Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aristotle Books III (Chapters 1-5) Book VII (Chapters 1-10) Western Civilization
Aristotle Books III (Chapters 1-5) Book VII (Chapters 1-10) Western Civilization
Nicomachean
Ethics of Aristotle, in Books III (chapters 1-5), and Book VII (chapters 1-10). These discussions have
been a major influence in the development of ethical and legal thinking in Western civilization.
In Book III Aristotle divided actions into three categories instead of two:
Not everyone who stands firm on the basis of a rational and even correct decision has
self-mastery. Stubborn people are actually more like a person without self-mastery,
because they are partly led by the pleasure coming from victory.
Not everyone who fails to stand firm on the basis of his best deliberations has a true lack
of self mastery. As an example he gives the case
of Neoptolemus (in Sophocles' Philoctetes) refusing to lie despite being part of a plan he
agreed with.
A person with practical wisdom (phronesis) can not have akrasia. Instead it might
sometimes seem so, because mere cleverness can sometimes recite words which might
make them sound wise, like an actor or a drunk person reciting poetry. A person lacking
self-mastery can have knowledge, but not an active knowledge that they are paying
attention to. For example, when someone is in a state such as being drunk or enraged,
people may have knowledge, and even show that they have that knowledge, like an
actor, but not be using it.
Medieval-European philosophy[edit]
Inspired by Islamic philosophers Avicenna and Averroes, Aristotelian philosophy became part of a
standard approach to all legal and ethical discussion in Europe by the time of Thomas Aquinas[1] His
philosophy can be seen as a synthesis of Aristotle and early Christian doctrine as formulated
by Boethius and Augustine of Hippo, although sources such as Maimonides and Plato and the
aforementioned Muslim scholars are also cited.
With the use of Scholasticism, Thomas Aquinas's Summa Theologica makes a structured treatment
of the concept of will. A very simple representation of this treatment may look like this: [2]