Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Travel Blogs and the Implications for

Destination Marketing
BING PAN, TANYA MACLAURIN, AND JOHN C. CROTTS

This study explores travel blogs as a manifestation of Industry Association of America, 67% of online travelers
travel experience. Visitor opinions posted on leading travel (those travelers who have Internet connections) in the
blog sites were analyzed to gain an understanding of the United States search for information on destinations or
destination experience being manifested. Travel blogs on check prices or schedules via the Internet; 41% book airline
Charleston, South Carolina, were collected through the tickets, hotel rooms, or car rentals (Travel Industry
three most popular travel blog sites and three blog search Association 2005). With increasing amounts of travel-
engines. Blogs were analyzed using semantic network related online information, tourists have an enormous
analysis and content analysis methods to ascertain what number of choices as to where they travel and what they do.
bloggers were communicating about their travel experi- The Internet will continue to influence and shape the
ences. Results revealed that major strengths of the destina- tourism industry more so than any other sector of the econ-
tion were its attractions: historic charm, Southern omy (Travel Industry Association 2005).
hospitality, beaches, and water activities. Major weaknesses To date, Internet marketing researchers have primarily
included weather, infrastructure, and fast-service restau- focused on online consumer behavior and Internet advertis-
rants. Qualitative results demonstrated that travel blogs are ing strategy (Hoffman and Novak 1996; Werthner and Ricci
an inexpensive means to gather rich, authentic, and unso- 2004; Yadav and Varadarajan 2005). The marketing of desti-
licited customer feedback. Information technology advances nations has primarily focused on the potential of the Internet
and increasingly large numbers of travel blogs facilitate as a B2C medium where firms and organizations promote
travel blog monitoring as a cost-effective method for desti- and sell their products and build customer relationships
nation marketers to assess their service quality and improve (Gretzel, Yuan, and Fesenmaier 2000; Wang and Fesenmaier
travelers’ overall experiences. 2006). Though the Internet is an important medium for travel
information, consumer confidence in Internet advertisement
Keywords: Consumer decision making; advertising; is low (Cyr et al. 2005; Kwak, Fox, and Zinkhan 2002).
external stimuli; mental imagery; consump- The Internet provides new ways for individuals to learn
tion vision about tourist destinations and their products and services
directly from other consumers. This has created a new
method of communication that is similar to word-of-mouth
and empowers consumers. Travelers can e-mail one another,
INTRODUCTION post comments and feedbacks, publish online blogs, and
form communities on the Internet. Blogs, as “push-button
Research has shown that interpersonal influence arising publishing for people,” are becoming more and more popu-
from opinion exchange between consumers is an important lar (Cayzer 2004). There are currently 31.6 million blogs on
factor influencing consumers’ purchase decisions. Word-of-
mouth or advice from friends and relatives often ranks as the Bing Pan, Ph.D., is an assistant professor in the Department of
most influential source of prepurchase information (Crotts Hospitality and Tourism Management, and head of research in the
1999). While some literature indicates that word-of-mouth Office of Tourism Analysis at College of Charleston in South
Carolina; e-mail: panb@cofc.edu. Tanya MacLaurin, Ph.D., is an
can be manipulated by marketers (Smith and Vogt 1995), associate professor in the School of Hospitality and Tourism
most literature suggests that meeting and exceeding visitor Management at the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada;
expectations is the most effective means of inducing positive e-mail: tmaclaur@uoguelph.ca. John C. Crotts, Ph.D., is a professor
word-of-mouth (Dichter 1966; Neelamegham and Jain and founding chair of the Department of Hospitality and Tourism
Management at the College of Charleston in South Carolina;
1999; Nyer 1997; Westbrook 1987). e-mail: crottsj@cofc.edu. The authors would like to thank the
The Internet has become a major source of information anonymous reviewers for their detailed and constructive
for travelers and a platform for tourism business transac- comments, which helped the revision significantly.
tions. Specifically, the tourism industry is today’s leading Journal of Travel Research, Vol. 46, August 2007, 35–45
application of the Internet in a business-to-consumer (B2C) DOI: 10.1177/0047287507302378
context (Werthner and Ricci 2004). According to the Travel © 2007 Sage Publications
36 AUGUST 2007

the Internet (Perseus 2005) with 40,000 new blogs coming word-of-mouth. The opinion leader in these exchanges was
online each day (Baker and Green 2005). Essentially a the person who, as an active user of mass media, interpreted
consumer-to-consumer (C2C) medium, Internet blogs have the meaning of the content of media messages for other con-
important implications for destination marketers that have sumers who sought advice (opinion seekers) and originated
thus far been overlooked by researchers. word-of-mouth information exchange. Further research has
As one type of digital word-of-mouth, blogs pose new determined that an opinion leader is held in high esteem by
possibilities and challenges for tourism marketers those who accept his or her opinions, and is trusted to
(Dellarocas 2003). The purpose of this study was to under- provide knowledgeable advice regarding the product due to
stand travel blogs as a manifestation of individual travel interest in a product field and exposure to mass media
experiences, and, from a marketing perspective, assess visi- concerning the product category (Piirto 1992; Walker 1995;
tors’ opinions posted on leading Internet travel blogs to Weimann 1994).
better understand the experience being communicated about This process of obtaining product knowledge and then
the strengths and weaknesses of a destination. This study voluntarily spreading this knowledge through word-of-
also defines and refines a qualitative methodology that des- mouth communication is mediated by several variables.
tinations could use to assess visitor perceptions of their Research has shown that a good customer–employee rela-
product, as well as their position in the marketplace. The tionship can foster the generation of positive word-of-mouth
study will demonstrate that travel blogs are uncensored and (Gremler, Gwinner, and Brown 2001); more consumer
rich expressions of a visitor’s travel experience that provide involvement will lead to higher levels of word-of-mouth
not only a cost-effective method of collecting visitors’ feed- activity and consumers’ effective levels will also influence
back, but also a service quality control mechanism. word-of-mouth volume (Westbrook 1987); and the intensity
of surprises in the consumption process is positively corre-
lated with the volume of word-of-mouth (Derbaix and
LITERATURE REVIEW Vanhamme 2003). On the recipient’s end, both positive and
negative word-of-mouth can influence a consumer’s loyalty,
Relevant literature in marketing, consumer behavior, product evaluation, and purchase decision (Westbrook
computer-mediated communication, and information tech- 1987). However, attitudinal and behavioral changes in the
nology were reviewed to provide a conceptual basis for the recipient are mediated by an evaluation of information
discussion on the relationship of word-of-mouth communi- sources. Research has shown that recipients do not readily
cations and online blogs, as well as the development of the change their attitude based on negative word-of-mouth since
research methodology. their sources may not be trustworthy (Laczniak, DeCarlo,
and Ramaswami 2001).
Opinion Leadership and a Word-of-Mouth
Model Blogs as Online Word-of-Mouth
Consumers learn about the attributes of a product With the advancement of the Internet, consumers are
through various means: advertisements, mass media, real now able to access not only opinions from close friends,
consumption experience, price, sale quantity, and often most family members, and co-workers, but also from strangers
importantly, word-of-mouth (Vettas 1997). Driven by the located around the world who may have used a particular
motivations of altruism, self-interest, or the expectation of product, visited a certain destination, or patronized a prop-
reciprocation, some consumers spread product knowledge erty. More consumers are relying on online opinions for
through word-of-mouth (Grewal, Cline, and McKenna their purchase decisions, from which movies to watch to
2003). Word-of-mouth has been defined as informal com- which stocks to buy (Guernsey 2000). Searching and read-
munication between consumers regarding the characteris- ing others’ opinions about a product can help a consumer
tics, ownership, and usage of a service or product save decision making time and make better decisions
(Westbrook 1987). Since a tourism product is, in essence, an (Hennig-Thurau and Walsh 2003). More important, accord-
experience good, the final product is a composite of services ing to Bickart and Schindler: “the Internet has expanded or
and experiences, which, by their very nature, are hard to changed both the nature of word-of-mouth communication
assess prior to purchase (McIntosh 1972). Therefore, advice and its impact on consumer behavior as well as the
from other consumers who have prior experience with a par- methodological approaches used to examine it” (2002,
ticular tourism product and who are interpersonally avail- p. 428). Thus, new research methodologies are needed to
able will no doubt rank as not only the preferred source of gain insight and understanding into the function of blogs as
prepurchase information but also the most influential in online word-of-mouth communication.
travel decision making (Crotts 1999). Because of the per- As an important form of digitized word-of-mouth com-
sonal connection involved, word-of-mouth is viewed as a munication, blogs are gaining more and more popularity.
more credible source of accurate consumer information than Blog is a shortened word originating from “web log” (Chow
marketing information obtained through mass media. 2005). The format consists of familiar, frequently updated,
Lazarsfeld, Berelson, and Gaudet (1944) discussed a reverse-chronological entries on a single Web page (Blood
two-step flow of communication in which political views 2004). Audio and video blogging from mobile devices are
were influenced largely by the communication between also available (Baker and Green 2005). Currently there are
voters themselves instead of the influence of mass media. 31.6 million blogs on the Internet (Perseus 2005) with 40,000
In their observations, political information was primarily new blogs each day (Baker and Green 2005). Perseus (2005)
transmitted from the mass media sources to the audience, randomly surveyed 10,000 blogs on 20 leading blog-hosting
and then secondarily within the audience itself through services, and reported that 68.1% of bloggers were female,
JOURNAL OF TRAVEL RESEARCH 37

with ages ranging from 13 to over 50, but the overwhelming 2004). Bloggers trust online blogs even more than tradi-
majority (94%) is under the age of 30. Pew Internet Research tional types of media (Johnson and Kayne 2003). Company-
showed that around 7% of the 120 million adults in the sponsored blog sites were evaluated by consumers as
United States have created at least one blog, and 27% of containing “conversational human voice” (Kelleher and
Internet users have read blogs (Rainie 2005). Sifry estimated Miller 2006). As a result, blogs have been shown to play an
that the total number of blogs doubles every 5 months (Sifry important role in online space (Trammell et al. 2006). For
2005) (Figure 1). Both blog creators and readers are more example, blogs have been used to overthrow prominent
likely to be young, male (this contradicts Perseus research politicians (Kurtz 2005; Shachtman 2002). Blogs have been
results, 2005; it might be due to different samples), broad- touted as the voice of the people and some elite bloggers’
band users and Internet veterans who are relatively well-off sites have become influential media sources (Trammell and
financially and well educated (Rainie 2005). The distribution Keshelashvili 2005; Winer 2003).
of influences, as measured by the number of in-links to the Dellarocas (2003) hypothesized that on a global scale,
blogs, follows power-law distribution, which makes only a this type of digital word-of-mouth is different from tradi-
small percentage of blogs the most popular and well-read tional word-of-mouth communications in four important
ones. Most blogs are read and linked infrequently, especially ways. First, with the low cost of access and ease of infor-
those recently built (Marlow 2003). Nardi et al. (2004) pos- mation exchange, this new type of word-of-mouth commu-
tulated that Internet users blog for various reasons: as a doc- nication will appear on a large scale and will create new
ument of one’s life, as a social commentary, as catharsis and dynamics in the market. Second, the format and communi-
outlet for their feelings, and/or as a thinking tool. These are cation type of these exchanges could be controlled and mon-
all intrinsic motivations, indicating the genuineness of travel itored precisely. Third, new problems may arise since users
blogs and their potential similarities to travel journals as real- could be anonymous or intentionally misleading; and fourth,
istic and honest chronicles of visitors’ experiences. online blogs may be captured out of context and may induce
Bloggers’ motivations for producing blogs are more multiple interpretations. Blogs and the information clusters
diverse than the mere communication of product informa- formed around them through links could provide connec-
tion. Computer-mediated communication studies have tions between otherwise disconnected smaller customer
shown that further motivations for blogging include enter- groups. Thus, they possess the potential to transform the
tainment, information, social interaction, self-expression, blogspace into large virtual communities. However, the
passing time, and professional advancement (Papacharissi anonymity and almost-free accessing and posting to online
2002). Among those, self-expression and social interaction space make collusion a potential problem for both cus-
are the two major gratifications for blogging (Papacharissi tomers and marketers.

FIGURE 1
GROWTH OF NUMBER OF BLOGS ACCORDING TO TECHNORATI (SIFRY 2005)
38 AUGUST 2007

Research has confirmed that blogspace is a complex and Charleston is located in the Low Country of South Carolina
rich environment for communications. Based on more than and faces the Atlantic Ocean. The area is composed of three
1 million blogs on www.livejournal.com, Kumar et al. major cities or towns: Charleston, North Charleston, and
(2004) demonstrated that the blogspace consists of at least Mount Pleasant, with a combined population of around
three layers: the individual bloggers who are defined by 600,000 (U.S. Department of Commerce 2007). Charleston
their demographic characteristics, a middle layer of pairs of boasts a rich history: the first shot of the Civil War of the
bloggers constructed based on friendship, and a third higher United States was fired in Charleston in 1861, and it is also
layer of interest groups and virtual communities explained one of the best preserved cities in America’s Old South, with
by geographic or demographic correlations. Blogspace can many pre-Revolutionary War buildings (Porter 2005). In
also create virtual relationships and communities, and its 2004, Charleston received 4.7 million visitors. The tourism
influence moves far beyond the readers of the blogs, creat- industry created about 105,000 jobs in 2005 and proves to
ing a new type of reality through search engines in the be a leading economic driver (Charleston Convention &
online space that practitioners should be aware of. For Visitors Bureau 2005). Charleston is ranked as the 6th “Top
example, Google bombing is a phenomenon in which savvy City in the United States & Canada” according to Travel and
bloggers of Google take advantage of Google’s algorithm. Leisure magazine’s 10th annual World’s Best Poll. It has
Google’s PageRank algorithm utilizes the link structure of consistently placed in the top 10 domestic travel destinations
the Web space to locate the most authoritative Web pages for the past 12 years in Conde Nast Traveler magazine’s
(Brin and Page 1998). Bloggers may manipulate the search prestigious Readers Choice Awards (Charleston CVB 2005).
results when the users type in a query in Google (Tatum
2005). Blogs are actually the tool that Google bombers use Data Collection
in manipulating the hyperlink structure of the Web space
and subsequently influence the returned results in Google. Since Google’s PageRank algorithm ranks documents
This demonstrates just one way that online communication based on popularity (Brin and Page 1998), the three most
differs from physical word-of-mouth, and it needs to be popular travel blog sites were identified through searches on
taken into consideration when evaluating the role of blogs in Google on September 7, 2005, using the keywords travel
word-of-mouth communications. blog. The top three travel blog sites were www.travelblog.org,
www.travelpod.com, and www.travelpost.com. All the sites
have a hierarchical directory of blogs (continents, countries,
Travel Blogs and Online Word-of-Mouth
states, then cities). All 30 blogs on Charleston, South
At the moment of decision making, the consumer must act Carolina, from the three sites were downloaded. In addition,
on impressions of a product’s attributes gathered from often- the authors also used the keywords Charleston, SC and
imperfect sources of information. Since a tourism product is, Charleston South Carolina to search the blog-specific
in essence, an experience good (McIntosh 1972), the emer- search engines www.technorati.com, Google blog search,
gence of travel blogs will inevitably influence the link struc- and IceRocket. More than 100 blogs were returned and the
ture and the content of the information space for visitors, and authors identified 24 more blogs on travel experience in
will induce different informational content when a visitor Charleston after deleting blogs about real estate, local col-
searches for destination-specific information on the Internet. leges, or other aspects of Charleston. In total, 54 blogs were
Travel blogs express the experiences of the visitor at a specific collected on September 12, 2005. Of these, 14 did not con-
destination, and given the ever-increasing number of Internet tain content relevant to a specific travel experience in
users, digital word-of-mouth communications will inevitably Charleston, South Carolina; the bloggers might have been
become more preferred as travel information sources (Crotts Charleston locals, or stopped in Charleston en route to
1999). For this reason, tourism marketers need to understand another destination. The remaining 40 blogs contained content
blogs as a new technological phenomenon with implications relating to visitors’ experiences in Charleston. These 40 blogs
for marketing and promotion of a destination. were placed in a master file for qualitative data analysis. Each
blog retained its title and identification information.

METHODOLOGY Data Analysis


After detailing the general characteristics of bloggers
In this study, various research methods were used to gain (demographical information) and their blogs (time of blog-
insight into the meaning of travel blogs and their relation- ging and the length of blog), the full text of all 40 blogs was
ship to one specific tourist destination. Bloggers’ demo- aggregated and analyzed using semantic network analysis
graphic information was researched, as were the and content analysis. Semantic network analysis is a quanti-
characteristics of the travel blogs. Various qualitative data tative method that has been used to analyze communication
analysis techniques were adopted to develop a travel blog content and generate networked representation of semantic
analyzing methodology. The text contained in blogs was meanings (Doerfel 1998), and has been found to be a useful
collected and analyzed by word frequency, semantic net- framework for the construction and analysis of communica-
work analysis (Doerfel 1998), and content analysis. tion content (Doerfel and Barnett 1999). It has also been
used in organizational culture, communication, marketing,
Charleston, South Carolina, United States and tourism research. The communication discourses
analyzed include phone conversations, published journal
Charleston, South Carolina, was selected as the tourist articles, messages in a Bulletin Board System, policy state-
destination for this qualitative blog data collection. ments, and text on travel Web sites (Doerfel and Barnett 1999;
JOURNAL OF TRAVEL RESEARCH 39

Pan and Fesenmaier 2006). Many researchers have argued Blog Profiles
that the meaning of a concept can only be determined by the
relationship with other concepts, and a model of networked On most blogs, each piece contained the description of
concepts can accurately determine their meanings (Barnett, one trip from one traveler, but there were some exceptions.
Palmer and Noor Al-Deen 1984; Palmer and Barnett 1984; For example, in one case two bloggers produced several
Woelfel and Fink 1980). Since concepts are embodied by postings for one trip in which they described one day’s expe-
the words in languages, semantic network analysis uses text rience in each. All the blog sites consistently showed the time
to capture the relationships between different concepts (key- the blog was added; some sites such as www.travelpod.com
words) and to explore the shared meaning. The adjacency of and www.travelpost.com ask the bloggers to also enter the
two concepts in the text reflects their relative distance of date they traveled. Additional information about the trip
their semantic meaning. Semantic network analysis begins could also be inferred from the blogs themselves. There were
with a content analysis of textual data to extract the most 18 blogs for which the researchers inferred both the trip dates
frequently used symbols. The relative frequencies of co- and blog posting dates. One blog was posted the same day
occurring symbols and the relative distances between these the trip was taken; four blogs were composed a few days
symbols represent the closeness of their meanings. Neural after the trip; four blogs were posted 2 to 10 months after the
network method is then used to obtain the networked mental trips; the rest of the blogs were posted more than 1 year after
models of symbols. Programs such as CATPAC II (Doerfel the trips were taken. The longest delay was a post in 2005
1998) and TextAnalyst (Megaputer Intelligence 2005) can about a trip taken in 1968. Interestingly, one account was not
be used to generate semantic networks from communication always associated with one blogger: there was one blog
content. For detailed underlying neural network procedure account that was co-owned by one family and two other cou-
for semantic network analysis, please see Doerfel and ples, besides other single individuals. However, it was not clear
Barnett (1999). In this study, a semantic network of the who in the group composed the blog messages. In addition, out
bloggers’ experiences was generated from the analysis of the of 40 blogs, 11 contained pictures (ranging in number from 1
full text of all the travel blogs for the Charleston area using to 53), in addition to the text about the trip to Charleston. The
TextAnalyst. Content analysis was also performed on the number of words in the blogs ranged from 4 to 1,972, with a
travel blogs (Weber 1990). An iterative process of content mean number of 444 words.
analysis was performed as follows: two researchers inde-
pendently coded the content of the blogs, then upon exami- Frequency Analysis and Semantic Network
nation of the results and discussion, a master coding scheme Analysis
was constructed. The blogs were finally coded using two
dimensions: the aspects of the tourism amalgam model Travel blog text was analyzed by word or phrase occur-
(Cooper 2005) and the positive or negative orientation of the rence and frequency using TextAnalyst (Megaputer
sentences. Intelligence 2005). Words commonly used in constructing
sentences (stop words) were eliminated using a stop word
list such as the, a, of, and is. The analysis resulted in the con-
RESULTS struction of a table of the “Most Frequently Used Keywords
or Phrases” that appeared at least four times in the blogs
(Table 1). The most frequently used keywords or phrases
The characteristics of bloggers and blogs revealed travel
blogs as a manifestation of communicated travel experience.
The results of semantic network analysis and content analy- TABLE 1
sis for travel blogs for Charleston, South Carolina, were MOST FREQUENTLY USED KEYWORDS OR
detailed to reveal the strengths, weaknesses, and the com- PHRASES IN TRAVEL BLOGS FOR CHARLESTON,
petitive environment of Charleston as a tourist destination. SOUTH CAROLINA

Keywords Frequency Keywords Frequency


Blogger Profiles
Charleston 75 owner 8
The demographic information of the bloggers was plantation 24 lobster 8
gleaned from the hosting sites through various methods. All city 23 history 7
the sites allow users to post their personal portraits in their car 14 cafe 7
profiles; their demographic and personal information can hotel 13 Magnolia 6
also be inferred from their blogs and usernames. On drive 13 Boone 6
French 12 aircraft carrier 6
www.travelpost.com, the users can choose to disclose their town 12 museum 6
age, gender, location, and occupation in their publicly acces- restaurant 11 Yorktown 5
sible profiles; certain demographic information was there South Carolina 11 mansion 5
fore obtained on 34 out of the 40 bloggers. The majority of dinner 11 acre 5
bloggers were from the United States, except for one from Fort Sumter 10 Sunday 5
Thailand and one from the United Kingdom. For the 13 menu 9 Patriot’s Point 5
users who chose to disclose their ages, the range was from inn 9 salad 5
21 to 64 with an average age of 38. Two cohorts of users fort 8 Folly Beach 4
seemed to be present: one cohort in its 20s to 30s and the road 8 harbor 4
other in its 50s and 60s. For those users who disclosed their hour 8
gender, there were 11 females (55%) and 9 males (45%).
40 AUGUST 2007

demonstrated that travelers express many aspects of travel cluster is specifically associated with plantations, a unique
experience in their travel blogs, including attractions (e.g., type of attraction in Charleston. Additional smaller clusters
plantation, city, and Fort Sumter), accommodations (e.g., of keywords are connected with dining experience, camp-
hotel and inn), dining (e.g., restaurant, dinner, menu, and ing, and museum attractions. The results demonstrate the
lobster), and transportation (e.g., car, drive, and road). kaleidoscopic nature of travel blogs in representing travel
experiences—every aspect of the travel experience, from
visiting attractions and dining at restaurants, to relatively
Semantic Network Analysis
ancillary activities such as driving and camping all become
Semantic network analysis provided a useful framework the major content of blogging and constitute a part of the
for the construction and analysis of meanings and impres- travel experience.
sions of Charleston as a tourist destination. The most fre-
quently used keywords or phrases reported were used to Content Analysis
construct a semantic network diagram from TextAnalyst
(Megaputer Intelligence 2005). Word frequency was illus- The researchers used NVivo (QSR International 2002)
trated in the diagram by size and color of circle surrounding software to perform content analysis on the blog data.
the word, that is, large frequency is illustrated by a larger NVivo tools enabled the creation of category trees to illus-
and darker colored circle, a less frequent occurrence is illus- trate relationships between different categories. Each of two
trated by a smaller and lighter colored circle. Lines drawn researchers independently coded the content by constructing
between the word circles illustrate the proximity of topical categories dependent on their own analysis of the
occurrence of the words. This semantic diagram provides blog content. No prior discussion of categories took place
a graphic representation of Charleston as a destination between the researchers. Strengths and weaknesses were
(Figure 2). From the graph, several clusters of keywords can also coded for all content that possessed positive or negative
be identified, indicating the types of travel experience as sentences related to the blogger’s travel experience while in
represented in travel blogs on Charleston. With its major Charleston. Upon completion of the researchers’ indepen-
tourist attractions, related accommodations, and dining, dent coding of the blog data, coding trees were compared.
Charleston is the most prominent cluster. The second major This comparison demonstrated many similarities and differ-
cluster is the driving experience related to the trip. The third ences in coding. All categories identified by the researchers

FIGURE 2
SEMANTIC NETWORK OF TRAVEL EXPERIENCE TO CHARLESTON
JOURNAL OF TRAVEL RESEARCH 41

were used to build a composite enabling the formation of a model and dimension two was the researchers’ evaluation of
master list of categories. The tourism amalgam model either positive or negative sentence orientation, in order to
developed by Cooper (2005) was adapted by adding subcat- understand the strengths and/or weaknesses of Charleston as
egories identified in the independent coding process. Cooper a destination (Table 2). Pure neutral descriptions of the trip
considers destinations as amalgams creating an inseparable were very few and ignored since the goal of the content
tourist product. His original destination amalgam model analysis was to assess strengths and weaknesses of
includes attractions (artificial features, natural features, and Charleston as a tourism destination. Figure 3 depicts the
events, all of which provide the initial motivation to visit), complete procedure for the content analysis. The intercoder
amenities (accommodations, food, beverage, retailing, and agreement in the final state of coding with the settled
other services), ancillary services (related marketing efforts categories is around 96%.
of tourism organizations and others), and access (transporta-
tion, car rental, and local transport) (Cooper 2005). The Strengths and Weaknesses as Reflected from
model was applied here for categorizing positive and nega- Travel Blogs on Charleston
tive remarks on travel experiences, since visitors encounter
every aspect of a destination, as described in the model, and Strengths and weaknesses identified in the coding
their experience is also integrated and inseparable from one process were calculated. A total of 177 positive and negative
aspect to another. However, from initial coding, the sentences were articulated about Charleston in the travel
researchers discovered that the aspect of “ancillary services” blog text studied, including 134 positive and 43 negative
is almost irrelevant; a new category of “overall impression” sentences. Thus, three out of four sentences made about
was necessary since sometimes the travel bloggers talked Charleston were positive (75.5%). Looking at the major cat-
about their overall experience without referring to any sin- egories, the results showed that attractions (history, hospi-
gle aspect of it. The final standardized coding categories are tality environment, and water attractions) were the major
listed in Table 2, along with the number of positive and neg- strength of Charleston. Major complaints about the city
ative responses relating to each one. came from access issues. The complaints were focused on
Once the category codes were standardized, as shown in navigation in the city and crowded traffic routes. Amenities
Table 2, researchers repeated the independent coding of the also showed a relatively high percentage of negative sen-
blog data. Upon completion, coding comparison indicated tences (32%), mostly concerning accommodations, and to a
that researchers were more consistent in their coding but sig- lesser extent, food and beverage. Looking more in-depth
nificant differences remained in the number of items coded. at the coding on the secondary level, the results showed that
Upon closer examination it was revealed that most differ- the four major areas of complaints were weather (too hot in
ences could be attributed to varying coding practice. One the summer), food (low-quality food in quick-service restau-
researcher coded multiple lines as one item, while the sec- rants and hotels), parking (hard to find a space), and road
ond researcher coded four keywords in the same text lines as signs (unclear). Three of the four complaints on overall
four items. A detailed set of coding procedures was devel- impression were about the high prices of the destination in
oped to assist in the third coding stage. In the final data cod- general (Figure 4).
ing, the researchers followed the rule that one sentence In addition, during coding, the researchers also captured
should be taken as one coding unit. Thus, the final coding the names of cities that bloggers compared to Charleston.
scheme was completed with two dimensions: dimension one The visitors compared Charleston with the following cities:
consisting of the different aspects of tourism amalgam Chapel Hill, North Carolina; Santa Barbara, California;

TABLE 2
CODING CATEGORIES AND NUMBER OF POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE SENTENCES FOR EACH CATEGORY

Positives Negatives Total Sentences % Negative Sentences

Attractions 81 16 97 17
History 35 2 37 5
Natural Environment 15 8 23 35
Hospitality Environment 5 1 6 17
Water Attractions/Activities 14 2 16 13
Other Attractions 12 3 15 20
Amenities 32 15 47 32
Accommodations 8 7 15 47
Food and Beverages 22 8 30 27
Shopping 2 0 2 0
Other Services 0 0 0
Access 3 8 11 73
Air Travel 0 1 1 100
Local Transport 1 1 2 50
Car Travel 2 6 8 75
Train Travel 0 0 0
Overall Impression 18 4 22 18
Total 134 43 177 24
42 AUGUST 2007

FIGURE 3 competitive environment of a destination and provide


CODING PROCEDURE FOR CONTENT valuable customer feedback that is richer and more detailed
ANALYSIS ON TRAVEL BLOGS than Likert response survey measurements.

Travel Blogs as Manifestation of Traveler


Experience in Charleston
Travel blogs qualitatively cover every aspect of a visi-
tor’s trip. From the overall experience of traveling, the antic-
ipation, planning, packing, departure, driving, flying, and
delays en route were all reflected in the travel blogs.
Visitors’ experiences involved kaleidoscopic perception and
sense of the destination: from attractions, accommodations
and dining, to access and overall impressions. Most of the
descriptions were experiential and subjective in nature. For
example, driving was a major part of most travel experi-
ences. For some bloggers driving was positive, while for
others it was negative. Food was also found to be both a
positive experience for many visitors but a negative one for
others. In a more detailed analysis, it was revealed that the
major complaints about food concerned quick-service
restaurants or free breakfasts in hotels. Most experiences
in fine dining restaurants in the Charleston area were
positive.
FIGURE 4
PERCENT OF POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE SENTENCES
IN TRAVEL BLOGS ON CHARLESTON Strengths and Weaknesses of the Destination
and Implications for Marketing
The results revealed that the major strengths of the
destination of Charleston lie in its attractions: the historic
charm, the Southern hospitality, the beaches, and water
activities. The major weaknesses were weather, infrastruc-
ture (roads and traffic), and fast-service restaurants.
“Pricey” was one of the overall complaints that stood out.
Despite the majority of positive sentences, the bloggers’
complaints about the infrastructure, especially on limited
parking space, road conditions, and traffic signs, caused the
researchers to look at the city as a whole to understand these
comments. Charleston has grown tremendously in the last
decade. The Charleston–North Charleston Metropolitan
Statistical Area is the 96th largest metropolitan area in the
United States; its population has grown from 430,346 in
1980 to 583,434 in 2004, a 35.6% increase (U.S. Census
Bureau 2005). The visitor volume has steadily increased
New Orleans, Louisiana; and Savannah, Georgia. These from 3.2 million in 1997 to 4.7 million in 2004 (Charleston
cities were only mentioned once, but with the increased pop- CVB 2005). The data show that the greater Charleston area
ularity of blogs and a larger sample size in the future, key is becoming a major metropolitan region in South Carolina
competitor cities might emerge. The information could be as well as the coastal South. However, the impressions
used to identify the competitive assets of Charleston and obtained from the travel blogs reflected a discrepancy
provide destination marketers with benchmarking cities. between the image of Charleston as a town, versus the real-
The marketers would then need to pay special attention to ity of a major metropolitan city. Thus, to maintain a healthy
those cities in terms of monitoring their marketing efforts tourism industry in Charleston, more investment needs to be
and tourist volumes. put into the infrastructure.
In addition, marketers need to promote a transformation
of the image of Charleston from a “town” with a single
CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSION dimension of historical heritage, to a metropolitan area with
multidimensional attractions, such as beach, seashore, golf,
This study revealed that travel blogs reflect the kaleido- historical heritage, and natural beauty. These results demon-
scopic aspects of a visitor’s experience at a destination. strated that analysis on travel blogs can reveal detailed and
Analysis of blogs on travels to Charleston, South Carolina, in-depth information about the characteristics of a destination,
revealed strengths and weaknesses of this tourist destina- which cannot be gathered from the Likert scale measure-
tion. Travel blogs can also be a useful tool in monitoring the ment on visitor surveys.
JOURNAL OF TRAVEL RESEARCH 43

It should be noted that blogspace, like the Internet in gen- tourist destinations. Several issues need to be taken into
eral, is changing in real-time with new blogs being added and consideration when applying this methodology to other
deleted everyday. To help marketers and others monitor destinations, including sampling and data collection issues,
information on their destination, an automated monitoring the issues of unit of analysis, and semantic network analysis
system for online blogs could be created. The system would issues.
start with the definition of research questions. Using Web First, this study chose Charleston, South Carolina, as the
crawlers or RSS (Really Simple Syndication), which allow destination. Since every destination is unique, the applica-
Internet users to subscribe to the Web sites or blogs, bility of the coding categories to other cities is limited.
(Wikipedia 2005), the destination marketers could monitor Second, the sample size was small and no random sample
the dynamics of customer feedback. Figure 5 proposes an was taken. With the increased number of travel blogs, a
automated mechanism and procedures for monitoring travel larger sample size with random selections may be preferred.
blogs, thus providing a real-time customer feedback and Third, the readership of the blogs is not clear and needs fur-
quality control tool for destination marketing. Researchers ther research. For example, some researchers argued that
would first need to identify and define the goal of the study, blogs are more important as a form of individualistic self-
whether it would be an analysis for strengths and weaknesses expression rather than as a form of documenting current
of a destination or a hotel, or the effects of a marketing cam- external events and social interaction. Even though blogs
paign. Then those keywords related to the questions could be might influence the dynamics of online information space
generated, for example, a city’s name or most commonly and Google ranking, further studies need to be conducted to
used complaint words. The researchers could then manually explore the readership of travel blogs and how visible they
search the blogspace using identified keywords or using RSS are when travelers search for information online (Herring
to track blogs in real time. Those blogs could then be manu- et al. 2004).
ally or automatically downloaded, aggregated, and analyzed Data collection methods proposed here are the initial
using semantic network analysis or content analysis. Similar steps in understanding the nature of blogs and the implica-
to the results of this study, this procedure will likely produce tions for destination marketing. Future researchers need to
insightful and cost-effective marketing implications for be aware of the following issues in adopting the methodol-
tourism organizations and businesses. ogy: First, the travel blogs are not collected from a random
sample of all the blogs about Charleston; rather, they are
collected from searching through major travel blog sites and
LIMITATIONS three major travel blog search engines. Second, the manual
data collection method is a form of nonrandom sampling of
This study represents an effort in applying semantic the blogspace, which can and should be replaced by auto-
network analysis and content analysis on blog data to under- mated and completely random sampling in the future, with
stand the competitiveness of, and customer feedback on, technologies such as RSS as described earlier.
Another issue in the process is the unit of analysis in the
content analysis stage. Depending on the goals of the
FIGURE 5 research, and the researcher conducting the research, a
AUTOMATED QUALITY CONTROL word, a sentence, or a paragraph could be the unit of analy-
MECHANISM/MARKET ANALYSIS THROUGH sis. For example, a travel blogger who visited Patriot’s
MONITORING TRAVEL BLOGS Point, one of the major attractions in Charleston, wrote
about her experience in five paragraphs with a very detailed
description of each ship and room she visited. If the goal of
the research is a destination, one coding unit would be suf-
ficient for the analysis, but if the goal is to specifically
understand the strength and weaknesses of Patriot’s Point,
then each sentence, or even each phrase, should be coded as
one unit. It also should be noted that the coding categories
are not initially set or defined, but emerged through the
initial analysis. Depending on different goals of research,
coding categories might be different.
This study adopted both traditional content analysis for
the analysis on strengths and weaknesses, and semantic net-
work analysis for travel experience; each has its advantages
and limitations. Content analysis of texts requires human
coding of the text (Krippendorf 1980), which involves
tedious and potentially biased operations. For example,
weather was coded as “Natural Environment” under the
“Attractions” category. Even though both coders agreed on
the sensibility of the coding and positive sentences on
weather as “Attractions,” the negative ones on weather as
one aspect of “Attractions” seemed a little artificial.
Alternatively, semantic network analysis uses the concepts
and words as they appear in the text to construct semantic
meanings (Woelfel and Stoyanoff 1993). The advantage of
44 AUGUST 2007

this method is that there is no need for preconceived Chow, J. (2005). “The New Frontier.” National Post Business Magazine, p. 40.
Cooper, C. (2005). Tourism: Principles and Practice. Upper Saddle River,
categories and the test of reliability between different human NJ: Financial Times Prentice Hall.
coders. However, when people mention a place or food, they Crotts, J. (1999). “Consumer Decision Making and Prepurchase
might express either positive or negative impressions; a high Information Search.” In Consumer Behavior in Travel and Tourism,
edited by Yoel Mansfield and Abraham Pizam. Binghamton, N.Y.:
frequency of keywords or phrases can indicate mixed expe- Haworth Press, pp. 149–168.
riences, and the direction is not reflected in the semantic net- Cyr, D., C. Bonanni, J. Bowes, and J. Ilsever (2005). “Beyond Trust: Web
work. In this sense, the content analysis with human coding Site Design Preferences across Cultures.” Journal of Global
Information Management, 13 (4): 25–54.
is superior. The combination of the two methods is recom- De Mooij, M. (2004). Consumer Behavior and Culture. Thousand Oaks,
mended since it can reveal both the directionality and also CA: Sage.
Dellarocas, C. (2003). “The Digitization of Word of Mouth: Promise and
the intensity of the experience. Challenges of Online Feedback Mechanisms.” Management Science,
In general, this study shows that blog analysis can be a 49 (10): 1407–1424.
useful way to detect the strengths and weaknesses of a Derbaix, C., and J. Vanhamme (2003). “Inducing Word-of-Mouth by
Eliciting Surprise: A Pilot Investigation.” Journal of Economic
tourist destination. Special attention must be given to the Psychology, 24: 99–116.
sampling, coding, and analysis process. The units of analy- Dichter, E. (1966). “How Word-of-Mouth Advertising Works.” Harvard
sis and coding categories will be distinct, depending on the Business Review, 44: 131–144.
Doerfel, M. (1998). “What Constitutes Semantic Network Analysis? A
different goals of research. Combining semantic network Comparison of Research and Methodologies.” Connections, 212: 16–26.
analysis and content analysis could provide more detailed Doerfel, M. and G. Barnett (1999). “A Semantic Network Analysis of the
International Communication Association.” Human Communication
and valid results. Novel software tools could be used to Research, 254: 589–603.
automatically track the dynamics of blogspace and poten- Gremler, D. D., K. P. Gwinner, and S. W. Brown (2001). “Generating
tially provide a quality control mechanism. Positive Word-of-Mouth Communication through Customer-
Employee Relationships.” International Journal of Service Industry
Management, 12 (1): 44–59.
Gretzel, U., Y. Yuan, and D. R. Fesenmaier (2000). “Preparing for the New
FUTURE RESEARCH Economy: Advertising Strategies and Change in Destination
Marketing Organizations.” Journal of Travel Research, 39 (38):
146–156.
Grewal, R., T. W. Cline, and A. G. McKenna (2003). “Early-Entrant
It is our hope that this research will be refined and repli- Advantage, Word-of-Mouth Communication, Brand Similarity, and
cated by others to better understand a destination’s strengths the Consumer Decision-Making Process.” Journal of Consumer
and weaknesses from the articulation of prior visitors who, Psychology, 13 (3): 187–197.
Guernsey, L. (2000, February 3). “Suddenly, Everybody’s an Expert on
by their actions, are willing opinion leaders. In addition, we Everything.” New York Times, p. G1.
hope that this paper stimulates interests among researchers Hennig-Thurau, T., and G. Walsh (2003). “Electronic Word-of-Mouth:
Motives for and Consequences of Reading Customer Articulations on
as to the characteristics or profiles of these online bloggers. the Internet.” International Journal of Electronic Commerce, 8 (2):
For those who choose to pursue this line of inquiry, we 51–74.
encourage you to capture subjects’ national culture of birth Herring, S., Scheidt, L. A., Bonus, S., and E. Wright (2004). “Bridging the
Gap: A Genre Analysis of Weblogs.” Paper presented at the 37th
and residence since the role of opinion leaders has often Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Honolulu,
been shown to vary across national cultures (De Mooij Hawaii.
2004). In particular, subjects from countries along Hoffman, D. L., and T. P. Novak (1996). “Marketing in Hypermedia
Computer-Mediated Environments: Conceptual Foundations.”
Hofstede’s power distance, masculinity, and uncertainty Journal of Marketing, 60 (3): 50–68.
avoidance dimensions will likely vary in terms of role, tenor, Hofstede, G. H. (2001). Culture’s Consequences: Comparing Values,
Behaviors, Institutions, and Organizations across Nations. Thousand
and willingness to offer interpersonal opinions (Hofstede Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
2001). On the other hand, the opinion seekers in the inter- Johnson, T., and B. Kayne (2003). “Wag the Blog: How Reliance on
personal exchange are also a neglected area of study. Traditional Media and the Internet Influence Credibility Perceptions
of Weblogs among Blog Users.” Journalism and Mass
Comparisons between those providing personal influence in Communications Quarterly, 11 (3): 622–642.
contrast to those who are recipients of the information is, to Kelleher, T., and B. M. Miller (2006). “Organizational Blogs and the
our knowledge, an area that has been poorly investigated Human Voice: Relational Strategies and Relational Outcomes.”
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 11 (2): 1.
(Wright and Cantor 1970). Krippendorf, K. (1980). Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its
Methodology. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
Kumar, R., J. Novak, P. Raghavan, and A. Tomkins (2004). “Structure and
Evolution of Blogspace.” Communications of the ACM, 47 (12): 35–39.
REFERENCES Kurtz, H. (2005). “In the Blogsphere, Lightning Strikes Twice.”
Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.
com/wp-dyn/articles/A20056-2005Feb12.html
Baker, S., and H. Green (2005). “Blogs Will Change Your Business.” Kwak, H., R. Fox, and G. Zinkhan (2002). “What Products Can Be
Business Week, 3931: 56–67. Successfully Sold on the Internet.” Journal of Advertising Research,
Barnett, G. A., M. T. Palmer, and H. S. Noor Al-Deen (1984). “An 42 (1): 23–25.
Examination of the Use of Multidimensional Scaling to Determine Laczniak, R. N., T. E. DeCarlo, and S. N. Ramaswami (2001). “Consumers’
the Accuracy of Translation.” Communication Yearbook 8, edited by Responses to Negative Word-of-Mouth Communication: An Attribution
Robert N. Bostrom and Bruce H. Westley. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage, Theory Perspective.” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 11 (1): 57–73.
659–679. Lazarsfeld, P., B. Berelson, and H. Gaudet (1944). The People’s Choice.
Bickart, B., and R. M. Schindler (2002). “Expanding the Scope of Word of New York: Duell, Sloan and Pearce.
Mouth: Consumer-to-Consumer Information on the Internet.” Marlow, C. (2003). “Audience, Structure and Authority in the Weblog
Advances in Consumer Research, 29: 428–430. Community.” Paper presented at the International Communication
Blood, R. (2004). “How Blogging Software Reshapes the Online Association Conference, New Orleans, LA.
Community.” Communications of the ACM, 47 (12): 53–55. McIntosh, R. W. (1972). Tourism Principles, Practices, and Philosophies.
Brin, S., and L. Page (1998). “The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Columbus, Ohio: Grid, Inc.
Web Search Engine.” Computer Networks and ISDN Systems, 30 Megaputer Intelligence. (2005). TextAnalyst. Retrieved from
(1–7): 101–117. http://www.megaputer.com/products/ta/index.php3.
Cayzer, S. (2004). “Semantic Blogging and Decentralized Knowledge Nardi, B. A., D. J. Schiano, M. Gumbrecht, and L. Swartz (2004). “Why We
Management.” Communications of the ACM, 47 (12): 47–52. Blog.” Communications of the ACM, 47(12): 41–46.
Charleston Convention & Visitors Bureau (2005). 2005–2006 Charleston Neelamegham, R., and D. Jain (1999). “Consumer Choice Process for
Area Convention & Visitors Bureau Book. Charleston, SC: Charleston Experience Goods: An Econometric Model and Analysis.” Journal of
Convention & Visitors Bureau. Marketing Research, 36 (3): 373–386.
JOURNAL OF TRAVEL RESEARCH 45

Nyer, P. U. (1997). “A Study of the Relationships between Cognitive Bloggers through Content Analysis.” Journal of Computer-Mediated
Appraisals and Consumption Emotions.” Journal of the Academy of Communication, 11 (3): Article 2.
Marketing Science, 25 (4): 296–304. Travel Industry Association (2005). Executive Summaries - Travelers’ Use
Palmer, M. T., and G. A. Barnett (1984). “Using Spatial Models to of the Internet, 2004 Edition. Washington, DC: Author.
Determine the Accuracy of Language Translation.” Cross-Cultural U.S. Department of Commerce (2007). Bearfacts 1995–2005: Charleston-
Adaptation: Current Approaches (no. 18), edited by Young Yun Kim North Charleston (MSA) [16700]. Retrieved from http://www.bea.
and William B. Gudykunst. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, pp. gov/bea.regional/bearfacts/lapipdf.cfm?yearin=2005&fips=16700&a
129–147. reatype=MSA.
Pan, B., and D. R. Fesenmaier (2006). “Online Information Search: Vacation Vettas, N. (1997). “On the Informational Role of Quantities: Durable Goods
Planning Process.” Annals of Tourism Research, 33 (3): 809–832. and Consumers’ Word-of-Mouth Communication.” International
Papacharissi, Z. (2002). “The Presentation of Self in Virtual Life: Economic Review, 38 (4): 915–944.
Characteristics of Personal Home Pages.” Journalism and Mass Walker, C. (1995). “Word of Mouth.” American Demographics, 17 (7): 38–45.
Communication Quarterly, 79 (3): 640–660. Wang, Y., and D. R. Fesenmaier (2006). “Identifying the Success Factors of
—— (2004). “The Blogger Revolution? Audiences as Media Producers. Web-Based Marketing Strategy: An Investigation of Convention and
“Paper presented at the Communication and Technology Division, Visitors Bureaus in the United States.” Journal of Travel Research, 44
International Communication Association Conference, New (3): 239–249.
Orleans, LA. Weber, R. P. (1990). Basic Content Analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Perseus (2005). “The Blogging Geyser.” Retrieved November 1, 2005, from Weimann, G. (1994). The Influentials. Albany, NY: State University of New
http://www.perseus.com/blogsurvey/geyser.html York Press.
Piirto, R. (1992). “The Influentials.” American Demographics, 14 (10): 30–38. Werthner, H., and F. Ricci (2004). “E-Commerce and Tourism.”
Porter, D. (2005). Frommer’s the Carolinas and Georgia. New York: Wiley. Communications of the ACM, 17 (12): 101–109.
QSR International (2002). “Using NVivo in Qualitative Research.” Westbrook, R. A. (1987). “Product/Consumption-Based Affective Responses
Retrieved from http://www.qsrinternational.com and Postpurchase Processes.” Journal of Marketing Research, 24(3):
Rainie, L. (2005). “The State of Blogging.” Retrieved September 12, 2005, 258–270.
from http://www.pewinternet.org/pdfs/PIP_blogging_data.pdf. Wikipedia (2005). “Rss (File Format).” Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/
Shachtman, N. (2002). “Blogs Make the Headlines.” Wired News. Retrieved wiki/RSS_(protocol)
January 2, 2003, from http://www.wired.com/news/culture/ 0,1284, Winer, D. (2003). “What Makes a Weblog a Weblog?” Retrieved November
56978,00.html 8, 2003, from http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/whatMakesAWeblog
Sifry, D. (2005, October 17). “State of the Blogosphere, October 2005 Part AWeblogWoelfel, J., and E. L. Fink (1980). The Measurement of
1: On Blogosphere Growth.” from http://www.sifry.com/alerts/ Communication Processes: Galileo Theory and Method. New York:
archives/000343.html Academic Press.
Smith, R., and C. Vogt (1995). “The Effects of Integrating Advertising Woelfel, J. and N. Stoyanoff (1993). “CATPAC: A Neural Network for
and Negative Word of Mouth Communications on Message Qualitative Analysis of Text.” Paper presented at the Annual
Processing and Response.” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 4 (2): Meeting of the Australian Marketing Association, Melbourne,
133–151. Australia.
Tatum, C. (2005). “Deconstructing Google Bombs: A Breach of Symbolic Wright, C., and M. Cantor (1970). “The Opinion Seeker and Avoider: Steps
Power of Just a Goofy Prank?” First Monday, 10 (10). Retrieved from Beyond the Opinion Seeker Concept.” In Research in Consumer
http://firstmonday.org/issues/issue10_10/tatum/index.html Behavior, edited by David Kollat, Roger Blackwell, and James Engel.
Trammell, K. D., and A. Keshelashvili (2005). “Examining the New New York: Winston, pp. 480–501.
Influencers: A Self-Presentation Study of a-List Blogs.” Journalism & Yadav, M. S., and R. Varadarajan (2005). “Interactivity in the Electronic
Mass Communication Quarterly, 82 (4): 968–982. Marketplace: An Exposition of the Concept and Implications for
Trammell, K. D., A. Tarkowski, J. Hofmokl, and A. M. Sapp (2006). Research.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 33 (4):
“Rzeczpospolita Blogów [Republic of Blog]: Examining Polish 585–603.

You might also like