Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vol 24 No. 08 Pages 36 January 2021 50
Vol 24 No. 08 Pages 36 January 2021 50
INTER
ss Laws
M
n e
E
i
D
Bu s
IAT
N :
E
O
E :
TI
con
A
ND
m
ics
O U for
F Fin
anc
e
CONTENTS
Board of Studies
(Academic) (2020-21)
INSIDE
Chairman 03 President’s Communication
CA. (Dr.) Debashis Mitra
Vice-Chairman
CA. Sushil Kumar Goyal, Kolkata 04 Vice-President’s Communication
Members
CA. Atul Kumar Gupta, New Delhi
CA. Nihar Niranjan Jambusaria, Mumbai 05 Chairman’s Communication
CA. Anil Satyanarayan Bhandari, Mumbai
CA. Tarun Jamnadas Ghia, Mumbai
CA. Nandkishore Chidamber Hegde, Mumbai 06 CA Final: Advanced Auditing and Professional Ethics
CA. Chandrashekhar Vasant Chitale, Pune
CA. Shriniwas Yeshwant Joshi, Mumbai
CA. Durgesh Kumar Kabra, Mumbai
CA. Aniket Sunil Talati, Ahmedabad 21 CA Intermediate: Economics for Finance
CA. Dayaniwas Sharma, Hyderabad
CA. Rajendra Kumar P, Chennai
CA. M P Vijay Kumar, Chennai 30 CA Foundation: Business Laws
CA. Pramod Kumar Boob, Jaipur
CA. Manu Agrawal, Kanpur
CA. Anuj Goyal, Ghaziabad
CA. Prakash Sharma,Jaipur 35 News Updates
CA. Kemisha Soni, Indore
CA. Satish Kumar Gupta, Jaipur
CA. Pramod Jain, New Delhi 36 Crossword
CA. Charanjot Singh Nanda, New Delhi
Dr. P. C. Jain, New Delhi
Adv. Vijay Kumar Jhalani, New Delhi
President and Editor-in-Chief Chairman and Editor
Co-opted Members CA. Atul Kumar Gupta, New Delhi CA. (Dr.) Debashis Mitra, Kolkata
CA. Amarjit Chopra
CA. Ashok Sharma Vice President Vice-Chairman
CA. Mukesh Goyal CA. Nihar Niranjan Jambusaria, Mumbai CA. Sushil Kumar Goyal, Kolkata
CA. (Dr.) M.S. Jadhav
CA. Senthil Kumar RM
CA. Viral Kiran Mehta Director- Board of Studies Editorial Support
CA. Aditya Kumar Maheshwari CA. Vandana D Nagpal Dr. Ruchi Agarwal, Assistant Secretary
CA. Jayesh Gupta
Office
Board of Studies, The Institute of Chartered, Accountants of India, ICAI Bhawan,
Total Circulation: 2,56,461 A-29, Sector-62, Noida-201 309. Phone : 0120-3045907
I
t is with great pleasure that I extend my heartiest wishes to at the Final level is open book and case study based. With a view
you all for a healthy, prosperous and wonderful new year to augment the preparation and practice of the students on the
2021. I am pretty hopeful that the hard lessons learnt from same, a new publication containing the independent MCQs, case
the pandemic during the past year will be succeeded by unfolding scenario based MCQs and case-study based questions is being
of innumerable opportunities, hopes, aspirations, vigour and prepared and will be available shortly.
vitality by the dawn of this New Year. Each year end marks the While theoretical knowledge provides necessary foundation,
beginning of new aspirations, dreams and ambitions. New Year is practical training helps aspiring CAs to apply the concepts learnt
the most appropriate time for all of us to take pledge that we will in theoretical education in practical scenarios on real-time basis,
serve our society with utmost sincerity, honesty, transparency thus honing their analytical and application skills as well as their
and thereby contribute to the overall development of the nation. oral and written skills. Therefore, my advice to you to sincerely
“Begin to be now what you will be hereafter”. William James. undertake your three-year mandatory practical training which
is the USP of the Chartered Accountancy course. It would be
I believe that those of you who have appeared in the November
appropriate to say that Practical Training is the bedrock on which
2020 CA examinations must be eagerly waiting for the results. My
ICAI’s distinction as an esteemed professional institution has
best wishes are with you and I hope that you will be able to achieve
been strongly built. Completion of practical training is critical for
success with flying colours. November 2020 examinations have
ensuring achievement of professional competence expected from
been one of the most challenging examinations in the history of
a chartered accountant, which ultimately enhances the credibility
the ICAI. Organising the Chartered Accountancy examinations
of the profession and protects public interest. Effective and
in physical mode at more than 1085 examination centres at global
sincere practical training would certainly lay the firm base for the
level in the midst of the pandemic and at the same time ensuring
ongoing development of professional competence throughout
the safety of the candidates, had been a foremost challenge. The
the career of a chartered accountant.
ICAI undertook adequate measures for the safety of candidates
without compromising the high standards, sanctity and fairness Keeping in mind the importance of practical training in
in the conduct of the examination. I must also compliment the developing professionally competent chartered accountants, a
fighting spirit of the candidates who, undeterred by the challenges two-level practical training assessment was introduced in the year
posed due to pandemic, appeared for the examinations. 2018 to assess the professional knowledge and intellectual skills
acquired by an aspiring CA in the course of practical training.
Those students who opted to appear for November 2020
Forthcoming Practical Training Assessment is scheduled to be
Cycle II examination commencing from January 21st, 2021 need
organised in this month on two consecutive weekends - 9th - 10th
to gear up and prepare. Chartered Accountancy course requires
and 16th - 17th of January, 2021.
a lot of perseverance and hard work. Perseverance makes all the
difference between success and failure as the future belongs to Before I conclude, I also express my best wishes on the 72nd
those who pursue their tasks unmindful of problems encountered. Republic Day of our beloved motherland – a day to remember
with gratitude, the enormous efforts and sacrifices of millions of
The Chartered Accountancy examination calls for a holistic
freedom fighters whose blood and sweat gave us Independence
professional approach. It is my earnest desire that the students
and created our Republic. Above all, this is a day to cherish
pass in their first available attempts and join the realms of
our republican values. I hope and sincerely cherish that in our
the profession at an early date. However, keep in mind that
country peace and prosperity prevail forever.
successful Chartered Accountants of future will be those who
see the qualification as the beginning point and not the end for Wishing you all the best in all your future endeavours!!
their professional education and development. In the dynamic
professional environment, you should continue to learn and Yours sincerely
update your skills.
Students’ interest has always been the topmost priority of the
Institute and for this, ICAI takes various initiatives to facilitate
their learning. The updation of Study Material is a constant
process. This entails meticulous quality review of the syllabus and
contents by ICAI. As conveyed in my previous communication,
I take pleasure to inform you that the rationalised and revised CA. ATUL K. GUPTA
editions of the Study Materials for all the papers at all the three PRESIDENT, ICAI, NEW DELHI
Dear Students,
T
he past year, with all its tribulations, has come to an your application and analytical skills and acquire and develop
end but has taught us an important lesson that we need the requisite professional competence expected at the point of
to take all odds in our stride and should strive to come qualification.
out as a winner. We pray to the Almighty for a better year ahead
The Board of Studies conducts MCQ-based assessment of CA
filled with happiness and prosperity. I, on behalf of the Institute
students after completion of first and second year of practical
of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), feel really delighted
training. In this series, the next test is being conducted in the
to convey my best wishes to all of you for a very prosperous and
month of January, 2021. This test is home-based and students
happy New Year 2021. Hope this New Year brings with it new
can appear in the test from the convenience of their homes. In
hopes and opportunities to explore new areas of professional
order to appear in the test, students are required to meet the
and personal success. Let’s make a resolve and regard New
basic system requirements at their place so that they can take
Year as a fresh opportunity for the betterment and to set higher
the examination in a hassle-free manner. These requirements
benchmarks as students of the Accountancy Profession. I also
are mentioned on the registration portal. All the students who
extend my warm greetings on the occasion of 72nd Republic
have appeared in the Final examination in November, 2020 or
Day of our nation. We salute our freedom fighters who sacrificed
are appearing in the Cycle-II Final examinations are advised to
their invaluable lives to redeem our country from the bondage of
complete their practical training assessment at the earliest.
foreign rule.
For the overall development of the CA students, virtual-cum-
I am sure that the students who have appeared in November 2020
physical two-days International Conference for the CA students
CA Examinations must be eagerly waiting for the declaration of
has been organized at Ahmedabad, Gujarat on 16th and 17th
the results. My best wishes are with you and I hope that you will
January, 2021. The theme for the conference is “Aptitude,
be able to achieve success with flying colors. Students who have
Attitude, Altitude”. Students from various International Bodies
opted out from November 2020 Examinations and opted for
are invited to participate virtually in the said International
November 2020 Cycle – II scheduled from 21st January 2021 to
Conference as it would help to learn and appreciate the impact
7th February 2021, due to any contingency, must stay focused
of innovations across the borders. This platform shall offer an
and give their best. I again extend my best wishes to all of you.
excellent opportunity for Chartered Accountancy students from
I am sure that you would improve your performance with your
different parts of India to share their knowledge and experiences.
persistent efforts and do exceedingly well to prove your mettle.
It is a step towards holistic education. It is my earnest desire that
The Board of Studies continuously strives to provide quality a large number of students join and participate in this grand
inputs to enhance student learning. In this direction, BoS would event. We, at the Institute are sincerely committed to work for
be coming out with a 100-page MCQ booklet in select papers the betterment of students.
of Intermediate and Final course, wherein assessment is partially
Stay safe, stay healthy.
MCQ based i.e., for 30 marks. This booklet would comprise a
mix of case scenario based MCQs, independent application- Yours sincerely
oriented MCQs and knowledge-based MCQs in each of the
select subjects. You are expected to solve these MCQs on your
own after reading the concepts and provisions discussed in
the Study Material, and thereafter, compare your answers with
the given answers. While attempting to solve these questions,
you should proceed in a systematic manner by first reading the
scenario/facts as well as the options given carefully; thereafter,
identifying the relevant provision(s)/concept(s) to be applied to
the facts of the case and finally, applying the same correctly to
choose the correct option to the question. The process of critical CA. NIHAR N JAMBUSARIA
thinking involved in solving MCQs will help you further hone VICE PRESIDENT, ICAI
"Small deeds done are better than great deeds planned." - Peter Marshall
CHAIRMAN’S COMMUNICATION
time table to fit in theory and practical subjects intermittently since
reading too much theory at a stretch may become monotonous.
Step III: Ideal study pattern
Ideally, when you take up any topic for study, you must first go
through the relevant chapter of the study material for building a
strong conceptual base. After reading each chapter in the study
material, try to work out the illustrations and exercise questions
given therein, and thereafter compare your answers with the
answers given therein. This would help you to identify your
mistakes and also learn from your mistakes. Further, this process
would help in revision of the concepts and principles contained
in each chapter of the study material and application of the same
while solving practical problems.
Step IV: Learn, revise, revise again
The first round of study should be concluded at least 3 months
before the examination; the initial round/s of revision should be
My Dear Students, done in the penultimate two months prior to the examination
W
and the final revision in the last month before the examination.
ishing you all a very happy and prosperous New Solving the questions and problems in the Revision Test Papers
Year! The New Year is a beginning with new and Mock Test Paper on your own would help you to self-assess
promises, new resolutions, and new aspirations. I the effectiveness of your study and revision.
believe we all make new resolutions, knowing that In this manner, you would be able to complete revision of
some may be achieved, and some may be left, midway but still the entire syllabus. Such effective planning would help you to
we continue with our persistent efforts. This shows our power approach the question paper with a positive attitude and this
of positivity and zeal to do new things and determination to would ultimately be reflected in your results. Do remember that
accomplish them. Please maintain the same zeal and zest for your implementation of your study plan is equally important – the
CA Course as well. plan should not be on paper alone. Do make sure you adhere to
Students appeared in November, 2020 examination - the timetable and avoid significant deviation, except, of course,
November 2020 examinations are over, I am sure many of you in case of exigency. Rest assured, if you put in your best efforts,
have performed satisfactorily. We hope that you succeed with success will surely follow.
flying colours. BoS Endeavours
Students appearing in November 2020 Cycle II examination
commencing from 21st January, 2021 - To students who have The Board of Studies, having direct interface with the students,
opted out of November, 2020 examinations, our best wishes has always been striving to add value to all its publications for
for upcoming exams in January, 2021. You should resist all the benefit of the students at large. This year, a comprehensive
distractions and give your 100%. exercise for quality enhancement of Study Materials has been
Students appearing in May, 2021 examination onwards undertaken in all subjects across the three levels, by adding more
- Effective planning is undoubtedly the key to success in examples/illustrations/questions for conceptual understanding
examinations. including pictorials, flow charts, and tables making the study
Your study plan may ideally be on the following lines material more students friendly.
These value added Study Materials relevant for May, 2021
Step I : Make a comprehensive study time examination and onwards, are intended to make students’
table learning both effective and enjoyable. Hope you all are availing
Making a detailed study time table well in advance would facilitate the benefits of the added features while preparing for May, 2021
in organising your study in an effective manner. The time table Examinations.
should be prepared keeping in mind the number of months It is to be clarified that the curriculum at all levels remains
remaining before the examination and the effective number the same. The new study materials, relevant from May, 2021
of hours available in a day for study. The last month should be examination, are available on ICAI’s BoS Knowledge Portal in
earmarked for final revision. The effective number of hours downloadable PDF form and also available at CDS Portal. These
available for study on a working day can range from, 2 to 4 hours will also be available in the form of e-books in due course of time
and on weekends from 10 to 12 hours. In this manner, you can so that students can make notes, annotations etc.
arrive at the total number of hours available for study before the Do also take the maximum advantage of the Free Virtual Coaching
examination. This would encompass the time for initial round & Classes which are conducted by the BOS for your benefit. While
rounds of revision as well. Final level classes targeting May 2021 are already going on, classes
for Intermediate and Foundation will commence in January/
Step II: Allocate time for each subject and February 2021. Please visit BoS knowledge portal for detailed
each topic within the subject announcement in this regard.
The next step is to apportion the time between the different Please remember the following Quote by Swami Vivekananda
subjects. It would, no doubt, involve estimation of time to be “Arise, Awake, stop not till the goal is reached”.
allocated for each subject and also for each topic/chapter of I hope the New Year brings an end to all the concerns related
the subject. The scope of syllabus and the contents of the study to the Pandemic and ushers in peace, happiness and success.
material would help you to broadly assess the time which each
subject and each topic within the subject would consume. The Stay safe, stay healthy.
section-wise weightages for each subject have been webhosted at
the BoS Knowledge Portal. This would also give you an idea of the
number of hours to be allocated for each section.
Of course, you have to keep some percentage margin over and
above the time assessed by you to take care of possible difficulty
in understanding or interpreting concepts, particularly relating to
accounting standards, Ind AS and tax laws. Try to organise your
CA. (DR.) DEBASHIS MITRA
CHAIRMAN, BOARD OF STUDIES (ACADEMIC), ICAI
The Chartered Accountant Student January 2021 05
"Never underestimate your problem or your ability to deal with it." - Robert H. Schuller
ADVANCED AUDITING AND PROFESSIONAL ETHICS
CA FINAL - PAPER 3 - ADVANCED AUDITING AND PROFESSIONAL ETHICS
It has always been the endeavour of Board of Studies to provide quality academic inputs to the students of Chartered Accountancy
Course. Keeping in mind this objective, BoS has decided to come out with a crisp & concise Capsule of each subject to facilitate
students in quick revision before examination.
This series of capsules is on Paper 3: Advanced Auditing & Professional Ethics of Final Course. In this capsule we are covering
Engagement and Quality Control Standards i.e. SA 300, 500 and 600 series (refer March 2019 edition for SA 540 and SA 600). It
may be mentioned that this capsule is a tool for quick revision of some significant areas of Auditing subject, but this should not
be taken as a substitute for the detailed study of the subject. Students are advised to refer to the relevant Study Material, Auditing
Pronouncements and RTP for comprehensive study & revision.
SA 300
SA 315
SA 320
SA 330
Scope Overall Responses: The A) The auditor shall design 1. Irrespective of the assessed
This SA deals auditor shall design & & perform test of controls ROMM, auditor shall
with the auditor’s implement overall responses when: perform substantive
responsibility to address the assessed 1. the auditor expects that procedures.
to design and ROMM at the financial the controls are operating 2. Auditor shall consider
implement statement level. effectively or whether external
responses to 2. Substantive procedures confirmation are to be
ROMM identified alone cannot provide performed as Substantive
& assessed by sufficient appropriate audit audit procedures.
the auditor in Audit Procedures for evidence at the assertion 3. Auditor shall perform
accordance Assessed ROMM at level. substantive procedures
with SA 315 Assertion Level: related to financial
B) The auditor shall perform
in a financial The auditor shall design statement closing process
other audit procedures along
statement audit. & perform further audit and those responsive to
with inquiry & determine
procedures whose nature, significant risks.
whether the controls to be
timing & extent are based 4. When substantive
tested depend upon indirect
on & are responsive to the procedures are performed
controls.
Objective assessed ROMM at the at an interim date, the
assertion level. C) The auditor shall test auditor shall cover the
To obtain
controls for a particular time remianing period also.
sufficient &
or throughout the period. 5. If misstatements that the
appropriate audit
evidence about D) The auditor may use audit auditor did not expect
In designing Further Audit
the assessed evidence obtained in previous when assessing ROMM
Procedures, the auditor
ROMM, through audits after considering are detected at an interim
shall:
designing & continuing relevance. date, the auditor shall
a) Consider the reasons
implementing for the assessment given E) The auditor shall test the evaluate whether the
appropriate to the ROMM at the controls for significant risk in related assessment of risk
responses to assertion level for each current period. & planned substantive
those risks. class of transactions, procedures covering the
F) When deviations from
account balance and remaining period need to be
controls are detected, the
disclosure. modified.
auditor shall make specific
b) Obtain more persuasive inquires to understand these
audit evidence because matters & their potential
of a higher assessment of consequences.
risk.
Definition
Substantive Procedure: 1. The auditor shall perform audit procedures to evaluate
An audit procedure designed to detect material the adequacy of presentation & disclosures made in the
misstatements at the assertion level. It comprises of: financial statements.
1. Test of details (of classes of transactions, account 2. The auditor shall evaluate the sufficiency &
balances, & disclosures), & appropriateness of audit evidence.
2. Substantive analytical procedures. 3. The auditor shall document:
a) the overall responses and the nature , timing, extent
of further audit procedures performed.
Test of Controls:
b) the linkage of those procedures with assessed risks
An audit procedure designed to evaluate operating at the assertion level.
effectiveness of controls in preventing, or detecting and c) the results of audit procedures.
correcting, material misstatements at the assertion level.
SA 402
Scope of Objective of the Types of Reports & their Requirements Reporting by the
the SA Auditor use by user auditor of the SA user auditor
This SA deals The objective of the user A) Type 1 Report The auditor shall obtain
with the auditor’s auditor, when the user entity Report on the description & an understandng of the
responsibility to uses the services of service design of controls at a service services provided by a
obtain sufficient organisation are: organisation. service organisation,
appropriate audit including internal control
evidence when a B) Type 2 Report that relate to the services
user entity uses Report on the description, provided by the service
the services of one To obtain an understanding design & operating orgainsation.
or more service of the nature & significance effectiveness of controls at a
organisations. of the service provided by the service organisation.
service organisation & their C) In determining the
effect on the user entity's sufficiency & appropriateness If the auditor is unable
internal control, sufficient of audit evidence provided by to obatin sufficient
to identify & assess the Type 1 & Type 2 report, the understanding from the user
ROMM. user auditor shall be satisfied entity, the user auditor shall
as to: obtain that understanding
(i) The service auditor's by:
professional competence. a) Obtaining Type1 or
To design & perform audit (ii) The adequacy of standards Type 2 report.
procedures responsive to under which the Type 1 or b) Contacting service
those risks. Type 2 report was issued. organisation through
D) When the user auditor user entity.
plans to use Type 2 report c) Visiting the service
as audit evidence, the user organisation &
auditor shall determine performing procedures.
whether the service auditor's d) Using another auditor to
report provides sufficient & perform the procedures.
appropriate audit evidence
about the effectiveness of the
Definition controls to support theuser
auditor's risk assessment.
Service auditor: An auditor who, at
the request of the service organisation,
provides an assurance report on the
controls of a service organisation.
Service Organisation: A third party
1. If the user auditor is unable to obtain sufficient
organisation that provides services
appropriate audit evidence regarding the services
to user entities that are part of those
provided by the service organisation, the user auditor
entities' information system relevant
shall modify his audit opinion.
to financial reporting.
2. The user auditor shall not refer to the work of the
User Auditor: An auditor who audits service auditor in the user's auditor report containing
& reports on the financial statements unmodified opinion.
of a user entity. 3. If user auditor makes reference of the work of the
User Entity: An entity that uses service auditor in user auditor's report with modified
a service organisation and whose opinion, the user's auditor report shall also indicate
financial statements are being that such reference does not diminish the user auditor's
audited. responsibility for that opinion.
SA 450
This SA deals The objective of the Auditor 1. The auditor shall accumulate The auditor shall first
with the auditor’s is to evaluate: misstatements identified during reassess the materiality
responsibility audit other than those clearly determined in accordance
to evaluate the trivial. with SA 320.
effect of identified 2. The auditor shall determine
misstatements whether the overall audit
on the audit and 1. The effect of identified strategy or audit plan need to
of uncorrected The auditor shall
misstatements on audit be revised.
misstatement s , determine whether
and 3.
If at auditor's request,
if any, on u n c o r r e c t e d
the financial management has examined misstatements are
statements. or corrected any misstatement material, individually or in
that was detected, the auditor aggregate by considering:
2. The effect of uncorrected shall perform additional
misstatement, if any, on a) The size & nature of
audit procedure to determine misstatements.
the financial statements. whether misstatement remains.
b)
The effect of
4. The auditor shall communicate u n c o r r e c t e d
all accumulated misstatements misstatements of prior
on timely basis at appropriate periods.
level of management with a
request to correct them.
5.
If management refuses to
correct them, auditor shall
consider managment's
reasons for refusal and shall
evaluate whether the financial
statements as a whole are free
from material misstatement.
Definition
Misstatement: A difference
Communication with TCWG:
between the amounts,
The auditor shall communicate with TCWG
classification, presentation or
a) uncorrected misstatements & their effects and request that
disclosure of a reported financial
uncorrected misstatements be corrected.
statement item and the amount,
b) the effect of uncorrected misstatements related to prior periods.
classification, presentation or
disclosure that is required for the
item to be in accordance with the
applicable FRF. Written Representation:
The auditor shall request a written representation from managment/
Misstatements can arise from
TCWG whether they believe the effects of uncorrected misstatements
error or fraud.
are immaterial, individually or in aggregate, to the financial statements
as a whole.
Uncorrected Misstatements:
Misstatements that the auditor has
accumulated during the audit and
Documentation:
that have not been corrected.
1. The amount below which misstatements would be regarded as
clearly trivial.
2. All misstatements accumulated during the audit & whether they
have been corrected.
3. The auditor's conclusion as to whether the uncorrected
misstatements are material and the basis of that conclusion.
This SA deals with the To design and The auditor shall consider the relevance Audit evidence to
auditor's responsibility perform audit and reliability of the information to be draw reasonable The auditor shall
to design and perform procedures in used as audit evidence. conclusions on determine what
audit procedures to obtain such a way as to which to base the modifications
sufficient and appropriate enable the auditor When information from management auditor's opinion or additions to
audit evidence to be to obtain sufficient expert is used, the auditor shall is obtained by audit procedures
able to draw reasonable appropriate audit evaluate the competence, objectivity performing: are necessary
conclusions on which to evidence to be able of the expert, appropriateness of the 1. R i s k to resolve the
expert's work. Assessment matter and
base the auditor's opinion. to draw reasonable
conclusions on procedures shall consider
This SA is applicable to When using information produced by
which to base 2. Further audit the effect of the
all the audit evidence the entity, the auditor shall evaluate
auditor's opinion. procedures matter, if any, on
obtained during the the reliability, completeness, accuracy
comprising of : other aspects of
course of audit. of the information.
Test of the audit.
controls and
Definition Substantive
procedures
Audit Evidence: Information used by the auditor in arriving at the conclusions on which
the auditor's opinion is based. It includes both information contained in the accounting
records underlying the financial statements and other information.
Appropriateness: It is the measure of quality of audit evidence.
Sufficieny: It is the measure of quantity of audit evidence.
SA 510 - "Initial Audit Engagements- Opening Balances" Refer page 18 for definition
SA 520
"Analytical Procedures"
Definition
Analytical Procedures means evaluations of financial information through
analysis of plausible relationships among both financial and non-financial data.
Analytical procedures also encompass such investigation as is necessary of
identified fluctuations or relationships that are inconsistent with other relevant
information or that differ from expected values by a significant amount.
SA 530
"Audit Sampling"
Scope of the SA & Sample design, size and Performing Other points of
Objective of the auditor selection of items for testing Audit Procedures consideration
Scope 1. While designing audit 1. The auditor shall perform 1. The auditor shall investigate
This SA applies when the sample, the auditor shall appropriate audit the nature and cause of
auditor has decided to use consider the purpose of procedure on each item deviation or misstatement
audit sampling in performing the audit procedure and selected. identified and evaluate its
audit procedures. It deals the characteristics of the 2. If audit procedure is not possible effect.
with auditor's use of statistical population. applicable on the selelcted 2. When a deviation/
and non statistical sampling. 2. The auditor shall determine item, apply the procedure misstatement is considered
sample size sufficient to on a replacement item. as anomaly, the auditor shall
reduce sampling risk to an 3. If the auditor is unable to perform audit procedures to
Objective acceptably low level. apply the designed audit obtain high degree of certainty
To provide a reasonable 3. The auditor shall select procedure to a selected that it is not representative of
basis for the auditor to items for the sample such item, treat that item as the population.
draw conclusions about the that each sampling unit in a deviation from the 3. For test of details, the auditor
population from which the the population has a chance prescribed control, in case shall project misstatements
sample is selected. of selection. of tests of controls, or a found in the sample to the
misstatement, in the case population.
of tests of details. 4. The auditor shall evaluate
Definition the results of the sample
Audit Sampling: and whether the use
of audit sampling has
The application of audit procedures to less than 100% of provided a reasonable basis
items within a population of audit relevance such that all for conclusion about the
the sampling units have a chance of selection in order to population tested.
provide the auditor with a reasonable basis on which to
draw conclusions about the entire population.
SA 550
"Related Parties"
1. Risk Assessment procedures and related activities. 1. Inspect the underlying contracts and
2. Understanding the Entity's related party relationships and evaluate:
transactions. a) the business rationale of the transactions.
3. Maintaining alertness for related party information when b) whether the terms of transactions are
reviewing records or documents. consistent with managment's explanations.
4. Sharing related party information with the Engagement team. c) whether such transactions have been
5. Identification and assessment of the risk of material properly accounted for.
misstatement associated with related party transactions and 2. Obtain audit evidence that the transactions
relationships.
have been appropriately authorised and
6. Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement associated approved.
with related party relationships and transactions.
Definition
Related party- A party that is either:
i) a related party as defined in applicable FRF.
ii) where applicable FRF establishes minimal or no related party requirements:
a) A person or other entity that has control or significant influence, directly or
indirectly through one or more intermediaries, over the reporting entity,
b) Another entity over which the reporting entity has control or significant
influence, directly or indirectly through one or more intermediaries; or
c) Another entity that is under common control with the reporting entity
through having:
• common controlling ownership,
• owners who are close family members, or
• common key management.
"Subsequent Events"
SA 570
"Going Concern"
This SA deals 1. To obtain sufficient and Use of Going The auditor shall
with the auditor's appropriate audit evidence Concern Basis communicate with
responsibilities and conclude on the of Accounting is TCWG, events
in the audit appropriateness of the inappropriate The or conditions
of financial management's use of going auditor shall express identified that may
statements concern. an adverse opinion. cast significant
relating to going 2. To assess whether a material doubt on the entity's
concern and the uncertainty exists about the ability to continue
implications on the entity's ability to continue as a as a going concern.
auditor's report. going concern. Use of Going Concern
3. However, auditor cannot be basis of accounting
expected to guarantee the is appropriate but a If there is delay
entity's ability to continue as a material uncertainty in the approval
going concern. exists and: of the financial
Adequate disclosure statements and the
1.
To make specific of material auditor believes that
assessment of the 1. Requesting managment to make its uncertanity is made such delay can be
entity's ability to asessment relating to entity's ability to in the financial related to events or
continue as a going continue as a going concern. s t a t e m e n t s - conditions relating
concern. 2. Evaluating management's plan of future Unmodified Opinion to going concern
actions. and a separate section assessment, the
3. Analysing the cash flow forecast of the "Material Uncertainty auditor shall
2. To make appropriate entity. related to going perform additional
disclosures in 4. Considering the additional facts or concern". procedures as well
connection with information available. as consider the
going concern in the 5. Requesting Written Representation from effect on auditor's
financial statements. management regarding the plans of future conclusion.
actions and the feasibility of these plans. Use of Going Concern
basis of accounting
is appropriate but a
material uncertainty
exists and:
Definition - SA 505 - "External Confirmations" Adequate disclosure
External Confirmation: Audit evidence obtained as a direct written of material
response to the auditor from a third party (the confirming party), in paper uncertanity is
form, or by electronic or other medium. not made in the
Positive confirmation request – A request that the confirming party financial statements-
respond directly to the auditor indicating whether the confirming party Qualified/ adverse
agrees or disagrees with the information in the request, or providing the opinion and mention
requested information. in the basis of opinion
paragraph.
Negative confirmation request – A request that the confirming party
respond directly to the auditor only if the confirming party disagrees with
the information provided in the request.
Non-response – A failure of the confirming party to respond, or fully
Management unwilling
respond, to a positive confirmation request, or a confirmation request
to make or extend its
returned undelivered.
assessment- Auditor
Exception – A response that indicates a difference between information shall consider the
requested to be confirmed, or contained in the entity’s records, and implications for the
information provided by the confirming party. auditor's report.
SA 580
"Written
Representations"
Scope of Objectives of Written Representation Date & Periods covered by Important points
the SA the auditor as Audit Evidence Written Representation to be considered
Doubts as to reliability of
This SA deals 1.
To obtain written Although Written Written Representations:
with the auditor's representation from the Representations If written representations
responsibility to management or TCWG that provide necessary are inconsistent with other
obtain written they believe that they have audit evidence, audit evidence, auditor shall
representation from fulfilled their responsibility they do not provide perform audit procedures
management and, for the preparation of the sufficient appropriate to resolve the matter.
where appropriate, financial statements and audit evidence on If the auditor concludes that
those charged with for the completness of the their own. the written representation
governance. information provided to the are not reliable, the auditor
auditor. shall take appropriate
action in accordance with
The date of Written SA 705.
Representation shall be
as near as practicable to,
2. To support other audit but not after, the date of Requested Written
evidence relevant to the the auditor's report on Representation not
financial statements or the financial statements. provided:
specific assertions in the
Written Representation Auditor shall discuss
financial statements by means
shall be for all financial with the management,
of written representations.
statements and periods re-evaluate the integrity
referred to in the auditor's of management, take
report. appropriate actions
including the impact on
3. To respond appropriately audit report as per SA 705.
to written representation
provided by managment/
TCWG.
Definition - SA 510 - "Initial Audit Engagements-
Opening Balances"
SA 610
Scope of External auditor's Objectives of Using the work of Using Internal When using the
responsibility for the External the Internal Audit Auditors to provide work or direct
the SA the Audit Auditor Function direct assistance assistance
SA 620
Auditor's Expert:
An individual or organisation possessing 4. Obtaining an Understanding of the field of
expertise in a filed other than accounting expertise of the Auditor's expert
or auditing, whose work in that field is
used by the auditor to assist the auditor in
obtaining sufficient and appropriate audit
evidence. 5. Agreeing with the Auditor's expert in
writing.
Management's Expert:
An individual or organisation possessing
expertise in the field other than accounting 6. Evaluating the adequacy of the Auditor's
or auditing, whose work in that field is Expert work.
used by the entity to assist the entity in
preparing the financial statements.
Public Finance
Instruments of
Fiscal Policy
Fiscal policy
Level
Pump priming involves Compensatory SAS1
a one-shot injection spending is said to be
of government resorted to when the
expenditure into a government spending
P3
depressed economy is carried out with
with the aim of the obvious intention P2
Compensatory Spending
boosting business to compensate the
confidence and deficiency in private AD2
P1
encouraging larger investment.
private investment. AD1
It is a temporary fiscal
stimulus in order to Y
set off the multiplier Real GDP (Y)
process.
Contractionary Fiscal Policy for combating Inflation
P2
P1
AD2 Crowding Out
P3
• Crowding out effect is the negative effect fiscal policy may
AD1 generate when money from the private sector is ‘crowded
out’ to the public sector. In other words, when spending by
government in an economy replaces private spending, the
Y1 Y2 Real GDP (Y) latter is said to be crowded out.
• For example, if government provides free computers to
Expansionary Fiscal Policy for combating Recession students, the demand from students for computers may not
be forthcoming. When government increases it’s spending
by borrowing from the loanable funds from market, the
demand for loans increases and this pushes the interest rates
It is designed to restrain the levels of economic up. Private investments are sensitive to interest rates and
activity of the economy during an inflationary therefore some private investment spending is discouraged.
phase by decreasing the aggregate expenditures
Contractionary and aggregate demand through a decrease in
Fiscal Policy all types of government spending and/ or an
increase in taxes.
• Money refers to assets which are commonly used and • First propounded by Irving Fisher of Yale University in his
accepted as a means of payment or as a medium of exchange book ‘The Purchasing Power of Money’ published in 1911
or of transferring purchasing power. and later by the neo-classical economists.
• Money is totally liquid and has generalized purchasing • Both versions of the QTM demonstrate that there is strong
power and is generally acceptable in settlement of all relationship between money and price level and the quantity
transactions and in discharge of other kinds of business of money is the main determinant of the price level or the
obligations including future payments. value of money.
r*
Transacton Motive
• The transactions motive for holding cash relates to ‘the need Interest Rate
for cash for current transactions for personal and business
exchange.
• Lr = kY, Where, Lr is the transactions demand for money, r1
k is the ratio of earnings which is kept for transactions
purposes and Y is the earnings. r2 Liquidity Trap
• The aggregate transaction demand for money is a function Region
r0
of national income.
Precautionary Motive
• Precautionary motive is to meet unforeseen and un
predictable contingencies involving money payments and
depends on the size of the income, prevailing economic as 0 M1 M2 M3 M4
well as political conditions and personal characteristics of Speculative Demand for Money
the individual such as optimism/ pessimism, farsightedness
etc. Aggregate Speculative Demand for Money
Speculative Motive
• The speculative motive reflects people’s desire to hold cash Post-Keynesian
in order to be equipped to exploit any attractive investment Developments in the Theory
opportunity requiring cash expenditure. of Demand for Money
• The speculative demand for money and interest are
inversely related.
Baumol's Inventory Friedman's Tobin's The
Approach to Restatement of Demand for
Transaction the Quantity Money as Behavior
When the current rate of
Balances Theory toward Risk
interest rn is higher than the
critical rate of interest rc, the
entire wealth is held by the
Individual's individual wealth-holder in the Baumol (1952) and Tobin (1956) developed a
Speculative deterministic theory of transaction demand for
demand for form of government bonds. If Inventory
Money the rate of interest falls below Approach to ‘real cash balance’, known as Inventory Theoretic
the critical rate of interest rc, Transaction Approach, in which money is essentially viewed
the individual will hold his Balances as an inventory held for transaction purposes.
entire wealth in the form of People hold an optimum combination of bonds
speculative cash balances. and cash balance, i.e., an amount that minimizes
the opportunity cost.
The optimal average money holding is: a positive
function of income Y, a positive function of the
m price level P, a positive function of transactions
costs c, and a negative function of the nominal
interest rate i.
Interest Rate
rc
Friedman's Restatement of the Quantity Theory
The Concept of • L1 = NM3 + All deposits with the post office savings banks
Money Supply (excluding National Savings Certificates).
• L2 = L1 +Term deposits with term lending institutions and
refinancing institutions (FIs) + Term borrowing by FIs +
Certificates of deposit issued by FI’s.
The Sources Measurement Determinants The Concept • L3 = L2 + Public deposits of non-banking financial
of Money of Money of Money of Money companies
Supply Supply Supply Multiplier
Determinants of Money Supply
Interest rate
Lower will be
Channel Higher the
liuidity in the
CRR with the
system and
RBI
vice versa
"If you don't like the road you're walking, start paving another one."
- Dolly Parton
1
B 2
I 3
T 4
T E A 5
F I 6
N 7
I T 8
E
9
A C U 10
T E 11
R 12
C I 13
O P E N
14
N O T A R Y 15
O F 16
F E R D
17
N O R M 18
E M A I L
19
L 20
R O S E P V 21
L 22
O 23
T
E 24
A T 25
T U 26
T E 27
L A G E
28
A D 29
D 30
I 31
R A T E 32
V I R E
D N 33
B E T E N 34
O I R E
35
S 36
P A 37
C E B A R V 38
S
O 39
I T O 40
P E R 41
T T
42
M I N T O 43
S L R 44
O L E
C N 45
E 46
N T 47
R E A T P A
48
I T I E 49
I N G 50
T E 51
A M
52
I E 53
N E M O 54
U P P E R
55
I R I S 56
T I E A 57
E G
A contract is said
Legal
to be performed Promisor himself Promisor’s Agent
-Either perform, or
Representatives
when the
parties
to the -Offer to
contract
perform their
promises
makes
Fails to perform
it impossible
refuses, or his part of the By his act
(11) Impossibility existing at the time of contract or Initial to perform his
contract, or
Impossibility obligation
Case Effects
If the impossibility is known to Such an agreement is void-ab- (2) Effects of the Breach of Contract
the parties initio
If unknown to the parties Such an agreement is void on
the ground of mutual mistake The aggrieved party is
If known to the promisor only Such promisor must gets a right to proceed
relieved from performing
against the party at fault
compensate for any loss his obligation, and
which such promisee sustains
through the non performance
of the promise.
The Chartered Accountant Student January 2021 31
BUSINESS LAWS
(3) Types of breach of contract
Case laws Facts Decision
Breach of contract Gibbons A business man whose In the case, it was held
Vs. West credit has suffered will that a non-trader cannot
Minister get exemplary damages get heavy damages in
Bank even if he has sustained the like circumstances,
Anticipatory breach Actual breach no pecuniary loss. unless the damages are
alleged and proved as
special damages.
breach occuring
before time fixed Refusal to perform
for performance has promise on the
arrived scheduled date III. Special types of Contract
Contingent
(4) Liability for Damages Quasi-Contracts
Contracts
Ordinary
damages
Rules Relating to
Cases deemed as
Pre-fixed Special
Enforcement of
Quasi -Contracts
damages damages Contingent Contracts
Contingent contract is
Nominal
damages
(a) Rule 1 regarding contingent contracts (e) Rule 5 regarding contingent contracts
Where a contingent contract is made to do or not to do • Such contract can be enforced by law if before the
anything if an uncertain future event happens, expiry of fixed time-
• Such event does not happen ,or
• it cannot be enforced by law unless and until that • It become certain that such event will not happen.
event has happened.
• If the event becomes impossible, such contracts
become void.
(f) Rule 6 regarding contingent contracts
(1) Meaning
Quasi
Contract
(c) Rule 3 regarding contingent contracts
(d) Rule 4 regarding contingent contracts Obligation is a duty and not the promise of a party
• Such an obligation/right to recover arises “where a Trikamdas T’ was traveling without The suit was decreed in
person lawfully does anything for another person, vs. Bombay ticket in a tram car and his favour.
or delivers anything to him not intending to do so Municipal on checking he was asked
gratuitously and such other person enjoys the benefit Corporation to pay R5/- as penalty to
thereof, compound transaction.
• the latter is bound to make compensation to the T filed a suit against the
former in respect of, or to restore, the thing so done corporation for recovery
or delivered. on the ground that it was
extorted from him.
NSE launches first agri-commodity futures Rising loan collections bring relief but risks still
linger in securitization
National Stock Exchange of India Ltd (NSE) has launched
India’s loan securitization market is slowly buzzing with
its first agricultural commodity futures contract on crude
activity, encouraged by the broad-based improvement in
degummed soybean oil (CDSO Futures) on December 1, 2020.
loan collections by lenders but risk still persists. Most banks
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/ and even some non-banking financial companies (NBFCs)
n e w s / n s e - l aun ch e s - f ir s t - a g r i - c o mm o di t y - f u t ur e s / have reported a marked improvement in repayments after
articleshow/79529036.cms the economy steadily unlocked from June. Delinquency rates,
especially those of home and auto loans, have dipped.
SEBI considering revamp of IPO rules on equity https://www.livemint.com/market/mark-to-market/in-
dilution: Sources securitisation-rising-loan-collections-bring-relief-but-risks-
The capital markets regulator may cut down the requirement linger-11607685972412.html
of 10 percent equity dilution for IPOs that have more than Rs
4,000 crores of post-issue equity capital.
Banks turn to AI to curtail loan frauds
https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/ipo/sebi- Banks such as state-run Punjab National Bank (PNB) are
considering-revamp-of-ipo-rules-on-equity-dilution- looking to deploy an artificial intelligence-enabled early
sources-6094151.html warning signal system that crawls the web for information on
borrower’s activities, including news articles and social media.
SEBI introduces flexi cap category in mutual funds https://www.livemint.com/industry/banking/banks-turn-to-
ai-to-curtail-loan-frauds-11603889357341.html
SEBI has given a green signal to the introduction of a flexi
cap category in mutual funds. Schemes in this category are
required to invest at least 65% of their corpus in equity. Unlike ECONOMIC UPDATES
the new multi cap funds, there is no restriction in terms of
allocation to any market cap. RBI keeps repo rate unchanged at 4%, maintains
https://m.economictimes.com/mf/mf-news/sebi-introduces- accommodative stance
flexi-cap-category-in-mutual-funds/articleshow/79084269. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) kept the repo rate unchanged at
cms 4 per cent and maintained the policy stance at accommodative.
The RBI’s Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) made a
SEBI lays downs guidelines for due-diligence on unanimous decision to maintain status-quo after a three-day
debt securities meeting that began on December 2.The reverse repo rate also
The SEBI laid down fresh set of norms for increasing diligence remains steady at 3.35 per cent, RBI Governor Shaktikanta Das
said. “MPC decided to continue with accommodative stands
on debt securities. It prescribed enhanced disclosures in the
of monetary policy as long as necessary, at least till current
trustee deed which would make it easier for debenture trustees
financial year and into next year to revive growth on a durable
to conduct due-diligence on encumbrances of underlying
basis and mitigate the impact of Covid-19 while ensuring that
assets. inflation remains within the target,”
h t t p s : / / w w w. l i v e m i n t . c o m / n e w s / i n d i a / s e b i - l a y s - h t t p s : / / w w w. l i v e m i n t . c o m / v i d e o s / r b i - k e e p s - r e p o -
downs-guidelines-for-due-diligence-on-debt- rate-unchanged-at-4-maintains-accommodative-
securities-11604471006209.html stance-11607073294950.html
The Chartered Accountant Student January 2021 35
RNI NO. 66180/1997 Registered: DL(C)-01/1280/2018-20, D. NO. MH/MR/TECH-47/3/2018-20 License To Post Without Prepayment,
WPP Licence No.: MR/TECH/WPP-247/DL(C)/2018-20 Posted at Mumbai Patrika Channel Sorting Office, Mumbai - 400001
Posting Date: Last three days of advance month & first 04 days of current month, Date of publication: 26th of previous month