs lkyg]u'nL tx|f]u' ltjM ljoflb w}u' en;f sof .
yf}sGx] hM

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 9
Rjv+
g]jf hfltof hgtfof pTkL8tof
Oltxf; j u0ftGqof ;fGble{stf
k|f]= dfl0fsnfn >]i7

tMu' dl5 hfltof hgtf ån+å bFlg;]+ 5u" x] ljsl;t h"u' ljlzi6 ;+:s[lt vM . cy] h"ul' n+ g]jf
b]zo\ gfk+ d'gf 5u" x] /fHo cGtu{t Rjgf Rj+u' wofu' 5u" hft dv' 5u" hflt vM, cem cfkfn+
yfo\ emLu' b]z g]kfnof ljleGg hfltof hgtfdWo] ljåfg lk+; g]jf hgtfoft 5u" hflt g+ dv', 5u"
5g" k|dv ' hfltof hgtf g]jf hgtf vM . g]jfto\t /fi6« wfo]u' ofM . Yjof ljlzi7tf x] ;+:s[lt vM, g]jf
k|dv ' hflt wofu' sf/0f /fHo–;+oGqo\ u'u+' x] Ono\ ;+:s[lt wofu' x] g]kfn ;+:s[lt vM .
g+ k|dv ' e"ldsf b'lk+ d'v;f+ pNn]vgLo :yfg b'lk+ t/ y'ln ljlzi6tf b'u' j b]zof k|dv ' hflt
g+ d'v;f+ b]zof ;+:s[ltof ljsf;o\ ljlzi6 e"ldsf dWo] 5u" hflt h'of Rjlk+, cem b]zof hgtfof
b'ul' n+ k|dv
' hfltdWo] 5u" hflt wofu' vM . pln d'lQm ;+3if{o\ bsn] ckf] of]ubfg laplk+ 5u" pGgt
dxTjk"0f{ h"u' x] sf/0f+ ofgf j+u' lg;M rfr" bF lg;]+ hfltof hgtf g]jf hfltof ån+åM bFof Oltxf;
:jb]zL j ljb]zL ljåfglk+;+ yldjf/] t:;s+ cle?lr x] pTkL8gof Oltxf; vM, Oltxf;of qmdo\ Yj
sof cWoog j cg';Gwfg g+ ofu' vM, cy];f+ Yj b]zof cflbjf;L e"ldk'q g]jf -g]jfn_ hgtf ujn]+
hfltof ljz]iftf af+nfs y'Os]u' j AofVof ofo]u' x] g]kfn b]zof dflns h'O dv+, GXofan]+ /}lt,
Hof cftsg+ af+nfs dh"lg . Yj n]vo\ g+ g]jfto\ bf; hs . t/ Yj hfltof 5u" ljz]iftf 5' wfM;f+
ljz]iftfaf/] 5tflgtf s'nu] ' Hof hs h'O, t/ k"js + g]jfto\t Gx'of /fh ofgf Rj+lk+ zf;sto\t d]lk+
cWoog h'Ou' wsf bfjL ofo] dk'm . cfqmd0fsf/Lt jofM cldt a'sfM yM zf;s h'Oj
g]jf woflk+ b]zof d]du] ' Yjof eft[hfltlk+ s't' j+lk+ Gxfkfof zf;st cyf{t a"lk+ zf;st
-tfdfª, u'?ª, du/, /fO, lnDa', yf?, z]kf{ cflb_ g]jf hfltO b'xfFjO, lanLg h'O . lnR5ljto\;+
y]+ 5u" g:n cfwfl/t -jf 5u" lx oflk+_ dg"to\ zf;g sfo]j ls/ft j+zof h'hl' klg ef/bf/ ju{
;d"x dv' . g]jfto\ b'g] cfo{dn " oflk+, d+uf]n d"n g]jf h" jn, lnR5ljto\t a'sf dNnto\;+ /fHo
oflk+ j b|flj8 d"noflk+ dg" b', wd{ :jM;f+ yf}s + Gx] sfo]j lnR5lj t g]jf h'n . yDx+ /fhofgf Rj+tn]
z}j j af}4 t b', k[YjLgf/fo0f zfxof bdg+ Gxgf dNn zf;st\o; \ + ælhlk+ 7s'/L, lhld k|hf g]jfMÆ
jg] GXof]ts g]jfwoflk+ Ko+u" wd{oflk+ -z}j, af}4, wof h'n, cn] zfx h'h+' cldu' /fh nfsf sfo]j
O:nfd j OzfOt_ b' . g]jf hgtfoft 5u" hfltsy+ dNnt g+ g]jf hfltO b'Yoft . y'sy+ g]jf woflk+
5lwofgftMu' cfwf/ efiff j ;+:s[lt vM . g]kfn x] zfl;t, pTkLl8t -cn] k/flhtlklg cf>o
efiff NxfOlk+ j g]jf ;+:s[lt sof Rj+lk+ dg"to\ ;d"x sfOu' yfo\of_ hflt h'ofRj+lk+ hflt vM . yy]
g]jf hflt vM . cn] g]jf ;+:s[lt wofu' ljleGg ;Dk"0f{ Oltxf; x] ls/ft hfltof ljleGg j+zof
;+:s[ltof ;lDd>0f j ån+åM bFof ;Eotfof ljsf;+ zf;slk+;,+ cn] lnkf qmdzM lnR5lj, dNn, zfx,

10 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
/f0ff, xfsg+ zfx zf;slk+;+ SjTo]sf cjx]lnt, sfo\ lgDx -dfwj /fh hf]zL j+ z'qm/fh zf:qL_,
zf]lift, pTkLl8t h'of Rjg] dfMu'ln+ :jefjtM yMu' b]zoft ljb]zL Psflwsf/ k"hLof cf}Bf]lus
g]jfto\s] ljb|fx] of k|jl[ t Ajng, ljb|fx] x] g]jfto\ pTkfbgof ahf/ ofs] dlaOt :jb]zL j;t'of k|of]u
lxof :jefj h'n . Yj x] sf/0f+ !((& ;fnof ofo]u' cfGbf]ng GXofs"Dx t'n;L d]x/ >]i7, gful/s
sf08o\ zxLb h"lk+ KoDx ;k'tlk+dWo] :jDx g]jfM, ;hutf j r]tgf ysfo]t Gxofs" u' k':tsfno
g]kfn k|hf kl/ifbof sfo{ ;ldltO tMDx dl5 g]jf, :yfkgf cfGbf]ngof g]tf of]ujL/ l;+x s+;sf/,
!((* ;fnof g]kfn k|hftGq ;+3of ;+:yfks dft[efiffof dfWod+ lzIff wofu' gf/f Yjo]sD" x hut
GXoDxdWo] v'Dx g]jfM, g]kfnL /fli6«o sf+u; ]| bo]st] ;'Gb/ dNn, :s"n :yfkgf ofo]u' z}lIfs cfGbf]ng
kxn ofMDx u0f]zdfg g]jfM, g]kfn k|hf k+rfotof ofgfM sf/faf; nfan] x] zxLb h'of j+Dx lrlgof
;+:yfks gfof]gj] f, g]kfn sDo'lgi6 kf6L{of GofDx nfn l;+xlk+ ;sn]+ x] g]jf hfltoflk+ vM .
;+:yfkslk+ k'mSs x] g]jfM h"u' g]kfnof Oltxf; yy] hfu|t JolQmlk+ hs dv', cfd hg–:t/+
b' . cy] x] @)$^ ;fnof hg–cfGbf]ngof ;jf]R{ r g+ ljb|fx] ofu' w6gft g]kfnof Oltxf;o\ b' . O{:jL
sdf08/ u0f]zdfg l;+x >]i7 j pu' cfGbf]ngo\ ;Djtof lem+vu' u" ' ztfabLO h'h' ;bflzj dNnof
Ajlt sfMu' :j+u' ;d"xM g]kfnL sfFu; ]| , ;+oQ ' m lj?4 h"u' ljb|fx] o\ Hofk'to\;+ h'ho' ft Gjn+ hs
jfddf]rf{ j ;+oQ ' m /fli6«o cfGbf]ngof g]tT[ j bfof b]z+ Vofgf lkltgf 5jMu' 36gfof pHHjn
ofMlk+ k|dv
' lk+ -jf sdf08/lk+_ qmdzM u0f]zdfg pbfx/0f g]jfto\;+ tMu' b' .
l;+x, t'n;L nfn cdfTo j zDe"/fd >]i7 :jDx+ Rjo\ wofy]+ g]kfnof ljleGg j+zof zf;s
g]jfM vM . cn] ;+oQ ' m jfd df]rf{of dfgfy{ cWoIf h'h' to\;+ g]jf hgtfoft GXofan]+ bdg x] hs
t'n;L nfn cdfTo vM;f sfo{sf/L cWoIf h'of oft . g]jfto\t h"u' pTkL8gof 5'+ elt vF hs
bLDx ;fxgf k|fwg g+ g]jfM vM . yg pNn]v ofo] . ls/ft sfnof vF pln :ki6
;Dk"0f{ Oltxf;of qmdo\ /fhg}lts ?k+ /]s8{ db'ul' n+ j pln k|frLg sfnof :ki6 lrq
pTkLl8t -e]befjof lzsf/_, clwsf/+ jflR5t h'of emLs] db'ul' n+ pu' o'uof vF TjMt] . lnR5lj sfno\
Rjg] dfM;f+ b]zof bsn] pa{/ e"efuo\ -:jlguM j lnR5lj zf;slk+ dfuwL jf d}lynL efo\ NxfOlk+
rfsMlnof Onfsf_ s]lGb|t h'of Rj+u' g]kfn d08n h";f pu' O{of g]kfnof lnR5jL /fHoof ;/xb
e"ldof ;Eotfof y'jfM h"ul' n+ j ljleGg d"nof g]kfn d08no\ b'g] ;seg+ dv';f+ /fhwfgL j
dg"t NjfsHofgf ljleGg wd{ j ;+:s[ltof ;dGjo plsof rfsMln -yf}s + Gx]of g]kf ufM jf :jlguM
h"u' sf/0f+ g]jft 5u" pGgt ;Eotf j ;+:s[ltof j plsof 5rfVo_of Onfsfof hgtfof efiff
y'jf h'O vg . Yj x] sf/0f+ g]jfto\s] pGgt ;+:sf/ g]kfn efiff vM, dtnj g]jfM t ygof 5u" k|dv '
j ljrf/ bOu' :jfefljs vM . g]kfno\ k'mSs kIfo\ hflt vM . plsof b;' lnR5lj h'h' lklg ;+:s[t
k'nf+u' cg'bf/ ljrf/, rfnrng j k/Dk/fof efo\of clen]vo\ yfo\ yf;o\ g]kfn efiffof zAb
lj/f]wo\ cu|ufdL ljrf/ xo]u' Hofo\ g]tT[ j sfOlk+ b'YofMu'ln+ ;L b' . hgtf+ NxfOu' efo\ g]kfn efiff
g]jf ;d'bfo+ lkxfF jMu' b' . wfld{s kIfo\ ;'wf/ h'Os g+ ;+:s[tof /fHoof cf}krfl/s efo\ofgfM
cfGbf]ng j j0f{–Joj:yf, hft k|yf, c5't k|yf g]kfno\ g]kfn efiffefifL hgtfof efiffoft
j wfld{s s§/tf j cGwljZjf;of lj/f]wo\ af}– lnR5ljsfn e/ x] bdgoft . dNn sfno\ vf;
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 11
ofgfM lnkfof cjlwO Yj bdg erf sd h'n, b' . VjkMof h'h' /0fhLt dNn+ -k[YjLgf/fo0f zfxof
hgtfof efo\ g]kfn efiffoft dNn h'hl' d+;+ gfnf Tjfo\ ca'_+ k[YjLgf/fo0f zfxof cfqmd0f h'Oj cf
sfn, /fHo efiff hs dv', dNnto\;+ yDx+ NxfOu' 5' ofo] dfnL wsfM ef/bf/lk+s] ;Nnfx sfMjn] jof
efo\of ?ko\ g+ g]kfn efiff x] gfnf sfn . k|wfg ;]gfklt dxfjL/ l;+x -l;d/f}gu9of d}lyn
efiff bdg lbs";f+ dNnto\;+ g]jf hgtfoft h'h+' xl/l;+x b]jof a+;h ;Gtfg_ æcfTd–;dk{0f
/}tLsy+ zf]if0f pTkL8g ofo]u' dTjMt" . ;bflzj wofu' ofo] dlhp, d;Ltn] x] cfqmd0fof k|ltzf]w
dNnof lj/f]wo\ h"u' ljb|fx] nf 5u" :ki6 vg] b'u' ofo] dfMÆ wsf ;Nnfx lapu' j /0fhLt dNn+ cfTd
k|df0f h'n . pu' O{ of nf]s–Do] :jo]an] ;fdGtL ;dk{0f ofo] w'gj] d]lk+ ef/fbf/lk+ k[YjLgf/fo0f h'h'
h'h' j jof kl/jf/ ;fdGtL ef/bf/ ju{ ofgf gfn] w's
+ f g+ dxfjL/ l;+x j jof KoDx sfo\lk+;+ No+
Rj+u' zf]if0f, pTkL8g jf cTofrf/of lrq0f jf bgLlk+ 5'+ elt ;]gf HjgfM Njfgf x] Rjg, cn] o'4of
k|ltljlDat h"u' vF dNn sfnof l;n' Do] j d]du] ' d}bfgo\ clk+ GofDx+ l;t . Yj x] tDj+ k[YjL gf/fo0f
afv+–Do] -;LgfHof Do], ælh jofu' nl5 db'lgÆ zfx+ k|ltzf]wof efjgf+ dxfjL/ l;+xof kl/jf/oflk+
wofu' k+lQm+ z'? h"u' Do] cflb _ ; af+nfs vg]b' . wfSsf]l;t ldh+t k'mSs+ -a'9f, o'jf, drfts+_ :ofgf
g]kfn ;Djt *** -lj=;+= !*@%_ ; dNn 5\jt, ld;f wfSsf]l;t b]z–lgsfnf oft .
/fh Sjbnf zfx h'h' k[YjLgf/fo0f zfx+ zf;g on– /fHo sAhf ofo] w'gj] onof P]ltxfl;s
sAhf ofo]j ljleGg hghfltof hgtf j g]jfM æv'Dx sfhLÆ lk+t, cfM ono\ b'u' l:ylt sfod
hgtfoft q"m/ bdg z'? oft . cy] h"ul' n+ g]jfto\;+ ofo]u' wsf ;Nnfx ofo]t wsfM lgz:q ;Mtn .
:j+uM Rof -*_ of ;Djt *** of sf/0f+ Rofo\ ;Demf}tf ofgfM a]OdfgL ofo] bOdv', afudtL by'O
xfOu' dle+ wofu' cfxfg gfk+ bt . Rofo\ xfMu' lgz:q RjgfM afudtLof nMlyof zky sfo]u'
bFlg;]+ lg;M j ;'ORofoF Rj+u' zfxj+zLo /fhtGq wsf Ajgf o+sn, cgM Gxfkf+ x] ;'rs ' f tMu' t/af/+
g]kfnof ;Dk"0f{ hgtfoftnf ;fdGtL zf]if0f j ;sl;t+ kfnf lan, GofDxnf l;t, 5Dx lal;pF
pTkL8gof s's' a'Osn . ljleGg cflbjf;L, jg] kmt .
hghflt db]zL j blnt hfltof hgtfoft wfM;f ef/bf/to\t hs dv' cfd hgtfoft ofMu'
;fdGtL bdgof cltl/Qm d]u' 5u" g+ pTkL8g aa{/ bdgof af/] ;sl;g+ l;pu' vF, lsk'ld
lan, hftLo e]befj j q"m/ bdg oft . cldu' wfSsf]l;of Gxfo\ j Dx'tl' ; rfgf lan. pu' Ono\
efiff j ;+:s[ltoft lgd"n { + ofo]t :jt . g]jfto\ b'g] z}j, af}4, O:nfd j OzfO Ko+u" wd{
Yj ljifo; g]jf hgtfoft zfx j+zLo dfg] ofOlk+ KoYjM dg" b' . O;fO -lqmlZrog_ g]jfM
/fhtGq+ ofMu' bdg j cTofrf/of 5u" lgu" wfSsf] ælhu' /fHo TjMtf lkxfF jg] dfMÆ wsf x'sd '
pNn]vgLo 36gf hs yg GXoyg] . lan, lal;pF jg] dk'mld+t ovfof :ofgf 5\jt .
k[YjLgf/fo0f zfx+ :j+u" dNn /fHo, sAhf ofo] pu' O{of ;Dklt jfnf -hUuf jfnf_ g]jfto\u'
w's
+ fM o'4of qmdo\ dv' n8fOF l;wof yMu' zf;g cfd ?k+ g]jfto\u' 5]+ a'F nfsf sfMu'ln+ æg]jft
sfod h'O w's + fM ofMu' bdg ljZj Oltxf;of t:;s+ k'mSs cfM ltªl/ d}bfg -g]kfn ;Ldf kfl/O
aa{/ cfqmd0fsf/Llklg bdg ln;] HjMnf . dNn ltAatof Onfsfo\_ Rj+jg] dfnLu' h'nÆ wofu'
h'ho' f ef/bf/lk+t k|ltzf]wof sy+ ofMu' 5'+ 36gf yy] cfxfg x] Rjg .

12 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
k[YjL gf/fo0f zfx w's+ fM jofM sfo\ k|tfk l;+x g]kfn efiffÆ gf+of klqsf k|ltjlGwt wsfM 3f]if0ff
zfxof af/] cTofrf/of vF Gog] db' . t/ /0f axfb'/of dof;] x] yg jo]s] dljn . b]zo\ b'g] x] g]kfn
Ono\ xfsg+ t:;s+ bdg h'n, æ:jfld h'ho' f wd{ efiff+ 5'+ k|sflzt ofo] vgLu' nf vF x] dGt .
dbof k|hf g+ b'Mv l;nÆ wofu' ehg x] k|rlnt g]jfMto\ lj?4 eoÍ/ e]befj j cldu'
h'n . Vjk j cf;kf;of Onfsfo\ tMs}of k|sf]k efiff ;flxTo j ;+:s[ltoft bdg ofo]u' qmd
jM an] k|hfoft 5'+ /fxt laOu' kn];f tMs} jMlk+ GXofgfj+ jg, h'4 zdz]/of k|wfgdGqLTj sfno\
drfto\ kl/jf/ wfSsf] b]z+ lkltgf 5\jt . æ5Dx kmQ]axfb'/ l;+xof ;Dkfbgo\ lkb+u' æg]kfn ljxf/Æ
drf n'sl+' 5gf, 5Dx drf Aos'+ Rofgf, 5Dx drf n'Q' sljtf ;+ux| oft g]jfMefo\ h"u' x] sf/0f+ k|ltjGw
n'of jg] dfn tfdfsf]zL kfl/Æ wofu' Do] pu' Ono\ tofljn, gful/s to\s] b'u' k|ltt hkmtoft cn]
x] jMu' vM . slr drf -tMs} jMlk+ drf_ HjgfM b]z !((& ;fn+ æg]kfn k|hfkl/ifbÆ of tTjfjwfgo\
TjMtf jg] dkmof drft ;'rs ' f tMlk+yfo\ ;]gf 5\jof h"u' k|hftflGqs cfGbf]ngoft SjTonfM 5\jMjn]
pHjMlk+ drfto\t efnf+ ;'ofM :ofs] lan . k|hfkl/ifbof ;b:olkGt hs Hjgf s'u+ ' dv';]
zfx h'hl' klg+ x] /fh cGtu{t lj=;+= !()# ;dfh ;'wf/ cfGbf]ng ofMlk+ :s"n :yfkgfofgf
; hË axfb'/+ /f0ff zf;g sfod ofo]j g]jfto\ lzIff k|rf/ ofMlk+ j g]kfn efiffof n]vs lk+t g+
lj?4 hflte]bof gLlt tRjo]sn . lj=;+= !(!! Hjgf s'g . g]kfn efiff+ RjOu'oft x] ck/fw efMkfM
; lksfMu' d'ns ' L P]go\ æg]jf/ hftsf] P]gÆ wsfM j x] cleof]uo\ æ/fhsfh d'2fÆ wfsf GXofsfM
5u" cnu cWofo tofM g]jfto\ lj?4of e]befj lrQw/ Åbooft lem+lgbFof s}b, l;l4r/0f >]i7oft
oft æsfg"gL ?kÆ lan, Gxfkf k[YjL gf/fo0f zfx+ lem+RofbFof s}b j kmQ]axfb'/ l;+xoft ;j{:j x/0f
lqmlZrog g]jfto\t bdg ofMy]+ t'+ hËaxfb'/+ af}4 j hGd s}bof ;hfo ljn . h'4 zdz]/ /fhkft
g]jfto\t bdg oft . k|lz4 ef/tLo g]tf -ef/tLo TjMtf jg] GXoj k|hfkl/ifbof k|dv ' g]tflk+ jfx]s
/fli6«o sf+u; ]| b'g] dfS;{jfbL ljrf/wf/of ;d"x ;sl;t TjMt"u' ‰jno\ josMlk+ :jDxl;t g+ GofbF
bo]sD" x ;dfhjfbL ljrf/ofDx g]tf_ cfrfo{ g/]Gb| s'g] o+sf TjtfMljn . jx] Ono\ g]jfMto\t wfld{s
b]j+ Rjof bLsy+ æhËaxfb'/ g]jfto\ 5]+ 5]o+ \ Rj+u' bdg ofo]u' ‰jno\ a'4 wd{ k|rf/ ofMlk+ wsfM
af}4 u|Gy hkmt ofgfM ;8so\ af+5j\ofljn, u'u' leIf'lk+ ;sl;t+ b];+ lkltgf 5\jt .
a[l6z /fhb"t hË axfb'/of cg'dlt sofM a[l6z /f0ffsfno\ h'4 zdz]/ w's + f kß zdz]/of
b"tfjf;of 8f= /fO6 wfDxl;g o+sn . kfnfo\ bdg erf sd h'n . t/ kß zdz]/of
/f0ff k|wfgdGqL rGb| zdz]/ g]jfM hfltof zf;g tfMO{ dRj+, joft lkltgfM df]xg zdz]/
hgtf lj?4 ltj| e]befjof gLlt nfu" oft . jo]j+ hflt e]bof gLlt Gxfkf y]+ x] GXoft .
lj=;+= !(%( ;fno\ rGb| zdz]/ k|wfgdGqL h'of @))& ;fn+ /f0ff zf;g SjMbnf æ;+;bLo
5'+ bF lnkf æg]jfMto\t j db]zLto\t ;]gfo\ dto]uÆ' k|hftGqÆ :yfkgf h'O w's + fM g g]jfMto lj?4
gLlt nfu' oft . y'lsof gfk+ g]jfto\ efiff g]kfn e]befjof gLlt c3f]lift ?k GXofgf x] Rjg . g]jfM
efiff oft bdg ofo]u' ‰jno\ ef/to\ k|sflzt to];+ yMu' df+efo\of dfWod+ lzIff sfo\ bo]df wsfM
h'Ou' g]kfn efiff klqsf jf ;k"m g]kfn b't xo\ dfu ofgfM Rj+jn] ;g !(%% ; æ/fli6«o lzIff
dbOu' gLlt sfn, snstf+ lkb+u' æa'4 wd{ j cfof]uÆ+ Ao"u k|ltj]bgo\ yMyM df+ efif+ lzIff ljOu'
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 13
Joj:yf nfu" ofM;f -k|fylds sIff tshs h"+ hgtfoft ljz]ifofgf g]kfn efiff j g]jfM ;+:s[lt
;f+_ ;'gf+ g+ /fi6«efiff g]kfnL ;o]sL dv', plsof oft SjTon]u' Hof dlbSs, cem Yj gLlt oft
k|rf/ h'O dv' .Æ wsf pNn]v ofMu' vF n'ds + ] jx ;Ldbo]s ;lDawfgo\ gfk+ b'Yofsn . Yj x] gLlt
h" . y'sy+ ;Dj}wflgs ?ko\ æk'mSs gful/s ;dfgÆ sy+ :yfgLo lgsfo -gu/kflnsf j uf=lj=;=_ o\
wfM ;f+ /fHo+ 3f]if0ff dofM;]+ x] hfltjfbL ;fd'bflos g+ cgof hfltof efiff to] dbOu' lg0f{o ;jf]R{ r
zf;s to]u' sd{rf/LtGq+ g]jfMto\t g]kfn efiff cbfnt+ ofMu' vM .
oft j g]kfn ;+:s[ltoft yM k|ltåGåL j b'id0fÆ ;'? lg;]+ cfM ts yy] h'of Rj+uo' f sf/0f b' .
tfo]sf lhpsy+ ts Sj\Ton]u' gLlt sfn . eujfg a'4+ wofM ljHofy]+ GXofu' lrh, GXofu' 36gf,
@)!& ;fn+ h'h' dx]Gb| zf;g yMu' x] NxftL GXofu' ljs[ltof g+ sf/0f bO . y'hf]u' ljs[lt, b'Mv
sof k+rfotL tfgfzfxL Joj:yf sfo]d ofo]j+ xfsg+ kfv] d'Qm h'Ot sf/0f n'OsfM sf/0f oft lrOs]dfM .
k[YjLgf/fo0f zfxM rGb| zdz]/ j h'4 zdz]/of ;Dk"0f{ g]kfnL hgtfof b'Mv si6of sf/0f ;fdGtL
x] gLlt sy+ ljleGg cflbjf;L, hghflt, db]zL zf]if0f vM, g]jf hgtfoft g+ ån+åM bFlg;]+ Rj+ zf]if0f+
j blnt hghflt lj?4 e]befj j bdgof Hof SjTonf tMu' b' . cy];f+ g]kfnof cflbjf;L, hghflt,
tRjo]sn, Yj gLltof bsn] tRjMu' k|xf/ g]jfMto\t db]zL blnt j wfld{s cNk;+Vosoft, ljz]if ofgf
oft . !& ;fnof zfxL s" of lgbF lnkf lksfMu' g]jfM hgtfoft ;fdGtL zf]if0f cltl/Qm d]u' emg
;lDawfgo\ g]kfnL efiff -vo\ efo\_ oft /fi6«efiff q'm/, bdg hftLo bdgof gLlt zfxj+zLo /fhtGq+
3f]if0ff oft . …/fli6«o PstfÚ of gfd+ b]zo\ 5u" ofu' vM . k[YjLgf/fo0f zfxof ljho cleofg+
x] efiff 5u" x] ;+:s[lt ofo]u' gf/f sy+ g]kfn g]kfnof clwsf+z efuo\ zfx j+zLo /fhtGqfTds
efiff j g]jfM ;Dj[lt Gx+su] ' cg]s k|xf/ oft . zf;g sfod h'Oj+ g]kfn oft c;nL lxGb':tfg
Yj qmdof k/fsfi6f @)@@ ;fno\ /]l8of] g]kfno\ -wfTy]o+ f lxGb':tfg_ bo]su] ' wofu' k[YjLgf/fo0fofu'
Gxfkf+lg;] k|;f/ h'of Rj+u' g]kfn efiff+ ;dfrf/ 3f]if0ff sy+ g]kfM of u}/ lxGb', ef/t ofu' cfo{;:+ s[lt+
ljOu'ln k|ltjGw tn, ;dfrf/ k|;f/ lbs]u' gfd+ leGg ;+:s[lt b'lk+ v; efiff jfx]s d]u' efiffefifL
g]kfnefiffof ;flxlTos sfo{qmd lbsn /]l8of] j to]u' wd{ ;+:s[lt, efiff Gx+sf 5\jo]u' gLlt sfn .
;/sf/L k|sfzg -uf]/vfkq_oft g]kfn efiffo\ ljof k[YjLgf/fo0f zfx j jof pQ/flwsf/Llk+; sfMu'
xMu' lj1fkg lksfo] db' wsfM k|ltjGw tofljn . hflte]bjfbL bdgof v+ Rjo\ jg] w's + n . cy] h"ul' n+
k+rfot sfno\ x] lnkf xfg+ lghfdlt sd{rf/L to]u' g]jfM hgtf nufot ;Dk"0f{ g]kfnL hflt hghfltof
k|df]zg ofo]jn] c+s NofM vfO Hofo\ Pd=P= oft hgtfof d'lQm nf nf]stGq, hgjfb, ;dfhjfb j
j kL=Pr=8L= jfkt jLu' c+s g]kfn efiffof Pd=P= ;fDojfbof :yfkgf h'Ojltlg ;fsf/ h'Ou' h"; + f+
j kL=Pr=8L= oft djLu' lg0f{o nf]s;]jf cfof]u yf}o+ f q'm/ hflte]bL bdg+ d'Qm h'Ot plsof sf/0f
nfu" ofsn /f0ffsfno\ x] y]+ xfsg+ g]kfn efiffof zfxj+zLo /fhtGqof cGTo ofgfM u0ftGqof
n]vslk+t s'gu] ' Hofoft, cfMnf emg d'2f g+ dof;] :yfkgf ofgfof cy{ h'h' 5Dx lnsofM 5\jo]u' jf
s}b ;hfo\ dlj;] cy]+ x] s'gu] ' Hof tRjo]sn . /fhtGqof cj;fg ofgf hs dufM . /fhtGqfTds
@)$^ ;fnof hgcfGbf]ng g ax'bnLo s]Gb|Lo hfltjfbL bdgsf/L ;fdGtL /fHo ;+oGq g
;+;bLo k|hftGq xfs+g jo] w's + f g+ g]jfM y'gf 5\jo]dfM u'b' .

14 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
Rjv+

af]8]of P]ltxfl;s k:tf yfou'


hfqf 5' vM < Kf|]d s] lg8/

g]kfno hfqf kj{t oSj b'M . hfqf kj{ g++ lt;f dfn]u' hfqf d'Vo d'Vo vM . j hfqfkj{t
;+:sf/ ;+:s[ltof 5u' ?k vM . hfqf kj{ wfld{s k|frLg sfn+lg;]+ Gxofsf jof Rj+u' vM . ;+:sf/
?k+ Gxofsf tMu' vg] b';f+ , pls+ b'g] ;fdflhs j ;+:s[lt tgf j+ln;] u'ln+v] hfqfkj{ tgf+ jg
j ;f:s[lts dxTj+ hfMu' vg] b'M . wfM;f u'ln+ cgof hgtft;]+ OZj/of HofM cn]+
Hffqf kj{ g]jfto\u' df}lns ;+:sf/ vM . lhdL afHof aHo]lg;]+ Gxofsf tMu' ;+:s[lt wsf
;+:sf/ dfgo\ ofo]u' hs dv' ;fdflhs hLjgo Djfsf tMu' vg] b' . yy] x] k'vf{ lg;]+ rno ofgf
GXofO{k's] g+ dfM w}y]+ GXofHofsf tMu' vg] b' . Rj+u' cn]+ Bof HofM wsf P]ltxfl;s ;+:s[lt
Ufg ug g]jft b' cg cg yd+ km'y]+ yMu' lsl;d+ Djfsf Rj+u' 5u' yfo vM af]8] .
hfqfkj{ Gxofsf Rj+u' vg] b' . g]jft;]+ gMv Af]f8] 5u' P]ltxfl;s sfn+lg;] ;f+:s[lts
rMvjno hs dv' ;+Nx'+ k'lGX cn]+ rf}lyoft g+ dxTj+ hfMu' yfo vM wsf cgof ;f+:s[lts
cKkf] dxTj laof hfqf kj{ Gofos]u' ofgf Rj+u' dxTj+ hfMu' ;f+:s[lts hfqf kj{ cn] Kofvt
vg] b' . j hfqfkj{t ug+ Bof vM s'laof GXofsf kfv]+ l;Os] k'm . Vjk lhNnfof 5u' k|l;4 hfqf
Rj+u' b' wfM;f ug+ ug+ Bof /y;fnf g+ hfqfkj{ la:s]6 hfqf g+ af]8]of k|d'v hfqf vM . VjKf
Gxofsf Rj+u' b' . pls+ 5u' g 5u' P]ltxfl;s lydLof la:s]6 hfqf gfk+ la:s+ lsjbGtL b'u'
lsjbGtL bof Rj+u' vg] b' wfM;f 5Dx g+ 5Dx af]8]of la:sf hfqfof Ono Do] KjfM vg]u' Hof g++
Bof e'ldsf g+ vg] bof Rj+ . plsof cfwf/+ x] h'O{ . jf]8]of la:s]6 hfqf+ Do] KjfM vg]u' hfqfof
cg j Bof hfqfkj{ Gofosf jof Rj+u' vg] b' . gfd+ g+ k|l;4 h' . j hfqf g]kfno ugg+ db'u'
Bof vM s'laof Gofolsu' hfqfkj{ dWo cfZro{ j cbe't hfqf vM .
Gxo\ uf+of hfqf, la:sf hfqf, kgf}ltof OGb|]Zj/ df]xgLano vf+ Df] kfn]u' hfqf, bzdL s'Gx'
dxfB j pGdt e}/jof hfqf, ef]to rGb|]Zj/L v8u Hjgf+ lkxf+ jOu' v8u hfqf, nfl5 k'v'nL
hfqf, Ujnoof e'jg]Zj/L hfqf, onoof le+Bof Tjogf+ ltg]u' hfqf, slt+ k'lGx s'Gx' u0]fBof
hfqf, s[i0f Bof hfqf, kfnf+rf]sof eujtL Bof hfqf cflb af]8]of P]ltxfl;s hfqf kj{ vM . j
hfqf ;Sjof jh|of]lugL hfqf lydLof afns'df/L hfqf kj{ dWo 5u' gf+ hfMu' P]ltxfl;s hfqf kj{
j l;4LsfnL hfqf, af]8] j n'‘e'of dxfnIdLBof vM k:tf yfou' hfqf . la:sf hfqfof Do] KjfM
hfqf, l6sgLof lgna/fxL Bof hfqf, xf+bLufof+ vg]u' hfqf j lgna/fxL u+ Kofv+ gfk+ :jfk' b'u'
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 15
j k:tf yfou' hfqf g+ af]8]of ;f+:s[lts dxTj+ yMDx ;+lugLtot b'Mv Ao"u'ln+ gLna/fxL t;s+
hfMu' hfqf kj{ vM . k|To]s aif{of a}zfv ! ut] t+ rfMu' ledbQ+ yMu' Dx+u;o v+u' h'of Rjg .
la:sf hfqfof Ono h'Ou' hfqf h'u'ln+ g+ k:tf ledbQ+ yd+ x] tf/0f tof Hjgfu'of kZrftfk
yfou' hfqfof dxTj cKjM h' . :j?k gLna/fxLof t+ zfGt ofot Ifdf k'hf ofu'
k|To]s jif{of a}zfv ! ut]oft g]kfdLt;]+ hg wf/0ff b' . lsjbGtL cg'zf/+ gLna/fxL B t+
Gx' lb+of ?ko xif{ j pNnf;k"0f{ ?k+ dfgo ofO{ . rfMu'ln+ tf/0ftof Hj+Dx gLna/fxLof ;+lugL e't+
dg't u'Dx Bof k'hf ofgf yMu' hMof ;'v ;d[l4 Gxob+ ts+ Do] KjfMMvg]u' wfMu'ln+ Ifdf k'hf ofgf
j ;' :jf:Yoof sfdgf ofgf ;fs le+s gof hs Do] KjfM v+s]u' ofgf tMu' vM . a}zfv ! ut]
GXofOk'sf dfgo ofO wfM;f u'DX yfo yf;o Ifdf k'hf ofgf k:tf yfou' Hof h'o w'+sfltgL
rflxnf GXofOk'sf dfgo ofO{ . aif{of GX' lb+ s'Gx' Do] KjfM vg]u' hfqf GXofsf ys'u' lsjbGtL b' .
x] af]8]of ef+u' Tjfno P]ltxfl;s k:tf yfou' pls+ a}zfv ! ut] k:tf yfou' hfqf ofgf @
hfqf h'O{ . la:sf hfqfof O{no x] h'Ou" Yj ut] Do] KjfM vg]u' hfqf ofgf tMu' vM wfMu' b' .
k:tf yfou'+ hfqfof la:s+ laz]iftf b' . af]8]of k|frLg sfn+lg;]+ dxfnIdL Bof GXof]go
dxfnIdL Bof Gxof]go Gxoflsu' Yj k:tf yfou' k:tf yfgf Ifdf k'hf ofou' k/Dk/f yf}ts+
hfqfoft Ifdf k'hfof ?ko g+ sfO{u' vM . k:tf af]8]of hgtft;]+ Bof HofM wsf dlbs Gxofsf
wofu' k|folZrt vM . gLna/fxL u+ Kofv+of jfhf Rj+u' b' . gLna/fxL u+ Kofv+ gLna/fxL yd+ x]
yfgf k|folZrt :j?k Ifdf k'hf ofO{u' h'of :ogf+ Nx'Osf tMu' Kofv+ wsf+ gLna/fxLof t+
Yj hfqfkj{oft k:tf yfou' hfqf wfO{ . y'ls+ :ofot gLna/fxL u+ Kofv+of Do] xfosf cn]+
g+ 5u' lsjbGTfL b' . lsjbGtL cg';f/++ af]8]of emL+lgbo 5s Sog] dfMu' laz]if Kofv vM Tolnu'
a:tL z+vsf]6o h'jn] gLna/fxLof ;+lugLt e't hfqfof af]n j tfnof afhf j Kj+uf k'Osf
k|]t dg'?k h'of gLna/fxLof u‘+' l;yo Rj+u' a'‘O{ Ifdf k'hf ofou' ofgf tu' vM wfMu' b' . k:tf
HofM;gf+ Rjlglk+ dg'tot ujn]+ ujn]+ UjfxfNlL yfou' Ono Ifdf k'hf ofgf dxfnIdL Bof Sjo
of jOu' cn] jhL g+ gof jlgu' h'of Rjg . t/ Rj+u' kf]n+of uh'lg;]+ dxfnIdL Bof b'g] Rj+u'
t+ jnls yMu' e't k|]t Vofof ;snL ?k Sogf+ l5kmMts lb ktf 5fodf . j lbktf ledbQ
VofOu' g+ h'of Rjg . gLna/fxLof ;+lugLt e't cfrfh'+ gLna/fxLof ;+lugLtot Hjg]t tMu'
k|]t VofMt;]+ VofO{u' h'of ;+vsf]6of dg't cg+ tf/0fof ?ko sof sGx]v'Gx' Do] KjfM v+s]u' ofgf
la;' jof a'+b] cyjf af]8] wfMu' yf;o Rj+jn . tMu' vM wfMu' b' . u'ls+ofgf e't k|]t kfv]+ z'/lIft
af]8]af;L tot cem g+ j gLna/fxLof ;+lugLt;]+ h'Ou'of ?ko softMu' b' .
Vofou' dTjMt' . cy] x] VofM jlk+ e't k|]ttot tflGqs lalw lawfg sy+ Gxoflsu' j
kz'ktLof uf]n] Rj+DX tflGqs ledbQ cfrfh'+ k:tf yfou' hfqfo yfOu' afhfof af]n j tfn
tf/0ftof Hjgf Do] KjfM v+sf cn]+ dxflbk Hj+sf Kj+ufof ;'/ gLna/fxL u+ Kofv+of laz]if Kofv+ vM
af]8] b]l5+ rfMxLsu' h'of Rjg . gLna/fxLof Tolnano yfOu' af]n j tfn cn] Kj+ufof z'/

16 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
j tfn h'O{ . gLna/fxL u+ Kofv+of laz]if Kofv+ afhfufhf k'mSs jgf+ sof xofln+ltlg b]un] d'lt{
vM Tolnano jx] afhfof z'/tfno u+ Kofv+of la/fhdfg ofO{ . cn]+ltlg lalwjt ?k+ af]8]of
Bt Kofv+ Nx'O{ wfM;f k:tf yfOu' Ono lv+ yfgf hfqf GxofHofO{ w}u' cgof hg wf/0ff b' . cjn]
Kj+uf hs k'Os]u' ofO{ . dxfnIdL Bof GXof]go laleGg afhf ufhf
k:tf yfOano laz]if cfsif{0f d" u'?of yfgf hfqfof /f}gs laof Rjlg wfM;f ps'Gx
lgb]{zgo ;xfos SjMtfof rM rr xM wof jfhf doh'lk+ dxfnIdL B D'xOs]u' g+ ofO{ . dxfnIdL
yfOu' j Kj+uf k'O{lklgu' Kj+ufof ;Mh'O{ . rM B Dx'nls ;'v ;d[l4 gfkgfk+ ;Gtfg ;'v, eft
rr xM wfOu' tfGqLs dGq vMM;f g+ ;'gf+ y'Os] db'Dx doh'of eft bOu', ;Gtfg db'Dx doh'of
dk'm . t/ j BM Nxfot cn]+ B Kofv+ Nx'O]t tof/ ;Gtfg b}u' hg la:jf; b' .
h' wsf laOu' ;+s]tof ?ko sof tMu' wfMu' g]jf a:tL y'hf]u' hfqfkj{ oSjM b' .
b' . vM Tolnano j ;+s]t lnkf yfOu' af]n j y'hf]u' hfqf kj{t 5u' lnkf d]u'+ofgf tgf j+u'
tfno u+ Kofvgo Rjlk+ Bt Kofv+ Nx'Ou' vM . b' . emLu' ;+:s[lt emLu' w/f]x/ wsf Djfsf to
e}nM Bof g]t[Tjo u0]fBM, j/fxL BM, s'df/L BM dfMu' vg] b' . y'ls+ emL g]jft x] nuo dh';f
l;+Dxf j w'Dxf cn]+ åf/kfnt 5u' yf;+ d]u' yf;o ;' h'O{ .
jgf+ cfqmd0f ofgf Tofsf jMu' Sogf+ tMu' Kofv+
h'u'ln+ vM Tolnu' Kofv+ wof tMu'M wfk' b'M .
k:tf yfou' Hof emj k:tf u'7L+ Gxoflsu'
vM . bln y/of dg'tou' u'7L h';f+ d" u'? leGb'jf
y/of dg' h'O{ . ledbt cfrfh' Gxofsf ys'u'
h'of leGb'jft g+ ledbQ cfrfh'of k'vf{ wsf
cfts+ leGb'jft d" u'? h'of GxofsftMu' vg] b' .
uf]Dx leGb'jft d" u'? h'of Hof emj Gxofsf jg
j wfM;f ;Ldb' . t/ t'Onfn leGb'jf, xs{ gl;+
leGb'jf j b]a|] leGb'jf dbo w'sf+ cf afa'sfhL
leGb'jf d" u'? h'of GXofsf Rj+u' b' .
k:tf yfou' hfqf af]8]of la:s]6 hfqfof
Do] KjfM vlgu' hfqf lnkf d]u' cfsif{0f vM .
dxfnIdL BM g+ gLna/fxLb]jLof 5u' ?k vM .
la:s+ b]aLof d'VoDx b]aL v dxfnIdLM . jx]
sf/0f gLna/fxLB gfk+ :jfk' b'u' j k:tf
yfou' hfqf dxfnIdL BMofyfo ofu' vM wfMu'
b'M . k:yf yfou' al5 jg]j b]of d'Vo d'Vou'
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 17
Rjv+

d'lQmgfy ofqf–$
wL/h cdfTo

lhF yMu' k'nf+u' vF sg] l;w]sf lagf]b u'lnl;+g lutf/ j lrSrfw+u' 8«d;]6\ yfn .
tfd|sf/ h'of kfMjn . jo\sM o]F j+wMTjf kfv]+/ cy]h"an] c+g ;+uLt ;Dd]ng y]+ h'n . uLt j
yMDx+ lt/Ldo\h' gfk+ aMrflwsDx DXofo\do]h' g ;+uLt ;+ud Go]gf+ d]d]lkF Sjyfo\ b]g]+w's'lkF g+
j ofqfo\ ;fd]n h'oflbDx vM . jo\slkF lgDx+ g Gx]n+rfo\sf ‰ofM rfo]sf :jofRjlk+ b"u' h'n .
cg nMla h'ofRj+u' /demd\ bL . lhF yMu' g'uM vF z]ifgf/fo0f 5Dx GXofOk's]dfDx+ cn] yMu'
k|:t't ofgfy]+ jo\sn+ d]F xfnfbLt tof/ h'n . Wo]afof Nofrf db'Dx cy]h'of g'uMd:of;]
yMu' unfof ;M lksof xn – cg d'gfRj+lkGt oMlkGt wfwfy] Sjfu' ,Vjfp+u'
æd}n] k"mn dg k/fP+ of >fk dg k/fP+ ======h] k]o kbfy{t uy]ls Rof, skmL, h";,lao/,gfk
xf];\ d}n] ltldnfO{ r"krfk dg k/fP+===========Æ lXjl:sof ;jf sfo\sfn . dGWofGx rfGxo\l;of
Yj :j/ ;d|ft gf/fo0f uf]kfn+ xfnfM ys'u' lem+GoftfM h"an] ;lS;g æXoflKk Go" Oc/ Æ wsf
tfd|fsf/+ h'F j x] ;M lksof j y]+ Rj+s afnfs+ 5;Mofgf Gx"bF @)&)of leGt'gf yMylklg+ b]5ft .
xfnflbu' vM . gf/fo0f uf]kfnof ;M uy] c+g cy] g æXoflKk Go" Oc/===Æ of xf;MYjan] cg+
lkHjn y]+ Rj+g . jo\sn+ Do]F xfnfRj+gfbLan] xf]6]no\ b]gfRj+lk+ ;sn g]kfnL j ljb]zLto];+
ldvf Uj yMDx lt/Ldo\h' kfv]/ j+gfRj+g . cyx] Gx]nrfo]sf ‰ofMrfo]sf :jjn . cn] Old+; g
lt/Ldo\h'Dx g d';'sofRj+u' :jo\an] jo\slklgu' cy]x] xfnf lhldt g Gx" bF @)&)of leGt'gf
dltgfof n" c+g ;lS;t g aofg ofgfRj+u' y]+ b]5fn .
Rj+ . lagf]b tfd|fsf/ h' g xQfsQfDx+ :jo\an] ;stfSjl5+ wfo]dfn wf;f j @)^(;fnof
x] lx/f] y]+ af+nfDx cn] lt/Ldo\h' eftoft plts+ d;fGtof n" ;lS;t clts+ x] GXofOk'tfo\sn .
NjMDx, lgDxltk' plts+ GXofMlk+ . cg d'gfRj+lk Gx"bF dfg]ofo\ w'g]j+ yy] wfn–æyg emL
ldh+ HofyMt dWo] lh :jDxDx+ vM GxfkfDx Gxo]5\Fb ;sn]+ d'gf Gx"bFof no\tfv';L dfg]ofo\ vg+ lhu"
So+Dx yfo\d?ofDx+ s]za >]i7h' c+g lVjv'bFofDx kfv]+ l5lkF ;snoft leGt'+gf . cfM emL ;sn]+
dx]z k|wfg h' . c+g lnkf lh Go]o\RofbF b'Dx cn] yyMu' Sjyfo\ Bf]+ emf;+ . sGxo\ lemu' Hof‰jMof
tfd|fsf/h' Goo\bF hs k'nfbLDx+ . d]+d]lk+ ld;f vF Go]gfbLt O{gfk ofgf+ sGxo\ ;'yl;of v'tfMno\
ldh+ aMrflwslk+ j Nofo\Dx Nof;]lk+ . lhlkF k]Dx+ b+gf yMyu' dfntfn lysof+gf lb;+ . Gx"bFof Gx"u'
HofyMto\ kfMl;w]sf Old+ yMyu" kfno\\ kk\ Do]+ ;'yo\ Gxfkfnfs sfua]gL3ft gfFof v'l;O jlgu'
j GXof+GXofy] Dx+;+sf Kofv+ Nx'of GXofOk'sn . h'O{ . j v'l;of 5tf vF Gx]y]g] lhF , v'l; lrAofwsf
18 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
x]k]ofgf+ nfnfMy] ;g]+ dHo" . v'l;O byO jgf DjM v'l; vM . sfnLu08ls jfpF;] oRr';] Rj+ . nM
g Nx'O dHo" . nMVjfp+;] cn] tRjs+ nM 5\jfM, Dx+ g Ujf/fUjf/f bfl;jy]+ Rj+s yfxf+Sjfxf+ ld+s af
r'OsfMo+sL oM . cy]h';f xf]z\k"j{s+ nvo\ ;g]+df . jofRj+u' cn] Vjfp+kmo\-:of+y_ g x'O+x'O{ ;+gfRj+g
DjMNx'Odf;f l;yo\Rj+g]df . lkt[of gfdF tk{g j k|lz¢u' v'l;O zflnu|fd Njx+ b}u' yfo\ vM .
laOdflklg+ laoflb;+ . jof lnkf xf]6no\ lnxf+jof lxGb"to] lglt+ zflnu|fd clt+s >¢f+hfMu' Njx+oft
yyMu' dfntfn Hj+gf d'lQmgfy bz{0fofo]u' . eujfg lai0f'of c+z wsfM k'Hofu' rng b' .
joflnkf go\ Tjg]+of+gf lnxf+jg]u' h'O{ .Æ cg v'l;of l;yo\ dfnfM :jnwf;f ck's n'Os]
j}u' lgb]{z Go]gf ;lS;g+ sGx]l;of HofvF k'm . zflnu|fd sfnLu08ls v'l;of hs b}u' 5tf
y'Osn cn] yMylk+lgu' Sjyfo\ Bf]+jg . xfs"u'Njx+ d]d]u' glbO b}dv' .
@)&)of Gx" lbFof ;'yo\ Gxfkfg+ lhlkF c+g YoMlk+ bSjl;+g v'l;of GXof]g];of l;yo\
lty{ofqLt Gx]n+rfo]sf lgTosfo{ l;w]sf cn] Rj+gf kfMNxfltO nM tof VjfMl;n . u'lnl;of+ lkt[
yMyu' dfntfn ldn]of+gf xf]6]nof nMaL d'+jgf . tk{g ofo]dfM wsf :jDx+ ldhFto\ hfs]t l:j6/
sfua]gL3f6o\ k"hfcfhfoft dfMu' Hjn+t hs sldh Tjtf leqL ul~h j kfOG6 dTjt';] nv+
lnsof 5yfo\ to\sn . |d'lQmgfy Bf]oft dfMu' 5\Øf]+ Kofhs Kofsf Dxo\ nM xfMhsof+gf yMlkG;+
Hjn+t emf]nfkGt'/fo\t+' c+g;+ Tjtsf lhlk+ o+s'u' lkt[ tk{gof Hjn+t ;stf+ nKt]of Ajxtfo]
;sn] xf]6]n+ lkxf+jof . Gx]n'jfof No'No' ;sn]+ tofM lkt[oft :d/0fofgf v'l;O r'Osn . lgDx
sfua]lg3f6 kfv]/ j+g]t xf]6]n+ lkxf+hs jofano\ dfF DXofo\g+ lrs'rfof ;kM km]gf 5\of]F Kofsn .
n'vfof lkg] v;'+ e'gfRj+u' h'n . ;lS;g+ yu' cn] n+g]o\ nM xfMofgf+ tk{g lan .
Dxo\ l:j6/ lkmgfg+ jof Bf]+g] hfs]6 lkmgf+tMu'ln+ Olk+ ;lS;g 5sn+ x] ofp+s tk{g
lrs'drfn . nFo\ l;yo l;yo\ zLt+ hfofRj+u'ln+ laOl;w]sn . lh g+ kfOGt GXofgf ul~h 5kfhs
cn] nF b'yO g zLt gfof jfRofjfRof+ Rj+ . lkmgf nvo\ DjNx'O efjofgf+ 5]go\ nv+ Kofsf
knfM 5Lan] r'n'ofM b}y]Rj+ . xf]6]n+ sfua]gL3f6 ?dfn+ 5\of]F x'ofRj+gfan] nfs lgDx dg" lgodsy+
jg]Togf+an] cgof 5u" rs+u' yf;o\ >L d'lQmgfy x] >fWb l;w]sf v'l;O lk08 r'Osjlk+ gfk+ 5Dx
df=la=v+g]bg, j nFof gfk;+ nf . j Ajg]s'lyof a|fDx0foft vg]j+ lhF j}t lhlk+ g lkt[oft tk{g
lnSs Yof]+an] g+of n'vf vfkf ltgf+tMu'ln+ lhF j laOt j}u' . k'/]t db\of lhld;+ g cy]x] tk{g
n'vfof Kjfn :jof . j Ajg]s'ly d':tfË nfufof laTo]gfu' . l5 efUo+ gfknfk lhldt g tk{g
5u" hs vMnf w}y]+ dtLn't . lat l5 k'/]t laoflb;+ lhlkF sf7df8f}+ j}lk+ vM
nFo\ j+gfRjRj+ v'l;O nM GXofgfRj+u' , wd{nfoL l5tMg wsf lhF j kxfl8 aDx"oft
;M tfo]bt . ;M tfu'ln+ v'l;of lnSs Yog wofan] j+ lhtM jo]slk+ dWo] 5Dx Yj lhNnfof
w}u' ;Lbt . j+gfRj+u' nFof hjkfv]/ lxn]j+ l;=l8=cf]= ;fx]j j d]Dx+ lshfDx vM . jo]sMlkGs]
sfua]gL3f6\ vg]bt . lhlkF v'l;of l;yo\ y]g+ . dGof];] l5lSklgu' Hofo]dHo' . l5 yDx wofbL;f
k"j{ lbzf+ klZrd h'of GXofgf+Rj+u' sfnLu08ls hLnf Û wfn . j a|Dx"+ g cy] wfan] c+g lnSs jgf+

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 19
lhF Gxfkfnfs jo]slkGt cfb/efj+ lalGtofgf+ afo\tofM cg la/fsfo]sf yMyu' emf]nft Hj+sf
cn] yMu' vF wofan] jo]sMlkG;g+ lhlk+ :jDx]l;u' xf]6n
] + lkto+sn . lh nFo\ jj+ emf]nfo\ Rj+u' ;km"
Vjfno\ :joflbn cn] lhldt g lalGt ofgf Ho' lnsof Nxflt+ Hjgf j+gf . d'lQmgfy df=la=of
wsf ln;M laOsf ltlg+ a|Dx+" dfg]h'n . l;=l8=cf]= d"nv ' fo\ y]g+] t/ jlbF Gx"bF @)&) h'of drfM .
g Ho' wfan] dn]h" j lhF lk08aLt a|Dx" vo]afHof lh n'vfo\ b+ jMu' v+sf 5Dx dg" jof lhtM yf}F
g bt wsfM lhlkF no]tfof . rflndv' wfo]j+ lhF j}t NxftLRj+u' yDx+ Rjo]u'
cn] lt/Ldo\h' j dn]h'+ sfrfsfrf+ ældqagsf] u'kmfÆ gfFof ;k"mof b'gR+] j+u' kfgfo\
5];+ tk{gofo]dfM wsf xMu' Hjn+t k'mSskmfSs df=la=of gfF j yfo\sf cfvMUjt ofsgofsg+
lnsof 5uM tUju' Ajxtfo\ ldn]oft . t5\j, Rjof j}t nMNxfgf+ Yj ;k"m nfOa]l| /O toflb;+
xfdf]M, hfsL alh, s]/f, lg:nfdl/,£of]sl:t wof . j dg" g Ho' wsf sfo\wo' w] g' j+] j+gf5\jof .
bSj+ Njfs\5\ofgf+ lh+ j dn]h'F lgDxl;g tk{g cn] lh xyf; k+ nfM l5gf+ j+gf .
aLt slk08 Ujf/ft ufSs lhDx+ lt/Ldo\h'F sfua]gL sfnLu08lsof l;yo\nfu'
bo]sn . a|Dx"+g Gxfkfnfs lhtMlg lk08 aLs]t a;:6ko\ lhldt d'lQmgfy jg]+t kLsn . c+g
lhDx tfkfMafHof, tfkfMaHo] lg;] sof lbj+ut 5u" Tjfytno\ lyly cfsf/ cfsf/ k|sf/of
h'Ow'slkF j lt/Ldo\h'of lbj+utlklgu' gfF tuM lruMu' zflnu|fdt ldOt AjoftMu' vgf+
sfo]sf >f4of lk08t 5uM 5uMofo]sf Ajxtfo\ lhF g lrs\rfu' 5uM Gofgf+ . j zflnu|fdoft
5fo]sn . lhF 5fo]l;w]j k'/f]lxt h'Dx+ a|Dx' g k"hfs'ly k'Hofgftof .
v'l;O r'Os]lan . dn]h'oft g jo]sf lkt[to\u' eltrfn+sf lDxuM uofMj}u' hLk y]x]+ hfMu'
gfFsfo]sf lk08 aL l;wo\sn . cn] a|fDx0foft d]u' hLkt xn . lemDx+ lemDx+ uo]sf d]u' nFk'
blIf0ff wsfM Gof;, Gof; bfF blIf0ff b]5fgfano\ o+sn . d''lQmgfyoft lgu" Ajo\ ynfMtu' vM
j d':tfËof k'/f]lxt h'Dx+ vo\a|Dx" g no]tfn . Rj d':tfË j Sj d':tfË . Rjo]kfv]/ cGgk"0f{
lhlkF lgDx]l;u' g OR5f k"j+g . Rjfk'dfM-lxdfn >[+vnf_ uMjlgu' nfuf vM wfM;f
sfua]gL3f6of sfnLu08ls lty{:yno\ Sj d':tfË Bf] bz{gofo]t jlgu' nfuf vM . cg+
dn]h' j lhDx lkt[to\t tk{g laOl;wano\ d]lk+ Rjfk'dfMt tfkfs lgnlu/L gfFof Rjfk'dfM afFnfs
3f6\of Rjo]kfv] jgf+Rj+u' lhlkF :jDx+ g Oldt vg]+ b' . lgnlu/L cGgk"0f{ Rjfk'dfMof bSjl;a]
lnnfs]t sfrfsfrf+ knfMl5gf Olk+gfk y]s + j+gf . b]kfkfv]/of lnkfu' Rjfk'dfM vM .
:jDx]l;g+ knfM tkfnfofgf Wjb'an] ;/:jtL b]uMof lhlkF hLko\ Rj+Rj+ t+uofMj+gf Rj+u' hLk+
No'g+ ] y]g+ . b]uMrflxnf lzIffof clwi7fqL b]jLof lgnlu/Loft b]kf kfv]/nfsf yf+Sjf+j+u' Njx+rf
bz{g ofgf . j b]uMoft l;d]G6L+ bo]sftMu' UjUj nfoftu' nF k'nfM 5u" 3f}lt lnkf 5yfo\
b' . Bf]of Dx+lws wf;f 9nf}tof vM . ;lS;g+ lbsn . j yf;+ g 5u" Rjo\nfu' kxf/o\ d'lQmgfy
Bf]oft lkg];+ bz{ofo]ws +' f xf]6n
] o\ lnxf+jgf . Rof b]uMb' . cfM c+g yf+jg+]t Njx+of oSj TjfyMt
Tjg]wj' + z]ifgf/fo0f+ lhldt ;f+lu|nf xf]6n ] o\ rlR5 uo]dfM . Gofl;j+lglkG;g+ yMu' Dx+of larfofo\dfM .

20 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
Gofl;jg] an] ;f;M Nxfo] yfs'of jn ls Kofh dˆo';] sQ'5uM j ld:to\ lgkf Nxfof AjxMSj;+
GXoGXo+ a'n'x'+ a'n'x'+ jg]df . Tofg'of ;g]dkmt wf;f ofSjo\ts k]6Lsf]6+ lxgf+ Dx+ 5Dx ;lR5 j Rofu'
t+uo]u' lbgflbgf+ jg]df M cy]ofgf g dlhnwf;f lx6L+of kljqhn+ xfo]sf DjNx't . Djnf ;lS;g+
yf+dj+;] lnxf+jg]dfM wsf nFhjf z]ifgf/fo0f+ Nx't t/ Dxo\ Vjfp+u' nMnflo wsfM g UofM .
Wjfy'sf wfMan] HofyMldh+ 5Dx j :j+Dx HofyM 5fo]wf;f+ clts Vjfp+u' nMv+ ;lR5 j RofwfM
ld;flk+ df]6/afO{s+ j+g]u' h'n . cn] k]+u ttMu' DjNx'O w}u' Nx'lt k"lGx+an] y]+ dv' Û k'; df3+
afO{sto\ o+sn . cn] drf j tlwslk+ ;sn]+ t+ xfOu' nM lx6L+Kjfn+lg;]+ a+o\yLs 5:jf h'of a/km
uu+ yf+jg . d'lQmgfy Bf] :joDe'gfy eujfg y]+ l9sf Rj+lg wfu' g Gogf+ . cy] Vjfp+u' nvo\
Rj]nfM , :joDe'O l;a]g c+g oSj Njx+of Tjfy af+nfs DjlNxt yfs' cyh'of lhF g af+nfs
b' . :joDe' u'O+ Rjsfo\nfu' h'of TjfyMof hj j DjlNXj dvgf 5\Øf]+ 5uM nv+ xfo]sf ;lR5 j
b]kf kfv]/ ttMdf+u' oSj b';f d'lQmgfyof l;dft Rofwfn+ eltrf eltrf xfo]sf x't't' Ajfo+jgf+
db' ttMuu' j lrlrrfuMu' Njx+rf b' ,cy]x];t'+ bSj lxl6of nv+ xfo]sf DjNx'of dgoft ;Gtf]if
:joDe' TjfyMgfkgfk+ a'¢ d'lt{ j lrefMt 'b' . ofgf+ . d]lk+ ;lS;t g+ cy] x] nf h'n h'Olg Û
t/ c+gwf;f Tjfyto\ hj j b]kfkfv]/ Njx+rft ;lR5 j Rofwflx6L DjlNXj l;wo\j+ d'lQmgfy
b]5'gf tlu+ tlu+ ldn]ofgf r}To y]+ 5f]t]{g Bf] bz{g k'hfof lglt+ lhldu' 5Yjn+ cg+ b]uno\
bo]sftMu' j :j:j+jg]an] GXofOk'u'ln+ Tofg'drfM le8 h'n . kfn+kfofgf dj+;] duft, cy]ho' f b]uMof
cn] ;f;M Nxfo\dkmof k"m+k"m+ dj . af3f}lt t+ lns;+Rjgf lt/Ldo\h' j dn]h' k'hfHjn+ ;stf+
uofM Rjo\ y]g ck's x] . afO{so\ Rj+gfj+lk k]Dx+ tofRj+tn] xfsg+ lhF xfsg+ j x] ;k"m 5kfM lnsof
ofp+s Gxfkfnfs y]+sfRj+g] w'+sn . k'n]j+ b]uM tof . k'hfe'nL k'hfofo]t bSj to\l;wo\j Olk+
g v+g]bt . b]uMof GXof]g];+ arflwsMu' lgu" k'v" lgDx+ nfOgo\ Rj+gf Bf] k'Hofgf lkg]j+ n . cn] lh
b' . wd{s'08 j kfks'08 gfFof . Gxfkfnfs b]uMof g ;k"m Hjgf b'gj] gf+ d'lQmgfy eujfgoft bz{g
No'+g];+ kxf/of Rjsf+ s'xf+jofRj+u' nM ;lR5 ofj+gf . b]uMof b'g] pln le8 dbo\ w+s' n . cy]ho' f
j RofuM l;+xof 5\of]]+of 9nf}6of+lxlt+ xfofRj+u' af+nfs w}ot{ ofM Bf] bz{g ofo]vg+ . by'Onfs
kljq nv+ DjNx'O k'mlklg+ DjNx'O dk'mlklg+ Nxf arflwsu' eujfg gf/fo0f cn] hj j b]kfo\ lgDx
t'lt l;nf 5of]+ hs g Kofsf DjNx'Ou' efjofO . nIdL j ;/:jtL b]jL tof d'lQmgfy :j¿kof d"lt{
jof lnkf wd{k'v'nL jof DjNx'O ofgfRj+u" v+gf bz{gfofo\ v+gf yOt wGo tfo]sf .
t/ kfks'08 wfu'lnwf;f 5Dx+ dg"t dv+gf . kfk c+g Bf]of kfMnft lgDx af}¢ wd{dfg]ofOlk+
wfn ls plnUof vlg+sf . cy]h'of j kfkk'v'lnO ld;fto\t k"hfl/gL dwf;] cflg+ wfOu' vlg+ .
DjMNx'lk+ v+g]db' t/ d;Ls dv+s ;lk'nf d]d]yfo\ gf/fo0f b]uno\ lxGb"of lyly Bf]of b]uno\
kfkofOlk+ oSj b', wd{ofOlk+ DXjhs . lyly hfltt b};f c+g 5yfo\ hs af}¢wdf{jlnof
lhlkF cg y]g]j+ Gxfkfnfs kfn+kf DjlNXju'ln cflg+ wflk+ kfnftM v+gf . Olk+ kfnfM hs vM;f
nuo\h'n . c+g DjdNx';] dHo" wsf ldhFt nF d"nk"hf/LwfM;f lxGb' a|fDx0f v+;ftla lgTok"hf
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 21
ofo]w'g]j b]uMof kmno\ ˆot'gf+ bz{gfly{lkGt b' . cg+ Sj;of :jo]an] Njx+sflk+ OtfMdt y]
l;Gx l6s]u' cn] kf7ofo]u' hs ofo]u' k/Dk/f ld+Tof 5Tof x'n'n'+====lkxf+jofRj+u' v+g] b' . j
b' . cy]h'of lhF ældqagsf] u'kmfÆ;km" Bf]oft x] ld+TofjofRj+u' yfo]oft HjfnfdfO{ wsf bz{g
lyhs lysf,Bf] efluofgf+ lkxf+jof kmno\Rj+gf cf/fwgf ofOu' c+gof rng h'ofRj+g t/ c+g Bf]
wfld{s kf7ofgfRj+Dx Nofo\rfDx kl08t v+gf eflkof :jfF, cIftf+-hfls_ j w]af 5fo\s] dAo" .
j}s] Go]gf l5 ygofDx k"hf/L vMnf y]+ < cIftf :jfF 5fn ls 5"+rfto\ xtfMofoM xF . w]af
cn] j kl08t+ lh k"hf/L dv' , lhDx ca' 5fo\t lkg]+ n'vfo\ Rj+u' ls:tL 5fOu' . pso\
h' vM jo]s gs\ltlg+ 5u" xyf;of Hof jof 5]+ x] ;lS;g Goftsf, lemtsf j Gotsfof gf]6\t
emfn . wsf +lhtM sg+ cn] lhF jo]sMof gfF >Wbfefj+ 5fgf+M lnxf+jgf .
Go]gfan] sfo\Dx+ ca'of gfF sgf+ wfn –kl08t j Hjfnfd'vL wfu' ld+of hM Njx+sflkof by';+
s[i0fk|;fb ;'j]bL . lkxf+jofRj+u' ld+of hMoft j}1flgs Zff:qof sy+
cn] lhF ;k"mof b'g] …k+= >L s[=k|=;'a]bLoft pu' yf;o\ UofF;of e08f/ cyf{t UofF;of vfgL
Yj ;k"m b]5fgf+ Úwsf g]kfnL+ Rjof lemtsf bf+ h'OdfM Û d'lQmgfy Bf]of af; j k|s[lt+ hfgfRj+u'
kl08toft blIf0ff nMNxfgfan] jF lhtM l5u' d':tfË nfuf g]kfMof 5u' cd"Nou' w's" vM .
dgf]sf+Iff k'/o\ h'Odf wsf cflz{jrg Nxft . wfld{s vFof kfv]/ lgtf vFt yg GXoy+g]
lhlk+ ;lS;g Bf] k'Hofl;wan] ;'yof lemtfMO{ s""tMofgfRj+gf . j vFF yy] vM, Gxfkf Gxfkf nf
h'n . cn] z]ifgf/fo0f+ lhlk+ ;sn]+ gfktof b]uM d'lQmgfyo\ j+lglk+ jg]GXof]g] x] yM l;O GXof]
jo]s lskfM sfo]sn . jof Gxfkf yMylkG; x] Djfgf Rj+an] l;O w'+sf ofOu' sfhlqmoft
yfo\yf;o\ lskfMt sof dRj+u' dv' . cg+lnkf 3M;', nTof, v'nfM, blsnf j lgbFltly of+gfltlg
Sjo\ lnxf+jg]t Rjo\sn . j}u' vo\+ wfwfy] lhlk+ d'lQmgfyof ofqf j+lg . 5fo\wf;f+ pan]of clts+
;sn]+ ,j}t GXog] dtM;] lhlk+ jg] d;M cy]h'of s7Lg j tfkfM gfkgfk+ kxfb uof=Mjg]dfM. cfMof
j}u' ln;]ln;] dj+;]dufM . j+ lhldt c+g yf;o\of nF y]+ dv', cku' g dv' . j+lk+ lnxf+jo] km}nf
lyly vFof j0f{gofof+ Sjo\kfv]/ o+sfRj+g . jj+ dkm}nf w}u' x'lg+ yMu' Dx+ bosg+ ;Lgfj+Dx+ y]+
x] df};d lxnf u'An]+ v;' jy] Rjl+g+ u'An]+ jf sfhlqmofof Hof km'Ss l;w]sf ylklgu' 5]+hMlkF
j}y+] Rj+lgu' . lgefMg bGg+ Tjof jgf+Rjgfyfo\ gfk afofMltlg DjfDjfs+ x] j hLjg d'Qmofgf
hhdf+ h'Ou' GXofOk'u' k|s[lt pnfMRj+u' d':tfË y]+ ofgf ltlg+ d'lQmgfyo\ jlg+ -nFo\ jj+ l;tM
yfo\ vM . 5yfo\ kmlxnf SjYofu' nF afnf jn cyfj Nof+jj]u' l:ylt ldn]dh'of c+g yftMwf;f
cg+ lhldt Sjt\o+sn . j yf;o\ HjfnfdlGb/ lnkfof vF 5' vM 5' vM wsf yM l;O GXof]j+ x]
wfu' b]uMy]+ Rj+u' 5vf 5]+ jn . lkg]+ 5Dx j d]lk+ yMu' sfhlqmofof bSj k'mSs Hof l;w]sf ltlg
leIf't bgf+Rj+u' b' . Old;+ lhldt nfsf+ Tjtsf jlgu' h'ofRj+u' Go]gf+ t}u' vM_ .
b'g]+ HjfnfdfO{ bz{g ofs]t b'5\jn,cg+ g cflg+ -yf}+ sGx]o\ df]6/ufl8+ j+;f+ Nof+Yof+
x] kfnfMt . b'g]+ Vo+'Vo'+;] Rj+u' yf;o\ ufM5uf h'Oan] GofGx" j k]rfM-$/ft_ dfM . uy] ls

22 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
o]F yf;+ a]lg ahf/o\ axlg+ y]lg+ cg+ rlR5 lkxf+jof lgDx+ d:to\ laof . j ;k"mt sflk+ d:to;\
afo]Rj+g]df-!/ft_ . sGx]s'Gx" ;'yo\ a;+ j+gf lht lGxnf no\tfgf+ s]g+ ,Dx't+" WF; F F 5'+ g dwfM .
sfua]gLO ;GofMsfOno\ y]lg cg rlR5of af;\ 5];
+ + lkxf+jof an] yDx+ Rjof lks\oft}u' k]kfM ;k"mt
h'O-@/ft_ . s+;-:jGx"of lbgo\ d'lQmgfyo\ y]lg+_ Og]t+ xofu' vM . cg :jyfo\ Og]+ g v+g . ;k"m
j ;'yo\ a;+ lnxf+ jof 3f;f wfu' yf;o\ afo\ Og]wg' j] + ;sn]+ d'gf+Rj+yfo\ b'xf+jg+ T] o+agfan] ;sn]+
Rjlg+-#/ft_ k]Gx"of lbFof axgL kf]v/fo\ afo\ Rj+g] lkxf+jn . yMyu' emf]nft HjHj+sf Gofl;o+sn . j
dfM-$/ft_. GofGx"+ bt\ls o]Fo\ y]lg+ . nF jj+ lDxu a;+ Sjxf+ju} ' :ofª wfMyfo\ y]g+ . cg
cn] xfsg+ phf]u' d]u' vF 5tf GXoyg], :ofpof ;'sl' 6 d]yfo\ l;a]g efM bFuh ' o' f bSjl;g+
ef/tof agf/; sfzL dxfMBf] bz{g ofMjlg+lk+ Gofo]t k;Mklts+ jg . lhDx lt/Ldo\h' j
sfzL+ lnxf+dj;]+ d;L tn c+g x] Rjgf+ yMu' k|f0f dn]h' ylklg ynfMlkGt d'lQmgfyof k|;fb gfkgfk+
Tofu ofo\t hs c+g j+lg -d'Qm h'Ot_ w}u' vF g sf]zn ] L Og]dfM wsf 5å+ld+s Gofgfxn . d]dl] k+G;
Go]gftof . y'lk+ lgtf Go]gfvF vM cfM j Gxfkfof cy] GofMgf xMu' g v+gf .
k'nf+u' Go]gf+vFt rLsf 5\jo\ . :ofª+ a;\ duo]s';] lhldt cg+ g
lhlk+ c+g yf;+ lnxf+jj+ rs+u' a'+Vono\ Gof;]o+sn, af3f} lt Sjo\ jofan] hf]d;f]dof
Yog . a+'of lar+ knfMl5gf d':tfËof 5u" af+nfu' s};ËSofDk wfMu' ahf/o\ y]+sn . c+g …pRr
/]i6'/]G6o\ o+sn . bSj+ d]ro\ ˆot'sn . ;'y+lg;] lzv/ ;}Go ;fvfÚ gfFof 5u" tMw+u' g]kfn ;]gfof
nFo\ h'h'+ lhlk+ ;Sn]+ Tofg' j go\lkTofrfof Aof/]s v+gf . j Aof/]so\ xln+of lyly ;]gfto\t
nvt\/fg h"u' h'n . c+g ˆot'gf emf;' n+sf . tflnd laOu' yfo\ wsfM 5Dx]l;g+ s+g . chfu'
lhlk+ Rj+gf yfo\ Sjf Sjfu' Rof xn . Rof TjTj+ vF l;ofM lhtM g]kfM b]M of uj{ tfn . 5fo]wf;f+
‰ofn+ lkg]+ :jofan] j yfo\ 6'l/i6 :kt h'ofM g]kfM b] lrw;f+ xln+of lyly b]z+ tflnd sfMj}u'
c+g lyly ljb]zof kfxfFto\u' x"n x] v+gf . pan]of Aof/]s g b'an] b]M lrw;f ttwFu' b]Moft g
O{M 6'l/i6 l;hg vM . j yf;+ Rj d':tfË jlgu' j tflnd laOyfo\ g]kfMof hf]d;f]do\ b"u'h'ofRj+g .
cg+ lnxf+jof j yf;o\ afo\ Rj+lgu'h'of af+afnfu' 3f}l5 lt j ahf/ rflxsn . c+g jfp+rf+
xf]6]nt Olnln+ v+g]b' . xf]6]nof gfF t oSj b' , lg;]sof lab]lz ;fdfg ts g Gofo]u' k;Mt
xf]6]n d':tfË, g]kfn, Pe/]i6, cGgk"0ff{,l/NofS;\, b' . kf]v/f+ cg+ l;;fa';ft j lGxyoft dfMu'
l;hg , 6'l/i6 Eofln, xf]6]n /]i6'/]G6 P08 af/ dLx}u' h'ofRj+g . c+g xftahf/ y]+ g Rj+ .
cflb OToflb gfFof xf]6]nt b', o]Fof 7d]no\ y]+ . dg"t g x"nd"n v+g]b' x. lhlk+gfk emfoflbDx
c+gof n" :j:j+ ;'yl;of Hofgf+ g 6]an ' 5Dx+ HofyMDx ld;f kf]v/fof ;Gtnfl; Go]uMlt
to]xn . lkTofu' KjfM hfo]s go\wg' j] + 5emf Gofgf+ lhlk+ ;lS;t g 5uM 5uM elk wsf Ogf+
emf;"ns + ] lan . j Ono\ lhF yMu' emf]nfo\ lgkfM laoflbn . ;Gtnfl; rfs';]Rjgf+ ;fM y]+ jo\s
/lu+g lskfMx+gftu' …;kgfÚ gfFof cFuh |] L j g]kfnL+ le+ g'uMn+ Sj;fDx+ y]+ tfn .
yDx+ Rjofu' drf pkGof; lnsof . cn] /]i6'/G] 6+ qmdzM
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 23
Oltxf;
g]jf ;dfho conf
j YjFof e"ldsf
?sld0fL >]i7

conf YjF+ oft ljZjo\ nfu' kbfy{of rng cfM g+ uf+ ufd] j k'nf+lk j'/f a'l/ t b'
ju{o Yofsf tMu' 5u' emf]n kbfy{ -Liquar_ yfo\ GXofgf Rj+u' b' . g]jf ;dfho hs dv'
vM . k|foM xlndo k'ms+ b]zo co\nf YjF of hghflt /fO{ lnDa' u'?ª kl/jf/]g+ co\nf YjF
k|rng ztfAbLof}+ lg;]+ 5]nfa'nf h'of Rj+u' vF oft yMlkG;+ hs Tjlgu' dv' ;+:sf/, wd{, sd{
Oltxf;o Ajg] b'. co\nf YjFof k|rng bsn] sf08 gfk+ gv rvM kf;f kfx'gf ;Tsf/ of
Gxfkf+ ol;of dxfb]z vM ;f plsg+ rLg b]z nflu g co\nf YjF lgle{s sy+ 5]nf Rj+u' vM .
YjF co\nf bo]lsu'ln Ozf k"j{ &))) bF GXoj+ ljZjo g+ osf] yf;] co\nf oft kf;f kfx'gf
x] bof Rjg] w'+s'u' vF Oltxf;+ l;O b' . pu' ;Tsf/ j kj{o conf YjF oft 5]nf Rj+u'
jvt] x] co\nf YjF bo]s]t hfsL j kmnk"mno\ vFg]b' . yy] x] k|mfG;o\ tMtM w+u' /fhlso Ejo
c+u'/ oft lkmgf -Wjlusf Fermentation_ jf Jofkfl/s x] yMh'Odf ;j{ ;fwf/0f of kfl6{
bo]lsu' k|rng h'O{ w'+snu' l;Ob' . cg+ lnkf ts g+ co\nf dGtls j Ejo of dxTj bOdv'
kl;{ofo\ O{zf k"j{ %$)) bF GXoM conf 5]n] wfOu' . k|To]s kfl6{ x}l;ot sy+ co\nf YjF of
w'+s' b' . cy] x] OlhK6, lu|;, /f]d, ef/t cflb 5]nfj'nf h'ofRj+u' l;Ob' . co\nf 5u' tfut
yf;o\ co\nf YjF oft 5]nf xo] w'+sn O;f of jf;M gfk+ ;+qmd0f k/h}ljs -Antibeotic_
k"j{ $#!–#$& GxoM lg;]+ nf co\nf YjF of g vM wsf O=;+= !&@! kfv] k|mfG;of lkG;+
dfqf ldn]ofgf Tjg]u' oft;f jf;Mof Hof jM gfnf tMu' b' . Yj vFo\ k|mfG;of 5u' 36gf
wsf cn] :jf:Yo le+s]t Hjf jM wsf lu|; k'li6ofgf Jo'u' b' . !&@! kfv] blIf0f k|mfG;of
of ljåfg h]gf]kmf]g -Zenophon_, Kn]6f] -Pleto_ df;]{N; wofu' yf;o Kn]u -Plague_ /f]u of
cn] lxkf]qm]6/ -Heppocrate_ lkG;+ g+ yMlklg+u' dxfdf/L h'of lGxy+ ån+åMnf nfjfl/; nf; t
ljrf/ ljof lbOu' vM;f g]kfno\ lnR5ljsfn clGtd ;+:sf/ ofo]t dg"t sd h'of ;d:of
GXoMlg;]_ YjF co\nf of k|rng h'of Rj+u' h'n cn] pu' On] Hofg ;hfFo kmof Rj+lk
cfo'{j]{bo\ hs dv' 3/]n' Jojxf/] g+ co\nf KoDx s}lb t b' . Oldt Yj ;+:sf/ of Hof
YjF oft dfqf l5 hs k|of]u ofgf :jf:Yooft lhDdf ljp;f ;/sf/+ b08 ljof Rjg] Djfos
eL+sf tOu' hs dv' zl//] ug+ b'wfM h'of Dx, yMyMDx x] y'lkg+ kf/ h'of jlgO wsf ljrf/
Nxf, t'lt :ofgf Rj+ yfo\ conf Sjfsf dfln; ofgf Oldt Yj Hof lhDdf ljn gfk+ Oldt Hof
ofo]u' rng k/+k/f lg;]+ GXofgf Rj+u' b' . Yj jf+nfs oft;f s}b dfkmL ljOu' g+ cfZjf;g

24 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
ljn . s}lbto\;+ ;x;| l:jsf/ ofgf nf; t ;+:sf/ gvM rvM hfqf kj{ hs dv' l/ltl/jfh
clGtd ;+:sf/ of Hof wdfwd ofgf o+sn . ;+:sf/ ;+:s[lt ;+ g+ lgle{s 5]nfj'nf h'ofRj+u'
b]zo /f]u tgfjg . Olk+ s}lbnf emg NJxgf b' . yy] 5]lnu' co\nf YjF k|foM k'ms+ g]jf gfk+
aMnfgf jn Oldt+ /f]u+ dlyp . Yj vFgf Oldt hghflt lklgg+ yMyMu' 5]F x] yMlklgu' HofvF
Hof laplk+ sd{rf/Ltnf b+u h'n . Olds] :jof dfSsf] hs O{ JoMoft ldn]ofgf bo]sLu'
Gog–l5lk+ uo]h'of yy] aMnfgf Rj+u' < lold;+ vM . t/ yf}+sGx] ljb]zof k|efj+ j 5]F 5]F bo]lsu'
ofpFs Hjfkm ljn vM lhldt TjFg]t ljOu' k|yf tgfjgf Rj+u' b' . t/ uf+ ufd] j k'nf+u'
confvo lhld;+ nfefof /; tof Tjgfu' vM ;+:sf/ b' lkGyfo\ cfg+ 5]F 5]F x] bo]lsu' rng
y's]+ lhldt an bof lhld;+ Hof ;'yf+nfs] k"mu' blg . pkTosfo\ k|foM ckf]l;g bo]s]u' dofo]
gfk+ lhldt /f]u+ g lyO dk'mu' vM wfn . cn] w'+sn . u'Dx u'Dx l;g+ hs u'7L k"hf cflboft
k|mfG;oflkG; g+ j co\nf k|of]u ofgf :jn dbo]s dufMu' Yj+, conf bo]s]u' ofMgL Tjg]u'ln
vMu' h'n . cn] nf k|mfG;oflkG; j co\nf of wfn;f k/+k/fof lylt :jof g+ osf] h'of
gf+ x] kmf]/ lyK; ckm e]lguf/ -Four Thieves jofRjgu' b' . Gxfkfof lkG; yMu' zl//oft
of Venegar_ wsf gf+ 5'gfljn . pln hs dv' Njo]s dfqfl5 hs jf;M sy+ 5]lnu' cf yf}+sGx]
s}lbtot dflkmljn gfk+ k|mfG;of /flhlso nfu' jf;M y]+ cdn ckf] bofjn . y's] yf}+sGx]
lg;]+ ;j{;fwf/0f of kfl6{ ef]ho Yj co\nf dtjfnL hghflt, g]jfM t :jofg ckf] Gxfkf
dbo]s dufMu' h'of jg . x/]s ef]ho\ Yj ;+sL0f{ h'of Rjlk j|Dx' If]qL tfufwf/L ckf]
co\nf tMlhs 5]nfj'nf h'of Rj+u' b' . k|mfG; lkoSs8 h'of jof Rj+u' b' . conf YjFof ;jfM
oflklg Tofg'n+s]t confvo nfef of lt y" jn] Tjt] dk'mlk+ h'of jn . Gxfkf hghflt j
Sjfsf tof Tjg]u' rng cfM g b' . g]jfM of Psflwsf/ lrh yf}+ ;j{hfltof clwsf/
g]kfno co\nf rng lnR5jLsfn bofjn . Yj cfw'lgs ;dfh j ljb]zof k|efj
GXojlg;] 5onf Rj+u' l;Ob' . rLg gfk g]kfof of lnRjM vM .
pQ/L l;dfgf :jfgf Rj+u' j Gxfkf+ lg;] rLg t/ yf}+ ljZjo g]kfof lrgfl/ x] g]jfM ;dfh
gfk :jfk' bof Rj+u' yfo\ vM . lgu'ln+ b]z gfk+ hghltof ;+:s[lt, l/ltl/jfh ;+:sf/, snf
lrs'u' yfo vM . cn] g]kfof pQ/L efu lrlgof g;fM Tj;fM e]ife"iff cflb kfv[]+ ljof Rj+u' b';f
;+:s[lt of k|efj gfk :jfgf Rj+u' hghflt y'lk lrhoft ljZj+ pRrsf]6L sy+ g+ gfnf Rj+u'
/fO{, lnDa', u'?ª, tfdfª, z]kf{ cflb vM ;f Olk+ b' . n'd+s] jxMu' v+ j+u' O @)!! l8;]Da/
gfk pkTosfof hghflt /}yfg] g]jft g+ :jfgf dlxgfo\ cd]l/sfof ;dfrf/ ;+:yf l;PgP g+ yMu'
Rj+u' b' . hghfltoft dtjfnL wsf wfOu' vM . 6«fen l/kf]6{o ljZjo pTs[i6 %) k]o kbfy{of
t/ yfo j ;+:sf/ gfk+ df};d of jftfj/0f of gf+ ljpu'ln g]kfof 3/]n' conf g+ b'YofMu' vM ;f
x'lg g]jftg+ dtjfnL ju{o\ b'Yofgf Rj+u' vM . cflwsfl/s ?k+ @)!@ cui6 !! tfl/vo\ hs
ps]+ g]jfMto]u' hLjg z}lnofkgo\ co\nf YjF l;=Pg=P= -CNA_ g+ pu' gf+ ck8]6 h'u' 3f]if0ff
of rng rNtL k/fk"j{sfn lg;]+ x/]s Hof vF ofMu' vM . y'ls+ g+ l;Ob' g]jfMof g;f Tj;f g+
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 25
ljZjo pTs[i6 h'Ou' ;f}efUo r"nfu' h'n . d]u' conf j YjF of tflh Sjo ljof y]+ b' .
5u' yMu' cg'ej gf+ nf nf]ddg O=;+ !(*)÷*! conf le+u' b';L ofu' bo]lsu' vM, d]u' hfsL
tfso 5Dx hd{g 6'l/i6, j/f]j/ g]kf jof Rjlgu' ofu' cy] x] kmnk"mnofu' g+ bo]s]u' ofM . co\nf
gfk nfgf Rjgfu' vM joft g]jfM t]ou'5]+ bo]sfu' le+u' Gxfkf+u' oft d";M conf wfOu' vM;f d]u'
conf t;s+ ;fM tfn. cn] j+ emLyfo\ conf Gxfkf sof tMu' sMoft xfg+ d;nf tof lnkf
sfo]u' , YjF y'Ou', gfk+ conf oft Gxfkf+ bo]lsu' sfOu' oft k'Osf tMu' wfOu' vM . y'u' conf
-sM_ Tok y'Ou' hfsL b';L of dfqf d;nf cflb Gxfkf+u' :jof erf sd;n h'O{ u' vM . d]u' conf
oft jf+nfs Wjfy'Osf bo]s]u' ljlw gfk+ ;o\sn . sofwf]vg] -lnsfo_ w'+sf xfg+ ljro d]u' yn
lnkf 5]F lnxfF jg]t j+ yg emL;+ 5]n]u' conf kmof lnsfOu' conf lnnf conf wfOu' rng
sfo]u' jftf, kmf]l;, xf;L, u'n', gfk+ Yj bo]s]t b' . y'u' conf lgMsM:jMs hs nM tofsfOu' vM .
dfMu' dgfk' cflb Hjgfjg plnhs dv' conf conf le+s d" ;M jo]s sfo]u' j sd;n ofgf
oft sMy'Ot dfMu' dgf -5j dgf, hfsL dfgf_ sfo]u'ln nMof kfv :jof jlg . le+u' d";M jo]s
g+ bo]s]u' ;osf jg . y's] g l;Ob' g]jfM to]u' s8f h'Os sfo]t nM $÷% hs tof softMu'
conf YjF of dlxdf tMlhu' vM . conf ld+ lyOjn] Xjf/f Xjf/f+ RofO{ . jx] conf
g]jf hfltof l/ltl/jfh ;+:sf/ ;+:s[lt hfqf &÷* sMnM tof softMu' conf ld+lyOsf RofO{
kj{ gvM rvM cflb;+ hs dv' k"hfljlw ts+ dv' t/ l5k] h"u' sM h'n;f nu] h'of Rjlg -u'h'+
co\nf YjF lglj{jfb 5]nf Rj+u' b' . g]jf ;dfho sfOu' . $÷% sM hs tMu' conf osf] Tjg]
b'g] ;gftlg af}4 jf lxGb' j}lbs wdf{g';f/ kmOdv' ckf] h'nls 5flQ lxO;]Rjlgu' vM .
tflGqs k"hfljlw ckf] 5]nf a'nf b' . Yj tflGqs YjF of tfhL d'Vo % u' vM .
ljlw k"hfljlw k"hf hs dv' ;+:sf/ g+ Gxofsf -!_ ef} YjF y'lsoft h'lt YjF g wfO . Yj
Rj+u' b' . Yj ljlw k+rdsf/of :yfg x/]s YjF kf]s Togf tMu'ln nM dtM;] Kjso /;o h'of
k"hfljwL;+ b'Yofsf Rj+u' b' . k+rdsf/] conf jf Rj+u' lt :jo+sf sfOu' vM Yj YjF rfs'O . t/
Yj+ nf, ªf v]F j cf] Yj Goftf clgjfo{ b'Yofgf TjFg]t 5olnu' dof k'hfof nflu hs 5]lnu'
Rjlg . tflGqs k"hfo\ e}/j j e}/lj cyjf lzj vFg] b' .
zlQm, lk7 u0f b]jL u0f cflb b'Yofgf Rjlg . -@_ clh YjF Yj YjF kf]so Gxfkf+u' nM tof
Yj k+rdsf/ oft k~r tTj k[YjL, jfo', cfsfz, sof tMu' d'lQ YjF g wfO{ . Yj YjF oft pRrsf]6L
cUgL j hn tTjof k|lts sy+ gfnftMu' h'n . of sy+ gfnftMu' b' . Yj Gxfkf+ lnsof tMu' sto
Yj Gofu' x] ef}lts tTj lnkf k|s[lt x] ljlng xfg+ nM tof sfOu' Yj oft axtf Yj+ wfOu' vM
h'of jlgu' vM . cy] x] emLu' zl// g+ k~rtTj+o Yj lnkf ofu' Yj+ d"ltu' y]+ h'Odv' eof sdzn
lglxt h'of Rj+u' lnkf k+r tTjo\ x] ljlng h'of h'O{ .
jlgu' j:t' vM . Yj x] x]t' tflGqs k"hf ljlw ;+= -#_ sQf YjF j XofpF YjF y'Ot kf]x]+nf -d+l;/
Yj Goftf co\nf jf YjF nf, ªf, v]+ cf]=b'Yofgf k';+_ lrs'nf y'Ou' vM . le+u' sy+ ofo]t y'u'
Rj+u' vM . YjF y'Ot Gxfkf jnf jlh l;of hfls g+ l;of

26 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
s]nf kf]s bo]sf ltgf tO{ lnkf kf]s jn ls g]jf ;dfho conf Yj oft clgjfo{ sy+ b'ltgf
nM u'ln to]dfMu'vM tof j/fj/ ;+sf O{Ton ls Rjg . x/]s gvM rvM hfqf kq+ ;+:sf/ cflb;
y's] xofpFs nM yfxf jOu' j XofpFu' lt oft b'Yofsftn . u'jn] dTjlglkGt gfk+ g]jfM;dfho
XofpF Yj wsflnsfO{ , cn] Sjo\ sf]l;gf Rj+u' u'u'+ k'hfljlw; conf of ;jfM dsf;] dufu' g+
tfs'u' YjF u'lsoft sQfYjF wfOu' vM t/ yf}+sGx] rng b' . /fO{ lnDa' hfltof conf oft BM oft
yy] hfls jlh l;of Kjs bo]sf stfYjF xofpF 5fgf -ck0f{_ hs gvM rvM xlgu' rng b' .
YjF b]o]s]u' rng tgf jlg w'+sn . ufufd] u'ln g]jfM to g+ u' u'+ gvM rvM no BMoft conf
u'lnl;of u'7L, k'hf oft dbos+ duf lkG;+ Yj+ 5fgf hs Ejo go]u' gfk k'hfljlw;+ ljleGg
hs yy] k'nf+u' k|ljlw 5onf YjF bos]u' ofgf BMlkGt ljleGg k"hf ofO{ u' ‰jno conf jf
Rj+u' b' . k|foM yy] dofo] w'+sn t/ stf YjF j Yj+of tflh oft 5]nf Rj+u' b' tflGqs k"hfljlw
XofpFYj k'hfoft dfMlklt conf bo]s]t y'Ou' GofuM :jgf, :ju+ :jgf jf 5uM :jgf k'hf
-Tok_ sMoft x] stf YjF ofgf 5\onf Rj+u' . h'Ou'ln k"hf sy+of YjF of tflhno clh YjF,
XofpF Yj of nflu jx] sto] conf sfo] Tonls ef} YjF, stf YjF xofp YjF, cflb g+ 5]lnu' vM .
yxfF jOu' lt oft x] XofpF Yj ofgf 5]nf Rj+u' ci6 dft[sf e'lQm d'lQm k'hf ofOjn] ljleGg
b' . y'hf]u' conf sd{sf08 oft hs 5]nf Rj+u' b]jL lkGt 5fOu' YjF conf dWo] -!_ s'df/L oft
vg]b' . Tjg]u' oft 5]nf dRjF . sfMYjF -stf Yj_ -@_ j}i0fjLoft clh Yj+ -#_
-%_ Eofj/ YjF–sMlg r'+ jf hfsL r'+of jf/fxLoft clh Yj+ -$_ OGb|fo0fL b]jL oft clh
bo]lsu' vM . kf]stof nM Gxfof a'? a'? Rj+s Yj+ -%_ rfd'08f oft hfsL l;of bo]sf tMu'
bo]sf Tjlgu' vM . ;Fo to b'l;of kf]so SjfnM stf YjF -%_ dxfnIdLoft stf YjF j conf -^_
tof Tjlgu' y]+ x] vM t/ lold sto nM tof dxfsfnoft stfYjF -&_ u0f]zoft clh YjF -*_
;+sf nM hs Tjlgu' vM Yj Eofj/ YjF sM gfk+ x] led;]goft XofpF YjF 5fOu' vM .
tfs's Tjlgu' vM . oFof jn] cfh' b]jof yfo] YjF conf 5fodfu'
Yj Eofj/ YjF oft k'hfljlw 5]n]u' dof b' . cy] x] Gxfkf tMs} jOjn] l;tnf dfh' tMs}
Tjg]t hs vM . tfnf+ a'+ Hof ofOlklt Tjlgu' Boft k'hf ofM jlgjn] clh YjF gfk+ conf g
rng b' . gfk+ l;gf Hofjn] jf lkOu' Ono g+ tofo+lsu' ljlw b' .
Tjg]u' ofM . Yj YjF Gxfkf+ nu] h'O dv' Tjg] w'+sf xf/tL df+of yfo 5fo] xfls jn] conf dbos
wf} jfwf} lnkf u'h'+ Rjgf nu] h'Ou' vM . dufM yf}+sGx] u}/ g]jf t;]+ g+ 5fo] xfs]u' ofgf
;To o'uo\ b]j0f j b}To u0f ldn] h'of ;d'b| xMjn] confof kN;f b'? tof ofo]u' ofgf xn .
dGyg ofMjn] cd[t j conf lkxfF jn . cd[t Yj lxpkf O{ sy+ nf]u' h'n . yy] x] d]d]u' If]qo
hs b]ju0f+ nfsf Tjgfljn ;f b}To u0fof efuo\ g+ lxpof xo]dfMu' vM . g]jf ;dfho ;gftlg
conf nft . conf TjFgf /fIf]z b}To u0f h'of k'hf ljlwsy+ lzj, dxfb]j, lji0f' gf/fo0f oft x]
ljn . y's] l;Ob' conf cflb sfn+ lg;] pTklt hs conf Yj+ 5fOu' db' . t/ u'u'+ uf]Ko tflGqs
h'u' cn] zlQmlk7 cflb tflGqs ljlw k"hf oft k"hfo\ y'lk g+ conf YjFo 5'6 dh' . kfxfF rx|] jn]
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 27
n's'dfBMoft conf Yj gfk+ ;doalh 5fo]u' -$_ g]jf hfltof ;u+M -;u'g_ of Joj:yfo\
ofM . cy] x] u'lnl;of cfu+ B x] pdf dx]Zj/ nf ªf, v]F j cf] gfk conf jf YjF tof ljOu'
zlQm?k dfBkfjtL{ j u0f]z 5u" x] d"lt{_ b' vM . Yj ;u+ drf Kjfyo\ b'Dx oftlg;]+ drf
cn] Yj b]j oft co\nf Yj+ gfk+ tfdl;s k"hf h+sf], sotfk'hfu' j;'sf , Olx, jf/fxf to]u'
lglj{jfb GXofsf Rj+u' b' . cy] jf}4 k"hfljlwof gfk+ ljof 5\jo] Gx]j ld;f drfoft ko]g+ hf
k|foM k'mSs k'hf tflGqs dt sy+ x] h'Ou' vM . gs]u' ljjfxof ;xef]hg, yfoAj gfk+ Hof,
eujfg a'4 gfk tf/f BMlkGt nf ªf v]F conf h+sf], led/yf/f]x0f, dxf /yf/f]x0f, b]j /yf/f]x0f
YjF jlh{t vM x/]s lgTo k"hfo lg/fd]if ;flTjs hs dv' jflif{s+ hGd lbg j :jGtLof Dx k"hf
k"hf x] h'Ou' vM . t/ jif{ aGwg of sfo{qmdo lshf k'hfo\ ts+ ;u+ ljOu'ln conf jf YjF oft
wfn;f tflGqsljlw df+;, dB clgjfo{ sy+ x] clgjfo{ b'Yofsf tMu' b' . y's] ckf]l;of conf
5]nf k"hf h'of Rj+u' vM . jln ljO DjfMu' k"hfo 5\olnu' vM . t/ u'efh', zfSo], pbfo, Hofk',
g+ conf YjF oft lglj{jfb clgjfo{ sy+ b'Yofsf ;fold cflblk+ o}Fof lklg YjF x] 5\olnu' vM ;f
k"hf h'of Rj+u' b' . d]u' g]jfM hflt j o]F on Vjko lklg conf
;+:sf/] g]jf ;dfhof dg" hGd h'of lg;] 5]lnu' vM . t/ Hof h+sf]of lgsf]u' h+sf] !)))
d/0f ts of !^ ;+:sf/ h'Ou'ln x/]s ;+:sf/ rGb|df v+u' lx;fj+ ofOu' h'of y's] ckf] ;flTjs
cj:yf sy+ YjF confoft b'Yofsf tMu' b' . ef]hg gfk+ ;Fu+ g+ wf} j sfkM ;u+ 5]lnu' vM .
cfgGb j /demdof nflu hs dv' b'Mv zf]s t/ o]+ on, Vjko >]i7 ;d'bfo jfx]s d]lkG;+ v]F
of Ono g+ conf oft k|fyldstf hs dv' ;u+ gfk conf YjF oft k|fyldstf ljof tMu'
u'lnl;of nf clgjfo{ 5]nf Rj+u' b' . vFg]b' .
-!_ drf j'of nR5L btls yM5]+ vnM ;gftlg k"hfljlw sy+ ;flTjs j tflGqs
Dxofodrfoft nf gs] o+s]u' wsf nf, jhL rfs' ljlw vM . t/ ;flTjs k"hf j}lbs sy+ h'Ou'
gfk+ d"ltu' YjF g+ o+s]u' rng b' . Yj d"ltu' vM ;f tflGqs ljlw g+ j}lbs sy+ x] vM ;f+
YjF tfut bOu' ljb]zL conf Vibrona of gfk+ tflGqso df+; dlb/f oft clgjfo{ ofgf tMu'ln+
HjMnfu' wsf 5\o]lnu' vM . ;+;sf/] u'lnl;of j|Dx" k'/f]lxt u'lnl;of u'efh'
-@_ ;+:sf/] u'ln+ hfltof ef}drf n;s'; k'/f]lxt b' . t/ j|Dx" k'/f]lxt lklg lk7 zlQm
ofo]t XofpF RjF ef}drfof t'lt l;sf b'sfOu' k'hf+ tflGqs ljlw k"hf ofodfn ;f u'lnl;of
rng b' . Yj rng o]F nfufo\ jh|frfo{, zfSo, cfrfh' kfv]+ u'lnl;ofj|Dx" t yM lkG;+ x] ofOu'
t'nfwf/, dxh{g ;fold cflb hfltoflklg rng vFg]b' . j|Dx" k'/f]lxt kfv]+ ;+:sf/ of Hof uy]
b' . t/ >]i7 ju{o Yj rng db' gfk+ ono Vjko\ ls sotfk'hf, drf h+sf], Hof h+sf] cflb of
g+ rng db' . k"hf h'Ojn] xf]dofgf oft;f+ cyjf snztof
-#_ ljjfx jn] *$ Ao+hg tof yfoAj, oft;f+ g+ yflk+ :jg] DjfM t/ s'df/L k"hf wfn;f
;xef]hg glsu'ln YjF, conf, XofpF yF g+ ofo]df y's] ;doHjn+ gfk YjF jf conf g+ bO .
to]dfu' rng g]jfM ;dfho b' . jh|frfo{ k'/f]lxt lklg yflk+ :jgf x] k'hf ofOu'

28 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
rng b' . t/ yy] k'hf ofOjn] s'dfl/ k'hf g+ g]jf ;dfh+ gfnf Rj+u' sf/0f 5' b' wofu' ljifon]
clgjfo{ b'u'ln wfn;f j|Dx k'/f]lxt h";f lk7 5s b':jo] .
k'hf j s'df/L oft conf YjF oft ;do jlh ljz]if conf YjF oft g]jf ;dfh+ :jf:Yo
gfk+ 5]lnu' rng b' . gfk+ yfoAj glsjn] g+ le+s]of nfuL j zlQm cfh{gof nflu clgjfo{
conf YjFoft g+ gfnf tMu'b' b' . sy+ dfqfl5 hs 5]n]u' ofgf Rj+u' vM . t/
gvM rvM jn] j}lbs tflGqs j tfdl;s ;sn dg"of :jefj py]+ h'Odv' cn] 5'+ lrh g+
k"hfo\ conf Yj+oft cj:yf j k'hfljlw sy+ cltzo h'nls ljs[lt jOu' g+ :jefljs vM cy]
5]nf Rj+u' nf b'u' x] h'n . gv rvM no g+ x] le+u' lrh h'Odf jf dleDx dg" h'n;f g+ clt
df]xlgjn] yflk+ :jgf k"hfofOlklg conf YjF h'nls plsof lnRjM g+ jf+dnfOu' c:jfefljs
, clgjfo{ dfMu' h'n . d]u' gvM jn] kl/l:ylt dv' . conf Yj+oft g+ dfqf ldn]ofgf lGxlGx 5]nf
j cj:yf sy+ Yj+ j conf oft 5]nf Rj+u' Rj+g]u' jf;M x] h'O{ wsf cf'o'j]{lbso g+ GXoygf
b';f OGb| hfqf jn] ljz]if xfy' BM k"hfofgf tMu' b' . t/ dfqf ldn] dh'Os O{ JoM dh'Os
xfy' xfo]lsjn] conf j YjF lgtf+ x] dfMu' ckf] h'Ojn] plsof lnRjM g+ cjvt+ h'of jgf
ofgf tMu' b' . j+wn] cfh' BM of yfo conf Rj+u' emL;+ vgf Rjgfu' b' . GXofu' lrho\ u'0f
hs xfo]lsu' vM . xg'dfg wf]sfo\ e}/jof j cju'0f bOu' h'n . Yj conf YjF g+ cy] x]
yfo Gxfkf+ conf xfo]lsu' vM;f k'lGx s'Gx' u'0f j cju'0f lgtf b'u' cn] 5u' pRrsf]ltofu'
YjF xfo]lsu' vM . gzfn' -Intoxication_ vM . ps]+ dfqf ldn] h";f
d[To' ;+:sf/] g]jf ;dfho conf oft g+ cd[t dh";f ljif g+ vM . g]jfM ;dfho conf
5]nf Rj+u' b' . ;'of+ l;gf b'Mv+ Rjgf Rjlgjn] YjFoft k"hfljlw, ;+;sf/] hsdv' jf;M of ?ko
lrk+ lyOs]t conf lr kfn' jlh o+lsu' rng g+ plts+ 5]nfa'nf h'of Rj+u' b' .
b' . cy] x] d[tsof gfd+ ofOu' sd{sf08 cfo'{j]{lbs If]qo confoft jf; cs{ sy+
k"hfljlw GXog'df wM;', nf]sf]Q/ lk08 cflb ;+ gfnf 5]nfRj+u' b' . yy] jf;Mno 5]n]u' conf
g+ conf, XofpFYj cflb dbo]s dufMlk+ g+ b' . le+u' ld;fjt db'u' z'4 b'l;of bo]sf tMu' conf
t/ yy] rng vf;ofgf jh|frfo{, zfSo], p/fof oft k|fyldstf ljof tMu' b' . cfo'{j]{lbs jf;Mno
Hofk', ;fodL cflb lklghs b' . b'Mv+ RjlglkGt confoft hl8a'6L Njfs5ofgf hs 5]lnu' vM .
lrk+lys] wfn;f g]jf k|foM k'msl;ofF conf g+ uy]+ls tfut j d'6'of rfn jMnfs]t lbJofd[t,
o]lsu' rng b' . yy] g]jf ;dfho j';f+ lg;]+ ;+lhjfd[t cflb jf;M confvo\ bo]lsu' vM;f
l;gf jgf ts hs dv' knfM klts+ xgfjof ug= Nxft'lt ds{o\ h'of kfMjf;M kfo]t d';fj/,
Rj+u' gvM rvM hfqf kj{ cflb ;+ conf YjF kfMjf;M cflb confvo\ tof bo]sf tOu' vM .
oft clgjfo{ sy+ ;dfhof cleGg c+u gfnf cy] x] ;fwf/0f Nxf t'lt Dx :ofOjn] le+u' d";Mu'
5]nfj'nf ofgf Rj+u' h'n . Yj conf YjF of conf Sjfsf dfln;ofo]u' ngfjlgu' rng
k|lts"n emLu' zl//oft u'u' uy]nfgf Rj+u' b' Gxfkf+lg;] b' . Yj g+ cfo'{j]{lbssf pkrf/ ljlw
cn] Yj conf Yj+ oft yy] dlh dufMu' sy+ vM . d]u' %) k|ltzt cfo'{j]lbs jf;M cs{ bo]sf

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 29
5olnu' vM . cs{of cy{ hl8a'l6oft lkmgf b' . Yj Alchohol of dfqf bo]lsu' k|ljlw sy+
conf y]+ bosf tOu' 5u' sy+of conf vM . km/s g h'ofRj+lgOu' vM . km/d]G6]zg ofgf
cy] x] Pnf]k}ly jf o'gflg g+ l8:6Ln]6 k|ljlwoft bo]sf tMu'ln $–!%Ü 8]li6n];g ofgf tMu'ln
bo\lsu' emf]n jf;M tg+ cs{ jf co\nf x] vM . $)–%)Ü cNsf]xn bof Rjlg . cy] x] ljleGg
ljZjo\ ;sn dg"io yMyMu' l/lt, yfo\ jfo\ Tj;f bOu' tTj M–
jftfj/0f j gvM rvM gfk+ ;+;sf/ oft :jfsf -!_ lao/ -Beer_ – $–%Ü
dBkfgoft c+lusf/ ofgf Rj+u' b' . pls+ jf+nf -@_ jfOg -Wine_ – !!–!$Ü
jf+dnf, lhp dlhpof jf:tfdtM k|mfG;of lklg -#_ z]/L -Sherry_ – !%–@)Ü
jfOg j ljo/ of rng b';f :s6Nof08of lklg -$_ lXj:sL -Whiskey_ – $)–%)Ü
:srlXj:sL Tjg]b';f notfM . g]kfno /fO lnDa' -%_ lhg -Jeen_ – $)–$%Ü
cflb hghflt gfk+ g]jfMt g+ gv rvM hs dv'+ -^_ a|f08L -Brandi_ – $)–$%Ü
5'+ g+ k"hf kj{ cflb ;+ conf Yj of e"ldsf uxg -&_ ef]8sf -Vodka_–
h'ofRjlgu' vM . t/ yf}+ ljZjo jof Rj+u' lxpkf -*_ /d -Rum_ cflb $)–$%Ü
gfk+ g]kfof hghflt ofs]g+ /fhgLlts lxpkf y'u' sy+ lkg] ahf/] Rj+u' conf :jof lemu'
gfk+ kR5LdL xfjf of k|efj nfgf jMu' b' . cn] 5]+ bo]lsu' confno cnsf]xn of dfof ckf]u'
g]kfof hghflt j g]jf nf hGdhft+ dtjfnL l;Ob' .
wfo\sf Rj+u'ln j|fDx0f If]qL tg+ dtjflnof y'lk conf Tjg]w'g]j Kjfy] Yolgu' cNsf]xn
clwsf/L h'of jof Rj+u' b' . Gxfkf ;f æa|Dx" lxg'ln Dx5Dx Yo+sf ljO . lx NjfsHofu' cNsf]xn
g+ Rofp gM;f hs ;jf y'O{Æ wfOu' k|rng cfM ckf] h'of+ j+ln;] GXok' -lbdfuo_ k|efj nfgfjlg
conf, YjFof ;jfM hghflt g]jfMtos] Gog]dfMu' cg+ lnkf d'6'O, ;]+ qmdzM nfgf jlgO cn]+ ;]+
y] h'O w'+sn . YjF conf 5u' gzf vM u'u' gzf+ co\nf kr]ofo]t ckf] lqmoflzn h'Ou' lnkf ;]+ of
yf}+sGx]of :dfos, lx/f]Og, :jof sd dh" . 5sf] zlQm Dxf] h'of jgf confoft kr]ofo]u' Ifdtf
;jfM sofkns]y'n ls j dg"g+ hGde/ Tjt] g+ sd h'of jlg ;]+o\ cNsf]xn d'gf j'n'x'F bfM
dkmOu' . -Fat_ h'of lxg' d'6'O GXofgfjlg . y'u' x'lg ;]+
conf of hGdnf cflb sfn+ lg;] x] Hof ljO dkmOjn] -Lever Sirosis_ ;]+of Njo\ h'O .
h"u' cg'dfg ofo]k'm . dWosfnof o'u kfv] conf wofu' 5u' sy+ sfjf]{xfO8«]6 -zlQm_
c/ajfl;to\;+ cGg j kmnk"mn Wjlusf vM .
Destilation k|ljlw conf bo]s]u' Hof ofMu' vM . conf no bOu' Sofnf]l/ yy] vM –
cg+lnkf o'/f]k b]z+ GXofu' l;Ob' . conf lgu' ljo/ -@%) ldln= -Ps lunf;_ – !@@ mg
sy+of bo]s]u' rng b' 5u' cGg wf]lusf, d]u' a|fG8L #) ld=ln= -! k]u_ – (* mg
kmnk"mn wf]lusf Yj conf lgly sy+ x] bo]lsu' XjfO6 jfOg !)) ld=ln= – &% mg
vM . 5u' Fermentation j d]u' destilation confvo\ lhg – #) ld=ln= -! k]u_ – *$ mg
OyfOn cNsf]xn cyjf Oy|f]gn /;folgs tTj /d – #) ld=ln= -! k]u_ – (* mg

30 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
lXj:sL #) ld=ln= -! k]u_ – (! mg 8fS6/ tou' wfk' sy+ conf dTjlglkG;+
/]8jfOg #) ld=ln= -! k]u_ – *@ mg uan]+ g dTjg]u' j]; h'O . @) bF sf]o oflk+
5u' o'lg6 conf !) u|fd h'O;f y'ln wofu' ld;f jf ldh g+ conf dTjg]u' j]; . Kjfyo
5u' k]u lXj:sL 5u' lunf; jfOg j jfuM l;l; b'lkG; g+ conf dTjg]u' . d'6', ls8gLof,
ljo/ j/fj/ h'O{ . Yj 5u' u\fd confno & u|fd xfO k|];/, Nxjlk+, jfy Nj] b'lkG; 8fOa]l6h
Sofnf]l/ lx;fjo !) u|fdo &) Sofnf]/L bOu' conf oft Tofu ofo]u' x] lg/f]uL h'Ou' vM .
h'n . ldh to\;+ xKtfof Yj o'lgt cyjf @! k]u ps]+ confoft Sjfln6L y'Osf k|of]u ofo]u'
ts hs cn] ld;f to; !$ o'lg6 cyjf !$ SjflG66L oft dljOu' x] emLu' ;+:sf/ oft
k]u 5u' xKtfo hs Tjg]u' :jf:Yooft jfFnfsf Djfsf to]u' vM .
tO{ . Yjof+ ckf]h'nls d'6', ;]+, :j+, ls8gLof nf]o\ cGto\– y}+sGx] conf bo]ls lkG;
gfk+ cfGb|fof SofG;/ cflb oft lgdGq0ff ljOu' Jofkfl/s b[li6 ckf] 5]nfRj+u' vFg]b' . Gxfkf
;+efJo ckf]Ou' vM . Gxfkf 5]+ 5]+ bo]ls conf yM5]FhM oft hs
t/ 5YjM j}1flgs to]u' cg';Gwfg+ conf le+s ld;fjt dbo]s d's+ b'l; j hfsL jf
lglZrt ?k+ dfqf ldn]ofgf Tjgf Rjg wfn;f kmnk"mn hs bo]ls vM . t/ yf}+lDxuM Jofkfl/
d'b' of Nj]o #*Ü sd h'O{ wofu' ljZjf; ofgf tfn+ ld;fjtofgf bo]lsu' ckf] h'n . Gxfkf
Rjg . cd]l/sfo ;fpy Sof/]lngf k|fGtof conf bo]s]t sMbo]lsjn] 36f] g+ #÷$ nf
j}1flgsto; $ jif{ ts l/;r{ofgf lnrf] nu]h' . cf yf}+sGx] !%÷@) lbg+ sM j'sf conf
lktljpu' cd]l/sg d]l8sn hg{+no\ GXoJjof sfo] lhlsu'M . yy] ofOu' stMo\ ofsg j's]t
tMu'+ sy+ ldh+to\t lGx @ u' k]u j ld;fto]t o'l/of dn, EjfyMu' :kf]hof Knfl:6s cflb
lGx 5u' k]u hs jfOg Tjg]jn] g'u r'+ of rfn cvfB j:t'tof bo]ls h'n . u's]+ confof
jf+nfgfRj+u' sgf tMu' b' . t/ cd]l/sg x6{ :jfb gfk+ u'0f:t/ g+ Sjxf+ jgf Rjg . y'hf]u'
P;f]l;o;g g+ conf dTj+lkGt Tjs]u' ofo]dlhp conf 5]n]u' x] dfgj zl// oft ofsg+ hL0f{
y's]+ emg v/fj h'O j}1flgs 8fg lsË of wfk' ofo]u' vM ps]+ emL g]jfto;+ k/+k/f lg;] 5]nf
sy+ SofG;/ j ls8gLof /f]uL conf Tjg] dlhp jof Rjgfu' ljlwoft gfnf bo]s]u' conf oft
Tjgls+ lnRj jf+nfO{ dv' . k|fyldstf ljOdf . dv';f confoft Tofu
conf Tjlglklgu' k|hgg\ zlQmsd ofgf Rofg' lemGx' x] bo]s] k'mu' 5]+ofu' clh
h'ofjlg . Kjfyo b'lkG; Tjg]u' jflg h'+;f Kjfyo\ YjF oft -g]kfnL ljo/_ sy+ gfnf Tjg]k'm . yf]
Rj+Dx drfoft j lnrf] nfOu' vM . g+ lgoldt dv' ;+:sf/ j ;+:s[ltoft Djfsf
ckf] conf Tjlglklg lnkf h"ln;] Tj+Tj+ dfMu' sy+ hs 5]n]u' x] Yj cd'No zl// oft
dugf jlnu' h'of g;fof sdhf]/ h'of Nxft'lt ;'yf+nfs]u' x] emLu' bfloTj vM . ahfl/of j
vfOu', g'uM ef/fef/f ldlgu' vFTofdlhof jlgu' cfofltt j:t'oft ltnf~hln ljOk'm;f hs
cflb vM . dfqf ldn]h'of Rj+;f jf;M vt, dfqf emLu' ;+:s[lt Djfgf RjlgO .
ckf] h'of jgls ljif h'Ou' conf vM .
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 31
;dfnf]rgf

Affv+ 5u" la:s+u'


SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' bLks /fh æVjkÆ

Gx\ovFM 5'+ O{ Gxo\+ g]jfM ;"r+ s]Gb|of n'k'+ Vjkef;+ x] RjoftMu' ;km' cn] Vjkof x] Rjld
Vjkof gu/sf]6o\ h'Ou' 5u" afv+ ;km"of h'Ou' dgt'gf . ;km" sofM Rjldof gf+ Ajgf . gf+
lrlvkmo\g] Hofof ;"r+ yf}+sGx]of clts+ Dx:o' y]+ Gogf y]+ h'n . lnpg]of AjMlg+ :jof .
nf]s+xjfMu' km]zj"sof ;+hfno\ Ajgfu" h"n . j Yjo]s nf Vjkof cfbz{ cfhfb ljBfnoof u'?j/
;"r+ Ajgf dgo\ dltj+u' vM ls ;'efo\ eujfg cn] ug ug jo]s ;/:jtL ljBfu[xo\ k'nf+Dx
ls g]kfn ef;f ;flxTo VoMof bj' ;u{y]+ rs+u' ljBfyL{y]+ tfn . vM nf dv'nfof bf]dg t+s]t
vgfM . gfk+ Yj Ajgfln+ dgo\ yLyL vF bfl;jMu' ;km" Ajg] wof g+ O{ r' dnf .
vM ls cf]xf] Û emLu' ;flxToof ;+;f/ tJofMh'h'+ 5Gx' :s'nof kf;f s[i0fetm jf]8]of uklnof
j+u' h'n u'an]+ jfrfdl/ u'an]+ gu/sf]6o\ k;no\ ;f}/e bfO gfk+ vF Nxfgf RjRj+ x] efh'
u'an]+ ug u'an]+ ug Gx' Gx"u' ;km" t v'?v'? Gx'5]etm sjf+ h' Yo+s emfn . Hjhnkf .
pv]+y'v]+ lktAjHof g+ h'ofjMu' gfk+ afv+ldlk+, jo]sn+ yf}+ uy] cfk'ns+ wof Gxo;M 5'gflbn .
lrafv+dLlk+, pkGof;sf/lk+, RjvFld lrgfvFldlk+ v g+ vM Vjk] h'of g+ Vjko\ yy] kf;flk+ gfk
y]+ yLyL ljwfof Rjldt g+ v'l;afMjMy]+ GxoHofof dnfgfMu' g+ tfMbo\ w'+s"u'ln+ 5u' sy+ cfk'ns+
Rj+u' :jo]bofM, Ajg]bofM dg t;s+ no\tf . lnkf x] h'nwfM;f+ dkfM . cy]g+ Gx'5]etm h' oft lh+
SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' 5]Fof lrlvkmo\g] Hof gu/sf]6o\ ln;M laof cfk'ns+ x] h'n . y]x] vM gfk+ l5u'
h"u'of a'v' gf+ b+Dx kqsf/ do\h' /]vf zfSoof ;km" Gofo nf w'g :jo]rflx' dv+lg wof cg+
Rj;f+ g]kfnef;f 6fOD; lGxkf}no\ Ajg]vg . labfsof jgf5j\of . pan]lg;]+ tfs 5'gf Rjgf
cy]g+ j lGxkf}no\ Ajgfsy+ SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' 5]F ls Gx'R5]etm sjf+of afv+ ;km" u'an] Ajg] wfwf+
wof AjgfM x] ch' rfOu' ls SjfMgfv+ 5]Fo\ uy] lnkf O{ nfsf Sjrfo]sf . Yj ;km" Ajgf y'ln oM
ld gO SjfgfM h'Odf Vjf+u' gf h'Odf pls+ nf tfn ls plsof 5'+ 5'+ Rjo] wof Rj;fM Gxofsf .
ld uy] gO ld gMu' 5]' nf nfv+ :ofo]u' s"tMofO s'tM lksfsof lkygf+ afv+ld efh' Gx'R5]etm
wof ch' rfMu' vM . yy] dgof s't's't'ld+u' t+s]t sjf+of ;km" SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' 5]' yMt Vjk ef;+
j ;km" uy] Nxfto\ nfs] wof dg xyfo\ rfn . RjoftMu' tfo]sf . cn] efh' ladn tfd|fsf/of
ug dg cg n' w}y]+ 5Gx" g]kfnef;f Ps]8]dLof n'kfo\ aM sfo] ano\ d's+ Yj Vjkef;+ x] RjMu'
Uj;fno\ h"u' ;km" AjHofo\ j ;km" Gof x] Gofgf . u'lsoft lgk' afv+ hs Vjkef;+ x] tof d]u'
wfy]+ wfo]u' vM ;f SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' 5]F wfo]ano\ rflx ladn h'+ efo\ lxnflbu' h'ofRjg . cy]g+
32 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
;km" AjgfM yMtnf pkf]w}y]+ Vjkef;+ x] Rj}tMy]+ x] efM lys] h';]ln+ ahf/o\ emg lys]h"u' l/kf]6{
tfn . laO . plnhs dv' Aof+rf+ ofgf yy] lys] h'u'ln+
bsn]+ Gxfkof afvgo\ kz'k+l5of xTofof j}t kmfFl; ts laOu' cg'udg 6f]lnof l/kf]6{ .
Njfk' sy+of afv+ b' Gx"u' åGb . kz' clwsf/jfbL cy]x] On+ O{of dfof afvgo\ ci6dfg ;fx" 5Dx
j kz' anL dg Sj;flklg Njfk" x] y'lsof afv+ t;s+ lndnfMDx Jofkf/L . yy]h'of yM sfo]j+
h'n . 5Yjl;g+ kz' anL lbsL Oldg+ Djfo]u' cfvM Aj+ dAj+u' :jo] dkmO . pv] ljBfno+ sfo]
clwsf/ b' wfOlk+ d]lk+ dfg] dofOlk+ . pls+ Old g+ cfvM dAj+u' wofxO . yM snfMgfk+ ;nfofgf
by'O lx+;fTds Njfk" h'O . afv+of gf+ sy+ 5u" df+of dgo\ Njx 3fsfM drfoft af]8;{ ofO .
Gx"u' åGb . afv+dLof d]u' afv+ dfsM dltgfo\ O{ kmk'O . sfo\ Dx Nofo\Dx h'O . Jofxf ofgf
Vjkjf;L a'l4gf/f+of ;f]emfkg wfo]nf rnflvkg laO . df+af} a'/fa'/L h'O . yf}+sGx]of edrf t
5u" Ono\of e'vfr+ 5]Fo\ b'+lk+t lgu" nfv cn] 5]Fo\ Ono\ bgf Hof sM3fgf ofOdv' . Yj vgf ;;Mdf+
lrl/afof Rjg] dHo'lk+t ;o\s8f lgu" k|ltzt edrfof vF Nxfgf h'O . edrf+ vF ;L cn]
sy+ gLGofu" nfv Tof;f laOu' w}u' Ujkmo\ . efMtoft Gxfo\kgo\ :jf+ k'O . Old;+ df+af}oft
plsof No' No' jgf a'l4gf/f+ g+ Nxj\gf Rjg]Ho'u' j[4f>d to]u' dlt tO . 5Dx sfo] g+ df+af}g+
5]F g+ 3f/f3'?+ y'gf5j\O . ;/sf/+ laOu' bf+of u'ln b'Mvl;of yMt Ajn+sn j nf]d+ls . df+af} x]
nf]e+ 5]Fo\ nf y'lg . lnkf ;/sf/of j ar+ cy]+ yM hGdbftf sd{bftf w}u' nf O{of v'l;+ r'Ols .
h'O . y'v] a'l4gf/f+ yM RjgfRj+u' 5]Fo\ u'lsof efh' Gx"5e
] tm sjf+of xfkmj\ j 5]F afvgo\
nfnk'hf{ db'u', j bo]s]t gfkL ofo] No+ blgu' cbfnt+ Tofsf jMDx xs{jL/of dg r+r+ wfO .
hs dv' plsof :jaf;L btf{ ofo] x] No+ blgu' snfM r't+ /Loft cf emLu' Yj 5]oF \ ;'gfg+ 5'+ ofo]
vF nf]d+lsu' g+ yMu' t'ltO yd+ x] kf+ kflny]+ h'O . km}dv't, dg" g+ dofM;f+ Bj+ 5fo] dofO wof vF
cy]x] dfkb08 afvgo\ cf;nfnoft 5u" km;fb ;o]s+' slg d':of YjF TjTj+ x] xfKjMo\ ldvf h' jlg .
h'of aMh'yfo\ ;Nnf;fx'lt ofMjlg . ad"{ afh]+ ;f snfM r't+ /Loft af]/f lx' wfO . snfd+ 5fo] wof
5Dx bfgofM;f jof kfk+ d'tm h'O wfO . cf;nfn+ Golg . j xfKjM :o+sd ] fn afa'+ 5'+ ofM;f j}t GofO
yM sfo]j+ hs dv' aMh"of sfo]j+ g+ lvrfof nf wof 5j\fnL j ;nfO Rofsf xfKjno\ toflaO .
gMu' b' 5' wof Gxo\; tO . Yj Gogf j ad"{+ Gxfr ;'kf}of kln 5sn+ ld+ lyO . Olk+ yf/f Gx'O . nM lx'
x] wfo] Djfnf 5sM lgsM cfkto\ xfs'Dx lvrfof s?jf+ dv' 3M lx' wfO . r'Gt/L lrNnfo\bgf xfnL
nf gM;f+ gs{o\ djlgu' vF wof xO . u'xfnL u'xfnL . yy] d'2f+ TofsfxMu' 5]' yMu' x] sd{+
ahfM ef lys]h"u' 5' x'lg+ wof cg'udg gf} h'Osf Rjg]dfMu' afv+ h'n Yj .
cfof]u+ Hof ofof+ jlgano\ Jof+rf Ono\ dxfMu'ln+ j]bgf afv+ cy{of cgy{ h'Ou' afv+ vM .
Ono\ jf djMof dfSj cfn' Kofh d;Mu' afv+ r' Rjldof sy+ gls+ oft Vjkef;+ Gofls, slgoft
h'n cfof]u . Yj x'lg+ dfu sy+ pTkfbg dh'u'ln+ nfjhf wfO . vnf Vjk efo\ o]' j onof efo\
dg"t a'O jgf x] lys] h'Os Gof jlg . yy] cg :jof ufs+ kfM . yMlk+ Ajn+u' b]o\ j plsof
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 33
efo\ sy+ Gxo\fDxl;g+ vF NxfOu' :jfefljs x] . dfi6/+ vlg . Rjldof ;km"of Nof kf} $# ; sy+
PsfTdstf efo\no\ djMu' w}u' rflx wfy]+ vM dfh' lhtM ;'of e/o\ Tjtf ysf, lh larfM ofo]
;f+ tla yLyL efo\of 5o\nfa'nfo\ cy{of cgy{ duf lg, dfh' lhtM g+ sfM jf wof . plsof 5'+
h' j+u' x] Rjldof afv+ . b]o\efo\ sy+ :j0f{o'uo\ lb+ No' dfi6/+ u'Xo]Zj/L ttf oft wfO . pv'Gx'
u'lng+ Yof;km", Njx' kf}, l;hM kf}, g]jfM Do] cflb 5+ cy] Vjof jn wfMy]+ 5+ dfh'+ sfMjnwfM;f jg]u'
k|rlnt lnlk+, /+hgf+ lnlk+ Rjoft}tMu' h'n j vMnf j gfk+ . j+ ln;M laO cf Û 5 dfi6/of vF
nf tTsflng Ono\of /fi6|ef;f sy+ nf kSsf wfM;f chf]u' hs . uy] jg] lh sfo\ Dxo\fo\of
x] vt . 5u" Ono\ b]o\of /fhwfgL sy+ h"u' Jofxf ofo]dfgL yM g+ ;;M df+ h'OdfgL . cy]+ jg]
Vjk b]of jf;Lto]t a]Sjo\ jf b' w}u' u'ln t Ho'nf . jof+ 5u" nf]sfrf/ hs s . yg Rjld
kfo\l5 n] Yj 5u" Gxo\; lr+ vM . lh+ :jo] yMu' efh'+ 5u" Wjfy'Osf lbn ls nf]skTof/of lx;fa+
df+ efo\ yMt tMw+ . cy]g+ 5u"of cy{ d]u' sy+ h';f+ ldn] dh'lk+ ;;Mdf+ ef} g+ uy] ;dfhof
kfM;f+ pls Xo'kf xo] uy]ofgf km} . Rjldof Yj Gxo\g] Sog] df Yj yMu' hLjgo\ x] 5fo] dSog]u'
afvgo\ efo\ sy+of cy{ 5o\nftMu' h'n u'u' w}u' lnUof+ pnflby]+ tf .
;fGble{s tf . a? jo]sof Yj afv+of 5o+\ rflx r'/f];, co]nf, YjF y]+ yLyL cdn w}u' y'ln
lh+ :jo] j]bgfof kln ltsld+u' afo\ oMdtfMu' ;s;s h'O ls pls+ emLu' z/L/of d" d" c+u
h'u' ;f af+nfOu' ls Û Rjldof nf]sfrf/ afv+ uy] :jF, :o],F g'uMoft :o+sf laO . chf]u' x] cdn+
rflx 5Dx ef}+ ;;Mdf+ ;';fs';f ofo]dfMu' afv+ . sof rl5+ d';j' of Bg] x] dkm}u' 5Dx sljof afv+
emLu' ;dfho\ 5]vfklt+ vg] bofRj+u' ;;Mdf+ h'n w'dk| fg . Rjldof wfk" TofGx'Dxl;t nF tfxf
ef}of ugug x] Rjld+ Gxo\Aju' afv+ vM . afv+ Gxo\djMl;t rf tfxf wfy]+ x] ;fsf/u' v' . rl5+
y'sy+ Gxo\fO . Dxo\fod+ yM df+oft u'lyof No+b'u' d';j' of Bg] dkmof rf 5o\fODx slj+ sGx]vG' x'
k'nf+u' Sjfsf gls . dfd+ kr] ofo] km}dv' . 8fS6/ So+jlg . cg dfdfMu' hfFr ofsf l/kf]6{
ofsMef}+ lkg]lg;]+ nM Nxo\ofxof ;;Mdf+of kl;{ :jof 8fS6/+ cfkf r'/f]; Tj+ul' n+ :jF xfs';] Rj+u'
rfo]dfnL . edrf e't'e't' xfnf xO . bl5 dofs+ cn] plsof x] lnRj+ d';' jO Rj+u' åk+laO . cy]g+
Dx dkmofRj+Dx ;;Mdf+oft yy] Gxo\g] nfnfMu' sljh'of dg+ r'/f]; r6Ss Tjt] yfs'O . lnkf
gsfM jof Dxo\fo]j+ larfM ofO nf . cgyfo\ 5Dx r'/f]; dTjt]u' vM;f jf;M g+ RjoflaO dv' wof
dfi6/+ j xfnfRj+u' tfof co\ u'Xo]Zj/L ttf Vofgfltlg lgDx Tok' 8fS6/of EjF Hjgf jf;M
Û a'/fa'/Llk+ yy] x] vMlg emL g+ yy] h'Oltlg . Gof jlgu' afv+ . cyx] jfof b'g] hfsL b' afvgo\
ofsMef} h'of km's+ yd+ x] nf :jo]dflnlg . cfdy] ;dfhof a]Sjo\ j Oiof+{ :jOu' ldvf+ :jOlk+;+
xfnf Rjg]u' kfo\l5 dh' wof ;+em]ofo] y]+ wfO . wgdb';f+ dg b'lk+ lgDx Tok'oft oflju' afv+
Hof g+ ofgf h; g+ dbo]sf Rjg] dHo' . plsof Gxo\Aju' b' Rjld+ . b]uMof klnO Rj+lk+ Hjav'ty]+
lgGx" :jGx" lnkf g+Vo Wjdf Vj/] o+s"Dx cg t;s+ ldn]hl' k+t ;dfhof tMldlk+;+ wgof km'lt{+
x] dbO . y'yfo\ u'Xo]Zj/L ttf VjofjMu' j x] kmfoflaOu' afv+ vM Yj . afvg+ 5u" Uof+ Ao'u' b'

34 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
bsn] Gxfkf+ Tok'of dg ;'vo\ h'Odf b'Mvo\ elt gfk+ jo]sn+ g]jfM g]jfM x] h'O w}u' pltm Sogflby]+
x] xyfo\ drfM;]+ dgoft lrgfM ljZjf;of lrMk"u' tfo]sf . d]u' afv+ dflxnf WjAjfo\ 5Dx a'/fof
;'sf+ So+sftMu' 5u" wfM oft rdkm'O wof jo]sn+ yM sfo\ ef}j+ ofMu' Jojxf/oft pnftMu' h'n . ;'+
Sogflbu' b' . jfof b'g] hfsL b' of afv+ sy+ dv' . lkg]of dg" t jM;f Oldu' Jojxf/ kfOu" cn] ;'+
e"ldut lu/f]x afv+ of d" kfq vM d'ltm db';f 5'+ Ro"tf dofOu' Yj ;dfho\ AjngfRj+u'
k|;fb zdf{ . Rjldof sy+ Yj 5Dx lgZrn, ;fk x] af+dnfMu' v' u'lsoft Rjld+ yMu' afvg+
ulDe/ j ;dk{0f eltmefj+ hfMDx JoltmTj . lemb' wfo]sftMu' h'n . vnf Yj clgTo ;+;f/o\ ldvf s+
lem+lgb' ts clj/n 5u" x] Ono\ kz'ktL B yfo\ jo] w+';]ln ldvf ltl;gf jg]dfgLu' tYo Nofo]Dx
jgf Hjhnk] ofgf k'Hofgf b/jf/of n'vfo\ jof Nof;];' btn] n'ddlgu' ls < pls+ yd+ dfg]ofo]
dxf/fhof ho h'Odf w}u' jrg NxfODx dg" . dflk+t xg]sg] db}u' yd+ dfof ofo] dflk+t Ro"tf
5Gx" h'h'of ;jf/L Ono\ Wjfvf lkjfofs] 5'+ b'nf db}u' vfnL yM j yMlk+t hs larfM ofOu' k|j[lt
wof ph+ h'O . lkjfof 5'ofo] 5'ofo] h'of 5Dx Xo'kf xo] x] df . 5fo]wfM;f Gxo\fSj sd] of, 5]Fo\
dg" oSj x] bo]w'+sn b/jf/of n'vfo\ ;bf+ 5u" x] a''F bo]ls 5Gx" nf TjMtf x] jg] df . Hjgf jg]u'
Ono\ jof dxf/fhof ho h'Odf wof jlg wsf 5u" x] hs yd+ ofOu" k'0o, wd{, ldhf; u'u' yM
slg . h'h'+ j}t sGx] b/jf/o\ Ajgf lx' w}u' ph+ dbo] w'+sf g+ cgGt ts NogfRjlg, bofRjlg
h'O . sGx]v'Gx' j lkjf+ d'ltm k|;fboft jx] Ono\ cn] n'd+sfRjlg .
dxf/fhof ho wfMjOano\ TofkM Hjgf h'h'yfo\ 5Dx c:oDx drfoft ;'/o\ xo]dfMu' afv+
yg] o+ls . h'h'+ j dg"ofs] 5' vF b'nf wof Golg . h'n df;f{aof Do] . 5Dx xf/f+Dx, bfbf+ bfVjDx
j+ km's+ lys h' dxf/fh ;n Ajfs]u' lGx v'Gx' Gxo\fDxl;g+ Njfk'lvrf wfODx drf /fhgoft
lh dxf/fh gfk+ Rjgf 5sM :jo]u' OR5f wfO . Vjkof cfbz{ cfhfb :s"no\ af}Dx+ v"u' tludo\
h'h'+ yM dg"oft jof OR5f k'j+ls wof ph+ h'O . egf{ ofs]t xO . c+u]|hL ljifoof dfWod+ Aj+lsu'
yy] ;n Ajflsu' hfqfo\ d'ltm+ h'h'gfk+ Rjgf :s"n TjMtf cg Aj+s] xO . chf]Dx drfoft+ d]lk+
Ono\ Jono\ h'h'of lnSs jgf h'h'of ho wof ;/ ld;lk+;+ c6]/LDx, c:oDx j}t nf ;fk Aj+s]
Rjlg . p;f+lg;]+ d'ltmof 5]'o\ dg"t d' jO . yfs', lnsof 5j\o]df wfo]s+ wfo]s+ x] x]8;/+ yMu'
tw+Mlk+ g]tft, sd{rf/Lt Gxfo\Dx+ h'h'oft yMu' ;Lk cn] d]xgt+ 5Dx 1fgL, u'0fL cn] lnkf j}t
OR5f tOAo' wfOlk+ . d'ltm zdf{+ lnkf afaf+nfMlk+t 5Dx af+nfMDx lzIfs Yo+s h'Osf laOu' afv+ h'n
d'ltm laof dle+lk+t a9'jf ofo]u' yM dg" r'gfj+ df;f{aof Do] . Rjld yM x] g+ jx] :s"nof lzIfs
Tofsf zf;g yMu' Nxfto\ nfls . yy] Rjldof Yj cn] jo]sof afv+of n'Fk+' cfbz{ cfhfb :s"n 5u"
afvgo\ vo\ kfq NoMu' j g+ vo\ ad"{ yhfMlk+;+ af+nfMu' gfk+ Gxo\fSj x] :o+lk+ ljBfyL{t h';f+ jx]
g]kfMof g]jfM /fHo wfo]sf zf;g h'ofRj+u'ln sy+ lzIff laof le+Dx dg" ofo] kmOu' xfYofoft
gof e'O kmfof ;tfM yMu' ofgf sfMu' afv+ Rjld cgof x]8;/+ yd+ So+u' h'n . Yj sy+ cfbz{
Gx"R5]etm sjf+of dgo\ g+ ltsld+u' jfrfo]s] km' . cfhfb :s'nof ul/df Rj5fMu' h'n . ofM;f 5'
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 35
dh'O w}u' wfk"oft l;4ofgf Ao"u' b' Rjld+ . yy] 5o\fsMrf k;no\ jnls+ dg x] r+r+ h'O ;'kfFo\
;kmn h'of x] dvf h'O x]8;/+ gf/fo0f uf]kfnof lnrLu' ;u{ y]+ wfM;f jx] ;u{o\ Go+seg+ ;'kfr+
t;s+ ao\ao\ h'u' Do] Pptf dfG5]sf] dfof n] e'gfM B lvp'lsu' xf/f+lrof Vjf . yy] h'of nf
slt km/s kb{5 lhGbuLdf==== u'gu'go\ h"u' h'O . vO lg Rjldof kf} Nof *@ ; yy] RjoftMu'
afv+dL efh' 5Dx Vjkjf;L h'u' gftf+ jo]sn+ 5 h'n ofsM lh h'n 5o\fsM .
Yj ;km"of d's+ afv+ Vjk ef;+ x] RjMu' wof nf emL lgDx ldn]h' u'ln Yofs ..
emL;+ Ajg]kmO efh' ljdn tfd|fsf/of n'kfo\ . Vjf hs xfs' lhu' dfof dfs' .
yMt cy]g+ Rjld efh'of afvgo\ Vjk j o]ld 5 lhs] jnwfM;f gs] £o rfs' ..
efo\of NjfsAjfs wfo]ls 5u" kmo'hg sy+ cfkf yy] Do] xfxf+ 5o\fsMrf k;no\ b'xf'jO .
x] yf;o\ v+s]km", Ajg]km" . ygyfo\ nfsM Vjkef;+ xf/f+lrt 5lKt x] x]dtfO . y'v] r'Gt/L d+}rf
x] RjODx cn] AjlgDx d]Dx Vjkof ;flxTosf/ wfM;f kmfu' ano\ xfn]dfMu' Do] g+ ooM ano\
efh' afa'sfhL ;'jfn n'dg . km]za"sof ;+hfno\ xfn] Ho' nf wof 5o\fsMlrt GjfO . 5o\fsMrf
jo]sn+ emL;+ Vjkef;+ x] Rjo]g' w}u' ;fO8 j r'Gt/L cy] vF Nxfgf Rj+u' xf/f+lrof :jo] x]
t}tMu' b' . lhu' yMu' Joltmut larfM sy+ g+ dg dbO . jof dgdgo\ vF h'O . yd+ 5'+ wfM;f
Gxo\fDx]l;g+ g+ yMu' df+ ef;+ x] Rjo]dfMu' vM glgdjfODx r'Gt/L 5o\fsMrfgfk+ lGxnf lGxnf
t/ plsoft d's+ g]jfMt;]+ y'Os] dkmOnf w}u' :jn] vF NxfgfRj+u' . yy] h'h'+ r'Gt/Lrf kfoM
Uof lrs' . cy]g+ Rjld efh' Gx"R5]etm sjf+ g+ Gxo\flsu' vF ao\ao\ h'O . dg"t;]+ j}t xf/f+rf+
Yj afv+ ;km" Rjoflbof yMu' df+ efo\oft Gofo o+s"u' h'O wof Rjlgu' . kf;flk+ cy] vF Nxfgf
ofMu' t;s+ x] Rj5fo]ax . jo]s oft oSj oSj Rj+yfo\ ug xf/f+rf Yo+s jlg . cg 5yfo\ km]t'O .
n;xgf . gfkgfk+ efh' ljdn tfd|fsf/+ Rjldof yM yd+ x] r'Gt/Lrf kfoM Gxo\fMu' x] vt nf wfwf+
Vjkefo\of afv+oft d's+ dv';f+ lgk" afv+ ;'4 a]xf]; h'O . elt hfo]sf xf]; jO .
Vjk ef;+ x] lkygf lbn . Yj 5u" g+ af+nfMu' b;' Yj afv+ g+ kTofdh'u' v'l;+ r'Os] oM w}u'
h'n d]d]lk+t g+ Vjk] efo\ y'Os] laOu', Rjo]s] wfk" k'j+sf Jo"u' b' . y]6 Vjkof ;fdflhs kl/
laOu' cn] ;o]s] laOu' . j];o\ YofSs ldn] h'Os Ono\ Jono\of n' n'd+sf
r'Gt/L d}+rf Rjld efh' Gx'5] etm sjf+of laOt Rjld t;s+ ;kmn .
5u" lqsf]0ffTds afv+ h'n 5o\fsMrf, r'Gt/L j lkt[;tfTds ;dfhof jftfj/0fo\
xf/f+lrof . 5o\fsfl5lsDx Vjf xfs';f+ lxl;b'Dx AjngfRjlk+ emL ;sn]o+ f 5u" OR5f x] kl/jf/
5o\fsMrf, t'O;] Rjgf r+r+wfMDx eltk;Mof hgo\ yMu' s'n yfd] ofo]u' lglt+ 5Dx sfo\of
;fx'lg r'Gt/L cn] Vjf af+nfM;f+ dg af+dnfMDx rfxgf . yg afv+ Rjld Gx'R5] etm sjf+of ofsM
xf/f+rfof dltgfof afv+ x] r'Gt/L d}+rf . sfo\ afvgo\ Vjkof rf]5oF] f ;fx" aL/ axfb'/of 5]F
5o\fsMrf j xf/f+rf nM j ld . cy];f+ lgDx+ hMlk+ 5Dx kf;f cn] ;fx" s[i0fdfgof Ajgfo\ Ejo\
r'Gt/Lof k;no\ alh gMjlg . r'Gt/Lof wfM;f jlgu' afv+ . ofsM sfo\\ h'of g+ cfvM Ajgf dAo"u'

36 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
b'Mv af}Dx]l;s] bO . cn] j x] Ejo\no\ kf;fof sfn xgfRjlg . df+af} db'lk+ Olk+ bfh' a'nfn+
sfo\ rflxF P;OO SjrfMDx sfo]Dx gsltlg Rofu" /Tgnfnoft lshf dv';]+ yM sfo\ eflkof
tludo\ h'ul" n+ Gxo\fDxl;t g+ vMu' vF wfM h'O af}Dx+ dfofofgf tO . yy]h'of /Tgnfn+ bfh'oft /fd
cg . u'ls+ sfo]Dx t+rfof Ejo\ x] dgO . dfd+ sy+ gfnftO . ofpFs sfn xgf Rjlk+ Old . 5Gx'
sfo] t+rfMu' l;Osf af}Dx]l;t efo\ ofgf j af/] a''O Hof ;gfRj+Dx /Tgnfnof kf;f+ lgult r'/f]6
gdjfo]t GxofSjwfM;f+ eftd+ j y'Os] kmOdv' . 5k'of vFo\ j}t Nxj\lg . 5 5]Fo\ b'Dx a'' b'Dx yy]
y'lsof lnRj sfo]d cg+ Bf+ nfgf jO . jx] td+ r'/f]; 5k' g+ s/lk+s] kmj\gf Rjg]dfMnf, lguM
emg lgGx" lt :s"n x] djlg . af}d+ Ajlanwof 5]+ Ko+uM Wo]af nf lDxrfo\ 3fgf h'Odf . 5'+ k/] h'O 5+
lkxfFjlg . ug Yolg ug . cGto\ aL/ axfb'/of nf dl;n wfo] sf . 5+ bfh'+ nf l;Os]dfMu' vMlg
kf;f+ofgf ug Yo+Dx sfo\oft 5]' xO . df+af}of j nf ;dfho\ Aj+nDx vMlg wof lshfd]l;t
OR5f sfo\ a'Osf ;dfho\ Gxfo\ w:jfsf Sog]u' Nxj\gfxO, :jf+ k'of xO . cn] 5' dflg ;f]emf
cn] yM HofylHoly h'nls+ t'tf+ h'O nf w}u' dgof l;wfDx /Tgnfn r'/f]6of ld+ k'sfM jO . bfh'oft
vF u'u' yf}s
+ Gx]of ns;o\ kfgf jo] w's + n. Tjx tof Jofun+ Rjlg 5'tf+ Djfo]s .
cy]x] v'Fof nfn df]x/ afvgo\ 5Dx drf+ vnf dg" dg" ldn]ho' f x] 5]' h'O, hnfvnf
:s"no\ s't'+jgf Rj+u' lz;f snd uy] lDxrfo\ h'O, TjfM af h'O, ;dfh h'O . Yj ;dfh b'g] g+
tofxO{ lnkf j}t vF' kfM ofO . Ajg]u' 5v] nfO yLyL dg"t u'ln+ t;s+ ;f]emflk+, Uoflglk+, u'ln+
cn] wfy]+ v'Ou' Hof ofO . lnkf yMu' j}; jgf xf;f t;s+ xf/flk+, u'ln+ Dx't+' lys ofOlk+ dg+ jfr'lk++
k;M tof gn g+ ;'v dbO . u[xdGqLof kf;fof bO . u'Dx+ stMoft u'xfln ofo]df wfOlk+ ;f u'Dx+
5]'o\ v'of o+s"u' 36\gf+ j}t g+ Hjgfo+sf s]nsfn ;'of+ Ro"tf dt}lk+ cn] u'Dx+ lvrf NjfsfM Ejo\
ofO . cn] 5Dx ;fx"oft Tjfnf+ :jofRj+u' k'ln;+ gOlk+ Yj x] afv+of kfq zdz]/ ;fx" yHoflk+
:jo]ano\ v'ofxMu' ;fdfg GofgfsfMDx j x] ;fx" g+ ;dfho\ bO, b' . cy]nf ;dfh g+ nf emL;+
wof j}t g+ s'g] xOu' afv+ h"n v''of nfn df]x/ . x] bo]su] ' vM gfk+ snf ;+:s[lt, yMu' tlhnlh
Rjldof ;km" SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' 5]F sy+ b'Yofu' b]uM kmnrf 5]' a'' ;tM lx6L k'v" km's km's+ Yj x]
afv+ ;'4 Vjkef;+ RjoftMu' afv+ h'n . ldn] ;dfho\ Djfgf Rjgflk+ emL;+ x] nf bo]lsu' vMlg .
h'ofRjlk+ bfh' lshfoft Aofun+ Rjg] dfo\sf emL;+ jfrfo]s] df . lgGx" Ko]Gx"of Yj clgTo ;+;f/
laOu' afv+ . /fd nId0f y]+ ldn]h'lk+ bfh'lshflk+ yy] x] vM wof Tofuof efjgf bo]sd ] f . 5' x]
yMu' 5]Fo\ hM km's+ gfk+ ldn]h'of b'Mv+ ;'v+ hLjg Hjgf jg] db'u' Yj gZj/ z/L/ Djfgf Rj+tn] dfof
xgf Rjlgyfo\ d]lk+ dg"to\ ;+ut+ 5' vM 5' dv' dltgfof efj+ cfgGb+ sfn xgfRjg] g ls zdz]/
wof dl;of dy'of yMyM Njfk" lksfOu' afv+ h'n ;fx" cn] jlsn zdz]/ yhf]lk+ ;f]emfl;wf to]u'
SjfMgfv+ ld+gMu' 5]' . 5]' t5o\fOlk+ abdf; t y]+ dbO dv' . /Tgnfn j
afv+ sy+ Vjkof uf]d/L Tjf hMvMof lgDx a'nfnof y]+ SjfMgfv+ ld+ gMu' 5]' y]+ dv' .
km'ls a'nfn j /Tgnfn 5]' hMlk+gfk+ hLjg afv+dL efh' Gx"5]etm sjf+of lnkf+u' afv+
yf}+sGx] no\kf} 37
h'n ;Ddfg kmODx /fdz]v/ . Yjx] ;km"of Hofemj\ g+ SjrfO . km's+ lnxf'jlg . b'uf{nfn g+
Gxfkf+Dx AjgfdL Rj;"of lnw+;fo\ lrafv+dL jlg cn] ;Todf]xg h' g+ sf ;f efO{ lhg+ jg]
efh' Zofd cfzfof kf;f e]6]/Lg/L k;no\ wfO . /fdz]v/ oft km;fb h'O . Vjk] Yo+s
;GWof O{ h'nls+ yLyL ;flxTosf/ JoltmTjlk+ jg]dflgu' O{ lnafgf a; g+ d+t h'O . a]tfnL
d'lgu' h'ofRjg . cg x] 5Gx' /fdz]v/h'+ yd+ lrgf :jf+df sf]vfof Gofl; jg]u' g+ lx;L dbof
lnlkj4 ofo] No+ blgu' afv+ ;snl;t Go+sn yMu' v' ;Todf]xg h' oft slg . vF vMlg x nf
vlg . j lnlkj4 dh'u' afv+oft efh' Gx"5]etm y'ls nf Wofg x] dj+u' wof cfof]hs 5Dx]l;t
sjf+ h'+ ;'Ot+ 5'+ dwfM;]+ lnlkj4 ofgf jo]sof ;Mtf jo]soft 6\ofS;L 5uM ldn]ofgf laOt ph+
:ofGofDx kf;f /Tg sf]h"oft Jo"u' h'ofRjg . Yj ofgf jo]s g+ lnxfF jlg . Vjk] Yo+sf 8fOe/+
x'lg+ ;Ddfg kmODx /fdz]v/ afv+ emL ;sl;g+ Woaf kmj\lg . /fdz]v/ h'+ ;'gf+ 6\ofS;L ldn]ofMu'
Ajg] v+u' h'n 5Dx Ajld sy+ . afv+ sy+ g]kfn vM j+ x] k'ln wfO . srdr h'O . 8fOe/+ nfo\s'O
ef;fof sljj/ cn] Do] Rjld b'uf{nfnof kmf]g yfgfo\ o+ls . cg k'ln;+ /fdz]v/oft Dxl;Osf
jO /fdz]v/ oft . g]kfnef;f Ps]8]dL+ ;Ddfg jo]sn+ Wo]af k'ln lg wfO . yMs] wfM;f Wo]af b'u'
j k'/:sf/ /fdz]v/oft ofOu' Hofemj\of vF dv' . k'ln;oft yMt h«u' v' bSj+ slg . gfk+
wfO . y'v] /fdz]v/ ch'rfO yM :jof ysflnlk+ 8fOe/+ 6[ofS;L uODx 5 Wo]af d]lk+;+ 5fo] k'ln
bofg+ yM j ;Ddfg sfo]u' O{ dTolgu' s'nflb l8P;lk ;fx]a lhtM Yjof e/ dtfM 5]Fo\ Yo+sf
jo]sn+ . cy]wf;]+ln b'uf{nfn h'+ yd+ hs dv' Wo]af dk';]+ lnt 5j\ofxM;f 5'ofo]u' pls+ 5Dx
g]kfnef;fof ;+:s[lt sdL{ cn] ;flxTosf/ efh' k'ln; g+ gfk+ jo]df wof gfk+ tofxO . 5]Fo\
;Todf]xg hf]zL g+ Yj vF Sjl5u' wof jo]sgfk+ Yo+sf snfMoft ;Gb'of tfMrf 5sM xlh wof cg
g+ vF Nxfls . /fdz]v/ h'+ yM :jof ysflnDx Rj+u' Sjf/fSjf/f j+u' ;l5j+u' :jkf gf]6 sof
;flxTosf/ cn] nf]s+XjfDx Wofr'dL efh' ;"o{ 8fOe/oft laO . Yj vgfM jo]sof snfMof dg
axfb'/ lkjfof gf+ laO . efh' ;Todf]xg hf]zL g+ Sjf/fSjf/f ldlg . lDxuM ltlg Otf ldof hfsL
h'+ ykfn] l5t Yj ;Ddfg laOu' Sjl5w'gfu' j Gofo] wof t}tMu' :j;M bf+ j+u' vgf . y'ls+ No'
jo]s ;"o{ axfb'/ lkjfoft d]u' bFo\ laO wof ph+ efh' /fd z]v/h'+ cfj+ln yhf]u' ;Ddfgo\ u'an]+
h'O . ofofy]+ dlhof /fdz]v/h' Ono\ x] dfMu' x] djg]u' kf kmo]ls ;To ld;f w/f]wd{ wof .
Hof Sjrfo]sf j yf;o\ Yo+s jlg . cg nf ls yy] GxofOk';] Rj+u' 5u" Tof bh{g afv+of
Sj 5Dx x] vlg dv' . gfk+ Rj+u' Rof k;no\ afv+sMld efh' Gx"5] etm sjf+of yMu' df+ efo\of
O{ 5o\fo]t r'/f];, Rof TjgfM Rjlg . elt No' Nofv+ Ajg] v+u' afv+ t GxofSj Aj+;f+ n'dw+u'
cg l;g] snfsf/ t jof Oldu' arfMxfsMu' gfk+ lnkf g+ yy] x] ch Yj :jof g+ dfs'u' afv+
Hofemj\ Sogf jlg . Olk+ jano\ uy] dg"t jMu' Ajg] bo]df w}u' en;f cn] dgt'g] .
vM lnxfF jg]w'+sf g+ cy] x] dg"t jlg . Gxfkf ;'efo\
uy] vM cg cy] x] h'O . /fdz]v/ of ;Ddfgof lrNnfuf ;KtdL !!$)

38 yf}+sGx] no\kf}
v“UjM Dxl;s]
d"n zAb pRrf/0f vo\ efo\ c+u|]hL
tls tls rfFª pile/role

tls tls yf]kf drop

tls lrg] tls lrg] rfª nufpg' to pile up

ts' ts' jfSnf] dense/thick

ts'lrg] ts'lrg] jfSnf] x'g] to become thick, thicken

ts]g] ts]g] sfddf clNemg' to be entangled

ts]x]+ ts]x]+ lbbL alxgL sisters group

tvtf tVtf leQ] b/fh a rack

tvtf 38L tvtf 38L leQ] 38L walk clock

tlug tlu+ le/fnf], >]0fL a slope rank, grade

tuf]nljlx tuf]Mljlx si6sf/L yellow berried nightshade

tFr tFo\ pmg wool

t+rfdfs' t+tfdfs' kfgb; -v]n_ !pcat (a game)

t5f] t5f] hf} barley


according to lunar calender eight month
t5f]nf t5nf g]kfn ;Djtsf] cf7f}+ dlxgf (May/June)
tRjt tRjM l;ls:t, zfgbf/ serious, dangerous/grand pompous

t5ofo\ t5ofo\ k'm6fNg' to break, crush

tlh tlh /fd|f] ljrf/ conscience, discre!on

tFHof tFHof ;+/If0f protec!on

tlhnlh tlhnlh ;+:s[lt culture

ttf ttf lbbL sister

ttfh' ttfh' cfdfh', efph' husband's elder sister/elder

ttSog] ttSog] c8sg', cNdlng' to be entangled

ttdt jog] ttdtSog] c8sg', cNdlng' busy, run errands

tlug tlu+ txtx k/]sf] terrance

tlug tlu+ >]0fL, :t/ rank, grade, status

tluga'+ tlu+a' kfvf] v]t a teraced field

tuflvg tuflv+ 7"nf] afhf a large drum

yf}+sGx] no\kf} 39
a'v“
!= o]+ dxfgu/ b'g] Rj+u' Ajg]s'lyO g]kfn efiff+ #= jN8{ g]jf cu{gfOh];gof cd]l/sfsof
:yflgo kf7oqmdo\ Aj+s]u' lglt clGtd ?k+ of slh s]z/dfg tfd|fsf/of Uj;fno,
GXoAjo]t j+u' c;f/ !$ ut] lj1lk+ gfk jf;j /fhf]kfWofo j o"P; RofK6/of gfof]
;xnx h'u' b' . Ajg] s'ly 5u' tlu+dlg;] k|d]z >]i7of d+sf s'tno ld;f jfv+ Rjld
Rofu' tlu+ ts b'YofMu' o]+ of tlhnlh gfk+ cgnfOg ;Dd]ng h"u'ln !^Dx doh'
gu/kflnsf b'g] of ;Dkbf, efiff, gvMrvM, lkG; gf+ b'Yofu'ln GofDx Rjldlk+ 8f= l/gf
;+;sf/, zLk snf sf}zn gfk+ g}lts t'nfw/, lbJof tfd|fsf/, nf]rgtf/f t'nfw/,
lzIff ef}uf]lns j k|fs[lts :j?k of ljifo lglh/f]; >]i7 j l/tf dxh{g lkG;+ afv+
gfk+ :yflgo lnlk ts+ b'Yofu' pu' ;k"m Go+s'u' b' .
;fd'bflos j lglh Ajg]s'lyO g+ nfu' h'Ou' $= noklts+ Gxfkf+u' zlgjf/ GXofgf Rj+u' ;M
v+ GXo AjMu' b' . pu' Hof emf]no d=g=kf=of 5u' km/s cleJolQmof lrjfv+ Hof‰jM cfM
pk k|d'v lzIff ljefuof k|ltlglw k|f= ;fdflhs ;+hfn+ o'6o"j+ k|ljlw ;+rfng h'u'
lzIffljb 8f= lq/Tg dfgGw/, ;x k|fWofks b' . j+u' h]i7 !) ut] GXofu' Gxfkf+u' Hof
/fhgnfn hf]zL lkG;+ toflbOu' k|Zgoft ‰jno :jDx afv+ Rjldlk+ sljGb|nfn k|wfg,
kf7oqmd ;ldltlof b'hM 8f= r'Gbf jh|frfo{ k"0f{ d"gsdL j lbJof jh|frfo{ lkG; Ajlt
ln;M ljoflbOu' vM . sfMu' vM . Yj Hof‰j 5'+ On ts oyfjt
@= on gu/kflnsf, jg]kf gu/kflnsf cy] x] GXofgfRjlgu' v+ ;+rfns æDxl;sfÆ k'rM
lyld gu/kflnsf j lslt{k/' gu/kflnsf kfv]+ ljpu' b' .
If]qo b'g] Rj+u' :yflgo Ajg]sl' y g]kfn efiff
ljifon] Aj+su] ' ;xnx h'of Rj+u' a'vF b' .

yf}+sGx] oft, Rjv+, jfv+, Oltxf;,


;+:s[lt cflb n]v t ljof df+ efiff
of w's'lt hfo]sf lbOt
;sn efiff ≈old, Rjld lkGt
Ogfk ofgf Rjgf .
;Dkfbs

40 yf}+sGx] no\kf}

You might also like