Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10.1136@neurintsurg 2019 015375 PDF
10.1136@neurintsurg 2019 015375 PDF
Neuroimaging
Original research
Protected by copyright.
three cohorts. with SAH, and the diagnostic yield of repeat DSA
Results A total of 186 patients had CTA-negative ranges from 4% to 16%.13 Review of the literature,
ntSAH. The ntSAH pattern was identified as however, primarily reports findings obtained using
cortical (n=77, 41.4%), diffuse (n=60, 32.3%), or outdated CTA technology. Our aim was to analyze
perimesencephalic (n=49, 26.3%). In eight patients the diagnostic yield of DSA after high-resolution
(4%), DSA revealed a vascular lesion (one cervical modern CTA with negative findings during a 5-year
arteriovenous fistula and seven atypical aneurysms) after period at our high-volume neurovascular center.
negative CTA findings. All eight patients with positive
DSA findings had diffuse SAH (13% of patients with Methods
a diffuse pattern). The seven aneurysms included four At a single tertiary care center, medical records
blister or dissecting (two basilar artery, one superior from a prospectively maintained neuroendovascular
cerebellar artery, and one dorsal wall internal carotid database were reviewed for patients with an initial
artery), two fusiform (one posterior communicating presentation of ntSAH and negative CTA findings
artery and one anterior spinal artery), and one saccular who underwent subsequent DSA between January
aneurysm (middle cerebral artery). 1, 2014 and December 31, 2018. The study was
Conclusion DSA identified a causative lesion in approved by the institutional review board of our
4% of patients with CTA-negative ntSAH, but only in hospital and complied with the Health Insurance
patients with diffuse ntSAH. Most of the lesions detected Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Images
were atypical aneurysms and were found on delayed were obtained with use of a GE LightSpeed VCT
angiograms. These results suggest that DSA can help CT scanner using a 64-slice CTA protocol for high
to diagnose CTA-negative ntSAH caused by unusual resolution (GE Healthcare, Chicago, Illinois, USA).
aneurysms, and repeat DSA may be needed only for Hospital notes, age, sex, and imaging studies (CT,
patients with diffuse ntSAH. CTA, and DSA) were analyzed. The pattern of ntSAH
was categorized as diffuse (figure 1A), perimesen-
cephalic (figure 1B), or cortical (figure 1C) on the
© Author(s) (or their basis of a review of the report by a cerebrovascular
employer(s)) 2019. No Introduction neurosurgery attending physician. Cortical ntSAH
commercial re-use. See rights Non-traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage (ntSAH) was defined as that occurring near the convexity,
and permissions. Published
by BMJ. occurs in approximately 30 000 patients per year, without the involvement of the basilar cisterns.
or 5% of strokes in the USA.1 Although most Perimesencephalic ntSAH was defined using previ-
To cite: Catapano JS, SAHs are caused by rupture of a brain aneurysm, ously described features.14 In general, this pattern is
Lang MJ, Koester SW, et al.
a causative lesion is not found in 15–20% of localized to the cisterns at the level of the midbrain,
J NeuroIntervent Surg Epub
ahead of print: [please patients.2–4 Patients with aneurysmal SAH experi- often centered around the interpeduncular cistern.
include Day Month Year]. ence high rates of morbidity and mortality; there- Additional extension, particularly superior to this
doi:10.1136/ fore, prompt diagnosis of a ruptured aneurysm is location and with blood layering in multiple cisterns
neurintsurg-2019-015375 essential. and subarachnoid spaces, was defined as diffuse
Catapano JS, et al. J NeuroIntervent Surg 2019;0:1–5. doi:10.1136/neurintsurg-2019-015375 1
J NeuroIntervent Surg: first published as 10.1136/neurintsurg-2019-015375 on 4 November 2019. Downloaded from http://jnis.bmj.com/ on November 5, 2019 at Western Sydney University.
Neuroimaging
Figure 1 CT of the head without contrast. (A) Diffuse non-traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage (ntSAH) is diffusely layered in multiple cisterns and
subarachnoid spaces. (B) Perimesencephalic ntSAH is localized to the cisterns at the level of the midbrain, centered often around the interpeduncular
cistern. (C) Cortical ntSAH occurs near the convexity, without involvement of the basilar cisterns. Used with permission from Barrow Neurological
Institute, Phoenix, Arizona, USA.
ntSAH. Negative CTA findings were defined as no lesion being rate for perimesencephalic, cortical, and diffuse hemorrhage on
identified or suspected on the final attending neuroradiologist CTA was 0%, 0%, and 7.3%, respectively. Table 3 highlights
report (seven patients had suspected vasculitis as the cause for recent large studies on CTA-negative ntSAH, with the majority
ntSAH and were excluded). of lesions found among patients with diffuse ntSAH.7 13 15–17
If the first DSA after a CTA with negative findings was unre-
Protected by copyright.
vealing, a follow-up DSA was performed at the discretion of the Discussion
neuroendovascular attending physician, generally 5–7 days after CTA has emerged as the first-line diagnostic study for patients
the initial study. Statistical analysis was performed using IBM presenting with SAH, as it is more sensitive and less time-
SPSS Statistics for Windows Version 24.0 (IBM Corp, Armonk, consuming than magnetic resonance angiography and less inva-
New York, USA) and Microsoft Excel (Microsoft, Redmond, sive than DSA.18 19 However, in 5–30% of patients with SAH,
Washington, USA). CTA does not identify a causative vascular lesion.20 21 Because
Results
From January 1, 2014 to December 31, 2018, 186 patients Table 1 Characteristics of patients with CTA-negative ntSAH
presented with ntSAH and had negative initial CTA findings. Patients
Of these patients, 99 were men (53%) and the mean (SD) age Characteristic (n=186)
was 56 (14) years (table 1). The SAH pattern was identified as Sex
cortical (n=77, 41.4%), diffuse (n=60, 32.3%), or perimesen- Men 97 (52)
cephalic (n=49, 26.3%). Intraventricular or intraparenchymal
Women 89 (48)
hemorrhage was present in 40 (21.5%) and 18 (9.7%) patients,
respectively. Age, mean (SD), years 56 (14)
Eight patients (4%) had a DSA positive for a vascular lesion ntSAH pattern
(one cervical arteriovenous fistula (AVF) and seven atypical Diffuse 60 (32)
aneurysms) after a CTA with negative findings (table 2). All eight
Perimesencephalic 49 (26)
patients with positive DSA findings had a diffuse pattern of SAH
(13% of patients with a diffuse pattern). Of the seven aneurysms, Sulcal 77 (41)
four were blister or dissecting (two basilar artery, one superior IVH 40 (21)
cerebellar artery, and one dorsal wall internal carotid artery), IPH 18 (10)
two were fusiform (one posterior communicating artery, diam-
Repeat DSA
eter 2 mm, and one anterior spinal artery), and one was saccular
(middle cerebral artery, diameter 1 mm). 2 DSAs 109 (59)
All 186 patients underwent initial DSA at a mean of <1 day 3 DSAs 18 (10)
from admission (median 1 day; range 0–8 days), and 109 patients Vascular lesions found
underwent repeat DSA at a mean of 7.6 days from the first study
Overall (n=186) 8 (4.3)
(median 6 days; range 2–9 days; one outlier at 148 days). A caus-
ative lesion was identified in two additional patients at the time First DSA (n=186) 4 (2.2)
of repeat DSA (two aneurysms; one fusiform, one dissecting). Second DSA (n=109) 2 (1.8)
Eighteen patients underwent a third DSA at a mean of 110 days Third DSA (n=18) 2 (11.1)
from the second DSA (median 75 days; range 1–416 days). The Data are n (%) of patients unless otherwise indicated.
third study identified a causative lesion in two patients (two aneu- CTA, CT angiography; DSA, digital subtraction angiography; IPH, intraparenchymal;
rysms; one fusiform, one dissecting). The overall false-negative IVH, intraventricular; ntSAH, non-traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage.
Table 2 Patients with CTA-negative ntSAH and vascular lesion found on DSA
No of DSAs with
negative
Patient findings SAH type Lesion Type Location
1 0 Diffuse Aneurysm Blister Dorsal wall ICA (figure 2A)
2 0 Diffuse AVF N/A Cervical (figure 2H)
3 0 Diffuse Aneurysm Dissecting Basilar (figure 2C)
4 0 Diffuse Aneurysm Saccular MCA (diameter 1 mm) (figure 2D)
5 1 Diffuse Aneurysm Dissecting Basilar apex (figure 2B)
6 1 Diffuse Aneurysm Fusiform PCOM (diameter 2 mm) (figure 2F)
7 2 Diffuse Aneurysm Fusiform ASA (figure 2E)
8 2 Diffuse Aneurysm Dissecting SCA (figure 2G)
ASA, anterior spinal artery; AVF, arteriovenous fistula; CTA, CT angiography; DSA, digital subtraction angiography; ICA, internal carotid artery; MCA, middle cerebral artery; ntSAH,
non-traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage; PCOM, posterior communicating artery; SCA, superior cerebellar artery.
of the devastating consequences of a false-negative finding in the atypical and dangerous features. Similar diagnostic yields for
diagnosis of a ruptured vascular lesion, most of these patients are finding uncommon or small aneurysms have been reported in
subsequently evaluated by DSA.22 the literature for repeat DSAs.24
In our study, DSA revealed a cause of the hemorrhage in eight In our study, DSA did not reveal a causative vascular lesion
(4%) patients with CTA-negative ntSAH, all of whom presented for any of the cases with a perimesencephalic or cortical pattern
with a diffuse pattern of SAH. Seven vascular lesions detected by of SAH. Although, in more recent studies (table 3), the majority
DSA were atypical ruptured aneurysms and one was a cervical of lesions in CTA-negative ntSAH are found among patients
AVF (figure 2A–H). These results are similar to previous retro- with diffuse SAH, some lesions are identified among patients
spective analyses in which aneurysms were the primary causative with other bleed patterns, most of which were caused by vascu-
vascular lesion in patients with CTA- negative, DSA- positive litis.7 13 15–17 Historically, perimesencephalic SAH has been asso-
Protected by copyright.
diffuse SAH.7 16 Less frequently, arteriovenous malformations ciated with negative DSA findings.4 7 16 25 Approximately 10% of
or intracranial dural AVFs were identified as the source of all spontaneous SAH cases exhibit this pattern of hemorrhage,
bleeding.13 16 In a 2017 retrospective cohort study by Philipp with venous bleeding as the suspected source. Nonetheless, addi-
et al,23 the sensitivity of CTA was notably only 57.6% for aneu- tional studies have reported cases of false-negative CTA findings
rysms smaller than 5 mm in diameter. As such, small aneurysms for perimesencephalic SAH and source identification in 3–4.5%
may be missed in patients undergoing CTA alone. of cases after DSA.13 24 As a result, an initial DSA is supported
For cases of diffuse SAH with both negative CTA and negative for perimesencephalic SAH, despite the expected low diagnostic
DSA findings, a vascular lesion still may be the cause. Negative yield. However, in the event of an initial DSA negative for the
DSA findings in patients with SAH caused by a vascular lesion perimesencephalic pattern, our results are in agreement with a
may be due to adjacent blood causing compression of the aneu- report by Huttner et al26 in which additional DSAs did not yield
rysm, aneurysmal thrombosis, vasospasm of the parent vessel, further evidence of a vascular lesion.
or small aneurysm size.22 In our study, we report the results of Timing of DSA may play a role in identifying vascular lesions.
additional follow-up DSAs in the event of negative CTA find- The median time interval between the initial CTA and the first
ings and negative baseline DSA findings. With this protocol, DSA was 1 day in our series. The median time between the first
ruptured aneurysms were found in two of 109 patients (1.8%) DSA and the second DSA was 6 days, followed by a median of
on a second DSA and in two of 18 patients (11.1%) on a third 75 days to the third DSA. These time intervals between studies
DSA. Notably, all of these lesions were small and possessed are shorter than those in the existing literature. In particular,
Table 3 Major studies on patients with CTA-negative ntSAH and DSA findings, 2006–2018
No of patients with CTA-
negative non-diffuse
No (%) of patients ntSAH with vascular
No of patients with with DSA-positive, lesion on DSA (% of
Study, year Period of review Study type CT scanner(s) used CTA-negative ntSAH CTA-negative ntSAH lesions)
Bashir et al, 201815 2011–2017 Retrospective case series Unknown 74* 1 (1.4) 0
Heit et al, 201613 2002–2012 Retrospective case series 64 slice and 16 slice 230 29 (13) 14 (48)†
Delgado Almandoz et al, 2007–2011 Retrospective case series 64 slice and 16 slice 55‡ 6 (11) 1 (17)
201316
Agid et al, 20107 2005–2009 Retrospective case series 64 slice 193 12 (6) 7 (58)§
Jung et al, 200617 1986–2004 Retrospective case series Unknown 143 18(18) Unknown
*Study included combined CTA-negative and DSA-negative ntSAH.
†Twelve negative-CTA ntSAH due to vasculitis.
‡Magnetic resonance angiography used for eight patients.
§All non-diffuse ntSAH with a lesion found on DSA were due to vasculitis.
CTA, CT angiography; DSA, digital subtraction angiography; ntSAH, non-traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage.
Protected by copyright.
Figure 2 Vascular lesions identified on digital subtraction angiography among patients with CT angiography (CTA)-negative non-traumatic
subarachnoid hemorrhage. (A) Reconstructed three-dimensional (3D) image of a dorsal wall right internal carotid artery blister aneurysm (arrow)
that was not seen on the initial CTA due to the small size and abnormal location of the lesion. (B) Reconstructed 3D image of a dissecting basilar
apex aneurysm (arrow) that was not visualized on the initial CTA due to the small size of the lesion. (C) Reconstructed 3D image of dissecting basilar
artery aneurysm (arrow) that was not identified on the initial CTA due to the small size of the lesion. (D) Reconstructed 3D image of a small 1 mm
right middle cerebral artery aneurysm (arrow) that was not seen on the initial CTA due to the small size of the lesion. (E) Right vertebral artery
injection with a lateral working view showing a small fusiform atrial septal aneurysm (arrow) that was not visible on the initial CTA because the
aneurysm was too caudal. (F) Lateral view of a fusiform left posterior communicating artery aneurysm (arrow) not seen on the initial CTA because a
large subarachnoid hemorrhage around the lesion made the aneurysm difficult to visualize. (G) Right vertebral artery injection posterioranterior view
showing a dissecting left superior cerebellar artery aneurysm (arrow) that was not visualized on the initial CTA due to the small size of the lesion
and a large subarachnoid hemorrhage around the lesion. (H) Lateral view of a left vertebral artery injection showing a cervical arteriovenous fistula
(arrow) that was not visible on the initial CTA because the fistula was too caudal. Used with permission from Barrow Neurological Institute, Phoenix,
Arizona, USA.
reports vary in the interval between CTA and DSA, ranging from Conclusion
less than 1 day to 7 days.24 26 27 As the diagnostic yield from DSA identified a causative vascular lesion in 4% of patients
DSA relative to the timing of the procedure has varied between with CTA-negative ntSAH, even with the use of high-resolution
studies, no clear association can be made between timing and the modern-era CTA. A vascular lesion was identified by DSA only
discovery of a causative vascular lesion. in patients with diffuse pattern ntSAH. Furthermore, most of the
Limitations of our study include those inherent to a retrospec- vascular lesions detected were atypical aneurysms, and half were
tive analysis. Furthermore, the definition of SAH patterns may found on the second or third DSA study. These results support
differ among papers and institutions, leading to variable results. the importance of performing DSA for patients with CTA-
In addition, repeat DSAs were ordered on the basis of the prefer- negative ntSAH to diagnose atypical or small aneurysms, with
ences of the attending neuroendovascular surgeon. In the future, repeat DSAs for patients with diffuse pattern ntSAH.
a prospective study design with standardized SAH diagnostic
criteria and DSA repeat time intervals could help the develop- Acknowledgements The authors thank the Neuroscience Publications staff at
ment of concise guidelines. Barrow Neurological Institute for help with manuscript preparation.
Protected by copyright.
with spontaneous subarachnoid hemorrhage: when is digital subtraction angiography 24 Delgado Almandoz JE, Jagadeesan BD, Refai D, et al. Diagnostic yield of repeat
still needed? AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 2010;31:696–705. catheter angiography in patients with catheter and computed tomography
8 Hoh BL, Cheung AC, Rabinov JD, et al. Results of a prospective protocol of computed angiography negative subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurosurgery 2012;70:1135–42.
tomographic angiography in place of catheter angiography as the only diagnostic and 25 van Gijn J, van Dongen KJ, Vermeulen M, et al. Perimesencephalic hemorrhage:
pretreatment planning study for cerebral aneurysms by a combined neurovascular a nonaneurysmal and benign form of subarachnoid hemorrhage. Neurology
team. Neurosurgery 2004;54:1329–42. 1985;35:493–7.
9 Fox AJ, Symons SP, Aviv RI. CT angiography is state-of-the-art first vascular imaging 26 Huttner HB, Hartmann M, Köhrmann M, et al. Repeated digital substraction
for subarachnoid hemorrhage. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 2008;29:e41–2. angiography after perimesencephalic subarachnoid hemorrhage? J Neuroradiol
10 Kelliny M, Maeder P, Binaghi S, et al. Cerebral aneurysm exclusion by CT angiography 2006;33:87–9.
based on subarachnoid hemorrhage pattern: a retrospective study. BMC Neurol 27 Hijdra A, Braakman R, van Gijn J, et al. Aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage:
2011;11:8. complications and outcome in a hospital population. Stroke 1987;18:1061–7.